Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
4. Misuse of Statistical Methods for a part of the day or month. How should
we measure their employment?
As it is true for every science, statistical
Statistical methods are no
methods are based on certain well
substitute for common sense. They
defined assumptions. While analysing
should not be used blindly. The following
and interpreting statistical results one
two examples illustrate this point.
should be very careful about the
An epidemic once broke out in some
assumptions they are based on. If we
villages of a certain state. The government
ignore them our conclusions will be
took immediate steps to control the
wrong.
epidemic. Medical assistance was sent
The quality of data plays an
important part in statistical analysis. in terms of medicines and doctors. One
Fallacies may arise, if we are using data of the political leaders, who also claimed
which are either insufficient, or to be a statistician, collected data and
unrepresentative, or incomparable. For found that the number of deaths were
example, suppose we want to test the larger in those villages which had large
efficacy of a certain drug, or a fertilizer; number of doctors. He, therefore,
we must test it in a number of cases concluded that doctors were responsible
under varying conditions. If we jump to for deaths and they should be punished.
conclusions by examining the effect in Another interesting story is usually
very few cases, we are likely to make told to make fun of statistics. It is said
mistakes. Similarly, if we want to that a family of four persons (husband,
estimate the average income of wife and two children) once set out to
people living in a town and base our cross a river. The father knew the
estimate on income of people living in average depth of the river. So he
the rich areas alone we will get an calculated the average height of his
overestimate. family members. Since the average height
Any vagueness in the definitions and of his family members was greater than
concepts employed in data collection may the average depth of the river, he thought
lead to wrong conclusions. For example, they could cross safely. Consequently
if we are collecting data on the income some members of the family (children)
of households, we must make clear how drowned while crossing the river. What
we intend to calculate the required was the mistake? Does the fault lie with
income. People with fixed wage or salary the statistical method of calculating
income may be able to give a correct averages, or, with the misuse of the
answer, but a businessman does not averages?
have a fixed income. His income varies Many times, people talk of ‘statistical
from month to month, and he may not fallacies’, ‘statistical lies’, etc. It should
maintain accurate records of his income be noted that they arise due to wrong
regularly. Then, how would we calculate handling of data, or, because of ignoring
his income? Similarly, suppose we are the underlying assumptions, or, by
collecting data on employment. There are misusing certain summary indices (like
many people who may be employed only averages) — as noted above.
INTRODUCTION 5
EXERCISES