You are on page 1of 12

Methods for Collecting, Rearing

and Preserving Dragonflies 13

Abstract
to sample, and caution is advised when trying to sample in
Collecting and preserving methods for both nymphs and
deep water. Nymphs of several North American species are
adults of Odonata are described. Procedures for rearing
reportedly resistant to desiccation in habitats that become
and feeding nymphs are outlined; rearing nymphs is an
completely dry for several months. Examples include
essential tool in learning about their growth and develop-
Somatochlora semicircularis, reported by Willey and Eiler
ment. Suggestions for equipment and other materials, and
(1972), Aeshna sitchensis, Leucorrhinia hudsonica, reported
also safety concerns, necessary in field studies of nymphs
by Cannings (1982), and Somatochlora albicincta, reported
and adults are provided. Field guides to the adults of
by Hutchinson and Moressette (1977). The nymphs appar-
North American dragonflies are listed.
ently bury themselves in the cool bottom mud and somehow
cut down on water loss from their bodies. Temporary pools
To kill both the things one doesn’t know and the things one loves of very brief nature (filled for only 5–20 days for any particu-
is a peculiarity of humans. lar wetting episode—the main habitat of floodwater mosqui-
toes) may be frequented by adults of some species, but I
Field studies are essential in learning firsthand about Odonata. know of no North American species of Odonata that under-
Any effort spent in studying nymphs will be greatly rewarded goes development in such habitat.
(DuBois and Tennessen 2016). Seeing nymphs and adults in Whether capturing dragonfly nymphs for purposes of
their native habitats is crucial in understanding their biology field identification  and release or preparing specimens for
and can be a great aid in identifying them. Furthermore, iden- taxonomic study, the basic collecting equipment and initial
tifying nymphs to species is greatly enhanced by knowing the handling techniques are similar. The considerable variety of
adults, as nearly all species definitions are based on the adult aquatic habitats in which Odonata occur, however, makes dip
stage. Species lists based on thorough adult collections pro- nets of different sizes and shapes a necessity. The various
vide many clues to nymphal identification for specific locali- collecting methods outlined here are based on those used by
ties. Because of the tremendous differences in form between numerous experienced collectors of dragonflies and are
the aquatic nymphs and the terrestrial adults, the effort intended to provide guidelines for beginners in the field.
required is similar to learning two different groups of insects. Most collectors eventually modify and adapt existing meth-
Therefore, I have included methods for collecting and pre- ods and equipment to fit their circumstances or to make
serving both stages in this chapter. However, as only nymphal improvements.
identification is addressed in this book, for adults the reader Many types of aquatic nets used for collecting aquatic
must refer to several of the excellent references on adult iden- insects are sufficient for collecting dragonfly nymphs
tification listed at the end of this chapter. (Usinger 1963; McCafferty 1981; Merritt et al. 2008), but I
have limited this discussion to the devices and methods most
useful for Odonata. For qualitative sampling, there are sev-
13.1 Collection of Nymphs eral types of commercial dip nets available for collecting
dragonfly nymphs. A D-frame net, so-called because the rim
Almost any permanent pond, stream, or lake is likely to har- is shaped like the letter D, is useful in both lentic and lotic
bor dragonfly nymphs, and certain temporary water bodies at situations (Fig. 13.1). The D-frame net is lightweight, sturdy
times provide habitat for them. Success in finding nymphs is and has a relatively long handle. The frame is made of a stout
increased if searching is concentrated mostly along the edges metal rod and measures one foot across. The upper part of
of aquatic habitats. Large rivers and large lakes are difficult the bag is made of heavy canvas to resist wear, although the

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019 579


K. J. Tennessen, Dragonfly Nymphs of North America, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-97776-8_13
580 13  Methods for Collecting, Rearing and Preserving Dragonflies

corners eventually tear with hard use over rocks and other ioned to the collector’s own specifications of shape and mesh
abrasive substrates. The bag is made of soft, fine mesh mate- size. A kick screen (Fig. 13.2a) with a large mesh, such as 8
rial (0.7–0.8  mm) that can be punctured or torn by sharp openings per inch, is an advantage in loose substrates with
sticks and roots. The bag is shallow for easy removal of large particles, as the material passes through more readily,
insects, and the fine mesh retains all sizes of Odonata except making nymphs easier to detect; however, most early instars
perhaps the first few instars. However, because the mesh is are lost through large mesh nets. A mesh of 6 to 10 openings
fine, large amounts of substrate, such as organic material and per inch retains smaller than half-grown to full-grown
coarse sand and gravel, are often retained. Nymphs are dif- nymphs. If it is necessary to collect smaller nymphs, a finer
ficult to see and pick out of large masses of such material. If mesh bottom can be installed. Kick screens and fish seines
a large amount of substrate is netted, I suggest dividing the are most effective when used by two or three people.
material into small portions and picking through it in a white Hutchinson and Ménard (2015) described an aquatic net
plastic pan. All leftover material should be returned to the made by removing the net from a commercial fish-landing
habitat from which it was collected. Other types of commer- net and replacing it with screen. I have made dip nets using
cial, short- and long-handled aquatic dip nets are also avail- stainless-steel mesh. Hardware cloth is less expensive and
able, but I have found them to be more cumbersome than the more readily available than stainless steel-mesh but it will
D-frame net. not last as long. Nets should be inspected for damage after
Do-it-yourself aquatic nets, including simple kick screens returning from the field. Aluminum bands (1/8” × 1/2”) make
made from wooden dowels and window screen, can be fash- a light, solid frame that can be readily attached to a wooden
handle (Fig. 13.2b). Net width is based on stream size; I have
found widths greater that 14” rather cumbersome. A shallow
box (ca 3–4” deep) accommodates easy removal of nymphs.
In very shallow streams, the substrate can be scooped into
the net and then carried to deeper water for rinsing.
The above-mentioned nets can be used in lotic and lentic
habitats. In flowing water, the dip net or kick screen is held
downstream of the collector while the substrate is disturbed,
usually by loosening it  with one’s feet or a stick or rake.
Dislodged nymphs float with the current onto the screen.
Although D-frame and kick nets can be used in lentic habi-
tats also, digging down into the substrate of many such
places is difficult with these devices. A more useful device in
weedy areas and compact muddy or gravel substrates is the
Needham scraper (Usinger 1963, p.  52). The 4-foot long
Fig. 13.1  D-frame net with fine mesh bag handle attaches to the net box at slightly less than 30°. The

Fig. 13.2  Homemade aquatic nets: (a) kick screen; (b) shallow box net with long handle.
13.1  Collection of Nymphs 581

front edge of the metal frame has a fairly dull, metal cutting
blade that is set approximately at 60° to the opening of the
catch box; the bottom and sides are wire mesh (typically
2.5–3.0 mm, although a finer mesh can be installed). When
the leading edge of the scraper is dragged through heavy
vegetation or a compact substrate, it cuts down and through,
scooping the loosened material into the sturdy screened
frame. The scraper is then rinsed in the water to wash most
of the fine material out through the mesh of the side and bot-
tom screens, leaving the dragonfly nymphs easy to detect
amongst the remaining larger pieces of stems and stones on
the bottom screen. The original Needham scraper was quite
heavy (4.5 lb without the handle) and could become tiresome
when used for extended periods. I built a lighter version with
an aluminum frame, a stainless-steel cutting edge, and Fig. 13.3  Lightweight modified Needham scraper with aluminum
stainless-­steel mesh formed to make a slightly shallower box frame (f) and stainless-steel front edge (b)
(depth 3.5 inches); it weighs only 2 lb. (Fig. 13.3).
For sampling in deep water, a long-handled rake can be
used to pull leafy and/or woody debris toward the bank where
it can be examined for nymphs. In small spaces, such as
spring runs, seeps, and pockets of water in bogs and swamps,
a tea strainer or small minnow net is useful. Small dip nets
can be made from various sporting rackets (Fig. 13.4). Small
strainers and minnow nets are also handy when collecting in
phytotelmata. Picking up logs and rocks at the edges of rivers
and lakes often reveals clinging species that are rarely taken
by a net. Sturdy tree roots along river banks and in swamps
are very difficult to sample; groping by hand, diving or snor-
keling and then sighting and handpicking them are fairly
effective ways to collect nymphs clinging to such substrates.
Cook (1994) described a method using a centrifugal water
pump powered by a gasoline engine to create a water jet for
loosening nymphs from their hiding places. One person
directs the jet of water, washing nymphs into a catch net held
by an assistant. Although the equipment and effort required is
substantially greater than in more conventional techniques,
this method will increase yield and might be useful in esti-
mating population sizes. For sampling in winter conditions,
Cebulski (2009) designed a dragnet for use under the ice.
Whatever catch net is used, nymphs of most species will Fig. 13.4  Racket ball racket converted to a dip net for sampling small
try to free themselves immediately from the debris in the net, aquatic habitats
and they are thus easily detected by their movements.
Whereas Cordulegaster, Ladona and Libellula try to escape
immediately, some species, such as Hagenius, Lanthus, and Gomphidae and Cordulegastridae should be provided some
Neurocordulia, will remain motionless for a while when first mixture of sand and gravel so they do not constantly crawl in
captured. Patience and a keen sense of their shape are neces- attempts to find cover. For aeshnids, provide a damp leaf or
sary to find nymphs that tend to hide or feign death. stick onto which the nymphs can cling. If the nymphs cannot
Mortality of captive nymphs is usually highest during be transported to an artificial stream (see p. 584) within a day
transport, especially during hot weather and over long dis- or two of collection, water should be added to the container;
tances. One method that increases survival is to keep the aeration should be provided with a portable, battery-operated
nymphs wet but not in water. I put them in plastic vials with air pump (available in most stores that sell fishing supplies).
wet moss and keep the containers from becoming warm; it is Empty the water from the containers daily during transporta-
best to use snap caps that have small holes in them. tion and replace it with fresh water.
582 13  Methods for Collecting, Rearing and Preserving Dragonflies

Few methods have been developed for quantitative sam- explain your purpose to the landowner and politely ask per-
pling of Odonata nymphs. Odonata are usually poorly repre- mission; most people are willing to let you collect if they
sented in most quantitative benthic sampling efforts. For know what you intend to do beforehand. Appropriate collect-
example, Hess and Surber samples (Merritt et al. 2008) are ing permits are required for public lands such as national
taken in riffle areas away from stream banks and result in few parks, US Forest Service lands, Army Corps of Engineers,
odonates because the majority of stream-inhabiting Odonata state conservation areas, and preserves owned by The Nature
occupy the slower edges. Banks are usually highly irregular, Conservancy.
often with uneven vertical or undercut margins. A uniplanar Collecting Odonata, in either the adult or nymphal stages,
sample area, be it a square foot, square meter or whatever, usually does not significantly impact dragonfly populations
cannot be mechanically delineated in such multidimensional or their habitats. Garrison (1993) discussed various aspects
space. However, semi-quantitative samples can be obtained of collecting and the lack of significant effects it has on
by estimating the area that is to be disturbed and washed into Odonata. Nonetheless, collectors should carefully weigh the
the net. Another method is to collect exuviae of emerging consequences of their actions on a species and its habitat
individuals along a shoreline for a measured distance before they collect. I believe it is unwise and unethical to
(DuBois 2015; see discussion below). It is necessary to col- over-collect rare species, especially those that occupy small,
lect the exuviae for the entire emergence period of the spe- fragile habitats such as spring seepages, small pristine
cies being investigated. streams, or any unusual habitat. If a few specimens need to
For purposes of species level identification, it is best to be taken from such habitats, every effort should be exercised
collect at least some late instars whenever possible. Many of to disturb as little of the habitat as possible. The Dragonfly
the characteristics used to identify late stage nymphs to spe- Society of the Americas (1996) adopted a collecting policy
cies (especially size, setal number, antennal segment ratios after its members thoroughly discussed and weighed all
and wing sheath characters) are not yet fully developed in issues, pro and con [see Orr 1994 and access the
nymphs smaller than F-3. Very few characters have been OdonataCentral website (http://www.odonatacentral.org/
found that are reliable for identifying small nymphs. index.php/PageAction.get/name/CuratingInfo) for further
Therefore most keys to species, including those presented in information].
this book, are applicable only to larger nymphs. Spring is a
good time to collect final instars, many of which will be near
emergence. However, streams and ponds are often swollen 13.2 Collection of Exuviae
from heavy spring rains, making them difficult to sample. In
temperate areas, autumn is usually a good time of year to Picking up the exoskeletons left after adults metamorphose
collect nymphs because streams are usually at low levels is an excellent method for surveying dragonflies. Exuviae
and final instars of many species are present. Many groups (Fig.  13.5), also called “skins,” are fairly easy to find if
overwinter in the final instar; if nymphs are collected in shorelines are searched shortly after emergence. No net is
autumn and brought inside the lab, rearing to the adult stage necessary. Finding exuviae sometimes requires bending and
usually takes considerably longer than if they are collected looking at potential supports from different angles. Exuviae
in spring. Also, a source of live prey organisms, such as oli- are usually present within a meter or so of the water line but
gochaetes, must be available throughout the cold months of can be present at greater distances from the water (Tennessen
the year. If only F-4 or smaller nymphs are found, I suggest 1979). Stream banks and most lake shores are fairly easy to
rearing some of these to F-0 or F-1 for ease of search whereas ponds, bogs and fens choked with emergent
identification. vegetation present difficulties in detection.
It is important to keep two things in mind while collect- Dry exuviae should be handled gently as they are brittle
ing. First, aquatic habitats and their surroundings can be haz- and quite fragile; wetting dry exuviae before picking them
ardous places, especially if one is alone. Currents and up helps prevent breakage. The exuviae can be placed in a
bottoms in some rivers can be deceptive and unpredictable, light-weight plastic container and then preserved in 70%
so proceed in unknown areas with great caution. Rocks in ethanol or isopropyl in vials. Identification is based on the
rivers and lakes can be very slippery and sharp, and deep same characters as for nymphs, although setal characters are
sediment can trap the unaware. Poison ivy, thorns, smart- sometimes difficult to ascertain due to matting and
weed, wasps and snakes present further dangers. Dehydration breakage.
is also likely. Therefore it is a good idea to go with a compan- In population studies, the exuviae search method offers
ion and be sure to pack water and a first aid kit. Secondly, several advantages over nymph and adult collecting:
collectors must respect the habitat and the property they
visit. Refrain from unduly trampling or damaging vegeta- 1. Exuviae constitute unequivocal evidence of successful
tion, banks and substrate. If you wish to go on private land, development and  the locality and the precise habitat in
13.3  Rearing Dragonfly Nymphs 583

Fig. 13.5 Exuviae
(Gomphidae) left by emerging
adults: (a) Ophiogomphus
rupinsulensis; (b) Stylurus
scudderi

which species develop. Whereas adults often wander to 2. Plan to sample shortly after target species are expected to
habitats where they do not reproduce, under most circum- emerge.
stances, exuviae remain in place where nymph develop- 3. Search by sight from edge of water to about 1  m from
ment occurred (Raebel et  al. 2010). Exuviae persist for edge; try to view from different angles and by carefully
variable periods of time (Lubertazzi and Ginsberg 2009). moving stems, grasses (some are not in plain sight).
Species composition surveys based on exuviae are likely 4. Make two passes through the transect or quadrat.
to produce non-biased results. 5. Pick exuviae off supports and preserve.
2. Exuviae are non-living, so no part of the life cycle is sac- 6. Identify and enumerate exuviae.
rificed when they are collected. This consideration is 7. Note weather conditions
especially important when sampling for species that are 8. Record latitude and longitude, preferably in decimal

considered sensitive or vulnerable (e.g. Foster and Soluk degrees.
1994).
3. Searching requires little equipment; therefore data-­

gathering is inexpensive. 13.3 Rearing Dragonfly Nymphs
4. Results can be obtained quickly, depending on identifica-
tion skills. Rearing nymphs to the adult stage is a valuable tool for learn-
ing about dragonflies, and the emerging adults can be used to
Several drawbacks regarding exuviae include 1) damage confirm determinations based on nymphs. Live nymphs
to and displacement of exuviae in severe weather; 2) the win- should be handled with great care, either with fingers or
dow of opportunity is narrow, requiring exuviae search blunt forceps to prevent injuring them. Great success in get-
efforts to be scheduled shortly after adults emerge; 3) species ting captive nymphs to transform is achieved by collecting
identification in some groups can be challenging; 4) some final instars. If nymphs with swollen wing sheaths are found
habitats, such as fens and bogs, are difficult to sample. (Fig. 13.6a, b), chances are high that they will emerge suc-
Quantitative studies, such as determining population cessfully in captivity. Nymphs that are within a week of
trends over a period of years, can be achieved using exuviae emergence must not be dropped; the shock can cause trauma
(DuBois 2015). The following steps, based on some prior to the pharate adult inside the nymphal skin, usually result-
knowledge of the species and physical characteristics of the ing in death before or during emergence. Lotic species
habitat, may be helpful. should be provided with aerated water in artificial streams
(Fig. 13.7), although aerated aquariums will work for some
1. Establish transects (a set distance of bank or shoreline species. Lentic species usually can be reared in small cups or
such as 10 m or 20 m) or square area plots (quadrats such jars. Early instars and final instars with flat wing sheaths
as 1m2 or 10 m2). need live prey to complete their development. Small oligo-
584 13  Methods for Collecting, Rearing and Preserving Dragonflies

Fig. 13.6  Nymph of Tramea


lacerata with swollen wing
sheaths, nearing time to
emerge to the adult stage: (a)
dorsal view; (b) dorsolateral
view. Arrows indicate right
hind wing sheath. Photos
courtesy of Marla Garrison

When a nymph’s wing sheaths become swollen, it needs


an emergence support, such as a piece of screen, a stick, or a
sloped bank in order to leave the water and transform.
Numerous books illustrate the sequence of events that take
place during emergence (Hammond 1977, Askew 1988,
Rowe 1991). Information on details of emergence (e.g., pos-
ture, time for wings to extend) are lacking for most of our
species. Making a video of an emerging dragonfly provides
details of the sequence that can be described and timed later.
Some species tend to crawl long distances before emerging.
It is best to put a screen top on the rearing containers so that
when nymphs leave the water to emerge, they do not crawl
too far and become lost.
Fig. 13.7  Small artificial stream with recirculating filter for rearing Newly emerged (teneral) dragonflies are soft and delicate
lotic Odonata and should be left undisturbed until they are ready to fly. As
soon as they attempt their first flight, they can be released,
chaete worms, chironomids and mosquito larvae are excel- preferably near the proper habitat. If a teneral is to be kept
lent food sources. Although few North American species for a museum specimen, it should be put in a paper bag or
have been reared from the earliest instars all the way to the cardboard box so it can harden and develop its color pattern.
adult stage, existing attempts indicate that a varied diet is not In dry climates, a damp piece of cotton or moss should be put
necessary  — I have reared several species of Libellulidae in the bag to provide moisture. The fresh exuviae should be
(Erythemis simplicicollis, Pachydiplax longipennis) solely put immediately in a vial of alcohol with a label (noting date
on mosquito larvae. Newly-hatched dragonfly nymphs can of emergence and any other particular data) and kept associ-
be fed tiny newly-hatched larvae of Chironomidae (midges) ated with the adult. The teneral adult, if kept alive for several
and/or Chaoboridae (phantom midges, also called days, can be hand-fed small insects such as mosquitoes and
­glassworms). Gravid females of these dipterans can be col- midges, starting on the second or third day after emergence.
lected in small plastic vials at night by setting up a UV light Hold the dragonfly gently with wings together between
under a white sheet; a little water squirted into the vials will thumb and forefinger and touch the prey, held by forceps, to
induce many such females to lay eggs overnight; the eggs its mouthparts. It may take several attempts before the drag-
usually hatch within 2 or 3 days (Tennessen 2016). An onfly accepts prey in this manner (Tennessen 1994a). I have
advantage of this method is that large numbers of small prey kept some species alive for up to two weeks feeding them in
can be obtained quickly, and the nymphs detect and catch this manner, but many species, especially Aeshnidae, attempt
them quite easily. Rowe (2002) provided methods for suc- to fly inside containers and break their wings. If museum
cessfully rearing odonates from egg to adult; special empha- specimens are desired, it is best to preserve the adult either in
sis was given to feeding early stage nymphs. the alcohol vial containing its exuviae or to acetone it two or
three days post-emergence.
13.4  Collection of Adults 585

Fig. 13.8  Egg strings of Epitheca species; eggs in mass on left are
recently deposited, while those on the right are darkened, nearing time Fig. 13.9  Narrow, custom-made aquarium for photographing nymphs
to hatch and observing behavior

To obtain eggs, ovipositing females or females in copula


with males usually must be collected (Dunkle 1980). Hold a made from microscope slides stuck together using a hot glue
captive female’s hind wings together between thumb and gun.
forefinger and dip the tip of the abdomen in a small container Because most Odonata nymphs are thigmotactic, it is best
of water. Females that are going to release eggs usually will to add stems for climbers and clingers (such as Aeshnidae)
do so within a minute or two. Although most libellulid spe- and clean sand for sprawlers and burrowers. With these sub-
cies usually release eggs when held captive, many other strates available, the nymphs do not constantly swim around
groups are uncooperative and other methods are necessary. looking for cover. In particular, Aeshnidae adapt well to such
Egg strings of the genus Epitheca can often be found at the narrow aquariums and feed readily, providing opportunities
water surface, attached to emergent vegetation (Fig. 13.8) or for behavioral observation. The small aquariums are also
woody debris. One might find eggs of species that insert their useful in photography, as slender, elongate nymphs, such as
eggs into a substrate by observing exactly where a female Aeshnidae and Zygoptera, are kept perpendicular to the
oviposited and then collecting a small amount of the sub- plane of the camera’s sensor. The aquariums can also be used
strate (such as a stem, moss or mud). Searching is best done in videoing nymphs as they engage in stalking prey, breath-
under low power through a dissecting scope. For example, ing, cleaning, etc.
Cordulegaster females jab their ovipositors into muddy and
sandy substrates; however, sifting through such material to
find the eggs is tedious work. Females of some aeshnid spe- 13.4 Collection of Adults
cies will lay eggs in moist paper towels or coffee filters when
held captive in a large plastic jug (Steve Valley pers. comm). Very little equipment is needed to collect adult dragonflies.
Eggs are easy to keep alive for observation of embryogenesis The most important item is a sturdy, long-handled net. An
and hatching. Aeration of the water is usually not necessary, aerial net can be purchased from a number of biological sup-
but the container should be loosely covered to prevent inva- ply houses, or you can make your own. The handle should be
sion by fungi. 4–6 feet long, and the rim 18–22 inches in diameter. The net
Feeding behavior, molting, and taxis can be observed by bag should be of fairly large mesh (about 2 mm), providing
keeping nymphs in small, narrow aquariums. The containers for a faster swing by lowering air resistance. Some collectors
can be built out of plastic or glass. I have used 5 mm thick say a camouflage net bag is less likely to be detected by wary
clear plastic sheeting for the narrow bottom and ends and adults. However, captured dragonflies and damselflies are
2  mm thick plastic for the bigger sides; I glued the pieces difficult to see and retrieve in a green net bag. I prefer a white
together with epoxy [non-toxic type]. Different sized bag and have found that if the net is held motionless over a
Anisoptera require different widths, so I made them from 8 riffle some species of Gomphidae will try to perch on it
to 14 mm wide in increments of 2 mm. Dimensions of the (Tennessen 1994b) Other items needed are glassine or cel-
sides can vary from 30  mm high × 50  mm long to larger lophane envelopes in which to place live dragonflies tempo-
aquariums 70 mm × 100 mm (Fig. 13.9). Miniature aquari- rarily and a pouch to hold the envelopes, preferably one that
ums, for early instar Anisoptera and for Zygoptera, can be can be attached to a belt. Other items include: boots or old
586 13  Methods for Collecting, Rearing and Preserving Dragonflies

shoes for wading, forceps, hand lens, insect repellent (sulfa to prevent its escape. Individuals perched on twigs or stems
powder is very effective in repelling chiggers), paper bags usually can be captured by a quick swing from behind.
(for tenerals) and several small cardboard boxes. However, sometimes the “pancake” method is required,
Although adult dragonflies can be encountered almost especially for individuals perched flat on the ground or on a
anywhere outdoors (and occasionally indoors!), searching rock. This technique consists of sneaking up very slowly
natural habitats and the surrounding areas will lead to the from behind the dragonfly and dropping the net down over it
most success. Nearly all bodies of water, including ponds, very quickly. Some collectors even pancake dragonflies that
lakes, swamps, rivers, creeks, seeps, springs and canals are flying fast and low over water. Probably the two most
­harbor some species of Odonata. Some species even inhabit difficult situations are when a dragonfly is perched on a tree
permanent roadside ditches. Temporary wetlands, such as trunk or on barbed plants or wire. I suggest bringing the rim
shallow pools that hold water for most of the year but dry up of the net slowly up behind such an individual almost to the
for a month or more, are habitat for several species, such as tip of the abdomen, with the tip of the bag pinched against
Epiaeschna heros in woodlands (Boose 2014) and Sympetrum the handle with one hand, and quickly swinging upward.
spp. in both woodland and more open habitats. Adults can be More often than not, however, the net will become stuck or
seen near temporary pools of very brief nature also (depres- tangled, and might be torn.
sions filled for only 5–20 days for any particular wetting epi- To remove a dragonfly from the bag, grasp all four of its
sode—the main habitat of floodwater mosquitoes). However, wings between thumb and forefinger and slowly bring it out.
I know of no North American species of Odonata that under- If the dragonfly grasps the netting with its mandibles, be
goes development in such ephemeral habitats; opportunistic patient until it releases its grip so as not to pull off its head.
adults in these areas are most likely seeking a place to hide In the field, live dragonflies can be put in cellophane or glass-
or catching small flying insects for prey. ine envelopes, but each envelope should hold only one drag-
Visiting a certain habitat on repeated occasions and visit- onfly to prevent them from chewing and damaging another
ing different types of habitats is certain to increase the list of individual. The male and female of a mated pair can be
species found based on adults. Collecting near water usually placed in one envelope if it is large enough to be folded,
results in collecting a preponderance of males because which keeps them associated but prevents contact with each
females make fewer visits to the water and spend less time other. The envelopes must be kept out of direct sunlight and
while there. Walking through dry areas away from the water, out of airtight containers (such as a metal box or a hot vehi-
especially along fencerows and fields, can be extremely cle) to prevent rapid death and breakdown of pigments. A
rewarding in  locating perched and feeding females. Mated pouch made of porous material, such as canvas or nylon
pairs often are found away from the water also. reduces stress to live specimens, especially if kept in the
Collecting at different times of the day and during differ- shade as much as possible. It is best to record living colors in
ent seasons of the year will also increase the number of spe- the field soon after collecting a specimen, as some colors
cies seen. For example, certain species fly mostly in bright change quickly due to light and temperature changes. It is
sunlight (e.g., Gomphurus, Macromia) whereas others appear especially important to note the living colors of the com-
mainly around twilight (e.g., Neurocordulia, Gynacantha). pound eyes. Records can consist of notes, drawings or
Some groups, such as Aeshna, can appear during either light photographs.
condition. Some species appear early in spring and disappear The presence of mature adults near an aquatic habitat is
within a month, whereas others may be seen from spring no assurance that the nymphs reside there. Adults usually
through fall. A few occur only in late summer and fall. A range quite far from the area where they spent their nymphal
dense flight of a certain species at a particular time one day life, and may spend much of their time, such as feeding, at
does not guarantee a repeat of such a flight the next day. different types of water bodies. For example, although
Approaching a dragonfly and then swinging a net swiftly nymphs of most Gomphurus species are restricted to mid-­
and accurately enough to capture it requires cunning and sized or large rivers (the habitat in which females lay eggs),
skill. A few tips here may save some frustration and disap- adults can be found perching near small streams or feeding
pointing misses. To net a flying dragonfly, swing in the direc- in fields near ponds. Some species are not narrow in their
tion in which it is flying. Their keen sight and quick reflexes habitat requirements. Nymphs of Basiaeschna janata,
enable them to dodge head-on shots. Males of many species Dromogomphus spinosus, and Didymops transversa can be
patrol certain areas over a pond or stream riffle, and some- found in ponds, lakes and streams. Collecting nymphs gives
times flight paths can be anticipated. Be patient and wait for a more accurate picture of the species composition of a spe-
the dragonfly to come within reach of your net and to fly past cific locality, provided the nymphs are mature enough to be
your midpoint. Swing quickly from behind it; if your swing specifically identified. The species list garnered by collecting
is successful, usually indicated by the rustle of wings in the adults at a particular locality can aid nymphal determination.
bag, quickly flip the bag over the rim by rotating the handle For example, if nymphs of a Sympetrum species collected
13.5  Preservation of Specimens 587

along a lakeshore were difficult to identify to species, the


presence of only S. costiferum adults would indicate that the
nymphs are also this species. Presence of newly emerged
adults (less than an hour post-emergence and still very soft)
is a good indicator that the species inhabits a particular habi-
tat. Soft adults must be handled carefully; I put them in paper
bags and keep them alive for a day or two so the colors pat-
terns develop fully, making identification easier. However,
Fig. 13.10  Example vial label for associated adult and exuvia
some species groups, such as in the genus Erythrodiplax (see
Paulson 2003), are very difficult to separate based on imma-
and taxonomic study, are well worth the effort. Nymphs pre-
ture adults. Structural characters that separate young adults
served by simply killing them and storing in alcohol eventu-
have not yet been found in many species groups.
ally become soft, partly decomposed specimens that are soft
and distorted, making them difficult or impossible to mea-
sure accurately.
13.5 Preservation of Specimens

Nymphs.  In the field, live dragonfly nymphs should be put Labels should be made from acid-free bond paper, stored
in vented plastic bags or plastic vials with a small amount of within the vials, and should include GPS coordinates and a
wet sphagnum moss or other fibrous or light material and note on the microhabitat in which the specimens were found
kept cool. Too many large nymphs in one bag can lead to such as sand—moderate flow, or rocks—pool, or woody
predation, even though no water is present. In the lab, detritus—slow flow, or poor fen—small sphagnum pool
nymphs can be photographed and then released, reared or (Fig. 13.10). I recommend printing labels with a laser or ink-­
preserved. If nymphs are to be preserved, I recommend kill- jet printer. If the specimen was found in the field emerging,
ing them by dropping in near-boiling water (remove water or if the nymph was transported to a lab and allowed to
from heat source and then immediately immerge nymphs). emerge to the adult stage, the label should bear “assoc.,”
Notes or image recording to document living color patterns meaning that the exuvia was definitely associated with the
should be made prior to preserving the nymphs as delicate adult. Teneral adults found a short distance away from an
color differences disappear after preservation. Large nymphs exuvia, or even if found fully formed with wings out and
should be left in the hot water for 45 seconds to one minute, perched on an exuvia, might have flown and perched near a
smaller ones for about 20–30  seconds. After this time, different exuvia from which they emerged. In such cases, the
remove them from the hot water and allow them to cool for adult and exuvia can be put in the same vial but should be
a few minutes to room temperature (do not let dry). When labeled “not definitely associated”.
cool, the specimens can be placed in 75–80% ethanol. I usu- Exuviae and eggs can be put directly in 75 or 80% alco-
ally extend the labium and labial palpi at this time, when hol. Exuviae stored dry are brittle, and important structures
they are still pliable; these structures usually become stiff such as antennae, labium, and legs are easily broken off and
after being preserved for a long period, especially in 80% lost when handled, especially when manipulated for close
alcohol, and they can then be broken if manipulated. examination. Dry exuviae can be relaxed in 75 or 80% alco-
Injecting nearly fully-grown nymphs (F to F-4) with a small hol and their parts can then be more easily flexed so key
amount of alcohol before placing them in a vial improves characteristics can be observed. Exuviae stored in alcohol
preservation, but care must be taken not to distend the should not be allowed to become dry afterwards as they will
nymph by over-­injecting. Isopropyl alcohol can be used if decompose and fall apart very easily when handled, even if
ethanol is not available. Most species of Anisoptera fit in a alcohol is restored to the vial. Checking vials every few
4-dram vial, although larger vials are necessary for full- months for alcohol level prevents this problem.
grown nymphs of some genera. Large nymphs should be
placed anal end first into the vial to facilitate removal later. Adults.  Keeping dragonflies for reexamination and study
Within a month or two of initial preservation, the alcohol will require maintenance of specimens in a collection, either
should be replaced, and if a vial is packed full of nymphs, temporary or permanent. A collection is an irreplaceable
the alcohol should be replaced again after a few more resource for learning about dragonflies, especially by provid-
months of storage. Because caps and stoppers do not always ing reference specimens for comparison and data on species
seal completely, the entire vial collection should be checked distributions. The main value of voucher specimens is that
every few months for alcohol level. Although this method is they can be used to verify identifications and answer future
fairly time-consuming, the benefits it renders in condition questions on distribution. Proper techniques should be fol-
and longevity of specimens, as well as aiding identification lowed to minimize the amount of work undertaken to create
588 13  Methods for Collecting, Rearing and Preserving Dragonflies

and maintain a collection and to ensure ease of study and


accuracy of data.

A method for preserving the beautiful, bright colors and


color patterns of live dragonflies has not yet been found. The
beautiful eye colors and the array of blues, greens, yellows,
and reds of the body disappear quickly in dead dragonflies.
Simple drying procedures usually obscure or destroy colors,
and specimens become greasy. Preservation in ethanol
retains some colors (Young 1966), although in my experi-
ence, specimens in 95% ethanol become very brittle and pig-
ments eventually break up. Also, the large adults require
many vials that are expensive and require much space.
Pinned dragonflies, either in a dorsoventral plane with wings
spread horizontally or laterally through the thorax with
wings together, take a lot of storage space. Another disad-
vantage of pinned specimens is potential loss of heads, legs,
and other parts. Two methods that result in good to fair color
preservation are freeze-drying and acetoning. Because speci-
mens are preserved with wings together, space needed for Fig. 13.11  Position of head, wings, legs, and abdomen of adult drag-
storage is kept to a minimum. Davies (1954) introduced vac- onfly specimen ready to be acetoned
uum drying and Carle (1978) described the freeze-drying
technique, but the equipment needed is not available to most tone, the envelopes are removed from the jar, excess acetone
collectors, especially on extended field trips. The acetoning is drained from the envelopes and they are placed in a well-­
method (first proposed by White and Morse 1973) described ventilated room for several days (preferably air-conditioned).
below is an inexpensive, transportable method that produces An alternative is to remove the envelopes from the acetone,
dry specimens with most colors and color patterns preserved drain and let dry for a few minutes, and then place them in an
satisfactorily. air-tight container containing a drying agent, such as molec-
At the end of each day of collecting, specimens should be ular sieve (4A 1/16” beads, 8-12 mesh) or calcium chloride.
removed from the envelopes, and any further notes on color This latter procedure is fairly helpful in humid climates,
or color pattern taken. The quickest way to kill dragonflies is although such drying agents are no longer effective once
by placing them directly in acetone or injecting them with a saturated. When in extremely humid climates for extended
small amount of acetone while submerged in it. Immediately periods, I remove the envelopes from the acetone container
after death, the specimens are removed from the acetone, the and drain them, but I then store them still wet with acetone in
wings folded together, the abdomen straightened, the head an air-tight container until returning to a dry climate or an
turned to one side, and the legs pulled slightly away from the air-conditioned room where they can be dried properly.
thorax (Fig. 13.11); the specimens are then placed in paper When thoroughly dry, acetoned specimens will be very
triangles or glassine envelopes to be submersed back into brittle and fragile, so take extra care when handling them.
acetone. The specimens can then be transferred to cellophane or plas-
Before putting the envelopes in acetone, the date and tic envelopes containing a 3  ×  5-inch index card with the
locality data, or a coded number, should be written on the printed data (Fig.  13.12). If known, the latitude and longi-
envelopes in pencil or indelible ink. Be sure to check that the tude coordinates for the collection locality should also be
lead or ink is not affected by acetone before using it for included, along with elevation. It is best to put only one spec-
actual specimens. Specimens are then placed in a jar of ace- imen in an envelope. The male and female of a mated pair
tone for soaking, medium-sized to large specimens for about should be placed in individual, smaller cellophane envelopes
24 hours, very small dragonflies for about 12 to 18 hours. which are then put together in a 3 × 5 envelope. Species too
Longer periods of time may be necessary after the acetone large for male and female to fit together in a 3 × 5 envelope
becomes discolored from repeated usage. Once the acetone should be stored separately and the data cards marked
becomes yellow or tannin-colored, it no longer removes accordingly to indicate that they were mated.
enough water and fat from the insects to properly preserve Clear cellophane envelopes allow for rapid examination
them. Leaving specimens with certain kinds of pigment, of specimens without removing them, and they can be stored
such as light blue, for longer periods can bleach them; expe- in a box much like index cards are stored in a file drawer.
rience is the best teacher. After the required time in the ace- Insects stored in collections are prone to attack by scavenger
References 589

Fig. 13.12  Example of data


entered on a 3 × 5 inch index
card to be placed in a
cellophane or plastic envelope
with the dry specimen

insects such as psocids (small wingless insects related to Dunkle SW (1980) Second larval instars of Florida Anisoptera
booklice) and carpet beetles (Coleoptera: Dermestidae). (Odonata). Ph. D. Dissertation, University of Florida, Gainesville
Foster SE, Soluk DA (1994) Evaluating exuvia collection as a manage-
They feed on the tissues of dead insects and can hollow out ment tool for the federally endangered Hine’s emerald dragonfly,
or completely destroy museum specimens. Moth balls (naph- Somatochlora hineana Williamson (Odonata: Corduliidae). Biol
thalene) are effective in warding off these pests but are inef- Conserv 118:15–20
fective once a collection is infested; moth crystals Garrison RW (1993) The role of amateur and professional insect col-
lecting. Argia 5(1):5–9
(paradichlorobenzene) will kill most such pests. In a small Hammond CO (1977) The dragonflies of Great Britain and Ireland.
collection, the boxes can be sealed in large, zip-lock plastic Curwen Books, London. 115 pp
bags as a physical barrier to pests and to lessen escape of the Hutchinson R, Morrissette R (1977) Découverte de larves d’odonates
moth crystal fumes. The collection should be stored where vivantes dans une mare asséchée. Cordulia 3:145–146
Hutchinson R, Ménard B (2015) The Ménard aquatic net for collecting
relative humidity is low to help prevent fungi from growing dragonfly larvae. Argia 27(3):36–37
on the specimens. Lubertazzi MAA, Ginsberg HS (2009) Persistance of dragonfly exu-
viae on vegetation and rock substrates. Northeastern Naturalis
16(1):141–147
McCafferty WP (1981) Aquatic entomology. Science Books
References International, Boston. 448 pp
Merritt RW, Cummins KW, Berg MB (2008) An introduction to the
Askew RR (1988) The dragonflies of Europe. Harley Books, Colchester, aquatic insects of North America, 4th edn. Dubuque, Kendall Hunt.
UK. 291 pp 1158 pp
Boose AE (2014) Epiaeschna heros (Swamp Darner) and survivorship OdonataCentral (http://www.odonatacentral.org/index.php/
during dry periods in vernal pools. Argia 26(1):35–37 PageAction.get/name/CuratingInfo) accessed Aug. 10, 2016
Cannings RA (1982) Notes on the biology of Aeshna sitchensis Hagen Orr RL (1994) Proposed DSA collecting policy (guidelines). Argia
(Anisoptera: Aeshnidae). Odonatologica 11:219–223 6(3):6–8
Carle FL (1978) Freeze drying techniques for preserving dragonfly Paulson DR (2003) Comments on the Erythrodiplax connata
specimens. Odonatologica 7(1):11–13 (Burmeister, 1839) group, with the elevation of E. fusca (Rambur,
Cebulski BC (2009) Collecting odonates under the ice. Argia 21(3):8–9 1842), E. minuscula (Rambur, 1842), and E. basifusca (Calvert,
Cook C (1994) A novel technique for collecting aquatic invertebrates 1895) to full species (Anisoptera: Libellulidae). Bull Amer Odonatol
(with particular application to Odonata nymphs). Argia 5(4):6–8 6(4):101–110
Davies DAL (1954) On the preservation of insects by drying in vacuo at Raebel EM, Mercls T, Riordan P, McDonald DW, Thompson DJ (2010)
low temperature. Entomologist 87:34 The dragonfly delusion: why it is essential to sample exuviae to
Dragonfly Society of the Americas (1996) Statement of committee on avoid biased surveys. J Insect Conserv 14:523–533
collecting policy. Argia 8(2):36–37 Rowe RJ (1991) Larval development and emergence in Hemianax
DuBois RD (2015) Detection probabilities and sampling rates for papuensis (Burmeister) (Odonata: Aeshnidae). J Aust Entomol Soc
Anisoptera exuviae along river banks: influences of bank veg- 30:209–215
etation type, prior precipitation, and exuviae size. Int J  Odonatol Rowe R (2002) Rearing dragonflies. Austrolestes 3:2–3
18:205–215 Tennessen KJ (1979) Distance traveled by transforming nymphs of
DuBois R, Tennessen K (2016) The rewards of collecting and rearing Tetragoneuria at Marion County Lake, Alabama, United States
nymphs. Argia 28(2):5–8 (Anisoptera: Corduliidae). Notul Odonatolog 1(4):63–65
590 13  Methods for Collecting, Rearing and Preserving Dragonflies

Tennessen KJ (1994a) Feeding teneral adult dragonflies – and more on Dunkle SW (2000) Dragonflies through binoculars: a field guide to
rearing. Argia 6(1/2):19–20 dragonflies of North America. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Tennessen KJ (1994b) A collecting tip for gomphids. Argia 6(3):12 266 pp
Tennessen KJ (2016) What to feed tiny dragonfly nymphs? Argia Garrison M (2011) Damselflies of Chicagoland: a photo field guide,
28(3):19–22 version 2. Marla Garrison. 135 pp
Usinger RL (1963) Aquatic insects of California. University of Glotzhober RC, McShaffrey D (eds) (2002) The dragonflies and dam-
California Press, Berkeley. 508 pp selflies of Ohio. Ohio Biolog Surv Bull NS 14(2):1–364
White HB, Morse WJ (1973) Odonata (dragonflies) of New Hampshire: Hudson J, Armstrong RH (2005) Dragonflies of Alaska. John Hudson
an annotated list, Agricultural and Experimental Station Resources and Robert H, Armstrong. 48 pp
Report 30. University of New Hampshire, Durham. 46 pp Huggins DG, Brigham WU (1982) Odonata. In: Brigham AR, Brigham
Willey RL, Eiler HO (1972) Drought resistance in subalpine nymphs WU, Gnilka A (eds) Aquatic insects and oligochaetes of North
of Somatochlora semicircularis Selys (Odonata: Corduliidae). Am and South Carolina. Midwest Aquatic Enterprises, Mahomet, IL,
Mid Nat 87:215–221 pp 4.1–4.100
Young AM (1966) A new method for preserving color patterns and Hutchings G, Halstead D (2011) Dragonflies & damselflies in the hand:
color brilliance in dragonflies. Turtox News 44(2):58–59 an identification guide to Boreal forest odonates in Saskatchewan
and adjacent regions. Nature Saskatchewan, Regina. Special
Publication No. 29. 159 pp
Kerst C, Gordon K (2011) Dragonflies and damselflies of Oregon: a
field guide. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis. 304 pp
ADDENDUM. References for Identifying Adult Legler K, Legler D, Westover D (2013) Dragonflies of Wisconsin, 5.1
Anisoptera of North America (including edn. Karl Legler, Sauk City
Manolis T (2003) Dragonflies and damselflies of California. University
regional field guides) of California Press, Berkeley. 201 pp
Mead K (2017) Dragonflies of the North Woods, 3rd edn. Kollath-
Abbott JC (2015) Dragonflies of Texas: a field guide, Texas Natural Stensaas Publ, Duluth. 276 pp
History Guides. University of Texas, Austin. 448 pp Needham JG, Westfall MJ Jr (1955) A manual of the dragonflies of
Bailowitz R, Danforth D, Upson S (2015) A field guide to the North America (Anisoptera). University of California Press,
Damselflies & Dragonflies of Arizona and Sonora. Nova Granada Berkeley. 615 pp
Publications, Tucson Needham JG, Westfall MJ Jr, May ML (2000) Dragonflies of North
Beaton G (2007) Dragonflies and damselflies of Georgia and the America, Rev edn. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville, FL. 939 pp
Southeast. The University of Georgia Press, Athens. 355 pp Needham JG, Westfall MJ Jr, May ML (2014) Dragonflies of North
Behrstock RA (2008) Dragonflies & Damselflies of the southwest. Rio America, 3rd edn. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville, FL. 657 pp
Nuevo Publishers, Tucson. 80 pp Paulson D (2003) Comments on the Erythrodiplax connata (Burmeister,
Cannings RA, Stuart KM (1977) The dragonflies of British Columbia, 1839) group, with the elevation of E. fusca (Rambur, 1842), E.
British Columbia Provincial Museum Handbook No. 35. British minuscula (Rambur, 1842), and E. basifusca (Calvert, 1895) to full
Columbia Provincial Museum, Victoria. 254 pp species (Anisoptera: Libellulidae). Bull Am Odonatol 6(4):101–110
Carpenter V (1991) Dragonflies and damselflies of Cape Cod. Cape Paulson D (2009) Dragonflies and damselflies of the West. Princeton
Cod Museum of Natural History, Brewster. 79 pp University Press, Princeton, NJ. 535 pp
Curry JR (2001) Dragonflies of Indiana. Indiana Academy of Sciences, Paulson D (2011) Dragonflies and damselflies of the East. Princeton
Indianapolis. 303 pp University Press, Princeton, NJ. 538 pp
DuBois R (2010) Dragonflies & damselflies of the Rocky Mountains. Walker EM (1958) The Odonata of Canada and Alaska, vol 2. University
Kollath+Stensaas Publishing, Duluth, MN. 301 pp of Toronto Press, Toronto. 318 pp
Dunkle SW (1989) Dragonflies of the Florida Peninsula, Bermuda and Walker EM, Corbet PS (1975) The Odonata of Canada and Alaska, vol
the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville. 155 pp 3. University of Toronto Press, Toronto. 307 pp

You might also like