Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cite this article as: Acta Agron Sin, 2008, 34(8): 1424–1434. RESEARCH PAPER
Abstract: To investigate the absorption and utilization of major nutrient elements of rice (Oryza sativa L.) plant when wheat (Triticum
aestivum L.) residues returned to the field (residue incorporation, RI) or under site-specific nitrogen management (SSNM), the effects of
RI and SSNM on harvest index, translocation, and transportation efficiency were evaluated in 2005–2006, using a midseason japonica
rice cultivar of Yangjing 9538. The results showed that under same N level, compared with the no straw incorporation, RI reduced N
content and the accumulations of N, phosphorus (P), and potassium (K) in rice plants at the early growth stage but maintained high levels
of contents of P and K during the whole growth period. Moreover, RI improved the N use efficiency and the harvest index and biomass
production efficiency of N, P, and K. Under RI with the same amount of wheat residues, rice plants in SSNM had less absorption of N and
P than in the N fertilizer rate in farmer practice (FFP). However, the transportation percentages of N, P, and K from heading to maturity,
as well as the harvest indices of N and P under SSNM, were higher than those under FFP. The results indicate that both RI and SSNM can
increase the absorptions and use efficiencies of N, P, and K in rice plants, and their combination shows better effects.
Keywords: rice; wheat residue incorporation; site-specific nitrogen management; phosphorous; potassium; nutrition use efficiency
Application of nitrogen (N) fertilizer has been considered Plant Analysis Department, SPAD) or the leaf-color chart
as an important approach to increase grain yield in rice (LCC), and a scheme of N fertilizer is corresponding to the
production. However, excessive use of N may not only result SPAD or LCC readings. Therefore, the rate and time of N
in crop lodging, long vegetative growth, ripening delay, and application are in need of N absorption of plants [4, 5]. In China,
poor quality of grains but also aggravates the occurrences of the SSNM has been demonstrated in Zhejiang, Jiangsu, Hunan,
diseases and insect pests and reduces N use efficiency. Guangdong, Hubei, and Heilongjiang Provinces and proved to
Moreover, a series of environmental problems, such as be effective in N fertilizer saving and grain yield promotion [5, 6].
underground water pollution, eutrophication in the rivers and However, the absorption and use efficiency of phosphorous (P)
lakes, and greenhouse effect are accompanied with excessive and potassium (K) under SSNM have been rarely studies.
application of N fertilizer [1–3]. To resolve these problems, the Crop residue is a kind of energy materials that is rich in
site-specific N management (SSNM) has been introduced carbon. Returning crop residues to field has great significance
from the International Rice Research Institute, Los Banõs, the in maintaining soil fertility and developing sustainable
Philippines. The principle of SSNM is determining N agriculture [7]. With the development of chemical fertilizer,
application rate on the basis of indigenous N supply from soil, use of the organic fertilizers made from straw has dramatically
the target yield of rice, and absorption rate of plants. The N reduced. Although, the effects of residue returning to the field
condition in plants (represented by leaf color) is monitored on the growth and development of crop, as well as the yield
regularly or irregularly using the chlorophyll meter (Soil and formation, have been studied [6–10], the characteristics of
nutrition absorption under SSNM and wheat (Triticum Prior to incorporation, the field was flood irrigated. The
aestivum L.) residue incorporation (RI) are not well details in Table 1 were followed during N fertilizer application.
understood. In this study, the effects of RI and SSNM on Each plot was 30 m2 with 4 replicates. The plots were
absorption and utilization of N, P, and K in rice (Oryza sativa separated by a 1 m wide alley using plastic film inserted into
L.) plants were investigated to provide theoretical bases for the soil to a depth of 50 cm.
high yielding and high efficiency in production of rice. Seeds were sown in nursery on 18 May, and seedlings were
transplanted on 6 June at a hill spacing of 0.2 m × 0.2 m with
1 Materials and methods 2 seedlings per hill. Before transplanting, the paddy field was
applied with P fertilizer of 75 kg ha1 (as calcium phosphate)
1.1 Experimental site and plant material and K fertilizer of 90 kg ha1 (as KCl). Shallow water was
The experiment was conducted in the farm of Yangzhou maintained during the total growth period except for drainage
University (Yangzhou, China), and the soil was a sandy loam. at leaf ages of 14 to 15. Insect pests and weeds were
After the previous crop (wheat) was harvested, the soil completely controlled.
fertility was assayed with 2.02% organic matter and available 1.3 Sampling and measurements
N, P, and K at 103.2, 24.5, and 85.6 mg kg1, respectively.
A mid-season japonica cultivar of Yangjing 9538 was 1.3.1 Chlorophyll content The second leaf from the top
planted in a paddy field. This cultivar had 17 leaves in the and the flag leaf were sampled before and after heading,
main stem and 5 elongated internodes with the whole growth respectively, at a 10-day interval from 20 d after transplanting
period of 150–155 d. (26 June). In each plot, 20 leaves were measured every time
using SPAD 502, with 3 measured points per leaf at upper,
1.2 Experiment design medium, and lower position of the leaf. The average of the 3
In 2005 and 2006 growing seasons, treatments of wheat measurements was used.
residue management (A) and N management (B) were carried 1.3.2 Nutrient contents Rice plants of 5 hills from each
out in a split-plot design with the main plot of factor A and plot were sampled at the stages of mid-tillering, panicle
split plot of factor B. In factor A, 2 levels, i.e. minimum initiation, heading, and maturity. Plant shoot (plant excluding
tillage with no wheat residue incorporation (A1) and the roots) were separated into stems and sheaths, leaves, and
minimum tillage with all wheat residues incorporation (RI, A2) panicles prior to being dried in an oven and ground. The
(7.21 t ha1 in 2005 and 7.38 t ha1 in 2006) were arranged; in contents of N, P, and K in different organs were assayed as
factor B, 3 levels, namely, no N fertilizer applied (B1), N described by Bao [11].
fertilizer rate in farmer practice (FFP, B2), and SSNM (B3) 1.4 Formulas and statistical analysis The nutrition
were arranged. Wheat straws were shattered with a combine harvest index (HI), translocation (TL), and transportation
machine at harvest and incorporated into the soil with a tractor. efficiency (TE) were calculated using the following formulas:
Analysis for variance (ANOVA) was carried out using a result, the translocation rate and translocation efficiency of
SAS/STAT statistical analysis package (version 6.12, SAS N from heading to maturity were significantly enhanced in A2
Institute, Cary, NC, USA). The plots were generated using treatment than in A1 treatment (Fig. 2). Under the same straw
SigmaPlot 8.0 software. management, SSNM decreased the accumulation of N in
vegetative organs but increased N content in grains. Although
2 Results SSNM decreased the amount of N utilization from heading to
maturity, it significantly improved N translocation from
2.1 Effects of RI and SSNM on absorption and utilization vegetative organs to grains. These results indicated that both
of nitrogen RI and SSNM increased in N use efficiency by improving N
allocation in vegetative organs and grains of rice.
2.1.1 N content in rice plants Compared with A1
2.1.3 Harvest index of nitrogen Under the same N
treatment, A2 treatment reduced the N content in plants at
management, RI and N application significantly increased N
midtillering under the same N management, and the N content
harvest index compared with no wheat residue returned
increased with the growth process of rice. Under the same
treatment. Under the same straw management, SSNM
wheat straw management, N content in plants was lower in
enhanced N harvest index by 7.66% compared with FFP (Fig.
SSNM than in FFP treatment during the whole growth period.
3). This indicated that there was an excessive absorption of N
The reductions were significant at midtillering and heading fertilizer under FFP and most of the N was accumulated in the
stages but not significant at the maturity stage. The data in vegetative organs and few were translocated to the grains. RI
both years showed a similar trend with no significant and SSNM could increase N proportion in the grains and N
difference (Table 2). harvest index.
2.1.2 Distribution and transportation of nitrogen At the
maturity stage, most N was distributed in grains, followed by 2.2 Effects of RI and SSNM on absorption and utilization
stems and leaves. Under the same N management, RI of phosphorus
treatment significantly increased N content in leaves and 2.2.1 P content in rice plants Under the same N
grains at maturity but decreased N content in stems (Fig. 1). As management, RI increased the P content in plants during the
whole growth period compared with the wheat straw removal
treatment (A1). Under the same wheat straw management,
Table 2 Effects of wheat residue incorporation and site-specific
SSNM reduced P content during the whole growing period
nitrogen management on yield and N content in rice plants
compared with FFP, indicating that RI could increase P
N content (mg g1) content in rice plants (Table 3).
Grain yield
Treatment Panicle 2.2.2 Distribution and transportation of phosphorus
(t ha1) Midtillering Heading Maturity
initiation According to the proportions of P accumulation in different
2005 organs, grains distributed the most amount of P at maturity,
A1B1 5.26 d 26.7 c 14.9 b 11.2 d 9.7 c
whereas the leaves distributed the least. Under the same N
A1B2 7.48 c 31.7 a 16.2 ab 16.2 b 12.3 ab
management, compared with A1 treatment, RI significantly
A1B3 8.02 a 27.8 c 15.1 b 15.8 c 12.0 b
decreased P content in leaves and stems at maturity, and
Mean 6.92 28.7 15.4 14.4 11.3
markedly increased the amount and percentage of P
A2B1 5.21 d 25.9 d 15.6 b 11.4 d 10.3 c
translocation by 3.4 kg ha1 and 4.7%, respectively, from
A2B2 7.72 b 29.2 b 17.3 a 17.1 a 12.8 a
heading to maturity. Under the same straw management,
A2B3 8.10 a 27.6 c 15.9 ab 16.2 b 12.6 ab
SSNM decreased the P content in leaves in comparison with
Mean 7.01 27.6 16.2 14.9 11.9
FFP, accordingly the translocation amount of P reduced by
2006
A1B1 5.40 d 26.4 d 14.6 cd 11.0 d 10.2 c
2.6% from heading to maturity. However, the translocation
A1B2 7.41 c 32.0 a 15.6 bc 16.5 a 12.5 ab percentage of P increased by 3.3% (Figs. 4 and 5). These
A1B3 8.36 a 28.3 c 15.3 bc 15.0 c 12.4 ab results indicated that RI promoted P translocation from
Mean 7.06 28.9 15.2 14.2 11.7 vegetative organs to grains.
A2B1 5.29 d 26.1 d 15.4 bc 11.4 d 10.7 c
2.2.3 Harvest index of phosphorus Under the same N
A2B2 7.81 b 30.2 b 17.0 a 16.6 a 12.9 a management, when compared with no wheat residue
A2B3 8.51 a 28.1 c 16.2 ab 15.9 b 12.8 a incorporation treatment, RI significantly increased P harvest
Mean 7.20 28.1 16.2 14.6 12.2 index by 8.2%. Under the same amount of straw incorporation,
In each year, values within columns followed by different letters are SSNM enhanced P harvest index compared with FFP (Fig. 6).
significantly different at P < 0.05. Therefore, higher P proportion in grains and P harvest index
Treatments described as in Table 1. can be obtained with the approaches of RI and SSNM.
XU Guo-Wei et al. / Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2008, 34(8): 1424–1434
2005 2006
30
Leaf Leaf
25
20
15
10
5
0
70
N accumulation (kg ha1)
60 Stem Stem
50
40
30
20
10
0
180
Grain Grain
150
120
90
60
30
0
0N FFP SSNM 0N FFP SSNM
Nitrogen management Nitrogen management
A1 A2
Fig. 1 Proportion of N accumulation in leaves, stems, and grains at maturity stage of rice
Treatments described as in Table 1.
2005 2006
100
Amount of N transport
80
(kg ha1)
60
40
20
0
80
Percentage of N transport
60
(%)
40
20
0
0N FFP SSNM 0N FFP SSNM
Nitrogen management Nitrogen management
A1 A2
Fig. 2 Effects of wheat residue incorporation and site-specific nitrogen management on N translocation
from vegetative organs to grains during grain filling of rice
Treatments described as in Table 1.
XU Guo-Wei et al. / Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2008, 34(8): 1424–1434
2005 2006
3.0
Leaf Leaf
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
18
Stem Stem
P accumulation (kg ha1)
15
12
9
6
3
0
70
60 Grain Grain
50
40
30
20
10
0
0N FFP SSNM 0N FFP SSNM
Nitrogen management Nitrogen management
A1 A2
Fig. 4 Proportion of P accumulation in leaves, stems, and grains at maturity stage of rice
Treatments described as in Table 1.
XU Guo-Wei et al. / Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2008, 34(8): 1424–1434
2005 2006
30
25
Amount of P transport
20
(kg ha1)
15
10
5
0
80
Percentage of P transport
60
(%)
40
20
0
0N FFP SSNM 0N FFP SSNM
Nitrogen management Nitrogen management
A1 A2
Fig. 5 Effects of wheat residue incorporation and site-specific nitrogen management on P translocation
from vegetative organs to grains during grain filling of rice
Treatments described as in Table 1.
Table 4 Effects of wheat residue incorporation and site-specific the straw removal treatment. Under RI, the number of soil
nitrogen management on K content in rice plants microorganisms can increase rapidly to decompose the
Treatment Midtillering Panicle initiation Heading Maturity organism into humus and release the nutrient components.
2005 Simultaneously, the soil carbon and other nonorganic nutrition
A1B1 3.71 d 3.14 d 2.06 c 1.29 d were assimilated for biomass of the microorganisms. During
A1B2 4.04 b 3.51 bc 2.55 b 1.65 b this process, microorganisms consume a lot of N nutrition for
A1B3 4.26 a 3.59 b 2.57 b 1.48 c its own metabolism. Therefore, the growth and development
Mean 4.00 3.41 2.39 1.47 of rice plant are affected at the early growth stage under
A2B1 3.89 c 3.38 c 2.17 c 1.38 cd RI [12–15]. However, during the whole growth period, RI
A2B2 4.37 a 3.62 b 2.70 a 1.62 b improves the absorption and accumulation of P and K with
A2B3 4.29 a 3.79 a 2.73 a 1.80 a higher contents of P and K in rice plant than in no wheat
Mean 4.18 3.60 2.53 1.60
residue incorporation treatment. This is probably because RI
2006
can not only provide soluble P and K for direct use but also
A1B1 3.62 d 3.28 e 2.08 d 1.27 d
activate microorganism in soil to release more P and K
A1B2 4.16 b 3.47 d 2.47 c 1.55 b
A1B3 4.11 b 3.65 c 2.52 bc 1.54 b
nutrition [16–18].
Mean 3.96 3.47 2.36 1.45 RI increases N use efficiency under all N application rates.
This may be explained in several reasons. RI could enhance
A2B1 3.85 c 3.47 d 2.15 d 1.42 bc
A2B2 4.42 a 3.89 a 2.88 a 1.53 b
nitrate reductase activity in roots and leaves in rice and maize
A2B3 4.36 a 3.74 ab 2.66 b 1.82 a (Zea mays. L.) and promote the absorption of N, leading to
Mean 4.21 3.70 2.57 1.59 an increase in the total amount of N absorption [14, 19]. Yang
In each year, values within columns followed by different letters are et al. [20] reported that the enhancement of nutrition
significantly different at P < 0.05. absorption was related to the enhancement of phosphatase
Treatments described as in Table 1. activity in root surface, and phosphatase played an important
2005 2006
30
Leaf Leaf
25
20
15
10
5
0
250
Stem Stem
K accumulation (kg ha1)
200
150
100
50
0
80
Grain Grain
60
40
20
0
0N FFP SSNM 0N FFP SSNM
Nitrogen management Nitrogen management
A1 A2
Fig. 7 Proportion of K accumulation in leaves, stems, and grains at maturity stage of rice
Treatments described as in Table 1.
XU Guo-Wei et al. / Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2008, 34(8): 1424–1434
2005 2006
120
Amount of K transport
100
80
(kg ha1) 60
40
20
0
50
Percentage of K transport
40
30
(%)
20
10
0
0N FFP SSNM 0N FFP SSNM
Nitrogen management Nitrogen management
A1 A2
Fig. 8 Effects of wheat residue incorporation and site-specific nitrogen management on K translocation
from vegetative organs to grains during grain filling of rice
Treatments described as in Table 1.
0.0
high activity of roots at heading and late grain filling stages.
0.3 In addition, RI could enhance the activity draw power of sink,
2006 resulting in more nutrition translocating from vegetative
organs to grains [19, 20].
0.2
application for the midseason japonica rice cultivar of Performance of site-specific nutrient management for irrigated
Yangjing 9538. Either with wheat residue incorporation or rice in southeast China. Agron J, 2001, 93: 869–878
with straw removal, the N use efficiency was significantly [7] Wang Z Z, Dong B S,Wu J M.Effect of the straw returned into
higher under SSNM than under FFP; simultaneously, the grain soil in rice and wheat planting area of Taihu regionJAnhui
Agric Sci, 2002, 30: 269–271 (in Chinese with English
yield of rice was higher to some extent. Xu [23] studied the
abstract)
SPAD reading criteria using several rice cultivars and gave
[8] Kludze H K, Delaune R D. Straw application effects on
results as 36 (equiv. LCC reading of 3.0) for indica rice and
methane and oxygen exchange and growth in rice. Soil Sci Soc
39 (equiv. LCC reading of 3.5) for japonica rice. These Am J, 1995, 59: 824–830
criteria have proved to be able to obtain high yield and N use [9] Ocio J A, Brookes P C, Jenkinson D S. Field incorporation of
efficiency in rice [24]. We observed that rice plants needed straw and its effects on soil microbial biomass and soil
more N nutrition during the early growth period under RI than inorganic N. Soil Biol Biochem, 1991, 23: 171–176
under the wheat-residue removal treatment. Therefore, the [10] Liu T X, Ji X E. Effect of crop straw burning on soil organic
SSNM technique should be improved precisely in the rate and matter and soil microbes. Soil, 2003, 35: 347–348 (in Chinese
proportion of N application at different growth stages to meet with English abstract)
the requirement of rice plants under RI. [11] Bao S D. Analysis of Soil and Agrichemistry. Beijing: China
Agriculture Press, 2000. p 12 (in Chinese)
[12] Zhang Z J. Effect of long-term returning straw on crop yield
4 Conclusions
and soil fertility. Chin J Soil Sci, 1998, 29: 154–155 (in
Chinese with English abstract)
RI reduces N content and the accumulations of N, P, and K
[13] Eagle A J, Bird J A, Horwath W R. Rice yield and nitrogen
in rice plants at the early growth stage but increases the efficiency under alternative straw management practices.
contents of P and K in plants during the whole growth period. Agron J, 2000, 92: 1096–1103
Both RI and SSNM can increase N use efficiency and the [14] Witt C, Cassman K G, Olk D C. Crop rotation and residue
harvest indices of N and P. The combination of RI and SSNM management effects on carbon sequestration, nitrogen cycling
can efficiently improve absorption and use efficiency of N, P, and productivity of irrigated rice systems. Plant Soil, 2000, 225:
and K in rice plants. 263–278
[15] Insam H, Mitchel C C, Dormaar J F. Relationship of soil
microbial biomass and activity with fertilization and crop yield
Acknowledgments
of three ultisols. Soil Biol Biochem, 1991, 23: 459–464
[16] Liu L J, Sang D Z, Liu C L, Wang Z Q, Yang J C, Zhu Q S.
This study was supported by the National Natural Science
Effect of real-time and site-special nutrient management on rice
Foundation of China (30671225 and 30771274), the National
yield and N use efficiency. Sci Agric Sin, 2003, 36: 1456–1461
Key Technologies R & D Program of China (2006BAD (in Chinese with English abstract)
02A13-3-2), and the Program of Introducing International [17] Peng S B, Huang J L, Zhong X H, Yang J C, Wang G H, Zou Y
Super Agricultural Science and Technology of China B, Zhang F S, Zhu Q S, Roland B, Christian W. Research
(2006-G60). strategy in proving N-fertilizer use efficiency of irrigation rice
in China. Sci Agric Sin, 2002, 35: 1095–1103 (in Chinese with
References English abstract)
[18] Wang G H, Zhang Q C, Huang C Y. SSNM–A new approach
[1] Li Q K.Fertilizer Issues in Sustainable Development of China to increasing fertilizer N use efficiency and reducing N loss
Agriculture.Nanchang: JiangxiScience and Technology Press, from rice fields. J Zhejiang Univ (Agric Life Sci), 2003, 29:
1997 (in Chinese) 67–70 (in Chinese with English abstract)
[2] Kumar K, Goh K M. Crop residues and management practices: [19] Huo Z,Wang P,Fu J F. Effects of two N-fertilizers on the
effects on soil quality, soil nitrogen dynamics, crop yield and growth of summer maize with straw in the field.Acta Agric
nitrogen recovery. Adv Agron, 2000, 68: 197–319 Boreali-Sin, 2005, 20: 100–104 (in Chinese with English
[3] Ocio J A, Brookes P C, Jenkinson D S. Field incorporation of abstract)
straw and its effects on soil microbial biomass and soil [20] Yang C M,Yang L Z,Yan Y M,Ou Y Z. Effect of nutrient
inorganic N. Soil Biol Biochem, 1991, 23: 171–176 regimes on dry matter production and nutrient uptake and
[4] Peng S, Garcia F V, Laza R C, Sanico A L, Visperas R M, distribution by rice plan. Chin J Soil Sci,2004, 35: 199–202 (in
Cassman K G. Increased N-use efficiency using a chlorophyll Chinese with English abstract)
meter on high yielding irrigated rice. Field Crops Res, 1996, 47: [21] Prettykm K M. Potassium and Crop Quality. Saskatchewan,
243–252 Canada: Potash and Phosphate Institute, 1980. pp 165–178
[5] Hussain F, Bronson K F, Yadvinder S, Bijay S, Peng S. Use of [22] Tian X Y,Shi X J.The effects of different fertilizers on the
chlorophyll meter sufficiency indices for nitrogen management absorption and utilization of rice and wheat.J Chongqing
of irrigated rice in Asia. Agron J, 2000, 92: 875–879 Normal Univ (Nat Sci),2003, 20: 44–47 (in Chinese with
[6] Wang G H, Dobermann A, Witt C, Sun Q Z, Fu R X. English abstract)
XU Guo-Wei et al. / Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2008, 34(8): 1424–1434
[23] Xu W. Study and Demonstration on Site-Specific Nitrogen [24] Yoshida S. Fundamentals of Rice Crop Science. Los Banns, the
Management in Rice. MS Thesis of Yangzhou University, 2006 Philippines: International Rice Research Institute, 1981. pp
(in Chinese with English abstract) 255–269