Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arc Resistant…..
Metalclad Switchgear...
...to 15 kV, to 63 kA.
...to 26 kV, to 40 kA.
...to 38 kV, to 40 kA.
For:
Oil & Gas
Chemical
Electric Utilities
Industrials
Technical Municipals
Authorities
Information Marine
Railway & Transit
...etc.
Indoor or Outdoor
Switchgear and Apparatus Available To IEEE Standards For Domestic Use, or IEC Standards For International use.
2 61 Steamboat Road, Great Neck, NY 11024, U.S.A. Tel: 516-829-9060 e-mail: sales@pacsindustries.com
What is Arc Fault Damage?
Arc-flash is normally the result of a short circuit that can occur randomly,
because of poor maintenance practices, deteriorating insulation creating ioni-
zation, tools being left behind on live bus bars, animals, or any such event.
The fault can occur between phase and ground or across phases. A series of
destructive and life threatening events are set in motion, as illustrated in the
four panels to the right. In the worst case, the complete system available short
circuit can flash across the fault, causing considerable damage.
Arc-Current can flash across the short circuit.. A plasma arc is created by
this energy, which can create temperatures as high 35,000 degrees Fahren-
heit within a millisecond. The Arc-Flash can expand with high speed that can
exceed 300 feet per second. There is an immediate burst of radiation of visi-
ble and invisible light, in the range of 300 to 1500 nm, copper expands and
vaporizes by a factor of 67,000.
Arc-Blast is immediate, and a powerful pressure wave occurs which can
exceed thousands of pounds, accompanied by sound that can exceed 160
db. Material, metal, flames and smoke is expelled away from the arc at
speeds exceeding 700 miles per hour, which can create shrapnel that com-
pletely penetrates the body. Arc flashes can kill at a distance of 10 feet.
Arc-Fault collectively describes the forgoing events.
Safety Steps. NFPA E70 requires the use of Personnel Protective Equip-
ment (PPE) when operating switchgear, and IEEE C37.20.07 is the defining
Standard for Arc-Resistant switchgear. PPE clothing is rated from Hazard/
Risk Category 0 to Category 4. The use of Arc-resistant switchgear can mate-
rially reduce the Hazard/Risk rating, a result of which could be less stringent
(or no) PPE clothing. Most important however, is that even though
PPE can protect against burning, shock, or similar hazards, it CANNOT
PREVENT AGAINST INJURIES CAUSED BY THE VIOLENT NATURE OF
AN ARC-FAULT EXPLOSION. Arc-Resistant switchgear can however, con-
tain these violent forces which can mitigate or prevent injuries, or worse.
Representative views of switchgear damaged or destroyed by the effects of an Arc-Fault. Above representations can be mitigated by use of a roof
mounted Collector Plenum as on further pages.
61 Steamboat Road, Great Neck, NY 11024, U.S.A. Tel: 516-829-9060 e-mail: sales@pacsindustries.com 3
Type Testing Criteria
FAILED PASSED
Test standards require that a thermal indicator rack ( 2 During a test series, a cubicle failed. Upon investi- There were several subsequent tests after the
meters high) containing black cotton fabric be placed in gation it was found that a plug weld was not strong welding design change, and they all passed.
front (and sides for Type 2) of cubicle being tested. If enough for the forces exerted. The plug weld design This photo illustrates how the front of the switch-
was changed to stitch welds at the laboratory (and
fabric ignites during a test, this is a failure. During a se- gear has contained the Arc fault explosion, and
in later production) and the unit was retested. This
ries of tests, a cubicle may sometimes fail. After investi- photo is representative of a bolted short circuit how the energy debris has been moved to the
gation, corrections are made (at the lab) on remaining failure that could occur in non-Arc Resistant switch- top Collector Plenum. In an actual installation,
cubicles and the tests continue. Normally, spare cubicles gear. this would be ducted out of the area.
are included for retest. You do not want to be there ! ! !
Following are the IEEE C37.20.7-2007 test criteria assessments required to pass Arc Resistant Type
Tests. These tests are conducted in high power laboratories such as KEMA.
Arc duration should be maintained for 0.5 seconds.
No fragmentation of the enclosure occurs within the test time. IEEE allows small parts up to 60 grams to be ejected
over the 2 meter height.
There shall be no burn-through of metal cubicle surfaces (Type 1 & Type 2).
No cotton indicators shall be ignited. Surface charring is permitted.
All grounding connections remain effective.
Accessibility Type 1: Switchgear with arc-resistant designs or features at the freely accessible front of the equipment only.
Accessibility Type 2: Switchgear with arc-resistant designs or features at the freely accessible exterior (front, back, and sides) of the
equipment only.
Suffix B: This is a new standard that applies to Type 1 and Type 2. It applies specifically to compartments designated as low voltage
control , or instrumentation compartments. During testing, “Suffix B” requires that indicators be placed directly in front of such com-
partments with the doors removed to evaluate the entrance of ionized gases into those compartments.
Suffix C This suffix is designated for equipment where isolation from the effects of an internal arcing fault is desired between all of the
compartments within a vertical switchgear cubicle. An Arc fault within a vertical cubicle with compartments would undoubtedly
cause bowing and distortion which would render the complete vertical cubicle unusable. PACSafe switchgear is constructed wit h a
double 11 gauge wall between cubicles, and the Vertical Plenum separates adjacent vertical cubicles by six inches, minimum. Conse-
quently, since there has never been burn-through between adjacent vertical cubicles, PACSafe equipment is offered as Suffix C be-
tween adjacent vertical cubicles.
Suffix D: This is a new standard. It is designed for special applications where certain installations would require that flame indicators
be placed at the front of the switchgear, and then only those surfaces (sides or rear) that are accessible to personnel.
4 61 Steamboat Road, Great Neck, NY 11024, U.S.A. Tel: 516-829-9060 e-mail: sales@pacsindustries.com
The Plenum System
In order to safely divert the Arc Tunnel Type Vent Direct Vertical Access
Blast pressure, flame, debris, Vent
gas, etc., from the switchgear Collector Plenum
Collector Plenum
interior, various plenums and
Tunnel
tunnel designs have been devel-
oped that divert the blast from
the affected cubicle interior, to a
safer location. Each compart-
ment of a vertical switchgear
cubicle such as the circuit
breaker, main bus, cabling com-
partment, etc., includes flaps Above is an illustration of a “Tunnel Type” system that Each vertical cubicle of PACSafe switchgear directly accesses
that are forced open by the Arc uses a common horizontal tunnel located within the the top exiting Collector Panel using our patented Vertical
Blast. The pressure of the blast switchgear to create a path out of the affected cubicle Isolated Plenum (VIP), and/or Vertical Direct Access (VDA) to
then forces all the Arc Blast and into a vertical exit vent. This tunnel will route directly discharge Arc Blast byproducts into the exiting top
byproducts into these plenums, through a number of adjacent cubicles until it reaches Collector Plenum. A common interior tunnel is not used. Each
which reduces the cubicle pres- a vertical empty section and thence to the exit plenum. vertical cubicle includes a dedicated VIP or VDA that is not
sure and diverts these byprod- This could create a longer path, and with the possibil- shared by adjacent cubicles. Field ducting will direct these
ucts out of the switchgear and to ity of penetrating neighboring cubicles. PACS does dangerous by products into a safe area. Two vents may be also
a safer area. not use this method. Two vents may also be used. be used.
Ductwork
PASSED
Although the photo at the left looks ominous, it is actually a “Pass” for an Arc Resistant Type Test we performed at KEMA in about 1996. All of the Arc Blast
byproducts have been forced to the top of the switchgear, and do not come through the front doors. In those days switchgear without the top Collector Plenums
were common, but it created a terrible environmental condition for the operators, and the explosion could as well damage the building. Since then however,
PACS has developed a Collector Plenum mounted on the switchgear roof which routes these byproducts through field installed ductwork to a safe area, safe-
guarding the operators and the building. The center photo shows the ductwork installed in the field. The right illustration depicts an Arc Blast being routed away
from the operator through the ductwork. Without such ductwork, the ceiling height above the switchgear would need to be 8-12 feet, the building must withstand
the severe Arc Blast pressure, and equipment such as cable trays, lighting, etc., must not be installed over the switchgear.
IEEE C37.20.7-2007, paragraph B.2.3.2.2 , Building Considerations (in part) states : “When the arc-resistant switchgear vents the overpressure
directly into the building, the building must be evaluated for the items below:” “ d) The ability of the ceiling, roof, and other structural components
of the building located in the path of arc gases released from the switchgear’s pressure relief vents to remain intact when exposed to the exhaust so
they will not be damaged, compromise the areas designated by the switchgear accessibility type rating, or create additional hazards. These items
may need to be flame resistant.”. PACS’ NOTE: The use of the PACSafe Collector Plenum should always be specified to avoid these problems.
SPECIFY & PURCHASE VERTICAL ISOLATION PLENUM, & COLLECTOR PLENUM SWITCHGEAR
61 Steamboat Road, Great Neck, NY 11024, U.S.A. Tel: 516-829-9060 e-mail: sales@pacsindustries.com 5
Details
Standards: The switchgear portion is manufactured to the standards of IEEE C37.20.2. The Arc Resistant switchgear enclosures manufac-
tured to the standards of C37.20.7-2007. Circuit breakers manufactured to standard of IEEE C37.20.4,6,9. Some IEC standards.
Circuit Breakers:
C37.20.7-2007 criteria allows that rather than use actual circuit breakers and other major components in these destruc-
tive Type Tests, that equivalent volume dummy devices may be used.
As a consequence the actual Arc Resistant enclosure being tested is independent of interior components. Therefore any
brand of circuit breaker can be used in PACSafe switchgear, such as GE, Siemens, ABB, Square D, Areva, or Eaton
vacuum circuit breakers. At 24-38 kV, we provide our own vacuum drawout circuit breaker. In all cases, we build the cell
to meet stringent Arc Resistant requirements.
2-high PACSafe switchgear, with PACSafe circuit breakers utilize safe PACSafe switchgear utilizes simple one-
lifting rack for 2 high breakers. through-the-door racking. Or remote. handle open/close method for front & rear.
ABB Breaker-
38 kV Arc resistant
switchgear now GE Breaker
available in 2 high
construction.
6 See appropriate PACS’ metalclad bulletins (to 15 kV, to 38 kV) or industry references for standard circuit breaker ratings.
Details
PACSafe PCC being prepared for shipment. Includes other PACSafe metalclad switchgear in an outdoor PCC manufactured in
items such as MCCs, aux transformers, LV switchgear, etc. PACS’ factory, prior to disassembly for road clearances.
IEEE C37.20.2, C37-20-7-2007 , IEEE C37.20.2, NFPA E70, and other similar references are trade mark property of IEEE, NFPA, and others. Used for reference only.
7
61 Steamboat Road, Great Neck, NY 11024, U.S.A. Tel: 516-829-9060 e-mail: sales@pacsindustries.com
Typical Dimension Guide
Arc Resistant switchgear, does not allow for relays and other devices to be mounted on the doors in front of the Arc Resistant
cubicles because these doors must contain the pressures created by an Arc Blast. Consequently, many specifications do
not properly serve the protective relay and control requirements. Most available 2 high Arc Resistant switchgear allows only
for a small 19” high by 30” control cubicle placed between the upper cubicle and lower cubicle. PACSafe switchgear offers a
series of cubicles with various control configurations to allow maximum space and flexibility for controls. See below. Call
PACS for final dimensions. 3000 Amp and 4000 Amp breakers may not have medium voltage equipment installed in the
upper cubicle. All cables that enter switchgear must be properly sealed by installer against pressure. For bus duct entry,
contact PACS. Following for estimating purposes only. Contact PACS for project-specific requirements, and for PCC outdoor
Control cubicle showing space & tight wiring.
dimensions.
Front Views Side Views
To 15 kV and 26 kV (125 kV BIL)
Collector Plenum 24” 15kV or 26kV 9” Collector Plenum typical for all 12”
Floor Plan Views
Control 1 high, Control
101” controls on Power
Compartment cable Cable entry Power
top. entry top or bottom
125” Control cables cables
36” wide. top
total
Model VDA Main top or bottom
height Bus
Circuit breaker typical Power
for all
Circuit breaker
or Potential wiring
Models or Potential
transformer compart-
transformer
compartment ment
To 15 kV, depth 96 inches.
26 kV (125 kV BIL, depth 108”)
Instrument and control space is normally limited on two-high construction for Arc Resistant switchgear, because unlike standard,
non-Arc Resistant switchgear, the front doors may not be penetrated with instruments or other such devices.
The unique construction of PACSafe Model VIP addresses this problem because of our patented Vertical Isolated Plenum Model
VIP construction. The VIP offers additional vertical control space of 6 inches minimum width, to 12 inches optional width. The
difference being a function of required control devices to be installed on a given circuit. Please note in the sketch above, that the
front of the vertical plenum is sealed from the Arc Resistant section, the same as is for any other control section.
The minimum 6 inch width allows for switches to be installed in this space relieving the center control space. If additional space
for relays is required, this space can be widened to 12 inches during design. The control front of the VIP can be equipped with a
door when relays are used.
In comparing floor space required for the basic VIP (42”) against the tunnel method (36”) please be aware that the tunnel type
could require a 36” wide vertical column about every 5 cubicles, which could require additional floor space.
OSHA, NEC, NFPA (and other agencies) require that the Owner , User or Maintainer (OUM) of switchgear shall provide a safe workplace for all personnel. PACSafe products
W Rev o
shall be properly installed and used by OUM, and OUM shall train personnel prior to operating or maintaining PACSafe and other PACS products. During maintenance all 8
power must be disconnected. Proper PPE must be worn as determined by the OUM. PACS Industries, Inc., assumes no legal responsibility or liabilities of any injuries or
death or damage to property whether sold through a third party reseller or directly to a OUM.