Professional Documents
Culture Documents
John C. Lammers
March 9, 2000
This paper was made possible through support provided by the Office of Population, Bureau
for Global Affairs, U.S. Agency for International Development, under the terms of Grant number
CCP-A-00-94-00014-4. The author wishes to thank Valerie Barker, Joshua Barbour, and Jeffrey
Farrar for their assistance on this project.
Leadership concepts review, page 2 of 26
Leadership:
A Brief Review of Traditional, Recent, and Emerging Concepts
Abstract
Outline
Tables
Introduction
There may be more written about the concept of leadership than any other single topic in
the social and management sciences. Bass (1990) reviewed 7,500 publications for his 1,000-page
review of leadership. ABI/Inform, a highly regarded on-line business reference data base, in
January 2000 lists 23,962 books and articles published under the keyword “leadership” since
1971. The topic is currently more popular than ever. Amazon.com, the successful on-line
bookseller, lists 7,226 currently available book titles under the heading of leadership. It is a topic
Leadership also is a concept that is defined in many ways. Bennis has identified 300
different characteristics of an effective leader in his publications (please see the bibliography).
Bass (1990) found nine major taxonomies of leadership characteristics with 58 unique and
overlapping leadership categories. The popular and professional leadership literature is full of
confidently numbered prescriptions: seven habits (Covey, 1989, 1990); five disciplines (Senge,
1990); 21 irrefutable laws (Maxwell, 1998); five temptations (Lencioni, 1998); five challenges
(Kouzes & Posner, 1990); eight reasons leaders’ change efforts fail (Kotter, 1996); three levels
With all the work that is being accomplished in the leadership arena, a sense of
government and business organizations throughout the world. But there is no quick-
Leadership concepts review, page 4 of 26
fix solution. We need to meet the many challenges of leadership, which include the
engendering a sense of trust in the organization, and managing its scarce resources
Fifteen years ago, Bennis and Nanus (1985) also noted a chronic crisis of leadership in
American institutions; that is, the pervasive inability of organizations to cope with the
conclude, “if there was ever a moment in history when a comprehensive strategic view of
leadership was needed, not by just a few leaders in high places but by large numbers of leaders in
The following brief review is divided into three sections: traditional schools of thought
regarding leadership; recent popular thinking on leadership, and new directions that leadership
experts and consultants are likely to take. The aim here is not to be comprehensive but selective,
with a focus on the most prominent and enduring ideas. Moreover, this selective review focuses
on models (rather than anecdotal or biographical accounts) that have or claim to have empirical
foundations. Nevertheless, a short review will inevitably do injustice to important ideas. Thus,
this paper should be considered an introduction, rather than the final word on leadership
principles.
Leadership concepts review, page 5 of 26
Trait refers to innate characteristics of persons. The earliest leadership research focused
on traits such as age, height and weight, physique, energy, health, appearance, fluency, and
vein continued, more social-psychological traits were studied, such as social activity, popularity,
mobility, and cooperation; the research even began to consider the interaction of traits and
situations. In a review of all of this literature, which spanned roughly the years 1904-1947, Bass,
(1990, p. 76) concluded that only a few traits could predict leadership success: capacity,
Table 1
Personal traits found to be associated with successful leadership*
Trait Description
Situation mental level, status, skills, needs and interests of followers, and
objectives to be achieved
*adapted from Bass, 1990, p.76.
Leadership concepts review, page 6 of 26
In assessing the studies of leadership traits through 1989, and focusing on 52 studies
deemed scientifically reliable, Bass (1990, p. 85) further concluded that the trait characteristics of
leaders included:
Discussion of traits. Clearly, many strictly genetic traits--like age, gender, height, or
weight--do not predict successful leadership. In addition, many of the traits found to correlate
with leaders’ success appear to be habits, preferences, or even learned behaviors. For example, a
somewhat softened view of traits is the set of 16 personality preferences measured by the Myers
Briggs Type Indicator (Myers & Brigs) Other instruments have been developed to test
individuals’ unexamined preferences and habits in conflict management, facing change, and
interpersonal relations. Yet trait theories also survive today in the popular anecdotal accounts of
Leadership: Executive Lessons in Character, Courage, and Vision (1999), Phillip’s Lincoln on
Leadership concepts review, page 7 of 26
Leadership: Executive Strategies for tough times (1993), Axelrod’s Patton on Leadership:
Strategic Lessons for Corporate Warfare (1999), or Robert’s Leadership Lessons of Attila the
Behavior, although it may be influenced by genetic traits, also is the result of learning or
training. There is not complete agreement on where inherited traits leave off and behaviors begin,
but it is agreed that behaviors are directly observable while traits must be inferred from behaviors
or reports (Davis & Luthans, 1979). In general, behavioral models of leadership historically
followed investigations of traits. By the 1980's a considerable number of investigations lead Yukl
(1981) to identify fifteen observable behaviors correlated with successful leadership (see Table
2). Yukl’s conclusions have been reiterated by other writers, as well (e.g., Block, 1986). In
addition, it appears that the behaviors observed as conducive to successful leadership can be
summarized as the skillful use of information (about goals, rewards, or tasks) critical to a group’s
goal achievement in an energetic and compelling way. Further research into behaviors
associated with successful leadership seems to lead back toward traits. Research indicates that in
addition to the behaviors noted above, task competence, that is, applied intelligence, is associated
with successful leadership. McCall and Lombard, in their study of failed leaders, observed that
social behaviors alone are insufficient at higher levels of organizational leadership: “the charming-
but-not-brilliant [leaders] find that the job gets too big and the problems too complex to get by on
Table 2
Behaviors identified with successful leadership efforts*
would like to learn how to lead; we can observe others’ efforts and modify our own approaches.
A behavioral approach does not simplify leadership however, for as Table 2 above shows, the 15
behaviors associated with successful leadership are varied and complex. And researchers still
have not successfully teased out the role of traits, or for that matter, situational influences.
manifestation of the trait of intelligence--is essential to leadership has lead to the single most
enduring distinction in the leadership literature: the need for the leader to be proficient in
personal and social needs. Two prominent models emphasize these variables. Hersey and
Leadership concepts review, page 9 of 26
Blanchard (1969a, 1969b, 1974, and 1982a) combined leaders behaviors--either emphasizing the
task or interpersonal relations--with the maturity of group members in a powerful model that.
predicts success in differing situations (see Table 3). The Hersey-Blanchard model combines the
behavioral identification of task and social competence with the observation that all groups have a
life cycle of experience and motivation. As group members grow in maturity, that is, expertise
and motivation, the behaviors necessary for the leader to be effective also shift and change. Early
in a group’s work, the leader must emphasize the task; eventually as the group matures, the
leader may shift emphasis to social support, and eventually is needed less as a task or social
support agent.
In a related scheme, Blake and Mouton developed the Managerial Grid, which maps out
the possibilities of managers’ or leaders’ concern for people or concern for production in a nine
by nine grid. High people concern combined with a low production concern they label “the
country club manager,” whose central problem is thoughtful attention to people. High concern
for production combined with low concern for people results in the “authority-obedience” style.
In contrast, low concern for both people and production yields impoverished management or
leadership, while high concern for production and people they term “team management” (Blake
Table 3
The Hersey-Blanchard Situational Leadership Model
Many other situational effects upon leadership have been identified by researchers,
including market forces (Burns and Stalker, 1961); environmental stability or turbulence
(Lawrence & Lorsch, 1967); and political or legal influences (Pfeffer, 1972). Situational concerns
also take into account the size, age, and industrial sector or policy arena of the leader’s
organization. While leadership in various types of organizations has been studied, few conclusive
studies show how the leader of a public organization should behave differently from the leader of
the private organization. The latest version of concern about situational effects concerns
organizational cultures. Schein (1985) observed that leaders’ efforts to change organizations must
take into account culturally specific beliefs regarding time and space, the nature of work, the
nature of human relations, and the nature of knowledge. It is likely that the cultural aspect of
leadership situations will become more important in global, cross-national, and multicultural
organizations.
Leadership concepts review, page 11 of 26
In the last ten years, leadership has become an ever more popular topic. Hundreds of
schools and universities offer programs and courses on leadership, in addition to the programs
offered by major university business schools. Also, a number of non-university based programs
have developed, one of which ranks among the top programs in management (see Table 4).
Characteristic of many programs is the role of consultants and faculty who have published works
growing out of their academic research and private consulting (just two examples: Astin and
Leland, 1991, from the Center for Creative Leadership; and Kotter, 1988, 1996, of Harvard
Table 4
Top 10 Programs for Nondegree Study in Management and Leadership
9 INSEAD Paris
In addition, the sale of books on the topic of leadership is brisk. New models of
leadership consist of many of the elements established by social science evidence earlier in the
century. Table 5 shows the 26 most popular titles in the United States on the subject of
leadership. The titles included are only those works with some formula or model for leadership,
and are drawn from the records of the largest book wholesaler in the U.S. The titles reflect a bias
based on anecdotal evidence from personal experience or consultancy contexts rather than
By contrast, based on interviews with several hundred managers and leaders, Kouzes and
• Challenging the Process (verbally questioning the way things are done)
• Inspiring a Shared Vision ( motivating subordinates with inspiration language)
• Enabling Others to Act (empowering with authority and staying out of the
way)
Leadership concepts review, page 13 of 26
• Modeling the Way (acting the way one wants other to behave)
• Encouraging the Heart (recognizing what is valuable to subordinates and
offering validation
(challenging, inspiring, enabling, and encouraging), while a fifth (modeling) may play role in task
accomplishments.
• Team learning - the use of open dialogue to explore variations and commonalities in a
group’s thinking
• Mental models - the identification of taken for granted ways of perceiving and
solving problems
• Shared vision - the development of a common view of the future
• Personal mastery - increased self-awareness
• Systems thinking - recognizing the patterns and interconnections in and around
organizations
Senge is concerned with the leader's role in developing an organization’s capacity to learn,
that is, to adapt successfully to its internal as well as its external environment. He highlights the
worlds in terms of complex systems rather than isolating individual components. The
examination of mental models and the development of shared vision. “Personal mastery is the
discipline of continually clarifying and deepening our personal vision, of focusing our energies, of
developing patience, and seeing reality objectively” (p. 7). Limiting mindsets can be illuminated
and discarded by personal analysis and mastery of mental models. Personal vision is translated
into shared vision by communicating a common identity and a sense of destiny to organizational
members. This is achieved through team learning rather than prescription from the top down.
leader might be compared to a detached but caring and supportive parent. According to DePree,
“…the art of leadership: liberating people to do what is required of them in the most effective
and humane way possible” (p. 1). The leader creates an atmosphere where the people in the
organization can succeed. In this way, the leader takes a back seat to the people in organizational
Leadership concepts review, page 15 of 26
success. The leader is a facilitator not a producer of organizational success. The role of facilitator
• Leaders should make a measured contribution. They must leave behind a legacy
• Leaders should generate momentum through a clearly articulated and shared vision
• Leaders should enable others and encourage leadership in others.
• Leaders should encourage participatory action where all members of an
organization become committed to the organization’s success
• Leaders must take a role in developing, expressing, and defending values
skills can be learned. Although charisma and the ability to transform organizations through
inspired leadership remain important, the idea that all leaders are born is spurious. Over the
through training --leaders develop and are developed. An important source of this
perspective is the Center for Creative Leadership (CCL). This organization is the top
nonprofit organization in its field; in addition to consultancy and training, their work
consists of conducting empirical research in the area of leadership. Their book The
Lessons of Experience: How successful executives develop on the job (McCall, Lombardo,
& Morrison, 1988) is based on interview data gathered from 191 successful executives. It
delineates five "lessons" for leaders that involve the need for self-awareness in terms of
• Handling relationships
• Basic values
Leadership concepts review, page 16 of 26
• Executive temperament
• Personal Awareness
Discussion of currently popular models. As reviewed above, much of the currently popular
leadership wisdom recapitulates earlier formulas of traits, behaviors, and situational forces.
However, some important new themes and concepts are developed that underscore the
interconnectedness. Many of these aspects are encapsulated in the still popular classics
Leaders: Strategies for Taking Charge (Bennis & Nanus, 1985) and On Becoming a Leader
currency of ideas rises and falls. But based on the work that is currently popular, and the
Group Communication: Dialogue. Emerging partly out of Senge’s concern for team and
Leadership concepts review, page 17 of 26
organizational learning, and partly out of the search for new ways to deal with conflict (at an
interpersonal, organization as well as at a global scale) three new works have recently been
published that emphasize dialogue as an essential group process that requires leaders’
support and commitment. Yankelovich (1999), a leading market researcher, argues that
dialogue is at the heart of how Americans decide how their values drive voting and
purchasing decisions. Yankelovich’s book his quickly risen among Amazon.com’s millions
of titles to under the 3,500 rank. Isaacs, an Oxford-trained MIT-based researcher and
arguments about the importance of dialogue. And Ellinor and Gerard place dialogue
squarely in the context of modern American organizations faced with complexity and
conflict.
Values and spirituality. Both popular and more established authors are emphasizing the
role of values in leadership (Jones, 1998a, 1998b; O'Toole, 1996; Blanchard & O'Connor, 1997).
While some of the literature in this vein emphasizes Christian principles (Jones 1998b), it
seems clear that the role of values in leadership is receiving new emphasis. The widespread
popularity of Covey’s work (1989, 1992) emphasizes value clarification. Yet, the concept
remains illusive and little in the way of valid indicators of values and the role they play in
Cultural issues. Globalization is easily the strongest situational factor facing leaders
ethnic identity and inter-ethnic understanding, just to name a few major issues. While
considerable work has been accomplished in understanding the relations among western
European societies (Hofstede, 1980) and Western versus Eastern societies (particularly
Japan), less is understood about the key needs of leaders in multi-cultural, cross-national
situations, becoming so commonplace today. Just one factor likely to gain in recognition in
Leadership concepts review, page 18 of 26
the near future is the leader’s cultural communication competence (Hajek and Giles, 2000).
Hajek and Giles draw on the work of Harvard psychologist Ellen Langer (1989) to develop a
categories, and viewing situations in new ways. Alternatively, mindlessness occurs when
These inter-related concepts (dialogue, values, and cultural issues) emerge as key to
leadership development. Not only are there signs in the popular leadership literature, but
example, Giles is one of the world’s leading experts on intergroup communication research,
scholar and best-selling author on innovative learning). Leaders' core values and the
promotion of dialogue will impact intercultural competence. As the work place becomes
more diverse, and the world becomes smaller, leaders must be prepared to confront cultural
Table 5
26 Best Selling Formulaic Leadership Books as of January 2000*
After 1998
1. Maxwell, J. The 21 irrefutable laws of leadership: Follow them and people will follow you. 1998
4. Ledeen, M. Machiavelli on modern leadership: Why Machiavelli's iron rules are as timely and 1999
important today as five centuries ago.
5. Wheatley, M Leadership and the new science: Discovering order in a chaotic world 1999
Before 1998
1. Kouzes, J., & Posner, B. The leadership challenge: How to keep getting extraordinary things done in 1996
organizations.
4. Senge, P. The fifth discipline: The art and practice of the learning organization. 1994
5. Jones, L. Jesus, CEO: Using ancient wisdom for visionary leadership. 1996
6. Blanchard, K. Leadership and the one-minute manager: Increasing effectiveness through situational 1985
leadership.
8. Tichy, N. The leadership engine: How winning companies build leaders at every level. 1997
10. Toogood, G. The articulate executive: Learn to look, act and sound like a leader. 1997
16. Greenleaf, R.K. Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. 1997
19. Scholtes, P.R. The leader's handbook: Making things happen, getting things done. 1998
21. Bolman, L. G. Leading with the soul: An uncommon journey of spirit 1995
* Source: The Ingram Company
Leadership concepts review, page 20 of 26
Bibliography
Adair J. (1993), Effective Leadership, how to develop leadership skills, London, How to
books.
Thornely N. and Lees D. (1993), Leadership, the Art of Motivation, London, Random
Ackerman, L. S., & Whitney, D. K. (1984). The fusion team: A model of organic and
Apps, J. W. (1994). Leadership for the emerging age. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Autry, J. (1992). Love & profits: The art of caring leadership. New York: William
Morrow.
Badaracco, J. L., Jr., & Ellsworth, R. R. (1989). Leadership and the quest for integrity.
Barker, J. A. (1992). Future edge: Discovering the new paradigms of success. New York:
William Morrow.
Barker, J. A. (1992). Paradigms: The business of discovering the future. New York:
Harper Collins.
Barr, L., & Varr, N. (1989). The leadership equation. Austin, TX: Eakin.
Leadership concepts review, page 21 of 26
Barrentine, P. (Ed.). (1993). When the canary stops singing: women’s perspectives on
Bass, B. M., (1990). Bass and Stogdill's Handbook of Leadership: Theory, Research, and
Bass, B. M. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York: The
Free Press.
Association.
Belgard, W. P., Fisher, K. K., & Rayner, S .R. (1988). Vision, opportunity and tenacity:
Three informal processes that influence formal transformation. In R. H. Kilmann & T. J. Covin,
et al., (Eds.). Corporate transformation: Revitalizing organizations for a competitive world. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Bennis, W. G. (1988, Fall). Inventing our leaders. New Jersey Bell Journal, 17-28.
Bennis, W. G. (1989). Why leaders can't lead: The unconscious conspiracy continues. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Bennis, W. G., Parikh, J., & Lessem, R. (1994). Beyond leadership: Balancing economics,
Bennis, W. G., & Nanus, B. (1985). Leaders: Strategies for taking charge. New York:
Harper Collins.
Berret-Koehler.
Bolman, L. G., & Deal, T. E. (1995). Leading with soul. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Boyer, E. L. (1989). Leadership: A clear and vital mission. The College Board Review.
150, 6-9.
Boyett, J. H., & Conn, H .P. (1991). Workplace 2000. New York: Plume/Penguin.
Brady, F. N. (1990). Ethical managing: Rules and results. New York: MacMillan.
Cantor, D. W. & Bernay, T. (1992). Women in power: The secrets of leadership. New
Development.
Cetron, M. J. (1994). An American renaissance in the year 2000. Bethesda, MD: World
SRA/Pergamon.
Clancy, J. J. (1989). The invisible powers: The language of business. Lexington, MA:
Lexington Books.
Clawson, J. G. (1998). Level Three Leadership: Getting Below the Surface. Englewood
Clemens, J. K., & Albrecht, S. (1995). The timeless leader. Holbrook, MA: Adams.
Clemens, J. K., & Mayer D. F. (1987). The classic touch: Lessons in leadership from
Conger, J. A. (1992). Learning to lead: The art of transforming managers into leaders. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Covey, S. R. (1989). The seven habits of highly effective people. New York: Simon &
Schuster.
McGraw-Hill.
Cambridge: MIT.
DuBrin, A. (1992). Human relations: A job oriented approach. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice Hall.
Edelman, J., & Crain, M. B. (1993). The Tao of negotiation. New York: Harper Collins.
Fairhols, G. W. (1994). Leadership and the culture of trust. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Fiedler, F. E., & Garcia, J. E. (1988). New approaches to effective leadership: Cognitive
Cincinnati: Western.
Glasser, W. (1986). Control theory in the classroom. New York: Harper Row
Gretz, K. F., & Drozdeck, S. R. (1994). Empowering innovative people. Chicago: Probus.
Hajek, C, & Giles, H. (in press). Intercultural communication competence: A critique and
theoretical alternative. In B. Burleson & J. Greene (Eds), Handbook of communicative and social
Harrison, R. (1984). Leadership and strategy for a new age. Transforming work: A
Hesselbein, F., Goldsmith, M., & Beckhard, R. (Eds.). (1996). The leader of the future.
Hickman, C. R. (1990). Mind of a manager. Soul of a leader. New York: John Wiley &
Sons.
Hitt, W. D. (1993). The model leader: A fully functioning person. Columbus, OH:
Battelle.
Hoyle, J. R. (1995). Leadership and futuring: Making visions happen. Thousand Oaks,
CA: Corwin.
Isaacs, W. (1999). Dialogue and the Art of Thinking Together : A Pioneering Approach
Jones, L. B. (1998a). The Path : Creating Your Mission Statement for Work and for Life.
Hyperion.
Jones, L. B. (1998b). Jesus CEO : Using Ancient Wisdom for Visionary Leadership.
Hyperion.
Prentice- Hall.
Leadership concepts review, page 26 of 26
Jossey-Bass.
Kouzes, J. M., & Posner, B. A. (1990). The leadership challenge: How to get
Kroeger, O., & Thuesen, J. (1992). Type talk at work: How the 16 personality types
Lencioni, P. (1998). The five temptations of a CEO. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
Lucas, A. F. (1989). Motivating faculty to improve the quality of teaching. In A.F. Lucas
Maxwell, J. C. (1993). Developing the leader within you. Nashville: Thomas Nelson.
Maynard, H. B., Jr., & Mehrtens, S. E. (1993). The fourth wave: Business in the 21st
How successful executives develop on the job. Lexington, MS: Lexington Books.
McFarland, J. L,. Senn, L. E., & Childress, J. R. (1993). 21st century leadership. New
Leadership concepts review, page 27 of 26
York: Leadership.
Morrison, A. H., White, R. P., & Van Velsor, E. (1987). Breaking the glass ceiling: Can
women reach the top of America's largest corporations/ Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Nanus, B. (1992). Visionary leadership: Creating a compelling sense of direction for your
O’Toole, J. (1995). Leading change: The argument for values-based leadership. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Roberts, W. (1993). Victory secrets of Attila the Hun. New York: Doubleday.
Roberts, W., & Ross, B. (1995). Make it so: Leadership lessons from Star Trek, the next
Review, 119-125.
Rost, J. (1991). Leadership for the twenty-first century. New York: Praeger.
Rosen, R. H. (1996). Leading people: Transforming business from the inside out. New
York: Viking.
Senge, P. M., Kleiner, A., Roberts, C., Ross, R. B., & Smith, B. J. (1994). The fifth
Leadership concepts review, page 28 of 26
Tichy, N. M., & Devanna, M. A. (1986). The transformational leader. New York: Wiley
& Sons.
Toffler, A. (1990). PowerShift: Knowledge, wealth and violence at the end of the 21st
Vaill, P. B. (1989). Managing as a performing art: New ideas for a world in chaotic change.
Walters, J. (1987). The art of supportive leadership: A practical handbook for people in
87(11):5.
Wheatley, M. J. (1992). Leadership and the new science: Learning about organization
Yukl, G. (1994). Leadership in organizations. (3rd. ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice
Leadership concepts review, page 29 of 26
Hall.