&UtWLFD

GH-XQKRGH⋅)LORVRILDGDUHOLJLmR

$HSLVWHPRORJLDUHIRUPLVWDGH
3ODQWLQJD
'RPLQJRV)DULD
(VFROD6HFXQGiULD$OEHUWR6DPSDLR%UDJD

$HSLVWHPRORJLDGDFUHQoDUHOLJLRVDpXPDiUHDGDILORVRILDGD
UHOLJLmRTXHSURFXUDUHVSRQGHUDRVHJXLQWHSUREOHPDKDYHUiMXVWLILFDomRSDUDVHWHUIp
VHPSURYDVDUJXPHQWRVRXLQGtFLRV"2XIRUPXODQGRGHRXWUDIRUPDVHUi
HSLVWHPLFDPHQWHOHJtWLPRDFUHGLWDUHP'HXVVHPSURYDVDUJXPHQWRVRXLQGtFLRV"
$OpPGDVUHVSRVWDVWUDGLFLRQDLVGH:LOOLDP&OLIIRUGHGH:LOOLDP-DPHVDHVVH
SUREOHPDKiXPDUHVSRVWDPDLVFRQWHPSRUkQHDHILORVRILFDPHQWHSURPHWHGRUDD
HSLVWHPRORJLDUHIRUPLVWDGH$OYLQ3ODQWLQJDQ&KDPDVH³UHIRUPLVWD´jVXD
HSLVWHPRORJLDSRUTXHHVWHILOyVRIRVHLGHQWLILFDFRPRSHQVDPHQWRUHIRUPLVWDWUDGLomR
SURWHVWDQWHTXHUHPRQWDD-RmR&DOYLQR

&OLIIRUGGHIHQGHTXHQmRpOHJtWLPRDFUHGLWDUTXH'HXVH[LVWHXPDYH]TXHVyp
OHJtWLPRDFUHGLWDUQDTXLORSDUDRTXDOWHPRVLQGtFLRVVXILFLHQWHVHQmRWHPRVLQGtFLRV
VXILFLHQWHVGDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXV'HVWHPRGR&OLIIRUGDUJXPHQWDTXHQmRKi
TXDOTXHUFDVRHPTXHDFUHGLWDUHPDOJRVHPLQGtFLRVFRQFOXVLYRVVHMDSHUIHLWDPHQWH
UDFLRQDO3ODQWLQJDQHJDHVWDSURSRVLomRPDVSDUDLVVRQmRVHFRPSURPHWHFRPD
LGHLDGHTXHpVHPSUHUDFLRQDODFUHGLWDUHPDOJRVHPLQGtFLRVFRQFOXVLYRV$SHQDV
DUJXPHQWDTXHhá certos casos em que acreditar em algo sem indícios conclusivos é
perfeitamente racional,QRPHDGDPHQWHTXHH[LVWHPDOJXQVFRQWH[WRVTXHMXVWLILFDP
UDFLRQDOPHQWHXPDFUHQoDPHVPRVHPSURYDVRXLQGtFLRV3RULVVRGHIHQGHTXHSRGH
VHUOHJtWLPRDFUHGLWDUQDH[LVWrQFLD'HXVVHPSURYDVDUJXPHQWRVRXLQGtFLRV

3RUpPSDUDGHIHQGHUDVXDWHRULD3ODQWLQJDQmRXWLOL]DXPDDUJXPHQWDomRVLPLODUjGH
-DPHV(VWH~OWLPRVDOLHQWDTXHpOHJtWLPRDFUHGLWDUQDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXVVHPSURYDV
SDUDHYLWDUDSHUGDGHXPDSRVVtYHOYHUGDGHHGHXPEHPYLWDO²DYLGDHWHUQDH
RXWUDVJUDoDVGLYLQDV3ODQWLQJDDRLQYpVGHIHQGHTXHpSHUIHLWDPHQWHMXVWLILFDGRFUHU
HP'HXVVHPTXHRIDoDPRVFRPEDVHHPTXDLVTXHULQGtFLRVRXDUJXPHQWRVH
LQGHSHQGHQWHPHQWHGDSRVVLELOLGDGHGHJDQKDUDYHUGDGHRXEHQVYLWDLVGHIHQGHTXH
a crença em Deus é apropriadamente básica

8PDFUHQoDpEiVLFDTXDQGRDDFHLWDPRVPDVQmRFRPEDVHQRXWUDVFUHQoDVRX
LQGtFLRV(HVWDVFUHQoDVTXHQmRVmRMXVWLILFDGDVFRPEDVHQRXWUDVWDQWRSRGHPVHU
LQDSURSULDGDVFRPRDSURSULDGDV8PDFUHQoDEiVLFDpLQDSURSULDGDTXDQGRQmRVH
MXVWLILFDDVLPHVPDVHQGRDVVLPLUUDFLRQDO3RUH[HPSORDDOXQD9HUDDSHVDUGH
DSUHQGHUYiULDVWHRULDVpWLFDVDFUHGLWDVHPTXDLVTXHUUD]}HVRXLQGtFLRVTXHQR
SUy[LPRWHVWHGHILORVRILDPRUDOVyVDLUi.DQWHSRULVVRVyHVWXGDDpWLFDGH.DQW
3DUDHODHVWDpXPDFUHQoDEiVLFDSRLVQmRIRLIRUPDGDDSDUWLUGHRXWURVLQGtFLRVRX
UD]}HVDOLiVRSURIHVVRUQHPHVFODUHFHXTXHFRQWH~GRVLULDPVDLUQRWHVWH1R
HQWDQWRDFUHQoDEiVLFDGHVWDDOXQDQmRpDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDSRLVpXPDFUHQoD
DUELWUiULDHDFLUFXQVWkQFLDDSDUWLUGDTXDODIRUPRXQmRDWRUQDMXVWLILFDGD

8PDFUHQoDEiVLFDpDSURSULDGDTXDQGRVHMXVWLILFDSRUVLPHVPDVHQGRSRULVVR
UDFLRQDO3RUH[HPSORWHPRVDFUHQoDGHTXH HVWDFUHQoDQmRpEiVLFD
SRLVSUHFLVDVHVXVWHQWDUQRXWUDVFUHQoDVDGHTXDGDPHQWHEiVLFDVTXHDFHLWDPRVVHP
UHFRUUHPRVDRXWUDVSURSRVLo}HVFRPR ,PDJLQHPRVRXWUDVLWXDomRDDOXQD
9HUDROKDSHODMDQHODGDVDODGHDXODHYrXPDiUYRUHIRUPDQGRDVVLPDFUHQoDGH
TXHYrXPDiUYRUH1HVWHFDVRHVWDPRVSHUDQWHXPDFUHQoDDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD
XPDYH]TXHQmRDGRSWDPRVHVWDFUHQoDFRPEDVHHPRXWUDVFUHQoDV3RGHUtDPRV
SHUJXQWDUTXHLQGtFLRVSRGHULDPVXVWHQWDUDFUHQoDGHYHUXPDiUYRUHPDVD9HUDQmR
WHPTXDOTXHULQGtFLRDIDYRUGDVXDFUHQoDSRLVVLPSOHVPHQWHHVWiDYHUXPDiUYRUHH
LVVRMXVWLILFDDVXDFUHQoD'RPHVPRPRGRPHVPRTXHQmRKDMDTXDOTXHULQGtFLRD
IDYRUGDFUHQoDHP'HXVHVWDSRGHPHVPRDVVLPVHUDGHTXDGDPHQWHEiVLFD

3DUDGHIHQGHUDVXDWHRULDGDFUHQoDHP'HXVFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD
3ODQWLQJDFRPHoDSRUDUJXPHQWDUTXHo indiciarismo e o fundacionalismo clássico são
incoerentes2LQGLFLDULVPRFULWLFDDFUHQoDHP'HXVDILUPDQGRTXHHVWDFUHQoDVyp
MXVWLILFDGDVHH[LVWLUHPLQGtFLRVVXILFLHQWHVDVHXIDYRUFRPRSURS{V&OLIIRUGRUD
FRPRQmRH[LVWHPLQGtFLRVVXILFLHQWHVDIDYRUGDFUHQoDGH'HXVHQWmRHVWDFUHQoD
QmRpMXVWLILFDGD0DVHVWDREMHFomRLQGLFLDULVWDjFUHQoDHP'HXVEDVHLDVHQR
IXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFR2IXQGDFLRQDOLVPRpXPDWHRULDHSLVWHPROyJLFDTXHGHIHQGH
TXHDVQRVVDVFUHQoDVVHMXVWLILFDPLQIHULQGRDVDGHTXDGDPHQWHGHRXWUDVFUHQoDV
MXVWLILFDGDVHDVVLPSRUGLDQWH3RUpPLVWRVHULDXPSURFHVVRVHPILPGHMXVWLILFDomR
3RULVVRDWHRULDIXQGDFLRQDOLVWDGHIHQGHTXHKiFUHQoDVDXWRMXVWLILFDGDVRXVHMD
FUHQoDVDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDVFXMDDGRSomRpRIXQGDPHQWRGHWRGDVDVRXWUDV
FUHQoDVTXHQmRVmREiVLFDV

4XHFULWpULRVH[LJHRIXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRSDUDDFHLWDUXPDFUHQoDFRPR
DSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD"2IXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRSURS}HTXHXPDFUHQoDp
DSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDVHIRUDXWRHYLGHQWHLQFRUULJtYHORXHYLGHQWHVHQVRULDOPHQWH
$RVDWLVID]HUHVWHVFULWpULRVSRGHPRVGL]HUTXHHVWDPRVSHUDQWHXPDFUHQoDEiVLFD
GHYLGDPHQWHMXVWLILFDGDHFRUUHFWD

0DVKiXPSUREOHPDVHUiTXHHVWHFULWpULRGHEDVLFLGDGHH[SULPHHOHPHVPRXPD
FUHQoDDXWRHYLGHQWHLQFRUULJtYHORXHYLGHQWHVHQVRULDOPHQWH"&RQVWDWDPRVTXHHP
VLRFULWpULRGHEDVLFLGDGHGRIXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRQmRpQHPDXWRHYLGHQWHQHP
LQFRUULJtYHOQHPHYLGHQWHVHQVRULDOPHQWHDVVLPDRDFHLWDURFULWpULRGHEDVLFLGDGH
FRPRFUHQoDEiVLFDRIXQGDFLRQDOLVWDFOiVVLFRHVWiDYLRODURSUySULRFULWpULRGH
EDVLFLGDGHTXHHOHPHVPRHVWDEHOHFHX'HVWHPRGRRIXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRp
LQFRHUHQWHSRLVQmRFXPSUHDVVXDVSUySULDVH[LJrQFLDV2UDVHRIXQGDFLRQDOLVPR
FOiVVLFRpLQFRHUHQWHDREMHFomRLQGLFLDULVWDjFUHQoDHP'HXVTXHVHEDVHLDQR
IXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRQmRpSURFHGHQWH

eSUHFLVRQRWDUTXHDFUtWLFDGH3ODQWLQJDLQFLGHHVVHQFLDOPHQWHQRFULWpULRGH
EDVLFLGDGHDSURSULDGDGRIXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRPDVQmRQDHVWUXWXUD
HSLVWHPROyJLFDIXQGDFLRQDOLVWDSRLVFRQWLQXDDGHIHQGHUTXHKiDOJXPDVFUHQoDVTXH
VmRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDVHTXHVXVWHQWDPDVFUHQoDVUHVWDQWHVTXHQmRVmR
EiVLFDV(DSHVDUGH3ODQWLQJDUHMHLWDURFULWpULRGHEDVLFLGDGHDSURSULDGDGR
IXQGDFLRQDOLVWDFOiVVLFRnão defende que qualquer crença possa ser apropriadamente
básica.$VVLPQDDXVrQFLDGHXPFULWpULRWRWDOPHQWHGHOLPLWDGRGHEDVLFLGDGH
3ODQWLQJDVXJHUHTXHDPHOKRUIRUPDGHFKHJDUDWDLVFULWpULRVpSRUYLDindutiva2X
VHMDpQHFHVViULRUHXQLUYiULRVH[HPSORVGHFUHQoDVTXHREYLDPHQWHVmR
DGHTXDGDPHQWHEiVLFDVHDSDUWLUGHODVHVWDEHOHFHUSRUJHQHUDOL]DomRTXDLVVmRDV
RXWUDVFUHQoDVEiVLFDVHpWDPEpPSUHFLVRIRUPXODUKLSyWHVHVGHEDVLFLGDGH
DSURSULDGDHWHVWDUHVWDVKLSyWHVHVSRUUHIHUrQFLDVDYiULRVH[HPSORVFDQGLGDWRVDR
HVWDWXWRGHEDVLFLGDGHDSURSULDGD3ODQWLQJDWDPEpPGHIHQGHTXHQRVYiULRVH[HPSORV
H[LVWHPcircunstâncias e condições que conferem ou não EDVLFLGDGHDSURSULDGDD
GHWHUPLQDGDFUHQoD$VVLPPHVPRUHMHLWDQGRRVFULWpULRVGHEDVLFLGDGHGR
IXQGDFLRQDOLVPRFOiVVLFRSRGHPRVDLQGDDFHLWDUFHUWDVFUHQoDVFRPR
DSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDV3RUH[HPSORDDOXQD9HUDDRGHLWDUVHQDFDPDUHFRUGD
TXHROKRXSDUDXPDiUYRUHDWUDYpVGDMDQHODGDVDODGHDXODVHHODQmRFRVWXPDWHU
ODSVRVPQpVLFRVHQWmRSRGHDOHJDUFRPRFUHQoDDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDDFUHQoDGH
TXHYLXXPDiUYRUHGXUDQWHDDXODGHILORVRILD3RUpPVHDVXDPHPyULDIRVVHSRXFR
ILiYHOSUHJDQGROKHYiULDVSDUWLGDVDFUHQoDGHTXHHODYLXXPDiUYRUHGXUDQWHDDXOD
GHILORVRILDQmRSRGHULDFRQWDUFRPRXPDFUHQoDEiVLFD

(DFUHQoDHP'HXV"3RGHUiVHUXPDFUHQoDEiVLFD"3ODQWLQJDSHQVDTXHDFUHQoD
HP'HXVSRGHVHUDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDWDOFRPRWHUDH[SHULrQFLDGHYHUXPD
iUYRUHVHQGRSRUWDQWROHJtWLPRHUDFLRQDODFUHGLWDUHP'HXVVHPSURYDVDUJXPHQWRV
RXLQGtFLRV0DVLVWRQmRVLJQLILFDGHIRUPDDOJXPDTXHpXPDFUHQoDLQIXQGDGD
JUDWXLWDRXDUELWUiULD+iSHORPHQRVWUrVUD]}HVTXHSRGHPMXVWLILFDUDWHVHGHTXHD
FUHQoDHP'HXVpDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD

&HUWDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDVHFRQGLo}HVWRUQDPDFUHQoDHP'HXVDSURSULDGDPHQWH
EiVLFD2XVHMDH[LVWHPPXLWDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDVHFRQGLo}HVTXHWRUQDPUDFLRQDOH
MXVWLILFDGDDFUHQoDHP'HXV3ODQWLQJDLQGLFDDOJXPDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDVQDVTXDLVD
FUHQoDHP'HXVQmRpLQIXQGDGDSDUDXPWHtVWD

³$ROHUD%tEOLDSRGHVHILFDULPSUHVVLRQDGRFRPRSURIXQGRVHQWLGRGHTXH'HXVQRV
IDOD'HSRLVGHID]HURTXHFRQVLGHURUHOHVRXLPRUDORXPDOpYRORSRVVRVHQWLUPH
FXOSDGRDRVROKRVGH'HXVHIRUPDUDFUHQoDDeus desaprova o que fiz$RFRQIHVVDU
PHHDUUHSHQGHUPHSRVVRVHQWLUPHSHUGRDGRIRUPDQGRDFUHQoDDeus perdoa­me o
que fiz8PDSHVVRDHPJUDYHSHULJRSRGHYROWDUVHSDUD'HXVSHGLQGROKHSURWHFomR
HDMXGDHFODURTXHHOHRXHODIRUPDUiHQWmRDFUHQoDGHTXH'HXVpGHIDFWRFDSD]
GHRXYLUHDMXGDUVHRFRQVLGHUDUDSURSULDGR4XDQGRDYLGDpGRFHHJUDWLILFDQWHXP
VHQWLGRHVSRQWkQHRGHJUDWLGmRSRGHDVFHQGHUQDDOPDDOJXpPQHVWDFRQGLomRSRGH
DJUDGHFHUHORXYDUR6HQKRUSHODERQGDGHHIRUPDUiHYLGHQWHPHQWHDFUHQoD
FRQFRPLWDQWHGHTXHQDYHUGDGHKiTXHDJUDGHFHUDR6HQKRUHORXYiOR´3ODQWLQJD


9HPRVDTXLYiULDVVLWXDo}HVTXHRFRUUHPIUHTXHQWHPHQWHFRPRVWHtVWDVHTXHJHUDP
QDVFLUFXQVWkQFLDVDGHTXDGDVDFUHQoDHP'HXVGHXPDIRUPDMXVWLILFDGD(VWDV
H[SHULrQFLDVUHOLJLRVDVGmRRULJHPDSURSRVLo}HVHFUHQoDVDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDV
FRPR³'HXVIDODPH´RX³'HXVSHUGRDPH´(SDUWLQGRGHVWDVFUHQoDVEiVLFDV
SRGHPRVLQIHULUGLUHFWDPHQWHDFUHQoD³'HXVH[LVWH´

$FUHQoDHP'HXVpDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDQXPDFRPXQLGDGHQDWXUDOSRU
H[HPSORQDFRPXQLGDGHGRVFULVWmRV&RPRTXHYLPRVDWpDJRUDVHUiTXHTXDOTXHU
FUHQoDQmRSRGHUiVHUDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD",PDJLQHPRVDIRUPDomRGHXPD
FUHQoDQXPDHQWLGDGHVXSHULRUFKDPDGD*UDQGH$EyERUDSRURFDVLmRGR+DOORZHHQ
3RGHUHPRVGL]HUTXHHVWDFUHQoDpDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD"3ODQWLQJDGHIHQGHTXH
QmRpSRVVtYHOTXHWDOFUHQoDVHMDDGHTXDGDPHQWHEiVLFD3RLVSDUDVHSRGHUMXVWLILFDU
FRPRWDOpSUHFLVRGHWHUPLQDUVHH[LVWHPFLUFXQVWkQFLDVDGHTXDGDVSDUDVHIRUPDU
HVVDFUHQoDEiVLFDSULQFLSDOPHQWHDYHULJXDUVHH[LVWHXPDH[SHULrQFLDIUHTXHQWH
GHVVD*UDQGH$EyERUDRXVHH[LVWHXPDFRPXQLGDGHQDWXUDOTXHFRQFHGDFUpGLWRDWDO
HQWLGDGH2UDpIiFLOFRQVWDWDUTXHQmRH[LVWHPH[SHULrQFLDVIUHTXHQWHVHFRQGLo}HV
QDVTXDLVIRVVHQDWXUDOIRUPDUXPDFUHQoDHVSRQWkQHDQD*UDQGH$EyERUDQHP
VHTXHUH[LVWHTXDOTXHUFRPXQLGDGHQDWXUDOGRVFUHQWHVQD*UDQGH$EyERUDTXHGHVVH
IXQGDPHQWRDWDOFUHQoDORJRDFUHQoDQD*UDQGH$EyERUDpLQIXQGDGDHQmR
MXVWLILFDGD

3HORFRQWUiULRWHtVWDVFRPRRVFULVWmRVSRUH[HPSORWrPDOHJLWLPLGDGHGHIRUPDU
XPDFUHQoDDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDHP'HXVSRLVWrPH[SHULrQFLDVIUHTXHQWHVGD
SUHVHQoDGH'HXVFRPRRVHQWLUVHDPDGRSRU'HXVSHUGRDGRHVFXWDGRHWFH
H[LVWHXPDFRPXQLGDGHQDWXUDOGRVFULVWmRVTXHDXWRUL]DPHGmRIXQGDPHQWRjFUHQoD
HP'HXVFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD9HMDPRVXPH[HPSORVXSRQKDPRVTXHD
DOXQD9HUDWHPTXLQ]HDQRVYLYHQXPDFRPXQLGDGHRQGHWRGRVDFUHGLWDPHP'HXVH
IRLHGXFDGDSDUDDFUHGLWDUQDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXV3RGHPRVGL]HUTXHD9HUDQmR
DFUHGLWDHP'HXVFRPEDVHHPSURYDVRXLQGtFLRVHDLQGDQHPVHTXHUHVWXGRXR
DUJXPHQWRRQWROyJLFRRXFRVPROyJLFROLPLWDQGRVHDDFUHGLWDUQDTXLORTXHOKH
HQVLQDP$TXLYHPRVTXHD9HUDWHPXPDFUHQoDHP'HXVDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD
SRLVQmRpLQIHULGDGHSURYDVRXDUJXPHQWRV(HVWDFUHQoDpMXVWLILFDGDSRLVQmRWHP
ERDVUD]}HVSDUDSHQVDUTXH'HXVQmRH[LVWHQHPTXHDVXDFRPXQLGDGHDHVWiD
HQJDQDU3RUWDQWRD9HUDHVWiMXVWLILFDGDDDFUHGLWDUHP'HXVVHPSURYDVLQGtFLRVRX
DUJXPHQWRV

$FUHQoDHP'HXVWRUQDVHDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDSRUPHLRGRQRVVRVHQWLGR
GRGLYLQR3ODQWLQJDGHIHQGHTXHH[LVWHQRVVHUHVKXPDQRVXPDIDFXOGDGHFRJQLWLYD
TXHIXQFLRQDQGRDGHTXDGDPHQWHFRQGX]jMXVWLILFDomRGDFUHQoDHP'HXVFRPR
DSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDFKDPDVHDHVVDIDFXOGDGHsensus divinatis(VWHVHQWLGRGR
GLYLQRIXQFLRQDGHIRUPDDQiORJDjSHUFHSomROHYDQGRDVSHVVRDVDILFDUHPFLHQWHV
GH'HXVGHXPDIRUPDLPHGLDWD9ROWDQGRDRH[HPSORGD*UDQGH$EyERUDSRGHPRV
FRQVWDWDUTXHQRPXQGRQmRKiTXDOTXHUWHQGrQFLDQDWXUDOSDUDDFHLWDUFUHQoDVQD
*UDQGH$EyERUDPDVH[LVWHXPDWHQGrQFLDQRVKXPDQRVSDUDSHUFHSFLRQDUHPD
SUHVHQoDGH'HXVQRPXQGRGHYLGRDHVWHVHQWLGRGRGLYLQR

8PDREMHFomRDHVWHDUJXPHQWRpTXHPXLWRVDWHXVHDJQyVWLFRVSOHQDPHQWH
UDFLRQDLVDILUPDPTXHQmRWrPWDOFUHQoDEiVLFDHP'HXV2UDVHRVVHUHVKXPDQRV
IRUDPGRWDGRVSRU'HXVGHIDFXOGDGHVFRJQLWLYDVHGRVHQWLGRGRGLYLQRHQWmRSRUTXH
H[LVWHXPDSHUFHQWDJHPVLJQLILFDWLYDGHSHVVRDVTXHQmRFUrHP'HXV"3ODQWLQJD
UHVSRQGHDHVWDREMHFomRH[SOLFDQGRTXHRSHFDGRKXPDQRSRGHFRUURPSHUHVWD
IDFXOGDGHFRJQLWLYDGRVHQWLGRGRGLYLQRTXHDRGHL[DUGHIXQFLRQDUDGHTXDGDPHQWH
QmRSHUPLWHDIRUPDomRGDFUHQoDHP'HXV$VVLPWDOFRPRXPREMHFWRDILDGRSRGH
FDXVDUXPDOHVmRQXPROKRRSHFDGRWDPEpPSRGHOHVLRQDUDIDFXOGDGHFRJQLWLYDGR
VHQWLGRGRGLYLQRRULJLQDQGRSRUFRQVHJXLQWHDGHVFUHQoD0DVVHRQRVVRVHQWLGRGR
GLYLQRIXQFLRQDUDGHTXDGDPHQWHHQWmRIRUPDUVHiDFUHQoDDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD
HP'HXVGHXPDIRUPDMXVWLILFDGDHUDFLRQDO

eDOWXUDGHSHUJXQWDUVHUiHVWDWHRULDSODXVtYHO"3DUDDYDOLDUFULWLFDPHQWHD
SODXVLELOLGDGHGHVWDWHRULDpPHOKRUWRPDUSULPHLURQRWDGHDOJXPDVREMHFo}HV
9HMDPRVDVSULQFLSDLVFUtWLFDVTXHVHSRGHPOHYDQWDUFRQWUDDWHRULDGH3ODQWLQJD

$VYiULDVFRQGLo}HVHFLUFXQVWkQFLDVTXHHYRFDPDFUHQoDHP'HXVQmRVmR
HPVLVXILFLHQWHVSDUDMXVWLILFDUDFUHQoDHP'HXVFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD
3RUH[HPSORLPDJLQHPRVTXHD9HUDQmRYDLjPLVVDQXPGRPLQJRSRLV
VLPSOHVPHQWHQmROKHDSHWHFHX2UDFRPRD9HUDVHFRQVLGHUDXPDFDWyOLFDURPDQDH
FRPRGHVUHVSHLWRXRWHUFHLURPDQGDPHQWRGHVDQWLILFDURVGRPLQJRVHIHVWDVGH
JXDUGDFRPHoDDVHQWLUVHFXOSDGDHIRUPDDFUHQoD³'HXVGHVDSURYDRTXHIL]´0DV
VHUiHVWDXPDFUHQoDDGHTXDGDPHQWHEiVLFD"7DOYH]D9HUDVLQWDVHFXOSDGDSRU
IDOWDUjPLVVDSRUTXHQDFDWHTXHVHOKHHQVLQDUDPTXHLVVRpSHFDGR

1RHQWDQWRVHSHQVDUPRVEHPYHUHPRVTXHD9HUDFRQWLQXDULDDVHQWLUVHFXOSDGD
SRUIDOWDUjPLVVDPHVPRTXH'HXVQmRH[LVWDHPHVPRTXHRVPDQGDPHQWRVHVWHMDP
HUUDGRVSRLVVXDVFUHQoDVIRUDPIRUPDGDVDSDUWLUGHXPDHGXFDomRUHOLJLRVD
ULJRURVDDFUtWLFDHGRJPiWLFD/RJRWHUXPDGHWHUPLQDGDH[SHULrQFLDGHFXOSDQmR
VLJQLILFDUHDOPHQWHTXHVHHVWHMDMXVWLILFDGRHPWHUXPDFUHQoDEiVLFDHP'HXVSRLV
HVWDH[SHULrQFLDSRGHVHUDSHQDVRIUXWRGHXPDHGXFDomRUHOLJLRVD3RGHUtDPRV
DSOLFDUHVWHUDFLRFtQLRDXPOHTXHDODUJDGRGHDFo}HVTXHVmRQDWXUDLVHPRUDOPHQWH
QmRSUREOHPiWLFDVFRPRRFDVRGDPDVWXUEDomRRXGDKRPRVVH[XDOLGDGHPDVTXH
SRGHPVHUFRQVLGHUDGDVSHFDPLQRVDVHJHUDUVHQWLPHQWRVGHFXOSDGHYLGRDXPD
HGXFDomRUHOLJLRVDULJRURVD3RUpPSHORIDFWRGHXPDSHVVRDWHUXPDH[SHULrQFLD
GHVWHJpQHURRXRXWUDGHDJUDGHFLPHQWRORXYRUHWFQmRVLJQLILFDTXHVHMXVWLILTXHD
FUHQoDHP'HXV

$FRPXQLGDGHSRGHOHJLWLPDUFUHQoDVEL]DUUDVHPRQVWUXRVDV3ODQWLQJD
GHIHQGHXTXHDFRPXQLGDGHpGHFLVLYDQDDXWRUL]DomRGHFUHQoDVFRPR
DSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDV$VVLPFRPRQmRH[LVWHXPDFRPXQLGDGHGD$EyERUD
*LJDQWHHVWDFUHQoDQmRSRGHVHUEiVLFD1RHQWDQWRpIiFLOHQFRQWUDUFRPXQLGDGHV
TXHOHJLWLPDPFUHQoDVWmREL]DUUDVHPRQVWUXRVDVFRPRDGD$EyERUD*LJDQWH6HD
FRPXQLGDGHGRVFULVWmRVMXVWLILFDPDVVXDVFUHQoDVFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDV
SHORIDFWRGHSHUWHQFHUHPjVXDFRPXQLGDGHWDPEpPRXWURVJUXSRVHFRPXQLGDGHV
MXVWLILFDPDVVXDVFUHQoDVSHORGHIDFWRGHSHUWHQFHUHPjVVXDVFRPXQLGDGHV3RU
H[HPSORSDUDDFRPXQLGDGH$O4DHGDDILUPDo}HVFRPR³$OiH[LJHTXHGRPLQHPRVR
RFLGHQWHHIDoDPRVWHUURULVPR´³$OiGL]QRVSDUDPDWDURVGHVFUHQWHV´RX³DRID]HUPH
LUSHORVDUHVDPLPHDRVRXWURV$OiGiPHVHWHQWDHGXDVYLUJHQVQRSDUDtVR´SRGHP
VHUFUHQoDVDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDV$VVLPGDPHVPDIRUPDTXHDFRPXQLGDGH
FULVWmSRGHMXVWLILFDUDFUHQoD³'HXVH[LVWH´FRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDWDPEpP
SRGHMXVWLILFDUTXDOTXHURXWUDFUHQoDPRQVWUXRVDRXEL]DUUDTXHVXUMDHPDOJXPD
FRPXQLGDGHFRPRDVGR[DPDQLVPRGDEUX[DULDGRYXGXHQWUHRXWURV

&DGDFRPXQLGDGHMXVWLILFDFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDDFUHQoDQDVXD
HQWLGDGHVXSHULRUPDVDH[LVWrQFLDVLPXOWkQHDGHWDQWDVHQWLGDGHVSDUHFH
LQFRHUHQWH(VWDREMHFomRpDSHQDVXPFRUROiULRQDWXUDOGDREMHFomRDQWHULRU8PD
FRQVHTXrQFLDGDVWHVHVGH3ODQWLQJDpTXHTXDOTXHUSHVVRDQRVHLRGHXPD
FRPXQLGDGHSRGHULDDFHLWDUFRPRMXVWLILFDGDDFUHQoDQDHQWLGDGHVXSHULRUTXHDVXD
FRPXQLGDGHSDUWLOKDFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD$VVLPpMXVWLILFDGRRVFULVWmRV
WHUHPDFUHQoD³RGHXV7ULQLWiULRH[LVWHHHOHpXPVy´RVMXGHXVDVVXPLUHP³-DYp
H[LVWHHpR~QLFRGHXV´RVPXoXOPDQRVSURIHULUHP³QmRKiRXWURGHXVVHQmR$Oi´RV
FUHQWHVGRKLQGXtVPRSURFODPDUHP³%UDPDpRSULPHLURGHXV´RVEXGLVWDVDVVXPLUHP
³H[LVWHPVHUHVFHOHVWLDLVTXHVmR'HYDV´HWF0DVSDUHFHTXHVHHVWiDFDLUQXPD
LQFRHUrQFLDFRPRpSRVVtYHOTXHH[LVWDPHPVLPXOWkQHRWRGDVHVWDVGLYLQGDGHV
LQFRPSRVVtYHLV"6HR'HXVWULQLWiULR-DYp$Oi%UDPD'HYDVHQWUHPXLWRVRXWURV
QmRSRGHPH[LVWLUHPVLPXOWkQHRHQWmRSUHFLVDPRVGHDUJXPHQWDUHGDUERDVUD]}HV
SDUDVHMXVWLILFDUDFUHQoDQXPDGHWHUPLQDGDHQWLGDGHVXSHULRU'HVWHPRGRQmR
SDUHFHMXVWLILFDGRFUHUHP'HXVVHPDUJXPHQWRV

$VSHVVRDVTXHLQYHVWLJDPVHULDPHQWHDVTXHVW}HVUHOLJLRVDVSDUHFHPQmRWHU
MXVWLILFDomRUDFLRQDOSDUDWHUXPDFUHQoDDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDHP'HXVVHP
TXDOTXHUERPDUJXPHQWR1RFDVRGD9HUDSRGHPRVDFKDUOHJtWLPRDVVXPLUDFUHQoD
HP'HXVFRPRDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDSRLVD9HUDQmRDFUHGLWDHP'HXVFRPEDVH
HPLQGtFLRVOLPLWDQGRVHDDFUHGLWDUQDTXLORTXHDFRPXQLGDGHHPTXHHVWiLQVHULGD
OKHHQVLQD3RUpPDOJRDQiORJRDFRQWHFHULDVHHVWLYHVVHQXPDFRPXQLGDGHDWHtVWDDt
DFUHQoD³'HXVQmRH[LVWH´WRUQDYDVHDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDSHORIDFWRGHVHOLPLWDU
DDFUHGLWDUQRTXHDFRPXQLGDGHDWHtVWDOKHHQVLQD0DVVXSRQKDPRVTXHD9HUDHQWUD
HPFRQWDFWRFRPWUDGLo}HVUHOLJLRVDVTXHGLYHUJHPVLJQLILFDWLYDPHQWHGDVXDH
TXHVWLRQDVHVREUHDYHUGDGHGDVXDUHOLJLmR

$OpPGLVVRDSHUFHEHVHGHPXLWRVKRUURUHVQRPXQGRYrSHVVRDVPXLWDVGHODV
UHOLJLRVDVTXHFRPHWHPDWHQWDGRVFDXVDQGRLQ~PHUDVPRUWHVHVRIULPHQWRGH
SHVVRDVLQRFHQWHVHGiVHFRQWDGDH[LVWrQFLDGHWHUUDPRWRVFKHLDVtsunamis
IXUDF}HVHRXWURVGHVDVWUHVQDWXUDLVHVXUJHDSHUJXQWD³VH'HXVpVXPDPHQWHERP
RPQLSRWHQWHHRPQLVFLHQWHFRPRPHHQVLQDUDPHQWmRSRUTXHH[LVWHWDQWRPDOH
VRIULPHQWR"´(TXHVWLRQDQGRVHVREUHDH[LVWrQFLDGHWDQWRPDOJUDWXLWRFRPHoDD
UHIOHFWLU³VHUiTXH'HXVH[LVWH"´

1DDXODGHILORVRILDD9HUDWDPEpPLQLFLDXPDDSUHQGL]DJHPGHGLYHUVRVDUJXPHQWRV
DIDYRUHFRQWUDDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXVTXHDID]HPDQDOLVDUHSHQVDUFULWLFDPHQWH

6HUiDJRUDUDFLRQDOHOHJtWLPRD9HUDDFUHGLWDUHP'HXVVHPDUJXPHQWRVRXLQGtFLRV"
$9HUDGHGLFRXVHDLQYHVWLJDUVHULDPHQWHHVWDVTXHVW}HVUHOLJLRVDVDYHULJXDQGRDVXD
SODXVLELOLGDGHHDQDOLVDQGRGLYHUVRVDUJXPHQWRVDIDYRUHFRQWUDDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXV
SRULVVRSDUHFHTXHD9HUDQmRHVWiMXVWLILFDGDDDFUHGLWDUHP'HXVQDDXVrQFLDGH
DUJXPHQWRVHLQGtFLRV

2VHQWLGRGRGLYLQRTXHJDUDQWHDEDVLFLGDGHGDFUHQoDHP'HXVSUHVVXS}HD
YHUGDGHVREUHDGRXWULQDGRSHFDGRHVREUHDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXV2DUJXPHQWRGR
VHQWLGRGLYLQRpGXSODPHQWHFLUFXODUeFLUFXODUSRUTXHSUHVVXS}HDH[LVWrQFLDGHXPD
IDFXOGDGHTXHGHSHQGHGDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXVSDUDHQWmRMXVWLILFDUDH[LVWrQFLDGH
'HXV(WDPEpPpFLUFXODUSRUSUHVVXSRUDH[LVWrQFLDGHXPDSURSULHGDGHFKDPDGD
³SHFDGR´TXHGHSHQGHGDH[LVWrQFLDGHXP'HXVHVSHFtILFRTXHpR'HXVFULVWmR
$VVLPWHPRVXPDUJXPHQWRDIDYRUGRWHtVPRTXHGHSHQGHGDVXSRVLomRGHTXHR
WHtVPRFULVWmRpYHUGDGHLUR

0DVWHUHPRVERDVUD]}HVSDUDDILUPDUTXHR'HXVFULVWmRH[LVWH"(VHUiTXHD
GRXWULQDGRSHFDGRTXHFRUURPSHRVHQWLGRGRGLYLQRpSODXVtYHO",PDJLQHPRVTXHVH
DSUHVHQWDPDUJXPHQWRVFRJHQWHVFRQWUDDH[LVWrQFLDGH'HXV,VWRQRVOHYDUiD
FRQFOXLUTXHQmRH[LVWHTXDOTXHUVHQWLGRGRGLYLQRHQWUHDVQRVVDVIDFXOGDGHV
FRJQLWLYDVHVHPHVWHVHQWLGRGRGLYLQRQmRSRGHPRVJDUDQWLUDEDVLFLGDGHDSURSULDGD
GDFUHQoDHP'HXV$VVLPSDUHFHPDLVUD]RiYHOH[DPLQDUFULWLFDPHQWHVH'HXVH[LVWH
GRTXHSUHVVXSRUGHVGHORJRXPVHQWLGRGRGLYLQRHXPDFUHQoDEiVLFDHP'HXVVHP
TXDOTXHUDUJXPHQWR

$SyVWRGDHVWDH[SORUDomRGHDUJXPHQWRVHUD]}HVTXHVXVWHQWDPDWHRULDGH
3ODQWLQJDHGHSRLVGHYHUPRVDOJXPDVREMHFo}HVSULQFLSDLVHVWiQRPRPHQWRGH
SHQVDUHVHH[DPLQDUHVFULWLFDPHQWHFRQVLGHUDVSODXVtYHODWHRULDGH3ODQWLQJDTXH
GHIHQGHTXHpUDFLRQDODFHLWDUDFUHQoDHP'HXVVHPTXHRIDoDPRVFRPEDVHHP
TXDLVTXHUSURYDVDUJXPHQWRVRXLQGtFLRV"6HUiDFUHQoDHP'HXVDSURSULDGDPHQWH
EiVLFD"

'RPLQJRV)DULD
GI#GRPLQJRVIDULDQHW

4XHVW}HVGHUHYLVmR
 2TXHVLJQLILFDGL]HUTXHDFUHQoDHP'HXVpDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD"
 3RUTXHPRWLYR3ODQWLQJDFRQVLGHUDVTXHQmRpSODXVtYHODFUtWLFDLQGLFLDULVWD"
 ([SOLTXHHPTXHFLUFXQVWkQFLDVHFRQGLo}HVDFUHQoDHP'HXVSRGHWRUQDUVH
DSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD
 $FUHQoDQD*UDQGH$EyERUDSRGHWRUQDUVHDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD"-XVWLILFD
 6HJXQGR3ODQWLQJDSRUTXHUD]mRRVDWHXVQmRWrPXPDFUHQoDEiVLFDHP'HXV"
 )RUPXODDREMHFomRTXHFRQVLGHUHVPDLVIRUWHFRQWUDDWHRULDGH3ODQWLQJD

4XHVW}HVGHGLVFXVVmR
 ³$FUHQoDHP'HXVpDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFD´&RQFRUGDV"3RUTXr"
 ³$FUHQoDDSURSULDGDPHQWHEiVLFDHP'HXVQmRpLQIXQGDGDRXJUDWXLWD´&RQFRUGDV"
3RUTXr"
 &RQVLGHUDVTXHppWLFDHHSLVWHPLFDPHQWHOHJtWLPRDFUHGLWDUHP'HXVVHPTXDOTXHU
SURYDDUJXPHQWRRXLQGtFLR"-XVWLILFD
3DUDVDEHUHVPDLV
3DUVRQV.HLWK³$OJXQV$UJXPHQWRV7HtVWDV&RQWHPSRUkQHRV´LQUm Mundo sem
Deus: Ensaios sobre o AteísmoGLU0LFKDHO0DUWLQWUDGGH'HVLGpULR0XUFKR/LVERD
(GLo}HVSS
3ODQWLQJD$OYLQ³6HUiD&UHQoDHP'HXV$SURSULDGDPHQWH%iVLFD"´LQA Ética da
CrençaRUJGH'HVLGpULR0XUFKRWUDGGH9tWRU*XHUUHLUR/LVERD%L]kQFLRSS

5RZH:LOOLDPIntrodução à Filosofia da ReligiãoWUDGGH9tWRU*XHUUHLUR/LVERD
9HUER

 

 3URFXUDU

(QVLQR )LORVRILDGDUHOLJLmR )LORVRILD$EHUWD 'LVVHUWDo}HV

(SLVWHPRORJLD )LORVRILDGDPHQWH )LORVRILFDPHQWH *ORVViULR
(VWpWLFD )LORVRILDSROtWLFD )LORVRILD3~EOLFD /LJDo}HV
eWLFD *XLDGDVIDOiFLDV 5HFHQV}HV
)LORVRILD +LVWyULDGDILORVRILD 6REUHQyV
)LORVRILDGDFLrQFLD /yJLFD 2SLQLmR 7HUPRVGHXWLOL]DomR
)LORVRILDGDOLQJXDJHP 0HWDItVLFD %ORJ ,661

,QtFLR  )DFHERRN  1HZVOHWWHU 

&RS\ULJKW‹FULWLFDQDUHGHFRP