Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SEMANA 6.4 T Guía para El Diseño Preliminar de Presas de Arco PDF
SEMANA 6.4 T Guía para El Diseño Preliminar de Presas de Arco PDF
I---
Guide for Preliminary Design
of Arch Dams
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT
OF THE INTERIOR
BUREAU OF RECLAMATION
A WATER RESOURCES TECHNICAL PUBLICATION
BUREAU OF RECLAMATION
. . _ _ * . “ . . “ . . _ _ . ”
For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, TJ.S. Government Printing Office, Wash-
ington, D.C. 20402, or the Engineering and Research Center, Rureau of Reclamation,
Attention 922, Denver Federal Center, Denver, Colo. 80225. Price SO wntn.
Stock Number 024-00340097-3 Catalog Number I 27.34 :36/976
-- ---
Pre face
IN THEIR PLANNINQ of water resources develop- In the past, there has been no convenient
ment projects, Bureau of Reclamation engineers method of preparing preliminary designs of arch
may be required to prepare preliminary layouts dams. This monograph provides a rapid method
and estimates of arch dams. Such preliminary to aid engineers in preparing such designs. The
studies aid the project planners in evaluating engineers will f!nd the empirical formulas and
the feasibility of arch dams and their relationship charts developed here useful as a guide in pre-
to other types of dams in the project plans in liminary layouts. They will also find that the
formulas are useful in reanalyzing previous
terms of comparative economy, availability of preliminary designs to obtain more accurate
construction materials, and other technical con- estimates of dimensions and volumes of arch
siderations. dams being considered in project plans.
iii
I ” . X . . _ . , - - _ ”
Summary
developed in this Empirical formulas derived from a statistical
T
HE EMPIRICAL FORMULAS
monograph for use by project planners or other analysis of existing concrete arch dam data are:
interested persons will assist them in estimat-
Tc=0.01[H+1.2L1];
ing volumes and basic dimensions for arch dams
on future projects and in updating past estimates. T,.a=O.95Tg
The information contained here is to be used
only as a guide for the preliminary layout of
concrete arch dams.
Topographic dimensions necessary to compute
thicknesses, projections, and volume are structural
height, H, and horizontal distances between
abutments including estimated excavation to
sound rock at crest elevation, L1, and 15 percent
of H above base, L. Generally, results from
the suggested formulas are conservative as
compared with values computed more precisely.
Acknowledgments
John R. Brizzolara and Kenneth G. Bell of and Mr. Bell developed the volumetric formulas
the Stress Analysis Unit, Concrete Dams Section, and prepared the nomographs. The monograph
Dams Branch, Division of Design, were major
contributors to this monograph. Mr. Brizzolara was prepared under the supervision of M. D.
assembled major portions of the statistical data Copen, Head of the Stress Analysis Unit.
V
Contents
page
.a.
Preface ____- ___________--___- L_________-- ______________________ 111
Summary--.----------------------------------------------------- V
Acknowledgmenk------_---------------------------------------- V
Definitions------------------------------- ______________________ ix
Introduction---------------------------- ________________________ 1
Statistical Data------------------------------------- ____________ 3
Analyses---- ____- ____----..-----------..----_---_-------_---_--- 5
Results--- _____-_-__-- _____-___---_---_-_- _________- ____________ 7
CrownCantilever-Thicknesses--------- _________-___- _______- 7
Crown Cantilever-Projections-~----~---c________ -__-- _______- 7
Volume___---_--------------------------------------------- 10
LimitationsandAccuracy-__--------------------------------- 10
Examples_------------------------------------------------------ 13
Examplel_--__----_-__---_--------------------------------- 13
Exarnple2_________-___------------------------------------- 16
Layout--_-___------------------------------------------------- 17
LIST OF FIGURES
1. Damsit.e topography and required dimensions for nomographs and
layoutofdam__--__-______-___------------------------------ 2
2. Nomograph for obtaining crest thickness and projections on crown
cantilever__--____-____-___-_-_---_------------------------- 8
3. Nomograph for obtaining base thickness and projections on crown
cantilever__--__---____,___________-___--------------------- 9
4. Nomographforobtaining VI- _________ -_-__---__--_--- _________ 11
5. Nomographfor obtaining Vz---- ______ -_-_----__-__--- ________- 12
6. Planforapreliminarydesign __________--__----__-_--_- ____-____ 14
7. Crown cantilever and lines of centers for a preliminary design- _____ 15
vii
Definitions
CONCRETE ARCH DAM TERMINOLOGY is not univer- Crown cantilever- _ _ _ Vertical section positioned about
sal and physical terms used in this guide may, in midway between abutments and
whose base is generally the lowest
some instances, seem ambiguous. For this reason,
elevation of the dam.
words, phrases, and symbols used in this guide Structural height- - _ _ Vertical distance from crest of dam
referring to arch dams are defined. to lowest point of foundation.
Double curvature---- Continuously curved in plan and Thickness- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Horizontal distance between up-
elevation. stream and downstream faces of
Single curvature----- Curved in plan only. dam on line normal to extrados.
Depth of excavation- Depth from ground surface to Upstream projection- Horizontal distance from extrados
sound rock as determined from to axis on line normal to extrados.
available geological sources (geol- Downstream projec- Horizontal distance from intrados
ogists, geologic maps, cores, etc.). tion. to axis on line normal to extrados
Foundation-..--..---- Total mass of sound rock support- (thickness=upstream projection
ing the dam. + downstream projection).
Abutment __________ The rock mass which supports the
H =structural height.
horizontal elements, such as can-
yon walls. TC =thickness a6 crest.
Base ________-___.__ Bottom surface of vertical element TB =thickness at base.
resting on foundation. TO.aH=thickness of crown cantilever at O.&N
Extrados- __ _ _ __ _ __ _ Curved upstream surface of hori- above base.
zontal arch elements.
USP =upstream projection.
Intrados- _ _ _ _ _ ___ __ Curved downstream surface of hori-
zontal arch elements. DSP =downstream projection,
Crest- _ __ _ ____ __ __ _ Top of dam. Ll =straight line distance at crest elevation be-
Axis- _- _ _____ ____ __ Vertical reference surface, cylindri- tween abutments assumed excavated to
cal in plan and coincident with sound rock.
the extrados at crest elevation.
Axis radius--_--_..-- Radius of axis equal to extrados
LZ =straight line distance, at 0.15Habove base,
radius at crest elevation. between abutments assumed excavated to
Central angle- _ _ _ _ _ _ Angle at extrados center formed by sound rock.
lines extended to arch abutments. V =estimated volume of dam.
ix
“ - . . - . . * _ . - _ _
Introduction
THIS MONOGRAPH is a guide which presents for- From statistical analyses of arch dam geometri-
mulas and charts for preliminary design of arch cal properties, empirical formulas were developed
dams. Included are the procedure and examples for t,hherapid determination of initial physical
for preparing a preliminary layout of a concrete dimensions for design and volume estimates. The
more complicated formulas are expressed in
arch dam. Figure 1 shows the topographic map nomographic charts, shown in figures 2, 3, 4, and
used in example 1. The figure indicates the re- 5. Figure 6 illustrates a plan and figure 7 illus-
quired measurements for determining the volume trates the crown cantilever and lines of centers for
of the dam and dimensions of the crown cantilever. example 1.
1
..--._- .._. ..“__.
I II,w L>
FIGURE 1 .-Damsite
--
topography and required dimensions for nomographs and layout of dam. For example 1: H= estimated
structural height (890 feet); L,=chord length, crest elevation (660 feet); L,a=chord length, 0.16H above base (160 feet);
and crest assumed at elevation 326.
Statistical Data
DATA USED in the statistical analysis were taken d. Length and central angle of lowest theoretical
from a.nalytical studies currently on file in the arch in analysis.
Stress Analysis Unit,. Data used in preparation e. Thickness and upstream projection at base of
of this guide include : crown cantilever.
f. Volume of dam.
a. Structural height.
g. Sustained modulus of elasticity of concrete
b. Length, thickness, and central angle of arch and rock.
at crest of dam. h. Approximate loaded foundation area.
c. Axis radius. i. Profile of dam developed along axis.
3
..-_. -.. .-_____
Analyses
STATISTICAL ANALYSES of tabulated data were width near the base, enable both canyon shapes to
based on observation, experience, and intuition. be handled with a single formula. The most satis-
Combinations of height, thicknesses, projections, factory elevation for measuring the lower canyon
and distances were incorporated with constant or width is 15 percent of the structural height above
variable coefficients in linear, nonlinear, or expo- the base.
nential equations to determine proper relation- Difficulties experienced in arriving at simple
ships for the basic dimensions and Volume. equations were due in part to the inclusion of data
A foremost consideration in developing empirical for both single and double curvature dams.
formulas for concrete arch dams is the shape of the
Although a greater number of single curvature
canyon. Initia.lly, the tabulated data were sepa-
rated into two general canyon shapes, U and V. dams have been designed, data from the more
Several formulas were developed in part for each efficient double curvature concrete dams were used
shape, considering arc length at crest and struc- to develop the final empirical formulas. As more
tural height. These observations disclosed to double curvature arch dams are designed, more
some degree the relative importance of the selected data may become available for refinements in the
variables. Including anot’her variable, the canyon formulas and nomographs.
Results
T
HE ~0sT IMMEDIATE INFORMATION necessary
for the design of a concrete arch dam for a ;
reconnaissance study is an estimate of the
volume and a general plan. As a result of the c. Thickness at O.45H, in feet,
statistical analyses, empirical formulas were de-
veloped for computing the volume of concrete in T,,,4m=0.95 TB.
a dam and for sufficient dimensions for a crown
cantilever to produce an adequate shape. Di- Nomographs for estimating the crest and base
mensions, in feet, required for solving the equa- thicknesses are shown in figures 2 and 3. The
tions are: H, the structural height (which is the crest thickness is found by intersecting the TO-scale
vertical distance from the crest of the dam to the with a straight line from H to L, in figure 2.
lowest assumed point of foundation) ; L1, the Thickness of the base is obtained from figure 3 by
straight line distance at crest elevation between the following procedure:
abutments, assumed excavated to sound rock; and 1. Mark on the S-scale the intersection of
Lz, the straight line distance at 0.15H between a straight line between known values L1 and
abutments, assumed excavated to sound rock. L-2.
2. The base thickness is read from the
Crown Cantilever-Thicknesses T,-scale at the intersection of a straight line
Thicknesses which are necessary for shaping between S, and the known value H.
the crown cantilever are at the crest, T,; at the
base, TB; and at 0.45H above the base, T,,.u,. Crown Cantilever-Projections
Formulas for computing each of the thicknesses Upstream and downstream projections are hori-
are: zontal distances used to locate the extrados and
a. Crest thickness, in feet, intrados relative to the reference surface, the axis,
T,=O.Ol [H+ 1.2 L,]; as shown in figure 2. Projections related to the
b. Base thickness, in feet, preceding three thicknesses are defined as follows:
7
--. -- .--._.
- mo M- - so,
so -
--II00
70 - -,OO
- ,000
-000
so-
- 400
- so0
so -
-700
-so00
SW 40-
NOTES
Dlmonsions roquirod for using shotis
H SEstimotod structural height of dam from crest to
bore including assumed depth of excavation.
so0 L1 &might line dirtonce at crest elevation between
SO- obutmonts including l stimatod excavation to sound rock.
pooo L2 =Stmight line distonco between abutments including l stimotmd
excovation to sound rock ot O.lSH above the base.
-.OO
Procedur.
Crest thickness, TC, on Figure 2
1. Intersact TC with o straight line from H to L1
Upstream pro/*ctions:
At crest, USP = 0.0
At 0.45”, USP = 0.951s
At baso, USP = 0.67Ts
Downstream pmioctions:
At crest, DSP = TC
At 0.45H, DSP =O.O
At base, DSP s 0.331~
FIGURE 2.-Nomograph for obtaining crest thickness and projections on crown cantilever.
RESULTS 9
roo-
Ii
rwo
- woo
-11ooo
300
wo
400
woo
-000
3007
-000
PO0 -
-IO00
-wo
- 700
--- _---
,--- -
-WO
Too
-600
600
C-- too -:
600 SO
-300 1 w
To
400
60
-
-400 /
80
300’
/
/
/
- / 40
/
I /
900
M-
M-
1
L- j
I- to --
to
- 100 1loo I II a
1 LI S I L8
FIQUMO 3 .-Nomograph for obtaining ba.se thicknees and projection8 on crown cantilever. See note8 and drawing on figure 8.
_ .”* ‘ ^ . .. “.- - _
RESULTS
m-
to- 40.000,occ
lo-
so-
IOQ-
Loo-
H x0-
c
FIGURE 4-A _-
600-
NOTES
7w-
MO-
mo-
looo-
On Ftgure 4.B
3. Inkrsoct S1 with a straight Iin. from tl to L2
4. Intersect 52 with a straight lio. from U to W
(Values for U and W are obtained from
Figure 4-A)
rm
5. Intersect V1 with o straight line from Sf to I:
60
W U FIGURE 4-B
H x Ll - - c=;----- __----
----+
----- __
-
5-A
WOW E
f-
FIGURE
i
NOTES
wnrionr r.qu1r.d for using charts.
N = Estlmoted structural height of dam from
crest to bore including assumed depth
of l rcowtien.
L1 = Straight line distant. at crest &votion
between abutments including estimated
l mwation to sound rock.
L2 = Straight line distance bohreon abutment
including estimated wwwtion to sound
reck at 0.15N above the base.
on Figun LB -i
2. Intersect S3 with o straight line from
3.
H to L1
Intorsoct V2 with a straight lin. from
HW
53 to X (Value for X is obtained from
Figur. bA) FIGURE S-B
EW
,.--Axis of dam
El. 325;-,
Normal W.S. --LB.
El. 30 5-----”
T, = 28.9.:’
BECAUSE IDEAL DAMSITES are virtually nonexist- this point and the axis center may be used
ent, a final design for an arch dam is the result, for the plane of centers.. On this vertical
of judicious evaluation and selection of physical plane, extrados and intrados centers are located
properties which best satisfy site conditions, for drawing circular arcs which represent con-
stress requirements, and design cyiteria. This tour lines on the faces of the dam. The system
final design is arrived at by several cycles of of centers for each face must form smooth and
layout, analysis, evaluation, and improvement. continuous curves to produce a satisfactory
The initial layout in the series is based on results line of centers.
of formulas in this guide and the judgment of f. The extrados and intrados centers at each
the designer. A procedure for making the initial selected elevation should be spaced on the plane
layout is as follows: of centers to produce a variation in the ratio
a. From the structural height, H, and chord of abutment thickness to crown thickness of
lengths, Ll and Lz, describe the crown cantilever 1.0 : 1.0 at the crest to about 1.5 : 1.0 at mid-
using equations or nomographs in this guide. height and 1.1: 1.0 at the riverbed.
b. Compute the axis radius: RAxIB=0.6L1. g. Contour lines on the dam pass through
c. From all available geological information the faces of the crown cantilever and terminate
on the damsite, estimate the depth of excavation ,at the abutments. For reasons of expediency,
to sound rock. the contours should be selected at convenient,
d. Draw on vellum overlaying a topographic elevations on both faces, equally spaced wher-
map of the site a circular arc, with the axis ever possible, and at intervals not greater than
radius connecting abutments at the crest eleva- 100 feet nor less than 20 feet in elevation.
tion.’ This arc should be so oriented that h. Abutments are drawn radial from the
the angle of incidence t#o each abutment is extrados center. The perimetrical contact of
approximately equal. dam and foundation should be smooth and
e. On the axis, locate a point about midway continuous.
between abutments and in the riverbed (crown i. A tangent, to each contour on the down-
cantilever). A line on the drawing connecting
stream face at t,he abutment line should make
1 The RAXIS should be longthcned if either the arc fails to make contnct an angle not less than 30” with a line generally
with the abutment at the estimated depth of excavation, or if the subtended
central angle exceeds 120°. parallel to the canyon wall at that elevation.
17