Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Division of Neurology, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
The author has indicated he has no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
ABSTRACT
One of the highest risk periods for seizures during the human life span is the first
month of life. Most neonatal seizures are triggered by acute illness such as
www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/
hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, stroke, or infection; rarely are they triggered by peds.2005-0620D
epilepsy per se. Seizures are the most common and important sign of acute doi:10.1542/peds.2005-0620D
neonatal encephalopathy, are a major risk for death or subsequent neurologic
The views presented in this article do not
disability, and by themselves may contribute to an adverse neurodevelopmental necessarily reflect those of the Food and
outcome. Customary clinical practice includes visual monitoring of high-risk ne- Drug Administration (FDA). This article
reflects discussions of designing clinical
onates for seizures, performance of a routine electroencephalogram (EEG) for trials in newborns and should not be
suspicious clinical seizure activity, and empirical treatment with phenobarbital. construed as an agreement or guidance
from the FDA. Drug development and
Presently, however, there are no data that have unequivocally demonstrated the clinical-trial design must be discussed with
efficacy of barbiturates in the treatment of neonatal seizures. The neurology group the relevant review division within the
recognizes an important need for randomized, placebo-controlled, ethically ac- FDA.
ceptable trials of phenobarbital efficacy and safety in the treatment of neonatal Key Words
EEG, seizures, congenital heart disease,
seizures. After exploring 3 possible frameworks for clinical trials of phenobarbital neonatal seizures, phenobarbital
in the treatment of neonatal seizures, the neurology group ultimately focused on Abbreviations
a multicenter, placebo-controlled, electroencephalographer-blinded study of phe- HIE— hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy
EEG— electroencephalogram
nobarbital versus placebo in a homogeneous group of newborns who are at high ENS— electroencephalographically
risk of developing early subclinical electroencephalographically detected neonatal detected neonatal seizure
seizures. Continuous video-EEG monitoring would establish the presence and ECMO— extracorporeal membrane
oxygenation
number of seizures. Criteria for escape from the study to treatment are clearly
Accepted for publication Oct 17, 2005
defined. The proposed study could provide the first concrete evidence of treatment Address correspondence to Robert R. Clancy,
efficacy because (1) it examines a homogeneous patient population, (2) the MD, Division of Neurology, University of
Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Children’s
recognition and quantification of seizures rests solely on the gold standard of Hospital of Philadelphia, 324 S 34th St,
seizure detection (EEG), and (3) the dosing of phenobarbital is matched specifi- Philadelphia, PA 19104. E-mail: clancy@email.
chop.edu
cally to the phenobarbital-binding characteristics of the individual treated. This
PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005;
study would affirm or refute the common practice of phenobarbital as the first-line Online, 1098-4275); published in the public
treatment of neonatal seizures. domain by the American Academy of
Pediatrics
S24 CLANCY
Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Dalhousie University on June 23, 2015
not participating in the study, they could be studied desired effects, is highly variable. The neurology group
ethically, at least for a few hours, by using either phe- concluded that the goal of treatment is a free (“un-
nobarbital or placebo to assess seizure reduction. The bound”) level of ⬃25 mg/L, which has been shown to
occurrence of clinical seizures or electrographically de- be safe in neonates.20 This level corresponds to a load-
tected status epilepticus would constitute escape criteria. ing dose of ⬃35 to 45 mg/kg per dose. The neurology
The neurology group initially proposed to use a com- group hopes that participating clinicians will accept
monly used definition of efficacy for seizure-reducing this dose, which exceeds the often-cited clinical con-
drugs (ie, a 50% reduction of seizures in at least half of vention of 20 mg/kg loading dose.
the treated patients, adjusted for the controls). Sample- ● An efficacy trial of phenobarbital would have an im-
size estimates varied on the basis of the threshold values mediate impact on understanding the therapeutic
chosen for study entry, determined by preliminary da- value of phenytoin, because a comparative study
ta.24 For example, if at least 10 ENSs in a 3-hour pre- showed that total cessation of seizures is the same
treatment baseline were required to enter the phenobar- whether an infant is randomly assigned first to phe-
bital treatment study, it was estimated that 46 patients nobarbital or to phenytoin.20
(23 treated with phenobarbital and 23 treated with pla-
cebo) would be needed for enrollment. After additional ● Evidence is insufficient to recommend the primary
discussion, however, the neurology group decided that study of benzodiazepines and other putative antiepi-
in this specific clinical context, the definition of efficacy leptic drugs; these drugs must await secondary confir-
should be a total cessation of seizures, not merely a 50% mation in circumstances of primary treatment failure.
reduction. This alteration reduces the number of subjects
required for enrollment. Exclusion of Preterm Infants
The underlying causes of seizures in preterm infants are
Clinical-Trial–Design Issues not as well understood as those for term infants. The
The neurology group reported the following conclusions preterm group is etiologically heterogeneous, and no
about the study-design issues. consensus exists for an epileptic basis of paroxysmal
clinical “seizures” (variable occurrence of electrographi-
Clinical End Points cally detected seizures). Theoretically, ␥-aminobutyric
Clinical end points for treatment of ENSs are notoriously acid (GABAergic) drugs, paradoxically, may depolarize
elusive but are still important to clinicians.25 The custom- neurons and lower the seizure threshold in very low
ary clinical practice is to visually monitor high-risk ne- birth weight neonates,28 although this effect is not sup-
onates for the emergence of clinical seizures, perform ported by typical clinical observations. As a conse-
routine EEG examinations when suspicious clinical ac- quence, the neurology group concluded that this inau-
tivity appears, and empirically treat with phenobarbital. gural phenobarbital study should focus on neonates of
Video-EEG monitoring allows examination of the tradi- ⱖ37 weeks’ conceptional age.
tional end point of treatment (ie, cessation of clinical
seizures) and ENSs. Although EEG-detected seizure end Generalizability of Phenobarbital-Treatment–Trial Results
points are believed to be more objective,26 there are no The neurology group acknowledged that great care must
data that demonstrate interobserver agreement; how- be exercised in applying the results of the proposed
ever, disputes can be adjudicated posthoc. In summary, study to other neonatal-seizure populations. The neu-
the neurology group decided that ENSs should be the rology group considered the proposed clinical scenario of
primary efficacy end point rather than clinical seizures. the phenobarbital-treatment trial as an example of early
and mild seizures, albeit triggered by an acute stress in
Selection of the First Drug To Study the form of serious congenital heart defects that require
The neurology group agreed that phenobarbital should early heart surgery. It is possible that seizures might
be the first drug studied on the basis of the following respond to phenobarbital differently in other circum-
considerations. stances such as for severe HIE, in the premature infant,
or in those infants whose seizures arise from develop-
● Phenobarbital is the traditional agent selected to treat
mental abnormalities such as tuberous sclerosis.
neonatal seizures and is used worldwide.
● The best scientific data that exist in animals are based Proposed Clinical-Trial Framework
on phenobarbital. The neurology group had sought a randomized, con-
● Adequate safety data exist. However, preadministra- trolled trial study design that would be sensitive to and
tion testing would need to include an in vitro binding respectful of customary clinical practices. After examin-
study to determine the dose.20,27 This study is needed ing 3 different study designs, the neurology group pro-
because the portion of phenobarbital that is unbound, posed a phenobarbital-efficacy trial for ENSs (see Fig 1)
and thus available to enter the brain and produce the that would include the elements described in Table 1.
SUPPLEMENT S25
Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Dalhousie University on June 23, 2015
FIGURE 1
Phenobarbital (PB) efficacy trial for ENSs. Rx indicates phenobarbital administration.
Ethical Considerations newborn heart surgery, and many are not accompanied
Seizures are common in newborn infants who are ex- by visible clinical seizure activity.11,29 The opportunity to
posed to serious conditions such as HIE, ECMO, and detect early subclinical ENSs is only possible in an inves-
tigational environment that includes continuous video-
EEG monitoring on all at-risk subjects. Thus, it is very
TABLE 1 Framework for the Study of Phenobarbital Treatment of likely that those infants who participate in this study will
ENSs have their ENSs detected and the initiation of specific
Type of study Multicenter, placebo-controlled, electroencephalographer- treatment much earlier than those infants who do not
blinded study of phenobarbital vs placebo participate in the study. The determination of the free-
Study population A homogeneous population of term infants (ⱖ37 wk
phenobarbital– binding capacity improves the accuracy
conceptional age) at high risk for ENSs (eg, congenital
heart disease surgery, HIE, or ECMO); potential study of phenobarbital dosing, is not a part of routine clinical
populations with conditions other than congenital care, and improves the likelihood of seizure cessation if
heart disease would need extensive preliminary data phenobarbital is indeed an efficacious drug. It is likely
and individual study
that infants in the placebo group, who are given the
Enrollment Preoperative enrollment for infants undergoing congenital
heart disease surgery appropriate dose of phenobarbital after the first 3 hours,
Monitoring Continuous video-EEG monitoring to establish the would still have received treatment for their seizures
presence and number of seizures earlier than if they had not participated in the study. It is
Entry criteria Two or more ENSs in a 3-h pretreatment baseline period unlikely that those infants who do not participate in the
Intervention The study would include the following 2 arms, with
phenobarbital administered and adjusted to achieve
study would reach that point of therapy sooner than
a free-phenobarbital level of ⬃25 mg/L those infants who do participate.
Phenobarbital (early treatment) The contemporary treatment of neonatal seizures is
Placebo (and later treatment with phenobarbital) hampered by the absence of even a single randomized,
End point Cessation of EEG-detected seizures, adjusted for the
controlled efficacy study of phenobarbital or any other
controls
Escape criteria Criteria for escape from the study to treatment would antiepileptic drug.21 Although it is customary in the care
include of newborns with seizures to use phenobarbital or other
Presence of clinical seizures (specifically defined as focal traditional antiepileptic drugs, evidence of efficacy has
clonic, focal tonic, or sustained eye deviation) verified never been established. The proposed study could pro-
by EEG
Electrographically detected status epilepticus that will
vide the first concrete evidence of treatment efficacy
need to be defined in the protocol (no formal because (1) it examines a homogeneous patient popula-
definition of electrographic status exists) tion (those with seizures provoked by acquired central
Secondary The neurology group needs to determine the secondary nervous system stressors such as HIE, ECMO, or new-
treatment treatment protocol for initial drug failure
born heart surgery), (2) the recognition and quantifica-
protocol
Follow-up Careful neurodevelopmental follow-up to 8 y of age; there tion of seizures rests solely on the gold standard of
was consensus that it will not be possible to seizure detection (the EEG), and (3) the dosing of phe-
demonstrate subtle adverse effects of phenobarbital nobarbital is specifically matched to the phenobarbital-
administration per se on long-term outcomes binding characteristics of the individual treated. In the
S26 CLANCY
Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Dalhousie University on June 23, 2015
contemporary treatment of neonatal seizures, physicians 9. Legido A, Clancy RR, Berman PH. Neurologic outcome after
around the world most commonly choose phenobarbital electroencephalographically proven neonatal seizures. Pediat-
rics. 1991;88:583–596
as the first line of treatment. This study would be the first
10. Nelson KB, Broman SH. Perinatal risk factors in children with
to affirm or refute this practice. serious motor and mental handicaps. Ann Neurol. 1977;2:
371–377
FUTURE DIRECTIONS 11. Mizrahi EM, Clancy R, Dunn JK, et al. Neurologic impairment,
The neurology group agreed that the next steps should developmental delay and post-natal seizures two years after
include the following: video-EEG documented seizures in near-term and full-term
neonates: Report of the Clinical Research Centers for Neonatal
● Obtain preliminary data in other groups at high risk Seizures [abstract]. Epilepsia. 2001;102:47
for ENSs (eg, infants in the HIE hypothermia trial and 12. Holmes GL, Gairsa JL, Chevassus-Au-Louis N, Ben-Ari Y. Con-
infants who have undergone ECMO therapy) and de- sequences of neonatal seizures in the rat: morphological and
behavioral effects. Ann Neurol. 1998;44:845– 857
scribing the incidence of ENSs and the number of
13. Holmes GL. Seizure-induced neuronal injury: animal data.
seizures per hour. Neurology. 2002;59(9 suppl 5):S3–S6
● Explore a range of sample-size estimates based on 14. Miller SP, Weiss J, Barnwell A, et al. Seizure-associated brain
different values for specific entry criteria such as the injury in term newborns with perinatal asphyxia. Neurology.
2002;58:542–548
number of pretreatment seizures that must occur in
15. Goldberg RN, Moscoso P, Bauer CR, et al. Use of barbiturate
the baseline period. therapy in severe perinatal asphyxia: a randomized controlled
● Consider adding an additional study arm to include a trial. J Pediatr. 1986;109:851– 856
16. Hall RT, Hall FK, Daily DK. High-dose phenobarbital therapy in
benzodiazepine drug.
term newborn infants with severe perinatal asphyxia: a ran-
● Consider alternative approaches for premature infants domized, prospective study with three-year follow-up [com-
with ENSs. mentary]. J Pediatr. 1998;132:345–348
17. Connell J, Oozeer R, de Vries L, Dubowitz LM, Dubowitz V.
Clinical and EEG response to anticonvulsants in neonatal sei-
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
zures. Arch Dis Child. 1989;64:459 – 464
I gratefully acknowledge financial and administrative 18. Bye AM, Flanagan D. Spatial and temporal characteristics of
support from the National Institutes of Health and the neonatal seizures. Epilepsia. 1995;36:1009 –1016
Food and Drug Administration. 19. Boylan GB, Rennie JM, Pressler RM, Wilson G, Morton M,
My thanks go to Donna Ferriero, MD, for helpful Binnie CD. Phenobarbitone, neonatal seizures, and video-EEG.
comments. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2002;86:F165–F170
20. Painter MJ, Scher MS, Stein AD, et al. Phenobarbital compared
with phenytoin for the treatment of neonatal seizures. N Engl
REFERENCES J Med. 1999;341:485– 489
1. deVeber G, Chan C, Monagle P, et al. Anticoagulation therapy 21. Evans DJ, Levene MI. Anticonvulsants for preventing mortal-
in pediatric patients with sinovenous thrombosis: a cohort ity and morbidity in full term newborns with perinatal as-
study. Arch Neurol. 1998;55:1533–1537 phyxia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2001(3):CD001240
2. Eriksson M, Zetterstrom R. Neonatal convulsions: incidence
22. Lago P, Rebsamen S, Clancy R, et al. MRI, MRA, and neuro-
and causes in the Stockholm area. Acta Paediatr Scand. 1979;68:
developmental outcome following neonatal ECMO. Pediatr
807– 811
Neurol. 1995;12:294 –304
3. Lanska MJ, Lanska DJ, Baumann RJ, Kryscio RJ. A population-
23. Clancy RR, McGaurn S, Wernovsky G, et al. Risk of seizures in
based study of neonatal seizures in Fayette County, Kentucky.
survivors of newborn heart surgery using deep hypothermic
Neurology. 1995;45:724 –732
circulatory arrest. Pediatrics. 2001;111:592– 601
4. Ronen GM, Penney S, Andrews W. The epidemiology of clin-
ical neonatal seizures in Newfoundland: a population-based 24. Sharif U, Ichord R, Gaynor JW, et al. Electrographic neonatal
study. J Pediatr. 1999;134:71–75 seizures after newborn heart surgery [abstract]. Epilepsia. 2003;
5. Saliba RM, Annegers JF, Waller DK, Tyson JE, Mizrahi EM. 44:164
Incidence of neonatal seizures in Harris County, Texas, 25. Mizrahi EM, Kellaway P. Characterization and classification of
1992–1994. Am J Epidemiol. 1996;150:763–769 neonatal seizures. Neurology. 1987;37:1837–1844
6. Leviton A, Nelson KB. Problems with definitions and classifi- 26. Clancy RR. The contribution of EEG to the understanding of
cations of newborn encephalopathy. Pediatr Neurol. 1992;8: neonatal seizures. Epilepsia. 1996;37(suppl 1):S52–S59
85–90 27. Painter MJ, Alvin J. Neonatal seizures. Curr Treat Options Neu-
7. Bergman I, Painter MJ, Hirsch RP, Crumrine PK, David R. rol. 2001;3:237–248
Outcomes in neonates with convulsions treated in an intensive 28. Staley K. Enhancement of the excitatory actions of GABA by
care unit. Ann Neurol. 1983;14:642– 647 barbiturates and benzodiazepines. Neurosci Lett. 1992;146:
8. Ellenberg JH, Nelson KB. Cluster of perinatal events identifying 105–107
infants at high risk for death or disability. J Pediatr. 1988;113: 29. Clancy R, Legido A, Lewis D. Occult neonatal seizures. Epilep-
546 –552 sia. 1988;29:256 –261
SUPPLEMENT S27
Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Dalhousie University on June 23, 2015
Summary Proceedings From the Neurology Group on Neonatal Seizures
Robert R. Clancy
Pediatrics 2006;117;S23
DOI: 10.1542/peds.2005-0620D
Updated Information & including high resolution figures, can be found at:
Services http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/Supplement
_1/S23.full.html
References This article cites 27 articles, 6 of which can be accessed free
at:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/Supplement
_1/S23.full.html#ref-list-1
Citations This article has been cited by 1 HighWire-hosted articles:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/Supplement
_1/S23.full.html#related-urls
Subspecialty Collections This article, along with others on similar topics, appears in
the following collection(s):
Fetus/Newborn Infant
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/fetus:newb
orn_infant_sub
Neurology
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/neurology
_sub
Permissions & Licensing Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures,
tables) or in its entirety can be found online at:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xht
ml
Reprints Information about ordering reprints can be found online:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtml
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is
located on the World Wide Web at:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/117/Supplement_1/S23.full.html