Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/342521343
CITATIONS READS
0 8
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Diseminasi dan Distribusi Shelter Bambu Deployable Sebagai Sarana Ruang Publik View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Anastasia Maurina on 29 June 2020.
ARCHITECTURE :
ANASTASIA MAURINA, BUDIANASTAS PRASTYATAMA
STRUCTURE:
ADHIJOSO TJONDRO
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT :
ADRIAN FIRDAUS
WHY BAMBOO ?
transformed from a
closed compact
configuration to a
predetermined expanded Mobile or temporary
form, in which they are application, such as
stable and can carry loads. emergency shelters for
(Grosso, 2013)
disaster relief or military.
(Adrover, 2015)
BAMBOO DEPLOYABLE STRUCTURE
One of bamboo’s disadvantages is
about durability. Bamboo is subjected
bamboo has a light density and high
Indonesia has various types of to attack by fungi, insects; for this
level of flexibility, which are
bamboo which are available in a vast reason, untreated bamboo structures
appropriate for earthquake resistant
area of the country are viewed as temporary with an
buildings
(Widjaya, 2001)
(Masdar, Noviarti, & Junnaidy, 2016). expected life of
not more than 5 years.
(Sharma, 2014)
EXPANDABILITY (MODULAR)
TRANPORTABILITY
SCOPE OF
EXPERIMENT
HANDY CONSTRUCABILITY
DUPLICABILITY
DISCUSSION FRAMEWORK STRUCTURAL SYSTEM
MODULE DESIGN
JOINERY
DESIGN
LOCKING MECHANISM
EXPERIMENTAL
PROJECTS
MODULE PRODUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
TRANSPORTATION
INSTALATION
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
ANALYSIS:
•VERY WEAK AGAINTS LATERAL FORCES PERPENDICULAR TO THE LENGTH OF FLOOR PLAN
•HORIZONTAL BAR’S TENSION FORCE AT CORNER MODULE IS HIGHER THAN AT MIDDLE MODULE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
ANALYSIS:
• STRUCTURAL MODULES WITH 2-STOREY POTENTIAL REQUIRED BREAK-DOWN TO SMALLER SUB-MODULES
•EVEN WITH ONLY 3 SUB-MODULES, THE DESIGN DID NOT ARRIVE AT THE REQUIRED SIMPLICITY
• HOWEVER, FINAL FIGURE SOMEWHAT ACHIEVE IMAGE OF MODERNITY
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
DESIGN | JOINERY
BOLT AND NUTS (+ WIRE & HOSE CLAMP TIGHTENERS TO REDUCE CRACKING)
ANALYSIS:
•PREMATURE DRYING PROCESS RESULTED IN INEFFECTIVE TIGHTENERS DUE TO EXTREME SHRINKAGE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
DESIGN | JOINERY
BOLT AND NUTS
ANALYSIS:
•THE IMPACT OF HOLE’S DIAMETER ON BAMBOO (LOCAL BUCKLING vs CRACK)
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
DESIGN | JOINERY
STEEL PLATE
ANALYSIS:
•PREMATURE DRYING PROCESS RESULTED IN INEFFECTIVE TIGHTENERS DUE TO EXTREME SHRINKAGE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
ANALYSIS:
•STIFFENER WORKED AS PLANNED TO MAINTAIN DESIRED FINAL MODULAR SHAPE
• LOW UNIFORMITY OF BAMBOO POLES RESULTS IN LOW PRECISSION OF PRE-DRILLED BOLT HOLES
• STIFFENER BEAM HAD TO BE DRILLED IN-SITU AFTER ASEMBLING MODULES
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
ANALYSIS:
• PRODUCTION OF SUB-MODULES REQUIRE SOMEWHAT LARGE SPACE
• PRECISION LEVEL WERE LOW DUE TO MANUAL WORKS WITH HAND & POWER TOOLS
•PROTOTYPE MODULES WERE CONSTRUCTED BY NEWLY TRAINED PERSONELS VS SKILLED ONES
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
CONSTRUCTION| TRANSPORTATION
SUB-MODULES TO ALLOW HIGHER TRANSPORT ACCESSIBILITY
5,20 m
ANALYSIS:
• AT 5 m, THE ‘X’ SUB-MODULES WERE STILL TOO LONG FOR SMALLER TRUCKS TO NEGOTIATE NARROW WAYS
• RISK OF INCREASING COMPLEXITY IF BREAKING THE ‘X’ INTO SMALLER SUB-MODULES
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #1
CIMANGGUNG BAMBOO COMMUNITY HALL PBN 2 - UNPAR & JUBIT - 2016
CONSTRUCTION| INSTALLATION
ANALYSIS:
• LOWER JOINTS ARE PRONE TO DAMAGE DURING TILTING UP / ERECTION
• DIFFICULT ADJUSMENT DURING INSERTION OF LOWER PARTS INTO METAL SOCKETS
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
ANALYSIS:
• STRUCTURAL MODULES WITH 2-STOREY POTENTIAL ACHIEVED WITH A SINGLE FOLDABLE MODULE
• THROUGH A SINGLE MODULE, THE DESIGN DID ARRIVE AT THE SIMPLICITY, ALBEIT SOME CRITICAL WEAKNESS
• FINAL FIGURE SOMEWHAT ACHIEVE IMAGE OF MODERNITY THROUGH A FAMILIAR GABLED-ROOF SHAPE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
ADJUSTABLE
BAR
ANALYSIS:
•MOMENT DIAGRAM OF CANTILEVERED BEAM TRANSLATED INTO MODIFIED TRUSS
•
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
DESIGN | JOINERY
STEEL BASE PLATE (WITH BOLT AND NUTS (+ WIRE & HOSE CLAMP TIGHTENERS TO REDUCE CRACKING)
ANALYSIS:
• STEEL BASE PLATES HELPED ACHIEVING A DEGREE OF PRECISSION IN MOVEMENT & MOBILITY
•BAMBOO POLES FORMATION DEMANDED SOMEWHAT LARGE BASE PLATE, A POTENTIAL COST & MATERIAL
DRAWBACK
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
DESIGN | JOINERY
MODIFIED STEEL PLATES (WITH BOLT AND NUTS (+ WIRE & HOSE CLAMP TIGHTENERS TO REDUCE
CRACKING)
ANALYSIS:
•ATTACHMENT FLANGES ALLOW LINEAR, CONCENTRIC, EVEN ELLIPTICAL FLOOR PLANS
• HOWEVER, THE PLACEMENT OF MULTIPLE PIN-JOINTS ACCROSS EACH OTHER DENIED INTERNAL STABILITY
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
ANALYSIS:
• THE ADJUSTABLE BAR IS THE ESSENTIAL TO ACHIEVE MULTIPLE-SPAN CAPABILITY WITH A DEGREE OF PRECISION
• MOST COMPLEX MECHANISM IN EACH MODULE (THREADED ROD + BOLT + MODIFIED STEEL PIPE + STEEL
PLATES) – REQUIRING HIGHER SKILL IN WELDING & STEEL WORKS
•
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
ANALYSIS:
• OVERLAPING POLES IN THE DESIGN REQUIRES SUPPORT ELEMENTS DURING PRODUCTION TO AVOID EXCESS
TWISTING
• WEAK AGAINTS LATERAL FORCES PERPENDICULAR TO THE MID SECTION OF A SINGLE PLANAR MODULE
• BAMBOO POLES AT POINTS OF JOINERY ARE VULNERABLE TO DAMAGE DURING ASSEMBLING & ERECTION
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
CONSTRUCTION| TRANSPORTATION
EASE OF TRANSPORT
4,20 m
ANALYSIS:
• FOLDABILITY OF A SINGLE MODULE ALLOW EASE OF TRANSPORT, SIMPLICITY OF PACKING, & SHORT
DEPLOYMENT TIME
• SINGLE MODULE STILL EXTEND OUT OF SMALL TRUCK ALTHOUGH FOLDED AT 4.20 m & +/- 100 kg
• BAMBOO POLES AT POINTS OF JOINERY ARE VULNERABLE TO DAMAGE DURING LOADING & UNLOADING
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
CONSTRUCTION| INSTALATION
ANALYSIS:
•WEAK AGAINTS LATERAL FORCES PERPENDICULAR TO THE MID SECTION OF A SINGLE PLANAR MODULE,
ESPECIALLY WITH INAPPROPRIATE ERECTION METHOD
•BAMBOO POLES AT POINTS OF JOINERY ARE VULNERABLE TO DAMAGE DURING ASSEMBLING & ERECTION
•WEAK AGAINTS LATERAL FORCES PERPENDICULAR TO THE MID SECTION OF A SINGLE PLANAR MODULE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #2
BUMI AWI KABULA KABALE UNPAR & JUBIT – 2016-2017
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #3
UNPAR BAMBOO CAFETERIA UNPAR - 2017
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #3
UNPAR BAMBOO CAFETERIA UNPAR - 2017
DESIGN | JOINERY
BOLT AND NUTS
ANALYSIS:
•REQUIRES AN ADEQUATE PERFORATION SKILL TO AVOID TORN ON THE BAMBOO
•SEATS ON A PEDESTAL AND BOLTED TO A STEEL PLATE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #3
UNPAR BAMBOO CAFETERIA UNPAR - 2017
ANALYSIS:
•FASTENER IS AIMED TO LOCK THE MODULE IN THE FINAL SHAPE (AS-BUILT)
• LOW UNIFORMITY OF BAMBOO POLES RESULTS IN LOW PRECISSION OF PRE-PERFORATED BOLT HOLES
• FASTENER HAD TO BE PERFORATED IN-SITU AFTER MODULE ASEMBLING
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #3
UNPAR BAMBOO CAFETERIA UNPAR - 2017
ANALYSIS:
• THE PRODUCTION TIME OF A MODULE IS 120 MINUTES BY TWO WORKERS
• PRECISION LEVEL WERE LOW DUE TO MANUAL WORKS WITH HAND & POWER TOOLS
•MODULES WERE CONSTRUCTED BY NEWLY TRAINED PERSONELS VS SKILLED ONES
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #3
UNPAR BAMBOO CAFETERIA UNPAR - 2017
CONSTRUCTION| TRANSPORTATION
EASILY DEPLOYED AND TRANSPORTED
4,20 m
ANALYSIS:
• DEPLOYED STRUCTURE LENGTH IS 4.2 METRES
•EASILY DEPLOYED AND TRANSPORTED
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #3
UNPAR BAMBOO CAFETERIA UNPAR - 2017
CONSTRUCTION| INSTALLATION
ANALYSIS:
• THE INSTALLATION INCLUDES DEPLOYING AND BOLTING
• THE INSTALLATION TIME IS 20 MINUTES PER MODULE, REQUIRING TWO WORKERS
•EACH MODULE ARE CONNECTED USING THREE HORIZONTAL BAMBOOS
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
ANALYSIS:
• INSPIRED BY UMRELLA-LIKE DEPLOYMENT
• 1 MODULE HAS ALL NECESSARY SUB-MODULES TO ACHIEVE WHOLE STAND-ALONE DEPLOYABLE STRUCTURE
• UNPAR’s 1st TRUE DEPLOYABLE BAMBOO STRUCTURE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
ANALYSIS:
• HEXAGONAL FLOOR PLAN
• 5 SIDES OF SCISSOR-BAR COMPONENTS
•1 SIDE OF N-BAR COMPONENTS WITH 2 TELESCOPIC / PISTON-LIKE VERTICAL BARS
• RECIPROCAL TOP COMPONENT WITH STEEL-RING AS ATTACHMENT FOR PIN-JOINTS
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
DESIGN| JOINERY
SIMPLE JOINTS
ANALYSIS:
• SIMPLE TYPICAL JOINT CONNECTING 2 & 3 BAMBOO POLES
• BAMBOO POLES AT POINTS OF JOINERY ARE VULNERABLE TO DAMAGE DURING ASSEMBLING & ERECTION
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
ANALYSIS:
• RECIPROCAL SYSTEM ACHIEVED WHEN FULLY OPENED / DEPLOYED
• STEEL-RING AS ATTACHMENT FOR PIN-JOINTS, KEEPING POLES IN POSITION WHEN CLOSED / UNDEPLOYED
• THIN STEEL PLATES FOR ATTACHMENT RING PRONE TO DEFORMATION, REDUCING RECIPROCAL CAPABILITY
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
ANALYSIS:
• SIMPLE X & N SUB-MODULES EACH SERVES DIRECTLY AS ONE SIDE OF THE HEXAGON
•
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
CONSTRUCTION| TRANSPORTATION
EASE OF TRANSPORT
5,80 m
ANALYSIS:
• AT 5.8 m, THE CLOSED STRUCTURE IS UNSUITABLE TO FIT INTO SMALL TRANSPORT VEHICLES, HARD TO
MANOUVRE THROUGH TIGHT WAYS
• HOWEVER, ONCE STOOD UP, IT TOOK ONLY 1 M2 AREA IN CLOSED MODE
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
CONSTRUCTION| INSTALATION
QUICK DEPLOYMENT
ANALYSIS:
• IT TOOK 4-5 PERSON & 1.5’ TO DEPLOY THE CLOSED MODE INTO THE FULLY DEPLOYED MODE
• JOINT AREA OF TOP & BODY SUB-MODULES IS THE WEAKEST PART DURING MANOUVRES & ERECTION
• RISK OF POLES-END BREAKAGE FROM TORSION AND BENDING FORCES
EXPERIMENTAL PROJECT #4
RESIPLOY BAMBOO SHELTER BERNADETTE SUDIRA’S RESEARCH- 2016
CONCLUSION
CONCERN OF DEPLOYABLE BAMBOO STRUCTURE:
MODULE SINGULARITY
JOINERY VS DEPLOYABILITY & INSTALLATION
LOCKINGMECHANISM :
ELEMENT LOCKING – BRACING VS. STRUCTURAL SYSTEM.
INSTALATION METHODS
THE OTHER RESEARCH PROJECT
SURAU BAMBOO (2014)
53
54
View publication stats