NETWORK SITES:

    

  
EXPLORE ARTICLES FORUMS EDUCATION COMPANY DIRECTORY CONNECT WITH US    

 Home  Forums  Communication  Modbus

No TCP ACK for Modbus TCP message with

Reply

exception?
 FieldEngLL ·  Today at 4:25 PM

Mark Forums Read Search Forums Watched Forums Watched Threads New Posts

Jump to new Watch

Thread Starter #1

F FieldEngLL
Today at 4:25 PM

Hello All,

I am attaching a redacted screen grab due to the nature of site security, but I am hoping is enough enough maybe someone can point me in right direction or
offer some knowledge.

The text portion in an Intouch .txt log file capture for a OI.MBTCP field device. It tells me that transaction 1695 timed out.

Wireshark capture tells me that transaction 1695 was "textbook" to what I would expect.

However, transaction 1694 in WS shows a modbus exception with the bridge device. I was curious because I never did see a TCP ACK for the frame 96480.
Would this be expected? K.

I don't understand why the Intouch OI.MBTCP says 1695 is the message that timed out.

I am open to any suggestions as I am sort of stuck with as to what direction. I wish I could just attach the capture file, but this is part of my struggle here and
why I decided to try my luck here. I am trying to clean up modbus commss and this seems to be a re-occuring thing with these particle devices. So if I can
resolve these issues, I can focus on my next round of cleanup.

Thanks.

Attachments


EMCP redacted c…
236.1 KB Views: 1

Report  Like  Reply

jschulze #2

J Today at 7:44 PM New

I assume that the bridge device is some sort of Modbus/TCP to Modbus RTU router or gateway, is this correct?

I can't speak to the timeout error you're seeing in Intouch, but the exception response you're seeing is exception 11, which is Gateway Target Device Failed to
Respond, defined by the spec as:
"Specialized use in conjunction with gateways, indicates that no response was obtained from the target device. Usually means that the device is not present on
the network."

It sounds like there is an issue on your Modbus RTU network (assuming that's the protocol used on the other side of the bridge device). A device is not
responding to a request or there is a communication issue that causes the response to not be received correctly by the bridge device. I recommend that you
check your wiring, ground references, and shielding terminations and make sure the RS-485 wiring is not run near any sources of EMI like motors or power
wiring.

Report  Like  Reply

                  

Write your reply...

Attach files Post reply Preview

Similar threads Forum Replies Date

General Automation
How to write to multiple modbus devices over TCP/IP simultaneously 0 Yesterday at 8:46 PM
Chat

W Send message by modbus Tcp over internet. Modbus 1 Jul 14, 2020

Modbus TCP communication between Yokogawa FCS centum VP R6 and WAGO

R Modbus 0 Jun 25, 2020
750-352 module.

E Modbus TCP - Dup Ack/FCS/Retransmit Modbus 3 Jan 31, 2019

M Modbus TCP/IP after Response an Extra ACK Message Modbus 1 Oct 24, 2017

Y O U M AY ALSO L IK E

Introduction to Add-On Quality Protocols and Considerations for An Overview of Industrial

Instructions Veri cation Master Plans for Designing Cleanroom Level Sensors
Manufacturing Facilities Control Systems
by Dennis Lynch by Muhammad Asim Niazi by Muhammad Asim Niazi by Damond Goodwin

WHO WE ARE PRODUCTS INDUSTRY CONTENT

Circuit Protection Agriculture Company Directory

Connectors Automotive Forums

Control Panel Building Industry White Papers

Control Systems & HMIs Cement News

More about us 
Enclosures, Racks & Cabinets Chemical Technical Articles

IIoT Electronics Textbook

Industrial Controls Food & Beverage Worksheets

CONNECT WITH US Motors Metal

Networking Military/Aerospace

    PLCs & PACs Mining

Pneumatics & Hydraulics Nuclear

Power Oil & Gas

Contact Us Advertise Protocols Medical & Pharmaceutical

Robotics Pulp & Paper

Write For Us Safety Rubber & Plastics

Sensors Utilities

Simulation View All

Test & Measurement

SIGN UP
Vision Systems

Wire & Cable

Enter your email address Register
View All

MORE FROM OUR NETWORK

    

© EETech Media, LLC. All rights reserved Privacy Policy · User Agreement