Case List for Provisional Remedies

Rule 57

Section 1
Calo vs. Roldan- 76 Phil. 445
KO Glass Construction vs. Valenzuela- 116 Scra 563

General vs. De Venecia- 78 Phil 780

Mialhe vs. De Lencquesaing- 142 Scra 694

Insular Savings Bank vs. CA- 460 Scra 122

Tan vs. Zandueta- 61 Phil 526

Walter E. Olson vs. Olsen- 48 Phil. 238

Santos vs. Bernabe- 54 Phil. 19

State Investment House vs. CA- 163 Scra 799

Aboitiz vs. Cotabato Bus Co- 105 Scra 88

People’s Bank and trust Co vs. Syvel’s Inc. – 164 Scra 247

Adlawan vs. Torres- 233 Scra 645

Claude Neon Lights vs. Phil. Advertising Corp- 57 Phil. 607

State Investment vs. Citibank- 203 Scra 9

Manabag vs. Gallemore- 81 Phil 254

Professional Video vs. Tesda- June 26, 2009

PBC vs. CA- Feb 23, 2001

Security Bank vs. Great Wall Commercial- Jan 23, 2017

Republic vs. Mega Pacific Solutions- June 27, 2016

PCIB vs. Alenjandro- Sept 21, 2007

Wee vs. Tiankiansee- Feb 13, 2008

Metro Inc. and Spouses Juan vs. Lara Gifts- Nov 27, 2009

Section 2
Sievert vs. CA- 168 Scra 692
Davao Light vs. CA- 204 Scra 343
Cuatero vs. CA- 212 Scra 260
Salas vs. Adil- 90 Scra 121
La Granja vs. Samson- 58 Phil. 378

Section 3
KO Glass vs. Valenzuela- 116 Scra 563
Guzman vs. Catolico- 65 Phil. 261
Jardine Manila vs. VA- 171 Scra 636
Ting vs. Villarin- 176 Scra 532
Cu Unjieng vs. Goddard- 58 Phil. 482
Carlos vs. Sandoval- 471 Scra 266
Salgado vs. CA- March 26, 1984
PCIB vs. Alejandro- September 21, 2007
Rp vs. Flores- July 12, 2007

Section 4
Arellano vs. FLojo- 238 Scra 72
Calderon vs. IAC- 155 Scra 531
Phil. Airconditioning vs. RCJ lines- November 23, 2015

Section 5
Gotauco vs. Registry of Deeds- 59 Phil. 756
Onate vs. Abrogar- 230 Scra 181 and 240 Scra 659
HB Zachary vs. Ca- 232 Scra 329

Section 6
Roque vs. CA- 93 Scra 540

Section 7
Siari Valley Estates vs. Lucasan- 109 Phil 294
Ravanera vs. Imperial- 93 Phil. 589
Obana vs. CA- 172 Scra 866
Du vs. Stronghold Insurance- 433 Scra 43
Valdevieso vs. Damalerio- 451 Scra 664
Walker vs. McMicking- 14 Phil. 668
NBI vs. Tuliao- March 24, 1997
Villanueva-Fabelle vs. Judge Ralphee- 419 Scra 440
Sebastian vs. Valino- 224 Scra 256
Villareal vs. Rarama- 247 Scra 493
Balantes vs. Ocampo- 242 Scra 327
Elipe vs. Fabre- 241 Scra 249
Roque vs. CA-93 Scra 540
Summit Trading vs. Avendano- 135 Scra 397
Chemphil vs. CA- 251 Scra 286
Tayabas vs. Sharruf- 41 Phil. 382
Gotauco vs. Registry of Deeds- 59 Phils. 756
Rural Bank of Sta. Barbara vs. Manila Mission- August 19, 2009

Section 8
Engineering Construction vs. NPC- 163 Scra 9
RCBC vs. Judge Castro- 168 Scra 49
The Manila Remnant vs. CA- 231 Scra 281
Chemphil Export vs. CA- 251 Scra 286
Abinujar vs. CA- April 18, 1995
National Bank vs. Olutanga- 54 Phil. 346
Perla Compania vs. Ramolete- 203 Scra 487
Tec Bi vs. Chartered Bank of India- 41 Phil. 596
Consolidated Bank vs. IAC- 150 Scra 591
BF Homes vs. CA- 190 Scra 262
Rp vs. Saludares- 327 Scra 449

Section 13
Jopillo vs. CA- 167 Scra 247
Mindanao Savings vs. CA- 172 Scra 480
Benitez vs. IAC- 154 Scra 41
Davao Light vs. CA- 204 Scra 343
Cuartero vs. CA- 212 Scra 260
Uy Kimpang vs. Javier- 65 Phil. 170
Filinvest vs. Relova- 117 Scra 420
Miranda vs. CA- 178 Scra 702
Adlawan vs. Torres- 233 Scra 645
Peroxide vs. CA- 199 Scra 882

Section 14
Manila Herald Publishing vs. Ramos- 88 Phil. 94
Traders Royal Bank vs. IAC- 133 Scra 141
Ching vs. CA- 423 SCRA 356

Section 15
Bilag-Rivera vs. Lora- July 6, 1995
PNB vs. Vasquez- 71 Phil. 433
PAL vs. CA- 181 Scra 557

Section 17
Luzon Steel vs. Sia- 28 Scra 58
Phil. British Insurance vs. IAC- 150 Scra 520
The Imperial Insurance vs. delos Angeles- 111 Scra 25
Vadil vs. de Venecia- 9 Scra 374
Zaragoza vs. Fidelino- 163 Scra 443
Dizon vs. Valdez- 23 Scra 200
Pioneer Insurance vs. Camilon- 116 Scra 190
UPPC vs. Acropolis- January 25, 2012

Section 19
Tiu vs. Villar- June 13, 2012

Section 20
Calderon vs. IAC- 155 Scra 531
Pioneer Insurance vs. Hontanosas- 78 Scra 447
Stronghold Insurance vs. CA- Nov 6, 1989
Carlos vs. Sandoval- 471 Scra 266
Maningo vs. IAC- 183 Scra 691
Santos vs. CA- 95 Phil. 360
Aquino vs. Socorro- 35 Scra 373
Hanil Development vs. IAC- 144 Scra 557
Malayan Insurance vs. Salas- 90 Scra 252
Philippine Charter Insurance vs. CA- 179 Scra 468
Zaragoza vs. Fidelino- 163 Scra 443
Zenith Insurance vs. CA- 119 Scra 485
Lazatin vs. Twano- 2 Scra 842
MC Engineering vs. CA- 380 Scra 116
DM Wenceslao vs. Readycon – 433 Scra 251
Spouses Yu vs. Ngo Yet Te- Feb 6, 2007

Rule 58

Purpose of the writ

PNB vs. RJ Ventures- Sept 27, 2006

Status quo ante

First global vs. Agustin- Feb 19, 2002

Section 1
DOH vs. Phil. Pharmawealth- March 13, 2007
Levi Strauss vs. Clinton Apparelle- September 20, 2005

Section 2
Doctrine of Non-jurisdiction
Gomos vs. Adiong- October 22, 2004
Dela Paz vs. Adiong- November 23, 2004
Mangahas vs. Paredes- Feb 14, 2007

Exceptions
Decano vs. Edu- 99 Scra 410
Dagupan Electric vs. Pano- 95 Scra 693
CSC vs CA- November 17, 2005
City Government of Baguio vs. Masweng- Feb 4, 2009
Reyes vs. Demetria- January 14, 2003

Section 3
Requisites:
Manila International Airport vs. CA- Feb 14, 2003
What is right in esse?
Paranaque vs. Ebio- June 23, 2010
Orocio vs. Angulunan- Jan 30, 2009
OWWA vs. Chavez- June 8, 2007
DPWH vs. City Advertising- November 9, 2016
NO right in Esse
Manila International Airport vs. CA- Feb 14, 2003
Bangus Fry vs. Lanzanas- July 10, 2003
Bayanihan Music vs. BMG Records- March 7, 2005
Levi Strauss vs. Clinton Apparelle- September 20, 2005
Elidad C. Kho vs. CA- March 19, 2002
Boncodin vs. NECU- September 27, 2006
APRI vs. Mun. Padre Garcia- March 14, 2012

There is Right in Esse

Talento vs. Escalda, Jr. – June 27, 2008
CSC vs. CA- Nov 17, 2005
Sy vs. Autobus Transport- December 3, 2012

Actual Violation of right

Hernandez vs. Napocor- March 23, 2006

Ineffectual Judgment
Unilever Phils. Vs. CA- August 10, 2006

Irreparable Injury
PNB vs. RJ Ventures- September 27, 2006

Section 4
Bacolod City Water vs. Labayen- Dec 10, 2004
Universal Motors vs Rojas- May 26, 2005
In Re Admin Complaint vs. Hon. Abesamis- Feb 13, 2002
Gonzales vs. State Properties- January 25, 2001
Borja vs. Salcedo- September 26, 2003
Pesayco vs. Layague- December 22, 2004
Lago vs. Abul- January 17, 2011
Bagong West Kabulusan vs. Lerma- Feb 18, 2005

Section 5
Editha Palma Gil vs. Lopez- April 29, 2003
Lago vs. Abul- Jan 17, 2011
Fortune Life Insurance vs. Luczon- Nov 30, 2006
Gomos vs. Adlong- October 22, 2004
Merontos vs. Zerna- August 9, 2001
Llamson vs. Logronio- June 26, 2007
Tomawis vs. Caudang- Sept 12, 2007
City Govt. of Butuan vs. CBS- Dec 1, 2010
Garrido vs. Tortogo- August 17, 2011

Section 6
Spouses Yap vs. International Exchange Bank- March 28, 2008

Section 7
Fortune Life Insurance vs Luczon

Section 8
Natalia Realty vs. CA- Feb 5, 2003
Philex Gold vs. Philex Bulawan- Sept 25, 2006
Limso vs. PNB- January 27, 2016

Section 9
Kho vs. CA- March 19, 2002
Palma Gil vs. Lopez- April 29, 2003
 Rule 59
Commodities Storage vs. CA- June 19, 1997
Vivares vs. Reyes- Feb 13, 2008
Citibank vs. CA- March 17, 1999
Traders Royal Bank vs. IAC- June 17, 1997
Limso vs. PNB- January 27, 2016

Replevin
Superlines Transportation vs. PNCC- March 28, 2007
Smart Communications vs. Astorga- January 29, 2008
PCI Leasing vs. DAI- Sept 21, 2007
Rivera vs. Vargas- June 5, 2009
Asian Terminals vs. Ricafort- October 27, 2006

Section 2
Citibank vs. CA- March 17, 1999
Servicewide Specialists vs. CA- November 19, 1999
Twin Ace vs. Rufina- June 8, 2006
Paat vs. CA- January 10, 1997
Factoran vs. CA- December 13, 1999
Superlines vs. PNCC

Section 3
Serg’s Products vs. PCI Leasing- August 22, 2000

Section 4
Rivera vs. Vargas- June 5, 2009
Torres vs. Cabesuela- Sept 28, 2001
Gomez vs. Concepcion- May 9, 2000
Hao vs. Andres- June 18, 2008

Section 5
Bautista vs. Sula- April 17, 2007

Section 6
Adoma vs. Gatcheco- January 17, 2005

Section 9
Allandale Sportsline vs. The Good Devt.- Dec 18, 2008

Rule 61
Support pendete lite

Coquia vs. Baltazar- 85 Phil. 265

San Juan vs. Valenzuela- 117 Scra 926
Ramos vs. CA- 45 Scra 604
Vasco vs. CA- 81 Scra 764
Mangonon vs. CA- June 30, 2006
Francisco vs. Zandueta- 61 Phil. 752
San Juan vs. Valenzuela- 117 Scra 926
Salazar vs. Salazar- April 29, 1953
Gotardo vs. Buling- August 15, 2012
Roxas vs. CA- August 15, 2001
Calderon vs. Roxas- January 9, 2013