Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review term technology is generally reserved for The disadvantage of these educational
SUMMAR its technical component. Education means, methods is in the fact, that teachers often
Advances in medicine in recent decades are learning, teaching, or the process of acquir- do not have enough time. Additionally they
in significant correlation with the advances ing skills or behavior modification through are not very convenient to the horizontal
in the information technology. Modern various exercises. Traditionally, medical edu- and vertical integration of teaching, create
information technologies (IT) have enabled cation meant the oral, practical and more weak or almost no self education, as well
faster, more reliable and comprehensive passive transferring of knowledge and skills as, low skill levels and poor integration of
data collection. These technologies have from the educators to students and health education with a real social environment.
started to create a large number of irrelevant professionals. For the clinical disciplines, of In this paper authors describe application
information, which represents a limiting special importance are the principles, such of modern IT in medical education – their
factor and a real growing gap, between the as, “learning at bedside,” aided by the medi- advantages and disadvantages comparing
medical knowledge on one hand, and the cal literature. In doing so, these techniques with traditional ways of education.
ability of doctors to follow its growth on the enable students to contact with their teach- Key words: medicine, education, infor-
other. Furthermore, in our environment, the ers, and to refer to the appropriate literature. mation technologies, distance learning..
1. I I
The term technology is of Greek ponents of technological packages, ment, but also the technological
origin and means a skill, while the such as: hardware, software, brain foresight and technological prog-
word logos implies – a science. Tech- ware and orgware that can actual- ress, which are defined as the specif-
nology refers to the applied knowl- ly cover all the medical technolo- ic combination of fundamental sci-
edge or the applied science. Accord- gy and technology in health activi- entific, research and development
ing to the “Office of Technology As- ties (4, 5, 6). Advances in medicine work that gives a concrete result; –
sessment,” “Medical technology is a in recent decades are in significant ( e.g. from fundamental discoveries
set of techniques, medicines, equip- correlation with the advances in the to their application in the form of
ment, tools and procedures used by information technology. Modern innovations) (11, 12, 13, 14, 15).
the health professionals in provid- information technologies have en- Education means, learning,
ing health care to the individuals abled faster, more reliable and com- teaching, or the process of acquir-
and systems, in which such technol- prehensive data collection (7, 8, 9, ing skills or behavior modification
ogy is used (1, 2, 3). Broader concept 10). These technologies have start- through various exercises. Tradi-
of medical technology constitutes ed to create a large number of irrele- tionally, medical education meant
the health technology, a term that vant information, which represents the oral, practical and more passive
includes all the procedures, tools a limiting factor and a real growing transferring of knowledge and skills
and techniques that are used in or- gap, between the medical knowl- from the educators to students and
der to improve health, as well as the edge on one hand, and the ability of health professionals. For the clinical
simplest and the most effective way doctors to follow its growth on the disciplines, of special importance
to treat and rehabilitate certain pop- other. Furthermore, in our environ- are the principles, such as, “learn-
ulation. Information technology, in ment, the term technology is gener- ing at bedside,” aided by the med-
medicine and healthcare can be pre- ally reserved for its technical com- ical literature. In doing so, these
sented by one complex technologi- ponent. This terminology essential- techniques enable students to con-
cal model, (e.g. Technology Pack- ly means not only the purchase of tact with their teachers, and to re-
age), which includes all the com- the computer and related equip- fer to the appropriate literature. The
disadvantage of these educational Software part of the computer essary to have enough trained peo-
methods is, in the fact, that teachers is a general term for software of a ple who utilize information sys-
often do not have enough time. Ad- computer, (i.e. a set of instructions tems. Therefore, educators, in ad-
ditionally they are not very conve- prepared so that it is performing in dition to their academic scientific
nient to the horizontal and vertical an appropriate way to obtain an ad- fields must be sufficiently IT literate.
integration of teaching, create weak equate final result). The software is To this end, the manufacturers are
or almost no self education, as well further divided into the system and developing information systems’ ap-
as, low skill levels and poor integra- application software. System com- plications that are easily acceptable
tion of education with a real social ponents would belong to the oper- to users, by organizing training of
environment. ating system, (i.e., now the predom- users and by providing continuous
Information technologies (i.e. inant Microsoft Windows operating support to the functioning of the
ITs) have the capacity, more than systems, and to a lesser extent Linux, system. Today, at the time of the
any other medium, to facilitate stu- Mac, etc.). Examples of the applica- general movement of globalization,
dent learning and problem solving, tion software are components of the we have such a global software de-
in addition to many other benefits Microsoft Office (Suite) package; velopment (e.g. GSD – Global Soft-
(16, 17, 18, 19, 20). (e.g. Microsoft Word processing, Mi- ware Development), where the vir-
A few decades ago, with the crosoft Excel spreadsheet, Microsoft tual teams are developing informa-
emergence of television, IT was Access database, Microsoft Power- tion systems, educate consumers
expected to becoming the dominant Point presentations etc., and the ex- and support the work of such sys-
medium, when it came to the tremely large number of other pro- tems. These particular systems can
information technologies that are grams (applications), used for vari- be developed at the level of a facility
used in medical education. Today it ous purposes). In this context, we for education; (i.e. university infor-
is clear that computers and computer will mention another term that is mation systems for education) and
technology took over the primacy rarely used – “a Firmware”, which can have separate subsystems for
of it, among other things, because is generally described as a special students, teachers and specialized
they are already, by definition, either type of software that provides sys- training systems for special purpos-
interactive mediums or require tem functions within a computer es, (for example, Blackbaud’s solu-
constant engagement of students system. As such, in principle, it can- tion for small universities – Black-
and teachers. not be changed without the danger baud Student Information System).
Computer, in general terms, is of serious damage to the basic logi- Educational information systems
the device, by which the informa- cal relations in instances when the can be arranged for one region or
tion is processed, or a device for the computer is blocked by the end user may be national and international
automatic processing of data of nu- (21, 22, 23, 24). educational systems. An example of
merical and non-numerical nature. these systems is MEISE, (Michigan
These devices comprise the bases for 1. COMPUTER Education Information System),
computer information systems (e.g INFORMATION SYSTEMS EUDISED (European Documen-
CIS) or (i.e. information technology (CIS) IN EDUCATION OF tation and Information System for
packages), which traditionally have HEALTH PROFESSIONALS Education), NEIS (National Educa-
been composed of at least two com- Various forms of information tion Information System) in South
ponents or two subsystems consist- systems have been developed; which Korea and many others. For the
ing of multiple elements such as (1): can be broadly classified into four purposes of the national system of
•• Hardware main groups: (26)
•• Software •• systems based on
These two components act computer support for
synergistically and both are learning of basic medi-
essentially important for the proper cal sciences,
operation of a computer system and •• computer simulation
its use in the medical education. systems for training
Therefore, Hardware refers to all and testing of clinical
mechanical, visible and “tangible” competency,
computers’ components. We can •• systems-based comput-
divide the elements of the hardware er consulting, and,
system into several groups that act •• systems based on com-
in interactive computer systems puters for data man-
such as: agement and quality
•• Data entry mechanism; assurance.
•• Data processing mechanism; Since these are com-
•• Data storage mechanism; plex systems that require
•• A mechanism for retrieving of a basic knowledge from
the processed data. many disciplines, it is nec- Figure 1. The E-learning framework
efficiently and effectively use it for and methods of information trans- nology for presentation and dis-
diagnostic analysis or students’ mission on distance (1, 2). There are tribution of educational content,
education. two broad approaches to Telemat- •• Providing two-way communi-
ics: cation over the Internet, so that
4. COMPUTER SUPPORTED First aspect of these is the one students can communicate with
INDEPENDENT STUDY that sees as important the possession each other, with teachers and
PROGRAM OF BASIC of knowledge about the use of faculties’ administration.
MEDICAL SCIENCES Telematics in learning (e.g. teaching Since the 1990s of the last cen-
Unlike the traditional methods medical students to use tools such as tury, WBE has become an impor-
of learning information systems, the Internet) (1). Another approach tant branch of educational tech-
telecommunications technologies is considered essential for the use nology. WBE provides the students
offer the possibility of Independent of Telematics for teaching (e.g. the with virtually unlimited informa-
Study Program (ISP – Independent use of WWW as a platform for CAI tion and educational facilities. As a
Study Program), in which students Computer-Based Instructions). highly innovative, effective and effi-
progress through the curriculum Today, distance learning and cient agent it provides many oppor-
independently. The main difference Web-based education are often used tunities for: self - learning, distance
from the earlier traditional view is as synonyms. However, distance learning and collaboration while at
that there are more variables dur- learning is much more general term the same time providing the clear
ing the learning process when a stu- and is certainly more comprehensive benefits of independent learning.
dents’ learning progress reaches a by including the WBE. It can be de- On the other hand, teachers and au-
certain level of competence to move fined as follows: “Distance learning thors of teaching materials may use
him or her to the next level. Individ- is planned learning that takes place many features of this platform for
ual progress requires that the stu- at the remote site of teachers, and as distance learning, by having suit-
dents complete the basic knowledge a result requires special techniques, able tools for the development of
that would allow them to move on curriculum design, special instruc- educational materials and for ar-
to the sphere of a clinical education. tional techniques, special methods chiving and distribution of this ma-
These training programs were of communication, as well as spe- terial. E-learning courses give you
first developed in the 1960s and cial organizational and administra- the opportunity to plan students’
1970s, first in Canada and then in tive arrangement(s) (Moore and Ke- time more efficiently, since the on-
the United States, only to be later arsley, 1966). Forms of distance edu- line learning material can be ac-
expanded to Western Europe. First cation include: individual participa- cessed at any time of day and night,
in medicine among them was the tion, teleconference, tele-seminar(s), seven days a week and 365 days in
State University of Ohio in 1970, web conferencing, electronic class- a year. If we take into account the
followed by the University of rooms, etc. (26, 27, 29, 30) aspect of communication, between
Wisconsin in 1972. students and sources of knowledge,
ISP has an integrated curric- 6. WEB BASED LEARNING we can say that distance learning
ulum, modular study objectives, Web-based learning (i.e. Web- can be interactive and passive. Pas-
computer-managed evaluation sys- based Education – WBE) covers sive learning involves viewing con-
tem and the means to manage the all aspects and processes of educa- tent on the screen, but without a sig-
independent student progress. Each tion using the World Wide Web nificant influence on the contents
student’s progress is monitored (WWW) as a communication me- that will be published.
through the computer or a support- dium in combination with its asso- There are many concepts of Web-
ed self evaluation leading system ciated technologies. There are many based training, such as e-learning, of
for the assessment (i.e. TES – Tuto- other terms for WBE, such as online whom we have discussed previously,
rial Evaluation System) in an inter- education, virtual education, inter- in addition to the distance education
active session, between a computer net-based education, etc. (25, 28, 30) and adaptive learning that we also
and a student. When a student an- WBE is character-
swers the question correctly, his or ized by:
her score increases and he or she •• the separation of
passes on to the next question, but teachers and stu-
if the answer is incorrect students dents (no longer
must complete corrective action(s) in the process of
before they could try to re-answer teaching face to
the question. face),
•• The existence of ed-
5. DISTANCE LEARNING ucational organiza-
For the development of distance tions (as opposed
learning is crucial the development to self-education or
of telematics. Telematics is the sci- private tutoring),
ence, which studies the techniques •• Use of Web tech- Figure 3. The system of E-learning with main components
260-267. 18. Rogers P, Berg G, Boettcher J, Intell Med. 1997 May; 10(1):59-73.
11. Trzebiatowski GL, Williams JH, Howard C, Justice L, Lechenk K. 25. Wolfram DA. An appraisal of IN-
Sachs LA, Altman M, Bellcham- Encyclopedia of Distance Learn- TERNIST-I. Artif Intell Med. 1995
bers M. Independent study: 10-year ing Second Edition. 2009. by IGI Apr; 7(2): 93-116.
programme review. Med Educ. Global, 2009. 26. Masic I, Pandza H, Kulasin I, Ma-
1987 Nov; 21(6): 458-63. 19. Grahame M, Moore, William G. sic Z, Valjevac S. Tele-education
12. Geertsma RH, Meyerowitz S, Salz- Anderson. Handbook of distance as Method of Medical education.
man LF, Donovan JC. An indepen- education. Adult students today. Med Arh, 2009; 63(6): 350-3.
dent study program within a medi- by Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 27. Masic I, Ciric D, Pulja A, Kulasin
cal curriculum. J Med Educ. 1977 Inc. Aslanian, C.B., 2001 I, Pandza H. Quality Assessment
Feb; 52(2): 123-32. 20. Finkelstein MJ, Frances C, Jewett of Medical Education and Use of
13. Stone HL, Meyer TC, Schilling R. FI, Scholz BW. (Eds.). Dollars, dis- Information Technology. Stud
Alternative medical school cur- tance, and online education: The Health Technol Inform. 2009; 150:
riculum design: the independent new economics of college teaching 898-902.
study program. Med Teach. 1991; and learning. Phoenix, AZ: The 28. Masic Z, Novo A, Masic I, Kudu-
13(2): 149-56. American Council on Education movic M, Toromanovic S, Rama
14. Masic I, Novo A, Deljkovic S, and the Oryx Press, 2000. A, Dzananovic A, Bander I, Basic
Omerhodzic I, Piralic A. How to 21. Devedzic V. Semantic web and ed- M, Guso E, Balta E. Distance learn-
assess and improve quality of med- ucation. Springer Science-hBusi- ing at Biomedical faculties in Bos-
ical education - lessons learned ness Media, LLC, 2006. nia and Herzegovina. Stud Health
from Faculty of medicine Saraje- 22. Moore MG, Kearsley G. Distance Technol Inform. 2005; 116: 267-72.
vo. Bosn J Basic Med Sci. 2007 Feb; Education: A Systems View, Wad- 29. Masic I, Kudumovic M, Novo A.
7(1): 74-8. sworth Publishing Company, Bel- Education of medical informatics
15. Khan BH. Managing e-learning: mont, CA, 1996. at Medical faculty of Sarajevo. Med
design, delivery, implementation, 23. Bokonjic D, Petrov B, Mašic S, Hu- Arh. 2004; 58(1, supl 2): 88-91.
and evaluation. 2005, by Idea wendiek S, Lozo S. Integration of 30. Masic I, Pandza H, Masic Z. Med-
Group Inc., 2005. virtual patients into existing cur- ical Informatics Education and
16. Jakšic Ž, Pokrajac N, Šmalcelj A, ricula of bh pediatric departments Distance Learning at Sarajevo
Vrcic-Keglevic M. Umjece medi- results of two evaluation studies. Biomedical faculties. Ukraini-
cinske nastave. Medicinska nakla- Bio-algorithms and med-systems, nan Journal of Telemedicine and
da, Zagreb 2005. Journal edited by Medical college Telematics, 2008; 6(3): 131-4.
17. Timothy K. Shih, Jason C. Hung. – Jagiellonian University, 2009;
Corresponding author: prof Izet Masic, MD, PhD.
Future Directions in Distance 5(9): 17-21. Faculty of medicine, University of Sarajevo, Sarajevo,
Learning and Communication 24. Díez FJ, Mira J, Iturralde E, Zubil- B&H.. E-mail: imasiclol.ba.
Technologies. 2007. by Idea Group laga S. DIAVAL, a Bayesian expert
Inc., 2007. system for echocardiography. Artif