Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/328856812
CITATIONS READS
0 417
5 authors, including:
Wael Alouani
OMV Tunisia
4 PUBLICATIONS 2 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Impact of the Salt Tectonic on Hydrocarbon Habitat - Central onshore/Offshore Tunisia View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Habib Troudi on 22 November 2018.
Habib Troudi, Francis Chevalier, Wael Alouani, Wala Mzoughi, and Omri Abdelkader, OMV Tunesien Production
GmbH
This paper was prepared for presentation at the Abu Dhabi International Petroleum Exhibition & Conference held in Abu Dhabi, UAE, 12-15 November 2018.
This paper was selected for presentation by an SPE program committee following review of information contained in an abstract submitted by the author(s). Contents
of the paper have not been reviewed by the Society of Petroleum Engineers and are subject to correction by the author(s). The material does not necessarily reflect
any position of the Society of Petroleum Engineers, its officers, or members. Electronic reproduction, distribution, or storage of any part of this paper without the written
consent of the Society of Petroleum Engineers is prohibited. Permission to reproduce in print is restricted to an abstract of not more than 300 words; illustrations may
not be copied. The abstract must contain conspicuous acknowledgment of SPE copyright.
Abstract
In Tunisian Ghadames sag basin, a significant portion of natural gas resources are looked within low
permeability Ordovician sandstones deposited immediately below the Early Silurian Tannezuft world-class
source rock.
The objective of this study was to develop an integrated approach to better estimate the amount of gas
stored in this emerging play via the analysis of four fundamental elements: 1) the thermal maturity of the
Silurian ‘hot shales’ source rock, 2) the trapping mechanism and the architecture of Upper Ordovician paleo-
valleys, 3) the impact of diagenesis-lithofacies association on petrophysical properties, and 4) the fracture
distribution/density and their contribution in the production.
The Early Silurian hot shales constitute the essential ingredient for the development of a pervasive gas
accumulation play. The gas generated at the deeper part of the basin has charged the underlying Ordovician
low-permeability sandstones mainly through complex faults system inherited from the basement. During
hydrocarbon maturation and charging, pore pressure increases at rates that exceed the normal gradients,
leading to local over-pressure as seen in several wells drilled down to the Ordovician reservoirs. Lateral
migration via regional faults is confirmed by numerous discoveries at the edges of the basin far away from
the gas kitchen.
Besides the structural closures accumulations, more complex structural/stratigraphic or purely
stratigraphic traps are deemed within the Late Ordovician, and documented for instance by the development
of incised paleovalleys filled with multiple fluvio-glacial and marine clastic sediments (i.e Algeria, Libya).
The discovery of hydrocarbon pay zones outside of structural closures and the result of the long term tests
confirm this hypothesis.
Based on seismic data it is generally very hard to recognize the paleorelief marking the base of the
Late Ordovician sequence. Key elements from core studies, regional correlations, isochore maps and
sequence stratigraphy have been combined accordingly, leading to a conceptual model within the observed
framework. It is then possible to identify the multiple incision surfaces associated with reservoirs of Jeffara
and M'Krata Formations.
2 SPE-192634-MS
The reservoir quality is considered as a major risk in deep areas (>4 km). Although, the primary pores
space have been occluded by quartz overgrowths and clay cementation or lost by lithostatic compaction.
The substantial gas rates observed in several wells drilled in the junction of NE-SW and NS fault trends
constitute an evidence of the contribution of open fracture into the flow.
This new insight into this play has been used by OMV to identify in Ghadames basin the area with
possible "Tunnel Valley features", analogues to those drilled in Libya Murzuk basin (Ghienne, 2003).
Introduction
This contribution focused on the exploration upside of low permeability Ordovician gas play in the Tunisia
Ghadames basin. The Ghadames basin is a large (~ 350,000 km2) intracratonic multi cycle basin in North
Africa encompassing parts of Algeria, Libya and Tunisia. The Latter is bounded by Hassi Messaoud ridge to
the west, the Telemzane –Nefusa Arch to the north-east and the Guergef uplift to the south-east (Figure 1).
In this basin, there are a variety of petroleum systems of widely different hydrocarbon productivity, hosted
within the intra-Paleozoic and Triassic clastic reservoirs (Figure 2).
SPE-192634-MS 3
The Ordovician low permeability sand intervals have been reported as the most important gas resources,
extensively distributed in Algeria, Libya and Tunisia Palaeozoic basins (Figure 3). In 2017 the estimated
cumulative recoverable gas reserves in Algeria (Illizi basin) and Libya (Murzuk basin) went beyond 680
billion cubic meters and the total recoverable reserves is about 8500 million barrels oil equivalent.
In Tunisia Chotts basin the Ordovician low permeability and fractured sand intervals produce gas and
condensate respectively in Sabria, El Franig and Ghrib Fields. The cumulative gas reserves from these small
4 SPE-192634-MS
size fields is up to 10 billion cubic meters and the total recoverable reserves is estimated to 100 million
barrels oil equivalent.
In Tunisia Ghadames basin, the increased drilling activities starting from 2010 led to the discovery of Bir
Ben Tartar oil field and a huge amount of gas from several wells such as EB#407, Larich SSE-1, Karma-2st,
Bochra-1, Adam-6, OZ-1, HAY-1, Durra-1 and CEM-1.
In Tunisia Ghadames basin, 45 wells were drilled into the Ordovician section and most of them had
a strong gas background in more than one sand layer, and from 19 drill stem tests only 5 failed to flow
hydrocarbon to surface giving a minimum geological success of 74%.
Low permeability Ordovician sands are characterized by variable performances and the maximum
unstimulated rates reached 14 million cubic feet per day and globally the average rate is about 5 million
cubic feet per day. The general condensate-gas ratio (CGR) is moderately high and ranging from 70 to 160
standard barrels per million cubic feet with a clear increase of the condensate amount toward the northern
edge of the basin. No trace of inert gas and water has been observed so far in the Ordovician reservoirs.
Triggered by these encouraging results the Ordovician play becomes an emerging target in Tunisia and
its substantial gas resources will be tied to the new South Tunisia gas pipeline.
Basin Evolution
The Ghadames basin has a stratigraphic record from basement to recent. The basement well imaged by
seismic is unconformably overlained by a thick sedimentary section structured during Paleozoic to Mesozoic
times.
This basin expressed a multi-phased evolution and the extensional features are clearly visible in Cambrian
deposits in the central part of the basin. Therefore, the initial phase of basin generation is extensional,
following the Pan-African Orogeny (Figure 4).
Figure 4—Regional transect (AA’) based on 2D /3D seismic lines and wells showing the present day structural
configuration of Ghadames basin, Telemzane Arch and the Chotts basin. The transect location is shown in Figure 5.
SPE-192634-MS 5
The (Infra-Cambrian?) and Cambrian succession, penetrated by several wells (Oz-1, Ra-1bis, SN-1,
PDG-1) can be seen as syn-extension deposits (filling of grabens, onlapping on faulted basement).
The Late Cambrian through Carboniferous times correspond to a long sag phase period and is dominated
by low but continuous subsidence without faulting, most likely a long lasting thermal subsidence. A
punctuated shortening event with local erosion during the Late Ordovician is plausible and confirmed by a
gap of 20MY at the base of Jeffara Formation in Bir Ben Tartar Field (Vecoli et al. 2009). At regional scale
this erosion is attributed to the Taconian unconformity. Above this unconformity a strong glaciation took
place inducing the generation of large stacked glacial paleo-valleys during Late Ordovician.
During the Silurian time the distribution of the Tanezzuft world class source rock is regionally influenced
by peri-glacial paleorelief or basement paleo-highs (Lüning et al. 2000).
The Hercynian orogeny superimposed a crustal-scale folding into North African basins. Faulting is
present, but the amount of missing section in the uplift zones cannot be explained by inversion faulting as
the offsets at faults are insignificant. Thus, is most likely related to a lithospheric folding mechanism and
the faulting being secondary features in those zones of the crust. The degree of truncation by the Hercynian
unconformity is more significant toward the northern edge of the basin, where most of the Carboniferous
and the major section of the Devonian are completely removed and only the Early Devonian remains above
the Silurian (Troudi, 2003).
During the Triassic-Jurassic times, after the tilting/folding uplift and erosion caused by the Hercynian
unconformity (Figure 5), the thermal subsidence restarted following a rifting phase of the Tethys to the north.
From Cretaceous to present the basin was impacted by a succession of shortening and extension
phases. Tilting and local uplift movements are visible at the northern basin margin along the Jeffara Fault
escarpment.
6 SPE-192634-MS
Kasba Leguine Formation. The Kasba Leguine Formation, Lower Ordovician in age, forms the best
reservoir in the western part of the Ghadames basin. In the most complete subsurface section three package
are defined KL1 to KL3. The stratigraphic contact between the Kasba Leguine Formation and the underlying
SPE-192634-MS 7
Sanghar Formation is marked by an erosive surface and the upper boundary is materialized by a sharp log
signature and a clear hard-ground with extensive lithification.
The Kasba Leguine Formation is characterised by massive fine-medium-coarse-grained sandstones with
minor thin stringers of claystones. Locally, erosive lags with enriched coarser sand grains and rip-up mud
clasts can be observed (Figure 7).
The reddish sandstones rich in oolitic ironstones are characterized by stacked, medium-scale, low
to high angle planar cross-bedding; bioturbation are very scarce. In some degree cross-beds with
apparently opposing foreset laminae can be seen. Remarkable to note is the isolated occurrence of thick
unburrowed mudstone layers. Based on these sedimentary characteristics, a marginal marine to brackish-
water environment in a fluvio-deltaic or estuarine setting is interpreted as facies model for the Kasbah
Leguine Formation.
The upper most part of this Formation is marked by a progradational succession with strongly reddish,
cross-bedded sandstones. This sandstone succession could represent a fluvial or alternatively an estuarine
subtidal sand dune system.
The quite uniform and continuous sedimentation over a long distance could argue for a broad, low-
gradient embayment possibly supporting an incised valley or bay head delta complex.
8 SPE-192634-MS
The detailed petrographic thin-section samples of these sandstones show abundance of iron ooides
(haematite) and pores filled by iron chlorite. Formation of iron chlorite required a freshwater-marine mixing
zone typically found in brackish water and/or estuarine-deltaic (i.e. paralic settings).
The Kasba Leguine Formation is overlaid by the shales of the Azzel Formation. The Latter is dominated
by muddy fine-grained deposits grading upwards to very fine-grained muddy sandstone and was deposited
in a glacio-marine, tide influenced shelf to offshore environment. They are considered to be the time
equivalents of the Melez Shugran Formation in Libya (Figure 8).
Bir Ben Tartar Formation. The Bir Ben Tartar Formation, Middle Ordovician in age, conformably
overlaying the Azzel Formation and is interpreted as peri-glacial deposits. The top of the Bir Ben Tartar
coincide with the main glacial erosion surface (Taconian unconformity). The Bir Ben Tartar formation is
dominated by micaceous sandstones with remarkable high gamma ray readings due to the high amount of k-
feldspars, plagioclase and heavy minerals such as zircon and monazite. Three facies have been recognized
in the Bir Ben Tartar Formation (Figure 9):
SPE-192634-MS 9
Amalgamated wave-generated storm sandstones: This facies recognized in the lower part of Bir Ben
Tartar (7m to 12m in thickness) were deposited by tractional rip currents which transported sand eroded
from shoreface complexes into shelf settings. Thicker sandstones are interbedded with heterolithic units
deposited during periods of lowered cyclonic activity.
The sedimentary characteristics of these wave-generated storm sands, with evidences of fluvial and minor
tidal influence, argue for delta front sandstones. Due to the rather fining-upward log tendency these deposits
might have been formed in a more distal position within a large estuary bay setting.
The overlying erosion surface materialized by 5cm-thick pebble lag is interpreted as transgressive lag
succeeded by thoroughly bioturbated, glaciomarine shelfal-like deposits.
Offshore to outermost lower-shoreface facies: This facies overlay the underlying storm sands. This fine-
grained sediment includes hummocky cross-laminated and wave-modified storm beds. The vertical increase
of sands beds defines a successive coarsening-upwards para-sequences which records distal progradation.
Lower shoreface progradational facies: This facies, up to 5m in thickness, has an overall coarsening
upward character (sand over more heterolithic facies) which reflects the first progradation of wave-
winnowed and hummocky cross laminated facies. The heterolithic facies is made by thin, cross-bedded and
mudclast-bearing sand units which were reworked by storm into muddy, outer lower shoreface settings.
Trace fossils are very common including Planolites, Teichichnus and Skolithos. However, burrowing
activity appears to have diminished significantly during the later stage of progradation.
10 SPE-192634-MS
After a brief drowning of the older shoreface materialized by offshore fine, the upper part of the Bir Ben
Tartar Formation was marked by a significant progradation phase as suggested by the development of a
sand-prone Lower shoreface complex.
The upper most part of the Bir Ben Tartar Formation is marked by the development of regional dark
mudstones which are devoided of any trace of bioturbations. The offshore mud-facies reflects a gradual
deepening which initially resulted in drowning of the first progradational cycle.
The top of the Bir Ben Tartar coincides with the main glacial erosion surface (Taconian unconformity).
Jeffara Formation. The stacking pattern of the Jeffara Formation reflects the development of glacial
deposits as a result of glacier retreat and subsequent advances. The Jeffara Formation has a sharp erosive
surface which constitutes a regional marker. This prominent sequence boundary coincides with the basal
glacial erosion surface of the Lower Mamuniyat Formation in Lybia (see Figure 8). Based on logs response
and the sedimentary characteristics variations the Jeffara Formation maybe subdivided into three major
units:
Lower Jeffara main sand: The Jeffara main sand (Figure 10) is made-up of coarsening-upwards cycles
developed in response to progradational outbuilding of shoreface complexes. Three main sand- units (J3,
J2, and J1) have been recognized at the basin scale.
The Lower Unit (J3) is composed of interbedded of faintly hummocky cross-laminated, fine-grained
sandstones and mudstone layers. These sedimentary characteristics are probably indicative of a storm
deposits. The sediments of the entire succession might represent delta front deposits. The distinct sharp-
SPE-192634-MS 11
based GR-log signature recognizable in several wells suggested that the lower unit (J3) was formed during
a period of retreat of glacial ice sheets i.e. falling and subsequent rising of relative sea-level.
The Middle unit (J2) is composed of a sharp-based, progradational sandstone interval. They can be
subdivided into at least two sub-units. Coarsening and fining-upward trends define an evolutionary history
that was characterized by repeated sea fluctuation. The unit (J2) is interpreted as wave-dominated, fluvial-
influenced and tide-affected delta front. It shows an upward evolution into a more storm wave-dominated
system.
The upper Unit (J1) appears to be dominated by heterolithic, bioturbated facies rich in tidal structures. The
deposits of these thick series show an overall transgressive character with internal progradational intervals.
In the uppermost part, a transgressive lag horizon is developed with associated reworked shoreface deposits
indicating the transgressive flooding on top of the Jeffara main sandstone interval.
Diamectite shale Member: Above the Jeffara main sand interval, a thick succession is including syn-
sedimentary deformed basinal dark grey mudstones grading upwards into siltstone. Fossils are very scarce
and poorly diversified (Planolites, Chondrites and Zoophycos) suggesting water columns to have been fully
stratified and the prevailing bottom condition to have been anoxic.
The upward transition from mudstones to siltstones is associated with evidence slumping and water
escape features consistent with high rate of sedimentation and the development of a low-angle slope within
the basin (Figure 11). In addition, ripple-drift lamination and lenticular siltstone are consistent with tractional
deposition of energy flows and suggest the local deposition of turbiditic sediments, as well as the presence
of sporadic lenticular sand bodies (turbiditic feeder channels).
Figure 11—Principal sandstone lithofacies identified within the Diamectite shale unit.
12 SPE-192634-MS
M’Krata Channel Member: The M’Krata Member, up to 15m in thickness, well known in Tunisia and
Algeria, is considered as time equivalent of the upper part of Libyan Bir Tlacsin Formation (see Figure 8).
Sedimentary characteristics indicate a pro-glacial environment and the overall M’Krata deposits are
interpreted as paleovalley or tunnel valley fills formed during glacial retreat and subsequent re-advance.
Glacier retreat is considered to have caused the formation of deep palaeovalleys cut by glacio-fluvial
streams, whereas during glacier advance the valley has been subsequently filled-up with glacio-lacustrine
sediments or the diamectite shale Member.
Based on core description and logs signature, three stacked lihofacies (Figure 12) have been identified
in M’Krata Member:
The Lower lithofacies is composed of heterolithic succession (mm -to cm-thick) of sand and mud layers.
A thick intercalation of chaotically sandstone is very common and mainly composed of pebbly coarse-
grained sandstone rich in pyrite and partly strongly iron dolomite-cemented.
The pyritic, muddy pebbly sandstone is interpreted to represent a glacio-fluvial debris-flow formed in a
subaqueous fan delta close to the glacial river inlet, whereas the chaotically sandstone resembles a diamectite
layer with broken and deformed clasts. Both layers reflect glacier-derived sediments supplied to glacial
lake. Another important characteristic of these sediments is their overall deformation and the occasional
occurrence of irregular deep cracks penetrating down into the underlying sand-mud interbeds. These cracks
are filled with overlying sediment and interpreted to represent desiccation or shrinkage cracks indicating
periods of subaerial exposure. Their formation is interpreted to be due to the repeated filling and draining
of the glacial lake.
The Middle lithofacies is dominated by fine-grained sandstones, mainly quartz-cemented, with repeated
mud interlayers and common large pyrite nodules. The sandstones are dominated by frequent climbing
SPE-192634-MS 13
current-ripple; aggradational wave-ripple lamination as well as common convolute bedding and water
escape structures. All these structures reflect a rapid and high sedimentation rates.
The overall middle lithofacies seems to be deposited in a glaciolacustrine setting and probably represent
deposits of a subaqueous fan delta front or less likely a braid-delta plain channel.
The Upper lithofacies consists of fine- to medium-grained sandstone showing a basal lag of calcite-
cemented and coarser grained sandstone with allochems. This lithofacies is considered as transgressive lag
indicated by the bioturbation, calcite cementation, occurrence of mollusc fragments and the locally coarser
grain size. The base of this unit is interpreted to be represented by a transgressive surface. It is considered
as onset of the lower Silurian marine transgression marking the end of the Ordovician.
The amalgamated sand bars (2 to 8m) corresponding to mouth and/or shelf bar deposits may encompass
a high chance for stratigraphic trapping potential toward the North-East flank of the Ghadames basin.
In the uppermost part of the M'Kratta Member a clear transgressive surface has been overprinted in
the whole basin. This surface is materialized by fine- to medium-grained, calcite-cemented sandstone with
basal enrichments of tiny rip-up clasts and bivalve fragments reflecting an earlier onset of the Silurian
transgression.
Diagenetic Overprinting
As indicated above, the mineralogy of the Ordovician reservoirs has typically been intensely overprinted
by authigenic cements, principally quartz overgrowths and more rarely by minor chlorite/illite dolomite,
siderite and kaolinite. The authigenic assemblage is completed by rare K-feldspar overgrowths and pyrite.
After deposition, the Ordovician reservoirs were impacted by several diagenetic modifications (Plate 1)
which lead to the transformation of both mineralogical composition and the interstitial space.
The eogenetic alteration, encountered in all Ordovician depositional facies, includes essentially the
kaolinitisation of instable detrital grains (Plate 1, Photo A) together with the precipitation of microcrystalline
carbonates and blocky pyrite. The amounts and the distribution of this diagenetic alteration are closely
related to the changes in pore water chemistry in response to changes of the relative sea level.
Authigenic clay cementation by Illite/Chlorite is typically very scarce and only locally forms a
subordinate to prominent cement within a few micaceous sand intervals.
16 SPE-192634-MS
Antigenic illite forms finely crystalline interwoven fibres, which preferentially line pores and replace
detrital clay mats/particles (Plate 1, Photo B).
Chlorite cement locally prominent in micaceous sands of Bir Ben Tartar Formation (Plate 1, D), forms
locally isopachous grain-rimming fringes, comprising loosely to moderately packed, euhedral platelets, that
are exceptionally finely crystalline and stacked perpendicular to grain surfaces, within a highly microporous,
honey-combed pattern.
Within the middle part of Kasbah Leguine reservoir (KL-2), the quartz overgrowths was partially
inhibited by the chlorite coating (Plate 1, Photo F), therefore primary porosity was preserved.
The main mesogenetic alterations which affected the petrophysical properties of the Ordovician
sandstone layers include rare dickitization of kaolinite and illitization of kaolinite, the partial leaching of
feldspar (Plate 1, Photo G), and the local dissolution of quartz at grain contacts (pressure-dissolution). The
extensive precipitation of quartz in most of Ordovician shoreface sandstone layers could be related to the
lack of extensive eogenetic cements. It is likely that the quartz and detrital clay precipitation occurred in
response to burial at temperatures up to 100°C.
Authigenic quartz are abundant, thick, pervasive syntaxial overgrowths within most of the sand layers,
and therefore represents the main cause for degradation of the reservoir quality within both Bir Ben Tartar
and Jeffara sand intervals (Plate 1, Photo K & L),. It is noted that quartz overgrowths are not completely
inhibited despite the presence of detrital clay. The presence of highly quartz-cemented intervals without
any evidence of pressure-dissolution would suggest also that quartz precipitation started at very early
stage of burial-related compaction. However, one cannot rule out the possibility that quartz precipitation is
multigenerational. Indeed, paragenetic evidence from thin-section and SEM suggest that quartz precipitated
over a relatively long period of time, both during and after the formation of kaolinite, dolomite and to a
lesser extent illite.
Carbonates (ferroan dolomite/Siderite) cement occurs during late diageneisis and replaces generally the
dissolved K-feldspar grains. The calcite and ferroan dolomite are very common in Jeffara, Bir Ben Tartar
reservoirs. Siderite and hematisation process involving the chloritic ooids and/or the pore filling chlorite
of the Kasbah Leguine reservoir.
Reservoir quality
The Ordovician reservoirs typically demonstrate poor pore systems and porosity variations are not very
significant. However, within the fine-grained sandstones the pervasive quartz cementation occludes the
primary pore networks (Plate 1, Photo K&L) and only isolated inter-particle primary pore have been
preserved (mean porosity is less than 5% and negligible permeability 0.05mD).
In ductile facies or rich clay sandstone the porosity is extremely low. However, the presence of abundant
ductile material or clay has facilitated extreme compaction, resulting in the ‘squeezing-out’ of most of the
matrix microporosity. Lithostatic compaction started at an early stage of diagenesis and had as a result grain
coating, mono-layer and multi-layers, and pore filling, particularly dense.
However, few thin intervals or sweet spots yield moderate to good porosity. Porosity and in particular
permeability, are significantly better in coarse sandstones of M'Krata Member and Jeffera main sand (J3
Layer) However, near unconformities the sandstone experienced several leaching phases and exhibit notably
more permeable (up to 4.3mD). Most of the MDT's single probe performed in such coarse sandstone were
successful and shwed good mobility. Within the micaceous sands of Bir Ben Tartar Formation, both porosity
and permeability are locally improved due to the high chlorite-cementation and less compaction or quartz-
cementation (Plate 1, Photo C&G) that is so prevalent elsewhere, resulting in the better preservation of
porosity (up to 12%) and permeability (up to 3.2mD).
In Kasba Leguine reservoir, the best reservoir quality is achieved in the shoal interval (KL-2)
characterised by high chlorite fraction, while in the other reservoirs is a mixture of illite, kaolinite and
chlorite (Plate 1, Photo E&F).
SPE-192634-MS 17
In Kasba Leguine reservoir, the best reservoir quality is achieved in the shoal interval (KL-2)
characterised by high chlorite fraction, while in the other reservoirs is a mixture of illite, kaolinite and
chlorite (Plate 1, Photo E&F).
Ordovician reservoirs quality appears to be mainly controlled by the amount of ductile/mud and the
intensity of quartz cementation. Grain size and chlorite cementation represent very localised or rare controls
on reservoir quality (rare coarser grained or highly chlorite-cemented intervals preserve better/moderate
reservoir potential).
18 SPE-192634-MS
The natural fracture on the Ordovician based on image logs does not show clear dominant sets in sand
packages and the main fractured zones are located at the top of the Ordovician (M'Krata sand Member) and
near the Taconian unconformity in the transition zone between Bir Ben Tartar and Jeffara main sands (Troudi
et al. 2003a). Very few other limited clusters of natural fractures have been observed in deep Ordovician
section along Kasbah Leguine reservoir, but they are characterized only by the presence of isolated features.
The maximum fractures density occurs in the Diamectite shaly interval. These fractures associated to
slumps and debris flows facies might be interpreted as syn-sedimentary features.
The majority of natural fractures are sub-horizontal to gently dipping and only few fractures have high
angle (up to 80°). The picked fractures show no preferred dip direction and two maxima, from NW to NE
were observed.
The estimated average fractures density in sand intervals, derived from cores and images logs was
seemingly homogeneous (3fractures/meter). Fracture apertures vary from few millimetres to two (02)
centimetres. It's noted that the classification of open/partially open fractures only indicates that fractures are
slightly open at the wellbore wall and the gap is filled with mud. However, due to the lack of the production
tool measurement (PLT) data it's not possible to know whether these fractures are hydraulically conductive
and could contribute to production.
Based on logs and depths versus gas distribution, the maximum depth, in which a commercial (gas)
production from the fractured tight Ordovician sand is possible, would be in the range of 3500 - 4000 m. In
case of high overpressure a maximum depth of ~ 4500 m can be assumed.
= 0.6%). In the Southern part of Tunisia Ghadames basin the "Hot Shales" is in the wet gas – condensate
window (R0 = 1.3 to 1.8%). The Northern flank of the basin, were most of the boreholes drilled up to now,
is in oil window (R0 = 0.6%).
The most likely reasons for this thermal evolution are the thickness variation of the overburden. However,
based on literature the amount of sediment exhumed during uplifts associated with the Hercynian orogeny,
Austrian and Alpine tectonics is about 1500 to 4000m (Dixon et al. 2010). It's also noticed that the depo-
centre of the Ghadames basin was shifted towards the West and Southwest during the Mesozoic and the high
heat flows maybe linked also to the deep-seated Pan-African faults and the magmatic activities occurred
during Hercynian tectonics.
Burial history diagrams performed over the basin revealed that hydrocarbon generation took place in two
major phases. The Silurian "Hot shales" entered the oil window in Early Carboniferous (Figure 15). In the
Tunisian side the age, when the Silurian "Hot Shales" entered the oil window, is getting younger from South
to the Northern edge of the basin. The base of the oil window is estimated to be as deep as 4500m. To date,
oil has been tested at depths of 4000m.
The continued generation/progression to the gas window was halted due to the widespread uplift and
erosion caused by the Hercynian erosion. Hydrocarbon generation resumed during the Late Triassic –
Jurassic – Early Cretaceous rifting phase. The Alpine and Austrian shortening events have a minor impact
especially in the Western part of Ghadames Basin.
Maximum Pre-Hercynian burial was reached in the Carboniferous, while post-Hercynian maximum
burial was attained in the Late Cretaceous. The Early Silurian "Hot Shales" entered the main gas generation
window in Late Cretaceous with a maxima was in Early Eocene.
The main producing areas of gas in Tunisia Ghadames basin are usually delimited by organic matter
maturity greater than 1.2 % Ro. In this high maturity area there is a reversal in ethane isotope abundance
owing to a second cracking of hydrocarbons, such a reversal is normally associated with best gas production
from the "Hot Shales" (Troudi et al. 2012).
In most wells drilled in Ghadames basin, the Ordovician reservoirs tested gas and condensate with 50
to 60 API. This high gravity API suggests that Ordovician traps are filled by the hydrocarbon expelled
principally after the maximum subsidence attributed to the Mesozoic rifting phase.
SPE-192634-MS 21
Figure 15—Hydrocarbon Generation – Expulsion from the Early Silurian "Hot Shales".
Structural traps
Ordovician structures in Ghadames basin were interpreted as low-amplitude fold and correspond to four-
way dip closures and locally fault bounded anticlines (faulting maybe reverse or normal). They are
commonly small in size (1 to 10 Sqkm) and characterized by low to moderate (Figure 17) vertical relief
(8m to 50m). The genesis of the Ordovician structures is closely related to the Late Ordovician Taconian
compressive event prior to the Hercynian phase. Inversion and/or rejuvenation of these buried structures
during Hercynian and alpine are not evident.
Figure 17—Growth strata are observed in most of grabens inherited from the basement activities.
These grabens could be filled by stacked glacial deposits of the Late Ordovician. Fault picking in
Ghadames basin is challenging due to the small fault throws and to the limited seismic resolution.
dominated by small sized horsts and grabens (see Figure 17). A clear increase of Infracambrian /Cambrian
thickness and growth strata has been observed within the graben features.
Stratigraphic traps
Given the fact that so far all the wells drilled into the Ordovician showed hydrocarbons regardless of their
structural position, the assumptions for the reserve calculations had to be challenged. The discovery of pay
within the syncline and the presence of continuous net pay exceeding the vertical closure (Figure 18a & b)
together with the absence of evident down- dip water suggest that different trapping mechanisms might exist.
Figure 18a—3D seismic line showing the present day location of two Ordovician wells. Note that
Well A was drilled in the syncline and the well B was drilled in the northern flank of the structure.
Figure 18b: Presence of continuous Hydrocarbon pay zone in well A & well B.
Different approaches are brought forward honoring the observations and demonstrating the enormous
potential of the Ordovician in Ghadames basin. The Ordovician stratigraphic upside in Tunisia could be
explained by the development of stacked channels developed in the context of glacial paleovalleys or by gas
accumulation at the margins of structures controlled by a simple function of pressure and fracture network
geometry.
During the Late Ordovician, Ghadames basin was affected by glaciation/deglaciation events affect the
Ghadames basin and the inherited Cambrian depressions (grabens) could be filled by a stacked glacial
deposits materialized by several deltaic sand prone of the Jeffra and M’Krata Formations (Figure 19).
The distribution of the Jeffara sands is interpreted to be controlled by different basal glacial erosions and
high chance of stratigraphic trapping can be expected in the NE flank of the Ghadames basin. Few isolated
sandy subaqueous fan lobe or debris-flow has been locally observed in Diamectites mud-prone facies.
Regarding the glaciofluvial deposits of M'Kratta Member, the thickness map highlights two depo-centres
located respectively in the SE and NE corners of the Tunisia Ghadames basin.
The boundaries of the Late Ordovician paleovalleys are expressed by facies change as documented
by amplitude variation (shale-out of the M'Krata sand to the West) and the complete erosion of the Late
Ordovician by the Hercynian unconformity to the North. The incision depth of these paleovalleys may reach
15 m and the expected lateral extension varies from 3 to 15Km.
24 SPE-192634-MS
Figure 19—Late Ordovician Paleovalley model with stacked glacial events, Southern Tunisia -Tunisia Ghadames basin.
The Ordovician sandstone layers with sporadic matrix porosity resulting out of the dissolution of
feldspars can be treated like any conventional siliciclastic. In contrast, the highly cemented fine-grained
sandstones layers had rather extremely low matrix porosity but they are prone to fracturing. Sweet spots and
hydrocarbon accumulations in such tight matrix reservoir are dependent to pressure and fracture network
geometry (Figure 20). The overpressure will locally change the depth/ fracture permeability. Due to the
absence of spill-point and down-dip water contact the gas generated by the overlying Early Silurian "Hot
Shales" will charge fractured permeable zone at the crest of the structure. The presence of hydrocarbon in
the flank of the structure could be explained by the good connectivity of permeable zone and/or the presence
of overpressure.
Figure 20—Conceptual model to explain the presence of hydrocarbon in Ordovician low permeability
sand (Stratigraphic Upside) in the flank or within the syncline which in fact is just function of
pressure and fracture geometry/density. In such model no spill point and no free water are expected.
SPE-192634-MS 25
Conclusions
The Ordovician in Tunisia Ghadames basin is considered a regionally extensive gas-condensate resource
play and displays the key characteristics of pervasive tight gas accumulations: good correlation and
connectivity of sand bodies, lack of down-dip water contact, low permeability directly overlay by the
Silurian world class source rock and presence of hydrocarbon pay zones even in wells drilled off structure
in a syncline.
The Ordovician is composed of a variety of facies associations, ranging from fluvio-tidal channels to
burrowed lower shoreface sediments organized into three major widespread progradational sequences. The
sequence boundaries correspond mainly to a regional erosional surface, or maximum progradation of littoral
sand-bodies.
The first depositional sequences include the transgressive shales of the Sanghar formation and the fluvial-
influenced deltaic or estuarine sandstone of Kasba Leguine Formations.
The second depositional sequence includes the transgressive shales of the Azzel Formation and the
shoreface sandstones of Bir Ben Tartar Formation.
The late Ordovician sequence was deposited rapidly during glaciation infilling of irregular
paleotopography in a complex of rapidly shifting environments characterised by multiple shifts in sea level
and significant variations in sediment supply. This sequence corresponds to the entire Jeffara Formation
that was bounded by a deep subglacial erosion surface (Tacaonian unconformity-SB). This surface records
an initial rise in the relative sea level owing to glacier advance and loading of coarser-grained, fluvioglacial
sandstones especially in the southern part of Ghadames basin. The transgressive systems tract (TST)
comprises The Jeffara main shoreface sandstones and offshore mudstones/diamictites with ice-rafted debris.
The upper part of the sequence or the high stand system tract (HST) comprises proglacial deltaic deposits,
which was formed when the rate of sediment supply exceeds the rate of relative sea level rise.
The primary controls on Ordovician reservoir quality are considered to be essentially facies related, and
include variations in textural and mineralogical parameters. Burial diagenesis including a pervasive quartz
cementation and compaction destroyed the reservoir parameters and the porosity loss become very important
above the depth of 3500m. Productive open fracture above 4000m is prohibitively low.
Sweet spots such fractures corridors and coarse sand with good initial porosity and permeability
preferentially exits near major unconformities and erosive surfaces.
Besides the structural trapping mechanism, the presence of hydrocarbon pay zone outside in the syncline
and the development of incised paleovalleys during Late Ordovician let us postulate that Ordovician
stratigraphic upside at least in the north-eastern part of the Ghadames basin is very high.
The evaluation of the Ordovician play attributes allowed us to have a strong insight on the prospectivity
and the main risk of this play over the Ghadames basin. If successful, this pilot project proposed by OMV
Tunisia would narrow down the exploration risk of the Ordovician play, confirm the new Ordovician
geological model for the stratigraphic upside and help us to better estimate the recovery factors and provide
a better handle on reserves.
Acknowledgment
The authors would like to thank OMV- Middle East & Africa Hub management for their support and for
permission to publish this study.
References
Dixon, R. J., Moore, J. K. S., Bourne, M., Dunn, E., Haig, D. B., Hossack, J., Roberts, N., Parsons, T. & Simmons, C. J.,
2010. Integrated petroleum systems and play fairway analysis in a complex Palaeozoic basin: Ghadames-Illizi Basin,
North Africa. Petroleum Geology Conference series, 2010, 7, 673–705.
26 SPE-192634-MS
Echikh, K. 1998. Geology and hydrocarbon occurrences in the Ghadames Basin, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya. In: Petroleum
Geology of North Africa (Ed. by D. S. MacGregor, R.T.J. Moody & D. D. Clark-Lowes), Geol. Soc. Lond. Spec. Publ.,
132, 109–129
Ghienne, J.-F., Deynoux, M., Manatschal, G. and Rubino, J.-L., 2003. Palaeovalleys and fault controlled depocentres in the
Late-Ordovician glacial record of the Murzuq Basin (central Libya). Comptes Rendus Geosciences 335, 1091–1100.
Le Heron D.P, 2009. Ancient glaciations and hydrocarbon accumulations in North Africa and the Middle East. Earth
Science Reviews 93, 47–76.
Luning, S., Craig, J., Loydell, D. K., Storch, P. and Fichtches, B., 2000. Lower Silurian "hot shales" in North Africa and
Arabia: regional distribution and depositional model. Earth-Science Reviews 49, 121–200.
Rezouga N., Benalya S., Troudi H., Saidi M., Meskini A. and Ziljstra H., 2012. Assessment of an Unconventional Shale
Resource Play: The Tannezuft "Hot Shales" in Ghadames Basin, South Tunisia. ACGGP Conference,
Troudi H., Soussi M., and Derguini K., 2018. Shale Play and Tight Gas Workshop. The 14th Tunisian Petroleum
Exploration and Production Conference, Tunis, 22-24 October.
Troudi H., Rezouga N. and Meskini A., 2012. The Unconventional Gas Play in Tunisia Ghadames Basin Require a Certain
Edge: IG/AIG - Shale Gas Workshop, Oran - Algeria 27-29 February.
Toudi H., Kebaier D., Acheche M. and Haddar Y., 2003a. Ghadames basin, Southern Tunisia: Appraisal of Paleozoic
Petroleum Systems and Future Prospectyivity. AAPG Search and Discovery Article #90013©2003 AAPG Annual
Meeting, May 11-14, 2003, Salt Lake City, Utah.
Toudi H., Ferjaoui M., Kebaier D. and Acheche M., 2003b. Paleozoic petroleum systems in Ghadames Basin, Southern
Tunisia. EAGE- 1st North Africa/Mediterranean Petroleum & Geoscience Conference & Exhibition, Tunis, 6-9
October, S036.
Toudi H., 2006. Sedimentological study of the Ordovician reservoirs, El Hamra Permit - Illizi Basin, Algeria. Internal
study for Numhyd a.r.l.
Vecoli M., Riboulleau A. and Versteegh G. J. M., 2009. Palynology, organic geochemistry and carbon isotope analysis
of a latest Ordovician through Silurian clastic section from borehole TT-1, Ghadames Basin, southern Tunisia, North
Africa palaeoenvironmental interpretation. Palaeogeog. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. V.273, p. 378–394.