Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Definition of Claim:
An assertion usually supported
with evidence. Usually
includes a support, refute, or
qualify statement.
Definition of Grounds:
Evidence provided to
bolster the Claim and
support the Warrant.
Definition of Rebuttal: an
answer that challenges or
refutes a claim. Rebuttals may
also be offered by writers who
anticipate objections to the
claims or evidence they offer.
Rebuttal Example: Parents may
argue all students should carry
cell phones with them in case of
an emergency, like the
Columbine shooting.
Qualifier
Definition of Qualifier: A
word, or phrase, that limits
the scope of a claim: Usually,
Sometimes, In most cases,
etc.
Qualifier: In most cases, it is
highly unlikely an emergency
will happen in school.
Furthermore, the school
could always contact parents
making a phone call using a
land line.
Create a Toulmin Model on your own
Qualifier – specific
limits to you claim or
warrant.
Grounds – reasons or
Claim – The position or evidence that supports
claim being argued for. the claim.
Warrant – implied or
stated principle that
connects the grounds
to the claim.
Rebuttal – counter
arguments to the claim
or warrant
iPad Scenario
Claim:
Students should not be required to
buy an iPad to attend a KSD school
because it would cause an undo
financial burden for families.
Backing:
The average iPad costs over $400
and would be unaffordable to
most students.
Warrant:
All families who live within the KSD
boundaries could afford an iPad.
Please write a Paraphrase on the
Toulmin Model