Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How to cite this article: Arumsari, D. R., Indrawan, I-W. A., Wahyuni, E. S. (2018), The Combination of Acupressure and
Affirmation Relaxation as an Alternative Method to Increase Breast Milk Production and Breastfeeding Self-efficacy. Research
Journal of Life Science 5 (1), 66-76. https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.rjls.2018.005.01.7
67
The critical period for the successful calm mother will have higher self-efficacy than
breastfeeding is the first 24 hours postpartum. those who are stressful, anxious or feeling
During that period, prolactin and oxytocin painful (Brockway et al., 2017). Those conditions
hormone which are important for the production may be minimized using acupressure and
of breast milk are released. The first several days affirmation relaxation.
of postpartum are also the most important times Affirmation relaxation is a combination of
for breastfeeding. Usually, mothers encounter breathing relaxation technique and repetition of
several problems such as insufficient breast milk a simple positive statement (affirmation)
supply and inability to produce breast milk. conducted orderly in order to create relaxed
Those are basic problems faced by mothers. condition physically and emotionally (Yusuf, A;
Therefore, they choose to take other alternatives Suarilah, Ira; Rahmat, 2010). Deep breathing
for feeding their baby. However, if support and relaxation might also improve the quality of
help are available that facilitating mothers in human resources, manage stress, maintain and
breastfeeding, it is possible that breastfeeding recover homeostasis through the improvement
will be successful (Rahayu, Santoso, & Yunitasari, of the beta-endorphin level, IgG and blood sugar
2015). secretion (Siswantoyo; Aman, 2014). Affirmation
Acupressure is commonly used in midwifery is a method of strengthening oneself by uttering
field. It uses hand to press several acupuncture short positive sentences repeatedly. It might
points on the body. Acupressure might recover reduce physiological response to stress and
and balance body energy to improve body repeated affirmation might also help us to
function. Based on medical perspectives, handle our daily stress. Affirmation might also be
acupressure is able to stimulate endorphin able to strengthen ones’ self-confidence and
release, block pain receptor and stimulate belief in handling the certain situation and
oxytocin release (Mollart & Leiser, 2013). It is also producing positive things (Yusuf, A; Suarilah, Ira;
able to influence the production of prolactin to Rahmat, 2010).
improve breast milk production (Raras, In Indonesia, there are several postpartum
Suwondo, Wahyuni, & Laska, 2016). massage techniques that are able to improve
Breastfeeding self-efficacy is a theoretical breast milk supply such as oxytocin massage and
framework on self-confidence for breastfeeding endorphin massage. Those techniques are
which was developed based on the theory of self- effective to improve breast milk production
efficacy. Breastfeeding self-efficacy is mothers’ (Hartono, Oktaviani, & Nindya, 2016; Suryani &
belief in their ability to feed their baby. It Astuti, KH, E, 2013). However, those techniques
influences mother’s response to baby feed require help from someone else because the
(effort and mind), which in turn, influences massage points are on the back or posterior part
initiation of breastfeeding and maintain positive of the body. Meanwhile, for acupressure, the
breastfeeding behavior. Breastfeeding self- acupoints to improve breast milk production are
efficacy improves exclusive breastfeeding on the anterior and lateral part of the body which
coverage showing that self-efficacy of is easy to reach and therefore, breastfeeding
breastfeeding is an effective theory of social mother might do that independently anytime
change to improve exclusive breastfeeding rate (Kemenkes RI, 2016a).
(Brockway, Benzels, & Hayden, 2017). Based on the above description, we were
Physiological response/affective state such willing to implement a combination of
as anxiety, stress, depression, fatigue, and pain acupressure and affirmation relaxation method
might influence one’s self-efficacy. Relaxed and to improve breast milk production and
breastfeeding self-efficacy. Besides, there has 20-35 years old; 4) Gestational age at 37-42
been no research combining those methods weeks; 5) Having no breast abnormalities; 6)
directly to improve breast milk production and Body Mass Index (BMI) before pregnancy is
breastfeeding self-efficacy. It is expected that the 18.5-25; 7) Having no complication during
combination of the two methods will result in antepartum, intrapartum, and postpartum; 8)
more optimum result. This research aimed at Pervaginam delivery; 9) Birth weight of the baby
analyzing the effect of the combination of is 2500-4000 gram; 10) The baby has normal
acupressure and affirmation relaxation method sucking reflex; 11) Mothers are not consuming
on breast milk production and breastfeeding self- drugs, supplements or other herbs to improve
efficacy of primiparous mothers in the breast milk production; 12) Mothers are willing
postpartum period. to be respondents. The BMI before pregnancy
was obtained from medical record.
Material and methods Breast milk production was measured as
This study was conducted from January breast milk intake using weighing test method
until February 2018. It was conducted in 4 (Rahayu et al., 2015) with baby digital scale
Independence Midwifery Practices in Malang. (Serenity SR30D with 5 g division). We used the
This study was true experimental design with calibrated baby scale and used the same baby
pre-test and post-test approach. To minimize scale to measure all of subjects. Baby weight
subjectivity, the measurement of pre-test and was measured before and after breastfeeding
post-test was completed by an enumerator without wearing any clothes. The weight
having midwifery educational background and difference was converted to volume unit by
getting briefing to make sure that she has same multiplying factor of breast milk density of 1.031
ideas. g/ml. Breastfeeding self-efficacy was measured
There were 24 primiparous mothers in the using Breastfeeding Self-efficacy Scale (Short
first day of postpartum period which were Form) which has been translated into Indonesia.
divided into 2 groups; that of treatment group That Indonesian version of Breastfeeding self-
(group given treatment of combination of efficacy scale has been validated (Muaningsih,
acupressure and affirmation relaxation) and 2013).
control group. We took the minimum sample The pre-test was conducted in 24 hours
size for experimental study of 10 respondents postpartum. After pre-test, the treatment group
for each group. To anticipate the drop out in this was given the combination of acupressure and
study, we added 2 respondents each group so affirmation relaxation with health education.
that the sample size remains fulfilled with the Only health education was given to the control
following formula n’ = n/ (1-f). group. The intervention was conducted 6 times
We recruited the respondents at 2 hours in 6 consecutive days. The interventions were
after delivery. The description of the study was started by conducting acupressure on acupoint
given to the respondents and written informed of ST15, ST16, ST18, ST36, SP6, SP18, CV17, SI1,
consent was obtained. The determination of LI14 and ended by conducting affirmation
which the treatment group and the control relaxation technique. Acupressure was
group was performed by randomization via conducted on both sides of extremities by
computer. The respondents who met the pressing that acupoints 30 times clockwise.
inclusion criteria were included in this study. Affirmation relaxation technique is a
The inclusion criteria were: 1) First day of combination of deep breathing technique and
postpartum; 2) Primiparous mothers; 3) Age of affirmation based on Benson’s theory of
Relaxation Response and theory of self- Wilcoxon and Mann-Whitney tests are
affirmation; employing deep breath and conducted.
repetition of simple positive sentences which are
sentences that may raise self-confidence and Results and discussion
avoid the word “no”. The combination makes up Table 1 shows that average age of those in
6 steps which are conducted orderly in order to the treatment group is 24 years old and those in
improve self-integrity and create a relaxed control group is 22 years old. Both treatment
feeling. Post-test was measured at the 7th day and control group, most of the respondents are
post-partum at 8-11 am. graduated from senior/vocational high school
We conducted normality test by using that are 8/12 respondents and 7/12
Shapiro Wilk tests on data distribution for breast respondents. Respondents with the high
milk production and breastfeeding self-efficacy. educational background (undergraduate) for
Unpaired t-tests were used to analyze the both treatment and control group is only 1
difference between breast milk production and respondent and the rest have low education
breastfeeding self-efficacy between the level (elementary and junior high school). Most
treatment group and control group on the 7th day of the respondents are a housewife for both
postpartum (post-test). Furthermore, paired t- groups that are 8/12 respondents for treatment
tests were used to analyze the difference group and 10/12 respondents for the control
between breast milk production and group. Most respondents give birth boy babies
breastfeeding self-efficacy on the first day and for both treatment and control group. Those
the seventh day postpartum for both groups. If giving birth boy babies in the treatment group
the data are not normally distributed then are 8/12 respondents and those in control
group are 9/12 respondents.
Table 2. Difference test of breast milk production between the treatment and
the control group on the 7th-day postpartum
Levene’s Mean (SD)
Δ 95% CI p
Test (ml)
Treatment Group (N=12) 30.1 (16.9)
0.009 12.5 ± 9.4 -23.79 – (-1.13) 0.033
Control Group (N=12) 17.6 (7.4)
acupressure might stimulate the release of research to evaluate the effect of acupressure to
oxytocin. It is crucial to the success of reduce anxiety on pregnant mothers (Moradi,
breastfeeding at let down reflex so the baby may Akbarzadeh, Moradi, Toosi, & Hadianfard, 2014).
get more breast milk intake. They proved that intervention group given
Several studies evaluated the effectiveness acupressure on SP6 and GB21 had lower anxiety
of electroacupuncture on SI1 on mother with level than control group although statistically, it
hypogalactia. The finding showed that the level of was not significant (p > 0,05). Stimulation given by
mammary filling, breast milk production, and pressing the acupoint seems to have a substantial
prolactin level was higher in the group given effect. Acupressure stimulation causes either
acupressure on SI1. Electroacupuncture on SI1 is systemic or local physiological change in the body
not only able to improve prolactin level but also which in turn result in the balance of body and
improves lactation after delivery (Tseng, 2015). mind. Several studies showed that acupressure
Based on Traditional Chinese Medicine, the causes the release of serotonin resulting in a
mechanism of action in acupuncture and relaxed mind. Several other studies showed that
acupressure depends on the existence of Qi. Qi is this method had analgesic effect by releasing a
important energy in the universe. The stimulation specific peptide and therefore, it reduces the
of acupressure results in the activation of Qi. Qi activity of sympathoadrenal system which is
flows along the body meridian and creates body activated during stressful condition. Thus,
balance so it results in the optimal and healthy acupressure might reduce stress symptoms
body. If there are less Qi in the body, acupressure (Moradi et al., 2014).
stimulation might improve it and if Qi is excessive In this study, acupressure was ended by
then acupressure stimulation might reduce Qi affirmation relaxation. Affirmation relaxation is a
(Schlaeger et al., 2017). combination of breathing relaxation and positive
Viewed from the western medicine affirmation. Breathing relaxation in this study was
perspective, stimulation of acupressure will be the form of diaphragm breathing. Diaphragm
transmitted to spinal cord and brain through breathing can cause physiological response such
nerve axon. Synapsis will result until signal as reduced consumption of oxygen, lowering
stimulus reaches the brain. Activation of the heart rate and blood pressure, increasing
central nervous system (CNS) causes the change amplitude of theta waves on EEG recording,
of neurotransmitter, hormone (including improving parasympathetic activity and creating
prolactin and oxytocin), body immune system, a condition which is full of energy (Varvogli &
biomechanics effect, and other biochemistry Darviri, 2014). Self-affirmation might also reduce
substances (endorphins, body immune cell such stress level. Respondents conducting self-
as cytokines). It is believed that it poses affirmation had lower epinephrine level than
normalization, modulation and balance effect those in control group. Affirmation was able to
(Sharp & Moriarty, 2013). reduce stress through sympathetic nervous
Psychological factor also influences the system activity (Sherman, Bunyan, Creswell, &
production of breast milk. The higher the Jaremka, 2009). Thus, acupressure and
psychological stressor, the lower stimulation of affirmation relaxation procedure used in this
prolactin and oxytocin hormone is given study might also help to create a calm condition
(Lawrence & Lawrence, 2016). The number of on breastfeeding mothers. In turn, we believe
research on the effectiveness of acupressure to that it will result in high production of breast milk
reduce psychological stressor on postpartum though we didn’t measure stress level of the
mothers is very limited. However, there was a respondents.
There was a significant difference in breast is p = 0.045 (table 4). There was a significant
milk production between the 1st day and the 7th statistical difference on breastfeeding self-
day postpartum for the two groups with p-value efficacy score for treatment group before and
of Wilcoxon tests was 0.002 for the treatment after treatment of acupressure and affirmation
group and p-value of 0.006 for the control relaxation with the result of Wilcoxon test
group. On the first day postpartum, breast milk showed that p = 0.008 (table 5). For the control
production is still influenced by progesterone group, there was also improvement of
and estrogen hormone. Progesterone and breastfeeding self-efficacy score on the 7th day.
estrogen have antagonist action on the However, the result of paired t-test showed p-
activation of prolactin secretions. The second value of 0.586 and confidence interval (CI) of
stage of lactogenesis is started on the second 95% between (-3,170) – 5,337. Therefore, the
day or the third day postpartum along with the increase of breastfeeding self-efficacy on
reduction of progesterone and estrogen control group was not significant. The
hormone. On that stage, the production of improvement of breastfeeding self-efficacy for
breast milk is excessive (Lawrence & Lawrence, control group might be influenced by other
2016). The production of breast milk for the factors that cannot be controlled in this study.
control group in the 7th day was a physiological Breastfeeding self-efficacy is influenced by
hormonal activity on lactogenesis. 4 factors namely 1) Previous breastfeeding
experience, 2) Successful breastfeeding
Breastfeeding Self-efficacy on primiparous
experience of others, 3) Verbal persuasions such
mothers on the postpartum period
as verbal supports from influential persons, and
There was a significant statistical difference
4) Physiological and psychological condition
on breastfeeding self-efficacy for treatment and
such as anxiety, stress, depression, fatigue and
control group on the 7th day postpartum (after
pain (Brockway et al., 2017).
treatment) with the result of Mann Whitney test
Median IQR p
Treatment group (n=12) 66 41 – 70
0.045
Control group (n=12) 56 35 – 67
The strategy used to improve breastfeeding pressure, decreased heart rate, and warmth
self-efficacy is by improving physical state and through the dilation of blood vessels in the
reducing stress on breastfeeding mothers. A hands and feet. When physical relaxation is
mother who feels painful, fatigue, anxious or formed, there is a message to mind and
stress might reduce their breastfeeding self- emotions to relax and a circular process is
efficacy. It is not only influencing breastfeeding formed. Decreased hormone epinephrine and
self-efficacy but also breastfeeding process norepinephrine will reduce tension, thus
itself. Pain, anxiety, and stress may inhibit the creating psychological relaxation (Fitzpatrick,
release of oxytocin, reduce let-down reflex, and 2013).
reduced breast milk supply of postpartum Affirmations is a strong and positive
mothers (Brockway et al., 2017). statement giving crucial influence to strengthen
Acupressure may also reduce stress or self-confidence. Affirmations can help us change
depression through the central effect such as our perceptions and beliefs. If we believe an
releasing noradrenaline and serotonin and affirmation to be true, our perceptions
improving the release of beta-endorphin and selectively reinforce it because we change our
adrenocorticotropic (Sharp & Moriarty, 2013). self-talk. Our mind is constantly engaged in
There has been limited research on affirmation dialogue with ourselves; in fact, the person we
relaxation on breastfeeding self-efficacy of talk to the most in a day is the self. Positive
postpartum mothers. Yusuf et al. (2010) images and affirmations also reinforce those
evaluated the application of affirmation things that have meaning and value. They help
relaxation on self-efficacy of patients with us in our spiritual development because they
nasopharyngeal cancer. Based on the statistical move into the deep layers of the unconscious,
test, it was found that there was a change in self- become part of our myths, and influence our
efficacy of nasopharyngeal cancer patients daily lives. If our thoughts are hopeful and
before and after affirmation relaxation optimistic, our body responds with confidence,
intervention with p = 0.008. energy, and hope. If negative thoughts
At the inspiration of the abdominal/ dominate, however, our body responds with
diaphragmatic breathing, the lower ribs press tightness, uneasiness, and an increase in
downwards and push the diaphragm upward, breathing, blood pressure, and heart rate. In
increasing the abdominal pressure. It can addition, a person with a positive self-image has
increase oxygen levels in the blood and increase a good stress defense mechanism. Affirmations
vascularization to the vital organs such as brain also help us to identify what is true for us so that
and heart. In addition, those breathing can the truth can manifest itself in behavior and
stimulate pulmonary stretch receptors and then more options; clarify goals, take actions, and
stimulate signals to the spinal cord that provide conduct self-evaluations; assume more
information that there is an increase in responsibility for our actions, thoughts, beliefs,
vascularization. It causes decreased blood
and values; and envision a new way of being study were statistically significant. Further
(Dossey, Keegan, & Guzzetta, 2016). studies should consider a larger sample size.
Affirmation relaxation might create a
relaxed state of physical and emotional Conclusion
condition. Mother with relaxed condition (not This study proves that the combination of
feeling pain, anxious, and stress) will be able to acupressure and affirmation relaxation method
improve her breastfeeding self-efficacy is able to increase breast milk production and
(Brockway et al., 2017). Besides, positive mind breastfeeding self-efficacy of primiparous
and belief build through affirmation relaxation mothers on the postpartum period. The
will strengthen someone’s self-confidence. In combination of acupressure and affirmation
turns, it will create strong self-integrity to build relaxation is an alternative non-pharmacological
good self-efficacy (Dossey et al., 2016; Yusuf, A; method which is easy to do for postpartum
Suarilah, Ira; Rahmat, 2010). mother. Health practitioners may include this
Research conducted by Henshaw, Fried, method of caring postpartum mothers and they
Siskind, Newhouse, & Cooper (2015) proved that need to teach this method to the mothers so
high breastfeeding self-efficacy on primiparous that they are able to do it independently at
mothers on the postpartum period were related home.
to lower depression syndrome during 6 weeks
postpartum and the success of exclusive Acknowledgment
breastfeeding for 6 months. Mothers who were The researchers extend our great gratitude
able to maintain breastfeeding were able to to the Head and staff of Midwifery Postgraduate
handle problems and hindrance in baby feeding Program, University of Brawijaya; the Midwives
especially those of first breastfeeding. It is in line (Soemidyah, Yeni Sustrawati, Siti Nurcahyaningsih
with Bandura theory of self-efficacy that person and Sri Sulami); dr. Lenny Tandya, Sp.Ak; and Ade
with low self-efficacy tends to lose hope in facing Laressa, M.Psi., Psi.
problems in their life; meanwhile, person with
high self-efficacy tries their best to handle References
challenges in their life. Breastfeeding process Brockway, M., Benzels, K., & Hayden, A. (2017).
might be stressful for primiparous mother. Interventions to Improve Breastfeeding
However, with good breastfeeding self-efficacy, Self-Efficacy and Resultant Breastfeeding
there will be a lower risk of postpartum Rates: A Systematic Review and Meta-
depression (Henshaw et al., 2015). Building Analysis. Journal of Human Lactation,
breastfeeding self-efficacy of postpartum 00(0), 1–14.
mother is important to maintain postpartum
mother’s health. Therefore, it is important to Dinkes Kota Malang. (2014). Kota Malang Tahun
improve their self-efficacy by conducting 2014.
acupressure method and affirmation relaxation
method. Dossey, B. M., Keegan, L., & Guzzetta, C. E.
The study also had limitation that need to (2016). Holistic Nursing: A Handbook for
be acknowledged. In this study, the sample size Practice (Seventh Ed). Burlington: Jones &
was relatively small. We only took minimal Barlett Learning.
sample size. Small sample size might reduce the
Esfahani, Mitra Savabi; Soonghe, Shoreh
validity of this study, although the results of this
Berenji; Valiani, Mahboubeh; Ehsanpour,
S. (2015). Effect of acupressure on milk
Childbirth. In M. D. Avery (Ed.), Supporting Tseng, Y.-J. (2015). Efficacy of Stimulation at the
a Pgysiologic Approach to Pregnancy and Jing-Well Points of Meridians.
Childbirth. Iowa: Willey-Balckwell. International Journal of Nursing & Clinical
Practices, 2, 1–5.
Sherman, D. K., Bunyan, D. P., Creswell, J. D., &
Jaremka, L. M. (2009). Psychological Varvogli, L., & Darviri, C. (2014). That Reduce
Vulnerability and Stress: The Effects of Stress and Promote Health. Health Science
Self-Affirmation on Sympathetic Nervous Journal, 2, 74–89.
System Responses to Naturalistic
Stressors. Health Psychology, 28(5), 554– Victora, C. G., Bahl, R., Barros, A. J. D., França, G.
562. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0014663 V. A., Horton, S., Krasevec, J., … Richter, L.
(2016). Breastfeeding in the 21st century:
Siswantoyo; Aman, M. S. (2014). The Effects of Epidemiology, mechanisms, and lifelong
Breathing Exercise Toward IgG , Beta effect. The Lancet, 387(10017), 475–490.
Endorphin and Blood Glucose Secretion, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-
1(4), 27–32. 6736(15)01024-7
Suryani, E., & Astuti, KH, E, W. (2013). Pengaruh Yusuf, A; Suarilah, Ira; Rahmat, P. (2010).
Pijat Oksitosin Terhadap Produksi ASI Ibu Relaxation Affirmation Technique
Postpartum Di Bpm Wilayah Kabupaten Increases Self Efficacy of Patients with
Klaten. Jurnal Terpadu Ilmu Kesehatan, Nasopharingeal Cancer. Jurnal Ners, 5(1),
2(2), 41–155. 29–37.