Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Renewable Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/renene
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this study, the first and second law of thermodynamics are used to analyze the performance of a novel
Received 3 November 2008 absorption system for cooling and heating applications. The active component of the sorbent used in this
Accepted 19 January 2010 study is sodium thiocyanate (NaSCN). Ammonia (NH3) is chosen as sorptive. A mathematic model based
Available online xxx
on exergy analysis is introduced to analyze the system performance. Enthalpy, entropy, temperature,
mass flow rate and exergy loss of each component and the total exergy loss of the system are evaluated.
Keywords:
Furthermore, the coefficient of performance (COP) and exergetic efficiency of the absorption system for
Absorption
cooling and heating processes are calculated from the thermodynamic properties of the working fluids
Ammonia-sodium thiocyanate
Enthalpy under different operating conditions. The results show that the COP of cooling and heating increases with
Entropy the heat source temperature and decreases with the cooling water inlet temperature, but the system
Exergy exergetic efficiency does not show the same trends for both cooling and heating applications. The
simulation results can be used for the thermodynamic optimization of the current system.
Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction properties for the NH3–LiNO3, and NH3–NaSCN solutions have been
presented by Ferreira [7], while interesting energy performance
Nowadays, with the rapid technology development, advanced comparisons between NH3–H2O, NH3–LiNO3 and NH3–NaSCN
absorption cooling and heating systems have become an accepted absorption systems may be found in the works of Sun [8].
and sound alternative for cooling residential, light commercial and This paper differs from the other literature studies in that the
industrial applications. The air-cooled NH3–H2O and H2O–LiBr cycle second law based thermodynamic analysis is carried out to eval-
continue to offer many distinct advantages to this field. However, uate the thermodynamic performance of an NH3–NaSCN absorp-
both working fluid mixtures have some disadvantages that limit tion system. Second law analysis is based on the concept of exergy,
their applications. which can be defined as a measure of work potential or quality of
In our recent research, the sorbent used is a salt-mixture that has different forms of energy relative to environmental conditions
been developed by DY Refrigeration Inc. and has been used in the [9,10]. A number of researchers have conducted various analyses for
ice-maker fishery industry [1]. The major active component of the refrigeration systems. A theoretical analysis was given by Bejan [11]
sorbent is sodium thiocyanate (NH3–NaSCN). Ammonia (NH3) is based on entropy generation minimization. Szargut et al. [9] pre-
used as sorptive [2]. The advantages provided by this system over sented energy and exergy balance of an NH3–H2O absorption
other absorption units include lower generator and evaporator refrigerator. Exergy analysis of an absorption LiBr–H2O refrigera-
temperatures, a higher coefficient of performance (COP). Compared tion cycle was carried out by Sencan et al. [12] and Talbi and Agnew
with NH3–H2O system, the NH3–NaSCN adsorption system doesn’t [13]. However, there is no academic work on exergy analysis for the
need the rectifier because there are only NH3 in the vapor phase and NH3-NaSCN system found in open literature. This study focuses on
the salt (NaSCN) doesn’t evaporate at all, that makes the system performing an exergy analysis on a NH3–NaSCN absorption system
simpler and cheaper. Among the first studies on an NH3–NaSCN at different operating conditions.
system are those of Blytas and Daniels [3] and Sargent and Beckman
[4]. Tyagi [5] and Aggarawal et al. [6] provided a review on ammonia- 2. Thermodynamic analysis
salts absorption refrigeration systems. Thermodynamic and physical
In this study, energy and mass balances are applied to each
component and combined with the state equations for the ther-
* Corresponding author. modynamic properties of the working fluids to provide with a set of
E-mail address: lzhu2@connect.carleton.ca (L. Zhu). equations to describe the system characteristics. In order to
0960-1481/$ – see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
determine the heat and mass transfer properties of the system, The relation between temperature and specific enthalpies of
each component is taken as a single unit, the balance equations of superheated vapor ammonia is given as:
mass, energy and exergy for the generator, condenser, evaporator ZT2
and absorber were calculated separately. hsuperheated ðT2 Þ ¼ hsaturated ðT1 Þ þ cp dT (12)
T1
2.1. Fluid properties where T1 is the saturated temperature corresponding to the pres-
sure of this superheated vapor ammonia, and hsaturated(T1) is the
The performance and efficiency of the absorption refrigeration corresponding enthalpy, T2 is temperature of the superheated
system are determined to a large degree by the properties of the vapor ammonia, hsuperheated(T2) is the corresponding enthalpy. Cp is
working fluids. In this analysis presented here, ammonia is the the specific heat and is given as:
refrigerant, and sodium thiocyanate is the absorbent, therefore the
thermodynamic properties for ammonia and ammonia/sodium 6
X
thiocyanate solution were studied. Except for entropy, the proper- Cp ¼ di ðT 273:15Þi (13)
ties of ammonia-sodium thiocyanate solution have been studied by i¼0
Ferreira [7], and the properties of vapor and liquid ammonia The above equations were collected by Zhu et al. [2] with source data
properties are provided by Sun [8]. taken from the properties of R-717 (ANHYDROUS AMMONIA)
The relation among saturation equilibrium pressure, concen- handbook presented by Industrial Refrigeration Consortium at
tration and temperature is given as: University of Wisconsin [15], and the coefficient di is listed in Table 1.
Unlike the above property values, for which the correlations are
B
ln P ¼ A þ (1) normally based on experimental data, the entropy of NH3–NaSCN
T solutions has not been studied before. The entropy data used in this
where paper are collected by the author based on the theory used by
Koehler et al. [16] and Aphornratana and Eames [17] for the entropy
A ¼ 15:7266 0:298628X (2) of LiBr–H2O solutions.
In order to simplify the entropy equations offered by the above
B ¼ 2548:65 2621:92ð1 XÞ3 (3) mentioned researchers, the pressure dependence of the entropy
may be neglected, thus the reference entropy is a function of the
The relation among temperature, concentration and enthalpy is solution concentration and the related temperature only. Based on
as follows: this assumption, at constant concentrations, the entropy of NH3–
NaSCN at 25 C is calculated as:
h ¼ A þ BðT 273:15Þ þ CðT 273:15Þ2 þDðT 273:15Þ3
(4) hsol gsol
S25 ¼ (14)
298:15
where
The Gibbs’ free energy of solution can be obtained as partial
A ¼ 79:72 1072X þ 1287:9X 2 295:67X 3 (5) molar quantities [18]:
X 1X
B ¼ 2:4081 2:2814X þ 7:9291X 2 3:5137X 3 (6) gsol ¼ m þ m (15)
MNH3 NH3 MNaSCN NaSCN
The chemical potential of ammonia and sodium thiocyanate
C ¼ 102 1:255X 4X 2 þ 3:06X 3 (7)
components in the solution are:
D ¼ 105 3:33X þ 10X 2 3:33X 3 (8)
mNH3 ¼ ðhv 298:15$Sv ÞNH3 (16)
within the ranges of pressure and temperature concerning refrig- mNaSCN3 ¼ 596:3R$lnðmNaSCN $gÞ þ 298:15K (17)
eration applications, the two phase equilibrium pressure and
temperature of the refrigerant ammonia are linked by the relation: where, K ¼ 0:1922kJ=kmol K. And the mean ionic activity coeffi-
cient g is obtained by Meissner’s method [19].
6
X The entropy of solution at the temperature T can be obtained from:
P ¼ 103 ai ðT 273:15Þi (9)
i¼0 R h i
St ¼ S25 X NaSCN logðX NaSCN $gÞ þ X NH3 log P=P * (18)
The specific enthalpies of saturated liquid and vapor ammonia Msol
are expressed in terms of temperature as follows:
6
X Table 1
hl ¼ bi ðT 273:15Þi (10) Coefficients of equations (9)–(11) and (13).
i¼0
i ai equation (9) bi equation (10) ci equation (11) di equation (13)
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
QG
QC
1
condenser generator
8 7
2
V1
9
Generator Absorber
V2 6 Exchanger (HEX)
3
10
4 Circulation
5
evaporator absorber pump
QE
QA
Fig. 1. The schematic of a single stage NH3-NaSCN absorption cycle.
2.2. System description and analysis The energy balance of each component based on the first law of
thermodynamic is:
Fig. 1 illustrates the main components of the system. High- X X X
pressure liquid refrigerant (2) from the condenser passes into the m_ i hi m_ o ho þ Qi Qo þ W ¼ 0 (21)
evaporator through an expansion valve V1 that reduces the pressure
of the refrigerant to the low pressure level as in the evaporator. The where m_ is the mass flow rate, X is the mass concentration of
liquid ammonia vaporizes in the evaporator by absorbing heat from ammonia in the solution, and h is the enthalpy of the working fluid.
the material being cooled and resulting low pressure vapor The system cooling and heating COP can be written as:
ammonia (4) passes to the absorber, where it is absorbed by the
strong solution (10) coming from the generator through the gener- QE m_ 4 ðh4 h3 Þ
COPcooling ¼ ¼ (22)
ator absorber exchanger (HEX), and form the weak solution (5). The QG _ 1 h1 þ m
m _ 8 h8 m
_ 7 h7
weak solution is pumped to the HEX and then the generator, and the
solution is boiled in the generator. The remaining solution (8) flows Q A þ QC m_ ðh h2 Þ þ m _ 10 h10 m
_ 4 h4 þ m _ 5 h5
COPheating ¼ ¼ 1 1
back to the absorber and the superheated vapor ammonia (1) passes QG _ _ _
m1 h1 þ m8 h8 m7 h7
into the condenser and liquefied to high-pressure liquid ammonia (23)
by releasing heat to the cooling material and, thus, completes the
cycle. The function of HEX is to improve system performance. The circulation ratio of the system can be defined as:
Based on the properties of the working solution pair, the
equations of mass and energy conservation are determined to _7
m
f ¼ (24)
describe the heat and mass transfer in every component. The _1
m
governing mass conservation equations for a steady state are:
X X The second law analysis can be used to calculate the system
_i
m _o ¼ 0
m (19) performance based on exergy. Exergy analysis is the combination of
the first and second laws of thermodynamics and is defined as the
X X maximum amount of work potential of a material or an energy
m_ i Xi m_ o Xo ¼ 0 (20)
stream, in relation to the surrounding environment [20,21].
Table 2
Absorption system data obtained from the thermodynamic analysis.
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Table 3
Energy transfer rates at the various components and performance parameters of the
system.
Performance parameters
Coefficient of performance for colling 0.5495
(COPcooling)
Coefficient of performance for heating 1.5495
(COPheating)
Circulation ratio (f) 7.9445
e ¼ ðh h0 Þ T0 ðs s0 Þ (25)
Fig. 2. Variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the system with the generator
where e is the exergy of the fluid at temperature T. The terms h and temperature for cooling application (TE ¼ 10 C, TC ¼ TA ¼ 25 C).
s are the enthalpy and entropy of the fluid respectively, ho and so are
the enthalpy and entropy of the fluid at environmental temperature
To. In this study, To was taken as 298.15 K. Based on above heat and mass balances, heat transfer equations
The exergy loss in each component and the total exergy loss for and the state equations for thermodynamic properties, a computer
the system are due to exergy destruction and heat transfer under simulation program was built to investigate the energy and exergy
temperature and unrestricted expansion and can be written as: analysis of the system. The initial conditions used in this program
include the heating, cooling and chilled water inlet temperatures,
DE_ G ¼ m
_ 8 e8 m _ 1 e1 þ Q_ G ð1 T0 =TG Þ
_ 7 e7 m (26) mass flow rate and the heat exchanger efficiency. In order to
simplify the simulation process, the work input to the solution
DE_ A ¼ m
_ 4 e4 þ m _ 5 e5 Q_ A ð1 T0 =TA Þ
_ 10 e10 m (27) pump and the friction losses of the system are neglected.
DE_ C ¼ m _ 2 e2 Q_ C ð1 T0 =TC Þ
_ 1 e1 m (28) 3. Results and discussion
_ 4 ðe4 e3 Þ
m
ECOPcooling ¼ (32)
_ 1 e1 þ m
m _ 8 e8 m_ 7 e7
_ 1 ðe1 e2 Þ þ m
m _ 4 e4 þ m_ 10 e10 m
_ 5 e5
ECOPheating ¼ (33)
m_ 1 e1 þ m_ 8 e8 m_ 7 e7
Table 4
Exergy loss rates of the components.
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 6. Variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the system with evaporator
temperature for cooling application (TG ¼ 90 C, TC ¼ TA ¼ 25 C).
Fig. 4. Variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the system with the condenser
and absorber temperature for cooling application (TG ¼ 90 C, TE ¼ 10 C).
Fig. 5. Variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the system with the condenser Fig. 7. Variation of the exergy loss percentage of different components with generator
and absorber temperature for heating application (TG ¼ 90 C, TE ¼ 10 C). temperature (TE ¼ 10 C, TC ¼ TA ¼ 25 C).
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
generator temperature is lower than a certain value, a higher of exergy losses in order to increase the exergetic efficiency of the
generator temperature can produce more exergy loss, otherwise, system.
when the generator temperature is higher than that value, the Finally, the results of the energy and exergy analysis presented
generator temperature increase will cause the increase of the in this paper can be applied as a useful tool for evaluation and
absorber and condenser output temperatures, furthermore, the improvement of the absorption systems, it provides a simple and
exergy output from the condenser and absorber will increase. effective method to identify how losses at different devices are
Fig. 4 shows variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the interdependent and where a given design should be modified for
absorption with the condenser and absorber temperature for the best performance.
cooling applications. In this case, both COP and exergetic efficiency
decrease with the increase of the condenser and absorber Acknowledgements
temperature. The reason for this behavior is that, as the increase of
the condenser and absorber temperature, the system pressure in This study was supported by NSERC (Natural Sciences and
the generator part will increase, and as a result, less ammonia vapor Engineering Research Council, Canada), OCE (Ontario Centres of
will be released from the generator. At the same time, a lower Excellence) and Thermalfrost Inc. (Ottawa, Canada).
condenser and absorber temperature has a bigger potential to
crease cooling effect at the same flow rate.
Nomenclature
Fig. 5 shows variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the
absorption with the condenser and absorber temperature for heating
applications. This can be explained by the fact that, the condenser and
COP coefficient of performance
absorber temperature are decided by the cooling water temperature,
ECOP exergetic efficiency
and the cooling water with higher inlet temperature will produce
f circulation ratio
outlet water with higher temperature, and the water at a higher
X liquid phase concentration (kg NH3/kg solution)
temperature has a bigger potential to extract energy for heating
cp specific heat (kJ/kg K)
application. And because the higher cooling water temperature can
T temperature ( C)
decrease the mass fraction slightly, the effect of condenser and
h specific enthalpy (kJ/kg)
absorber temperature in COP and exergetic efficiency is small.
S specific entropy (kJ/kg K)
Fig. 6 shows variation of the COP and exergetic efficiency of the
P absolute pressure (k Pa)
absorption system with the evaporator temperature for cooling
Q heat transfer rate (kW)
applications. As it can be seen, the cooling COP increases when the
m_ mass flow rate (kg/s)
evaporator temperature increases. The reason is that a higher
h specific enthalpy (kJ/kg)
evaporator temperature will cause a higher absorbing pressure,
m molarity (mol/mol)
which will greatly increase the absorption efficiency of the strong
e specofoc exergy (kJ/kg)
solution. Unlike COP, the exergetic efficiency of the system
g Gibbs’ free energy (J/mol)
decreases with the increase of the evaporator temperature. It can
also be explained by the definition of the second law of thermo-
DE exergy loss rate (kW)
M molecular weight (kg/kmol)
dynamics that the lower evaporator temperature has a bigger
R universal gas constant (kJ/kmol K)
potential to create cooling effect.
Fig. 7 shows variation of the exergy loss percentage of different
components versus different generator temperatures. It is shown
that the exergy losses of the generator and condenser are major Greek letters
fractions of the total exergy loss in the system. The sum of the non- m chemical potential (kJ/kmol)
dimensional exergy losses of these two components is about 80%, 3 heat exchanger effectiveness (%)
which is remarkably a high value. The values of the exergy loss for g mean ionic activity coefficient
the evaporator and HEX remain approximately stable. When the
generator temperature increase, the non-dimensional exergy losses
of the condenser and absorber will increase gradually, while the Subscripts
corresponding exergy value of the generator will decrease A absorber
remarkably. Therefore, in order to decrease the total exergy loss of C condenser
the system, the condenser, generator and absorber should be E evaporator
regarded as system components that need improvement. G generator
i inlet stream
4. Conclusion o outlet stream
v vapor ammonia
In this paper, the first and the second law of thermodynamics l liquid ammonia
are applied to a single stage NH3–NaSCN absorption system for
cooling and heating applications, the performance analysis and
References
exergy loss of each component are calculated. Results shows that
the system cooling and heating COP increase with increasing [1] Wang SG, Wang RZ. Recent development of refrigeration technology in fishing
generator and evaporator temperatures, but decrease with vessels. Renewable Energy 2005;30:589–600.
[2] Zhu LH, Wang SJ, Gu JJ. Performance investigation of a thermal-driven refrig-
increasing condenser and absorber temperatures. But the first law
eration system. International Journal of Energy Research 2008;32:939–49.
based thermal analysis is not adequate. In cretain operating [3] Blytas GC, Daniels F. Concentrated solutions of NaSCN in liquid ammonia: solu-
conditions, while the COP increases, the efficiency of the second bility, density, vapor pressure, viscosity, thermal conductance, heat of solution,
law of thermodynamics may decrease, the reason is that more and heat capacity. Journal of the American Chemical Society 1962;84:1075–83.
[4] Sargent SL, Beckman WA. Theoretical performance of an ammonia–sodium
exergy loss occurs in some components of the system. In these thiocyanate intermittent absorption refrigeration cycle. Solar Energy
cases, attention can be focused on such components that have high 1968;12:137–46.
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022
ARTICLE IN PRESS
[5] Tyagi KP. Ammonia-salts vapor absorption refrigeration systems. Heat [13] Talbi MM, Agnew B. Exergy analysis: an absorption refrigerator using lithium
Recovery Systems and CHP 1984;4:427–31. bromide and water as working fluids. Applied Thermal Engineering
[6] Aggarawal MK, Aggarawal RS, Sastry YVSR. Solid absorbents for solar-powered 2000;20:619–30.
refrigeration systems. Energy 1985;34:423–6. [14] ASHRAE Handbook. fundamentals, Atlanta, GA; 1993.p. 1745–81.
[7] Ferreira CAInfante. Thermodynamic and physical property data equations for [15] Properties of R-717 (anhydrous ammonia). Industrial refrigeration consortium,
ammonia–lithium nitrate and ammonia–sodium thiocyanate solutions. Solar University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, U.S.A.
Energy 1984;32:231–6. [16] Koehler WJ, Ibele WE, Soltes J, Winter ER. Entropy values of aqueous solution of
[8] Sun DW. Comparison of the performances of NH3–H2O; NH3–LiNO3 and NH3– lithium bromide and approximation equation. ASHRAE Transcations
NaSCN absorption refrigeration systems. Energy Conversion and Management 1987;93:2379–87.
1998;39:357–68. [17] Aphornratana S, Eames IW. Thermodynamic analysis of absorption refrigera-
[9] Szargut J, Morris DR, Steward FR. Exergy analysis of thermal, chemical and tion cycles using the second law of thermodynamics method. International
metallurgical processes. New York: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation; Journal of Refrigeration 1995;18:244–52.
1988. [18] Anand DK, Kumar B. Absorption machine irreversibility using new entropy
[10] Kotas TJ. The exergy method of thermal plant analysis. Florida: Krieger calculations. Solar Energy 1987;39:243–56.
Publishing Company; 1995. [19] Zemaitis JF, Clark DM, Rafal M, Scrivner NC. Handbook of aqueous electrolyte
[11] Bejan A. Advanced engineering thermodynamics. New York: Wiley; 1988. thermodynamics. New Yark: American Institute of Chemical Engineers; 1986.
[12] Sencan A, Yakut KA, Kalogirou SA. Exergy analysis of lithium bromide/water [20] ASHRAE Handbook. fundamentals. Atlanta, GA; 1997.
absorption system. Renewable Energy 2005;30:645–57. [21] Sozen A. Effect of heat exchangers on performance of absorption refrigeration
systems. Energy Conversion Management 2001;42:1699–716.
Please cite this article in press as: Zhu L, Gu J, Second law-based thermodynamic analysis of ammonia/sodium thiocyanate absorption system,
Renewable Energy (2010), doi:10.1016/j.renene.2010.01.022