Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VALUE:
The McDonald's Way
1
You walk into a McDonald's fast-food outlet the physical logistics company, cording to need. Need more lettuce than ice-
with your six-year-old kid. As you reach the Radhakrishna Foods Ltd (RKFL), which cream one day? No problem. The com-
counter, you place an order for two veg ships everything everywhere. partment with the relevant temperature can
burgers, pay for it, collect your burger-laden Some products (like lettuce) have more than be expanded to take in more lettuce. This
tray and pull away to find a place to park one supplier due to the fact that it can be flexibility is key to costs in a situation where
yourself while you munch your burgers. Your grown only in some seasons in some areas, some perishables like tomatoes have to be
kid is all vim and gusto, enjoying his burger while the demand is all-year-round. But the dispatched daily while products such as
with lots of sauce. You are happy that the usual norm is to have as few suppliers as cheese and buns need replenishing every
stuff didn't cost all that much. Just Rs. 76 for possible. The logic: when you want the two to three days, depending on demand
the two burgers. All served in the most burger in Delhi to taste and feel the same as and shelf-life.
hygienic packaging, and fast. You wonder From farm to
how they do it. factory to fast-
How does McDonald's deliver consistent quality at
The old saying food in your
about retailing affordable prices in India? Underlying its success tray, the
success mentions is a massive investment in the supply chain. From McDonald's
three golden rule-
farm to processing centre to food-stall, it has built supply chain
Location, location, appears well-
location. In
one of the most cost-efficient chains. oiled today,
McDonald's copybook you can add three the one served in Chennai, having too many but it took several years to achieve this. "It
more ingredients; supply chain, supply chain suppliers is a luxury McDonald's cannot wasn't an easy job," says Amit Jatia, the
and supply chain. A super-efficient supply afford. affable managing director of Hardcastle
chain is what lies behind its ability to deliver The McDonald’s chain, invisible for the most Restaurants, one of he two franchisees of
high customer value at purse-friendly prices. part, inf orms you of its existence only when McDonald's India. The other one is
Let's start with the Rs. 38 veg-burger- which it moves. At 8 o'clock every night, a score- Connaught Plaza Restaurants in the north,
your local restaurant can dish out just as and-odd white trucks carrying the run by Vikram Bakshi. The supply chain,
well, though maybe with a lower level of Radhakrishna Foodland banner move out of though, is common to both operations.
quality consistency. He will buy ingredients delivery bays from two distribution centers When one talks about retailing, the biggest
from different middlemen - the sauce, the just outside Mumbai and Delhi (Thane and element of cost that comes to mind is the
buns, the cheese and make the patty Noida, to be specific). From patties to real estate. McDonald's, which locates its
himself. He will change the middlemen if they cheese, ketchup to raw vegetables and ice- outlets only in the busiest places, no doubt
charge too high. At McDonald's, they do it cream mixes, a range of wet and dry pays hefty premiums for its location. But
differently. Each ingredient that goes-into the ingredients and pre-frozen products are equally eye-popping is its investment in the
burger will usually have one or two suppliers dispatched in hi-tech multi-temperature vans supply chain: Rs. 400 crore since it opened
at best and those suppliers are expected to to warehouses and then onwards to specific the first outlet in 1996. Between now and
keep working at reducing costs through retail golden arch outlets - some 48 in all 2005, it plans to invest another Rs. 400 crore
improved efficiencies. You might think having across 10 towns at last count. - all to deliver food items that cost, on
a monopoly supplier is the right recipe for The efficiency of the chain is apparent from average, around Rs. 20-40 apiece. (Average
higher prices; but at McDonald's the idea is the thinking that went into these trucks. bills per customer: Rs 85).
to develop suppliers who grow big enough to When you have to transport around 500 But a Rs. 800-crore investment) in supply
generate economies of scale and lower tonnes per-month of varying quantities of chain and logistics does not look like overkill
prices while, of course, maintaining some 250 ingredients from 50-suppliers at if one juxtaposes it against the growth of
consistent quality. varying temperatures, you would have business projected in the near future.
Coming back to the burger, the buns for the needed a wider assortment of trucks than According to retail consultant KSA
western region come from Khopoli
(Maharashtra)-based Ras Foods, while
Cremica Agro Foods, a Punjab-based bis- McDonald's believes in having as few suppliers
cuit-maker, supplies it to the north. The as possible. Reason: by giving them volumes,
sauces come from its affiliated company,
they can cut costs faster.
Mrs Sector's Specialty Foods of Ludhiana,
RKFL currently has. But look inside the Technopak, the Rs 500 crore fast food
the cheese from Dynamix Dairy in Baramati,
trucks, and you know how they contribute to industry is likely to balloon 12-fold to Rs
the patty from Vista processed Foods at
lower McDonald's supply chain costs. Each 6,000 crore by 2005. And in fast-food the
Taloja, the iceberg lettuce from Trikaya
truck has three levels of variable differentiator is always the efficiency of the
Agriculture (the last three in Maharashtra).
refrigeration, and the size of each re- supply chain.
And tying the whole supply chain together is
frigerated compartment can be varied ac-
Consider this. McDonald's made its entry of intermediaries in the food chain. There vegetarian and non-veg curry pans intro-
around the same-time as fellow American was no way McDonald's could have suc- duced in April this year, Work began on
food giant Kentucky Fried Chicken. But eight ceeded in India if it had to take this as given. these two products two years ago. They
years later, Kentucky is still a non-starter. Says S.D. Saravanan, quality assurance were tested in two restaurants in Mumbai
McDonald has gone places -48 outlets so manager of McDonald's: "There is no way we and Delhi before going national, "it takes us
Far, with more coming. can pass on our costs to the consumer. So that long to gel the supply chain right. We
If reaching breakeven has taken all of seven what do we work out efficiencies in the launch a product only alter everything is in
years, you have the real estate prices to system to reduce costs," This meant helping place." says Jada. "Our strategy is to achieve
thank. Exclude real estate and overheads, farmers improve yields on the crop; helping best value by offering best quality while
and the supply chain delivers such as cost poultry farmers use better feed so that birds keeping prices reasonable. We keep our cost
efficiencies that margins are said to ' be are heavier. low by increasing efficiency and cutting
For McDonald's foray in India goes back always "partners", never just suppliers - not volumes from suppliers and force them to
further. Its supply chain work began almost only ensures that it gets products as per upgrade their systems and processes to
four years before it started its first outlet in specifications, but also gives them minimize waste and speed up production.
1996. This meant not only identifying farmers opportunities to upgrade their services and For the farmer, a better yield means less
for each of its ingredients, but also hand- enlarge their business portfolio. 'The single- rejections and better price realization. And
holding them-to churn out products as per vendor concept has all the advantages of with increasing volumes, a supplier can
McDonald's specifications. The iceberg increasing volumes for suppliers." says extend his business beyond McDonald's, "it
lettuce, for example, has to be of a certain Sundar Srinivasan, country purchasing is a two-way thing. Both McDonald's and its
weight; the peas have to be of a certain manager for McDonald's. suppliers benefit through improved
It also meant putting in place a cold storage dedicated assembly line, also churns out Punjab, has tied up with one of McDonald's
chain, and cooking up a menu where mutton cheese singles for biscuit-maker Britannia British suppliers. It is now a major supplier of
stood in for the traditional beef patty - a strict that are marketed under the brand name buns and batter to the fast food chain and
no-no in the land of the sacred cow. Besides, Milkman. Trikaya Agriculture is now one of other companies.
the fast-food giant had to cobble up other the largest providers of iceberg lettuce to A look at McDonald's supply chain is an
India-specific concoctions Like McAloo Tikki. McDonald’s. And "Vista Processed Foods, amazing peep into how well the fast-food
And then there was the question of getting its which processes a range of frozen chicken giant has worked out the nitty-gritty’s of its
pricing right. In India, typically one third of the and vegetable foods at its state-of-the-art products right down to the basic ingredient.
150- million-tonne production of fruits and plant at Taloja, now supplies not only to local While it would be impossible to look at all the
vegetables is lost at the post-harvest stage - McDonald's outlets, but additionally to some 250 ingredients that go into making
most of it attributed to wastage in storage in the Middle East and a host of hospitality McDonald's Indian offerings, we zeroed in on
and transportation, mishandling and the cost companies. Even Mrs. Beetor's Specialty five products which account for 80 percent of
Foods, which supplies sauces to McDonald's McDonald's ingredient costs. These include
India, is considering enlarging its business to the patty, iceberg lettuce, buns, potatoes and
encompass a range of condiments and cheese. While patty tops the value chart, the
sauces. buns and ice-cream mixes account for the
warehousing, transportation and retailing of Just how do these products reach the
products under controlled temperatures. consumer? The daily logistics exercise for
Thai's where the cold-chain distribution each of the products is similar. From farm to
network comes in. As the ingredients move processing centre to distribution centre to
from farms to processing plants to retail outlet. Here's how McDonald's has
restaurants. McDonald's Quality Inspection added value to key suppliers in its supply
Programme carries out quality checks at over chain.
20 different points in the cold chain.
handling, the head, which is cut at the base, sanitation measures, have also increased the
is placed directly onto a tray which goes to shelf-life of the shredded iceberg lettuce at
the refrigerated room. It's stored there till the retail outlets. From the earlier three days, it is
morning, when it is sent, to the processing six days now. But it isn't that McDonald's
That's where McDonald's pitched in with plant. The lettuce is harvested everyday at picks up the same quantity. With the
advice. To avoid calamities, McDonald's 6am, packaged and maintained at a tem- constant launch of new products, projections
suggested that the lettuce seeds (purchased perature of two degrees centigrade in the are made six months in advance. So Trikaya
from McDonald's, which imports them) be cooler. It is transported by a truck in a monitors its iceberg lettuce accordingly. The
planted on raised beds or moved to two other compartment maintained at four degrees surplus is sold in the local market for which it
non-flood prone locations eight km and 40 gets a better price - Rs 30 to Rs 100 a kg.
McDonald's, on the other hand, is able to it is rejected. Why? There is every chance it a minimum. After every batch of patties, a
leverage the economies of scale to buy might pop out of the patty, which has a quality assurance expert fries a patty to test it
cheap. specified diameter, and get burnt. for color, appearance, internal texture and
Vista constantly works with its farmers to flavor. If it passes muster on all the above
VISTA PROCESSED FOODS obtain the right crop. Over the years, the parameters, it is ready to be sent to the
Let's now enter the industrial hub of Taloja suppliers who have been investing h cold distribution centre. If it falls short on even
on the outskirts of Mumbai, into the 2,000 sq storage plants send frozen produce to Vista. one of the parameters, the entire batch is
meter plot of Vista Processed Foods. Vista is It maintains a pea stock of one month in its rejected. By constant trial and error,
an equal partnership company between US- cold storage. The supplies are replenished rejections are down from the earlier eight to
based industries-(a food outfit with global by the farmer every month. "Any supplier ten per cent to the current two per cent.
interests m meat, poultry and other value- who works with us becomes an exporter. It is Singh claims that the major issues are
added, Food-processing activities) and backward integration for him," says Singh. temperature related.
McDonald's. It sources the chicken and Or take cheese, which comes in both
Now, take a look at how the patty is frozen. A
vegetable range for western India shredded form and as singles. While the
food expert mixes the vegetables as per
consumption from Vista. Processing food in singles go directly to McDonald's two dis-
McDonald's recipe. It is then mixed with rice
the north is Radhakrishna Foodland, which tribution centers, the shredded cheese
as the binding agent. Once -this mix is fed
also doubles up as a distribution centre. comes to Vista to be used in a range of con-
into the automated ma chine, it goes -
McDonald's strategy for its suppliers has through the motions of being dipped in batter coctions. While Modern Dairy and Amul
been simple. Once it identifies suppliers, it and then rolled in bread crumbs and fried provide the paneer, the cheese is made by
encourages them to work with its foreign and frozen - all this in exactly half an hour. Dynamix. Just how McDonald's nurtures its
partners to gain technical know-how. Over The final outcome is a frozen and packaged suppliers is evident in the Fact that Dynamix
the years, having acquired the wherewithal to patty which then has a shelf-life of one year. has set up a separate line for its fast-food
supply raw materials or products to It is maintained at -18 degrees centigrade. client. For Britannia, every cheese single
McDonald's Indian specifications, the local rolls out independently and is packaged at
Or take the chicken, which is widely used for
supplier has either gone it alone or has been the automated plant. For McDonald's,
the Chicken McGrill. It has been developed
bought over by the foreign counterpart. Dynamix produces sheets of cheese which
by Suguna Poultry of Coimbatore, which
are then cut into eight slices each. Says
Vista began as a joint venture between OSI provides the frozen deboned meat to Vista.
Saravanan, "In an efficient supply chain, you
and an Indian partner- Kitran Foods. The In fact, by the time the meal comes to Vista,
have to keep innovating. We will ensure that
latter opted out when it changed its business it has traveled quite a bit. The eggs are laid
our supplier makes money but not that much
focus. That's when McDonald's stepped in. in Bangalore. The hatching and contract
that he puts all costs on us. It has to be
Today, Vista, with its state-of-the-art plant, farming is done out of Pune. The bird is
activity-based costs."
provides 20-30 per cent of McDonald's total processed in Pune before it is deboned and
purchase of processed food. It also supplies sent to Vista. 'The egg hatching to bird killing
to oilier institutions like hotels, restaurants
MCCAIN FOODS
cycle takes 45 days and another five more
and hospitals. As part of Vista's quality Growing the right kind of potato for its French
days for processing," says Singh. Vista picks
control drill, no outside edible stuff-is fries has been a troublesome learning
up 70,000 birds a month from Suguna, which
permitted on its premises. It does about Rs experience for McDonald's. One of its
is 20 percent of its output.
400 crore of farm products, reveals CEO suppliers, Lamb Weston, invested heavily in
By improving the quality of the feed, Vista is
Bhupinder Singh, an ex-Nestle manager. It setting up production lines to process Indian
able to improve the weight of the bird.
deals with 45 suppliers for the 12 products it potatoes in the early nineties. But with the
Earlier, a bird's weight would vary between
supplies to McDonald's, ranging from frozen quality of the potato crop not up to Mc-
1.4 kg and 1.6 kg. Today, it ranges from 1.9
peas and assorted vegetables for the Donald's specifications, the project had to be
kg to 2.1 kg. Now what happens if pests
vegetable patties to procuring the right abandoned. Now, McDonald is partnering
attack the feed crop and destroy the birds?
quality of birds for the chicken patty. with its main global supplier, McCain Foods,
Are chicken patties discontinued at
the world's largest French fries company.
The loquacious Singh may be a food- McDonald's? Far from it. McDonald's has an
Together, they help Indian farmers grow the
processor, but his knowledge of farming and equally efficient backup plan in place for
right kind of potatoes. According to
supply chain intricacies could have even the assured supply. It has a host of suppliers on
Saravanan, who is an agricultural expert, the
most experienced farmer and restaurateur a standby if the assigned consignment fails to
Indian potato wasn't as good as farmers
complex. Quite aware that the country is deliver on different parameters. While the
used seeds from the preceding crop. As a
weak on post-harvest measures, he ensures vegetarian products are made every day, the
result, not only did it have only one variety of
that the farm harvest reaches his factory in chicken range, which has a separate but
the crop, but the quality was poor.
24 hours. identical line, is made five to six times a
The McDonald's specifications were clear
Take peas, for example. McDonald's accepts month. If Vista has to contain costs, then it
and unbending: a certain length, high solid
only a certain size of pea. If it is too big, then has to constantly strive to keep rejections to
content and low moisture. "Indian potatoes
have 14-19 per cent solid matter compared the processed food to its distribution centers, In terms of sales, the chilled and frozen
to the global standard of IS-26 per cent," where it is warehoused. From warehouses, supplies constitute 65 percent, says Sanjay
says Saravanan. So McCain, a leader in RKFL also takes the products to McDonald's Ghone, general manager of RKFLs DC near
agronomy, zeroed in on Deesa and Kheda, various outlets littered across the country, a Mumbai. "With the increasing number of
two Gujarat towns. It has been helping job which was earlier done by Cyrus restaurants, constant education and learning
farmers in these places with hotter agronomy Guzder's logistics company AFL. has made a difference. The relationship
techniques, including irrigation, sowing seed How did R KFL do all of this? Like the others, between McDonald's and us is that of a
treatment, planting methods, fertilizer RKFL too was in sync with McDonald's carrying and forwarding agent," he adds.
application and storage. strategy of helping its partners grow. It A critical factor has also been truck
Saravanan says the crop is improving. introduced RKFL to Australia's F J Walker to utilization. RKFL has invested in 24 multi-
McDonald's now sources the Indian potato develop the distribution system. In fact, temperature trucks which offer three different
from Gujarat for its wedges, which now claim Shete once admitted-that his group's growth temperatures - ambient, chilled and frozen.
21 percent solid content. He claims that it will was closely linked to McDonald's. RKFL This has no doubt saved on transportation
take a good three to four yean before the created better facilities, infrastructure and time and helped RKFL reschedule deliveries
right quality of potatoes (with 24 per cent new systems to satisfy McDonald's based on orders from various outlets. Earlier,
solid content) are grown for French fries. demands. transportation productivity was six 1(5 seven
"We are slowly getting better” he says. Consider the priorities of the distribution cases per man-hour. This has gone up to 16-
Meanwhile, the potatoes for French fries centre (DC). It is responsible for 17 cases. Moreover, every case was earlier
continue to be imported from New Zealand. procurement, quality inspection, storage, moved manually from the truck to the
Industry sources say McDonald buys around inventory management, deliveries to restaurant. Today, trolleys transport four
350 tonnes of potato for wedges every year restaurants and data collection, recording cases at a time. Even the boxes, which used
and imports around 1,200 to he placed haphazardly as in
tonnes for French fries. any godown, are well aligned
The help provided by McDonald's to
From the processor, the now.
RKFL's association with McDonald's began the DC had inventories of 35-36 days. Now, Once processed, all the products have a
well before the fast-food chain made an India with more sales and efficiencies, ii is down to minimum of 60 days’ shelf-life, except for the
entry. In 1993, having heard about their around 1.1 days. So much so that the buns, which have five days' and the lettuce
plans-to enter India, Raju Shete, head of the division has focused all its resources to meet three days.
RKHS group, visited the US-headquarters of McDonald's expectations of “cold, clean, on- There are also systems in place for tracking
McDonald's. This was largely for distribution time delivery”. The DC maintains nine to demand and supply. Every fortnight, RKFL
- picking up products from suppliers and 10'days1 worth of inventory - about 175 sends rolling projection to die suppliers for
bringing ii to the processing centers. Today, stock-keeping units. Dry goods account for the next three fortnights as every purchase
RKFL is the sole distributor of McDonald's. It 60 percent of inventory compared to 20 order is placed three weeks in advance. The
picks up raw materials from the suppliers and percent each of frozen and chilled stuff. This objective? 'To minimize the conversion of
sole distributor of McDonald's. It picks up raw includes both inbound (those picked up and raw materials into Finished products. This
materials from the suppliers and brings it to brought to the DC) and outbound (which are helps suppliers to control their inventory as
the processing centers. From there it takes taken from distribution centers to the outlets).
well" says Ghone. Adds Saravanan, "This is very important to our business."
A big hurdle here was the accurate forecast of product movement. Earlier it was tracked manually from each of the restaurants. Today, with
volume increasing, it is tracked through the product-mix. Outlets are able to gauge which are their best-sellers. "The distribution business works
on turnarounds of lock as fixed costs like storage are distributed over larger volumes," says Ghone. So RKFL has three turnarounds a month
compared to just one when it begun operations.
The use of multi-temperature trucks has reduced the number of daily deliveries to McDonald's outlets, which maintain an inventory of 2.5 to
three days' requirements. This is not all. McDonald's is constantly pushing its suppliers and DCs to bring costs down further. This means that the
suppliers have to continuously keep reinventing the way they do business to save time, speed up response and cut costs,
As a supplier says: "It is a win-win situation for both McDonald's and us. We cut costs and improve efficiencies, and the client stays with us
because we deliver. "Isn't that the best relationship possible?" Quite.
Suppliers
Trikaya Agriculture - Supplier of Iceberg Lettuce
Implementation of advanced agricultural practices has enabled Trikaya to successfully grow speciality crops like
iceberg lettuce, special herbs and many oriental vegetables. Farm infrastructure features:
A specialized nursery with a team of agricultural experts.
Drip and sprinkler irrigation in raised farm beds with fertiliser mixing plant.
Pre-cooling room and a large cold room for post harvest handling.
Refrigerated truck for transportation.
Source: http://www.mcdonaldsindia.com/aboutus/supplychain/suppliers.html