Professional Documents
Culture Documents
O U T L O O K M O N E Y. C O M
C VID-19
PARALYZED
ECONOMY?
Restructure your investments
amid gloomy economy with
reduced interest rates
8 904150 800027 04
Contents
April 2020 ■ Volume 19 ■ issue 4
pg
pg
10
10 pg
pg54
43
66My
52 MyPlan
Plan
COVID-19: How dedicated
Dedicated
discipline
SIPshelp
SIPs can
disciplineininyour
yourlife
canbring
lives
bringfinancial
financial
Volatile Markets
Investors need to diversify and Regulars : :6 6TalkTalkBack
Regulars Back
restructure portfolios to stay invested
and sail through these choppy waters Columns ::
Columns
AjayBagga,
Ajay Bagga, SSNaren,
Naren,Farzana
FarzanaSuri
Suri
Cover Design:
Cover Design:Vinay
VinayDOMinic
Dominic
HeadOffice
Head OfficeAB-10,
AB-10,S.J.
S.J.Enclave,
Enclave,New
NewDelhi
Delhi110
110029;
029;Tel:
Tel:(011)
(011)71280400,
71280400,Fax:
Fax:(011)
(011)26191420 OtHerOffices
26191420OtHer OfficesBangalore:
Bangalore:(080)
(080)43715021
43715021
Kolkata:(033)
Kolkata: (033)46004506,
46004506,Fax:Fax:(033)
(033)46004506;
46004506;Chennai:
Chennai:(044)
(044)42615225,
42615225,42615224;
42615224;Fax:Fax:(044)
(044)42615095;
42615095;Mumbai:
Mumbai:(022)
(022)50990990,
50990990,
Printedand
Printed andpublished
publishedby byVinayak
VinayakAggarwal
Aggarwalon onbehalf
behalfofofOutlook
OutlookPublishing
Publishing(India)
(India)Pvt.
Pvt.Ltd.
Ltd.Editor:
Editor:Arindam
ArindamMukherjee.
Mukherjee.
Printedat
Printed atKalajyothi
KalajyothiProcess
ProcessPvt.
Pvt.Ltd.
Ltd.Sy.No.185,
Sy.No.185,Sai
SaiPruthvi
PruthviEnclave,
Enclave,Kondapur
Kondapur––500 500084,
084,R.R.Dist.
R.R.Dist.Telangana
Telanganaandandpublished
publishedfrom
fromAB-10
AB-10Safdarjung
SafdarjungEnclave,
Enclave,New
NewDelhi
Delhi110029
110029
ForSubscription
For Subscriptionqueries,
queries,please
pleasecall:
call:011-71280462,
011-71280462,71280400
71280400ororemail: yourhelpline@outlookmoney.com
email:yourhelpline@outlookmoney.com
Published
Publishedfor
forthe
themonth
monthofofMarch 2020; Release
April 2020; Releaseon
on11April
March 2020.
2020. Total
Total no.no.
of of pages
pages 7092
OutlookMoney
Outlook Moneydoes
doesnot
notaccept
acceptresponsibility
responsibilityforforany
anyinvestment
investmentdecision
decisiontaken
takenby
byreaders
readerson
onthe
thebasis
basisofofinformation
informationprovided
providedherein.
herein.
Theobjective
The objectiveisistotokeep
keepreaders
readersbetter
betterinformed
informedand
andhelp
helpthem
themdecide
decidefor
forthemselves.
themselves.
www.outlookmoney.com April2020
www.outlookmoney.com April 2020 Outlook
OutlookMoney
Money 33
Chapter One
Introducing IDFC FIRST Bank, a bank that always puts you first. It’s why we offer 7% interest p.a. with an assured
6% interest p.a. on our Savings Account. Open an account and get returns better than the prevailing banking industry
deposit rates, with access to your money at all times. So bank with us, and see what it’s like to always be first.
Rates are applicable for domestic, NRE and NRO Savings Accounts. Frequency of interest payout will continue to be on quarterly basis.
Open an IDFC FIRST Bank account NOW idfcfirstbank.com 1800 419 3332
Talk Back
Cash &
Courage
In CrIsIs Is
PrICeless
Long-term investors should buy into extreme bouts of volatility
By Yagnesh Kansara
T
he coronavirus outbreak is like a Coronavirus is a serious set-back to the
Lehman Brothers moment for the economy in the short-run and a death knell
corporate world but in a much larger to the financial sector in the long term if this
sense, particularly for the emerging and menace does not stop. Mainland China and
developing markets. The Lehman Brothers Hong Kong‘s experience is that corona can be
crisis was only limited to impacting the thwarted and controlled. However, it is to be
banking/ financial markets, associated with seen how this stops worldwide.
financial aspects of corporate with respect to India is relatively insulated given the
raising capital and capex. The crisis did not relatively weaker link to Asia’s supply chain.
have any impact on the general growth and Given that the incidence of coronavirus has
consumption cycle of India, China, South Asia been surprisingly low in India (probably
and West Asia. Furthermore, the crisis was aided by under-reporting but also helped by
limited only to the banking level and had not warm weather) and assuming that it does not
spread to the day-to-day functioning of most increase in the coming weeks.
companies. Rahul Singh, Chief Investment Officer
The stock markets, as measured by the (CIO) – Equities Tata MF, says, “We prefer to
benchmark indices, have fallen by around 25-30 analyse the impact of a global slowdown and
per cent this year, and for once this has been possible China linkages on the earnings of
in sync with global markets as a whole. This specific sectors instead of a broader impact
heightened volatility and the general risk-off on India’s economy as of now. China is a large
attitude in the global markets is due to the supplier of raw materials, components and
uncertainty and fear created by COVID-19 and intermediates for textiles, pharmaceuticals,
the unprecedented actions of the governments chemicals and consumer durables/electronics.
to contain it. Decline in Chinese export capacity will impact
weather friends and should come forward to and soaps with people stocking more than what
help all those borrowers who are in real stress they can consume. The resultant benefit of
owed to the corona-related problem and explore volume increase of stocking will be a temporary
how best the adjustments can be made with the phase. However, it will be followed by delayed
stressed account so that the economy revives.” buying because consumers will have enough
It is better to survive than to perish. goods stored unless things are perishable.
Regulators and the government have come Every buying decision or discretionary spend
forward with pragmatic solutions as is expected like travelling, property purchase, marriage
in a welfare state. Most importantly, the functions, entertainment or even buying
borrowers have to exhibit their integrity and of essentials is likely to be deferred. The
approach their friendly bankers with truth and far-reaching impact will be felt not only on
true statements. It is not the time when they consumption-led industries like garment,
adopt unfair tactics or try to hoodwink their travel, restaurants and entertainment but also
lenders, Gupta explains. deferment of routine corporate expansion plans
This time around India has already been in an economic ecosystem where all sectors are
grappling with problems in the financial inter-linked.
markets with big players like IL&FS, Yes Bank With financial markets going down and
and DHFL going down simultaneously. At such interest rates reduced, the ability and intention
a time, any disruption in the consumption cycle to borrow and take incremental risk will also
and supply chain would exert a definite impact be affected considerably. In a way, it denotes
on the economy. We are already observing an that the economy will shrink and prepare
overstocking of goods like foodstuff, sanitisers itself for structural changes, before it bounces
S
tock Market always look Last 3 decades of investing has
ahead and the long-term taught me four important things
smart investors are the ones which has been proven right time
who will put money to work and again:
at this juncture. We want our Respect Valuation: When market
investors to play smart by making valuation is very attractive, you
lumpsum investments into equity have to bet saying that the current
funds with 3-5 years view and be economic/ market situation will
part of the smart money movers. normalise. All equity market indices
are trading at rock bottom valuations
The reasons for the fall have even when compared to global
been three folds: financial crisis periods.
Corona Virus Impact and the Believe Market Fundamentals: India
effect on the economies are has the best demography and is
uncertain the fastest growing economy in the
Corona Virus medicine/vaccine world. Fundamentals don’t change
is not known to anyone overnight.
Economic slowdown around Watch Market Sentiments: You need
the world expected to reduce to bet against the market sentiments.
Crude Oil demand. Crude Oil, George Heber Joseph Look for Triggers: Look for upside/
demand & supply issues are downside triggers depending on the
not known and the impact it market valuations.
has on various economies Markets bottom out in midst of the scare and
market peaks in midst of optimism. At the thick
“ITI Mutual Fund would like to convey this message of the problems generally markets bottom out.
to all of you. So, cutting all noise and focusing on long term
With the headlines screaming in your face about the investing makes a lot of sense.
gravity of the current situation, we strongly believe Investing into bust and selling into booms is very
that you need to look beyond the headlines. important to make big returns. This is the learning
Invest with discipline, keep in long term perspective, from all great investors like Warren Buffett, Seth
remember your investment horizon and remain calm Klarman, Charlie Munger, Benjamin Graham etc.
in times of distress are the key to long-term investing
success. HAPPY INVESTING AND BE SAFE.”
We are confident that all our funds are well poised
to generate good risk adjusted returns in the long run. Few mistakes that investors should avoid: -
Don’t panic at the wrong time and redeem your
ITI Mutual Fund view, in the next 3-5 years: investments.
Equities stack up as the best asset class to invest and Don’t mix Risk and Volatility
generate long term returns. Don’t bet on the same sectors which have done very
Small Cap segment will generate maximum returns well for a long period pre-crisis.
followed by Mid-Caps and Large Caps. Don’t make decisions based on hearsay, rumours
Small Cap segment returns will beat large cap and baseless assumptions.
returns by a wide margin on a 1 year, 3 year and
5-year basis. This is the time to be rational, invest maximum you
An outstanding opportunity of this decade: When can according to your risk appetite, ride through the
fundamentals are strong and the market valuations volatile period and make money, so we all can together
are at lowest point in two decades this becomes a laugh at volatility next time when it comes. In few
very good investment opportunity. years you would be very happy with your decisions.
We can prepare ourselves in this situation for a
better tomorrow. Nobody knows the bottom of the
corona virus impact or bottom of the markets. The author is the CEO and CIO of ITI Mutual Fund
Cover Story
What is the impact of coronavirus on markets cent correction, then it can have a deeper impact. If
and how is it different from previous attacks the prolonged spread of virus continues and supply
of other viruses? chain continues to get affected for many more
Coronavirus contagion is such an event where you quarters, then it would lead to recession. It would led
don’t even know the magnitude of the problem and it to a slowdown in the global economy and that could
is difficult to quantify. Compared to earlier cases of last for 8-12 quarters (two to three years). If we are
different virus epidemics like Ebola, H!N!, Swine Flu able to control it in next two quarters, then in next
and others, in this case it has spread in the second (subsequent) two quarters, things will settle down and
largest economy of the world. China, which has the world will move on.
linkages, is contributing 20 per cent of the global GDP.
It’s contribution to the incremental world GDP is also Which are the sectors that will get impacted?
significant. So, if the world GDP is growing at 3.2 per Impact of coronavirus on certain sectors will be
cent, attribution to China growth is higher. Even if long lasting. For example, hospitality (includes
China grows at the rate of 5 per cent, with $13 trillion airlines, hotels, tour operators, taxi companies,
economy, their absolute growth is much higher than cruzeliners, casinos and others) and others will take
the growth of many other nations, because their base their own sweet time to recover. The impact will
is very large. Another important point is that, China lead to restriction on travel; be it by road or by air.
is an export-oriented economy, unlike India. China This will lead to drastic fall in demand for crude oil.
has supplies all over the world and that is where the Coronavirus is at the centre-stage of recent fall in
magnitude of the problem is more. crude prices.
has the worldwide spread of coronavirus how will automobile sector get affected?
worldwide affected global markets? We have seen changes in the human behaviour,
Since China has locked down many of its provinces change in preferences and that has its impact on
and the entire nation is under quarantine, the markets certain sectors like automobile. We have moved from
have reacted very sharply in last few sessions. Earlier, a possessive to share economy. People who use to buy
people could not understand magnitude of the second or third car are not doing so. So, even in High
problem. Till mid-February, people never anticipated, Networth Individual (HNI) segment, Mass-affluent
it would become such a big problem and that is why segment or if the husband-wife have one car, they
in last 19-20 sessions markets globally have corrected will not buy the second car. What I am saying is that
in the excess of 20 per cent. When markets correct 20 passenger cars will continue to attract demand but the
per cent or more then the question that arises is - is it number will come down. The demand for second car
a bull market correction or is it the beginning of the has got impacted. If your second car is driven only 20-
bear market? That is something no one knows at this 30 days in a year, then in that scenario, it is prudent to
stage. But it is one of the triggers that could lead to go for a rented car option, which is freely available and
recession at global level. It could lead to a significant an easy option.
slowdown in growth. But at this juncture, we don’t
have data points that could tell us that. We are in Were indian markets due for correction and they
dangerous zone, but at the same time, I would not found opportunity in the name of coronavirus?
raise red flags at this point of time. I have a disagreement that Indian markets were due
If the spread of the Virus gets prolonged to another for correction. It would be fair to say, markets were
two to three months and if we get another 10 odd per ahead of valuations. It is not true that markets were
O
n March 13, NSE Nifty saw a massive It is important to have a plan in place in case of
plunge hitting the 10 per cent lower a downturn. Further, investors should not let
circuit towards 85000 zones and short-term market movements impact their long-
marking a history for Indian bourses in twelve term investments especially in mutual funds.
years. Market participants are concerned over As an investor, one should not stop the
the kind of economic damage the pandemic ongoing Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) or
would lead to and would most likely weigh on Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) strategies as
the market for a while. Given the suddenness volatility is the best friend of such investment
of plunge, it is difficult to predict the impact strategies in the long term. Discontinuing or
of COVID-19 or how soon normalcy would redeeming SIPs in a downturn is perhaps the
return. In the past with virus spreads like biggest mistake an equity investor can make. It
SARS, MERS, the economy and markets had defeats the very purpose of the SIP by denying
returned to normal within months. However, the investor an opportunity to accumulate
COVID-19’s global spread suggests the effect more when prices are low. “Volatility in markets
may take a while. is an ideal way to optimally use tools such as
“It is futile to predict market movements, but Systematic Investment Plans. SIPs are designed
in the near-term the global economic impact to increase unit purchase during weak market
will be really bad for various industries/ sectors. conditions and reduce unit purchase at elevated
Hospitality, travel, airlines, discretionary goods, levels. This reduces the cost of purchase (known
auto industry, you name it, will see a slowdown. as rupee cost averaging). Long term investors
As long as the fear is prevalent, markets will be must welcome such an opportunity to reduce
volatile,” says Neil Parikh, CEO, PPFAS Mutual the cost of acquisition of investments,” R.
Fund. Although markets might take a while Sivakumar, Head- Fixed Income, Axis AMC.
to recover from this significant price damage, The most important thing one can do, to
shield mutual funds from the downturn of the one cannot escape this inherent volatility. “One
current market, is to stick to the plan. As per of the reasons why the asset class has the higher
the experts, the current market has only made volatility but also delivers the higher return – for
investments more attractive, as the corrections instance, if one looks at a 5 to 10 year empirical
would provide great entry opportunities’. data in the Indian markets, equity as an asset
“Investors should consider staggering class delivers around 220-270 basis points (bps)
investments and continue to do systematic Compounded Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
investment plans (SIPs) and systematic transfer better returns than the next closest asset class
plans (STPs). SIP is a great way to commit (among the five most used asset classes in the
future cash-flows into the market while STP country like gold, property, fixed deposit and
is the most dispassionate way to stagger an 10 Year T-Bill proxy for fixed income, data as
otherwise lump sum investment amount. I of December 2019),” points out Chockalingam
think these two tools should be used effectively Narayanan, Head – Equities, BNP Paribas Asset
to ride the volatility and invest in the market,” Management.
explains Sandipan Roy, Head of Products for To ride this volatility, experts believe that
India, Credit Suisse Wealth Management. investing in funds that give diversification,
To start with the first step to successful especially a geographical diversification can
investing is to outline the investment objective. add a cushion of safety in volatile times. “As
This helps investors shortlist the investment you diversify across countries, you avoid taking
instruments best suited for achieving their country-specific risk, which helps you reduce the
financial goal. Experts believe Investors should overall risk of the portfolio. It is hard to predict
take advantage of volatility in markets. “Investors which markets will perform/ underperform (or
must realise that in a goal-based investment with which country will be the most affected by the
a multi-year time horizon, market volatility is a virus). So having global diversification will help
friend. When investors make decisions based on ride through the uncertainty. Someone who is
market sentiments, then they are prone to higher extremely risk averse can park some funds in safe
amounts of losses. Hence a prudent approach havens like gold or FD’s,” says Parikh.
during such volatile times would be to stick Further asset allocation is also crucial.
to the overall asset allocation plan and avoid Many experts believe that investing in gold
investing in funds, which may not help investors can mitigate the risk against the uncertainty.
reach their financial goals,” says Nimesh “One should look at some allocation to gold as
Chandan – Head Investment Equities Canara this works best as a hedge against downside
Robeco Mutual Fund. on the long equity portfolio. Moreover, apart
An investor should note that capital from being a safe haven asset in times of
markets, particularly equity, that are prone to uncertainty, gold also has a historically strong
gyrations. It is due to the nature of the product correlation to the US Fed rate cuts and can work
the equity holders have access to the last stream to an investor’s advantage in case the rupee
of cashflows in any corporate. So, during the continues on a depreciation bias,” says Roy. In
downturn or upturn the market impacts the uncertain times like these it is good to build in
cashflows of any of the other stakeholders in some kind of protection against further market
the corporate value chain, the highest volatility downturn. Says Roopali Prabhu, Director-
is to the cashflows of equity holders. However, Head of investment products, Sanctum Wealth
Management, “Gold historically has acted as a
hedge against increased market volatility. Thus,
NEil pARikh, it makes sense to have a bit of investment in
CEO, PPFAS Mutual Fund gold. Recently, we further added to our gold
overweight position. Buying a protection like
a put can also be a good strategy but with rise
In the near-term the global in volatility the cost of puts has become very
economic impact will be expensive now.”
bad for various industries/ In times of economic uncertainty and
sectors heightened volatility, an investor should avoid
leveraged and poor-quality speculative bets.
H
investments is hit by volatility or financial advisor when it comes to
ave you been stressed over even loss of value in extreme case; charting one’s asset allocation.
the past few days over the the other parts of your investment
money you have invested may gain thereby balancing off the Asset Allocation helps
in equity markets? Or have you net impact on one’s portfolio. This withstand turbulent markets
been stuck in contemplation mode leads us to the next question…. When the equity market is in a tailspin,
when market was rallying and now and if most of one’s investment is
correcting? If yes, then its time to How to determine one’s in equity, then one would tend to get
remind yourself of two words that asset allocation? worried by the fall in portfolio value.
financial advisors often discuss — Asset allocation as a concept But, if the same investment was a
Asset Allocation. Does it ring a bell? is simple but when it comes to healthy mix of equity, debt, gold and
After all why do financial advisors implementation it turns out to be cash, then only one portion of the
and other experts keep reminding us a not-so-simple process because investment would have been affected.
about asset allocation all the time? the implementation has to be On the other hand, the gains in other
Let us try to decode this. nuanced. A variety of factors asset classes would most likely provide
(one’s risk tolerance, investment the much needed cushion to the
What is asset allocation? vehicles, rebalancing), all comes into overall erosion in portfolio value. This
In simple terms, it is the age-old consideration when deciding on was in case of a market correction.
wisdom of not putting all the eggs asset allocation. Which asset class On the other hand if the market
in the same basket. The idea being, to choose, when to invest in them, rallies, by adhering to asset allocation
if something goes wrong with that what should be the proportion of one will not be tempted to invest
one basket, then one may end up exposure, etc… are all very personal beyond the designated equity level
losing all the eggs or atleast most of decisions to be taken when deciding planned for the portfolio. After all,
it. When the same idea is applied to on one’s asset allocation. no one knows if the same market will
financial planning and investments, One of the major determinants move in the opposite direction the
this translates to not investing your in asset allocation is being aware very next day! So, as investors what
entire investable amount in a single of one’s risk profile. A risk profile one should be most conscious about
asset class. This could be applicable is an indicator of how much risk when investing is the asset allocation
to any asset class - debt, equity, gold one can bear with respect to one’s one follows.
Aditya Birla Sun life liquid Fund Liquid 41465.99 0.41 6.31 6.83
uTi liquid Cash Fund - Regular plan Liquid 31148.23 0.41 6.23 6.81
kotak Standard Multicap Fund Regular plan Multi Cap 29459.53 -17.41 -8.33 4.51
Equity
iCiCi prudential Bluechip Fund Large Cap 23608.74 -18.06 -11.87 2.97
hDFC Mid-Cap Opportunities Fund Mid Cap 22754.65 -15.26 -11.82 0.56
Source: Value Research,Return as on 13th March 2020,AUM as on 29th Feb 2020
Also, generally in sharp corrections, mid and hence one cannot go overboard with long
and small caps bear the maximum brunt. So duration allocation now.” The current meltdown
far, the sell-off has been indiscriminate, but is more broad-based and hence impacts
as economic and Earnings Per Share (EPS) most stocks. Pharma companies that are not
impacts get analysed better, divergences are vertically and backwardly integrated and do
bound to occur. Experts believe it is better to not have their own captive Active Pharma
be in quality across caps. Also concentrated Ingredient (API) unit could be at risk, claim
thematic bets in cyclical sectors can be avoided experts. “Companies with significant exposure
for the time being. to China like certain Indian auto companies,
“We are aware that this sell-off so far has and commodity/ metal players could see some
largely been driven by foreign institutional dent. Consumer electronics manufacturers
investor sell-offs, but with infection spreading that rely on China for basic components are at
in India now as well, economic impact needs risk. Any funds, which have large allocations to
to be carefully monitored and hence it is best these sectors can be avoided for the time being,”
to avoid excessive risks now. On the fixed explains Rajesh Cheruvu, CIO, Validus Wealth.
income side, we would advise to steer clear of Investors should reassess their portfolios
aggressive credit funds,” says Roy, adding, “long and ensure allocations are in line with their
duration funds after initial rally may see some target and stay the course. It is important to
turbulence if fiscal stimulus measures kick in keep in mind not to panic in such times to
avoid any rash decisions. Investors should
stick to their asset allocation and tactically
rebalance from time to time. Further, investors
R SiVAkuMAR, should instill a certain discipline to save face
Head-Fixed Income, Axis AMC by multiple volatilities on income levels and
job certainty. Having said that, the outbreak
of COVID-19 is an unprecedented event. Till
Volatility is ideal to optimally there is a decline in the number of cases or
use tools like Systematic some progress in finding a cure, the market
Investment Plans could remain volatile.
himali@outlookindia.com
With COViD-19 leading to a gradual economic Can you list different types of mutual funds
slowdown, how should investors safeguard their that can add a cushion of safety right now?
mutual fund investments? Among all the myriad mutual funds available, asset
Coronavirus has been declared pandemic resulting allocation funds popularly known as BAF, that
in worldwide fear and global markets crashing. follow asset allocation based on a particular model,
Black Swan events are also becoming more frequent help in keeping emotions away in the investment
lately. Therefore, the best thing we can do is prepare process. These funds are more suitable for those
our portfolios accordingly. By using common sense who want to invest in equities, with caution. These
and good investment principles, one can safeguard funds manage equity levels between 30 per cent
portfolios from market volatility as much as possible. to 80 per cent that helps to handle the downside
Here are five tips that I learnt, during my first better. For the more conservative ones, Equity
Black Swan event in 2008. Savings Fund is a good choice. These funds manage
Cash is your friend. Keep some cash in your equity levels between 20 per cent to 40 per cent
portfolio that can be used, or invested to take and provide equity participation with very low
advantage of a crisis. Low risk equities like Balanced downside risk. Having such funds in your portfolio
Advantage Funds (BAF) are also good. Diversify helps in containing downside risks amid such
currency risk. The Indian rupee and emerging market volatile market phases.
currencies are vulnerable in Black Swan events.
Illiquidity is costly! This implies liquid assets What are the funds investors should avoid
become less liquid, and illiquid assets become capitalising right now?
extremely illiquid in a crisis. Always keep a watch on One should always invest in funds that suit one’s
your liquid assets and the liquidity of the underlying risk profile and avoid investing lump sum amounts
funds. Leverage should be limited; especially where and try timing the bottom. It is advisable to take
the underlying is risky. Appropriate advice is the the systematic to invest in pure equity funds. Funds
most important thing, which can help you during one should avoid are the ones, which do not suit
such times. It is often said that dealing with one’s your risk profile. For instance, if you are risk averse
own emotions is difficult, but with someone’s help, by nature or heading towards retirement, where
investors can make wise decisions, especially during an equity exposure, let us say, high-risk strategies
Black Swan events. like small-caps, can prove costly. Hence, for such
investors small funds can be avoided and a balanced
how long do you think it will take for global approach like investing in a BAF is efficient.
markets to bounce back?
The pandemic has brought instability to the global An investor’s course of action in times of
markets including the Indian stock markets, which COViD-19. Your advice.
is hitting new lows, not witnessed since the 2008 Well, the worst action you can take is to redeem and
financial crisis. Though it is extremely difficult to leave the markets; the best thing you can do is to
predict when the markets will attain normalcy, have the courage to invest strategically. It helps to
however, as far as India is concerned, I believe some ride the storm, not react.
of this panic is already priced in the market today. himali@outlookindia.com
By Vishav
I
t all started in China at the rise of the year
2020. A virus brought a whole nation to
standstill, and then began its spread towards
the rest of the world. Stock markets crashed. Fake
news and rumours spread. People panicked and
started hoarding essential goods, and then locking
themselves in their homes. It may all sound like the
plot of a blockbuster science-fiction Hollywood film,
but this is what the world has been going through
with the outbreak of the COVID-19 coronavirus - a
new virus whose cure and antidote are not known.
Towards the later half of March, the virus had
infected close to 2,50,000 people across the world
killing around 10,000. The second-biggest casualty,
after human life, in this epidemic is perhaps people’s
wealth, irrespective of which country they belong
to as stock markets crashed dropping as much as
30 per cent by the third week of March, erasing one
third of people’s wealth in the equity markets.
According to S&P Global, the total return in
euros from the S&P Europe Broad Market Index,
which tracks the share prices of more than 1,500
listed European companies, has fallen 33.3 per cent
since Jan. 1. The S&P BMI for the real estate sector
has fallen 38.4 per cent.
From the levels of close to 30,000, Dow Jones, a stock
market index that measures the stock performance of
30 large companies listed on stock exchanges in the
United States, dropped to the levels of 19,000. Japan’s
Nikkei 225 index nosedived to levels of 16,000 from the
highs of 24,000. UK’s FTSE 100 dropped 30 per cent
while Italy’s and France’s benchmark indices fell even
sharply by almost 40 per cent. In India, both NIFTY and
Sensex fell over 30 per cent.
According to former Finance Secretary Subhash
Chandra Garg, the largest turmoil post spread of
COVID-19 in Europe and North America is in the
stock markets.
“Most of these stock markets were at their life-
time peaks in January and February - even when
the virus was spreading its tentacles in China. For
last few days, the stock markets all over the World
(except in China) are in real mess and free fall. At
W
e are well aware of the idiom, what demand and growth, translate into lower
happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas. expected earnings growth for companies and
However, analysing the situation therefore lower expected returns from equities
we are in present times, this phrase has been in the near-to-medium term,” says Unmesh
completely subverted. What started off as Kulkarni, MD, Julius Baer India, a wealth
an infection in the city of Wuhan, China has advisory firm.
now spread its tentacles all over the world. This implies that your long-term financial
By last week of March, more than 6.25 lakh planning – be it securing a retired life or
individuals were affected and over 29,000 had financing your child’s higher education, is
succumbed to the deadly coronavirus. likely to be affected, with most of us seeing a
Needless to say, global economy has been significant erosion on our portfolios.
badly affected and India is no exception. Kulkarni feels this may become relevant
Markets have remained volatile and with to investors particularly if the damage to the
BSE Sensex witnessing some of the biggest economy is pronounced and it takes longer
falls in recent times. “With several countries for the demand and growth environment to
(including India) suspending human and revive. Accordingly, investors with meaningful
economic activities and ordering lockdowns, weightage to equities in their portfolio and
By Anagh Pal
W
ith over 30,000 dead and 6.6 lakh
infected with the COVID-19,
nobody is safe from the virus
anymore. India has been pretty successful in
containing the virus and the next fortnight or so
will be crucial.
“As we know that India no longer remains
immune to coronavirus and with the rising
number of confirmed and suspected cases,
the regulator has taken stringent steps to
ensure that claims related to coronavirus are
expeditiously handled,” says Prasun Sikdar, MD
& CEO, Manipal Cigna Health Insurance.
The first question that comes to our mind is -
If I am infected by the virus and need treatment,
will my existing health insurance cover me? cover you if you have visited any of the countries
“A health insurance policy covers all with high levels of infection after a government
infections and the novel coronavirus is one advisory against doing so.
such infection. Coverage will be available for all Batra suggests that under any such
indemnity products that offer hospitalisation circumstances, health insurance coverage
covers,” says Mayank Bathwal, CEO, Aditya Birla with an adequate cover is the key. The health
Health Insurance. insurance policy should also have wider cover.
Says Gurdeep Singh Batra, Head- Retail He advises that one should read the policy terms
Underwriting, Bajaj Allianz General Insurance, carefully before buying so that one does not end
“Your existing policy will protect you against up buying a cheap policy with a restricted cover.
coronavirus. Every insurance policy has a 30-day You should also opt for additional cover for
waiting period for any disease. For all those fresh expenses like OPD and so on.
policies that have exhausted the 30-day waiting Insurance companies are on the way to
period, every claim will be payable for coronavirus launch coronavirus specific policies. Star
under the policy. The regulator has already issued a Health and Allied Insurance has launched ‘Star
circular saying that all coronavirus cases have to be Novel Coronavirus Insurance Policy’, a benefit
attended to on priority.” policy to cover all those who test positive for
Agrees Sanjay Datta, Chief, Underwriting, the current pandemic COVID-19 and require
Claims and Reinsurance, ICICI Lombard GIC, hospitalisation. The Star Novel Coronavirus
“All group/corporate and retail health policies
will cover coronavirus related hospitalisation
expenses. Testing and other diagnostic related guRDEEp SiNgh BATRA,
medical expenses will be covered under the Head- Retail Underwriting, Bajaj Allianz
health policy if out-patient cover is opted. General Insurance
In case an instance leads to hospitalisation,
expense for such tests will be covered under
The regulator has said all
pre-post medical expenses.”
However, one needs to be hospitalised for at
coronavirus cases have to
least 24 hours to be covered under any health be attended to on priority
insurance policy. Also some policies may not
I
t has been declared a global health emergency WHO, many travel plans exclude losses incurred directly
and pandemic by the World Health Organization or indirectly arising due to corona.
and has already claimed thousands of lives since Having said that, if you are infected with the virus
being first reported. The coronavirus outbreak has sent during transit, then you can receive coverage. In
governments, people and markets into a tizzy. case you are travelling abroad, make sure to follow
With the virus spreading thick and fast across the government guidelines to ensure safety.
globe, insurers are being flooded with queries from With the increasing prevalence of the virus across
concerned policyholders as to whether their respective the globe, some insurers have decided against issuing
health and travel policies would cover them in case they policies in countries affected by the virus.
are diagnosed with this virus. If you too have a similar As there’s no specific treatment for coronavirus, it is
query, read on to find the answer. better to adopt precautionary measures to ensure safety.
Coronavirus is a family of viruses capable of causing a You must wash your hands with soap or sanitizer often,
range of illnesses in humans including the common cold, and avoid crowded places as much as possible.
with more severe forms being Severe Acute Respiratory It is also essential to cover your face with tissue or
Syndrome (SARS) and Middle East Respiratory handkerchief while sneezing and maintain at least a
Syndrome (MERS). If you are diagnosed with the virus distance of a metre from someone who is sneezing and
and need to undergo hospitalisation for treatment, your coughing. It is advisable to avoid touching eyes, nose and
health insurance policy in all probability would provide mouth, as there it increases chances of the virus being
coverage for the same. This will be basis the policy terms transmitted, and wear a mask while commuting.
and conditions of the health policy of the insured At the same time, it is better to restrict visits to
A disease like corona does not fall in the category relatives and friends who have recently travelled in
of pre-existing ailments, and therefore will be covered regions under the effects of COVID-19.
under the base plan. If you seek the treatment for this Given the gravity of the situation, it’s in your best
virus , your existing health plan will reimburse expenses interest to refrain from travelling to China and countries
incurred on treatment of the disease as per the policy’s being affected by the outbreak. Watch out for symptoms
terms and conditions. like fever, coughing, and shortness of breath and seek
The claims process is the same as in the case of any medical help at the earliest.
other ailment. You can either opt for reimbursement or Also, keep an eye on the updates issued by local
opt for a cashless method in a networked hospital by authorities and the government. Follow the advisory
your insurer. issued to mitigate the risk of getting infected.
This is a tricky aspect as whether your travel policy
would provide coverage for corona depends on the The author is the Chief - Claims, Underwriting and Reinsurance,
insurer. As it has been declared an epidemic by the ICICI Lombard General Insurance
policy will provide a lump sum payment to any As far as travel insurance is concerned, if one
insured between age 18 years to 65 years, who travels against a government advisory, as is the
is declared positive by a government-accredited case with most countries now, it is at your risk
test and is hospitalised for the coronavirus. and it is excluded from the policy. If you had
Importantly, the policy does not have any bought a travel insurance policy before such
international travel history related exclusions advisory had been issued, some policies will
ICICI Lombard has also launched a pay you the cancellation charges too. But if you
COVID-19 Protection Cover. The policy will pay still decide to travel due to some emergency,
100 per cent of sum insured on positive testing the policy will not pay anything related to the
for COVI-19. However, it has a 14-day waiting epidemic.
period with no overseas travel history. anagh.pal@outlookindia.com
L
ife is a constant cycle of learning and What is needed most, is to emphasise things that
transformation. We are in the first quarter of are missing most to get through this period. Have
2020 and the implications of the Universal patience, inner work, organization, altering beliefs and
number 4 (2+0+2+0 =4) are being felt. Number 4 resilience. Play by the rules. This is not the time to give
signifies reconstruction and re-evaluation of our vision. in to greed. Comply with the laws and regulations.
It encourages hard work, discipline, structure, realistic Even minor violations can negatively impact your
goals and the need for security in the wake of ensuing financial growth with hefty fines. Stay on top of your
obstacles. Add to it the wobble of the Leap Year, makes game. Be visible and act responsibly. Remember
the need for balance, all the more crucial. It is a pivotal financial security demands better moral sense and
year where materialism is being forced take a backseat. ethics. It is your family that remains your core strength.
This is a year of growth in the dimensions that need For the financial community, it is the time to heed
change. Changes are sudden to bring order in your life, the clarion call for balance. Re-calibrate and adjust
especially in the areas of finance and health. It induces your view of the world. Use the energy of the year
confinement, restrictions and hurdles. to build, cautiously with level-headed conservatism.
On a positive note, it reminds you of the strength It demands thorough research before you decide to
in going slow, exercising thrift and budgeting your invest. You may have to keep your spending down
excesses. It may get you involved in government-related to a minimum and avoid all but guaranteed (safe)
or collective projects, reworking both your business as investments, for now. Sectors in IT, medicine,
well as personal strategies. engineering, may see impetus.
The recent ‘awakening’ with the pandemic, is likely The confusion and chaos, is perhaps necessary for
to place things in perspective that you need to live your the growth of humanity and our personal evolution,
life in a different way. Perhaps be true to yourself and too. The challenge you face, may create new paths.
your needs. Open yourself up to new possibilities of Those who rise to stride towards it, will move ahead
leading a more fulfilling life. It guides you to transform, with greater ease. Release and surrender that which
transition and flourish. doesn’t support your progress. It’s time to work on a
new business idea and do things, differently. While, co-
operation and teamwork are the new way, it is also the
time to partner with ourselves.
Avoid unnecessary confrontations. Keep a lid on
your anger however, do not bottle up your emotions.
Make room for flexibility. Clinging to fixed beliefs
and ideas could be counterproductive. A good idea to
lean in to people who encourage and inspire you. Seek
professional help, if needed.
The next two quarters are challenging. The cloud
of uncertainty, is likely to clear up towards June
with August demanding more of you. In the period
between September and December, you may see some
semblance of ‘normalcy’.
Keep the hope alive, hold firm to the seed of peace
and shut off everything that causes you undue stress.
Be home. Stay safe. Pray for peace.
This, too shall pass.
34 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com www.outlookmoney.com April 2020 Outlook Money 57
Commodity Made Easy
Segments Climb
Consumer Electricals
x CMP: 214.15
x PE: 25.05
Working on commercialising the innovation pipeline *As on March 20, 2020
A
perfect blend of per cent rise in ECD and a small, return ratio and healthy prospects
premiumisation, innovation 86bp expansion in EBITDA margin n Increasing market share across all
and cost reduction has (on investments in advertising business segments
led Crompton Greaves Consumer and promotional and channel
Electricals (CGCE) post revenue expansion), says an analyst at Anand Watch out for
growth largely in-line with most Rathi Share and Stock Brokers. n Competitive market and weak
brokerage firms for the third The company is working summers might impact margins
quarter (Q3) results in FY2020. aggressively on the cost front, as
The company reported a revenue well as on commercialising the
growth of 4 per cent Year-on-Year innovation pipeline, by introducing
(Y-o-Y) at Rs 1,071.2 crore. CGCE a series of innovative products such 200
is into manufacturing of a wide as silent pro fans with a superior 143.58
range of consumer products that performance. The distribution has
include fans, lamps, household expanded in fans and B2C lighting. 150
appliances like water heaters, The management is stepping up
Base value taken as 100
36
34 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
Playing Along With
Domino’s Effect
Jubilant FoodWorks
x CMP: 1490
x PE: 57.64
Bringing more brands under one umbrella helps *As on March 20, 2020
D
espite facing intense Same Store Growth (SSG) was Why Buy
competition from 5.9 per cent Year-on-Year (Y-o-Y). n Strong revenue growth with retail
local players and The company attributes the strong expansion and launch of new
food aggregators, Jubilant performance to its delivery service, products
FoodWorks(JUBI), one of India’s which contributes to 87 per cent of n JUBI is improving SSGs and growing
largest food service companies has online sales. It recently launched faster than peers
gained market share over the last Masala Pizza alongwith a new
three quarters driven by its brand campaign - Dil, Dosti, Domino’s Watch out for
Domino’s. With concerns over range, which aided sales growth, n Impact on margins on account of
COvID-19, experts see a short-term during the quarter. “Healthy demand increase in raw material cost and
hiccup and suggest investors to environment, favorable base of 4 to competition from local players
focus on the long-term earnings and 6 per cent SSSG in next 4 quarters
market share position of JUBI. An and incrementally benign outlook on 250
analyst at Motilal Oswal Financial operating cost augur well for >25 per Note: Share quoting
ex-bonus from 173.44
Services points out that Jubilant cent earnings growth over the next June 21, 2018
FoodWorks dominates the Quick two years,” says an analyst at Motilal 200
Service Restaurant (QSR) pizza Oswal Financial Services.
Base value taken as 100
T
and believes that such money printing threatens the
he Supreme Court recently removed the ban global economy.
on dealing in cryptocurrencies imposed by What we consider an “asset” is someone else’s
the Reserve Bank of India. Bitcoin is the liability. This is true for bank deposits, government
most well-known, but there are many others such securities, corporate bonds, municipal bonds,
as Ethereum, Ripple. While it may now be legal, company shares – in short, all financial assets. It
investors must know the high degree of risk. applies to paper currency as well. It is the liability
Currencies have played an important part in the of the government which has issued it. The case
development of human society. Barter trade was of physical assets is different. If I own gold or
replaced by metal coins in gold, silver, copper and property it is not anyone’s liability and hence it
has no counterparty risk. Commodity money falls in
this category. Gold has been trusted by mankind for
Bitcoin is the most well-known,
thousands of years as a medium of exchange. but there are many others such
In today’s digital world, the concept of a digital as Ethereum, Ripple.
currency has emerged in the form of cryptocurrency.
It is based on a technology called Blockchain. This is a
While it may now be legal,
database system, which is like a transparent open ledger. investors must know the high
It has many other applications and is considered a safer degree of risk.
database technology. The first known cryptocurrency
– Bitcoin- was launched in January 2009. A reclusive
Japanese Mr Satoshi Nakamoto is believed to be the new hybrid model. It could become more acceptable
initiator of Bitcoin. The central feature is that the its by users, but could turn out to be a new weapon in the
supply is limited to a maximum number of 21 million currency wars. It could also mean more surveillance of
Bitcoins. The different transactions in the database are the users.
required to be reconciled and participants who work Two ingredients for a currency are limited supply
for this are rewarded in Bitcoins. This activity is called and wide acceptance, which historically, gold has
“mining”. Stacks of computers with graphic processing fulfilled. Initially limited supply for Bitcoin was also
units are today used in cryptocurrency mining. The believed, but today we have over 6,000 alternatives thus
degree of difficulty and cost of mining has been going undermining the limited supply.
up, as we approach the ceiling. Valuation of any asset is based on the stream of
The supporters of crypto currency also challenge future cashflows. In absence of cash flow, it cannot be
the sovereign authority for issuing and regulating. applied to currencies, including crypto. They will be
They also have no geographical limits and hence nearly “priced” based on their perceived value. If perception
impossible to regulate. There is also a darker side to changes, prices have no support. In the late 90’s, Dot
this aspect. The digital currencies are possibly used Com companies without a revenue model were priced
for terrorist funding, the underworld and demands for on “eyeballs”. Many lost 100% capital. We also cannot
ransom by hackers are made in crypto currency. The overlook that some of the most valuable companies
government authorities also find this an encroachment today are Dot Coms. Hence it will not be right to
on their sovereign right and would look at fighting the ridicule the digital currencies. Without knowing their
spread of digital currencies. Recently, there were news survival and valuation model, coupled with extreme
reports that the Chinese government was considering price volatility we should avoid crypto currencies as an
issuing its own crypto currency. This could become a “investment”.
Morningstar: Mutual Fund Guide
4.0 3.7
2.0
-0.3 -0.6 Fund Snapshot
0.0
YTD 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015
Morningstar Category India Fund
HDFC S/T Debt Gr India Fund Short Duration
Short Duration
Trailing Returns Fund Size (`) 122.2 billion
Data Point: Return Calculation Benchmark: None Inception Date 25/6/2010
Annual Report Net Expense Ratio 0.40
YTD 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years Morningstar Rating Overall *****
HDFC S/T Debt Gr -0.28 7.32 7.18 7.76 — Manager Name Multiple
Minimum Investment (`) 5,000
India Fund Short Duration -0.61 1.42 4.00 5.21 6.40
Morningstar Analyst Rating Silver
Disclaimer
@2017. All rights reserved. The Morningstar name and logo are registered marks of Morningstar, Inc. This report is issued by Morningstar Investment
Adviser India (“Morningstar”), which is registered with SEBI (Registration number INA000001357) and provides investment advice and research.
Please visit www.outlookindia.com/outlookmoney/invest/picking-the-right-mutual-fund-2542 and read important statutory disclosures, as
mandated by SEBI, regarding the information, data, analyses and opinions given in this report.
40
38 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
HDFC Small Cap Fund
Manager Biography And Fund Strategy
40
Procter & Gamble Health Ltd 2.24
20 6.4 7.7
-29.9 -28.7 -9.5 -5.9 -8.1 -22.9 5.4 2.7
00
-20 Fund Snapshot
YTD 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015
HDFC Small Cap Gr S&P BSE Smallcap TR ` Morningstar Category India Fund
Small-Cap
Trailing Returns
Fund Size (`) 92 billion
Data Point: Return Calculation Benchmark: S&P BSE Smallcap TR ` Inception Date 3/4/2008
Annual Report Net Expense Ratio 2.19
YTD 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years Morningstar Rating Overall ***
Manager Name Multiple
HDFC Small Cap Gr -29.91 -38.30 -5.97 0.79 6.99
Minimum Investment (`) 5,000
Morningstar Analyst Rating Silver
S&P BSE Smallcap TR ` -28.70 -33.70 -10.61 -1.68 2.60
Data Source: Morningstar India
since May 2011. Overall, the team has volatility targets. From a financial %
remained stable since 2016 and has standpoint, the team looks for Basic Materials 7.4
clearly outlined responsibilities. companies with low capital gearing Consumer Cyclical 13.2
Gopani looks for companies that and strong balance sheets. The fund
Financial Services 39.7
have the capability to grow over a house seeks to spend more time
three- to five-year period and places identifying fresh ideas and researching Real Estate 0.0
a lot of emphasis on finding quality companies that are not as widely Consumer Defensive 14.4
names at reasonable valuations. researched by the broader market. Healthcare 2.4
However, he can tend to invest in This results in a benchmark- Utilities 3.8
stocks that are slightly expensive in agnostic portfolio that typically Communication Services 7.3
relative terms as long as they meet shares a very low overlap of about Energy 0.0
his quality and growth criteria. The 25%-30% with the S&P BSE 200 Industrials 3.8
portfolio holds about 50%-70% Index. The AMC monitors the fund Technology 8.1
large-cap stocks, while small and size on a consistent basis and places Total 100.0
mid-caps constitute the remaining constraining limits on it, but this
portion. The focus is on being able to number can vary constantly based Portfolio
identify companies with sustainable on the growth and liquidity in the Top Holdings Weighting
earnings growth potential, credible markets. This, in addition to the (%)
management, and good corporate multicap nature of the fund, should Bajaj Finance Ltd 8.75
governance practices. Stock-picking help mitigate the risks of asset bloat. Avenue Supermarts Ltd 8.46
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd 8.45
HDFC Bank Ltd 6.35
Calendar Year Returns Tata Consultancy Services Ltd 6.17
Calculation Benchmark: S&P BSE 200 India TR ` Pidilite Industries Ltd 5.72
100 Info Edge (India) Ltd 5.08
80 Housing Development Finance Corp Ltd 4.90
60 Maruti Suzuki India Ltd 4.71
Return
40 37.4 35.0
Nestle India Ltd 4.53
20 14.8 10.4
2.7 0.8 -0.7 5.4 6.7
-23.0 -31.0 -0.2
0
-20
YTD 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015
Fund Snapshot
Axis Long Term Equity Gr S&P BSE 200 India TR ` Morningstar Category India Fund
ELSS (Tax Savings)
Fund Size (`) 217 billion
Trailing Returns
Inception Date 29/12/2009
Data Point: Return Calculation Benchmark: S&P BSE 200 India TR ` Annual Report Net Expense Ratio 2.13
YTD 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years Morningstar Rating Overall *****
Manager Name Jinesh Gopani
Axis Long Term Equity Gr -23.04 -12.52 3.59 3.71 13.46 Minimum Investment (`) 5,000
Morningstar Analyst Rating Bronze
S&P BSE 200 India TR ` -31.03 -27.29 -2.97 0.71 6.21
Data Source: Morningstar India
42
40 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
Interview
Rajat Mishra caught up with Prashant Kumar, the newly appointed MD and CEO of Yes Bank
who shared his roadmap and plans on the banks revival. Edited Excerpts:
Do you think the failure of financial institutions commercial bank lost any money and in the future
like PMC Bank and Yes Bank have largely eroded too this is not going to happen. According to me this
people’s trust in the Indian banking system? assurance was something very important and we have not
For a very long time, the customer was having a trust seen such assurances coming from the RBI in the past.
on Indian banking system, hoping the money was So, I think, this signifies that nobody needs to lose faith in
absolutely safe. So, when PMC crisis happened, which the system.
was a cooperative bank, there were some concerns.
Subsequently, the Yes Bank crisis happened, which is a After Yes Bank crisis unfolded do you see this
scheduled commercial bank. having a spill-over effect on other sectors and the
However, I think everybody has acted really fast economy at large?
during Yes Bank crisis. A revival plan has come out. What we are seeing is not happening only in the banking
Not only SBI - the largest public sector bank - but seven sector. Unfortunately, because of the coronavirus there
other private sector banks too are part of this unique are other events, happening in the economy. There is a
revival plan. The government and Reserve Bank of India tendency of customers running to safety. Hence, money
have also acted very fast. And within 13 days the scheme is flowing more into the public sector banks, despite a
was formulated and implemented. The moratorium low rate of interest. What we have seen is that people are
was lifted within 13 days. The RBI governor assured more worried and money is continuously flowing from the
that in the past not a single depositor of the scheduled private sector to the public sector. That is still a concern.
By Rajat Mishra panic-stricken depositors were left date perpetual. They are generally
with no option other than flocking to considered to be superior to equity.
T
he recent wounds created ATMs and branches of Yes Bank. And the bank with the RBI’s approval
by Punjab & Maharashtra Finance Minister Nirmala can very easily say it will not pay back if
Cooperative (PMC) Bank’s Sitharaman and RBI Governor Shakti there is a situation where the bank lost
failure have not healed yet. With RBI Kanta Das kept assuring depositors so much money. In fact, if tier 1 capital
blowing the lid off another crisis in about the safety of their money ratio falls below a certain limit or when
Yes Bank, it left depositors in the parked in Yes Bank, which according a bank needs massive capital infusion,
lurch, badly shaking people’s trust on to its balance sheet calls itself India’s this can be considered. This is exactly
Indian banking system. fourth largest private sector lender. what led Yes Bank take such a call. On
On March 5, 2020, the RBI Despite several safety assurances March 14, dashing hope of investors,
superseded the board of directors and taking depositors into Yes Bank issued a release to exchange
of Yes Bank and put it under confidence, one section who bore that its AT1 bonds worth Rs 8,500
moratorium, which was lifted on the maximum brunt was those crore will be fully and permanently
March 18. Within a few minutes of who invested in Additional Tier 1 written off to zero.
the announcement, digital payment (AT1) bonds. These are quasi-equity All retail and institutional AT1
networks collapsed and even internet instruments. They are like equity, investors were taken aback and in one
and mobile banking services of the but are structured as high interest- stroke were barred from having access
bank went dysfunctional. Baffled and bearing bonds without any maturity to their own hard-earned savings.
46
60 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
the relationship manager. We were
promised about the safety of these PANKAJ
bonds but now we understand why PATHAK
we were forced to buy these bonds.”
Fund Manager, Fixed
Another bond holder on condition Income, Quantum
of anonymity says, “My parents Mutual Fund
invested in these bonds after being
persuaded by the relationship
Moratorium on Yes
manager and we bought 14 bonds
worth Rs 1.4 crore. But now we are Bank has once again
left with not even a single penny.” He raised the vulnerability
sent an email to RBI and Ministry of in credit market
Finance with little avail.
These are just a few cases. In fact, of Rs 93,669 crore of AT1 bonds will
there are a plethora of stories of be outstanding as on date (Rs 84,574
depositors being duped by the bank, excluding Yes Bank) of which Rs
which lured customers to invest in 39,315 crore will be of private banks
risky bonds without letting them (Rs 30.620 crore excluding Yes Bank).
know other caveats involved. After Most of these bonds were issued during
this news broke out, it sent shock FY2017 and FY2018 with the first call
waves among retail and institutional option after fifth year of issuance and
investors. More than 100 retail hence a large number bonds are due for
investors have penned letters to call in FY2022 and FY2023.
RBI governor and FM Nirmala Dhiraj Relli, MD & CEO, HDFC
Sitharaman, highlighting the case. Securities says, “As per the latest
The letter that Outlook Money restructuring guidelines announced,
has seen says, “We are tax-paying Yes Bank AT1 bonds have been written
salaried class people, whose life off completely. However, there is
Laxmi Sirisha, 42, and Naveen savings are at stake. We request your no clarity as to whether the holders
Devnani, 43, a couple from Delhi urgent intervention in safeguarding of these bonds will be allotted any
bought 7 AT1 bonds worth Rs 70 the interest of retail investors. Yes equity in exchange of write-off after a
lakh. Laxmi, an HR professional Bank officials sold us the bond legal challenge. Mutual funds will be
recalls, ‘We were lured by the stating that they are safer than fixed cautious in subscribing to instruments
relationship manager to invest in deposits and have misguided us. Yes (including Tier1 bonds) of weak banks,
AT1 bonds saying it will fetch you Bank sold these bonds to retailers going forward due to the experience
more interest rate. Ever since we through incorrect representation of that they have had in Yes Bank.”
heard about these bonds being the features credit rating, risk factors Prateek Pant, Head of Products
written off, we were left in shock. and nature of these bonds.” & Solutions, Sanctum Wealth
That was our hard-earned money we As per ICRA estimates, a total Management says; “The draft
have saved over the last 10 years. resolution plan for Yes Bank completely
Naveen fears, “My father‘s writes off Additional Tier-1 bonds
retirement corpus is also locked in issued by the bank. Hence, mutual fund
these bonds. If he gets to know he houses that have invested in Yes Bank
will have a heart attack.” PRATEEK PANT AT1 bonds stand to lose the entire
Madhu Patni, 64, another Yes amount invested. Many mutual funds
Head of Products &
Bank customer also invested a Solutions, Sanctum have already segregated their portion of
whooping Rs 70 lakh in AT1 bonds. Wealth Management portfolio, which is invested in Yes Bank
It was also her husband’s and her AT1 bonds.” Talking about the impact
savings that were invested with of this he says, “The write-off by mutual
an intention to live comfortably,
Mutual funds houses funds would impact the NAV to the
post retirement. Her son Chirag that invested in Yes extent of investment in Yes Bank
complains, “We purchased these Bank AT1 Bonds stand AT1 bonds.”
bonds in 2019 after being pestered by to lose Fund houses including Nippon
Lessons To Be Learnt
India Asset Management, Baroda
Asset Management India, UTI Asset
Management, Franklin Templeton
RBI has set a wrong precedent for the perpetual bonds Asset Management and PGIM India
like AT1 as an instrument Asset Management have already side
pocketed their exposure to Yes Bank.
I f one wants to learn, there are multiple lessons that can be learnt from Yes
Bank episode. The first and the foremost is that demutualisation has to be
made mandatory for the entire Banking, Financial Services and Insurance
Rating Agency Fitch says Non-
Banking Financial Institutions
(NBFIs) in India could face a renewed
(BFSI) sector. Demutualisation is a process where any company/institution pressure on funding and liquidity
operating in BFSI sector, should have separate ownership and management. following the RBI’s takeover of
What we have seen during Yes Bank crisis was a lack of this. Rana Kapoor Yes Bank. “The consequences will
was the promoter as well as the CEO, before Ranveet Gill was appointed in compound the credit squeeze across
his place. Capital market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India the country’s financial system, adding
(Sebi) had introduced demutualisation process for Stock Exchanges (SEs) to current economic uncertainty,” it
way back in 2003-04, where by the management of SEs was taken away from says adding the recent announcement
stock brokers and was given to professionals. Here too, the regulator learnt may bring contagion effect for NBFIs’
the hard lesson from the mishap that occurred in 2000-01 at Bombay Stock funding condition. The AT1 bonds
Exchange (BSE), which was later known as ‘Rathi Tapes’. write-off will trigger a fresh round
Wherever management and ownership is vested in single hand, there of investor risk aversion that will
will be conflict of interest and it will create undue pressure on the board tighten the market access and raises
and on executives running the company. In such a scenario, there could be overall funding costs for borrower
malafide intentions; one can really leverage it, which is what has happened in with wholesale NBFIs likely to remain
case of Yes Bank. What happened in case of Karvy and DHFL recently, was more vulnerable in this situation.
also the result of ownership and management lying with the same entity. In Pankaj Pathak, Fund Manager,
BFSI space, it is important that professionals run the business and owners Fixed Income, Quantum Mutual Fund
maintain safe distance from running the business. says, “Given that liquidity conditions
It is a fact that as banking sector regulator, RBI is aware that ownership are likely to remain in surplus mode,
and management should be separate in functioning of banks and it has taken returns from overnight and liquid
several steps n this direction but what is required is speed. It was expected funds and money market fund,
that RBI would act swiftly in case of Yes Bank as issues related to mis- which do not take too much credit
governance were known. Many respectable brokerage houses have flagged risk, should also remain muted in
off that Yes Bank’s accounts are not correct. So to that extent RBI should have line with the repo rate. There will be
acted much early. But, nevertheless, the resolution proposed by the central recommendations to allocate to credit
bank is excellent and that is the reason why the bank is up and running so risk strategies given the fall in yields of
swiftly. However, the treatment meted out to the AT1 bondholders in the government bonds and AAA (Triple
resolution scheme is not right. In this issue, RBI has exploited technical A) companies. However, as we have
clause. In such a situation, one should first write off the equity and then been highlighting for some time, we
the AT1 bonds. But by not sticking to that order in the writing off process, do not yet see the end of credit crisis
we have killed the instrument. No, one would subscribe to it now. RBI has in the bond markets, despite RBI’s
treated AT1 bonds a secondary to equities in Yes Bank case, which is not actions, and crisis in the NBFCs,
right. Also, it has set a wrong precedent for the perpetual bonds like AT1 as telecom and now banking sector are
an instrument. Who will subscribe to the instrument, which carries 200-300 extension of the same crisis.”
basis points (bps) higher risk compared to other bond market papers. Pathak further adds, “The recent
The Yes Bank fall has set another bad precedent is that if someone developments of financial stress
mismanages and entity in the banking sector and at the end of the game, if in the Vodafone-Idea and the
you say, now I cannot run the show, RBI or the government will immediately imposition of moratorium on
intervene and bail out the troubled entity. That should not be encouraged. Yes Bank by RBI have once again
Today it is Yes Bank, tomorrow there can be five more, smaller banks that raised the vulnerability in the
may turn to RBI for help. This should not be allowed and regulator should credit market.”
take pro-active approach in dealing with such situations. rajat@outlookindia.com
Yagnesh Kansara
(With inputs from Himali Patel)
48
62 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
Standpoint
B
oth the global and domestic markets are currently Equity Valuation Index
reeling under the coronavirus siege. In India, on 170
a year-to-date basis, Nifty has corrected 22.44 150 Book Partial Profits
per cent and BSE Sensex was down by 21.76 per cent
130
on March 13, 2020. One does not know how long the Incremental Money to Debt
110 Neutral
impact of coronavirus is likely to play out and what
will be the exact impact of it on the health of the global 90
Invest in Equity
economy. As a result, global markets too are likely to be 70
Aggressively Invest in Equity
on the edge with investors flocking to safer asset classes. 50
Historically, it has been observed that any global Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
event, due to which a market meltdown has occurred,
have proved to be a lucrative investment opportunity Source: ICICI Prudential Factsheet; Equity Valuation Index is calculated
by assigning equal weights to Price-to-Earnings (PE), Price-to-Book (PB),
(see chart). At such times it is important to have a G-Sec*PE and Market Cap to GDP ratio. G-Sec - Goverment Securities. GDP -
staggered approach to investing and more importantly Gross Domestic Product; Data as of March 13, 2020
be invested in products that can make the most of the
ongoing market volatility. research conducted by Gary Brinston, Brian D Singer
Furthermore, an analysis by ICICI Direct shows that and Gilbert L Beebower on determinants of portfolio
in six out of nine occasions when the markets corrected performance found asset allocation is the key to
by more than 10 per cent, all the losses were recouped portfolio performance, which accounted for 91.5 per
within the subsequent two months. cent. This was followed by security selection, market
Our equity valuation index highlights that equity is timing and a few other factors, which contributed only
available at an attractive valuation with a good margin. 8.5 per cent. Investors should be conscious of asset
The Valuation, Cycle, Trigger and Sentiments (VCTS) allocation.
framework, which we at ICICI Prudential Mutual One of the best approaches to getting this done right is
Fund follow, indicates that valuations are attractive through dynamic asset allocation schemes which are on
and we are in the low to mid phase of business cycle offer from various fund houses. Here, based on the market
with sentiments around equity as an asset class being valuation, the allocation to equity and debt will keep
negative. Keeping these in view, we recommend adding varying. When the equity valuation is expensive, such a
equity to the investment portfolio at this juncture. A portfolio will increase its allocation to debt and vice versa.
This helps an investor to buy low
Mkt Cap GDP Mkt Cap BSE S&P Sensex Level Return in and sell high.
Date of Debt is an asset class which
Observation (`
Lakh (` Lakh to GDP Observation After 3 Next 3 Yrs
Crore) Crore) Ratio Date Yrs (CAGR) is often ignored. In the current
Dec-2007 72 48 149% 20287 20389 0% market, we believe credit funds
Dec-2008 31 56 56% 9647 15455 17% present an interesting opportunity
Oct-2010 72 72 100% 20032 21034 2%
for investment given their
attractive valuation.
Aug-2013 57 104 55% 18620 28343 15%
Opt for fund houses which
Feb-2016 87 133 65% 23002 35905 16%
follows rigorous process-oriented
Jan-2018 152 163 94% 35965 ? ? investment and stay away from
Aug-2019 136 195 70% 37018 ? ? troubled debt papers.
12-Mar-2020 126 206 61% 32778 ? ?
The author is ED and Chief Investment
Data Source: Bloomberg, BSE India, Internal Calculation. Past performance may not be sustained in future. Officer, ICICI Prudential AMC
68 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com www.outlookmoney.com April 2020 Outlook Money 49
Standpoint
Long term gains will help the patient, determined and resolute investor
T
he spread of the coronavirus pandemic globally of us can take for the next few weeks until this virus is
has had a severe impact on global stock markets. contained. After cash flows, look at your cash pool. The
With over 242,000 infections and 10,000 deaths, cash component in your portfolio can contain cash in
the epidemic has drawn comparisons with painful hand, banks accounts and deposits that can be broken
periods such as World War II, the 2008 global financial and liquid mutual funds with overnight redemption
crisis and the 1918 Spanish flu outbreak. facilities. Increase this cash pool so that one years of
Most markets have slipped down 20 to 30 per cent expenses are covered. One never knows with a huge
plus, with individual stocks lower by anything up to 50 downturn like this. With that in place you can be clear
per cent. As an example, on March 19, the entire US headed and unsentimental in dealing with your portfolio.
airlines industry had seen its combined market worth The second action item is to look at your insurance
fall to $51 billion. This for an industry that had used $39 coverage. Is your health insurance up-to-date, is it
billion over the last 5 years for share buybacks. adequate with top up and a family floater in place. If you
As always happens in large scale events with increased are dependent on a health insurance offered by your
uncertainty, not only risky assets but even so called employer, what is the risk of job loss? It may be better
safe haven assets like gold have seen a fall in prices. to spend the premium and acquire a personal health
Only cash and that too US dollar cash, seems to be insurance in these uncertain times. The same goes for
the king for now, as all assets, from stocks to bonds to your life insurance cover, don’t depend on the group
government securities to currencies to metals and other insurance covers offered by your workplace. There will
commodities fell sharply. be huge job losses if the economic pain stays for a few
As all of us are grappling with an uncertain medical months. At that time, being out of a job and losing your
event of the coronavirus, markets have started insurance coverage both will be a very big risk. Buy
discounting widespread economic destruction due to personal health and life insurance. Make sure your car
this and have fallen hard and fast. The market gave no and home insurance is also updated.
warning on Feb 19, 2020 before it started its fall, to The third thing to do, is get your entire portfolio down
become the fastest ever bear market in the US. Very few on paper and analyse it. How much of your money is in
investors had a chance to pull out their funds in time and cash, fixed income, stocks, mutual funds, private equity
even now most retail investors have stayed invested. The funds, PMS schemes, AIFs, unlisted stocks , gold, silver,
2008 experience has shown that, the stocks that fall the art and other valuables . We saw in 2008, that so called
most, on average don’t recover the fastest. Rather it is liquid asset classes turned illiquid with funds refusing
the stocks that fell the least that will form the nucleus of redemptions and other market events disrupting
the next bull run. normalcy. Ensure you have one year of expenses in cash
So the first lesson is, don’t be afraid that you missed kept aside. That gives a lot of strength of mind in such
the last helicopter getting you out of a disaster zone. trying times.
Relook at your portfolio and your emergency fund. If the broad stock allocation is troubling you, this
Ensure you have a cash flow other than from the stock may be the worst time to reduce your stock allocations.
market. It may be from a job, a business, fixed income But if your cash buffer is low, sell now and build your
investments, a side hustle. Relook at your cash flows cash cushion first. Remember, in the world’s largest
and if these look under threat, reduce expenses now. market, the US, the median number of days between
Postpone that big purchase. Holidays anyways none the US S&P 500 index hitting its peak and then hitting
its eventual low was 187 days. And the median time
from entering a bear market to the market hitting its
eventual low was 71 days. The median loss in each bear
Give a relook at your portfolio market was 32.9 per cent.
and your emergency fund Of course this time the market could be very different,
50
64 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
these historical figures are just indications for us to plan.
We can’t say how much more the markets will fall, for
how long the correction will be or how widespread the
Diversification is critical. Keep
economic suffering will be. the safety net. Buy some gold
The kind of selling we have seen is pointing to panic
and capitulation with algo based selling exacerbating the This is also a good time to weed out the losers
falls. Reputed market masters are talking of this being from your equity portfolio. These times favour quality
similar to 1920s or 1929 or 1937. Second order impacts companies that generate good cash flows and deliver
of the virus with high levels of leverage and the OPEC strong margins/ returns on capital. Stay conservative and
Russia oil war are scaring markets into a huge risk off. in quality.
Stick to your asset allocation plan. If you are regularly Assume it’s a long downturn, assume defaults will
investing X amount every month in the markets, happen, deals will dry up. Assess how you will stay
continue that. Maybe you will not get any returns for a solvent and liquid. A big lesson of 2008 was the lack of
year, but when the markets rebound, they will give two liquidity that hit all out of the blue.
years returns in a matter of weeks. Don’t miss that. Stick to what works for you in sum. No one has the
However, don’t try to go bottom fishing. We don’t one correct solution. Stay invested. Short term pain
know the depth of the bottom and those shiny objects is certain. Long term gains will accrue to the patient,
that seem so attractive, could be falling knives. Avoiding determined and resolute investor.
those starts with the humility to know that no one can The world has gone through many wars, disasters,
call the bottom. Don’t try that. epidemics and market cycles. This will be a very tough
Diversification is critical. Keep the safety net. Buy time, but with patience and discipline we will achieve
some gold. small coins that can be liquidated easily. our financial goals. That is what history teaches us. Let’s
Spread your accounts to two three banks. Reassess win this.
your risk appetite, which tends to shrink in market
downturns. The author is a private investor
R
upal Dhonkariya and her to note that millennials are importance of savings, proper
husband Yatharth Singh undertaking their financial planning financial planning at an early stage
Chauhan are a young at an early stage of their lives and and how it could help them sail
couple. While Rupal is working as career. through their future short-term as
a manager, audit and assurance in Rupal and Yatharth both had got well as long-term goals. Just like
one of the big four consulting firms, in touch with financial advisors the list of questions, they had a list
Yatharth is the managing editor around two years ago for chalking of financial aspirations that was
for content management with a out a roadmap for attaining their also long enough. However, with
premier automobile portal. They financial goals, and in the process, no other financial commitment and
both are in their late 20s. It has the financial freedom. They had plenty of time at disposal for crucial
indeed been a pleasing experience lots of doubts regarding the goals like retirement planning, all
that they required was a prudent
financial roadmap. The time in
hand also allowed them to undo
any of their earlier mistakes and
simultaneously take the remedial
action in their financial plans.
After a long discussion with the
couple, various financial goals were
quantified along with a revisit to
the current investment strategy.
I figured out that while they had
been staying financially aware and
making some investments since
the last two to three years, they
were not being guided well with a
clear strategy. Further, there was
also a need to guide them from the
traditional investment products
towards tax-efficient instruments,
so that the returns could be further
optimised. Rupal and Yatharth were
planning for a new car in the next
three years and further, aiming to
Disclaimer
Financial Planning of Rupal Dhonkariya and husband Yatharth Singh Chauhan is based on the “personal opinion and experience” of
Vidit Bhura and that it should not be considered professional financial investment advice. No one should make any investment decision
without first consulting his or her own financial advisor and conducting his or her own research and due diligence.
52
66 Outlook Money April 2020 www.outlookmoney.com
pursue higher education after five
With Rupal and Yatharth trying to sustain years. Their long-term goals included
the momentum to fulfill their financial investing in a house for themselves,
aspirations as desired, here are a few financial as well as planning prudently for
lessons one can learn from their financial their retirement corpus.
journey: The couple also deserved some
special appreciation, for they were
Link mutual fund investments to financial goals making a distinction between the
This was also the starting point for Rupal and Yatharth. While they had necessities and luxuries of life and
been investing earlier, their savings lacked discipline, with the primary planning for vacations, out of the
agenda behind such investments being tax savings. However, once they annual bonuses. As such, their
linked their plans and investments to their goals, the entire investing monthly take-home salary of `1 lakh
strategy found its purpose. Further, with the emotional connections each could be channelised towards
the couple had towards their financial goals, they found an internal savings and investments after
motivation to continue investing in their journeys and achieve the goals. making regular expenses. With such
cashflows, the financial goals planned
Select schemes as per the financial goals by the couple looked practical and
Different mutual fund schemes tend to carry different risk-reward achievable. In the course of the
trade-offs for the investors. Equity schemes may be volatile over the discussion, the importance of asset
short term but tend to create wealth over the long term. Similarly, debt allocation was also explained to
Rupal and Yatharth and how they
schemes may generate reasonable returns but tend to be relatively
can achieve their short-term and
stable. The investors can align their investments as per their risk
long-term goals with a proper mix
appetite and financial goals by maintaining a suitable mix of mutual
of equity and debt instruments. As a
fund schemes. For example, for long-term goals, one can stay invested
first step towards bringing financial
in equity schemes, for such schemes have historically created wealth for
discipline into their lives, dedicated
the investors over the long term. Similarly, for emergency fund corpus, SIPs were advised to be registered for
which must stay liquid at all times, one can choose to invest in liquid different goals.
funds and overnight funds. Further, given the career
aspirations to pursue higher
Instead of watching your portfolio monthly, make an annual education in five years, a need was
portfolio review with your advisor felt for them not only to start saving
A financially aware investor tends to make one common mistake of towards the goal but also to create
watching the portfolio movements quite frequently. Even when staying a corpus to tide through the days
financially aware and updated is good, staying influenced with short- of lower family income during the
term movements can push one to make emotional decisions. However, study period. They were also advised
just like it is advisable to ignore short-term movements in the portfolio, to have adequate life and health
it is equally important to review the portfolio on a periodic basis, insurance covers to mitigate the risk
preferably once every year with your financial advisor. Such a review can of any future uncertainties.
help the investors gauge the portfolio performance, enabling them to Starting early in the investment
achieve their financial goals in a time-bound manner. journey helped Rupal and Yatharth
plan for their financial goals in a
It is vital to trust your financial advisor better manner. You must also take
Markets can test the patience of the investors with short term volatile your first step right away as it is
movements. Often the investors can get impatient with their mutual never too late to start your journey.
Happy Investing!
fund investments and think of redeeming such investments. This
is when the financial advisors can help the investors reinforce their
confidence in the markets by guiding them about the market outlook
and aligning their investment portfolio suitably. As such, it is profoundly
crucial to trust your financial advisor to stay invested in the markets and
have a pleasant investing journey. Vidit Bhura
Partner,
JNV Advisors LLP
Moving Towards A
$5 Trillion Economy
In the opening address, Chandok shared how India was
Presents on its path to become a $5 trillion economy and the only
question was not about if that would happen, but when it
would happen. He talked about the fundamental pillars,
which would support India’s growth in years to come.
The keynote address was delivered by SBI’s Ghosh
who emphasised on the importance of policy making
frameworks and said that COVID-19 outbreak has put a
lot of uncertainties in the global economy, while India’s
aspiration to reach the $5-trillion GDP target by 2024 was
faced with serious questions.
In his power-talk session, Ranade discussed the
Industrial
challenges on the road to $5 trillion considering India’s
Destination Partner Life Insurance Partner Banking Partner Housing Finance Partner General Insurance Partner
growth in last four years had dropped from 8 per cent to 5
per cent.
Mutual Fund Partner Financial Education Partner Knowledge Partner Outreach Partner Bespoke Partner Outreach Partner
But the highlights of the event from an investor’s
perspective were the five eminent panels, which evoked
curiosity and answered many relevant questions. In the
Mutual Funds panel, moderated by Kailash Kulkarni, MD
By Vishav & CEO, L&T Mutual Fund, the panelists discussed how
the MF industry has changed in the past one year after
T
he third edition of the Outlook Money various tightening of norms by Sebi. This was followed by
Conclave, held on February 27 in Mumbai, the Insurance panel in which Tapan Singhel engaged in
turned out to be a huge success with industry a riveting conversation with Asish Mehrotra, CEO, Max
leaders across segments coming together on a single Bupa Health Insurance, and Sumit Rai, MD and CEO,
platform to inform and educate investors and discuss Edelweiss Tokyo Life Insurance. They discussed how
the future of money. In a fast-evolving world, it’s digitisation has transformed the insurance industry and
crucial to keep up with the change and the annual what the regulator should do to reduce digital scams and
event organised by Outlook Money has regularly and frauds in the insurance industry.
actively played a role in helping investors do that. This In the Personal Finance panel, moderated by financial
time around, with the theme “India Moving Towards educator and coach Mrin Agarwal, a threadbare
a $5 Trillion Economy”, 25 speakers participated in the discussion was held on the importance of blending robo-
event spread across five expert panels, three power-talk advisory vis-a-vis physical advice by financial advisors.
sessions and a keynote address. The panelists also discussed challenges people face while
From SBI Chief Economist Soumya Kanti Ghosh embracing technology and how to overcome them. The
to Aditya Birla Group Chief Economist Ajit Ranade, Capital Markets panel was headlined by the idea that if
from ICICI Securities MD and CEO Vijay Chandok to the economy was like a train destined to reach $5 trillion
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance’s MD and CEO Tapan station, then the market should ideally be its engine. The
Singhel, eminent personalities and industry captains panel led by Ajay Bagga, Chairman OPC Asset solutions,
graced the occasion sharing their invaluable thoughts discussed how the valuation game through equity markets
and insights on subject matters varying from the Indian help in achieving the goal of $5 trillion economy, besides
economy to specific sectors like insurance, banking and other factors.
finance. Former Union Minister Manish Tewari was also The final panel was on Fintech, during which experts
present who tore apart the government on its handling from the financial world had an engaging discussion
of the economy. He said for the sake of 135 crore people on how the use of blockchain by fintech companies is
in India, the economy just cannot be allowed to fail. redefining the sector.
F
or 135 crore people in India, whose collective wealth is in the “Before the budget, the economic
the economy just cannot be range of about Rs. 20 lakh crore. And survey was presented, and the
allowed to fail,” said Manish if you were to sort of juxtaposing economic survey for the year 2020-
Tewari, Member of Parliament and that with the entire revenue of the 21 unfortunately, tried to create a
former Information and Broadcasting government of India for the last fiscal false binary between socialism and a
Minister, while speaking at the third it was about 27 lakh crore. There new liberal economic order.”
edition of Outlook Money Conclave are about eight billionaires in the He took the gathering through
and 18th edition of Outlook Money world whose collective wealth is as the current state of the economy
Awards, held in Mumbai on February much as what is held by 400 crore and said, “If you will look at the
27, 2020. people on planet earth. They are a Indian economy today, it would be
Tewari was addressing a gathering bunch of companies, about 25 of a bit of an understatement to say
of stalwarts from the financial them, whose individual GDP is more that the economy is not doing well.
world as he pushed the subject of than the GDP of 85 per cent of the Because, if you look at any of the
inequality to center stage and said, countries on planet earth. So, there is indices, GDP growth at 5 per cent
“If you will step back and look at inequality.” is the lowest in 11 years. Private
India in a perspective, we are 17.7 consumption at 5.8 per cent is the
per cent of the world’s population. lowest in seven years. Investment
We occupy 2.4 per cent of the growth at 1 per cent is the lowest in
world’s area. But interestingly, 73 An understatement 17 years. Manufacturing growth at
per cent of India’s wealth is held by to say economy is not 2 per cent is the lowest in 15 years.
only 1 per cent of its people. And doing well Agricultural credit at 2.8 per cent is
the lowest in four years.
Bank credit growth between
April 2019 to January 2020 was 7.6
per cent as compared to 14.6 per
cent for the corresponding period
during the previous year. Inflation
at 7.35 per cent during December
2019 was the highest in five years.
Unemployment at 6.1 per cent is
the highest in 45 years. Exports
are down 1.8 per cent as compared
to December 2018. If you take
December 2019 as the benchmark
for which figures are available,
imports are down by 8.83 per
cent. In the corresponding period,
electricity consumption is down by
5 per cent. So, unfortunately, every
parameter that you look at does not
Manish Tewari, Member of send out a very comforting message.
Parliament and former Information The fiscal deficit is 14.8 per cent
and Broadcasting Minister over the budget estimate and this
was the figure for January 2020.”
From left to right: Rajesh Cheruvu, CIO, Validus Wealth; Abhishek Bansal, Chairman, Abans Wealth and Investment Managers; Mrin Agarwal, Financial
educator & Coach; Gaurav Mashruwala, Financial expert and author; Vivek Agarwal, COO, Scripbox
By Aparajita Gupta rapid advancement in disruptive So what are the challenges that
technology. people face while they embrace
D
isruptive technologies “When we started this technology? Gaurav Mashruwala,
are increasingly taking millennium, we probably started financial expert and author said many
charge of various aspects with a handful of online platforms, of the clients are still not used to
of life and the financial world is but now you have a whole technology and want a human-touch.
not an exception. When it comes magnitude of platforms available. “Yes, they want to see human faces.
to financial advising do people still As a financial educator, I meet a lot They want to meet them face-to-face.
favour one-on-one advisory or are of retail investors who tell me that Third, from a common independent
they ready for robo advisory to take their biggest concern is the access financial advisor perspective, what
charge of things? In the personal to financial advice. They could be happens is that the cost of upgrading
finance panel various luminaries partly to blame because they don’t on a regular basis could be prohibitive,”
from the industry did a threadbare want to pay for advice. But I think he said.
discussion on - “How important there’s a bigger systemic issue But would all problems end with
is it for financial advisors to offer as well, where it does not make robo advisor and technology at the
a blend of physical advice and economic sense, sometimes for the forefront and human manning it from
robo advisory?” - during the third advisor to provide physical advice. back end? Mashruwala said people
Conclave of Outlook Money held in In all this, you now have the new still want human presence at front-end
Mumbai. hybrid model, which is a channel when it comes to interaction. “People
Mrin Agarwal, financial where you can do a combination of also still want to meet us, talk to us, see
educator and coach, who was the technology and physical advice. And us and touch and feel and hence both
moderator of the panel said, over I think a lot of advisors have been should survive but majority of people
the last decade there has been a embracing technology,” she said. would still want to talk to us either on
KEYNOTE ADDRESS
S
tating that COVID-19 constrained discussion,” he said.
outbreak has put a lot of According to Ghosh, in India, the
uncertainties in the global RBI has been following a very rule-
economy, chief economist of the based policy of prompt corrective
State Bank of India, Soumya Kanti action. “In fact, India still follows a
Ghosh, said that India’s aspiration rule based policy in specific monetary
to reach the $5-trillion Gross policies. That’s a matter of debate and
Soumya Kanti Ghosh, Chief Economist, SBI
Domestic Product (GDP) target by research, which may be served better
2025 is faced with serious questions. by constrained discussion,” he said.
“The recent slowdown has put two types: constrained discretion Ghosh asserted that the income tax
a serious question on such an and unconstrained discretion. proposals announced in the budget
aspiration. The outbreak of the “Constrained discretion could be 2020 is the example of a very good use
virus from China has also put a good and unconstrained discretion of constrained discretion turning into
lot of uncertainties in the global could be bad for policy making,” unconstrained discretion. However,
economic scenario. We are actually he said, while giving highlights of he is doubtful of the government’s
dealing with uncertainties, and how policy making frameworks expectation to see around 80 per cent
economic policymaking is grappling in developed countries moved shift to the new tax regime.
with appreciations about the future,” from a system of rule-based policy “In fact, the proposals in the budget
Ghosh said at the Outlook Money to a constrained discretionary are noble, encouraging people to
Conclave 2020. policymaking after the global crisis make decisions in their broad self
Ghosh suggested to reconsider in 2008. interest, and not about penalising them
“basic principles” to design an According to Ghosh, in India, financially. However, the main research
effective and flexible regulatory there was a lot of unconstrained could be just the reverse, because the
mechanism capable of dealing with discretion exercised in the government is projecting around 80
structural changes. He emphasised policymaking till the opening of the per cent of the people could shift to the
on the importance of policy making economy in 1991, and afterwards new tax regime, but given the current
frameworks while making policies. moved towards rule-based regime. incentive structure, this number could
According to him, policymaking He said that fiscal policy making be much lower, it could be even lower
frameworks across the globe are in India continues to be dictated than 10 per cent.
either rule-based or discretion- by unconstrained discretion. “We Ghosh emphasised that incentives
based. “Rule-based framework used to do rampant monetisation of on peoples’ investments is a crucial
follows a pre-specified plan, and fiscal deficit, basically print money factor in order to impact household
policymakers pursue the same whenever we had a deficit. With savings in India. Citing studies, he
course of action in all circumstances the opening up of the economy in said, “Household savings in India
as written in the textbook. However 1991, India actually moved over are a function of macro economic
in a discretion-based framework, more towards rule-based regime. as well as qualitative factors. While
policymakers have wide latitude India still follows a rule-based macroeconomic factors are per
to design the best policy response capita real income, dependency ratio,
for the given circumstances. inflation, real interest rate, and access
Such flexibility in policymaking to banking; qualitative factors are
allows policymakers to respond to Fiscal policy making incentivisation. The incentive to invest
unforeseen scenarios,” he said. is dictated by uncon- is a crucial factor to impact household
Discretion-based policy is of strained discretion savings in India.”
By Vishav all these problems. We overtook four In real terms, it would be around 8
countries – Brazil, Canada, Russia and per cent. Today we are at 5 per cent.
I
ndia is firmly on its path to Italy. Today we have reached number So clearly, the question is why did we
become a $5 trillion economy 5 and are a $2.7-2.8 trillion economy, move back to 5 per cent and what
and the question is not whether having overtaken France and Britain needs to be done to move closer to
it would happen, but when would in the process over the last four years,” 8-8.5 per cent to get to $5 trillion
it happen, said Vijay Chandok, Chandok explained. sooner than later,” Chandok wondered.
Managing Director, ICICI Securities. He said in rupee terms, this He said when we were at seven per
He said his confidence in India’s economic expansion was even more cent, two main pillars supporting that
economy was due to three factors impressive as from Rs 14 lakh crore, rate of growth were the government
which were laying the foundation India had now become Rs 200 lakh spending and consumption which were
of a high-growth phase -- demand, crore economy, growing 20-23 disrupted by three-four big shocks
investment and massive productivity times in last 25 years, despite all the including the movement from non-
gains through digitisation. problems. GST to GST world, the demonetization
Delivering the opening address “So when we talk about $5 trillion world, the RERA world and the IBC
at the third edition of the Outlook world.
Money Conclave held in Mumbai, “Each one of them had great
Chandok said India had grown from a medium-term benefits because you are
$300-350 billion economy in early 90s moving from a random and inefficient
to a $2.8 trillion economy despite all way of doing business to a more formal
the problems and crises. way, which brings sustainability,
“25 years back, in early 90s, the comfort and greater scale in the course
GDP of India was $300-350 billion of time. But they were highly disruptive
and per capita income was around in the short term. And the net impact
$300. As time passed, despite some of each of these is that it shocks the
Vijay Chandok, MD, ICICI Securities
obstacles, our GDP touched $1000 economy in terms of demand. Then
billion, or one trillion, by middle during the election time, there was
2000s. We joined the trillion dollar economy, the question to be asked a pull-back from the government on
club which was a big deal. It took us is not whether it would happen, but capital expenditure. These support
12-13 years to get to that,” he said. whether it would happen by 2024, pillars of economy have disappeared,
He added that while we kept or 2025 or 2026. One is the massive which has brought our growth rate to 5
cribbing about one or the other consumption that is coming through per cent,” he explained.
problems in the economy, including the population of the country which The ICICI Securities MD said that
the big problem of the global financial is young. Second is that our country’s three things were needed to put this
crisis, by 2010, India was ranked unique ability to consume a lot of momentum back on track.
number 11 in terms of GDP. money for creating infrastructure “The government has come
“Time passed – we had something which is able to pay for itself. And up with a lot of well-intentioned
called policy paralysis in 2012-13 third is this wave of digitisation announcements recently. And the
when we said nothing was working, and technology changes that are third thing needed is to take feedback
the markets were down, liquidity leading to massive improvements in on those measures and tweak them
was bad, economy was floundering, productivity,” he elaborated. accordingly to ensure the intended
inflation was very high, interest rates “In a mathematical sense, we are outcome is achieved. Getting into that
were high. In the meantime, India today at around $2.8 trillion and to virtuous cycle will be more powerful
from the number 11 position moved get to $5 trillion by 2024, we need to than coming up with another 25
to number seven by 2015-16 despite grow at 12 per cent in nominal terms. initiatives,” he concluded.
From left to right: Shantanu Awasthi, Head (Family Office), Karvy Private Wealth; Gaurav Rastogi, CEO, Kuvera; Vijay Kuppa, Co-founder, Oro Wealth;
Financial Expert Deepika Asthana; and Sachin Vashishtha, Chief Digital Officer, PaisaBazar
F
intech has not only changed savvy, generations are changing
the way we bank but also and the use of digital platforms is
the way we think. With definitely increasing, said Shantanu
technologies like blockchain Clients are savvy, Awasthi, Head (Family Office),
causing large scale disruption in the
financial sector, fintech companies
generations are Karvy Private Wealth. He said that
from a transaction and information
that adapt smartly to this change changing and use of flow perspective, technology is
will come out on top. During the digital platforms is proving to be a big enabler. And
third Outlook Money Conclave increasing even in the background, like in the
held in Mumbai, experts from selection process, technology is
the financial world had a riveting Shantanu Awasthi being used massively.
discussion on how the use of Head (Family Office), Karvy Private Awasthi added that personal
blockchain by fintech companies is Wealth relationship and trust building
“ O The goal of
ne of the main pillars $5 trillion dream is quite far away,”
of production is said Uttam Bagri, Chairman, BSE
capital. India has been $5 trillion economy Brokers’ Forum while speaking
a capital scarce country. Within is achievable at the third edition of Outlook
last 10 years we have seen a good Money Conclave and 18th edition
capital flow but in last two years Devang Mehta of Outlook Money Awards on
anyone who is in business knows Head Equity Advisory February 27, in Mumbai.
what happened. So, if you don’t Centrum Broking The panel on capital market saw
From left to right: Uttam Bagri, chairman, BSE Brokers’ Forum; Ajay Bagga, Chairman, OPC Asset Solutions; Kedar Deshpande, Head, Retail
Distribution and Devang Mehta, Head, Equity Advisory Centrum Broking
By Himali Patel years substantially. According to permanent. “Most of the time I believe
him, the Securities and Exchange that regulation is the outcome of
O
utlook Money’s Conclave Board of India (Sebi) has been what we have been doing and is not
2020 saw many of the tightening the norms not only from the outcome of what Sebi thinks and
interesting and engaging one last year but has been doing it therefore the regulation comes,” said
discussions throughout the day. over the last few years. Balasubramanian. That said, panelist
One of which was - How has the Joining the discussion with him expert NS Venkatesh, CEO, Amfi
Mutual Fund industry changed was A Balasubramanian, MD & India was asked by the moderator
in the past one year after various CEO, Aditya Birla Sun Life AMC, about What are the steps and changes
tightening of norms by Sebi?” who was asked how the industry has undertaken by the regulator to make
Moderating the session was grown over last one year and how system far more transparent and easier
Kailash Kulkarni, MD & CEO, L&T the MF industry is going ahead? To to enter?
Mutual Fund. Before throwing the which he explained MF industry is As per Venkatesh, the regulators
questions to the other MF experts, now gaining the institutional face. have two roles to play - one is to
he made a point by emphasising Earlier, it used to be small ensure the safety of the market, a place
that mutual fund industry today industry in both size and where the investors are coming in,
is nearly Rs 28 lakh crore and the prominence in the eyes of the which has to be completely safe and
equity component has also grown investor. However, despite all the secure for them. And the second one
primarily in the last five to seven regulations the growth will remain is that the regulator has to look after
From left to right: Shreenivas Kunte, Director, CFA Institute; A Balasubramanian, MD & CEO, Aditya Birla Sun Life AMC; Navneet Munot, CIO,
SBI Mutual Fund; N. S. Venkatesh, CEO, Amfi; Swarup Mohanty, CEO, Mirae Asset India; Kailash Kulkarni, MD & CEO, L&T Mutual Fund
KEYNOTE ADDRESS
T
he economic context is not Now I will talk about what gives
very happy because of the us the confidence to talk about such
slowdown. In the last four a possibility in the medium to long
financial years, 2016-17, 2017-18, term. The main driving force for that is
2018-19 and 2019-20, as per the demography. The population of India
government’s data, the growth of the is growing at a rate of 1.7 per cent
economy has gone down from 8 to 7 per year. However, India’s workforce
to 6 to 5 per cent. or people in the age group of 18 to
The GDP growth depends on 60, which is a subset of the total
your investment, as what you invest population is growing at 2.5 per cent.
today becomes the GDP growth This demographic phenomenon is very
tomorrow. An important indicator of robust and impervious. People who are
how much the economy is investing Ajit Ranade, President and Chief Economist, going to be working, earning, saving,
is the investment to GDP ratio. That Aditya Birla Group investing, consuming and paying taxes
ratio in 2008-09 to 2010-11 was about surface is whether this is a structural are being driven by demography. Just
36 per cent of GDP. That number or a cyclical slowdown. A cyclical as the tax net is widening, the financial
has been 28 per cent of the GDP in slowdown means that the business savings of the country are deepening.
the last four years. With 28 per cent cycle is slow. It goes up as cycles go The kind of transfor-mation we are
investment to GDP ratio, you cannot up and down based on the movement having in financial inclusion
get high growth unless the investment of the business cycle. However, a is tremendous.
becomes super productive or super- structural slowdown means that the If we have a higher deficit today, it
efficient. But, in order to get a higher structure of the economy is flawed, means that the government is spending
growth, you need higher investments. so it will not grow at higher rates. The more than it is taking in through
The third important fact is exports. economy will continue to grow at 5 tax revenues. In such a situation the
In this case, the reference would be per cent unless we make some big government borrows money, but it
to manufacturing or merchandise decisions. I feel there are elements needs to be paid back. Hence, today’s
exports and not export of software of both in the current slowdown. deficit is nothing but tomorrow’s taxes.
or tourism revenue. Exports are However, let us not just blame the Since the demography is such that the
important because they are highly global economy for our slowdown. population of young people is stable
aligned with manufacturing activity There are many reasons for the and rising over the next two decades,
in the country. Since there is a high same. Some of the reasons will be and the median age is going to remain
degree of correlation it is not possible very difficult to overcome. The data at 27 to 28, the per capita burden on an
that industrial and manufacturing shows that the economy has not been average taxpayer in India is going to be
growth goes up and there is no robust and yet we are saying we will relatively low despite higher deficits.
growth in exports. In the last six double the economy from today to $5 So while the demographic advantage
years, exports have grown at an is in favour of India, the question is
average growth rate of zero per cent what are the policy obstacles and
which used to grow at 20 per cent. what needs to be done to convert
From the scenario we can conclude Economy will grow at 5 this demographic advantage into
that this is a slowdown. However, per cent unless we make innovation, increased productivity, and
now the question that comes to big mistakes higher GDP growth.
*(Systematic Investment Plan) SIP facility is generally available in Daily, Monthly & Quarterly frequency
“Visit here https://licmf.info/KYCredressal to learn more about KYC requirements, SEBI Registered Mutual Funds and Grievance redressal.”
Connect with us: /LICMutual /LICMutual /company/LICMutual 1800-258-5678 www.licmf.com
MUTUAL FUND INVESTMENTS ARE SUBJECT TO MARKET RISKS, READ ALL SCHEME RELATED DOCUMENTS CAREFULLY.
Available on BSE StAR MF, NSE-MFSS , NSE NMF II and MFU platforms.
169-20