Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00228-014-1738-2
Received: 10 April 2014 / Accepted: 18 August 2014 / Published online: 4 September 2014
# Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2014
We performed a descriptive study on data from the French Types of adverse drug reaction
Pharmacovigilance Database (FPVD). This database includes
all spontaneous adverse drug reaction (ADR) reports regis- The most frequently reported adverse drug reactions (Fig. 1)
tered since 1984 in France. According to French law, every were those concerning the central nervous system (behaviour-
health practitioner must report ‘serious’ or ‘unexpected’ ad- al problems, sedation and insomnia), followed by digestive
verse drug reactions to their Regional Pharmacovigilance problems (diarrhoea, vomiting). Sixty-five (37.4 %) cases of
Centre (31 centres in France). ‘Serious’ adverse drug reactions adverse drug reactions were considered to be serious. Adverse
are defined as any untoward medical occurrence that, at any drug reactions on the central nervous system also predominat-
dose, results in death, requires hospital admission or the ed among serious adverse effects, themselves accounting for
prolongation of hospitalisation for patients already in hospital, more than a third of all serious adverse reactions (sedation,
results in persistent or significant disability/incapacity, is life loss of consciousness). ADRs resolved in 79.3 % of cases, and
threatening, results in cancer, congenital abnormalities or birth outcome was unknown in 20.7 %.
defects or any medical event that would be regarded as serious
if it had not responded to acute treatment. Drugs involved
For each ADR report, information about the patient (age,
sex, medical history), drug exposure (to the suspected drug ‘Central nervous system’ drugs were implicated in more than
and other associated non-suspected drugs) and ADR charac- a third of all cases of adverse effects in breastfed children
teristics (‘serious’ or ‘non-serious’, ‘expected’ or ‘unexpect- (Fig. 2). The drugs involved were mostly antiepileptic drugs,
ed’, causality score, outcome) are recorded in the FPVD. A anxiolytics and opiate analgesics. ‘Alimentary tract and me-
detailed summary of the clinical description of the patient is tabolism’ drug class was the second most frequent class of
added to the end of each pharmacovigilance case report. The drugs implicated, followed by anti-infective drugs, such as
route of administration, including breastfeeding, is specified. beta-lactams and macrolides in particular, in third place.
In the FPVD, ADRs are encoded according to the Medical ‘Respiratory system’ drugs were in fourth place (mostly
Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA) classifica- atropinic antihistamines and pseudoephedrine).
tion. We categorised the medicines consumed by the women ‘Cardiovascular system’ drugs were in fifth place (with beta-
in accordance with the WHO’s Anatomical Therapeutic blockers at the top of the list). Table 1 provides a list of the
Chemical (ATC) classification. The French imputability drugs most frequently implicated in adverse drug reactions in
method, which takes into account chronological (graded breastfed children.
from C0 to C3) and semiological (graded from S1 to S3) At the top of the list, with 15 notifications of adverse
data, was used to assess the intrinsic or case-related imput- reactions, is paracetamol, which was often associated, in spe-
ability [8]. cialist formulations, with a more suspect active ingredient,
All spontaneous reports of ADRs in breastfed infants such as dextropropoxyphene. The second most frequently
recorded in the National Pharmacovigilance Database by implicated drug was dextropropoxyphene itself, an opiate
the 31 French regional pharmacovigilance centres between analgesic responsible for cases of hypotonia, apnoea, respira-
1984 and June 2011 were investigated. The variables men- tory distress, bradycardia and constipation. Of the 11 notifi-
tioned above were analysed. Analyses were performed using cations of adverse reactions, nine were considered serious. It
Epi Info version 6. was followed by hydroxyzine, an antihistamine implicated in
A % of drugs N
lim N er
en er vo
ta vo us % of ADRs
r s
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
y us ys
te
tr Sy
ac m
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
st G
ta em as di
nd Sk tr so
m in oi rd
an nt er
et
ab d e st s
in
34.8
ol su
is m b cu al
A an t di
so
nt
i-i eo rd
nf us er
R ec tis s
tiv
20.3
es es su
ito di rd
-u ar sy ov er
ri di st as s
ov em cu
6.5
se ar
x y
M h or di
us m R so
A Bl cu on es rd
lo pi er
nt
in
oo
d s ke
es ra s
5.8
eo an le to
pl
as d ta
ls
ry
bl di
tic oo ys so
an d te
m
rd
d fo G er
im rm en s
m
4.7
in
g R e ra
un or en ld
Sy om ga al is o
st od ns an rd
ADRs
em ul d
ATC classes
a er
ic tin ur
in s
g
4.7
ho ar
rm ag y
on en di
al ts so
pr al rd
ep im er
en s
4
an ar ta
tip at ry
ar io
as ns di
iti so
cp rd
er
ro s
4
du
ct
Se s D
ns
or ec O
y re th
as er
or
ga e d s
m
3.6
D ns ilk
er
m se
at cr
ol et
og io
ic
al Bl n
s
3.3
o od
di
O so
th rd
er er
s s
2.5
1363
1364 Eur J Clin Pharmacol (2014) 70:1361–1366
Table 1 Most often prescribed drugs factor is not limiting in the framework of this study, which was
Drugs Number of cases Percent descriptive in nature. The exhaustiveness of notifications is
not an essential prerequisite for obtaining a general view of the
Paracetamol 15 11.3 involvement of drugs in the occurrence of adverse drug reac-
Dextropropoxyphene 11 8.3 tions in breastfed children. The quality of Pharmacovigilance
Hydroxyzine 8 6.1 notifications is variable and some data (e.g. antecedents, con-
Ketoprofen 8 6.1 sumption of other products) may differ in their degree of
Amoxicillin + clavulanic acid 6 4.5 completeness between observations. For example, it is not
Ascorbic acid 6 4.5 specified, in the National Pharmacovigilance Database, if
Lamotrigine 6 4.5 breastfeeding was exclusive or complementary. However, this
Valproic acid 5 3.7 can affect the amount of drugs into the milk and the occur-
Levonorgestrel 5 3.7 rence of adverse drug reaction.
Ibuprofen 5 3.7 Despite the long study period, the total number of adverse
Flavonoid 5 3.7 drug reactions in breastfed children recorded was small (174
Iron 5 3.7 notifications over 26 years). There are several possible reasons
Clonazepam 5 3.7 for this. Firstly, for most drugs, the amount of the drug
Amoxicillin 5 3.7 received via breast milk would probably be too small to
Pseudoephedrine 4 3.0 produce an adverse reaction [4–10]. Secondly, mothers and
Carbamazepine 4 3.0 healthcare professionals might not necessarily make the con-
Vitamin A 3 2.2 nection between maternal drug intake and the occurrence of an
Topiramate 3 2.2 adverse drug reaction in the child, particularly if it is not
Clorazepate 3 2.2 severe. The considerable underreporting of adverse drug re-
actions, as described above, is also relevant. Otherwise, the
score of causality is rarely high: only 8.6 % of cases had a
‘likely’ or ‘certain’ causality score. This may be due to the
cases of sedation in particular. This list also includes non- difficulty in assessing ADR in breastfed infants.
steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, including ketoprofen (in Two-thirds of the cases of reported adverse drug reactions
fourth place), which was implicated in eight cases of adverse involved neonates (less than 1 month old). Same, Anderson
reactions, including several serious cases: one oesophageal et al. [7], who analysed all published studies and case reports
ulcer, one erosive gastritis, one meningeal haemorrhage and on adverse events in infants caused by medications in breast
one renal insufficiency. The list also includes several antiep- milk, showed that 63 % of reported cases were in neonates.
ileptic drugs: lamotrigine, which was associated with sedation, The metabolic system is immature during the neonatal period
hypotonia and weight loss; valproic acid, clonazepam; carba- resulting in a longer half-life of drugs in neonates than in older
mazepine and topiramate. Vitamins and mineral (ascorbic children. This may account for the higher frequency of noti-
acid, iron, vitamin D and vitamin A) were always associated fication of adverse drug reactions in neonates. The mean
with other more suspected drugs. Two cases of ADRs (1.1 %) weights and heights of the affected children were lower than
had a ‘certain’ causality score (I4) and 13 (7.5 %) a ‘likely’ would be expected given the mean age of the children. Indeed,
score (I3). Cases of serious ADRs with the higher causality based on body mass index curves, children of this age should
scores (I3 ‘likely’ and I4 ‘certain’) were presented in Table 2. weigh almost a kilo more than the actual weight of these
children [11]. This may reflect a higher rate of prematurity
among these children than in the general population [1], and
Discussion prematurity has indeed been identified as a factor of suscep-
tibility to drugs in children.
This study shows that ADRs via breastfeeding are rarely Despite the position of paracetamol at the top of the table of
reported. At least, two-thirds of reported cases were in neo- drugs most frequently identified in adverse drug reactions, this
nates. ‘Central nervous system’ drugs accounted for more than drug was almost invariably not itself directly implicated in the
a third of all ADRs. effect, but rather was a component of a formulation also
Our study is subject to several limitations relating to the use contained a more suspect active ingredient (such as
of the National Pharmacovigilance Database. There is known dextropropoxyphene in particular). The list of drugs respon-
to be considerable underreporting of adverse drug reactions, sible for adverse effects in breastfed children includes ‘expect-
and the adverse reactions listed in the FPVD are thought to ed drugs’, for which data consistent with our observations in
account for only about 6 to 10 % of the total number of this study have already been published; ‘unexpected drugs’,
adverse drug reactions occurring in reality [9]. However, this for which published data are currently reassuring or for which
Eur J Clin Pharmacol (2014) 70:1361–1366 1365
Table 2 Serious ADRs with the higher causality scores I3 (‘likely’) and I4 (‘certain’)
Causality score Suspected drugs Associated drugs ADRs Sex Age Outcome
little or no published information is currently available and risk of accumulation in the milk of the active metabolite of this
‘drugs to avoid’, for which the risk was always higher than the drug, norpropoxyphene, which has a long clearance half-life.
benefit. These examples highlight the problem of using opiate analge-
Some drugs are known to have unfavourable pharmacoki- sics during breastfeeding, particularly for long-term treatment.
netic and pharmacological profiles during breastfeeding. In Benzodiazepines, which are known to pass into breast
our study, as in the Ito et al study [6], expected and serious milk, have been identified in cases of adverse reactions fol-
adverse drug reactions for a certain number of these drugs lowing exposure through breast milk [19]. Benzodiazepines
were observed. This was the case for antiepileptic drugs, with a long half-life and active metabolites present the greatest
which constituted the drug class most frequently implicated risk during the breastfeeding period. As in the Rubin et al.
in the occurrence of adverse reactions. Antiepileptics are study [19], we observed adverse reactions, mostly apnoea and
among the drugs for which use during breastfeeding can be hypotonia, expected with this drug class.
most strongly questioned, due to their pharmacokinetics and Electronic supplementary material
their potentially serious adverse reactions. Lamotrigine was Some of the other drugs identified were more ‘unexpected’.
the antiepileptic drug most frequently implicated in the occur- This was the case, in particular, for ketoprofen, a non-steroidal
rence of adverse reactions. It was implicated in several ‘ex- anti-inflammatory drug. In our study, it was the third in the list
pected’ serious adverse drug reactions, such as depression of of drugs most frequently implicated in adverse drug reactions.
the central nervous system and liver damage. Apnoea, with- Most of the adverse reactions it caused were serious and
drawal reactions and an increase in hepatic enzyme activity typical of its pharmacological effects: oesophageal ulcer, ero-
have been reported in children breastfed by mothers receiving sive gastritis, meningeal haemorrhage and acute renal insuffi-
lamotrigine treatment [12–14]. In terms of pharmacokinetics, ciency. No particular event has previously been reported in the
lamotrigine is found in the serum of children breastfed by literature for children breastfed by mothers treated with
treated mothers, at concentrations of up to 74 % of the serum ketoprofen. A pharmacokinetic study has shown that only
concentration of the drug in the mother [15]. 0.3 % of ketoprofen passes into breast milk [20]; this study
Dextropropoxyphene, an opiate analgesic withdrawn from was carried out in women just after delivery. It would be
the French market in 2011, was also implicated in a large interesting to obtain data about the passage of this drug into
number of adverse reactions in this study: all the adverse breast milk in the longer term, given the disturbing nature of
reactions described were consistent with those well known the cases of adverse reaction we report.
of opiates: apnoea, respiratory distress, sedation, bradycardia Hydroxyzine was also characterised by the large number
and constipation. Cases of sedation, apnoea, bradycardia and and seriousness of the adverse reactions in which it was
cyanosis after the use of dextropropoxyphene by the mother implicated. Hydroxyzine is an antagonist of central and pe-
have been also reported in the literature [4–16]. Codeine, ripheral H1 receptors, with anticholinergic properties. In
another weak opiate analgesic, has been implicated in the France, it is indicated and often used as an anxiolytic. We
death of one breastfed child [17]; the mother and child found no relevant published data for this drug, particularly as
belonged to a subpopulation of ultrarapid CYP2D6 concerns its passage into breast milk. Nevertheless, it was the
metabolisers, and codeine is partly metabolised by the third most frequently implicated drug in adverse drug reac-
CYP2D6 pathway, to yield morphine. In terms of pharmaco- tions, with a frequency similar to that of ketoprofen. Half the
kinetics, despite the passage of only small quantities of adverse reactions involving hydroxyzine was serious. The
dextropropoxyphene into maternal milk [18], there remains a adverse reactions recorded were consistent with the known
1366 Eur J Clin Pharmacol (2014) 70:1361–1366
mechanism of action of this drug: adverse central (sedation, 2. Bavoux F, Elefant E (1989) Undesirable effects of drugs during
breast feeding. Rev Prat 39:881–882
excitation), cardiovascular (malaise, with bradycardia and
3. Davanzo R, Dal Bo S, Bua J, Copertino M, Zanelli E, Matarazzo L
cyanosis) and gastrointestinal (including constipation in par- (2013) Antiepileptic drugs and breastfeeding. Ital J Pediatr 39:50
ticular) effects. 4. Sachs HC, Committee on drugs (2013) The transfer of drugs and
We also observed apparent adverse reactions of drugs for therapeutics into human breast milk: an update on selected topics.
Pediatrics 132:e796–e809
which the benefit/risk ratio is not favourable in breastfeeding
5. Lacroix I, Arrault-Olanora A, Berrebi A, Montastruc J-L, Damase-
women. These drugs were mostly available over the counter, Michel C (2005) Drug use during postpartum period: a comparative
without a prescription. For example, pseudoephedrine, study between lactating and non-lactating women. J Pediatr 18:379–
pheniramine and oxomemazine are indicated for the treatment 385
6. Ito S, Blajchman A, Stephenson M, Eliopoulos C, Koren G
of colds and coughs. As previously reported, we found that
(1993) Prospective follow-up of adverse reactions in breast-fed
pseudoephedrine was implicated in states of agitation in neo- infants exposed to maternal medication. Am J Obstet Gynecol
nates [6]. These drugs should be avoided during 168:1393–1399
breastfeeding, given the benign nature of their indications 7. Anderson PO, Pochop SL, Manoguerra AS (2003) Adverse drug
reactions in breastfed infants: less than imagined. Clin Pediatr
and the potential adverse drug reactions they may cause.
(Phila) 42:325–340
8. Begaud B, Evreux JC, Jouglard J, Lagier G (1985) Imputation of the
unexpected or toxic effects of drugs. Actualization of the method
Conclusion used in France. Therapie 40:111–118
9. Begaud B, Martin K, Haramburu F, Moore N (2002) Rates of
spontaneous reporting of adverse drug reactions in France. JAMA
This study describes, over a long period, the cases of adverse 288:1588
drug reactions occurring in children breastfed by mothers 10. Hale TW (2008) Medications and mothers ‘milk, tenth edition.
using drugs. Its results confirm that certain drugs should be Pharmasoft publishing 1172p
avoided during breastfeeding, or at least used with precaution 11. Cole T, Bellizzi MC, Flegal KM, Dietz WH (2000) Establishing a
standard definition for child overweight and obesity worldwide:
in certain circumstances. The drugs concerned include antiep- international survey. Br Med J 320:1240–1243
ileptic drugs, opiate analgesics and benzodiazepines. The 12. Newport DJ, Pennell PB, Calamaras MR, Ritchie JC, Newman M,
results also show that other drugs that were thought to be Knight B, Viguera AC, Liporace J, Stowe ZN (2008) Lamotrigine in
more anodyne, or for which no data are currently available, breast milk and nursing infants: determination of exposure. Pediatrics
122:223–231
may also be involved in adverse reactions and should there- 13. Nordmo E, Aronsen L, Wasland K, Småbrekke L, Vorren S (2009)
fore be avoided during breastfeeding, including ketoprofen Severe apnea in an infant exposed to lamotrigine in breast milk. Ann
and hydroxyzine. Pharmacother 43:1893–1897
Finally, this study shows that certain drugs, such as pseu- 14. Precourt A, Morin C (2011) Use of lamotrigine during breastfeeding:
descriptive analysis of our population and report of five cases of
doephedrine, which should not be used by breastfeeding premature neonates. Breastfeed Med 6:S-18
women, were nevertheless involved in a number of the report- 15. Kacirova I, Grundmann M, Brozmanova H (2011) Serum levels of
ed adverse reactions. These findings highlight the need for lamotrigine in breastfeeding mothers, maternal milk and nursed
additional pharmacokinetic, clinical and epidemiological data, infants. Basic Clin Pharmacol Toxicol 109:135–136
16. Naumburg EG, Meny RG (1988) Breast milk opioids and neonatal
given the scarcity of relevant published studies. They also apnea. Am J Dis Child 142:11–12
indicate that more and better information need to be provided 17. Koren G, Cairns J, Chitayat D, Gaedigk A, Leeder SJ (2006)
to the general public concerning drugs and self-medication Pharmacogenetics of morphine poisoning in a breastfed neonate of
while breastfeeding. a codeine-prescribed mother. Lancet 368:704
18. Kunka RL, Yong CL, Ladik CF, Bates TR (1985) Liquid chromato-
graphic determination of propoxyphene and norpropoxyphene in
plasma and breast milk. J Pharm Sci 74:103–104
19. Rubin ET, Lee A, Ito S (2004) When breastfeeding mothers need
References CNS-acting drugs. Can J Clin Pharmacol 11:257–266
20. Jacqz-Aigrain E, Serreau R, Boissinot C, Popon M, Sobel A, Michel
J, Sibony O (2007) Excretion of ketoprofen and nalbuphine in human
1. Ministère de la Santé. Enquête nationale périnatale (2010) http:// milk during treatment of maternal pain after delivery. Ther Drug
www.sante.gouv.fr Monit 29:815–818