Sonnet-The Lotus

Love came to Flora asking for a flower

That would of flowers be undisputed queen,

The lily and the rose, long, long had been

Rivals for that high honour. Bards of power

Had sung their claims. “The rose can never tower

Like the pale lily with her Juno mien”-

“But is the lily lovelier?” Thus between

Flower-factions rang the strife in Psyche’s bower.

  “Give me a flower delicious as the rose

And stately as the lily in her pride”-

“But of what colour?”- “Rose-red,” Love first chose,

Then prayed, -“No, lily-white,-or, both provide”;

  And Flora gave the lotus, “rose-red” dyed,

And “lily-white,”- the queenliest flower that blows.

~Toru Dutt

_________________________________________________________________________

Explication of “The Lotus”

Toru Dutt was an educated young woman who had traveled to Britain and France during her childhood.  British
literature and culture influenced her and is demonstrated in various work by Toru, including “The Lotus”.  In the
poem, Toru presents the idea that the lotus is the most beautiful of all flowers in order to establish superiority of
the Hindu religion over other world religions.

“The Lotus”, begins with a conflict between the rose and the lily flower.  The goddess of love, Aphrodite,
approached the flower goddess, Flora to create a flower who would undisputedly be the queenliest of all flowers. 
Both the lily and the rose, used their “bards of power” in their fight over the queenliest flower title.  Bards is
associated with Gaelic spiritual power traditions of England, Scotland and Ireland.  Toru uses Greek and Roman
mythology as support for her Hindu beliefs and to establish her stand.   The rose is described as never reaching
the level of the lily flower, because the lily has a strong willed demeanor.

In line 8 of the poem, we reach the climax where all the flower groups form cliques in a bitter conflict within the
soul’s essence.  The goddess Flora is given a task of creating a flower as “delicious as the rose” and “stately as the
lily in her pride” (Dutt, 82)    Lines 9-14 of the poem, describes the solution to the problem of finding the
queenliest flower of all.   Toru has Flora create a flower that is both red as a rose and white as a lily.  As a result,
Flora creates a flower with the characteristics of a rose and a lily combined and created the beautiful lotus flower.

Why did Toru chose the lotus flower as the queenliest of all flowers?  The lotus is a national symbol of India and
the Hindu faith.  The overall theme of the poem is the pride of India’s culture and Hindu religion. The idea of
Hindu being the ultimate religion of the world is the main focus of “The Lotus”.   Hinduism is polytheistic in
nature and beliefs are practiced through idol worship.  The idols can be human, animal or natural, such as the
Sun God. Each idol has a form of symbolism, which represents knowledge, wealth, and strength among a few
things (Mullatti)  Toru wanted to acknowledge her Indian background for others to understand her love for her
native country India.  Although she had traveled and received her education abroad during her childhood, she
still believes India to be her home.   Indian tradition explains the lotus flower springs not from the earth but from
the surface of the water and will remain pure and unblemished, not matter the impurity of the water.  The purity
of the lotus expresses the idea of supernatural birth and the appearance of the first created entity from the ancient
waters of chaos, thus the lotus is observed as the medium of the Hindu creator Narayana and his second being
God Brahma (Mitra & Kaporr, 126).    Toru uses the idea of Greek and Roman goddesses to create a western
understanding of Hinduism and its divine faith of the lotus.

Toru had an ability to excel in her writing at a young age and is one of the most famous Indo-Anglican poets of
India.  She mastered “The Lotus” in a Petrarchan style by separating the poem into two divisions, the Octave and
the Sestet.  Toru was able to present the problem of searching for the queenliest flower in the octave, which was
composed of the first 8 lines and resolved the issue by creating the lotus in the sestet, which consists of the last 6
lines.  She uses the rose and the lily in the poem to describe the West and the East.  The “lily” is a representation
of the white race and the “rose” depicting the reddish skin tone of the eastern race, such as her native India.  Thus
the poem “The Lotus” indicates a fusion between the West and East (Dutt, 82).  Although Toru herself was raised
as a Christian with western ideology, she was able to relate herself back to her Eastern roots of India in the
sonnet.  The lotus is a representation of Toru and her cultural encounters living in Western Europe (Dutt, 82). 
She interlaces her Western experience and education in order to create herself as her beautiful native Indian lotus
flower.