Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bangladesh
ARTICLEINFO ABSTRACT
Keywords: This study investigates the factors influencing of
Facebook advertising on millennials purchase behavior
Facebook advertising, focusing fashion accessories, photography and event
intention-to- management services in Bangladesh. The study uses
purchase, both quantitative and qualitative approach to collect
Hierarchy of effects data through questionnaire based survey from 327
model, millennial Facebook users to determine their purchase
Bangladesh, intention while interacting with Facebook advertising.
Millennials, This paper focuses theory of planned behavior, theory
Fashion accessory, of reasoned action developed by Ajzen and Fishbein
Photography and (1980), hierarchy-of-effects model by Lavidge and
event Management Steiner (1961) and builds on adapting previous models
services, proposed by several researchers on purchase intention.
Alignment BSC, This paper presents a new conceptual model adding
Critical Success two new constructs grasping Bangladeshi millennials
Factors interest with Facebook adverts. Reliability and validity
analysis, factor analysis, goodness of fit, analysis of
variance and linear regression analysis measure
hypothesis, using SPSS 22. The result reveals,
businesses should carefully manage Facebook ads with
personalized customer engagement and reward
influencer customers.
Introduction
Worldwide 2.23 monthly active Facebook users until July, 2018; hosting over a half of
the world’s population in which 92% marketers agreed this is the best social media that
cultivates high engagement (Jolly, 2018; Wronski & Goldestruck, 2013). Millenials
(born between 1982 and 1994) have been manifested to an outburst of online
technological applications since childhood (Duffett, 2015). 50% millennials log-in to
Facebook waking up daily, revealing how they influenced to this social site (McNair,
2018). This study focuses on Facebook users in Bangladesh, where 38% deemed to be
millennials (www.btrc.gov.bd, 2018). 137.2 million Internet enabled mobile connection
results 83% of total till December 2017 in Bangladesh, posing high demand to
investigate online shopping behavior of these influential populations (Mallick, 2018).
Furthermore, Facebook revenue from advertising has grown by $22 billion and total
Facebook ad budget is 82.9% in 2018; 85% profits emerged from South-Asian countries
(Osman, 2018; McNair, 2018). This paper builds on previous research of Ajzen and
Fishbein (1980), Lavidge & Steiner (1961), Duffet (2015), Richard & Guppy (2014) and
Hosein (2011) adapted the theory of reasoned action (TRA), planned behavior (TPB)
and hierarchy of effects model with the aim of developing a model where Facebook
advertising of fashion accessory, photography and event management; influence
purchase intention representing new optimization of overall marketing communication
efforts towards millennials. This paper’s contributions mainly in the development of a
model for Facebook advertising blending the traditional marketing theory with new
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
39
Literature Review
Underpinning Theories
Theory of Reasoned Action and Theory of Planned Behavior (TRA and
TPB)
Ajzen and Fishbein’s (1980) most influential models of theory of reasoned action (TRA)
and theory of planned behavior (TPB) has been practiced and experimented widely for
predicting the online behavior impacted by some independent variables by Facebook
advertisement (Hosein, 2011; Raza et.al., 2014; Ketabi et al., 2014). Friends, family
members and colleague are considered as positive influence individuals to buy online as
subjective norms (Hasbullah, 2016). Ajzen & Fishbein (1980) proved that subjective
norm is considered as perceived pressure imposed by others with direct-indirect
influence. This model enormously supported by consumer behavior and social
psychology associated literature which is adopted by marketing academics affecting
future purchase consideration (Ketabi et al., 2014; Raza et al., 2014; Hosein, 2011). In
this research paper, the investigation is whether the attitude, attention (personal
factors), Facebook advertisements information availability, influencer marketing and
boosting strategy (social factors) influence Bangladeshi millennials purchase intentions
dominating final volitional purchase behavior of fashion accessories, photography and
event management services. These three specific areas are selected because these are
most frequent purchase products and services in Bangladesh based on researcher’s
observations upon Bangladeshi Facebook users. Attitudes and Hierarchy of
Response Model
The hierarchy of effects Model was created in 1961 by Robert J Lavidge and Gary A
Steiner. Several academics explored attitude changed due to general advertisings and
Facebook ads influence critically users brand attitude formation and shopping behavior
(Duffet & Wakeham, 2016; Chu, 2011). The adapted hierarchy response model proposes
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
40
that consumer experience a series of attitudinal stages from cognitive (awareness and
knowledge) to affective (liking and preference), and finally behavioral (intention-to-
purchase and purchase) in response to marketing communications (Chowdhury, 2016;
Duffet & Wakeham, 2016; Hudson & Hudson, 2013; Hassan et al, 2013; Yadav et. al,
2013; Smith 2013). At cognitive stage product contents, key benefits or brand attributes
engage Facebook users through awareness, information processing identifying personal
connection (Mansfield, 2014; Hubble, 2018). Emotional bonding with FB fan pages
shaping target user’s lifestyle-values at affective stage and blending of intellect and
emotions heading toward final adoption at conative stage differentiate brand
showcasing among rivals to feel and associate the brand with personal identity (Jolly,
2018; Mansfield, 2014, Carrillat et al., 2014; Hardwick et al., 2014).
However, theories by previous academics of different dimensions of purchase
intentions supports the theoretical foundation that millennials develop positive
attitudes toward the content and finally encouraged to purchase. The present scenario
of many users of Facebook indicates that, most millennials visit and curious about fan
pages, participate groups, share contents on news feed. Attitudes towards social media
marketing communications have not been suitably measured in Bangladesh like
developing countries in terms of the hierarchy response models stages specifically for
millennials. However prior studies have not focused on Facebook advertised products
purchase intentions on millennials most evaluated lifestyle, photography, event
management services in developing country context. This research seeks to disclose
whether Facebook advertising has a positive effect on the top two levels of the
communications of effect model cognitive and affective (awareness, knowledge, liking
and preference).
Facebook Advertisements’ Effectiveness and Millennials in Bangladesh
Millennials considered to 2.5 times more likely to be an adopter of technology than
generations past who influence the driving sales of present marketing environment in a
prominent way (Ledbetter, 2017). Millennials also referred as “Generation Y”, “Echo
Boomers” (as they are the children of “baby boomers” containing largest generation)
and “Digital natives” who mostly prefer to spend the adulthood having the latest
technological devices and Internet related activities in personal tech devices (Patel,
2018). 18-24 years of people age of Bangladesh are the major Facebook users and out of
the total 2.80 million Facebook users in Bangladesh, 1.37 million are young around
50% of total and 29% users’ aged 25-34 years (www.socialbakers.com, 2018; Halim
2017). A recent research shows that 53% of millennial households already have children
and one in four of them are parents today (www.millennialmarketing.com, 2018). So
their pattern of living, life styles, favoring any brands and viewpoints impact the
nourishment of their children’s; thus it’s become critical to analyze this gigantic
population’s behavior.
Dhaka has been ranked second in terms of having the most active Facebook users in the
world according to Global Digital Statshot of Q2 report of 2017 more than 60%
population counted as millennials aged between 18 to 35 (Tarik, 2018). McNair (2018)
reports to e-marketers that TV ad spending will drop to 0.5% and Facebook will
generate $21.00 billion in ad revenues, up 16.9%; by 2019 Google and Facebook will
have combined ad revenues greater that of TV ad spending. 87.87% Facebook users in
Bangladesh of total population use Internet only to access Facebook
(www.gs.statcounter.com, 2018; Rahman, 2015). By realizing recent purchasing pattern
of this huge number of young populations, the marketers of Bangladesh investigate the
millennials choice of brand purchasing mainly in online. Rehman et al. (2014)
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
41
described that, “Because of its popularity, businesses are placing their ads on Facebook
for creating awareness and influencing buying behavior”. One in five Facebook users
had purchased products as a result of advertisements and comments that they viewed
on Facebook (Patel, 2018). Facebook Pages were specifically engineered for businesses
as public home to on-time publish content and receive comments and feedback from
fans and customers (Kolowich, 2017). Among lots of online shopping portal Facebook is
the best shopping medium providing trouble free shopping experience (Zabeen et. al.,
2013). 4G service in 2018 added significant attribute regarding F-Commerce and 70%
F-stores got familiarity.
No research, both in Bangladesh and internationally has examined empirically the
relationship among Bangladeshi millennial’s (who are the 25% share of Bangladeshi
population and 0.8% share of the World Internet users) attitude, interest, preference
towards Facebook advertising in fashion accessories, photography and event
management. Therefore, marketers in Bangladesh and globally should consider this
study significantly.
Information availability
Facebook ad reporting ad revenue of $40 billion in 2017 and in 2018 90% FB ad
revenue comes from mobile based Facebook advertising from 1.15 billion daily active
users where ease of getting updated information is influential factor (Wagner, 2018).
Information availability vitally dominates consumer decision-making process
moreover, 46% millennials themselves post original photos and videos online by self-
creation (Song, 2018; www.millennialmarketing.com, 2018). Users can evaluate or seek
out the best deal through Facebook via recommendations or previous experience of
friends or followers, compare prices, other convenient parameters; A/B testing of
Facebook power editor, lead generation, creativity, conversion measurement including
Facebook pixel (Glover, 2018). Thus it does appear that information availability of
Facebook pages and promotions as independent variable, influence millennials
purchase intentions. So it is realistic to hypothesis that:
H3: Information availability of Facebook advertisement towards millennials in
Bangladesh has strong association with intention to purchase.
Influencer Marketing
Song (2018) notes that, “Influencer marketing is the process of identifying, researching,
engaging and supporting the people who create high-impact conversations with
customers about your brand, products or services.” Additionally, anyone who has
positive feeling among his/her follower, friends or liked by; can share opinion and
content thus become an influencer (O’Neil, 2018; Yodel, 2017). Influencer marketing
applies word-of-mouth to leverage influence among friend and family, breaking online
clutter, creating relevant customer dialogue and bringing trust to the brands (Pollak,
2018; Drake, 2017). Presently peoples are submerged in highly social web where,
information travels like waves; and influencers are the wave makers as they have bunch
of followers (Wharton, 2018). In Nielsen research, a study found 92% consumers trust
word-of-mouth recommendations above all advertising forms (Wagner, 2018). But
having huge quantity of followers is not appealing moreover desired quality is needed
(Drake, 2017). Influence means by advertising summing up three combinations of “R”-
reach, relevance and resonance (Zheng, 2018). Bevy of tools to navigate influencer
marketing spheres for social reach, influential blogs, automated research, engagement
persuasion; such as, Klout and GroupHigh (Song, 2018). This is true for popular
photographer, lifestyle fashion products, event organizer also. However, prior studies
have not focused on this application for developing country context towards millennials
purchase intentions, thus it can be hypothesized that:
H4: Influencer marketing of Facebook advertisement towards millennials of
Bangladesh has strong association with intention to purchase.
Boosting strategy
The millennials have dependence on Internet in such a way that, if they don’t know any
answer to a question, they simply “Google it” that shape engagement with purchase
decisions (Fromm & Lantos, 2014). Pickowicz (2017) says that “Boost Posts, is a type of
Facebook Advertising that allows companies to choose a post and have it distributed in
the News Feed to anyone they want, based on interests, demographics.” This reveals
like; if any brand doesn’t have a responsive online presence in today’s world it does not
even exists in world. Aminul Hakim, the president of Internet Service Provider’s
Association of Bangladesh, says that, 88 GB of the country’s total available 436 GB
bandwidth is used for Facebook (www.dhakatribune.com, 2017). Facebook converts
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
43
“cold audiences” to “warm audience” (Baranova, 2017). Facebok pixel, optins, sales,
enquiries are some available tools to track conversations resulted by boost post (Patel,
2018). Logging on 8 times more daily, millennials encounter boost video posts from 3
million business covering 93% Bangladeshi marketers (Pickowicz, 2018; Vahl, 2014).
Weekdays than weekends and afternoons between 1p.m and 3p.m. tend to be the
preferred times to log on (Osman, 2018). Facebook demographics, carousal ads, offers
and homepage ads, video ads, lead ads, custom audience remarketing strategies are
some sorts of boosting approaches applied by present fashion products and other event
marketers (Sorokina, 2014; O’neil, 2018). Millennials in Bangladesh have huge
conversions presently in shaping dramatic change of Facebook business (Tarik, 2018).
After meticulous review of updated Facebook analysis, boosting strategy is newly added
to the model for the appropriate outcome influencing intention-to-purchase which is
previously overlooked by academics. Therefore,
H5: Facebook boosting strategy towards millennials of Bangladesh has strong
association with intention to purchase.
The above discussion thus leads to develop a conceptual model for the study:
Attitude
Attention
Intention to Purchase
Information availability
Influencer marketing
Boosting strategy
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
44
Table 2 and 3 show the results of the validity and reliability analysis where (1) all
research variables exceed the minimum standard of Kaiser-Mayer-Olkin’s value of 0.55
indicating sufficient correlations Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity (x2=3398.008, p<0.01)
(2) all research variables has Eigen values larger than 1 and total variance explained
was 50.72% of the total variance (3) the items for each variable exceed factor loadings
of 0.55 on one factor and 0.3 or lower the other factors (Williams, Onsman & Brown,
2010) and (4) all the research variables meet the acceptable standard of 0.60 (Chetty &
Datt, 2015; Vinerean et al., 2013). These statistical results support the validity and
reliability of the questionnaire and signifying the goodness of data for this study.
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
46
ANOVA defines information about the model by investigating how the Facebook
advertisements effect with three age groups of millennials in Bangladesh (independent
variable) variables interact with each other and the effects of interactions upon
intention to purchase (dependent variable). According to F test, “FB_ad_effect” and
“age-group” have a statistically significant effect on the dependent variable, “intention
to-purchase” in table 7.
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
47
strategy_21
Boosting .124 .050 .136 2.493 .013 .026 .222
strategy_22
Boosting .113 .042 .132 2.709 .007 .031 .195
strategy_23
Boosting .138 .050 .149 2.736 .007 .039 .237
strategy_24
Boosting .130 .048 .144 2.711 .007 .036 .224
strategy_25
Boosting .055 .059 .044 .927 .355 -.061 .171
strategy_26
Boosting .082 .045 .097 1.849 .065 -.005 .170
strategy_27
a. Dependent Variable: I'm interested to buy a specific brand of fashion accessories,
photography & event mgt services by FB ad.
Table 6 displays the estimates for parameters included in the overall model and their
individual effects on the dependent variable, intention to purchase. Most notably, the
millennials who watch live videos, share contents, follow the fan pages, search
information on the Facebook; have a positive increase in purchase intentions
influenced by Facebook advertisements of fashion accessories, photography & event
management service.
Table 7 Multiple regression analysis results and hypothesis testing
Hypothesis Standardized t Sig. Supported
Coefficients
Beta P-
value
H1: Attitudes of millennials in Bangladesh 0.220 3.787 0.000 Yes
towards Facebook ad will have a
significant and positive association with
intention to purchase.
H2: Attention towards Facebook 0.143 2.501 0.013 Yes
advertisement of millennials in
Bangladesh will have a significant and
positive association with intention to
purchase.
H3: Information availability of Facebook 0.204 3.795 0.000 Yes
advertisement towards millennials in
Bangladesh will have a significant and
positive association with intention to
purchase.
H4: Influencer marketing of Facebook 0.147 2.639 0.009 Yes
advertisement towards millennials of
Bangladesh will have a significant and
positive association with intention to
purchase.
H5: Facebook boosting strategy towards 0.173 3.148 0.002 Yes
millennials of Bangladesh will have a
significant and positive association with
intention to purchase.
As table 7 of multiple regression analysis results and hypothesis testing, attitudes and
information availability of millennials in Bangladesh towards Facebook advertisement
of fashion products and services of photography-event management has largest impact
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
49
on Bangladeshi millennials purchase intention with B-value of 0.220 and 0.204 (p-
value=0.000 < 0.05, both). This clear that, there is a significant and positive
association with intention to purchase of millennials attitudes and Facebook
advertisements information availability. Boosting strategy having B-value= 0.173 (p-
value= 0.002 < 0.05) is significantly influence purchase intentions. Influencer
marketing (B-value=0.147, p-value=0.009 <0.05) and millennials attention (B-
value=0.143, p-value=0.013 <0.05) towards Facebook advertisement also significantly
and positively effects purchase intentions of fashion accessories, photography and event
management services. Consequently, hypothesis 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 are supported and
accepted; there is a significant and positive association of each of the independent
variables with purchase intentions.
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
50
Notes
http://gs.statcounter.com/social-media-stats/all/bangladesh. [Accessed on 20 June, 2018]
http://www.btrc.gov.bd/content/internet-subscribers-bangladesh-january-2018 [Accessed on
20 July, 2018]
https://www.socialbakers.com/social-media-content./2018. [Accessed on 20 June, 2018]
http://www.dhakatribune.com/feature/tech/2017/09/06/2-active-facebook-users-
bangladesh/. [Accessed on 20 August, 2018]
http://www.millennialmarketing.com/who-are-millennials [Accessed on 23 August, 2018]
References
Ahmed, G. (2017, May 18). Impact of advertising towards consumers purchase intentions.
Retrieved from: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/impact-advertisement-consumers-
purchase-intentions-ghufran-ahmed. [Accessed on 16 May, 2018]
Ajzen, I. & Fishbein, M. (1980). Understanding attitudes and predicting social behavior,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Printice Hall.
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
51
Baranova, T. (2017, August 3). 7 reasons why Facebook post boosting is a great strategy to use.
Retrieved from: http://tamarabaranova.com/7-reasons-why-facebook-post-boosting-
great-strategy/. [Accessed on 21 May 2018]
Carrillat, A.F., d’Astous, A. and Grégoire, E.M. (2014), Leveraging social media to enhance
recruitment effectiveness: a Facebook experiment. Internet Research, 24(4), 86-
123. https://doi.org/10.1108/IntR-07-2013-0142.
Cherry, K. (2018, February 24). How Psychologists Define Attention: Understanding the Key
Points About Attention. Retrieved From: https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-
attention-2795009. [Accessed on 17 May 2018]
Chetty, P. & Datt, S. (2017, February 7). Reliability Test in SPSS using Cornbach Alpha.
Retrieved From: https://www.projectguru.in/publications/reliability-test-cronbach-
alpha/. [Accessed on 4 June, 20182018]
Chowdhury, H.M. (2016). Impact of Facebook on Online Advertisement: A study on
Bangladeshi Users. Scholar journal of Business and Social Science, 2(1), pp. 1-6.
Chu, S. (2013). Viral Advertising in Social Media: Participation in Facebok Groups and response
Among College-aged Users. Journal of Interactive Advertising, American Academy
of Advertising. 12(1), 30-43. https://doi.org/10.1080/15252019.2011.10722189.
Conran, J. (2014, October 13). How to Grab Your Target's Attention in 8 Seconds (or Less)?
Retrieved from: https://www.inc.com/joshua-conran/how-to-grab-your-target-s-
attention-in-8-seconds-or-less.html. [Accessed on 17 May 2018]
Dada, A.G. (2017, November 14). What Is Influencer Marketing and How Can Marketers Use It
Effectively? Retrieved From:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbescommunicationscouncil/2017/11/14/what-is-
influencer-marketing-and-how-can-marketers-use-it-effectively/#6a7a633923d1.
[Accessed on 19 May 2018]
Drake, S (2017, December 12). Ads Are Out, Influencers Are in: How to Find the Right
Influencers for Your Brand. Retrieved From:
http://www.millennialmarketing.com/2017/12/ads-are-out-influencers-are-in-how-to-
find-the-right-influencers-for-your-brand/. [Accessed on 19 May 2018]
Duffett, R. G. and Wakeham, M. (2016). Social Media Marketing Communications Effect on
Attitudes Among Millennials in South Africa. The African Journal of Information
Systems, 8 (3), 20-44. Retrieved From:
http://digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/ajis/vol8/iss3/2.
Duffett, G. R. (2015). Facebook advertising’s influence on intention-to-purchase and
purchase amongst Millennials. Journals of Internet Research, Emerald Group
Publishing Limited, 25(4), 498-499, https://doi.org/10.1108/IntR-01-2014-0020.
Fromm, G. and Lantos, P. G. (2014). Marketing to Millennials: Reach the largest and most
influential generation of consumers ever. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 31(5), 401-
403. https://doi.org/10.1108/JCM-03-2014-0909.
Glover, E. (2018, February 6). Facebook advertising- advantages and disadvantages. Retrieved
From:https://www.hallaminternet.com/facebook-advertising-advantages-
disadvantages/ [Accessed on 17 May 2018]
Halim, A. H. (2017, September 7). Only 2% active Facebook user in Bangladesh. Retrieved
From:https://www.dhakatribune.com/feature/tech/2017/09/06/2-active-facebook-
users-bangladesh/. [Accessed on 30 June 2018]
Hall, S. (2017, September 29). What is the purpose of factor analysis? Retrieved From:
https://sciencing.com/what-is-the-purpose-of-factor-analysis-12225143.html.
Hardwick, J., Delarue, L., Ardley, B., & Taylor, N. (2014). Computer-Mediated Marketing
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
52
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
54
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
55
Available on SSRN-Elsevier
56