Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Subscribe
Designing and Impl ement ing Solut ions Wi t h Globa l Pos i t ioning Te chnologi es
INTEGRATION:
INTEGRATION: SYSTEM:
SYSTEM: IN REVIEW
REVIEW: INNOVA
INNOVATION:
TION:
Bluetooth & GPS Meeting Civil Needs Precision Revolution Something Old & New
Structural
Structural
Monitoring
Mo itoring
GPS Installations
Installa
Installations
Create Powe
Create Powerful
rful Data
Data
PUBLICATION
ADVANSTAR
©Reprinted from GPS WORLD, September 2003 AN ADVANSTAR ★ PUBLICATION Printed in U.S.A.
AN
APPLICATION CHALLENGE MONITORING BUILDINGS
The
Height of
Precision
Tall buildings are among the few
constructed facilities whose design
relies solely upon analytical and scaled
models. Home to many important
strides in the evolution of these struc-
tures — some say Chicago invented the
skyscraper — the “Windy City” provides
a fitting venue for full-scale investiga-
tions to improve understanding of these
structures and and their behavior under
wind conditions.
cutely sensitive to the effects of wind, tall buildings must be year events. This usually requires a building to be stiffened to
TABLE 1 Summary of calibration tests essential to assess system performance before full-
scale deployment. To determine sensor-pair accuracy
Test Description Purpose and identify the level of background noise, we con-
1a–c Static Background noise, influence of GDOP ducted nearly 40 static and dynamic calibration tests
2a–w Sine wave: 0.5 cm to Tracking ability over varying amplitudes, during spring 2002, in an open field sufficiently free
3.0 cm at 0.1 Hz to 1 Hz frequencies from potential sources of multipath error and with
3a Sinusoidal Chirp Ability to track complex signals limited obstructions to preserve a 15 mask angle.
3b Random Noise Ability to track complex signals Each choke ring antenna was mounted atop a
3c–3f Simulated structural Ability to track realistic building motions rigid wood mount, approximately 2.5 meters apart
responses along the North-South (N-S) direction, to avoid
4a–c Static with gas capsule Determine influence of in-line gas capsule shielding and still provide negligible baseline separa-
5 Sine wave: 2.0 cm Validate on-site coordinate tion errors. The rover unit’s mount was firmly affixed
at 0.2 Hz transformations
to a portable, displacement-controlled shake table
6a–b Static Determine influence of antenna mount
permitting introduction of a prescribed displacement
time history. N-S motions would be compared to
reference and rover. known table displacement to assess dynamic tracking
TABLE 2 Averaged statistics from static component With no clear line-of- ability. In this configuration, each dynamic test also
of calibration tests sight between the two provided a running measure of inherent background
and the noisy RF envi- noise, as the East-West (E-W) displacements were
Range 0.71 cm
ronment around the always static.
Mean Value 0.00 cm
rover, traditional radio Table 1 summarizes the tests. Static tests assessed
Standard Deviation 0.22 cm
telemetry links would the level of background noise in the system and the
be difficult to establish influence of geometric dilution of precision
and maintain. This (GDOP). Tests 2–3 affirmed validation of dynamic
GPS application, tracking ability for a variety of signals with different
intended for collection amplitudes (0.5–3 centimeters), frequencies (0.1–2
of displacement data in Hz), and waveform complexity. Tests 4–6 enabled us
varying wind events for to assess potential signal deterioration due to in-line
the evaluation of pre- surge protection, the accuracy of field coordinate
dictive design tools transformations, and mount elevation on the system
rather than for building performance.
operation, does not The static calibration studies captured the back-
require real-time capa- ground noise levels and resolution limits of the sys-
bility. So to avoid data tem, quantified by the statistics of motion detected
loss, we chose a more by the GPS when both the reference and rover were
FIELD conservative post-pro- held stationary over a range of GDOP conditions.
EXPERIMENTAL cessing option for the Table 2 summarizes the statistics of the displace-
VALIDATION of GPS prototyping phase. ments detected along this static direction in all the
sensor pair; inset closeup of We equipped both the reference and rover with a tests. From the studies, root mean square (RMS) sta-
shake table apparatus laptop running control-station software, remotely tic accuracy was found to be better than manufactur-
operated. Using this software, the system status can er specifications (see Figure 2), and any peak inaccu-
be continually checked, data acquisition direct to racies were at the sub-centimeter level.
the receiver’s PC card can be initiated, and any In the dynamic calibration testing, satisfactory
recorded data can then be downloaded from each tracking, when quantified in terms of averaged mea-
site to an off-site post-processing station at the sures like the standard deviation of the tracked dis-
University of Notre Dame. Here, software deter- placements, was achieved consistently for motions
mines the displacements of the rover relative to true above 1 centimeter. However, instantaneous statis-
North (N) and East (E) on a local coordinate tics like peak values are more difficult to capture,
grid, coincidentally aligning with the building’s two though they tend to be consistently identified for sig-
primary sway axes. The data is then processed, low- nals with amplitudes above 2 centimeters.
pass filtered to remove high frequency noise, and Figure 3 presents one example of the experimen-
then uploaded for analysis by authorized users at tal verification for a 0.1-Hz sine wave with varying
the project web site. amplitude levels. The RMS displacements were
In addition to bypassing communications compli- tracked in all four tests within 10 percent, though the
cations, the uncertainty information output by the peak values were best captured at the higher ampli-
post-processor also becomes a valuable tool in assess- tudes, as expected.
ing the reliability of the GPS displacement solution. In Test Series 3, a suite of tests determined the
Experimental Validation GPS tracking ability for simulated motions of tall
With any new sensing technology, calibrations are buildings under wind (sample shown in Figure 4). In
FIGURE 3 Verification of GPS dynamic tracking ability for sine wave at FIGURE 4 Verification of GPS dynamic tracking ability for simulated build-
0.1 Hz with amplitudes of motion from (a) ±0.5 cm, (b)±1.0 cm, (c) ±2.0 cm ing response at various times. GPS displacements blue, shaking-table motion
and (d) ±3.0 cm. GPS displacements blue, shaking table motion red. red
FIGURE 9 Example of
Position Quality Thresholds (green)
for evaluating reliability of GPS dis-
placements (light blue) of tall building
in Chicago on November 30, 2002
Acknowledgements
pied bandwidths distinct from
We are grateful for the financial support of the
other transmission sources
National Science Foundation (grant CMS 00-
onsite. In addition, recent
85109) and the University of Notre Dame. We
advances in the technology have
acknowledge project collaborators: the Boundary
further improved noise immuni-
Layer Wind Tunnel Laboratory, University of
ty and transmission security. We
Western Ontario in Canada; Skidmore Owings and
will therefore launch a pilot
Merrill LLP, Chicago; and Dr. Dae Kun Kwon,
study to assess the feasibility of
Tiphaine Williams, and Lijuan Wang of Notre
radio spread-spectrum wireless
Dame, who assisted with GPS testing and process-
radios to enable communica-
ing. This project would not be possible without the
tions between the reference and
cooperation and assistance of the building owners
rover stations and near real-time
and management of all the involved buildings.
displacement tracking in this
Thanks also to Mike Edwards and the Notre Dame
program.
Research Office, John Berkebile of the St. Joseph
Conclusion County, Indiana, Parks Department, and Leica
Just as Chicago’s skyline helped Geosystems staff for technical advice and support.
set the precedent for tall build-
Manufacturers
ings, these structures continue
The system used Leica Geosystems (Heerbrugg,
that innovative tradition by ush-
Switzerland) MC500 GPS receivers; Leica
ering in a new era in GPS mon-
AT504/International GPS Service (Pasadena,
itoring in the United States,
California) choke ring antenna; Leica ControlStation
advancing the current state-of-
software, remotely operated via PC Anywhere
the art in high-rise design.
(Symantec, Cupertino, California); Leica SKI-Pro
Through the Chicago full-scale
software; surge protection devices from
monitoring program, the first-
Huber+Suhner (Herisau, Switzerland); SA-107
ever systematic comparison of
LN accelerometers from Columbia Research
tall building response against finite element and
Laboratories, (Woodlyn, Pennsylvania);
wind tunnel models used in their design is currently
Campbell Scientific Inc. (Logan, Utah) CR23X
underway.
data logger; Matlab 6.1 (R 12) from Mathworks
In this program, we emphasize the need to cali-
(Natick, Massachusetts) and Java SDK 1.41-01 and
brate and experimentally validate any GPS sensor
Java Webstart 1.2 from Sun Microsystems, Inc.
before installation in full-scale, so that displacement
(Santa Clara, California).
tracking limitations and resolutions can be accurate-
ly benchmarked. As the accuracy of GPS continu-
TRACY KIJEWSKI-CORREA is Rooney Family Assistant Professor in the
ously fluctuates throughout the day due to the posi- Department of Civil Engineering and Geological Sciences at
tion and availability of satellites, it is especially University of Notre Dame, specializing in dynamic effects on struc-
important to provide some reliability measure, such tures and innovative monitoring technologies.
as PQTs. Ultimately, the ongoing collection of GPS
data and its assessment throughout this project will AHSAN KAREEM is Robert M. Moran Professor in the Department of
address the unique challenges facing applications in Civil Engineering and Geological Sciences at University of Notre
Dame and specializes in modeling, analysis and simulation of dynam-
dense urban environments.
ic load effects on structures under wind, waves and earthquakes.
GPS reference antenna
Copyright Notice Copyright by Advanstar Communications Inc. Advanstar Communications Inc. retains all rights to this article. This article may only be viewed or printed (1) for personal use. User may not actively
save any text or graphics/photos to local hard drives or duplicate this article in whole or in part, in any medium. Advanstar Communications Inc. home page is located at http://www.advanstar.com.