Comment (N°)

& Date
Doc Page Line/ Par. - Project Spec. Requirement / Siemens comment / Client Reply

Client Document and Revision number (D-R status)

Please do NOT delete this line
2 FS-2004A -- (Rev. 8) -- 1. FS-2004A Rev.8-piping design (Under Review) (B) Piping
1 15 (2.3) Spec Extract NDT Procedures
shall be submitted to the Company representative for review and approval.
Jan 10, 2017 Exception NDE procedures will be available at workshop for review but not sent for app
2 37/74 6.5 (2.7) Spec Extract Flanges shall be raised face up to #600 rating and shall be RTJ above #600 rati
Jan 12, 2017 Clarification D-R standard practice is to offer RTJ flanges for service rating 1500# and abov
implications.

3 '41/74 6.7 (2.8) Spec Extract Valve body of Cast material of Construction shall be 100% radiographed irres

Jan 12, 2017 Clarification 100% radiography on cast body will be performed with cost implications, for
comment for any further modifications.

4 3 FS 2004 A-- (Rev. 8) -- 2. Errata FS 2004 A-Rev-8-piping design (Commented) (B) Piping
11 3103-- (Rev. 4) -- 3103 LT Rev 4a Dtd 30.03.11 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
3/11 4.1.4 (11.2) Spec Extract 'All vent and drains of the transmitter/tubing/valve manifolds shall be routed
harmful fluids like chemical etc. then it will be routed to close drain header.

Jan 12, 2017 Clarification 'Routing of all drains to drain headers will be done with cost implications.

19 3207-- (Rev. 5) -- 3207 Turbine Flow Meter Rev 5 Dated 10.01.2014 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
20 3208-- (Rev. 4a) -- 3208 Coriolis MFM Rev 4a Dtd 31.03.11 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
(20.1) Spec Extract Entire document.
Jan 12, 2017 Clarification Not applicable to D-R scope of supply.

25 3300-- (Rev. 5) -- 3300 TG Rev 5 Dated 09.11.2012 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
4/12 4.6.3 (25.2) Spec Extract Thermowell flanges shall be of stainless steel and shall be rated one piping cl

Jan 12, 2017 Clarification Thermowell flange rating will be 300# however for service rating higher than

New Client Reply

30 3402-- (Rev. 2) -- 3402 PS Rev 2 date 18.02.08 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
3 4.0 SMART (31.1) Spec Extract 4.1.1 All the transmitter shall be SIL2 certified
TYPE
PRESSURE
TRANSMITTE
R:

Jan 05, 2017 Exception SIL2 certified transmitters shall be supplied if available.

New Client Reply

4 4.1.4 (31.2) Spec Extract All transmitters shall be provided with Digital integral output meters(with en
hazardous area.
Jan 05, 2017 Exception Dresser-Rand advise that standard package design does not include for LCD d

New Client Reply

4 4.1.10 (31.3) Spec Extract Transmitter shall be supplied with a 3 way 2 valve manifold. The Manifold sh

Jan 05, 2017 Exception Manifold can be from sourced other than same instrument vendor.

33 3501-- (Rev. 5) -- 3501 SDP Rev 5 Dated 31-08-2012 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
34 3502-- (Rev. 2a) -- 3502 TIC Rev 2a Dtd 31.03.2011 sht 0 (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation
Jan 04, 2017 Exception 'The 24 V DC power supply used within the UCP will have the negative side gr
As per change note all transmitters that can be Hart protocol will be converte
module are not available.
Devices will be either I.S. or Ex'd'.

Jan 04, 2017 Exception As above.

 4.6.5.1.2 (35.19) Spec Extract All pressure instruments shall be provided with individual block and bleed va

Jan 04, 2017 Exception As per change note all transmitters that can be Hart protocol will be converte
module are not available.
4.6.6.2.1 (35.27) Spec Extract Thermowells shall be a minimum of 316 SS, shall be flanged and be DN 40 for

Jan 04, 2017 Exception Accumulators for operation availability on failing air supply pressure are excl
Jan 04, 2017 Exception An indicator for open/closed valve position is provided. Proximity switches ar
housed in an Eex de certified switch box.

5.4 (35.36) Spec Extract All field mounted electrical equipment shall utilize the following methods of
Jan 04, 2017 Exception Tubing wall thickness is either 16SWG or 18 SWG depending on tube size.
9.1 (35.44) Spec Extract Tagging ' Nameplate requirements shall in general be in according to clause 3

Jan 19, 2017 Clarification Due to small flow on gas seal systems, the flow measurement is based on flo

36 3506-- (Rev. 1) -- 3506_-_Hyd_Power_Unit (Under Review) (B) Instrumentation

37 3507-- (Rev. 5) -- 3507 FS BULK MATERIAL REV-5 Dtd 19-01-15 (Under Review) (C) Electrical
12 8.1 b) (38.5) Spec Extract All instrumentation cables shall be supported / laid in trays. Power cables sha
power and signal cables shall be as per API-550 Part –I SECTION VII. Cables in
circuits shall preferably be not run in the tray for cables in non-intrinsically sa
be provided. Conduits carrying intrinsically safe cables shall be painted with t
at each end.

Jan 03, 2017 Exception Intrinsically safe cables will be run in same tray as Non intrinsically safe cable
of tray, and in separate fixing cable ties.

47 3700-- (Rev. 4) -- 3700 Control valve Rev 4 Dated 23.02.2010 (Under Review) (B) Control Systems
Entire (47.1) Spec Extract Control valves
Document
Jan 06, 2017 Exception All control valves used in Dresser-Rand driver pacakge is part of proven prop
requirements.
New Client Reply
4.1.3 (47.2) Spec Extract
Jan 20, 2017 Clarification Anti Surge Valve could have noise level above 85 dBA during opening.
4.3.4 (47.5) Spec Extract
Jan 20, 2017 Clarification A valve stem position indicator could be provided as an option on gas seal sy

New Client Reply

48 3701-- (Rev. 4) -- 3701 PSV Rev 4 Dated 31-8-12 (Under Review) (B) Control Systems
Client / End User: ONGC KG 98/2 OFFHSORE PLATFORM
Project: PROJECT

Comment (N°)
& Date
Doc Page Line/ Par. - Project Spec. Requirement / Siemens comment / Client Reply
Entire (48.1) Spec Extract PSV
Document
Jan 06, 2017 Exception All PSV used in Dresser-Rand driver pacakge is part of proven propriatary des

49 3702-- (Rev. 4) -- 3702 SAPCV Rev 4 Dated 15.12.10 (Under Review) (B) Control Systems
Entire (49.1) Spec Extract SAPCV
Document
Jan 06, 2017 Exception All SAPCV used in Dresser-Rand driver pacakge is part of proven propriatary d

53 5004-- (Rev. 1) -- 5004 Equipment vibration.doc-rev 1 (Commented) (B) Control Systems

7 7.1 (53.1) Spec Extract Complete section
 Jan 05, 2017 Clarification Testing to be do with contract equipment by supplier for vibration analysis. A

New Client Reply

7 7.2 (53.2) Spec Extract Complete chapter
Jan 05, 2017 Clarification Vibration analysis shall be as specified by supplier test procudure (attached)

9 9.1.1 (53.5) Spec Extract Complete section

Jan 05, 2017 Exception Contract vibration equipment (amount and possitions) is standard for GG ' PT

New Client Reply

14 Table 5 (53.6) Spec Extract Complete table
Jan 05, 2017 Exception Refer to supplier FAT for acceptable vibrations levels

New Client Reply

General (53.7) Spec Extract
Jan 20, 2017 Clarification DR take note this specification is applicable for main Equipment for example
or whasing pumps.

New Client Reply

General General and (53.8) Spec Extract
Table 4

Feb 07, 2017 Exception Factory acceptance No load test criteria for compressor vibration is per API
Factory acceptance load test criteria for compressor is not defined per API 61
617), then refer to D-R spec 003-341-001 for acceptance criteria of compress
skid is per D-R spec 003-361-001. Alarm and Shutdown limits on site are per D

New Client Reply

54 5055c-- (Rev. 1) -- 5055c-controlled vol rec pump (Under Review) (B) Auxiliary Specification
Entire (54.1) Spec Extract PUMPS
Document
Jan 06, 2017 Exception All pumps used in Dresser-Rand driver pacakge is part of proven propriatary

55 5086F-- (Rev. 2) -- 5086F Functional specification for Rotary Pump.doc (Under Review) (B) Auxiliary Specification
Entire (55.1) Spec Extract All pumps used in Dresser-Rand driver pacakge is part of proven propriatary
Document
56 5095F-- (Rev. 1) -- 5095F - FUEL GAS CONDITIONING skid (Under Review) (B) Auxiliary Specification
5/27 1.4 (57.1) Spec Extract Sub-Contractors
Dec 28, 2016 Exception Approval is not sort for GT/compressor sub vendors.
Dec 28, 2016 Exception OSHA 3124 - Stairways and ladders by Client.
API RP 2A-WSD – not applicable GT ' Compressor package. API RP 500 – area
ASME Sec. IX The welding associated with the Gas Turbine package is in acco
3834 Quality Requirements for Welding.
ASTM A 36/A 36M –01
The Carbon Structural Steel used in the GT-Compressor package is to Europe

Dec 28, 2016 Exception Please refer to comments to specifications, included in this document. Were
they have not been reviewed.

Dec 28, 2016 Exception D-R scope of supply currently excludes a Lifting spreader beam ' associated sl
can be supplied as an option.
9/27 4.1 (57.5) Spec Extract The Contractor shall provide to the Company all fabrication drawings, weld p

Dec 28, 2016 Exception The offer includes documentation as listed in tender. Additional requirement
may be subject to additional costs. Please note Weld procedures are not sub

10/27 5.1 (57.7) Spec Extract The equipment shall comply with the requirements of API RP 14C.
Dec 28, 2016 Exception With respect to API-RP-14C, Siemens believe this is applicable to compression
compressor supplier.
11/27, 12/27 5.3 (57.10) Spec Extract Safety
Dec 28, 2016 Exception Coupling guard is substantially constructed of brass and is sufficiently strong

New Client Reply

12/27 5.3 (57.11) Spec Extract Insulation
Dec 28, 2016 Exception On compressor skid, insulation will not be applied, personnel protection will

New Client Reply

12/27 5.3 (57.12) Spec Extract Handrails, walkways, stairs and platforms
 Dec 28, 2016 Exception D-R will support with necessary engineering inputs for the same, however sa

13/27 5.5 (57.15) Spec Extract Jackscrews shall be manufactured in stainless steel materials.
Dec 28, 2016 Exception Jackscrews are of CS and suitably protected.
New Client Reply
15/27 5.6 (57.16) Spec Extract Ancillary Structures
Dec 28, 2016 Exception Access ways, ladders and handrails to be engineered by Siemens, but supplie
16/27 5.7 (57.19) Spec Extract Drains or vents should be piped together and terminated with flanges at the

Jan 05, 2017 Exception Small vents and drains are API threaded. There several for baseplate of GT an
Routing of all vents/drains will require additional material such as more tubin
access to components, and make maintenance more difficult.

20/27 5.12 (57.26) Spec Extract Insulation

Dec 29, 2016 Clarification Personal are protected from hot surfaces inside the gas turbine package, by t
lagging for noise reduction purposes. The supply of this lagging is not include
compressor.
22/27 6.2 (57.28) Spec Extract Weld Specifications
Dec 29, 2016 Exception For the compressor and GT package, the Weld Procedures and Procedure Qu
Qualification Records to BS EN 287 or BS 4872. Several ASME Procedures are
shared outside D-R works for approval, same shall be available at D-R works f

26/27 8.1 (57.31) Spec Extract Painting

Dec 29, 2016 Exception Painting will be as per D-R standard for sevre environment, SS surface will no
27/27 8.3 (57.34) Spec Extract Lifting Equipment
Dec 29, 2016 Exception Currently D-R scope of supply excludes a package spreader beam and associa
equipment can be supplied as an option.

8 3.1 (57.38) Spec Extract Any necessary integral handling facilities (e.g. Monorails, Chain Pulley
Block, Hooks for Block, etc.)
Feb 09, 2017 Exception The individual compressor will be performance Type2 tested with shop drive
compressor train will be mechanical string tested, not performance Type1 str

Feb 09, 2017 Clarification Inspection of the individual compressor internals is not a Dresser-Rand stand

58 5101-- (Rev. 3) -- 5101-safety studies-rev 3 (Under Review) (C) Safety and Environment
Entire Document (58.1) Spec Extract Entire Document
Jan 06, 2017 Clarification D-R understand that this specification is more suitable for EPC / LSTK contrac
always ensure to implement best safety practices at their works. D-R will try

New Client Reply

59 5102-- (Rev. 3) -- 5102 Functional safety Spec rev 3 (Under Review) (C) Safety and Environment
Entire Document (59.1) Spec Extract Entire Document
Dec 29, 2016 Exception D-R understand that this specification is more suitable for EPC / LSTK contrac
always ensure to implement best safety practices at their works. D-R will try

66 5404F-- (Rev. 3) -- 5404F FS for PGCrev-3 (Under Review) (A) Driven Unit Specification
14/103 3.2 (66.6) Spec Extract Scope of supply - Gas Turbine
Dec 30, 2016 Exception Fuel gas conditioning skid is excluded from D-R scope of supply. Fuel should b
Siemens's standard for the same.
15/103 3.4 (66.9) Spec Extract Controls and Instrumentation
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Standard proven instrument selection and controls for compact Turbine pack
provided in lieu of switches. Flow elements, flow ' level transmitters are not fi

New Client Reply

16/103 3.4 (66.10) Spec Extract Beside UCP, Local Control Panel (LCP) / Local Gauge Board Panel shall also be
Client / End User: ONGC KG 98/2 OFFHSORE PLATFORM
Project: PROJECT

Comment (N°)
& Date
Doc Page Line/ Par. - Project Spec. Requirement / Siemens comment / Client Reply
Dec 30, 2016 Exception A local gauge board panel is included showing lub oil press ' gas temp ' pressu

18/103 3.8 (66.19) Spec Extract Trolley-mounted oil-transfer pumping system

Trolley-mounted oil purifier system
Trolley-mounted Turbine washing system
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Offer inlcudes one off oil transfer pump and purifier per module (total supply
(total supply one off), has been offered in base scope.

New Client Reply

18/103 3.8 (66.20) Spec Extract Storage pods for transporting and storage of sensitive equipment (gas genera

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Engine core is stored under hood rather than in storage pods.

18/103 3.8 (66.21) Spec Extract Support stands for rotating elements for compressors and turbines
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Support stands for rotating elements are part of workshop overhaul equipme

18/103 3.8 (66.22) Spec Extract All transportation stands and containers, fixings, blanks, shipping fastenings a

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification 12 months storage may require interim inspection depending on actual stora
 Dec 30, 2016 Exception Currently D-R scope of supply excludes a package spreader beam ' associated
can be supplied as an option.

18/103 3.10 (66.26) Spec Extract Full load - full speed string test at yard.72 hours offshore test.
Dec 30, 2016 Exception Since this is to be performed at yard, it is not included in D-R scope, same can
engineering inputs and site support, which is to be charged per diem basis as

19/103 4.2 (66.28) Spec Extract Design Life, Availability and Reliability
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Proven standard package auxiliary systems are provided which whilst designe
line maintenance (for safety purposes). These systems (gas fuel, lub oil, starti

New Client Reply

19/103, 20/103 4.2 (66.29) Spec Extract Design Life, Availability and Reliability
Dec 30, 2016 Exception Proven standard package auxiliary systems are provided which whilst designe
line maintenance (for safety purposes). These systems (gas fuel, lub oil, starti

27/103 5.3.2 (66.38) Spec Extract Compressor Washing System

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Compressor washing systems have been offered, on the basis of one per mod

28/103 5.5 (66.41) Spec Extract The guard shall be sufficiently rigid to withstand deflections as a result of bod

Dec 30, 2016 Exception Coupling guard is substantially constructed of brass and is sufficiently strong

New Client Reply

28/103 5.5 (66.42) Spec Extract Couplings and Gear Boxes
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification The gas turbine auxiliary gearbox is designed to British Standards and incorpo
service life to coincide with gas turbine service intervals.
New Client Reply
29/103 5.6 (66.43) Spec Extract The lube / Seal oil system shall be equipped with AC motor driven main and a
circulation requirements.
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Lube oils system for compressor, gear box and PT of gas turbine driver will be

New Client Reply

30/103 5.6 (66.44) Spec Extract All lube oil /seal oil piping, valve trims and related accessories shall be manuf
 Dec 30, 2016 Exception Most piping, fittings and components in the lub oil system are stainless steel
body/vessel shall be Carbon steel, thermostatic valve is in Cast Iron and nitril
accommodate expansion etc.)
This is D-R standard design.

New Client Reply

28/103 5.6 (66.45) Spec Extract In addition the lube oil system shall be provided with a 110V DC motor driven
Compressor, gearbox (' turbine) bearings during coast down after a trip or em

Dec 30, 2016 Exception D-R will provide rundown tank instead of DC motor driven pump for emergen

33/103 5.7 (66.54) Spec Extract Based on the buffer gas requirement, Vendors shall provide dedicated N2 ge
running all the compressors (working+ standby) together at a time.

Dec 30, 2016 Exception This is not included in D-R scope, same has to be included by EPC / cleint in th
specified parameters.
40/103 5.11 (66.57) Spec Extract Corrosion allowance for carbon steel parts shall be 3mm minimum.
Dec 30, 2016 Exception Corrosion allowance is not applicable to small standard turbine package com

44/103 5.15.2 (66.64) Spec Extract Field Instrumentation

Dec 30, 2016 Exception Only field instrumentation by GT vendor is loose gas fuel block ' vent valves a

New Client Reply

44/103 5.15.3 (66.65) Spec Extract Integrated Control/Safety Instrumented System
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Start operation from the UCP will be fully automatic from a single push butto

48/103 5.15.3.2 (66.68) Spec Extract Local Control Panel

Dec 30, 2016 Exception A local control panel will be provided which will consist of a touch screen onl
supplied.

49/103 5.15.3.4 (66.70) Spec Extract Controller shall allow compressor to operate as close as possible to the Surge
(@ 2% away from actual surge line) safely.
Dec 30, 2016 Exception Standard margin between actual surge line and control line is 10% considerin

New Client Reply

52/103 5.15.3.6 (66.71) Spec Extract Machine protection/ monitoring system
Dec 30, 2016 Exception D-Rs have included for the supply of Bently Nevada System 1.

54/103 5.16.1 (66.75) Spec Extract Fire ' Gas detection system components shall be type approved by UL or FM
Dec 30, 2016 Exception The Complete Fire ' Gas system is supplied by an LPCB (formally Loss Preventi
Lloyds Register approved and the individual detectors are manufactured by fi
Gas industry, unfortunately as major of the vendors are European, the detec
organisations).

59/103 5.17 (66.84) Spec Extract The main package mounting plate shall be designed for a single-point lift (wit
requirements of API-RP2A- WSD (21st edition).

Dec 30, 2016 Exception DNV design criteria is used for the Turbomachinery package lifting. The offer

New Client Reply

60/103 5.18 (66.85) Spec Extract The contractor shall provide personnel protection for those parts on externa
Deg.C

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Some areas inside GT enclosure (for example close to engine casing) may exc
provided by the acoustic hood.
63/103 6.6 (66.88) Spec Extract Unit Control Panel Tests:
Dec 30, 2016 Exception The completed UCP will undergo a full software integration test at theD-R co
Noise immunity test and dynamic simulation test are not available for the UC
 New Client Reply
64/103 6.8.1 (66.89) Spec Extract Performance Tests …………... Tape record vibration data for compressor, turbi

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification The offer includes Siemens standard GT performance test, based on PTC22. W
a tape recording of levels through out the test.
65/103 6.8.3 (66.93) Spec Extract Noise Test
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Since this test is to be performed at yard, it has to be included by EPC and no

67/103 7.2 (66.95) Spec Extract Included in the list of special tools shall be tools required for access ' remova

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification With exception of lifting equipment inside GT enclosure and core engine liftin

New Client Reply

67/103 7.2 (66.96) Spec Extract Tools shall also include any equipment necessary for carrying out inspection
monitor, recording equipment and related accessories.

Dec 30, 2016 Clarification A Boroscope set have been offered as an option.

New Client Reply

67/103 7.2 (66.97) Spec Extract Portable emissions monitor
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Portable emissions monitor – option (note; instrument should be used in safe
be arranged in exhaust stack away form hazardous area)

New Client Reply

67/103 8.2 (66.98) Spec Extract Calculations shall be provided that includes a complete rotor dynamic and vi
standards.
Dec 30, 2016 Clarification Vendor's standard lateral report is available for GT.

5.6 (66.103) Spec Extract In addition the lube oil system shall be provided with a 110V DC motor driven
Compressor, gearbox (' turbine) bearings during coast down after a trip or em

Jan 02, 2017 Exception D-R proposes an atmospheric rundown tank design. Rundown tanks are more
opposed to a DC motor. Reduced maintenance downtime.

5.7 (66.104) Spec Extract

Where Dry Gas seals are offered

Jan 02, 2017 Clarification Dry gas seal system ' GCU shall be as per the P'ID attached in proposal scope

79 G.I.5 (66.109) Spec Extract Standby lub oil pump failure

Jan 03, 2017 Clarification D-R understand this as low lube oil supply header pressure

79 G.I.7 (66.111) Spec Extract Lub oil inlet temperature to oil cooler. Indication required on
Local panel (LP)/Local Gauge Board
Jan 03, 2017 Exception D-R proposes temp. indicator before cooler but indicator is local ' not mount
79 G.I.15 (66.114) Spec Extract Lub Oil overhead tank level
 Jan 03, 2017 Exception Weld pad type Level indicator is used ' not possible to shown to level gauge o

78 G. LUB OIL (66.115) Spec Extract Trip (with simultaneous alarm)

SYSTEM(S)
Jan 04, 2017 Exception D-R proposes unit shutdown on only "low lube oil supply header pressure" to

15 4.6.8.1.3 (66.126) Spec Extract All shut down valves shall be provided with a beacon type position indicator.
position proximity limit switches. These shall be certified as Intrinsically Safe.

Jan 04, 2017 Exception An indicator for open/closed valve position is provided. Proximity switches ar
housed in an Eex de certified switch box.
19 6.7.4 (66.130) Spec Extract All pneumatic tubing and fittings shall be in accordance with the following m

Jan 04, 2017 Exception Tubing wall thickness is either 16SWG or 18 SWG depending on tube size.
Jan 17, 2017 Clarification DR proposed a compressor train. The process components and associated ins

77 Compressor (66.140) Spec Extract High and low Seal differential Pressure
Seal System

Jan 18, 2017 Exception D-R proposes shutdown on primary seal leakage ' loss of separation gas. D-R
Seal differential Pressure
Please refer to gas seal panel P'ID attached in proposal scope of supply.

New Client Reply

18 of 103 Para 3.10 (66.141) Spec Extract Full load full speed string train test at Module fabrication Yard.
Testing
Feb 09, 2017 Exception The full load full pressure full speed mechanical string test of the 1st unit will
test is proposed as a separate activity.
64 of 103 Para 6.8.2 (66.144) Spec Extract
String Test
Feb 09, 2017 Exception The full load mechanical string test of the 1st unit will be carried out at DR Ve

New Client Reply

65 of 103 Para 6.8.2 (66.145) Spec Extract Anti-surge and recycle control systems
String Test
Feb 09, 2017 Exception The job UCP will be used for the full load mechanical string test, However the
be used for test purpose.
93 402020-01391-06-- (Rev. 0) -- 402020-01391-06-ME-BOD-0001-0 Mechanical Design Basis (Under Review) (A) General Design Basis
37 8.11 (93.1) Spec Extract Tanks shall be designed, manufactured, and tested, in accordance with manu

Jan 06, 2017 Exception Tank is not designed according to API 650. Tank is designed according to turb
New Client Reply
37 8.11 (93.2) Spec Extract Inspection hatches with minimum size of DN500 shall be provided on tank ro

Jan 06, 2017 Exception Inspection hatch is not included for the synthetic lube oil tank. This is a small
(LxWxH) 2.6m x 1.1m x 0.55m. There are flanged openings in tank for heater

41 8.17.1 (93.5) Spec Extract Suitable lifting lugs, ears or ring bolts, or tapped holes for lifting rings shall be

Jan 06, 2017 Exception Equipment above 15 kg can lifted for maintenance, but no extra lifting equip
New Client Reply
41 8.17.1 (93.6) Spec Extract Equipment/parts heavier than 500kg shall be handled by permanent provisio

Jan 06, 2017 Exception Only lifting equipment for turbine handling is provided.

New Client Reply

47 9.4 (93.7) Spec Extract Positive material identification (PMI) is required for stainless steel and alloy s
component or weld, shall be carried out during the final stages of manufactu

Jan 06, 2017 Exception Not included in scope

New Client Reply
48 10.2 (93.8) Spec Extract For multiple identical items of equipment / packages (two or more), at least t
supplied.
 Jan 06, 2017 Exception Only one set of special tool is provided

New Client Reply

48 10.2 (93.9) Spec Extract Prior to shipment each special tool shall be packed in rugged tool box, tagged
used.
Jan 06, 2017 Exception Special tools are packed and preserved in a crate. No special tool box is provi
where to be used. The tool is tagged and marked, but has no detailing descri

New Client Reply

Page 30 Para 8.2 (93.11) Spec Extract Rotor
natural frequencies that fall within 10% of operating speeds are not acceptab
Feb 07, 2017 Clarification Acceptable separation margin and amplification factor will be per API617 for

105 Addendum to 2005-- (Rev. 0) -- Addendum to 2005-Protective Coating (Under Review) (C) Surface Preparation & Painting
106 addendum to 2009F-- (Rev. 1 ) -- addendum to 2009F (Under Review) (A) General Design Basis
(106.1) Spec Extract
Jan 17, 2017 Clarification Not applicable to DR scope.
New Client Reply
108 Appendix _A_3-- (Rev. 0) -- Appendix _A_3_Part-III_Response sheet - Blank Price format (Under Review) (C) Instructions to Vendor
109 Appendix_A_11-- (Rev. 8.4) -- Appendix_A_11_Part-III_Suggested_Vendor_List_Rev_8_4 (Under Review) (A) Instructions to Vendor
Entire (109.1) Spec Extract
document
Jan 12, 2017 Clarification D-R noted the client vendor list and can be complied. During execution stage
to meet project delivery schedule without comprimising quality and safety cr

New Client Reply

110 Appendix_A_16-- (Rev. 3) -- Appendix_A_16_Part-III_List_of_Agencies (Under Review) (B) Instructions to Vendor
(110.1) Spec Extract
Jan 17, 2017 Exception Not applicable to compressor scope.
Feb 13, 2017 Exception Specification appears to apply to main process piping and mainly the EPC con
auxiliary piping on GT-Driver unit.
For Driver Unit on skid piping will be according in house piping class system,
per ASME / ANSI standards and have been modelled in the company’s CAD.

New Client Reply

69 Piping (127.2) Spec Extract C.A 1.5mm ' sch. XXS
material
spec #1500
SS 316L

Jan 05, 2017 Exception D-R proposes gas seal conditioning skid ' gas seal panel primary seal gas supp

144 INVITATION TO BID-final-- (Rev. 0) -- INVITATION TO BID-final (Under Review) (A) Material Requisition
145 Mechanical Datasheet Part-1-- (Rev. 0) -- Mechanical Datasheet Part-1 (Under Review) (A) Driven Unit Datasheet
Page 26 Tittle (145.2) Spec Extract API 617 7th EDITION CENTRIFUGAL AND AXIAL COMPRESSOR

Feb 07, 2017 Clarification D-R understands that 7th edition of API 617 is the one applicable.

New Client Reply

Page 31 Line 11 (145.3) Spec Extract INDIVIDUALS STAGE DRAINS REQUIRED
Feb 07, 2017 Exception Individual stage drains not offered.

New Client Reply

Page 32 Line 41 (145.4) Spec Extract
Feb 07, 2017 Exception Helium leak test is not offered

New Client Reply

Page 33 Note 4 (145.5) Spec Extract
Feb 07, 2017 Clarification antifouling coating not considred for this application

New Client Reply

Page 33 Note 13 (145.6) Spec Extract Each Train shall be able to operate continuosly at 33% turndown of the speci
 Feb 07, 2017 Exception Expected turndown, expected stability, expected head rise to surge, expected
Turdown, stability, head rise to surge and overload limits are not guaranteed

New Client Reply

32 of 92 Lines 38 & (145.9) Spec Extract
44
Feb 10, 2017 Clarification A full load full pressure mechanical string test is offered for the 1st compress

New Client Reply

32 of 92 Line 42 (145.10) Spec Extract sound level test.
Feb 10, 2017 Clarification An overall sound noise level measurement based on sound pressure levels at
during the string test. A noise intensimetry measurement (method by scannin
of each train component) can be offered as a separate option.

New Client Reply

67 of 92 Lines 38 & (145.11) Spec Extract
44
Feb 10, 2017 Clarification A full load full pressure mechanical string test is offered for the 1st compress

Feb 10, 2017 Clarification An overall sound noise level measurement based on sound pressure levels at
during the string test. A noise intensimetry measurement (method by scannin
of each train component) can be offered as a separate option.

159 Piping - Misc Part-1-- (Rev. 0) -- Piping - Misc Part-1 (Under Review) (C) Piping
160 Piping - Misc Part-2-- (Rev. 0) -- Piping - Misc Part-2 (Under Review) (B) Piping
26 5.4 (160.1) Spec Extract Coatings to be selected from Norsok M-501
Jan 12, 2017 Exception D-R's supply chain is extensively qualified for painting to D-R standard severe
specifications may limit sourcing options and increase lead time risk of the pr

New Client Reply

61 8.2 (160.2) Spec Extract Use of stainless steel is limited to maximum operating temp. of 60 deg C
Jan 12, 2017 Exception D-R proposes gas seal panel, conditioning skid ' LOC pipe/valve etc material i

188 R3542‐MRT‐2260‐TS‐MCP04_A‐‐ (Rev. A) ‐‐ KG‐DWN‐98/2 Offshore Process Platform CPP & LQUP REQUEST FOR QUOTATION (RFQ) (Under Review) (A) Material Requisition
8.0 (188.4) Spec Extract
Jan 25, 2017 Clarification This specification is more adapted to EPC Contractor. For list of the documen
document list.
New Client Reply
Page 25 of (188.12) Spec Extract Inspection and testing.
30
Feb 09, 2017 Clarification Compressor performance test to be in accordance with ASME PTC-10 Type 2
7th Edition.
New Client Reply
Page 25 of (188.13) Spec Extract Inspection and testing.
30 Full load full speed string test of complete train.......specific to the purchase o
Feb 09, 2017 Clarification A full load full pressure full speed mechanical string test is offered as a separa

New Client Reply

189 SAES-H-001-- (Rev. 0) -- Coating Selection and Application Requirements for Industrial Plants and Equipment (Withdrawn)
Feb 06, 2017 Exception Specification Withdrawn.
Info Foster Wheeler via email dated Jan 8th, 2015: Spec does not need to be
-------------------------
S. Aramco Comment / Bid Clarification Meeting Agreement:
04Feb15: Noted. specification has been withdrawn from the material requisiti
------------------------- Accepted (Yes/No): N/A
-------------------------
Waiver Required (Yes/No): N/A
 Client
Discipline
mens comment / Client Reply Status

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
y representative for review and approval.
at workshop for review but not sent for approval
#600 rating and shall be RTJ above #600 rating. Open
TJ flanges for service rating 1500# and above. Client requirement of RTJ flanges will be complied with cost

nstruction shall be 100% radiographed irrespective ofrating in accordance with ASME B16.34 Annexure B. Open

ill be performed with cost implications, for more details client to refer D-R quality plan for this project and
tions.
_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
tter/tubing/valve manifolds shall be routed to open drain header. If the instrument is on sour service and Nb
Open
hen it will be routed to close drain header.

ders will be done with cost implications.

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
Nb
Open
pply.

_Doc Nb _Doc
inless steel and shall be rated one piping class higher than the pipe to which it is connected. Nb
Open

00# however for service rating higher than 300# its rating will be same as of piping class.

_Doc Nb _Doc
IL2 certified Nb
Open

supplied if available.

with Digital integral output meters(with engineering units). The output meter shall be suitable for use in the Open

d package design does not include for LCD display, reading is done in HMI.

a 3 way 2 valve manifold. The Manifold shall be supplied by the same instrument vendor Open

er than same instrument vendor.

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
within the UCP will have the negative side grounded only. Nb
s that can be Hart protocol will be converted. Only the gas fuel transmitter that are an integral part of the
provided with individual block and bleed valves as well as the primary process isolation valve. Open

s that can be Hart protocol will be converted. Only the gas fuel transmitter that are an integral part of the

of 316 SS, shall be flanged and be DN 40 for piping, DN 50 for vessels. Screwed wells are not acceptable. Open

bility on failing air supply pressure are excluded.

e position is provided. Proximity switches are not provided, provision for 2 off sealed position switches, 24 VDC,
ch box.

ment shall utilize the following methods of protection …… Open

WG or 18 SWG depending on tube size.
s shall in general be in according to clause 3.6.6.1 of Instrumentation Design Criteria. Open

ems, the flow measurement is based on flow orifice with differential pressure transmitter and rotameter.

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
e supported / laid in trays. Power cables shall not be run in trays carrying signal cables. The physical separation of Nb
Open
s per API-550 Part –I SECTION VII. Cables in intrinsically safe
n in the tray for cables in non-intrinsically safe circuits. If run in the same tray a metallic earthed separator shall
rinsically safe cables shall be painted with the blue color bands

in same tray as Non intrinsically safe cables. There is no metallic separator, but they will be located on each side
e ties.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open

Rand driver pacakge is part of proven propriatary design and not subject to change due to customer

Open
level above 85 dBA during opening.
Open
uld be provided as an option on gas seal systems and lube oïl systems control valve.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb

Client
Discipline
mens comment / Client Reply Status
Open

er pacakge is part of proven propriatary design and not subject to change due to customer requirements.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open

iver pacakge is part of proven propriatary design and not subject to change due to customer requirements.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
uipment by supplier for vibration analysis. Additional equipment (by supplier) may be used if necessary.

Open
ified by supplier test procudure (attached) Acceptance criteria is also included on the supplier test procedure.

Open
ount and possitions) is standard for GG ' PT and may not comply to this requirement.

Open
le vibrations levels

Open
pplicable for main Equipment for example Compressor and not for auxialiry component same as lube oil pumps

Open

criteria for compressor vibration is per API 617.

ria for compressor is not defined per API 617 (IOnly no load test criteria is defined per API
41-001 for acceptance criteria of compressor load tests. Pipe vibration testing and evaluatuion on compressor
Alarm and Shutdown limits on site are per D-R 'rainbow chart' spec.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open

river pacakge is part of proven propriatary design and not subject to change due to customer requirements.

_Doc Nb _Doc
river pacakge is part of proven propriatary design and not subject to change due to customer requirements. Nb
Open

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
essor sub vendors.
s by Client.
T ' Compressor package. API RP 500 – area classification to be advised by Client.
ted with the Gas Turbine package is in accordance SIEMENS welding standard, which conforms to BS EN 729/ ISO
elding.

n the GT-Compressor package is to European standards.

fications, included in this document. Were reference specifications are not applicable to D-R scope of supply

udes a Lifting spreader beam ' associated slings etc. If required a package lifting beam ' associated equipment

e Company all fabrication drawings, weld procedures and detailed calculations for approval. Open

as listed in tender. Additional requirements can be agreed, but increasing the documentation scope of supply
. Please note Weld procedures are not submitted but are available for inspection at vendor's works.

the requirements of API RP 14C. Open

ens believe this is applicable to compression module/platform builder and not specifically to turbine/

Open
nstructed of brass and is sufficiently strong although not necessarily to 100 Kg point load.

Open
l not be applied, personnel protection will be provided by warning signs indicating hot surfaces.

atforms Open
ngineering inputs for the same, however same shall be supplied by EPC / client.

in stainless steel materials. Open

protected.

Open
s to be engineered by Siemens, but supplied by Client.
ogether and terminated with flanges at the base edge. Open

eaded. There several for baseplate of GT and Compressor unit drain points .
quire additional material such as more tubing/flanges and fittings that will crowd the seal gas panel, obstruct
maintenance more difficult.

Open
urfaces inside the gas turbine package, by the enclosure. Some ducting outside of the enclosure will also require
ses. The supply of this lagging is not included in Siemens scope of supply. There will be no insulation for

Open
ge, the Weld Procedures and Procedure Qualifications comply with the requirements of BS EN 288 with Welder
7 or BS 4872. Several ASME Procedures are available and these can be included. However no procedure will be
oval, same shall be available at D-R works for review only.

Open
d for sevre environment, SS surface will not be painted.
Open
udes a package spreader beam and associated slings, etc. If required a package lifting beam ' associated
option.

acilities (e.g. Monorails, Chain Pulley Open

performance Type2 tested with shop driver in our Le Havre test facilities. However, the complete gas turbine /
cal string tested, not performance Type1 string tested (criteria according to PTC-10 Code are not met).

ressor internals is not a Dresser-Rand standard activity, this is subject to cost impact.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
tion is more suitable for EPC / LSTK contractor who is responssible for overall scope. As a standard practice D-R
safety practices at their works. D-R will try to comply with this spec wherever best possible.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
tion is more suitable for EPC / LSTK contractor who is responssible for overall scope. As a standard practice D-R
safety practices at their works. D-R will try to comply with this spec wherever best possible.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
ded from D-R scope of supply. Fuel should be made available at skid edge at required parameters as per

Open
tion and controls for compact Turbine package is supplied. Refer P'IDs for scope of equipment. Transmitters are
elements, flow ' level transmitters are not fitted. Oil level switch is fitted.
SPCON, B-193

CP) / Local Gauge Board Panel shall also be provided. Open

 Client
Discipline
mens comment / Client Reply Status
ded showing lub oil press ' gas temp ' pressure.
SPCON, Sagar
Samrat

ping system Open

m
system
pump and purifier per module (total supply one off). A fixed GT wash unit, one per module
ffered in base scope.

storage of sensitive equipment (gas generator, rotors, seals, instrument modules etc.) shall be supplied Open

rather than in storage pods.

B-193, SPCON

nts for compressors and turbines Open

nts are part of workshop overhaul equipment and not supplied. D-R have included roll off trolley.
B-193, SPCON

ainers, fixings, blanks, shipping fastenings and inhibitors etc. for 12 months storage Open

terim inspection depending on actual storage conditions.

udes a package spreader beam ' associated slings etc. If required a package lifting beam ' associated equipment

yard.72 hours offshore test. Open

rd, it is not included in D-R scope, same can be included by EPC, D-R can support the same with required
rt, which is to be charged per diem basis as per commercial schedule in D-R commercial proposal.

ility Open
y systems are provided which whilst designed for maximum reliability and availability are not configured for on
oses). These systems (gas fuel, lub oil, starting etc) are under hood also for safety purposes. B-193, SPCON

ility Open
y systems are provided which whilst designed for maximum reliability and availability are not configured for on
oses). These systems (gas fuel, lub oil, starting etc) are under hood also for safety purposes.

Open
e been offered, on the basis of one per module (total supply one off)

d to withstand deflections as a result of bodily contact of nominally 100kg. Open

nstructed of brass and is sufficiently strong although not necessarily to 100 Kg point load.

Open
is designed to British Standards and incorporates rolling element bearings. The bearings are deigned with a
rbine service intervals.

equipped with AC motor driven main and auxiliary oil pumps each capable of meeting 100% of the system oil Open

gear box and PT of gas turbine driver will be common.

rims and related accessories shall be manufactured from 316L S.S materials. Open
ents in the lub oil system are stainless steel 316. However valves trims and filter
thermostatic valve is in Cast Iron and nitrile rubber connections are used in a couple of low duty cases to

all be provided with a 110V DC motor driven emergency oil pump designed to protect the Open
earings during coast down after a trip or emergency shutdown.

tead of DC motor driven pump for emergency shutdown.

ent, Vendors shall provide dedicated N2 generation systems, common for all the compressors and sized for Open
ing+ standby) together at a time.

same has to be included by EPC / cleint in thier scope and Nitrgen should be made available at D-R skid edge at

eel parts shall be 3mm minimum. Open

ble to small standard turbine package components.

Open
vendor is loose gas fuel block ' vent valves and gas fuel meter.

ented System Open

be fully automatic from a single push button.

Open
ded which will consist of a touch screen only for operator interface, therefore no indicators or switches will be

to operate as close as possible to the Surge line Open

e) safely.
surge line and control line is 10% considering Compressor Safety.

ystem Open
of Bently Nevada System 1.

onents shall be type approved by UL or FM or LR. Open

supplied by an LPCB (formally Loss Prevention Council) approved supplier. Additionally the control panel is
individual detectors are manufactured by fire ' das detection vendors with proven experienced in offshore Oil '
jor of the vendors are European, the detectors are not UL or FM approved (as these are American

shall be designed for a single-point lift (with all equipment assembled onto it) in accordance with the Open
21st edition).

Turbomachinery package lifting. The offer does not include design calculations for lifting features.

onnel protection for those parts on external equipment surfaces that can reach temperatures more than 71 Open

or example close to engine casing) may exceed 71 degC. In these cases personnel protection is effectively

Open
a full software integration test at theD-R controls test facility. Please note that Burn-in tests, Power on-off test,
simulation test are not available for the UCP.
record vibration data for compressor, turbine shall be provided to the company. Open

rd GT performance test, based on PTC22. While the test records vibration levels at set points, it does not include
out the test. B-193, SPCON
Open
at yard, it has to be included by EPC and not by D-R
B-193, SPCON

shall be tools required for access ' removal operations such as mechanical handling and lifting aids, Open

nt inside GT enclosure and core engine lifting frame, lifting equipment is by client.

ment necessary for carrying out inspection operations such as test kits and Boroscopes complete with video Open
d related accessories.

d as an option.

Open
on (note; instrument should be used in safe area however it comes with a 5m sample hose and connections can
y form hazardous area)

t includes a complete rotor dynamic and vibration calculations for the shaft assemblies to applicable API Open

s available for GT.

all be provided with a 110V DC motor driven emergency oil pump designed to protect the Open
earings during coast down after a trip or emergency shutdown.

down tank design. Rundown tanks are more reliable because they are simple ' have less moving parts as
maintenance downtime.

Open

as per the P'ID attached in proposal scope of supply.

Open
l supply header pressure

oler. Indication required on Open

d
ore cooler but indicator is local ' not mounted on local gauge board.
Open
sed ' not possible to shown to level gauge on gauge board.

Open

nly "low lube oil supply header pressure" to increase the availability of system without compromising on safety.

ided with a beacon type position indicator. Where specified in the Datasheet, this shall house open and closed Open
These shall be certified as Intrinsically Safe.

e position is provided. Proximity switches are not provided, provision for 2 off sealed position switches, 24 VDC,
ch box.
hall be in accordance with the following minimum requirements….. Open

WG or 18 SWG depending on tube size.

The process components and associated instrumentation and control are not on DR scope.

ssure Open

ry seal leakage ' loss of separation gas. D-R has not considered shutdown on High and low

attached in proposal scope of supply.

t at Module fabrication Yard. Open

ed mechanical string test of the 1st unit will be carried out at DR Vendor test facilities, not at module yard. This
vity.
Open

t of the 1st unit will be carried out at DR Vendor test facilities, not at module fabrication yard.

tems Open

ull load mechanical string test, However the job anti-surge and job recycle valve will NOT

_Doc Nb _Doc
tured, and tested, in accordance with manufacturer proven standard and applicable requirements of API 650 Nb
Open

API 650. Tank is designed according to turbine system requirements.

size of DN500 shall be provided on tank roof in accessible positions Open

or the synthetic lube oil tank. This is a small size tank with approximately dimension of
ere are flanged openings in tank for heater and pumps that can be used for inspection.

olts, or tapped holes for lifting rings shall be provided on all equipment items where weight exceeds 15kg. Open

for maintenance, but no extra lifting equipment is supplied.

0kg shall be handled by permanent provision of lifting lugs, trolley, hoist etc. Open

handling is provided.

MI) is required for stainless steel and alloy steels. PMI, which need only be applied once to a particular Open
ed out during the final stages of manufacture in order to confirm the materials of construction are as specified.

uipment / packages (two or more), at least two sets of special tools shall be supplied, otherwise one set shall be Open
vided

l shall be packed in rugged tool box, tagged with stainless steel tag detailing its description and where it is to be Open

erved in a crate. No special tool box is provided. All special tools are listed in a special tool list with reference to
ed and marked, but has no detailing description, such detail will be provided in other relevant documents.

Open
n 10% of operating speeds are not acceptable
d amplification factor will be per API617 for compressor
B-193, SPCON

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
Nb
Open

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
Nb
Open

nd can be complied. During execution stage Alternate/equivalent D-R approved vendor can be proposed in order
without comprimising quality and safety criteria.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
Open
pe.
main process piping and mainly the EPC contractor, therefore is considered not applicable for standardized

be according in house piping class system, which is strictly designed per ASME B 31.3. The components used are
ave been modelled in the company’s CAD.

Open

g skid ' gas seal panel primary seal gas supply pipe in sch. 80 without corrosion allowance.

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
L AND AXIAL COMPRESSOR Nb
Open

of API 617 is the one applicable.

UIRED Open
d.

Open

Open
for this application

e continuosly at 33% turndown of the specify total export flow rate without recycling. Open
bility, expected head rise to surge, expected overload limits are as shown on expected performance maps.
rge and overload limits are not guaranteed.

Open

al string test is offered for the 1st compressor unit only.

Open
urement based on sound pressure levels at 1 meter distance from the compressor package will be carried out
nsimetry measurement (method by scanning with a sound intensity probe to determine the sound power level
offered as a separate option.

Open

al string test is offered for the 1st compressor unit only.

urement based on sound pressure levels at 1 meter distance from the compressor package will be carried out
nsimetry measurement (method by scanning with a sound intensity probe to determine the sound power level
offered as a separate option.

_Doc Nb _Doc
_Doc Nb Nb
_Doc
ok M-501 Nb
Open
ualified for painting to D-R standard severe environment specifications. Deviation from our standard painting
options and increase lead time risk of the project.

maximum operating temp. of 60 deg C Open

itioning skid ' LOC pipe/valve etc material in 316 SS even operating temp. is higher than 60 deg C

nder Review) (A) Material Requisition _Doc Nb _Doc

Nb
Open
to EPC Contractor. For list of the documents provided for the compressor scope, please see our standard

Open

be in accordance with ASME PTC-10 Type 2 (Class III reference is not valid anymore), and comply with API-617

Open
omplete train.......specific to the purchase order.
mechanical string test is offered as a separate price for the first unit train only, not for the additional units.

_Doc Nb _Doc
Nb
ed Jan 8th, 2015: Spec does not need to be considered by vendor for quotation.

ation Meeting Agreement:

been withdrawn from the material requisition. Item closed.
No): N/A
WPS, NDE procedures shall be sent to EPC
for approval by EPC/ONGC
DR shall comply ONGC FS requirement

DR shall comply ONGC FS requirement

Not acceptable. DR to consider routing of

drain-vents in base scope

Not Acceptable.
Coriolis flow meter for FG (loose supplied)
is in DR scope

Not acceptable.
Thermowell flanges shall be of stainless steel
and shall be rated one piping class higher
than the pipe to which it is connected.

Not Acceptable. SIL2 certified transmitters

shall be provided

Not acceptable.
LCD shall be provided for all PT's

Manifold shall be of reputed make. Delete

this deviation

Deviation not cler

Deviation not clear w.r.t spec extract

Deviation not clear w.r.t spec extract

Not acceptable
Position switch shall be privided which shall
be IS/Ex-e

Not acceptable. Follow the tbe thickness

inline ONGC FS
Clarification is not relevant to Spec extract

Not acceptable. DR to consider metallic

separator

Deviation not clear. Specific deviation shall

be informed and same shall be subject to
ONGC acceptance
Not acceptable.
DR to meet following requirement,
A valve stem position indicator shall be
provided. All control valve scales
shall be calibrated from 0-100 % of valve
travel. Smart positionar transmitters
shall be considered for valve status
indications in Process control room.

Specific deviations shall be informed and

same is subject to ONGC acceptance

Specific deviations shall be informed and

same is subject to ONGC acceptance
We understand that DR will perform
vibration testing during performance test and
MRT
Procedure not available. Same is subject to
Acceptance by ONGC & EPC
Deviation not clear.

Not acceptable. This shall be within the

acceptable range of FS

Not acceptable. This is applicable for all

rotor/reciprocating equipment

Acceptance criteris is subject to ONGC

acceptance

Specific deviations shall be informed & same

shall be subject to ONGC acceptance
Specific deviations shall be informed & same
shall be subject to ONGC acceptance

To be discussed
Refer comments regarding requirement for
access provision, elsewhere in document

Not acceptable. Specific deviations shall be

mentioned and same shall be subject to
ONGC acceptance
Not acceptable. Lifting beams are in DR
scope

WPS shall be submitted.

No past project reference

Not acceptable. Meet the ONGC FS

requirement

Not acceptable. Meet the ONGC FS

requirement
Refer Commenst regarding access
requirenment elsewhere in this document

Necessary access provision shall be provided

for equipment item within enclosure by DR
Refer comments elsewhere on the subject

Insulation shall be as defined on ONGC FS

Weld Procedures and Procedure

Qualifications shall be shared and same ahall
be subject to EPC and ONGC acceptance

Painting procedure shall be subject to ONGC

& EPC acceptance
DR to provide package spreader beam &
slings as optional quote

Refer Addendum from EPC for MRT/String

test requirement

Remove this deviation. DR shall participate

in safety study and shall technically justify
the queries on its scope of supply. Any
cost/time implicatoon on account of safety
study emommendations shall not be to EPC
account

Remove this deviation. DR shall participate

in safety study and shall technically justify
the queries on its scope of supply. Any
cost/time implicatoon on account of safety
study emommendations shall not be to EPC
account

Not acceptable. SFGCS is in CTV scope of supply

Accepted
LCP/Local Gauge board having replica of
UCP HMI shall be provided for all systems,
inline with FS5404

Not acceptable. Trolley mounted Lube oil

transfer pump, Trolley mounted LO purifier,
Trolley mounted GT water wash shall be
provided - 1 common for PGC 3 trains shall
be included in base offer

This needs to be looked into considering long

term prservation requirement post offshore
commissioning. For all 3 trains CTV shall
confirm the requirements for long term
preservation and same shall be included as
separate line item in commercial
offer( preservation cost is in EPC scope Refer
addendum dated 24th Feb 2017)

This needs to be looked into considering long

term prservation requirement post offshore
commissioning. For all 3 trains CTV shall
confirm the requirements for long term
preservation and same shall be included as
separate line item in commercial
offer( preservation cost is in EPC scope Refer
addendum dated 24th Feb 2017)

Not acceptable.
In past project ONGC insisted on deleting
this clarification. Based on discussion with
Dresser Rand 12 months storage is
considered in base scope.
Not acceptable
Package Lifting frame is in Base scope of
supply.
ONGC FS spec extract is concerning lifting
provision for each component. DR shall
explain the provision for handling of each
component in line with special tools
requirement mentioned in FS

Not acceptable.
Performance test of individual equipment
shall be carried out for all 3 PGC packages
as per ONGC FS requirement at vendor
works.
Dresser Rand shall provide cost & time for
coupled Mechanical run test with project GT
& compressor for each PGC package at
vendor works

This is accepted in B-193, SPCON with

confirmation from Siemens for meeting
ONGC BEC & FS requirement. This is
subject to ONGC acceptance.
Other OEM's raise similar deviations with a
rider that O&M of OEM has to be followed
in totality.

This is accepted in B-193, SPCON with

confirmation from Siemens for meeting
ONGC BEC & FS requirement. This is
subject to ONGC acceptance.
As per discussions with Dresser ,
Other OEM's raise wash
Compressor water similar
is deviations with a
not required.
rider that O&M of OEM
Dresser Rand to check. has to be followed
in totality.Dresser Rand to provide optional
However
cost for Mobile compressror water wash
common for 3 PGC trains

Not acceptable

Not acceptable. This is subject to ONGC

acceptance

Noted. However provision of having 2

separate LO system(i.e mineral+Synthetic) is
subject to ONGC acceptance
Noted. This is subject to ONGC acceptance

Noted. This is subject to ONGC acceptance.

However in the technical offer Dresser Rad
has given the option of DC LO pump or run
down tank, Dresser Rand to check

MDR to check the requirement for dedicated

N2 generator
No past project reference available. This is
subject to ONGC acceptance

Dresser Rand to note that other on field

instrumentation including antisurge
instrumentation is in Dresser Rand scope of
supply

Devition is not clear. We understand that

start command can be given from both UCP
& LCP

NO past project reference available.

This is subject to ONGC Acceptance

Not acceptable. This is subject to ONGC

acceptance

Machine protection/ monitoring

system shall be Bently Nevada 3500 for each
package & Common System 1 shall be
provided.

Not acceptable. This is subject to ONGC

approval.

To be discussed

Shall be discussed further. In past projects

Siemsn has provided personel protection
To be discussed with E&I
To be discussed with E&I

Not acceptable. String test/MRT(FLFS) is

planned vendor works

Not acceptable. All th especial tools as per

ONGC FS shall be included in base scope of
supply. Any additional Special tools as per
OEM recommendation shall also be included

Not Acceptable.
Boroscope meeting ONGC Spec requirement
shall be included in base scope

Not Acceptable.
Portable emission monitor meeting ONGC
Spec requirement shall be included in base
scope

Not Acceptable .complete rotor dynamic and

vibration calculations (Lateral & torsional) is
required, inline with FS requirement

Noted. This is subject to ONGC acceptance.

However in the technical offer Dresser Rad
has given the option of DC LO pump or run
down tank, Dresser Rand to check. EPC
prefers DC motor driven LO pump.

We understand that this is seal gas

conditioning unit. There is no deviation

Dresser Rand to confirm that in the event of

failure of Auxilliary AC motor driven LO
pump, Alarm/Indication will be displayed in
UCP

This shall be included in the gauge board

Not part of any previous project Exceptions.
To be discussed and transmitter for Low LO
tank start inhibit shall be in Dresser Rand
Scope

Not acceptable . This is subject to ONGC

acceptance. Dresser Rand shall provide
alarms & trips inline with Annexure-1 of FS
5404

Not acceptable. Refer comments elsewhere

Not acceptable. Refer comments elsewhere

Not Acceptable. SFGCS, LO cooler, ASV,
ASV- instruments are on DR scope

Not acceptable. Low/High differential

pressure shall initiate Alarm followed by trip,
any deviation shall be subject to ONGC
acceptance

Not acceptable. Refer scope split

Not acceptable. Dresser Rand to provide cost

& time for Coupled MRT of each train

To be discussed

Past project reference not avilable. This is

subject to ONGC acceptance

Past project reference not avilable. This is

subject to ONGC acceptance

Provision for lifting shall be provided

Provision for lifting all onskid items shall be

provided inline with ONGC FS

Not acceptable
Not acceptable
2 sets shall be provided as part of base scoe

SS tag shall be provided along with

embossing

Deviation may be provided inline with past

project, subject to ONGC acceptance

Spec applicable to DR

ONGC vendor list shall be followed

Applicable w.r.t modul engineering

Noted for skid, but for module engineering
same to be taken care by dresser rand.

Noted, if material is SS 316L or above.

As per ONGC FS 5404 latest edition of API

needs to be followed which is API 617 8th
edition

Not acceptable. Deviation should be accepted

by ONGC.

Not acceptable. Deviation should be accepted

by ONGC.

Clarification is not clear. As per datasheet

coating are not required.
Not acceptable. This is subject to ONGC
acceptance

Not acceptable. String test requirement is as

per the details commented elsewhere in the
document.

Not acceptable. Noise test requirement is as

per the details commented elsewhere in the
document.

Not acceptable. String test requirement is as

per the details commented elsewhere in the
document.
Not acceptable. Noise test requirement is as
per the details commented elsewhere in the
document.

Not acceptable.
Subject to accetance by ONGC

DR to note that SS 316 L is required for LO

piping

To be discussed with Dinesh

API 617 08th edition shall be followed

Vendor to comply with the requirement

mentioned elsewhere in the document.

Deviation not clear.