You are on page 1of 8

Adaptive Structuration Theory

Scott Poole
GROUP DECISION MAKING
INFLUENCED not DETERMINED by:
group composition, communication
networks, status hierarchies, task
requirements, group norms, peer
pressure
ADAPTIVE STRUCTURATION THEORY
moves beyond determinism, beyond
phases
Basic Ideas
 Addresses issues of stability and
change, free will and determination
 Rejects a single sequence of group
effectiveness in decision-making
 Few groups (25%) follow a single
sequence model
 Group dynamics too complicated to
reduce to simple propositions
Structuration
Structuration: People enter into situations not
of their own making, yet can transform it
Rules: ideas people have about how something
should be done
Resources: materials, possessions, attributes
(incl. expertise, relationships) people bring; in
short-supply, unequally distributed
Production: people ADAPT rules and resources
in interaction
Reproduction: action reinforces existing
system.
Structuration (2)
 People consciously adapt rules and
resources to accomplish goals
THROUGH COMMUNICATION
 Interaction raises concerns of morality,
communication and power
 Rules and resources restrain/empower
 Appropriation: rules/resources
borrowed from parent culture (e.g. one
person, one vote; balloting; anonymous
idea generation)
Structuration (3)
 Spirit – the values behind the
interaction, hold rules and resources
together. Spirit determines when
appropriation is faithful or ironic.
Duality of Structure
 Rules and resources are both the medium
and the outcome of the interaction. A
decision is affected by rules and resources,
but it also affects those structures.
 Rules and resources can be stable through
continual use, or can change, sometimes
gradually through “interpenetration of
structures” (e.g. consensus method might
interpenetrate voting method)
Implications and Critique
 Groups create themselves
 Focus on empowerment
 Preference for small, gradual changes
 Ethical preferences for certain forms of
communication not essential to the
theory: e.g. anti-authoritarian, pro-
democratic, anti-conformist

You might also like