Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Adaptive Structuration Theory
Adaptive Structuration Theory
Scott Poole
GROUP DECISION MAKING
INFLUENCED not DETERMINED by:
group composition, communication
networks, status hierarchies, task
requirements, group norms, peer
pressure
ADAPTIVE STRUCTURATION THEORY
moves beyond determinism, beyond
phases
Basic Ideas
Addresses issues of stability and
change, free will and determination
Rejects a single sequence of group
effectiveness in decision-making
Few groups (25%) follow a single
sequence model
Group dynamics too complicated to
reduce to simple propositions
Structuration
Structuration: People enter into situations not
of their own making, yet can transform it
Rules: ideas people have about how something
should be done
Resources: materials, possessions, attributes
(incl. expertise, relationships) people bring; in
short-supply, unequally distributed
Production: people ADAPT rules and resources
in interaction
Reproduction: action reinforces existing
system.
Structuration (2)
People consciously adapt rules and
resources to accomplish goals
THROUGH COMMUNICATION
Interaction raises concerns of morality,
communication and power
Rules and resources restrain/empower
Appropriation: rules/resources
borrowed from parent culture (e.g. one
person, one vote; balloting; anonymous
idea generation)
Structuration (3)
Spirit – the values behind the
interaction, hold rules and resources
together. Spirit determines when
appropriation is faithful or ironic.
Duality of Structure
Rules and resources are both the medium
and the outcome of the interaction. A
decision is affected by rules and resources,
but it also affects those structures.
Rules and resources can be stable through
continual use, or can change, sometimes
gradually through “interpenetration of
structures” (e.g. consensus method might
interpenetrate voting method)
Implications and Critique
Groups create themselves
Focus on empowerment
Preference for small, gradual changes
Ethical preferences for certain forms of
communication not essential to the
theory: e.g. anti-authoritarian, pro-
democratic, anti-conformist