Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C o n g e n i t a l B l o c k V e r t e b r a e C2-Cs
in Patients with Cervical Myelopathy
By
R. de Graaff
With 7 Figures
Summary
One hundred and forty-five patients presenting with symptoms of cervical
myelopathy were treated surgically. Eight of these patients (5.50/0) showed
congenitalblock vertebrae C~-C3. The relationship betweenthis congenitalanomaly
and the occurrenceof spondyloticmyelo-radiculopathyis discussed.
Keywords: Congenital block vertebrae; cervical myelopathy; cervical
spondylosis; Klippel-FeiI syndrome.
Introduction
Congenital anomalies of the cervical spine are relatively common
in clinical radiology. According to Fried 8 one of the most commonly
encountered anomalies are blo& vertebrae C2-Ca. The presence of
blo& vertebrae is not necessarily accompanied by clinical symptoms,
although in certain circumstances they may themselves cause neuro-
logical disturbances or they may reinforce the effect of trauma. They
also predispose to early spondylosis is.
Radiological examination shows also that cervical spondylosis is
a common finding after middle age. In only a small proportion of
the population, cervical spondylosis adversely affects the spinal cord
and its roots. We now know that patients presenting with symptoms
of spondylotic myelopathy often show a marked decrease in the
initial sagittal diameter of the spinal canal as compared to patients with
asymptomatic spondylosis or spondylosis with only radiculopathy.
In their paper on "The neurological manifestation of cervical
spondylosis" 2, Brain, Northfield, and Wilkinson described four pa-
0001-6268/82/0061/0111/$ 03.20
112 R. de Graaff:
Table 1
Table 1 (continued)
Vll Neck pain and left-sided shoulder Slight atrophy of Deltoid, Spinati
male pain, with numbness and tingling and Biceps. Paresis left forearms
44 years of all fingers, with a left-sided and hand. Slight impairment of
preponderance. After chiropraxis deep sensation of all fingers.
progressive spastic paraparesis, also Severe spastic-ataxic paraparesis,
more marked on the left side. more marked on the left side. Loss
Finally inability to walk without of deep sensation below the knees.
aid.
VIII Pain in the neck, right shoulder, Atrophy of Deltoid, Spinati, Bi-
female and hand with progressive wasting ceps and Brachio-radialis, with
66 years of shoulder musculature and weak- paresis of right forearm and hand.
ness of forearm and hand, fol- Impairment of deep sensation of
lowed by progressive paresis of both hands. Hypalgesia below the
both legs, numbness and tingling T2-1evel. Severe spastic-ataxic
of both hands and feet. Finally paraparesis. Incontinence.
bedridden.
Clinical M a t e r i a l
Since 1962, 145 patients presenting with symptoms of cervical spondylotic
myelopathy were treated surgically in our clinic. Forty-one patients were female
(28.5~ and 104 patients were male (71.5~ Sex ratio: 1:2.5. Ages varied
between 21 and 77 years.
Patients presenting with radiologicaI evidence of anomalies in the cranio-
cervical junction, and patients with the "original" Klippel-Feil syndrome,
Type I ~, 9, 10, were excluded from the series.
Three types of operations were performed: 1. decompressive laminectomy,
whether extensive 1 or limited to three or four levels, with or without sectioning
of the dentieulate ligaments and dural grafting (112 patients), 2. antero-lateral
8 Acta Neurochirurgica, Voi. 61, Fast. 1--3
114 R. de Graaff:
Table 2
operation according to the method of Robinson and Smith l~, which Verbiest
modified by using wedge-shaped, autoge~ous tibial cortical bone grafts instead of
cancellous iliac bone (21 patients), 3. a lateral operation on the cervical spine as
described by Verbiest 15, 18 with or without vertebral fusion (12 patients).
Eight patients (5.5%) showed radiologically congenital block vertebrae C~-C3.
One of these patients also had a congenital block vertebra C5-C ~. In this group
three patients were female. The length of history up to the time of diagnosis
varied from three months to nine years. All patients underwent a decompressive
laminectomy. One patient died two months after the operation due to cardiac
Congenital Block Vertebrae Ce-C z 115
failure. Sevenpatients were available for follow up. The follow-up periods varied
between 17 months and 8 years.
The clinical findings and other pertinent data are summarized in Tables 1
and 2.
Results
History and Examination
Since a C2-Ca block vertebra can cause excessive dynamic stress
on the lower cervical levels, and so lead to spondylarthrosis of C3-C~
and C4-C 5 levels, one should expect involvement of the upper cervical
cord and of the roots C 4 and C 5. In five patients, however, dys-
aesthesiae, i.e., "numbness and tingling" of the finger tips and
eventually of the digits and hands, often followed by clumsiness and
weakness of one or both hands, were prominent presenting symptoms.
All patients however showed also evidence of spondylosis C5-C6
with foraminal narrowing, which makes the presenting symptoms as
mentioned above understandable. Only three patients presented with
symptoms of flaccid paresis and atrophy of the spinati, deltoids,
biceps, rhomboids, and brachio-radiolis indicating some involvement
of the C~ and C~ roots. The presenting symptom in two patients was
neck pain radiating into one or both shoulders, and in one patient
neck pain radiating into both arms to the thumbs and index
fingers.
In most cases these signs and symptoms preceded the onset of
weakness and atrophy of the small muscles of the hand, which was
asymmetrical in most cases. They also preceded the spastic-ataxic
paraparesis with hyperreflexia, clonus and extensor plantar signs.
Five patients were unable to walk without aid, one patient was
bedridden.
Impairment of appreciation of light touch, tactile discrimination,
and pinprick over the fingers, and loss of vibration sense below the
iliac crest or below the knees, were found in every patient. One
patient showed Lhermitte's sign on flexion of the cervical spine. On
examination, only two patients showed a severe limitation of all
cervical spine movements. One patient had urgency of micturition,
and at the time of admission another patient was incontinent (see
also Table 1).
RadioIogical Examination
Plain lateral films showed congenital block vertebrae C2-C~ in all
patients. One patient showed also a C5-C 6 block vertebra (case VIII).
All patients showed segmentation failures of both articular facets
and neural arches. Five patients had "fused" spinous processes, and
one patient showed a spina bifida C6 (case IV). Six patients under-
8*
116 R. de Graaff:
Fig. L The foramen C=-C~ is round and shows no narrowing from osteopbytes
(single arrow). The foramen of C~-C4 is narrowed due to osteophytes (double
arrow)
30'
2;
2;
24
2~
26
18~
16~
12~
®O ®®
®
~l I I I l i i
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C-~
Fig. 2. The midline sagittal diameter in five patients of this series (--) in relation
to the normal range o,f the sagittaI diameter in normal patients (shaded area).
(3 represents the "minimum theco-periosteal diameter"
118 R. de Graaff:
Discussion
The nomenclature of the radiological diagnosis "block vertebra"
remains a matter of dispute. The term "block vertebra" is a descrip-
tive term, saying nothing about the aetiology of the anomaly. Block
vertebrae, in addition to being congenital may be acquired, as is the
case in juvenile rheumatoid arthritis (Still's disease), rheumatoid
spondylitis, trauma, tuberculosis, or other infective diseases.
Still there is some disagreement whether the lesion is a fusion or
a non-segmentation. Hadley prefers to describe congenital union of
vertebrae as non-segmentation rather than fusion, because separation
of the primary segments of the spine during the first eight weeks of
embryonic life does not occur. Not-segmentation is the preferable
designation since the condition results from failure of segmentation
Congenital Block Vertebrae C~-C3 119
Fig. 3. Case IV: Myelography with metrizamide shows a poor filling of the sub-
arachnoid space due to stenosis of the spinal canal and a "soft disc herniation"
Ca-C~ (arrow), which reduces the MTPD to 8.5 ram. Note also the subluxation
CrCv and the anomalous bifid spinous process C6
gl
b~
Fig. 7, Case VI: Extension-flexion films (A and B)show the disproportionate mobility at C4-C 5 and C5-C~. due
to a block vertebra C~-C3, spondylosis, and osteophytosis of C~-C4 and C~-Cv. Plain lateral film, six years after
operation, shows a fusion of C5, C6, and C 7. Although the greatest stress is now placed upon C4-C5, practically no
spondylotic changes are noticed at this level
124 R. de Graaff:
falls upon the C3-C4 level, and to a lesser extent upon the C4-C 5
level. Once a severe spondylarthrosis at the C3-C 4 level is established,
the movements at this level are inhibited by osteophytes of the
vertebral bodies, and by osteophytosis of the neurocentral and zygo-
apophyseal joints. This is the cause of extra dynamic stress upon the
C~-C 5 level (Fig. 4). In elderly people this can lead to very severe
degenerative changes of the upper cervical spine (Fig. 5), and to com-
pression of the upper cervical cord and its roots. In conjunction with
"the normal for age" degenerative changes of the lower cervical
levels, especially C5-C6, the cord may be compressed from C~ to T1.
It is a well-known fact that in most cases the development of
myelopathy is related to the initial size of the spinal canal 12. 23
Verbiest distinguished between patients with relative and patients
with absolute stenosis of the lumbar spinal canal 27. We used the
same nomenclature for stenosis of the cervical spinal canal, and so
did Epstein e t al. 6 in a recent article on traumatic myelopathy in
patients with cervical spinal stenosis. Although all our patients
showed evidence of a reduced initial sagittaI diameter, we were able
to make accurate measurements in only five cases. Two patients
showed an absolute stenosis with a sagittal diameter of 10 ram, and
two patients showed a relative stenosis with a diameter of 13 turn
or less. Osteophytes, and in case IV a "soft disc herniation" (Fig. 3),
further reduced the sagittaI diameter of the spinal canal, leading in
five cases to a "minimum theco-periosteal diameter" of less than
10 ram. This makes compression of the cord very likely, especially
on extension of the cervical spine. Patients with cervical spinal
stenosis are uniquely vulnerable to hyperextension injuries of the
cord ~. The abnormal mobility of the cervical levels below a block
vertebra C~-C3, with in some cases subluxation, add to the inter-
mittent compression of the cord. None of our patients however,
presented with a history of acute trauma.
The nerve roots C~ and C5, passing through the intervertebral
foramina C3-C 4 and C~-C5 respectively may be compressed in a
foramen, once this is narrowed by osteophytes. Only three patients
of this series showed a flaccid paresis and atrophy of the involved
muscles of the shoulder, although all patients showed foraminal
narrowing C3-C~ and C4-C 5.
In six cases an improvement of spastic-ataxic paraparesis was
noticed. These patients were able to walk without aid. The very
disabling sensory disturbances, for instance the paraesthesiae and
numbness of the fingers and hands, together with the atrophy of the
small muscles of the hand, leading to a loss of dexterity, remained
unchanged in most cases.
Congenital Block Vertebrae C2-C8 125
Conclusions
Acknowledgement
I would like to thank Mr. J. A. Veiga Pires, M.D., Ph.D., F.R.C.R., (Consultant
radiologist and head of the division of Neuroradiology, University Hospital,
Utrecht, The Netherlands) for helping me with the manuscript, Mr. A. Wollenberg,
medical photographer, for making the photographs and Miss Sanne de Graaff for
her administrative assistance.
References
1. Aboulker, J., Metzger, J., David, M., Ballivet, J., Les my~lopathies cervicales
d'origine rachidienne. Neurochirurgie 11 (1965), 87--148.
2. Brain, W. R., Northfield, D. W. C., Wilkinson, M., The neurological manifesta-
tion of cervical spondylosis. Brain 75 (1952), 187--225.
3. Burrows, H. R., The sagittal diameter of the spinal canal in cervical
spondylosis. Clin. Radiol. 14 (1963), 77--86.
4. Epstein, J. A., Carras, R., Epstein, B. S., Lavine, L. S., Myelopathy in cervical
spondylosis with vertebral subluxation and hyperlordosis. J. Neurosurg..32
(1970), 421--426.
5. Epstein, J. A., Carras, R., Hyman, R. A., Costa, S., Cervical myelopathy
caused by developmental stenosis of the spinal canal. J. Neurosurg. 51 (1979),
362--367.
6. Epstein, N., Epstein, J. A., Benjamin, V., Ransohoff, ]'., Traumatic myelopathy
in patients with cervical spinal stenosis without fracture or dislocation. Spine 5
(1980), 489--496.
7. Fell, A., L'absence et la diminution des vert~bres cervicales (~tude clinique).
Thesis, Paris, 1919.
8. Fried, K., Der Wirbelblock. Radiol. Diagn. 4 (1963), 165--172.
9. Gray, S. W., Romaine, C. B., Skandalakis, ]'. E., Congenital fusion of the
cervical vertebrae, a collective review. Surg. Gyn. Obstet. 118 (1964), 373--385.
126 R. de Graaff: Congenital Block Vertebrae C~-C3
I0. Gunderson, C. Ht, Greenspan, R. H., Glaser, G. I-t., Lubs, H. A., The Klippel-
Fell syndrome: genetic and clinical reevaluation of cervical fusion. Medicine 46
(1967), 491--496.
11. Hadley, L. A., Disturbances of cervical spine development. In: Anatomico-
Roentgenographic studies of the spine, 1st ed., chapter 3. Springfield, Ill.:
Ch. C Thomas. 1964.
12. Nurick, S., The pathogenesis of the spinal cord disorder associated with cervical
spondylosis. Brain 95 (1972), 87--100.
13. Payne, E. E., Spillane, J. D., The cervical spine: an anatomico-pathological
study of 70 specimens. Brain 80 (1952), 571--596.
14. Robinson, R. A., Smith, G. W., Antero-lateral cervical disc removal and inter-
body fusion for the cervical disc syndrome. Bull. Johns Hopkins Hosp. 96
(1955), 223--224.
15. Verbiest, H., A lateral approach to the cervical spine: technique and indications.
J. Neurosurg. 28 (1968), 191--203.
16. Verbiest, H., La chirurgie ant~rieure et laterale du rachis cervical. Neuro-
chirurgie 16, Suppl. 2 (1970).
17. Verbiest, H., Neurogenic intermittent claudication in cases with absolute and
relative stenosis of the lumbar vertebral canal (ABLC and RSLC), in cases with
narrow lumbar intervertebral foramina, and in cases of both entities. Clin.
Neurosurg. 20 (I973), 204--214.
18. Young, A. C., Radiology of the cervical spine. In: Cervical spondylosis,
2nd ed. (Wilkinson, M., ed.), pp. 106--112. London: William Heinemann. 1970.