Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary
School Students in Malaysia 1 Noor Haslinda Shuib, 2Noriah Mohd. Ishak, 3Salleh Amat & 4Ismail Ahmad 1 Institute of Teacher Education, Technical Education Campus, Negeri Sembilan 2 Pusat PERMATApintar Negara, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia 3,4 Faculty of Education, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Abstract: - Many researchers believe that high emotional intelligence (EQ) is a driving force for excellence in academic achievement. Thus, this study is conducted to identify the extent of contribution of eight EQ domains to academic achievement of primary school students. A total of 918 students in Grades 3 and 4 were involved. The results showed that the level of EQ among primary school students was 73.74%. The ranking of EQ domain according to the highest performance was spirituality (88.60%), and followed by self- awareness and empathy (77.69%), self-motivation (77.22%), maturity (72.58%), social skills (69.50%), self- confidence (67.68%) and self-regulation (63.42%). Thus, six from the eight domains (self-motivation, self- regulation, spirituality, self-awareness, empathy and self-confidence) were found to significantly contribute to student's academic achievement. The findings can be used by teachers, counselors, psychologists, academics and those involved in child development to develop EQ-related programs to ensure students' excellence in academic field. Keywords: emotional intelligence, academic achievement, primary school students. Introduction Over the last few centuries, philosophers and emotion can be handled well. Management is not psychologists have made 'emotion' as an important merely about self-emotion, but it also involves the issue to debate due to its high impact on academic emotions of others particularly those who are and career excellence. Among the aspects that are significant to them. Thus, EQ is defined as the often discussed are the needs of a student to manage ability of oneself to recognize, understand, analyze well his/her emotion in order to achieve outstanding and control his/her emotions as well as others while academic achievements. However, it is easy for an living a daily life, such as self-relationships and individual to show emotions, but it is usually surrounding community (Goleman, 1996). difficult to control such emotions to be appropriate Goleman (1996) further elaborates the advantages in specific times, places, situations and individuals. of EQ domain such as self-motivation, stress relief, In other words, appropriate emotions are difficult effective communication, empathy towards others, for an individual to practice and tackle without skill. overcoming challenges and solving conflicts. Hence, a few psychologists have developed Hence, individuals with high EQ are usually emotional management models to address associated with those who always have success in Emotional Intelligence or Emotional Quotient (EQ) life. (Bar-On, 2000; Goleman, 1996; Mayer, Salovey & A study reported by Chong, Zamri and Hamidah Caruso, 2004). (2013) found that there is no significant difference The above description explains that the concept of in level of students’ EQ according to gender, EQ is associated with one's ability to manage a suggesting that EQ-related programs in schools variety of emotions in a proper manner so that each should not differentiate male or female students. On
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia the other hand, if viewed from a different Chong et al. (2013), and thus EQ is not directly perspective, the program should take into account linked to academic achievement, but it can be their capabilities in certain subjects such as Malay suggested in improving their performance (Garg, Language (Chong et al., 2013), English (Elhaj, Levin, & Tremblay, 2016). At the same time, 2015) and Mathematics (Ramirez et al., 2016) to intrinsic motivation (Bouffard et al., 2003) and enhance their achievement in those subjects. In fact, social awareness (Minaabad & Rad, 2016) have not Minaabad and Rad (2016) emphasized the ability of contributed substantially to academic achievement. students to master two languages depends largely Based on the above arguments, EQ-related studies on their EQ level. Therefore, Minaabad and Rad need to be continuously carried out to obtain (2016) recommended that EQ should be taught or stronger and more reliable findings. exposed to primary school teachers. In fact, Elhaj Research Objectives (2015) suggested that English curriculum could be better taught when EQ domains are applied in the Generally, this study aims to examine the extend of teaching process. EQ domains that contribute to academic achievement of primary school students. Therefore, In the meantime, many EQ-related studies using a it is important to look at EQ domains consisting of special model which had been introduced by self-awareness, self-confidence, self-regulation, western researchers, but did not contain a spiritual self-motivation, empathy, social skills, spirituality domain. This model will not provide and maturity, which may influence student's comprehensive insights if studies are conducted on academic performance. Hence, the objectives of primary school students in Malaysia as their parents this study are as follows: are so concerned about religious matters. Besides, there are also a handful of students who do not care To identify EQ levels among primary school about spiritual elements while in schools. They students. often violate religious laws such as ‘khalwat’, To identify the level of students’ EQ domains, i.e. molest attempts, sexual promiscuity and many more self-awareness, self-confidence, self-regulation, (Salleh et al., 2016). Therefore, using the EQ self- motivation, empathy, social skills, spirituality model from the western researchers, the spiritual and maturity. aspect should be included in the model to suit the To identify the EQ domain that contributes to culture of schoolchildren in this country. Therefore, students’ academic achievement. this study uses the Goleman Model (1996) adapted from Noriah et al., (2004) to identify the Research Methodology relationship between EQ and students' academic Population and Research Samples achievement with several program proposals for improving the specific EQ domain; in particular the A total of 918 primary school students of Grade 3 spiritual aspect. and 4 in Malacca, Malaysia were randomly selected for this study. The ratio between male and female In conclusion, majority of the previous studies have students in this study was almost the same (N = 434 shown that EQ is significantly related to academic male students; N = 484 female students). Data for achievement. High EQ level leads to high academic students’ academic achievement were taken from achievement for a student. In addition, EQ is an their final exam conducted by their respective important predictor for academic achievement school. (Mega, Ronconi, & Beni, 2014), but the linkages between these two variables continue to be Methodology and Research Analysis questioned. For example, there is a weak The design of this study was a survey using relationship between EQ and achievement of Malay questionnaire as a means of data collection. Data Language subjects among students as reported by analysis procedures involved descriptive and
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia inferential analysis. Descriptive statistics, such as motivation, self-esteem, empathy, social skills, frequency, percentage, mean and standard spirituality and maturity on students’ academic deviation, were used to analyze EQ level and achievement. Interpretation of Emotional academic achievement of students. Furthermore, Intelligence Index Values was used to interpret the inferential statistics, i.e. multiple regression analysis EQ level. The interpretation is described as shown was used to predict the contribution of EQ domain in Table 1. factors such as self-awareness, self-regulation, self- TABLE 1 Interpretation of EQ Index Values Percentage value of EQ Index Interpretation 81 until 100 The emotional intelligence traits inherent within an individual can become his strength and should be fully utilized. 61 until 80 The trait of emotional intelligence within an individual can be his strength, but it should be sought in that individual. 41 until 60 The emotional intelligence traits needed by an individual are weak and need to be developed. Less than 40 The emotional intelligence traits that should be within an individual are at a very weak level and need to be built as soon as possible.
(Noriah & Siti Rahayah, 2005)
Measurement Tools MEQI-C has undergone validity and reliability testing. Based on the CFA test of the items in This study used the Malaysian Emotional Quotient MEQI-A, the loading items received for MEQI-C Inventory-Children (MEQI-C) as a measuring tool are as follows: (i) Intrapersonal competence of the for children version which was adapted from Siti self-awareness domain (EQ1 = 0.48, EQ2 = 0.58 Aishah (2006) from the adult version of Malaysian and EQ3 = 0.72), self-confidence (EQ4 = 0.28, EQ7 Emotional Quotient Inventory-Adult (MEQI-A) = 0.69 and EQ8 = 0.65) and self-motivation (EQ9 = developed by Noriah et al. (2004). MEQI-C 0.70, EQ10 = 0.62 and EQ11 = 0.37); (ii) contained 30 items with 'Yes' and 'No' as the Interpersonal competencies for empathy domain measurement scales. There were two main sections (EQ13 = 0.46, EQ16 = 0.61, EQ15 = 0.73 and in MEQ1-C: (i) respondent's profile such as name, EQ14 = 0.46) and social skills (EQ18 = 0.56., EQ17 school name, age, class, gender, number of siblings = 0.46 and EQ19 =.66) ; (iii) Spiritual domain and birth position in the family; and (ii) statements (EQ20 = 0.37, EQ21 = 0.35, EQ22 = 0.80 and that measured eight domains and some subdomains EQ23 = 0.48); and (iv) maturity domain (EQ26 = of emotional intelligence. Fifteen items represented 0.56, EQ27 = 0.71, EQ30 = 0.52 and EQ28 = 0.60) the intrapersonal competence; three items for self- (Siti Aishah, 2006). Subsequent to the construct conscious domain, three items for self-confidence validity process, this measuring tool was analyzed domain, six items for self-regulatory domain, and to obtain credibility. The overall reliability value of three items for self-motivated domain. Meanwhile, this measuring instrument was 0.71. Therefore, it seven items represented interpersonal competencies; four items for empathy domain and three items for can be concluded that this measurement tool is reliable because it is at a good level (Sherri, 2003), social skills domain. Moreover, four items and thus MEQI-C can be used in this study. represented spirituality domain and four items represent maturity domain.
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia Research Findings domains. The mean scores for other EQ domains were at moderate level, such as self-awareness (M = Analysis of Students’ EQ Level 77.69, SP = 2.42), empathy (M = 77.69, SP = 2.28), Table 2 shows that the students' EQ index was at self-motivation (M = 77.22, SP = 2.68), maturity moderate level, the overall EQ mean percentage (M = 72.58, SP = 2.51), social skills (M = 69.50, SP was 73.74% (n = 918, SP = 1.25). Detailed analysis = 2.88) and self-confidence (M = 67.68, SP = 2.31). based on each domain showed that the spirituality Similarly, self-regulatory domain (M = 63.42, SP = domain (M = 88.60, SP = 1.82) was at high level, 1.94) was also at moderate level with the lowest where the mean score was greater than other EQ mean score compared to other domains. TABLE 2 Level of Primary School Students’ EQ EQ Domains Mean (%) SP Interpretation Self-awareness 77.69 2.42 Moderate Self-confidence 67.68 2.31 Moderate Self-regulation 63.42 1.94 Moderate Self-motivation 77.22 2.68 Moderate Empathy 77.69 2.28 Moderate Social skills 69.50 2.88 Moderate Maturity 72.58 2.51 Moderate Spirituality 88.60 1.82 High
Overall Mean of EQ = 73.74% SP = 1.25
Contribution of EQ Domains to Students (r = .38) of variant changes in academic achievement [F (3,915) = 51.612, p < .05]. The Academic Achievement combination of the independent predictor variables Based on Table 3, results from the study shows (β = .15, p < .05) in four predictor variables significant six variants of the predictor, i.e. self- contributed 16.6 percent (r = .41) variant changes in motivation (β = .14, p < .05), self-regulation (β = academic achievement [F (4,914) = 45.560, p < .14, p < .05), spirituality (β = .13, p < .05), self- .05]. Meanwhile, when the empirical predictor awareness (β = .15, p < .05), empathy (β = .11, p < variables (β = 0.11, p < .05) were taken into .05) and self-confidence (β = .06, p < .05) as the account, the five predictor variables contributed contributing factors towards academic achievement 17.8 percent (r = .42) variant changes in academic of students. The findings for a combination of six achievement [F (5,913) = 39.430, p < .05]. Finally, EQ domains contributions were indicated by the R² the combination between the variables of self- value. In this case, self-motivation (β = .27, p < confidence predictor (β = .06, p < .05) in the six .05) contributed 7.2 percent (r = .27) variant predictor variables contributed 18.1 percent (r = changes in academic achievement performance [F 0.43) variant changes in academic achievement [F (1,917) = 70.812, p < .05]. The combination (6,912) = 33.632, p < .05]. between two self-motivated variables (β = .23, p < .05) and self-regulation (β = .22, p < .05) accounted Discussion for 11.9 percent (r = .35) variant changes to High EQ levels are important for primary school academic achievement [F (2,916) = 62.027, p < students in daily learning process. However, the .05]. findings from this study showed that the overall students’ EQ was at moderate level where self- In addition, when the predictor of spiritual variables regulatory domain has the lowest mean. In other (β = .17, p < .05) was taken into account, the three words, there are things that need to be learned, predictor variables were accounted for 14.5 percent repaired and enhanced by students; for example
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia teachers can give assignments to specific students in cannot control their emotions completely. order to become more responsible and thus able to Therefore, they need to learn how to identify and develop their own regulatory domain. This finding understand the emotions of others and to express is in line with a study reported by Moreno (2017) their particular emotions accordingly for who believed that students with moderate EQ levels developing more rational thinking (Moreno, 2017). TABLE 3 Contribution of EQ Domains on Variations of Students Academic Achievement Model B Beta (β) T Sig. R2 Contribution (%) Self-motivation .092 .141 4.347 .000 .072 7.2 Self-regulation .130 .143 4.490 .000 .119 11.9 Spirituality .126 .130 4.054 .000 .145 14.5 Self-awareness .111 .153 4.889 .000 .166 16.6 Empathy .086 .111 3.457 .000 .178 17.8 Self-confidence .048 .063 1.999 .000 .181 18.1 Based on the recommendation by Moreno (2017), certain number of students to improve their EQ the moderate level of students’ EQ in this study was level. For example, students’ EQ can be improved more likely because they could not fully exhibit and through group guidance using a particular module express emotion. Students were not only unable to which can be performed by applying therapeutic show their emotion freely, but more than that they play techniques in the module. The use of were reluctant to do so because of certain therapeutic play to children is very appropriate as constraints. Students often hide their feelings the desire to play is their natural trait. particularly at the age of nine and 10 years in which Although the overall EQ level of the students in this they are forced to abide the rules and regulations set study was moderate, however, high spiritual by adults. This situation is closely related to the awareness was the strength factor that can help the rank of heteronomous morality which is the first students to participate. A high spiritual domain stage in Kohlberg's moral development theory explained that the students in this study were (Zakri, 2014). It is therefore unfortunate that the capable of addressing issues in their daily lives as rules that are normally associated with moral and appropriate, for example they can think positively cultural will also affect the level of openness in when facing problems. Therefore, students are expressing emotions. Nevertheless, there is still encouraged to use all the advantages in this domain room for the students to grow well as according to to maximize their potential. They deserve to be Goleman (1996), the level of EQ can increase viewed as highly prudent individuals, avoid through age and life experiences, and in fact EQ can behavior that can harm themselves and others, and also be learned. always surrender to God in order to gain peace as a Furthermore, the findings of this study are contrary student. In other words, high spiritual domain that to a study reported by Kranzler et al. (2016) which exists within the student is the natural strength for was conducted on 204 children aged between seven themselves and should be used optimally (Noriah & and 16 years old. According to Kranzler et al. Siti Rahayah, 2005). (2016), the level of emotional awareness of children Spirituality is a part of religion which means that is low and this is a contributing factor to depression not all spiritual values can be attributed to religion. and anxiety among them. Findings by Kranzler et On the contrary, when discussing religion, al. (2016) are quite alarming when linked to this indirectly the spiritual aspect is involved because all study because the level of students’ EQ at medium religious values have spiritual nature and both terms level can be lowered if it is not well managed. can be used alternately. Based on this assumption, Hence, some programs need to be provided to a it is not surprising that students in this study have a
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia high spiritual domain because Malaysian parents are contributing to academic achievement. Self- concerned about religious aspects in their lives. motivation variable contributed 7.2 percent of This justification has also encouraged Noriah et al. variance in student's academic achievement. This (2004) to conduct a study on EQ by improving the finding is contrary to Bouffard et al. (2003), but Goleman Emotional Intelligence Model (1996). similar to that reported by Supardi et al. (2016). They have added two very important new domains, Supardi et al. (2016) found that high self-motivation i.e. spiritual and maturity domain into the EQ is an important factor in improving student model. academic achievement. High self-motivation means a strong will or spirit of the student which is the key Hence, multiple regression analysis in this study has driver for them to work diligently to achieve shown more detailed findings. From the eight EQ success and excellence. When students have high domains analyzed, it was found that only six level of diligence in learning and performing tasks, domains, namely self-motivation, self-regulation, it can help to improve their EQ and thus they tend spirituality, self-awareness, empathy and self- to achieve high academic achievement. confidence were the contributing factors to students’ academic achievement. On the other Implications and Recommendations hand, two other domains of social skills and This study provides theoretical and practical maturity were not the determining factors which implications for education, counseling and could could be due to lack of social skills at a very psychotherapy. From the theoretical point of view, young age in a learning environment; for example, this study corresponds to the formula by Billings et they may feel awkward in practicing group learning al. (2014) which stateds that EQ and academic methods. From the maturity perspective, it is achievement can be assessed among early difficult for the students to exhibit maturity of adolescent children. As a result, this study involved emotions in that age especially during the learning children as early as nine and 10 years old, so the process at school. data obtained were so valuable to examine the level In the meantime, the six domains described above of their EQ development. Therefore, EQ-related can be used as predictors of academic achievement studies should not only be concentrated in adults, levels. In that regard, the EQ variable predicted but study on primary school students should be 18.1 percent of variance change in academic conducted continuously to find the best ways to achievement. This finding is different from increase their EQ level. The findings can be used by academic achievement in the EQ domain of UAE teachers, counselors, psychologists, academics and (Understanding and Analysing Emotions) which those involved in child development to develop only associated to 11 percent variance change in appropriate programs. both reading and counting performance (Billings et Based on the Goleman EQ Model (1996) adapted al., 2014). It can therefore be concluded that the by Noriah et al., (2004), the dimensions of self- contribution of the EQ factor to the academic awareness, self-regulation, self-motivation, achievement in this study can be considered empathy, social skills, spirituality and maturity are substantial compared to the study conducted by factors that have contributed to academic Billings et al. (2014). Finally, from the 18.1 percent achievement. However, findings from this study variance, it is understandable that apart from the have given a new perspective to the model EQ, there are several other factors that could also developed by Goleman. In this study, the domain contribute to student academic achievement such as of social skills and maturity could not be regarded learning style, IQ, socio-economic status, classroom as factors that can contribute to academic environment and teaching method. achievement of students. In addition, the study also Furthermore, findings from this study showed that shows that self-confidence domain as introduced the self-motivation domain was a major factor in by Siti Aishah (2006) also contributed to academic
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia achievement. Hence, the relevant EQ model for Quotient Inventory. In R. Bar-On & J.D. A. children to be used in future research is to include Parker (Eds.), Handbook of emotional the domain of self-awareness, self-regulation, self- intelligence (pp. 363-388). San Francisco, CA: motivation, empathy, spirituality and self- Jossey-Bass confidence. It can therefore be concluded that these 2. Billings, C. E. W., Downey, L. A., Lomas, J. six domains can form an EQ model for children. E., Lloyd, J., & Stough, C. (2014). Emotional intelligence and scholastic achievement in pre- Conclusion adolescent children. Personality and Individual Overall, this study has succeeded in achieving the Differences, 65, 14–18. Retrieved from objectives outlined. The students involved in this http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2014.01.017 study have moderate EQ levels because they could 3. Bouffard, T., Marcoux, M., Vezeau, C., & not express emotion due to cultural constraints and Bordeleau, L. (2003). Changes in self- moral rules set by adults. However, this moderate perceptions of competence and intrinsic EQ level was offset by their high spiritual domain motivation among elementary school children. due to parenting styles of parents in Malaysia. In British Journal of Education Psychology, 73, addition, this study has reinforced the Goleman EQ 171–186. Model which was culturally improved by Noriah 4. Chong, O. S., Zamri, M, & Hamidah, Y. (Noriah et al., 2004) which assumed that there was (2013). The factors of gender, race, streaming an association between EQ and academic class and their relationship with student's achievement. Finally, in the EQ domains which emotional intelligence in learning Malay were studied, self-motivation domain was the Language. Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa Melayu, crucial factor for the students to achieve excellent 3(1), 12–23. Retrieved from academic achievement. Therefore, teachers, parents http://spaj.ukm.my/jpbm/index.php/jpbm/articl and community members are expected to play e/view/55 pivotal role in enhancing student’s motivation 5. Elhaj, N.H.M. (2015). The relationship through various methods and expertise. between emotional intelligence and english Finally, this study has pointed out that the existing language achievements among private EQ model was not entirely applicable to very young secondary schools’ students at Khartoum children. For example, this study has proven that locality. The Ahfad Journal, 32(1), 15–29. the domains of social skills and maturity did not 6. Garg, R., Levin, E., & Tremblay, L. (2016). affect their academic achievement. Therefore, Emotional intelligence: impact on post- modifications and improvements should be made to secondary academic achievement. Social the domains in the EQ model to explain the Psychology of Education, 19, 627–642. differences of EQ in children compared to adults. 7. Goleman, D. (1996). Emotional Intelligence: Students should be aware of the importance of EQ, Why it can matter more than IQ. New York. particularly through domains of self-awareness, Bantam Books. self-regulation, self-motivation, empathy, 8. Kranzler, A., Young, J. F., Hankin, B. L., spirituality and self-confidence in improving their Abela, J. R. Z., Elias, M. J., & Selby, E. academic achievement. With high EQ, students are A. (2016). able to control emotions, show positive attitudes 9. Emotional awareness : A transdiagnostic related to academic achievement and learn to adapt predictor of depression and anxiety for to the problems faced in their learning process. children and adolescents. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 45(3), 262– References 269. 1. Bar-On, R. (2000). Emotional and social intelligence: Insights from the Emotional
Noor Haslinda Shuib et al /Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement of Primary School Students in Malaysia Retrieved from S. C., & Beilock, S. L. (2016). On the https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/ relationship between maths anxiety and maths 15374416.2014.987379 achievement in early elementary school: The 10. Mayer, D., Salovey, P., & Caruso, R. (2004). role of problem solving strategies. Journal of Models Emotional Intelligence. In Sternberg J. Experimental Child Psychology, 141, 83–100. (Ed.). The Handbook of Intelligence. 396–420. Retrieved from New York: Cambridge University press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jecp.2015.07.014 11. Mega, C., Ronconi, L., & Beni, R. De. (2014). 19. Sherri L.J. (2003). Research Methods and 12. What makes a good student ? How emotions, Statistics: A Critical Thinking Approach. self-regulated learning and motivation Thomson Learning, Belmont, CE. contribute to academic achievement. Journal 20. Siti Aishah, H. (2006). Maternal quality time, of Educational Psychology, 106(1), 121–131. children's emotional intelligence and their Retrieved from academic performance: A structural equation http://www.researchgate.net/publication/26391 modelling analysis. Thesis Dr. of Philosophy, 6847 Faculty of Education, International Islamic 13. Minaabad, M. S., & Rad, M. Z. (2016). The University of Malaysia. study impact of emotional intelligence on 21. Supardi, S., Mohamed Nor Azhari, A., monolingual and bilingual students’ academic Ramlee, M., Ridzwan, C.R., & Che Ghani, achievement. Jurnal Pendidikan Malaysia, C.K. (2016). The emotional intelligence level 41(2), 157–163. Retrieved from of technical and vocational trainers in http://journalarticle.ukm.my/10652/ Kejuruan High School. Sainshumanika, 8(1), 14. Moreno, L.A.S R. (2017). Emotional 41–50. http://doi.org/e-ISSN ISSN: 2289-6996 intelligence and academic achievement. Liceo 22. Zakri, A. (2014). Meta-behavioral skills and Journal of Higher Education Research, 13(2), decision-making skills among student with and 48–64. Retrieved from without disciplinary behavior. Thesis Dr. of http://www.asianscientificjournals.com/public Philosophy, Faculty of Education, National ation/index.php/ljher/article/view/1056 University of Malaysia. 15. Noriah, M.I. & Siti Rahayah, A. (2005). Understanding emotional intelligence of Malaysian teachers. Proceeding for 12th International Conference (ISATT) 2005. 454- 461. 16. Noriah, M.I., Zuria, M., Siti Rahayah, A., Ramlee, M., Ruhizan, M.Y., Norzaini, A., & Ruslin, A. (2004). IRPA Executive Report. MOSTI. 17. Norsaleha, M.S., Ab Halim, T., Noor Hafizah, M.H., Salleh, A., & Amriah, B. (2016). Vitality of the tauhidic emotional intelligence of Malaysia’s muslim adolescents. Malaysian Journal of Society and Space, 12(5), 179–190. Retrieved from http://ejournals.ukm.my/gmjss/article/view/18 007 18. Ramirez, G., Chang, H., Maloney, E. A., Levine,
The Effect of Emotional Intelligence and Spiritual Intelligence On Learning Outcomes of Islamic Religion and Characteristics of Students at SMA Negeri 5 Makassar