You are on page 1of 6

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/5888283

Access to Health Care in Contexts of Livelihood Insecurity: A Framework for


Analysis and Action

Article  in  PLoS Medicine · November 2007


DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.0040308 · Source: PubMed

CITATIONS READS
230 493

12 authors, including:

Brigit Obrist Nelly Iteba


University of Basel 3 PUBLICATIONS   312 CITATIONS   
97 PUBLICATIONS   2,301 CITATIONS   
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE

Christian Lengeler Ahmed Makemba


Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute Ifakara Health Institute
222 PUBLICATIONS   14,794 CITATIONS    27 PUBLICATIONS   1,096 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

IMPROVING NEWBORN SURVIVAL IN SOUTHERN TANZANIA( INSIST) View project

Malaria epidemiology in Papua New Guinea View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Iddy Mayumana on 23 May 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Policy Forum

Access to Health Care in Contexts of


Livelihood Insecurity: A Framework for
Analysis and Action
Brigit Obrist*, Nelly Iteba, Christian Lengeler, Ahmed Makemba, Christopher Mshana, Rose Nathan, Sandra Alba, Angel Dillip,
Manuel W. Hetzel, Iddy Mayumana, Alexander Schulze, Hassan Mshinda

services with poor people’s needs, health care, which they commonly
expectations, and resources. define as utilization rates [15–17].
This article presents a framework They apply determinants’ models and
for analysis and action to explore consider access as a general concept
and improve access to health care in summarizing a set of more specific
resource-poor countries, especially dimensions, such as availability,
in Africa. The framework links social affordability, accessibility, adequacy,
science and public health research with and acceptability. Although they
broader development approaches to take into account demographic
poverty alleviation. It was developed in characteristics of health service users,
the frame of the ACCESS Programme, their knowledge about the disease,
which focuses on understanding and, more recently, wealth as measured
and improving access to prompt and by household assets, health services
effective malaria treatment and care studies tend to pay more attention
in rural Tanzania as an empirical case

A
ccess to health care is a major study [5,6]. The article first provides Funding: The ACCESS Programme is funded by the
health and development a brief outline of three approaches Novartis Foundation for Sustainable Development.
The Health Project Manager (AS) of the Novartis
issue. Most governments to investigating health care access, Foundation contributed to the project design and
declare that their citizens should focusing either on health seeking, the development of this generic access framework.
enjoy universal and equitable access health services, or livelihoods. It then
Competing Interests: AS works for the Novartis
to good quality care. However, even presents a framework that combines Foundation for Sustainable Development, which
within the developed world, this goal the three approaches, exemplified with is fully funded by the pharmaceutical company
research findings and interventions of Novartis. The Foundation works independently from
is difficult to achieve, and there are no the company’s business and supports not-for-profit
internationally recognized standards on the ACCESS Programme. health programs in developing countries.
how to define and measure “equitable
access” [1]. Evidently, big disparities Access to Health Care from Three Citation: Obrist B, Iteba N, Lengeler C, Makemba
A, Mshana C, et al. (2007) Access to health care
exist between the poor and the better Perspectives in contexts of livelihood insecurity: A framework
off with respect to access to health care Health-seeking studies focus on people for analysis and action. PLoS Med 4(10): e308.
doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040308
services and health status [2–4]. Gaps in [7–10]. They apply pathway models and
child mortality between rich and poor follow sick persons step by step from Copyright: © 2007 Obrist et al. This is an open-access
the recognition of symptoms through article distributed under the terms of the Creative
countries are wide, as well as between Commons Attribution License, which permits
the wealthy and the poor within most different types of help seeking until unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in
countries. Poor children are not only they feel healed or capable of living any medium, provided the original author and source
are credited.
more likely than their better off peers with their condition. Health-seeking
to be exposed to health risks and have studies provide a deeper understanding Abbreviations: IEC, information, education,
less resistance to disease, they also have of why, when, and how individuals, and communication; PIOP, policies, institutions,
organizations, and processes; SP, sulphadoxine-
less access to preventive and curative social groups, and communities seek pyrimethamine; TFDA, Tanzania Food and Drugs
interventions. Even public subsidies for access to health care services, and Authority
health frequently benefit rich people investigate interactions between lay Brigit Obrist, Christian Lengeler, Sandra Alba, and
more than poor people. Clearly, more persons and professionals [11]. In Manuel W. Hetzel are with the Department of Public
of the same is not enough [3]: To this perspective, social actors are the Health and Epidemiology, Swiss Tropical Institute,
Basel, Switzerland. Manuel W. Hetzel is also with
improve equitable access, innovative potential driving force for improving the Ifakara Health Research and Development
and community-based approaches access to effective and affordable health Centre, Ifakara, Tanzania, as are Nelly Iteba, Ahmed
are needed to better align health care care, but they are often constrained by Makemba, Christopher Mshana, Rose Nathan,
Angel Dillip, Iddy Mayumana, and Hassan Mshinda.
politics and the economy on national Alexander Schulze is with the Novartis Foundation for
The Policy Forum allows health policy makers around and international levels [12–14]. Sustainable Development, Basel, Switzerland.
the world to discuss challenges and opportunities for
Health service studies concentrate * To whom correspondence should be addressed.
improving health care in their societies.
on factors influencing access to E-mail: brigit.obrist@unibas.ch

PLoS Medicine | www.plosmedicine.org 1584 October 2007 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e308


to the supply than the demand
side [18,19]. They search for policy
interventions to reduce supply barriers
and improve the delivery of services,
including availability of health facilities,
equipment, and qualified staff, staff
skills, protocols of diagnosis, treatment,
and quality of care. Moreover, they
are less oriented towards health-
seeking processes. Interventions
on the demand side are commonly
limited to information, education, and
communication (IEC) campaigns.
Livelihood approaches—as the name
implies—emphasize assets (including
material and social resources) and
activities needed to gain and sustain a
living under conditions of economic
hardship [20–25]. Access is a key
issue for sustainable livelihoods [26].
Recent studies applying the Sustainable
Livelihood framework of the United
Kingdom Department for International
Development to study HIV/AIDS [27] doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040308.g001
and malaria (J. Chuma, unpublished
PhD thesis) demonstrate the many Figure 1. The Health Access Livelihood Framework
difficulties people face in gaining Once people recognize an illness and decide to initiate treatment, access becomes a critical
issue. Five dimensions of access influence the course of the health-seeking process: Availability,
access to household and community Accessibility, Affordability, Adequacy, and Acceptability. What degree of access is reached along
assets and how this constrains their the five dimensions depends on the interplay between (a) the health care services and the broader
strategies to cope with the disease. policies, institutions, organizations, and processes that govern the services, and (b) the livelihood
In other words, not only possession, assets people can mobilize in particular vulnerability contexts. However, improved access and
health care utilization have to be combined with high quality of care to reach positive outcomes.
but mobilization of household and The outcomes can be measured in terms of health status (as evaluated by patients or by experts),
community assets is a critical factor patient satisfaction, and equity.
influencing people’s access to health
care and other health-related services. accessibility, including long distances people can mobilize and combine
Interventions target communities and to nearest dispensary or health center, in particular vulnerability contexts.
social groups, emphasize solidarity scarce public transport, and lack of Hence, access improves as health care
and empowerment, and try to improve bicycles and other private means services become better aligned with
livelihood conditions. continued to be major access barriers. clients’ needs and resources.
Issues related to affordability were
Access to Health Care with a also major obstacles: complaints about The Health Care Services and the
Livelihood Focus fees were frequent, and even if official PIOP
The Health Access Livelihood fees were exempted (e.g., for children Sick persons and caregivers seek help
Framework combines health service under five) or waived (e.g., for persons not only in health facilities or private
and health-seeking approaches and temporarily unable to pay), people practice, but also in drug shops and
situates access to health care in the often ended up paying for drugs, small pharmacies as well as from healers
broader context of livelihood insecurity charges, kerosene, and even ambulance representing a wide array of medical
(Figure 1). transport. Poor people had to resort traditions. Access to these health care
to short-term coping strategies like service providers is governed by cultural
Five Dimensions of Access selling critical assets such as crops norms, policies, laws and regulations,
Access becomes an issue once illness to pay for health care, especially in which themselves are influenced by
is recognized and treatment seeking times of emergencies. Adequacy and broader trends in society, global health
is initiated. Five dimensions of acceptability in terms of people’s policy, research, and development.
access influence the course of the judgment of quality of care also played In malaria control, for instance,
health-seeking process: Availability, an important role. the World Health Organization has
Accessibility, Affordability, Adequacy, What degree of access is reached increasingly recognized the role of the
and Acceptability (see Table 1). along the five dimensions depends private retail sector in improving access
A review of literature from Tanzania on the interplay between (a) the to prompt malaria treatment, since
found, for instance, that people health care services and the broader self-treatment at home is often the first
considered the availability of essential policies, institutions, organizations, and response to a malaria episode [30]. The
drugs a prerequisite to the credibility processes (PIOP) [29] that govern the National Malaria Control Programme
of health services [28]. Problems of services, and (b) the livelihood assets of Tanzania also acknowledges

PLoS Medicine | www.plosmedicine.org 1585 October 2007 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e308


Table 1. Five Dimensions of Access to Health Care Services
Dimension Questions

Availability: What types of services exist? Which organizations offer these services? Is there enough skilled personnel?
The existing health services and goods meet clients’ needs. Do the offered products and services correspond with the needs of poor people? Do the supplies suffice
to cover the demand?
Accessibility: What is the geographical distance between the services and the homes of the intended users? By what
The location of supply is in line with the location of clients. means of transport can they be reached? How much time does it take?
Affordability: What are the direct costs of the services and the products delivered through the services? What are the
The prices of services fit the clients’ income and ability to pay. indirect costs in terms of transportation, lost time and income, bribes, and other “unofficial” charges?
Adequacy: How are the services organized? Does the organizational set up meet the patients’ expectations? Do the
The organization of health care meets the clients’ expectations. opening hours match with schedules of the clients, for instance the daily work schedule of small-scale
farmers? Are the facilities clean and well kept?
Acceptability: Does the information, explanation, and treatment provided take local illness concepts and social values
The characteristics of providers match with those of the clients. into account? Do the patients feel welcome and cared for? Do the patients trust in the competence and
personality of the health care providers?

doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040308.t001

the importance of shops for home Livelihood Assets and the al., unpublished data). Already in the
management of malaria [31]. A shop Vulnerability Context village, families face many difficulties
survey of the ACCESS Programme in gaining access to the resources
showed, however, that the proportion Whether people actually recognize necessary for malaria prevention and
of general shops with antimalarials in an illness and seek treatment in drug case management, but even more so in
stock had dropped from 27% in 2001 shops or through other health care the farming sites [35].
[32] to 8% in 2004 [5]. The reduced services depends to a large extent For nearly all members of the study
availability of antimalarials in general on their access to livelihood assets of communities, land is the backbone of
shops was largely due to a change in the the household, the community, and their livelihood (natural capital) (I.
policy of the Ministry of Health. Until the wider society. These livelihood Mayumana, unpublished MA thesis).
2001, chloroquine was the first-line assets comprise human capital To raise cash for renting bicycles,
antimalarial and was treated as an over- (local knowledge, education, skills), buying drugs, or paying treatment
the-counter drug; Part II drug stores—a social capital (social networks and expenses (financial capital), farmers
category of shops below pharmacies— affiliations), natural capital (land, have to tap household savings, sell
were allowed to sell chloroquine and, in water, and livestock), physical capital food stock, borrow from local money
practice, chloroquine was also tolerated (infrastructure, equipment, and lenders, and work as causal laborers.
in general shops, where it was widely means of transport) and financial Family members and relatives take
available [32]. After the policy change capital (cash and credit) [25]. The sick children to health care services,
from chloroquine to sulphadoxine- availability of these assets is influenced buy drugs, and provide practical
pyrimethamine (SP) as the first-line by forces over which people have little and moral support (social capital).
antimalarial in 2001, SP remained control, for instance economy, politics Bicycles feature prominently as an asset
classified as prescription-only. The or technology, climatic variability or enabling treatment seeking (physical
Tanzania Food and Drugs Authority shocks like floods, draughts, armed capital). Popular and biomedical
(TFDA), which is responsible for all conflicts or epidemics. Such factors concepts of malaria nowadays overlap
regulatory aspects of drugs and other may be referred to as their vulnerability (human capital), probably as a
medical products in the country, did context. consequence of regular and intensive
not reclassify SP as an over-the-counter In the study area of the ACCESS IEC and social marketing campaigns.
drug. Hence, SP could only be legally Programme, the Kilombero Valley in During its first phase (2003–2007), the
sold in pharmacies (Part I drug shops). southeastern Tanzania, the natural ACCESS Programme invested in social
In many parts of the country, SP was also environment increases people’s marketing to increase knowledge and
tolerated in Part II drug stores, though vulnerability to health risks [5]. awareness of malaria and to promote
not in general shops. In the study area, Malaria is highly endemic, transmission prompt and appropriate treatment
the TFDA regulations were enforced, is intense and perennial, and malaria seeking from reliable sources [6]. For
and while the change in malaria policy is the predominant cause of morbidity the second phase starting in 2008,
resulted in a higher treatment efficacy, and mortality. Large parts of the additional initiatives to facilitate access
it also led to an almost 50% decrease valley are flooded during the rain to livelihood assets are planned, such
in the availability of antimalarials. To season from November to May. Most as support to community health funds
improve the availability of antimalarials of the 517,000 people living in the and provision of microcredits.
for home management of malaria, 109 villages (2002) rely on subsistence
the ACCESS Programme decided to agriculture. Labor-intensive rice Health Care Utilization and Quality
collaborate with a TFDA-supported farming on distant fields in the of Care
program that upgrades Part II shops and floodplain forces many families to Depending on access to health care
enables them to sell antimalarials and move to their farming sites during the services and to livelihood assets, people
other essential drugs [33,34]. cultivation period (M. W. Hetzel et develop multiple and changing health

PLoS Medicine | www.plosmedicine.org 1586 October 2007 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e308


care utilization strategies. They may management scheme in all health Author contributions. BO and AS wrote
take no action at all or use different facilities [6]. the manuscript in collaboration with the
service providers simultaneously or in other authors. BO, CL, and HM designed
sequence. However, even if they gain Conclusion the ACCESS Programme. NI, AM, and CM
were responsible for the development and
access and health care utilization takes Even the most powerful diagnostic
implementation of the interventions. SA,
its course, the outcome in terms of tests, drugs, and vaccines have little AD, MWH, and IM were responsible for
health status (as evaluated by experts public health impact if they do not data collection and analysis. RN is in charge
or by patients), patient satisfaction, reach the poor. Providing the goods, of the Demographic Surveillance Site and
and equity (defined as equal access to as well as the services to deliver NI of the overall project management. All
health care by those in equal need [1]) them, and ensuring that goods and authors contributed to and approved the
is subject to the technical quality of services are of high quality, are major final manuscript.
care. In a broad sense, technical quality challenges by themselves, especially References
of care includes provider compliance in a resource-poor setting. But unless 1. Oliver A, Mossialos E (2004) Equity of access
and diagnostic accuracy, safety of the additional efforts are made to enable to health care. Outlining the foundations for
action. J Epidemiol Community Health 58:
product, and patient compliance (or poor people to gain access to these 655–658.
adherence; see Figure 1). goods and services, as well as to more 2. Gwatkin DR (2001) The need for equity-
An ACCESS Programme study basic livelihood assets required to oriented health sector reforms. Int J Epidemiol
30: 720–723.
to determine the effectiveness and initiate treatment seeking, equitable 3. Victora CG, Wagstaff A, Schellenberg JA,
promptness of fever treatment based access remains an empty formula of Gwatkin D, Claeson M, et al. (2003) Applying
the equity lens to child health and mortality:
on caregivers’ accounts highlights the politicians and experts. This is an More of the same is not enough. Lancet 362:
impact of quality of care (M. Hetzel et aspect of the illness–poverty trap that 233–241.
al., unpublished paper). A community is often overlooked. While it has been 4. Gwatkin DR, Wagstaff A, Yazbeck AS, editors
(2005) Reaching the poor with health,
survey of a random sample of 318 increasingly acknowledged that ill- nutrition and population services. What works,
household identified 80 children health contributes to poverty because what doesn’t, and why. Washington (D. C.):
under five years of age who had a fever health costs deplete people’s meager The World Bank. 353 p.
5. Hetzel MW, Msechu J, Goodman C, Lengeler
(considered as a proxy for malaria) resources, it is hardly recognized that C, Obrist B, et al. (2006) Decreased availability
during the 14 days preceding the people often cannot even gain access of antimalarials in the private sector following
the policy change from chloroquine to
interview. The results show that 100% to health services because they cannot sulphadoxine-pyrimethamine in the Kilombero
of the sick children were treated with mobilize critical livelihood resources. Valley, Tanzania. Malar J 5: 109.
a pharmaceutical drug (an antipyretic This article presents an innovative 6. Hetzel M, Iteba N, Makemba A, Mshana C,
Lengeler C, et al. (2007) Understanding and
or antimalarial), 88% were treated framework that pulls together the improving access to prompt and effective
with the recommended antimalarial, strength of social sciences, public malaria treatment and care in rural Tanzania:
76% received the recommended health research, and development The ACCESS Programme. Malar J 6:.83.
7. Suchman EA (1965) Stages in health seeking
antimalarial on the same day or the studies. Through this combination behavior and medical care. J Health Serv Res
day after the fever started, 43% got of perspectives and expertise, a more Policy 6: 114–128.
8. Chrisman N (1977) The health seeking
the recommended antimalarial on comprehensive, but structured analysis process: An approach to the natural history of
the same day or the day after the fever of access to health care in resource-poor illness. Cult Med Psychiatry 1: 351–377.
started in the correct dosage, and only settings can be achieved, which will 9. Kleinman A (1980) Patients and healers in
the context of culture. Berkeley: University of
23% were given the recommended lead to the identification of key entry California Press. 427 p.
antimalarial on the same day or the points and targeted action for health 10. MacKian S, Bedri N, Lovel H (2004) Up the
day after the fever started, in the right and poverty alleviation in horizontal garden path and over the edge: Where might
health seeking behaviour take us? Health Policy
dosage, considering also age and the community-based approaches.  Plan 19: 137–146.
reported symptoms. The multivariate 11. Montgomery CM, Mwangee W, Kong’ong’o
analysis showed that access to and use Acknowledgments M, Pool R (2006) ‘To help them is to educate
them’: Power and pedagogy in the prevention
of a health facility during the course We acknowledge the inputs of M. Tanner,
and treatment of malaria in Tanzania. Trop
of the fever increased the chance of M. Weiss, and other colleagues at the Swiss Med Int Health 11: 1661–1669.
Tropical Institute. Our understanding of 12. Singer M, Baer H (1995) Critical medical
receiving one of the recommended anthropology. Amityville (NY): Baywood. 406 p.
the links between access and livelihood
antimalarials (SP, amodiaquine, draws on discussions within the program 13. Farmer P (1999) Infections and inequalities:
or quinine, according to national The modern plague. Berkeley: University of
of the National Center for Competences California Press.
guidelines) (p = 0.004). On the other in Research “North-South: Research 14. Baer H, Singer M, Susser I (1997) Medical
hand, antimalarials from health Partnerships for Mitigating Syndromes of anthropology and the world system: A critical
perspective. Westport (CT): Praeger. 276 p.
facilities were not more accurately Global Change,” supported by the Swiss
15. Fiedler JL (1981) A review of the literature
dosed than those obtained from shops. National Science Foundation and the Swiss on access and utilization of medical care with
To improve quality of care in health Agency for Development and Cooperation. special emphasis on rural primary care. Soc Sci
This paper was published with the Med 15C: 129–142.
facilities, the ACCESS Programme 16. Penchansky R, Thomas JW (1981) The
supported the Council Health permission of Dr. Andrew Kitua, Director-
concept of access. Definition and relationship
General, National Institute for Medical to consumer satisfaction. Med Care 19:
Management Teams of the two districts
Research of Tanzania. Ethical clearance 127–140.
in carrying out refresher training in of the ACCESS Programme proposal 17. Andersen RM (1995) Revisiting the behavioral
malaria case-management for health was granted by the National Institute of model and access to medical care: Does it
matter? J Health Soc Behav 36: 1–10.
facility staff, followed by strengthening Medical Research of the United Republic of 18. Ensor T, Cooper S (2006) Overcoming barriers
of routine supportive supervision Tanzania (NIMR/HQ/R.8a/Vol. IX/236, to health service access: Influencing the
and the implementation of a quality September 16, 2003). demand side. Health Policy Plan 19: 69–79.

PLoS Medicine | www.plosmedicine.org 1587 October 2007 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e308


19. Gulliford M, Figueroa-Munoz J, Morgan M, Introduction—Overview 1.1. Available: http:// 4819&with=Malaria. Accessed 14 September
Hughes D, Gibson B, et al. (2002) What does www.livelihoods.org/info/info_guidancesheets. 2007.
‘Access to Health Care’ mean? J Health Serv html. Accessed 14 September 2007. 31. Ministry of Health (Tanzania) (2003) National
Res Policy 7: 186–188. 26. De Haan L, Zoomers A (2005) Exploring the malaria medium term strategic plan 2002–
20. Chambers R (1989) Editorial introduction. frontier of livelihoods research. Development 2007. Dar es Salaam: National Malaria Control
Vulnerability, coping and policy. How the poor and Change 36: 27–47. Program.
cope. IDS-Bulletin 20: 1–22. 27. Seeley J, Pringle C (2001) Sustainable 32. Goodman C, Kachur SP, Abdulla S, Mwageni E,
21. Chambers R (1995) Poverty and livelihoods. Livelihood approaches and the HIV/AIDS Nyoni J, et al. (2004) Retail supply of malaria-
Whose reality counts? Environment and epidemic: A preliminary resource paper. related drugs in rural Tanzania. Risks and
Urbanization 7: 173–204. Livelihoods Connect, DFID. Available: http:// opportunities. Trop Med Int Health 9: 655–663.
22. Chambers R, Conway RG (1991) Sustainable www.livelihoods.org/cf/search/showrecord. 33. Mbwasi R (2005) Using a holistic approach
rural livelihoods: Practical concepts for the 21st cfm?ID=135. Accessed 14 September 2007. to transform private sector drug outlets. The
century. IDS Discussion Paper 296. 28. Mamdani M, Bangser M (2004) Poor people’s Tanzania experience. Available: http://www.
23. Carney D, Drinkwater M, Rusinow,T, Neefjes experiences of health services in Tanzania. A msh.org/SEAM/conference2005/agenda.html.
K, Wanmali S (1999) Livelihoods approaches literature review. Reprod Health Matters 12: Accessed 14 September 2007.
compared. A brief comparison of the 138–153. 34. Management Sciences for Health (2006)
livelihoods approaches of the UK Department 29. SDC/NADEL (2006) The poverty-wellbeing Increasing access to quality essential medicines
for International Development (DFID), CARE, internet platform of the Social Development in Tanzania. Available: http://www.msh.org/
Oxfam and the United Nations Development Division (SoDev) of SDC (v 1.0 / 11.12.2006). news_room/stories/Dec22_2004_TZ_meds.
Programme (UNDP). London: Department for Available: http://www.poverty-wellbeing.net/. html. Accessed 14 September 2007.
International Development. 19 p. Accessed 14 September 2007. 35. Mayumana I, Kessy F, Comoro CJ, Obrist B
24. Hussein K (2002) Livelihoods approaches 30. World Health Organization (2005) The Roll (2007) Understanding resilience pathways
compared: A multi-agency review of Back Malaria strategy for improving access in malaria case management in the light of
current practice. London: Department for to treatment though home management of rural livelihood: The case of the Kilombero
International Development. 59 p. malaria. Available: http://library.searo.who. District, Tanzania. Consortium for Research on
25. Department for International Development int/modules.php?op=modload&name=websi Equitable Health Systems (CREHS) Exchange
(1999) Sustainable livelihoods guidance sheets: s&file=wholisdoc&from=wholisdoc1&show=4 Newsletter 2: 2–3.

PLoS Medicine | www.plosmedicine.org 1588 October 2007 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e308

View publication stats

You might also like