Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
High mortality rates among solid organ transplant recipients infected with
extensively drug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii: using in vitro
antibiotic combination testing to identify the combination of a carbapenem
and colistin as an effective treatment regimen☆,☆☆,★
Ryan K. Shieldsa,1 , Eun J. Kwaka,1 , Brian A. Potoskia , Yohei Doia , Jennifer M. Adams-Haducha ,
Fernanda P. Silvieraa , Yoshiya Toyodaa , Joseph M. Pilewskia , Maria Crespoa ,
A. William Pascullea , Cornelius J. Clancya,b,⁎, M. Hong Nguyena
a
University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
b
V.A. Pittsburgh Healthcare System, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
Received 18 June 2010; accepted 27 December 2010
Abstract
Extensively drug-resistant (XDR) Acinetobacter baumannii infections caused 91% (10/11) mortality in transplant recipients. Isolates were
colistin-susceptible initially, but susceptibility decreased during therapy in 40% (4/10). We tested antibiotic combinations against XDR
Acinetobacter in vitro and demonstrated positive interactions for carbapenem–colistin. Subsequently, 80% (4/5) of transplant patients
were treated successfully with carbepenem–colistin regimens.
Published by Elsevier Inc.
and/or tigecycline. Despite reports of successful therapy to published guidelines (National Committee for Clinical
using these regimens (Schafer et al., 2007), our experience Laboratory Standards, 1999). Concentrations in TKA were
was dismal. In response, our Antibiotic Management and selected based on the combination MICs identified by CBM.
Transplant Infectious Diseases (AMP and TID) programs Colony counts for all isolates were determined at 0, 2, 4, 8,
partnered to devise an institution-specific treatment regimen 12, and 24 h. The results were presented as the mean of all
for XDR A. baumannii infections. We used a variety of experiments for each isolate.
methods to test our XDR A. baumannii isolates for in vitro
susceptibility to multiple antimicrobial combinations. On the 2.6. Patient population and definitions
basis of these results, we recommended that the combination All SOT patients with infection due to XDR A. baumannii
of a carbapenem and colistin be adopted as standard therapy at the UPMC between November 2006 and August 2009
for XDR A. baumannii infections among our SOT patients. were included in the analysis. This study was approved by
In this paper, we review our clinical experience before the institutional review board at the University of Pittsburgh.
devising the carbapenem–colistin regimen, describe the All patients were evaluated and managed by our TID service
results of in vitro testing, and report on our early experience as part of routine patient care. The classifications of
using the carbapenem–colistin regimen to treat SOT colonization versus disease due to XDR A. baumannii and
recipients with XDR A. baumannii infections. the outcome were made by the treating TID physicians and
independently confirmed by at least 2 investigators. The
2. Methods primary outcome in this analysis was clinical success at
28 days (from the time of first positive cultures), and the
2.1. Bacterial strains secondary outcome was death from any cause at 90 days.
XDR A. baumannii isolates were obtained from the
clinical microbiology laboratory at the University of 3. Results
Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC). Isolates were stored at
−80 °C and subcultured a minimum of 3 times before Between November 2006 and December 2009, we
experimentation. MICs were repeated for all agents by E-test encountered 11 SOT recipients with diseases caused by
(AB bioMérieux, Solna, Sweden). XDR A. baumannii (Table 1). All isolates tested exhibited
colistin MICs ≤ 2 μg/mL, while the 7 isolates tested for
2.2. Synergy testing
susceptibility to tigecycline exhibited MICs ≥2 μg/mL.
All the experiments below were performed at least in Patient outcomes were dismal despite treatment with regi-
duplicate. Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 27853 and mens previously published to be effective (Motaouakkil
Escherichia coli ATCC 25922 were used as controls for et al., 2006; Schafer et al., 2007) (Table 1): the rates of
each set of experiments. clinical success and survival at 28 and 90 days, respec-
tively, were 9% (1/11). In addition, serial isolates recovered
2.3. E-test from 40% (4/10) of patients treated with colistin demon-
strated increasing MICs. Three of these patients had
Three hundred microliters of a suspension equivalent to
persistent disease, while the fourth had recurrent infection
the 0.5 McFarland turbidity standard was streaked onto
with XDR A. baumannii. In the 3 patients with persistent
150-mm Mueller–Hinton II plates. After drying for 30 min
disease (patients 4, 8, and 10; Table 1), colistin MICs
at 35 °C, an E-test for drug A was placed onto the agar for
increased from 0.5 to N256 μg/mL within 55 days, ≤0.125
1 h at 35 °C and then removed. Next, an E-test for drug B
to N64 μg/mL within 19 days, and 0.5 to 2 μg/mL within
was placed over the demarcation left from drug A. The
6 days, respectively.
resulting combination MIC was read between 18–24 h of
Given this experience, our AMP and TID services
incubation at 35 °C (Haddad et al., 2005).
partnered to devise an institution-specific treatment strategy.
2.4. Checkerboard microdilution We first tested 17 XDR A. baumannii isolates from unique
patients and confirmed that they acquired the OXA-23 gene
Checkerboard microdilution (CBM) synergy testing was (Adams-Haduch et al., 2008). We determined in vitro
performed on XDR A. baumannii isolates (Pillai, Moelle- susceptibility to various antibiotics, alone and in combina-
ring Jr, and Eliopoulos, 2005). The fractional inhibitory tion, using an E-test methodology (Table 2). Positive
concentration index (∑FIC) was used to interpret the interactions (defined as synergy or additivism) were
results of CBM synergy after 24 h of incubation at 35 °C observed most commonly for the combination of colistin
(Pillai et al., 2005). or ampicillin/sulbactam with a carbapenem. The combina-
2.5. Time-kill assay tion of colistin with doripenem was considered to be most
attractive because colistin was active as a single agent and
Time-kill assay (TKA) experiments were performed doripenem is our formulary preferred carbapenem. We
using a starting concentration of 1 × 106 CFU/mL according confirmed the positive interactions between these agents by
248
Table 1
Demographics and case summaries of 11 SOT recipients (preintervention) and 5 SOT recipients (postintervention) with diseases caused by XDR A. baumannii
Patient Age/sex (diseasea) Transplant type APACHE II Disease (onset MIC (μg/mL) Additional agent(s) Clinical responsec Mortality (follow-up)
R.K. Shields et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 70 (2011) 246–252
after transplant) (durationb)
Treatment regimen: colistin and ampicillin/sulbactam
1 36/woman (NASH) Liver 20 VAP (19 days) COL: 2 None (15 days) Successd Alive (11 months)
TGC: NP
2 80/man (ischemic cardiomyopathy) Heart 25 VAP (before transplant) COL: 0.25 None (3 days)e Failure Death
TGC: NP
3 63/man (ulcerative colitis) Liver 16 VAP and Bacteremia (55 days) COL: NP None (9 days)e Failure Death
TGC: NP
Treatment regimen: colistin and tigecycline
4 55/woman (Sjogren syndrome) Double Lung 20 VAP (85 days) COL(1): 0.5 INH colistin (38 days) Failure Death
COL(2)f: N256
TGC: 3
5 47/woman (pulmonary fibrosis) Single Lung 28 VAP and Mediastinitis (5 days) COL: ≤ 0.125 INH colistin (17 days) Failure Death
TGC: 6
6 43/man (obliterative bronchiolitis) Double Lung First episode VAP (24 days) COL: ≤ 0.125 INH colistin rifampin (52 days) Recurrence Death
8 TGC: 2
Second episode VAP (47 days) COL: 32 INH colistin Failure
14 TGC: 2 Amp-sulbactam
rifampin
(41 days)e
7 58/man (ischemic cardiomyopathy) Heart 17 VAP (29 days) COL: 2 INH colistin Failure Death
TGC: 6 rifampin (8 days)e
8 63/man (ischemic cardiomyopathy) Heart 28 Mediastinitis, VAP and COL(1): ≤ 0.125 Amikacin (17 days)e Failure Death
Empyema (11 days) COL(2)g: 64
TGC: 3
Treatment regimen: colistin and rifampin
9 68/woman (IPF) Double Lung 17 VAP (12 days) COL: 0.25 None (6 days)e Failure Death
TGC: NP
10 65/man (polycystic renal disease) Kidney 24 VAP and Bacteremia (18 years) COL(1): 0.5 None (30 days) Failure Death
COL (2)h: 2
TGC: 6
Treatment regimen: tigecycline and cefepime
11 58/man (cryptogenic cirrhosis) Liver 27 VAP and Bacteremia (81 days) COL: 0.25 None (6 days)e Failure Death
TGC: 3
Treatment regimen: carbapenem and colistin (postintervention)
1 67/woman (COPD) Double Lung 19 VAP and Empyema (23 days) COL: ≤ 0.125 Doripenem 500mg TID Failure Death
TGC: NP INH colistin (24 days)e
2 53/man (interstitial nephritis) Kidney 18 VAP (2.5 years) COL: NP Doripenem 250 mg BIDi Success Alive (5 months)
TGC: NP ampicillin–sulbactam (30 days)
R.K. Shields et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 70 (2011) 246–252 249
COL = colistin; TGC = tigecycline; NP = not performed; NASH = nonalcoholic steatohepatitis; IPF = idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis; INH = inhaled; COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder; VAP =
microtiter checkerboard method (data not shown). We then
Alive (7 months)
Alive (4 months)
further characterized 5 isolates using TKAs. For all 5,
Alive (1 year)
Clinical response was assessed at 28 days from the time of first positive culture by the treating Transplant Infectious Diseases physician and confirmed by at least 2 investigators.
bacteriostatic against all isolates, inhibiting growth of the
inocula, but not causing significant kills. Combinations of
doripenem at concentrations achievable in serum and colistin
Success
Success
Success
TGC: NP
COL: 0.5
COL: 2
TGC: 2
4. Discussion
VAP (3.5 years)
15
25
Single Lung
Single Lung
populations.
Treatment continued until death.
66/woman (IPF)
g
h
a
e
f
i
j
5
250 R.K. Shields et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 70 (2011) 246–252
Table 2
In vitro synergy testing against XDR A. baumannii by E-test methodology
Backbone agent Agents tested in combination Synergy no. (%) Additivism no. (%) Indifference no. (%) Antagonism no. (%)
Ampicillin/sulbactam Colistin 0 (0) 2 (12) 13 (76) 2 (12)
Doripenem 0 (0) 7 (41) 10 (59) 0 (0)
Imipenem 0 (0) 8 (47) 9 (53) 0 (0)
Rifampin 1 (6) 5 (29) 11 (65) 0 (0)
Tigecycline 1 (6) 1 (6) 15 (88) 0 (0)
Colistin Doripenem 0 (0) 5 (29) 12 (71) 0 (0)
Imipenem 0 (0) 6 (35) 11 (65) 0 (0)
Rifampin 0 (0) 1 (6) 15 (88) 1 (6)
Tigecycline 0 (0) 1 (6) 15 (88) 1 (6)
Rifampin Doripenem 2 (12) 2 (12) 13 (76) 0 (0)
Imipenem 2 (12) 1 (6) 14 (82) 0 (0)
Tigecycline 0 (0) 4 (24) 13 (76) 0 (0)
Interaction between 2 drugs were determined according to:
P
= FIC = MIC MIC
of drug A in combination
of drug A alone + MIC MIC
of drug B in combination
of drug B alone .
Synergy is defined as ΣFIC ≤0.5; additivism, ΣFIC N0.5–1.0; indifference, ΣFIC N1.0–4.0; antagonism, ΣFIC N 4.0.
2008), whereas OXA-40 carbapenemase, reduced expres- 2001) and in vivo data (Motaouakkil et al., 2006; Song et al.,
sion of outer membrane proteins, and the overexpression of 2008). In our experience, however, colistin and rifampin
efflux pumps were the mechanisms of resistance during were antagonistic or indifferent for 6% (1/17) and 88%
several other A. baumannii outbreaks in the United States (15/17) of isolates, respectively. Moreover, both patients
(Lee et al., 2010; Lolans et al., 2006; Perez et al., 2007). who were treated with this combination died during their
Although we demonstrated that the isolates in this study hospitalizations. Our results should encourage other institu-
contained OXA-23, we cannot exclude that other mecha- tions to conduct independent investigations to identify the
nisms contributing to resistance also may have been present. predominant strain(s) of A. baumannii locally, their
Discrepancies in resistance mechanisms between isolates mechanisms of resistance, and the optimal antimicrobial
from different centers may explain, at least in part, why combinations against XDR isolates.
combination regimens reported as successful in the literature This study is also notable for the insights it affords
were not successful among our patients. Perhaps the most into colistin resistance. Before the introduction of the
popularly cited combination for treatment of XDR carbapenem–colistin combination, colistin resistance deve-
A. baumannii is colistin and rifampin, which has been loped in 4 SOT recipients treated with colistin-containing
supported by both in vitro (Giamarellos-Bourboulis et al., regimens. Colistin is used increasingly for the treatment of
A. baumannii and other resistant Gram-negative infections,
both alone and in antimicrobial combinations. Increased
use of colistin, however, has raised concerns about the
emergence of resistance (Hawley et al., 2008), and our
clinical experience suggests that such concerns are
justified. This phenomenon underscores the importance of
preserving colistin susceptibility by using optimal antimi-
crobial combinations. Effective combination therapy with
colistin, therefore, may serve the dual purpose of decreasing
MICs to levels conducive to more favorable therapeutic
responses and playing a role in preventing the emergence
of resistance.
The extremely high rate of tigecycline nonsusceptibility
among XDR A. baumannii isolates from our institution
exceeds that of previous reports. In the absence of molecular
typing, we cannot exclude that at least some of our isolates
were clonal (Adams-Haduch et al., 2008). Nevertheless, our
experience differs from certain geographic regions, in which
tigecycline susceptibility rates among MDR and XDR
A. baumannii isolates remain high (Gales et al., 2006). At
present, the clinical efficacy of this agent against MDR and
XDR A. baumannii is undefined, the emergence of
Fig. 1. Representative TKA against an XDR A. baumannii isolate. tigecycline resistance has been reported (Savini et al.,
R.K. Shields et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 70 (2011) 246–252 251
Combination
Therapy
Pre-intervention Post-intervention
(n = 11) (n = 5)
Clinical success
(0%)
Survival (0%)
Fig. 2. Clinical outcomes and mortality for 16 SOT patients with diseases caused by XDR A. baumannii.
cilastatin for the treatment of hospital-acquired pneumonia. Diagn bacter baumannii using Etest and time-kill assay. Diagn Microbiol
Microbiol Infect Dis 68:140–151. Infect Dis 63:228–232.
Gales AC, Jones RN, Sader HS (2006) Global assessment of the Paterson DL, Rogers BA (2010) How soon is now? The urgent need for
antimicrobial activity of polymyxin B against 54,731 clinical isolates randomized, controlled trials evaluating treatment of multidrug-resistant
of Gram-negative bacilli: a report from SENTRY antimicrobial bacterial infection. Clin Infect Dis 51:1245–1247.
surveillance programme (2001–2004). Clin Microbiol Infect 12: Peleg AY, Potoski BA, Rea R, Adams J, Sethi J, Capitano B, Husain S,
315–321. Kwak EJ, Bhat SV, Paterson DL (2007) Acinetobacter baumannii
Giamarellos-Bourboulis EJ, Xirouchaki E, Giamarellou H (2001) Interac- bloodstream infection while receiving tigecycline: a cautionary report.
tions of colistin and rifampin on multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter J Antimicrob Chemother 59:128–131.
baumannii. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis 40:117–120. Perez F, Hujer AM, Hujer KM, Decker BK, Rather PN, Bonomo RA (2007)
Haddad FA, VanHorn K, Carbonaro C, Aguero-Rosenfeld M, Wormser GP Global challenge of multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii.
(2005) Evaluation of antibiotic combinations against multidrug-resistant Antimicrob Agents Chemother 51:3471–3484.
Acinetobacter baumannii using the E-test. Eur J Clin Microbiol Infect Pillai SK, Moellering RC, Eliopoulos GM (2005) In: Antimicrobial
Dis 24:577–579. combinations. Antibiotics in laboratory medicine. Lorian V, Ed. 5th ed.
Hawley JS, Murray CK, Jorgensen JH (2008) Colisting heteroresistance in Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Acinetobacter and its association with previous colistin therapy. Savini V, Catavitello C, Pompetti F, Talia M, Costanzi L, Balbinot A, Febbo
Antimicrob Agents Chemother 52:351–352. F, Di Zacomo S, Esattore F, D'Antonio D (2008) Isolation of uncommon
Korbila IP, Michalopoulos A, Rafailidis PI, Nikita D, Samonis G, Falagas respiratory and enteric Acinetobacter baumannii from hematologic
ME (2009) Inhaled colistin as adjunctive to intravenous colistin for the patients and emergence of tigecycline-resistance. J Infect 57:497–500.
treatment of microbiologically documented VAP: a comparative cohort Schafer JJ, Goff DA, Stevenson KB, Mangino JE (2007) Early
study. Clin Microbiol Infect [Epub ahead of print]. experience with tigecycline for ventilator-associated pneumonia and
Landman D, Butnariu M, Bratu S, Quale J (2009) Genetic relatedness of bacteremia caused by multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii.
multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii endemic in New York Pharmacotherapy 27:980–987.
City. Epidemiol Infect 137:174–180. Song JY, Lee J, Heo JY, Noh JY, Kim WJ, Cheong HJ (2008) Colistin and
Lee Y, Yum JH, Kim CK, Yong D, Jeon EH, Jeong SH, Ahn JY, Lee K rifampicin combination in the treatment of ventilator-associated
(2010) Role of OXA-23 and AdeABC efflux pump for acquiring pneumonia caused by carbapenem-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii.
carbapenem resistance in an Acinetobacter baumannii strain carrying the Int J Antimicrob Agents 32:278–286.
blaOXA-66 gene. Ann Clin Lab Sci 40:43–48. Sopirala MM, Mangino JE, Gebreyes WA, Biller B, Bannerman T,
Lolans K, Rice TW, Munoz-Price LS, Quinn JP (2006) Multicity outbreak Balada-Llasat JM, Pancholi P (2010) Synergy testing by Etest,
of carbapenem-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii isolates producing the microdilution checkerboard, and time-kill methods for pan-drug–
carbapenemase OXA-40. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 50:2941–2945. resistant Acinetobacter baumannii. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 54:
Mak JK, Kim M, Pham J, Tapsall J, White PA (2009) Antibiotic resistance 4678–4683.
determinants in nosocomial strains of multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter Souli M, Galani I, Giamarellou H (2008) Emergence of extensively drug-
baumannii. J Antimicrob Chemother 63:47–54. resistant and pandrug-resistant Gram-negative bacilli in Europe. Euro
Motaouakkil S, Charra B, Hachimi A, Nejmi H, Benslama A, Elmdaghri N, Surveill 13.
Belabbes H, Benbachir M (2006) Colistin and rifampicin in the Urban C, Mariano N, Rahal JJ (2010) In vitro double and triple bactericidal
treatment of nosocomial infections from multiresistant Acinetobacter activities of doripenem, polymyxin B, and rifampin against multidrug-
baumannii. J Infection 53:274–278. resistant Acinetobacter baumannii, Pseudomonas aeruginosa,
Pankey GA, Ashcraft DS (2009) The detection of synergy between Klebsiella pneumoniae, and Escherichia coli. Antimicrob Agents
meropenem and polymyxin B against meropenem-resistant Acineto- Chemother 54:2732–2734.