Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER
EMULSIONS 2017
Prepared by: Biocide Information Limited
Email: info@biocide-information.com
More about us on www.biocide-information.com
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS – GLOBAL SUMMARY ........................................3
7. BIOCIDE REGULATIONS.........................................................................................................31
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
2
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Biocides to increase:
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
3
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
2.1. Objectives
2. To identify and analyse the trends taking place within the biocides
industry.
2.2. Methodology
2.4. Definitions
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
4
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Distributors act as agents for both active manufacturers and biocide blenders.
They are the most popular choice of supplier for small end-users. Distributors
sell a range of industrial additives and so will be making deliveries to end
users and therefore biocides tend to be combined with other products which
allow the distributor to be competitive.
Prices are in U.S. dollars and are at active manufacturer level unless stated.
The exchange used is as follows:
Source: www.xe.com
Volumes are reported in tonnes based on a 100 % active biocide basis. In the
case of formulated products, the data is reported with a typical percentage of
the formulated product.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
5
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Polymer Emulsions are aqueous fluids, which present a medium for the
multiplication of micro-organisms (bacteria, fungi, yeast). As the emulsions
are used for the production of high quality products, including those coming in
contact with food, they have to be in clean condition when used, that means
in-tank protection to prevent microbes from proliferating is necessary.
Nearly all Polymer Emulsions are treated with biocides before or during
storage. The ambient pH of the emulsion is the major determinant in biocide
selection. Emulsions with pH ranges of 4 to 9 are most prone to microbial
growth and require biocide treatment, while higher Polymer Emulsions are
more resistant to contamination.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
6
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Freedonia says the global demand for emulsion polymers is forecast to rise
4.7 percent per year to 13 million metric tons (dry basis) in 2018. They say
advances will be fuelled by increased production of water-based paint,
coatings, and adhesives, which are displacing solvent borne formulations in
virtually all parts of the world. In developing regions such as China and India,
emulsion polymer demand will arise from strong economic growth and
increased penetration of waterborne technology in the coatings and
adhesives industries.
Acrylics will remain the largest and fastest growing emulsion polymer product
type through 2018, accounting for nearly 40 percent of the world market.
Demand for acrylics will benefit from rapid growth in the paint and coatings
market, where acrylic polymers are valued for their durability and wide range
of applications. Vinyl acetate emulsions will also see healthy increases in
demand, with the most favorable opportunities expected for vinyl acetate-
ethylene (VAE) copolymers in adhesives and coatings applications. The
slowest growth among major types will be for styrene butadiene latex,
restrained by sluggish advances in the paper coatings market.
Freedonia says the Asia/Pacific region has overtaken North America and
Western Europe to become the leading market for emulsion polymers with 43
%. The Asia Pacific region is followed by Western Europe at 23% and North
America at 22 %. Other world regions account for 12 % and will see healthy
gains in demand through 2016, the best opportunities are in Africa and the
Middle East.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
7
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Region % of Tonnes
America 35 %
Europe 27 %
Asia 38 %
TOTAL 18 Million Tonnes
Demand for Polymer Emulsions is highest in Asia pacific. The demand for
emulsion polymer in Asia-Pacific is driven by countries such as China, Japan,
South Korea, India, Taiwan, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, and Philippines.
Asia-Pacific has witnessed significant EP manufacturing capacity expansions
in the last five years.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
8
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
9
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Paint is the leading enduse for Polymer Emulsions. In the paints and coatings
sector, there is additional emphasis coming from the good environmental
profile that Polymer Emulsions have where VOCs are concerned. The
demand for Polymer Emulsion by application is as follows (figures are in
thousand tonnes):
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
10
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
11
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
The following table compares prices observed in the field for the Polymer
Emulsions industry by each of the main geographical Regions:
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
12
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
The following table compares the most commonly used formulated biocides in
Polymer Emulsions:
Table 11: Comparison of Biocides used in Polymer Emulsions
COMPARISON OF BIOCIDES USED FOR LATEX PRESERVATION
Chemistry TRADE NAME SUPPLIER % AI in Formulated
formulatio Price $/kg
n
1,2-Benzoisothiazolin- Proxel GXL Lonza 20 % 4
3-one
5-chloro-2-methyl-4- Kathon LX DOW 1.5 % 2
isothiazolin-3-1-2-
methylisthiazolin-3-1
Benzoisothiazolinone Acticide MBS Thor 5% 3
and methylisthiazolin
Benzyl alcohol Preventol D2 Lanxess 96 % 2
hemiformal
Bromo-1- Tektamer AD Lanxess 25 % 6
(bromomethyl)- 1,3-
propanedicarbonitrile
Glutaraldehyde Protectol GDA BASF 50 % 3.5
2,2 Dibromo-3-nitrilo Biobrom DOW 20 % 4
propionamide (DBNPA) (DOW)
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
13
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
14
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
The average selling price of one tonne of latex is $ 3,000 and the following is
a typical cost breakdown for latex production per tonne:
Table 13: Costs to produce one tonne of Latex
TYPICAL COSTINGS FOR A LATEX MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURING COSTS %
Raw Materials 42.5
Containers 8.0
Direct labour 5.4
Production costs 8.0
Laboratory costs 3.3
Warehousing 3.5
Total 70.7
MARKETING COSTS
Sales expenses 4.8
Distribution costs 3.6
Promotional costs 4.2
Administration 8.3
Other expenses 1.8
Total 22.7
Net profit (before tax) 6.6
TOTAL 100
Biocides are included in raw material costs which amount to 42.5 % of the
selling price for latex or $ 1,275 per tonne of latex. As shown in the following
table, the addition of a biocide has an insignificant effect on the raw material
costs of the latex:
Table 14: Biocides as a percentage of latex raw materials costs
BIOCIDES AS A PERCENTAGE OF LATEX RAW MATERIALS COSTS
Preservative Biocide sales Dosage rate % Cost per tonne Biocides as a
price $ / kg of latex ($) % of latex
selling price
Formaldehyde 2 0.10-0.2 2-3 0.1
(100 % ai)
CMIT/MIT (1.5 2 0.10-0.2 2-3 0.1
% ai)
BIT (20 % ai) 4 0.10-0.2 4-6 0.2-0.5
BIT & MIT 3 0.10-0.2 3-4.5 0.2-0.5
The costs of preserving latex at the above dosage rates range from $ 2 per
tonne up to a maximum of $ 6 per tonne of latex treated. The higher costs are
for BIT and MIT type biocides, which are the only biocides that are suitable for
high pH Latices such as styrene butadiene.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
15
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
16
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
4. BIOCIDE CONSUMPTION
4.1. GLOBAL AND REGIONAL ANALYSIS
The major disadvantages to BIT are: (1) Deactivated by strong oxidising and
reducing agents (2) Skin sensitiser (3) Not cost effective in acidic systems (4)
Slow acting. The leading manufacturer of BIT is Lonza with 70 % of the
market. Other producers include Dow, Prom and Chinese generic suppliers.
Benzisothiazolinone (BIT) and 2-methyl-4-isothiazolinone (MIT) has sales
of $ 17 million within Polymer Emulsions especially. The Biocide was
developed and patented by Thor (tradename is Acticide MBS). BIT / MIT has
the synergistic benefits from both compounds with the added benefit of no
chlorine. The product can be used alone or in combination with FR’s. In the
future, products preserved with MIT will have to be Labelled with hazard
statement H 317 and exclamation mark pictogram which will apply by the start
of 2019. Currently the views of latex producers is that they will have to move
to alternative biocides to avoid the H 317 labelling on their products.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
17
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
18
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
FR’s have achieved their high penetration as preservatives due to (1) Their
broad spectrum of activity (2) Low cost (3) Rapid speed of action. Despite
being cheap and effective, FR’s have a number of disadvantages such as: (1)
Unstable at low pH’s (2) Unstable at high temperature and volatile (3) Strong
odour – inhalation hazard (4) skin and eye irritant (5) Carcinogen (6) Poor
long term activity (7) High concentration of ai required (8) Contributor to
VOC’s. FR’s are manufactured by a large number of companies.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
19
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
20
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
The global market for speciality biocides in Polymer Emulsions at the end
user level was estimated at $ 126 million or 54% more than the value of the
sales at the active level.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
21
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
The following value chain illustrates the value added for Biocides used within
Polymer Emulsions:
Active Manufacturer
Technical Material Value added 30 %
With regulatory approval
Distributor
Value Added 10 %
Each stage of the distribution chain adds value to Biocide used in Polymer
Emulsions. As can be seen in the above chart, the combined value added
can be up to 70 % which is shared between Biocide manufacturers, Biocide
formulators and distributors.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
22
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Active Manufacturer
Formulator Direct
30 % 60 %
Distributor
10 % Direct
Latex Producer
The distribution route in % reflects the sales of Biocides to the final producer
of Polymer Emulsions.
Biocide manufacturers are the most important route in the distribution chain
with an estimated 60 % of all formulated Biocides to endusers going via this
route. Dow, Lanxess, Lonza, Thor and Troy are leading biocide
manufacturers who has been most proactive in moving up the value chain
and supplying direct.
Formulators are the second most important route in the distribution chain with
an estimated 30 % of all Biocide sales to Polymer Emulsion manufacturers
going via this route.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
23
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
24
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
5. BIOCIDE CONSUMPTION
5.1. BIOCIDE MANUFACTURERS
Lonza & Thor are the leading manufacturers of Biocides used in Polymer
Emulsions with sales of $ 12 million. The sale of Biocides at active ingredient
manufacture (a.i.) level for the leading manufacturers are illustrated in the
table below:
Table 16: Biocide Sales by Manufacturer in $ Million
BIOCIDE MANUFACTURERS SALES ($M)
BASF 1.0
Chemicrea 1.0
Clariant 1.5
Dalian Biochem 3.0
Dow 12.0
Lanxess 5.0
Lonza 15.0
Ruihao 1.0
Sinanen 0.5
Thor 15.0
Troy 8.0
Other 18.0
TOTAL 81.0
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
25
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Clariant had sales of $ 1.5 million to the global Polymer Emulsion industry.
The company manufactures BIT, formaldehyde releasers and silver for the
preservation of Polymer Emulsions.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
26
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Lanxess acquired Verichem in 2011 and this resulted in them getting the
biocide DBDCB (1,2-dibromo-2,4-dicyanobutane in water), which is sold
under the tradename of VeriGuard®. DBDCB AD is a preservative which
effectively inhibits the growth of microorganisms in aqueous systems,
including paints, emulsions, adhesives, joint cements, pigment dispersions,
metal-working fluids, waxes, polishes and inks, and fiber processing fluids
and coatings (including heating and air conditioning systems). Chemically,
VeriGuard® DBDCB AD is a 25.0% dispersion of 1,2-dibromo-2,4-
dicyanobutane in water.
PROM Chem has sales of $ 1 million to the Polymer Emulsions industry. The
company manufactures BIT under the trade name of PROMEX™. Recently
the company has introduced formulations based on BIT and also offers Prom
Chem's technical backup and service - including the new PROM™ ID Micro
microbiological test kit. The company has European Biocidal Products
Directive (BPD) and EPA registration.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
27
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
Troy has Biocide sales of $ 8 million. The company increased sales via the
acquisition of Ashland Industrial Biocides. Troy is a leading manufacturer of
formaldehyde releasers. Troy supplies direct to end-users with a range of
formulations based on BIT, CMIT/MIT and formaldehyde releasers.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
28
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
6. BIOCIDE TRENDS
1. The prevailing attitude among users of Biocides is the desire for more cost
effective Biocides. In addition, they require an active ingredient with the
following features:
1. The decline in Styrene Butadiene Latex (SBL) usage has stopped and
small growth is predicted as a result of its substitution for natural binders
in recycled paper. Also the renewed growth of SBL is likely to be spurred
by the increased demand for carpets where it is the principal latex used.
2. There is a drive for low VOC formulations especially from the carpet and
paint industries and this is beginning to influence the selection criteria for
biocides. There will be an increase in the use of solvent free biocides.
4. Within the last few years, the main active ingredients to the latex market
have had their patents expire. This has led to an increase in generic
product manufacturers, which in turn is leading to increased competition
e.g. price competition, customer service competition.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
29
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
30
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
7. BIOCIDE REGULATIONS
For the rest of world, countries have their own regulations governing the use
of Biocides or rely on the Biocides to have EPA or BPR approval.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
31
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
32
BIOCIDES IN POLYMER EMULSIONS - 2017
The growth rate for Biocides will depend on the following factors: (1) Market
Growth (2) Efficacy (3) Price (4) Economic Circumstances (5) Regulatory
Status (6) Adoption by major Suppliers (7) External Approvals.
As China is a major growth area, it will see growth for all biocides whereas the
America and Europe will experience a static market. The following are the
growth rates predicted for the main biocides used in Polymer Emulsions.
Thiabendazole 1%
Zinc Pyrithione 1%
BIT/MIT which was developed by Thor, has the highest forecasted growth
rate. The biocides which support lower VOC formulations will be the major
beneficiaries. Formaldehyde releasers will continue to grow only because of
their widespread usage in Asia and are a cheaper alternative in recessionary
times.
CHAPTER 14 www.biocide-information.com
33