Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REPORT
BIOCIDES IN
MINERAL SLURRIES
2017
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
1
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
2
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
3
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
OUTLOOK FOR THE FUTURE: The market for biocides in Mineral Slurries is
expected to increase 1 %.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
4
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
2.1. Objectives
2. To identify and analyse the trends taking place within the Biocides
industry.
2.2. Methodology
2.4. Definitions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
5
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
Distributors act as agents for both active manufacturers and biocide blenders.
They are the most popular choice of supplier for small end-users. Distributors
sell a range of industrial additives and so will be making deliveries to end
users and therefore biocides tend to be combined with other products which
allow the distributor to be competitive.
Prices are in U.S. dollars and are at active manufacturer level unless stated.
The exchange used is as follows:
Source: www.xe.com
Volumes are reported in tonnes based on a 100 % active biocide basis. In the
case of formulated products, the data is reported with a typical percentage of
the formulated product.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
6
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
There are 3 major types of mineral slurries sold for industrial applications:
kaolin, titanium dioxide and calcium carbonate (divided into ground (1/3) and
precipated calcium carbonate (2/3)). The following is a global summary of
each type:
Kaolin The global kaolin production is 15 million tonnes of which the USA
produces 9 million tonnes; UK produces 2 million tonnes and Brazil at 2
million tonnes. The average price for kaolin is $ 1,700 per tonne. Imerys is the
largest supplier with 40 % of the global market and the company owns English
China Clays, Dry Branch Kaolin, Georgia Marble, Rio Capim Caulim (Brazil).
BASF (Engelhard) of USA is the second largest global supplier of kaolin with
20% of the global market and has production in USA, China and Thailand.
The third leading player is Huber at 18 % followed by Thiele at 8 % and
Kadam at 7 %. Amberger of Germany and Utah Clay Technology of the USA
are large regional kaolin suppliers.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
7
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
8
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
4. BIOCIDE COMPARISON
4.1. APPLICATION RATE AND COST
Some of the factors that affect biocides used and application rates are length
of storage time for the slurry, climate, geographical location and end use of
the slurry. Generally, most biocides are effective at use levels of between 20
and 400 ppm as shown in the following table:
Table 7: Comparison of Biocides used in Mineral Slurries
COMPARISON OF POPULAR BIOCIDES USED IN MINERAL SLURRIES
CHEMISTRY TRADE SUPPLIER % Formulated USE
NAME ACTIVE Price $/Kg LEVEL
(ppm)
1,2- Proxel GXL Lonza 20 % 4
Benzoisothiazolin-3-
one
5-chloro-2-methyl-4- Kathon LX DOW 1.5 % 1.6 20-40
isothi-azolin-3-one-
2-methyl-4-iso-
thiazolin-3-one
Tetrahydro-3,5- Busan Buckman 20 % 2 200
dimethyl2H-1,3,5- 1058
thiadiazine-2-thione
(DMTT)Dazomet
Protectol BASF 99 % 4 40
TOE
Bromo-1- Tektamer Lanxess 25 % 4 200-400
(bromomethyl)- 1,3- AD
propanedicarbonitrile
Glutaraldehyde Protectol BASF 50 % 3.50 200-400
GDA
2,2 Dibromo-3- Biobrom Dow 4 (20) 15
nitriloprop-ionamide (Dead Sea
(DBNPA) Bromine)
(Dow)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
9
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
The following table compares prices observed in the field for Mineral Slurries
by each of the main geographical Regions:
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
10
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
5. BIOCIDE CONSUMPTION
5.1. GLOBAL ANALYSIS
The global market for Biocides used in Mineral Slurries is $ 53 Million. The
leading biocide consumed in Mineral Slurries is Benzisothiazolinone (BIT) with
sales of $ 10 million. BIT is followed by CMIT/MIT, Formaldehyde Releasers,
Glutaraldehyde, BIT/MIT and OPP. The following table summarises Biocide
sales in $ million:
The major disadvantages to BIT are: (1) Deactivated by strong oxidising and
reducing agents (2) Skin sensitiser (3) Not cost effective in acidic systems (4)
Slow acting. The leading manufacturer of BIT is Lonza with 70 % of the
market. Generic producers include Prom.
15ppm CIT/MIT will require label Xi and Risk phrase R43 ("May cause
sensitisation by skin contact"). As a result, consumption of CMIT/MIT has
reduced and biocides to gain include BIT, FR’s and MIT.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
12
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
Formaldehyde releasers (FR’s) are the third most important group of biocides
consumed with sales of $ 6.8 million within Mineral Slurries. FR’s are used as
preservatives and include the formals, triazines, oxazolidines and 1-(3-
Chloroally)-3,5,7-triaza-1-azoniaadamantane chloride which is commonly
supplied as Dowicil. The formals can be divided into o-formals and n-formals.
The o-formal type account for 70% of consumption (include o-acetates and o-
formals) while the n-formals (addition of formaldehyde and amines or amides)
accounted for 30%. The n-formals are growing and substituting for o-formals
due to less odour, increased stability but are more expensive.
FR’s are popular due to (1) Their broad spectrum of activity (2) Low cost (3)
Rapid speed of action. Despite being cheap and effective, FR’s have a
number of disadvantages such as: (1) Unstable at low pH’s (2) Unstable at
high temperature and volatile (3) Strong odour – inhalation hazard (4) skin
and eye irritant (5) Carcinogen (6) Poor long term activity (7) High
concentration of ai required (8) Contributor to VOC’s. FR’s are manufactured
by a large number of companies.
OPP had sales of $ 1 million to Mineral Slurries. It has become popular within
Mineral Slurries as it provides a broad spectrum of activity and rapid speed of
kill. The major suppliers of OPP are Dow and Lanxess.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
13
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
14
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
The global market for speciality biocides in Mineral Slurries at the end user
level was estimated at $ 88.08 million or 66% more than the value of the
sales at the active level.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
15
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
The following value chain illustrates the value added for Biocides used within
the Mineral Slurries industry:
Active Manufacturer
Technical Material Value added 30 %
With regulatory approval
Distributor
Value Added 10 %
Each stage of the distribution chain adds value to Biocides used in Mineral
Slurries. As can be seen in the above chart, the combined value added can
be up to 80 % which is shared between Biocide manufacturers, Biocide
formulators and distributors.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
16
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
Active Manufacturer
Distributor
20 % Direct
Mineral Slurry
The distribution route in % reflects the sales of Biocides to the final producer
of Mineral Slurries.
Biocide manufacturers are the most important route in the distribution chain
with an estimated 50 % of all formulated Biocides to endusers going via this
route. Dow, Lanxess, Lonza and Thor are leading biocide manufacturers who
has been most proactive in moving up the value chain and supplying direct.
Biocide Service companies are the second most important route in the
distribution chain with an estimated 30 % of all Biocide sales to Mineral Slurry
manufacturers going via this route.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
17
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
18
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
8. BIOCIDE MANUFACTURERS
8.1. GLOBAL ANALYSIS
Dow and Lonza are the leading manufacturer of Biocides used in Mineral
Slurries with sales of $ 6.9 million and $ 8 million respectively. The sale of
Biocides at active ingredient manufacture (a.i.) level for the leading
manufacturers are illustrated in the table below:
Table 14: Biocide Sales by Manufacturer in $ Million
BIOCIDE MANUFACTURERS SALES ($M)
BASF 3.5
Buckman 3.0
Changzhou Ruihao Chem 0.5
Chemicrea 1.0
Dalian Biochem 1.5
Dow 6.9
Kemira Vinings 3
Lanxess 3
Lonza 8.0
Solenis 2.0
Thor 5.5
Troy 4.5
Other 10.1
TOTAL 53.0
0.5 million to the Mineral Slurries industry. The Biocides produced are cmit/mit
and triazines.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
20
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
1.5 million to the Mineral Slurries industry. The Biocides produced are
cmit/mit.
Lanxess had sales of $ 3.5 million to the global Mineral Slurries industry.
Lanxess biocide business is located at Leverkusen, Germany. Lanxess’s
product line centres around its Preventol trade name which covers many
actives for preservation:
TABLE 16: ACTIVES SUPPLIED BY LANXESS
Preservatives
Preventol D2 (Benzyl alcohol mono(poly)hemiformal)
Preventol D4 (N-(2Hydroxypropyl aminomethanol))
Preventol D6 (Ethanediol + formaldehyde + CMIT/MIT)
Preventol D7 (CMIT + MIT)
Preventol O (OPP)
Tektamer 38 Dibromodicyanobutane
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
21
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
Lonza has sales Biocides to the Mineral Slurries industry with sales of $ 8
million. Lonza manufactures BIT, IPBC, n-butyl BIT and Zinc Pyrithione of
which BIT is used in Mineral Slurries. Lonza supplies direct, distributors and
also via service companies.
Thor has sales of Biocides to the Mineral Slurries industry of $ 5.5 million.
Thor manufactures BIT, CMIT/MIT, BIT/MIT and o-formals, which are widely
used as Preservatives in Mineral Slurries. Thor supplies biocides under the
Acticide tradename and the company has sales & technical support in Asia,
America and Europe.
PROM Chem has sales of $ 0.3 million to the Mineral Slurries industry. The
company manufactures BIT under the trade name of PROMEX™.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
22
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
9. BIOCIDE TRENDS
According to Slurry manufacturers, the ideal biocide should be:
1. Decisions on the choice of biocides are cost driven. In the future, stricter
environmental conditions will have an impact on the choice of biocide
used.
3. To help the paper industry reduce raw material costs, research is directed
at producing slurries that will improve hiding power (light scattering). This
will reduce the need for titanium dioxide. A new blended kaolin slurry is
emerging which consists of Titanium oxide blended with both wet and
calcined kaolin slurries.
4. The role of service companies is likely to increase further and even some
end users of the slurries such as paper manufacturers are specifying what
service company should be used. This allows the paper manufacture to
have better control over their raw materials.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
23
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
Regulations have a major impact on the Biocides used in the Mineral Slurries
industry. In most developed countries, all chemical components must be listed
on the relevant national “inventory” of chemical substances before it can be
supplied.
For the rest of world, countries have their own regulations governing the use
of Biocides or rely on the Biocides to have EPA or BPR approval.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
24
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
(4) Mineral slurries are being used as a carrier to deliver antimold effect. This
has happened in Wallboard and may be a future area of growth for Biocides.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
25
BIOCIDES IN MINERAL SLURRIES - 2017
The growth rate for Biocides will depend on the following factors: (1) Market
Growth (2) Efficacy (3) Price (4) Economic Circumstances (5) Regulatory
Status (6) Adoption by major Suppliers (7) External Approvals.
As China is a major growth area, it will see growth for all biocides whereas the
European economy is not growing and so will not see significant growth for
any biocides. The following are the growth rates predicted for the main
biocides used in Mineral Slurries.
BIT/MIT which was developed by Thor, has the highest forecasted growth
rate. The biocides which support lower VOC formulations will be the major
beneficiaries. Formaldehyde releasers will maintain static due to their
widespread usage in Asia otherwise they would decline.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CHAPTER 8 www.biocide-information.com
26