Professional Documents
Culture Documents
07 - Chapter 2
07 - Chapter 2
Introduction:
past to establish a relationship between the variables under study. According to Koul
(2009), “research can never be undertaken in the isolation of the work that has already
been done on the problems related to the study proposed by any research.” An
investigator needs to review literature from sources like relevant research journals,
books etc. to the areas of interest, reviews of previous work done on a particular area,
internet also, where she/he can access online library, e-journal etc. The present
researcher surveyed libraries situated in Guwahati city, and had an access to internet
extensively for searching relevant studies conducted in India and outside of it. But only
a few studies which were directly related to the present study were found available.
Again, the number of studies on mobile phone addiction is scanty. It is obvious, because
the concept is contemporary. The investigator reviewed the literature of last 12 years
etc.
But, for the overall organizational framework for the review, the chronological
method was employed. The details are reported in the following sections.
37
Campbell (2005) studied the impact of the mobile phoneon young people‟s
social life (such as, peer relationships, family relationships and on the institution
of the school). Young people use mobile phones positively to organize and
maintain social networks with others. Certain negative impacts of mobile phone
are also seen on young peoples‟ peer relationships, such as, ostracism and cyber
bullying. Likewise, the usage of mobile phone has led to change the dynamics in
a family. The issues of safety and surveillance from the perspectives of parents
lead to negotiate the changing freedoms for young people. Although the
functional coordination can be beneficial for a family, but some other problems
can arise, which include financial difficulties, non-custodial parent access, and
over reliance on the mobile phone for safety issues and disturb young peoples‟
lives. Disruptions to lessons, incidences of cheating and bullying etc. are the
young Australian adults (4,397 men, 4,703 women; M age=20.2 yr., SD=0.4). In
earlier achievement and family influences reinforced each other to account for
and academic achievement in adolescents. The sample size was 109 and the
chronological age of the subjects ranges from 14 to 16 years. The samples were
Environment Scale, developed by Moos and Moos (1986) and Bell‟s adjustment
school records. The result showed that family environment appeared to have an
environment. Boys and girls differ in perception of the home and environment.
Leung (2007) conducted a study with the objectives (1) to identify addiction
symptoms that are uniquely associated with mobile phone use among
individuals are related to the addiction symptoms; and (3) to explore how these
attributes, mobile phone addiction symptoms, and social capital can predict
39
improper use of the mobile phone. This study was conducted in Hong Kong in
China, among 402 teenagers and young adult whose ages ranged from 14-20.
These were: „losing control and receiving complaints,’ ‘anxiety and craving,’
‘withdrawal/escape,’ and ‘productivity loss.‟ This study found that those who
addiction were also higher. Conversely, participants with higher score on self-
esteem showed less of such tendency. Again, respondents scored low on self-
esteem but high on sensation seeking, showed the most improper use of the
mobile phone.
scholastic achievement. This study was conducted on 120 students of class viii
Inventory Scale and by collecting Records of report cards of students and other
positive correlation was found between the good quality of home environment
and the „high‟ level of scholastic achievement of boys than girls. Finally, the
study highlighted that good quality of home environment had more significant
(600 females and 600 males) in the University of Kelaniya in Sri Lanka. The
subjects were recruited by using Stratified random sampling. The survey used 5
years data related to the period, from 2002/2003 academic year to 2006/2007
academic year. The study showed no significant difference between the students
Management and Commerce degree, female students tend to perform better than
male students. Finally, the study reported that female students have higher
Hendrikz, Prins, Viljoen, and Preez (2009) conducted a study on the use of
African perspective with two research questions. Firstly, will SMS academic
support have a positive impact on the completion rate in the minimum period of
study? And secondly, did the SMS messages improve the academic performance
of the students in the various modules? For the purpose of the study, the Unit for
academic SMS tools, such as instructional, quiz and mini lecture SMS messages.
The study was conducted between two groups, that is, control and experimental
group. The messages were sent to an experimental group, but not to control
41
group. Then the academic performances of both the groups were compared. The
results indicated that the experimental group performed better than the control
group in some of the aspects which were measured. But it was not conclusively
proved that the SMS messages had a specific impact on academic performance.
which they took notes on video content and later completed a multiple-choice
test on the material. The study was conducted between two groups. One group
was in ringing condition where a video which was playing was disrupted
through the ringing of cell phone which other group was in control condition
where no such activities were done. The video was playing without any
disruption. It was hypothesized that the cell phone rings would impair
performance was confirmed. The result revealed that the students of the group
the disrupted test items than the students of the control group. Besides, students
who were in the ringing condition during this research, less likely to include the
disrupted information in their notes. Finally the study concluded that cell phone
and home environment among 235 students of standard eight whose age ranged
between 13 and 17 years, in Kenya. The subjects were recruited randomly from
42
six urban and rural primary schools located in Machakos district. To measure
namely the Simple Profile (SP) and Home Environment Questionnaire were
used. The result of the study revealed that a significant (p < 0.05) positive
relationship exited between six of the home environmental factors and academic
0.15), mothers’ education (r = 0.14), family size(r = 0.26) and learning facilities
related to academic achievement motivation. The study also highlighted that the
explore the extent of addictive behavior towards its usage. The result of the
study indicated that majority respondents were able to draw a line of priorities
between the responsibilities and commitments and the cell phone usage. Very
few always showed extreme addictive behavior while rests of the respondents
were not frequently involved in addictive usage patterns. Youngsters use their
cell phones logically and controllably within a limit and do not tend towards
extreme behaviors which are capable to lead towards addictive cell phone usage.
43
Javid, Malik, and Gujjar (2011) conducted a study on mobile phone culture and
University level). The sample size was 390. The subjects were students of The
subjects were taken by giving representation to all the students of all the
scale was administered with the subjects. Data was analyzed by using SPSS
XIV. This study revealed that students share useful information with their
classmates and teacher, can consult dictionary and thesaurus etc. for academic
purpose through mobile phone. The female students live in remote areas feel
secure and their parents can contact them whenever necessary. But at the same
time, research also revealed that mobile phone is wasting the students‟ precious
time and money.”Moreover it has increased the rate of telling lie among
Shivane(2011)studied the family environment and mental health of the tribal and
urbansecondary students. The sample size of the study was 300 (N=300, Tribal
150, urban-150) and the subjects were children whose age ranged between 11 to
16 years. They were studying in Vii to X standard and selected randomly from
Environment Scale by Dr. Bhatia and Chadha (1993) and Mental Health Battery
by Singh and Gupta (1983) were used in this study. This study finds significant
(100 boys and 100 girls) of the 9th standard of Marathi medium schools of Nasik
City. Family Environment Scale by Dr. Harpreet Bhatia and Dr. N.K. Chadha
(1993) and Second semester (yearly) marks of 9th standard were used to
were analyzed by using Pearson correlation coefficient and found that family
the students.
Duncan, Hoekstra, and Wilcox (2012) studied the effects of technology use on
the attitude and learning of students. The research was conducted at a state
university in the western United States over two semesters in eight introductory
Pradesh. The result of the study showed that male and female subjects were
and academic anxiety. Among the high and low family environment subjects
achievements were almost same despite having the levels of difference on family
environment.
environment scale for student, Family Environmental scale for parents and Socio
The samples were drawn from fourpublic Schools of Kurukshetra district. The
subjects were selected randomly (but the No. of sample was not mentioned
clearly). The study revealed that school performance of students was found to
have significant and positive relationship with their perceptions of overall family
Likewise, the school performance of students was found to have significant and
environment, and its four dimensions. This study also found that achievement
dimensions.
Osun State, Nigeria to examine access to Mobile Phone (GSM) and its effects on
The sample size of the study was 100. The sample was drawn randomly from ten
(10) senior secondary schools in Osun State, Nigeria. The data were collected by
using two instruments, such as, the GSM Access (GA) and Academic
coefficient and t-test statistics. The result revealed correlation between student’s
use of GSM (Mobile phone) and their academic performance. The study equally
secondary schools.
research question that is, what types of behaviour are associated with mobile
researchers found that mobile phone usage is not habit-forming and addictive.
The result also suggests that possibly mobile phone is the biggest non-drug
and Intelligence. Total No. 200 children of 13 to 15 years, among them 100
boys and 100 girls from English medium schools of Secondary State Certificate
(SSC) board were recruited for the study. Two psychological tools called
Family Environment Scale (FES) by (Bhatia and Chadha, 1993) and the
Standard Progressive Matrices (SPM) by (Raven, 1938) were used in the study.
The data analysis showed a significant positive correlation between all the
0.314 (p<0.01). No significant difference was found between boys and girls on
which the researchers had taken available onboard tools and different apps
which are available for downloading as the basis of the study. Many teenagers
were kept these tools in their pockets and were inside the classroom. The
researchers expected that the review will be able to bring to light some
innovative ways of how to being used of cell phone and it‟s positive and
the fact that several studies showed increases in student participation in class,
but there is no conclusive evidence which suggests that usage of cell phone is
Acharya, Acharya, and Waghrey(2013) studied the health effects of cell phone
usage. It was conducted among the students who were admitted to pursue
sexes were taken as subjects for the study and their ages were in between 17 to
negative mental and physical health symptoms attributed to cell phone usage
were included, was administered with the subjects. The result showed that
96.1% of the subjects possessed cell phones and they use cell phone a maximum
time of the day. 51.47% subjects had headache, while 50.79% had
49
irritability/anger followed by 32.19% had body aches, 36.51% had eye strain and
13.8% had digital thumb. Subjects also reported some other symptoms of mental
performance etc. Also, accidents were reported due to cell phone driving.
performance. This study had three prime objectives. These were: (1) to know the
between family environment and academic performance. Hence, it was said that
50
family environment can have significant relationship with mental health but not
Borah (2013) studied the relationship between family environment and the
result found a positive effect on academic achievement of the students. Both are
shyness. The sample size of the study was 206(N-206, Male 91, female 15). The
subjects were adolescents whose age ranges between 15-18 years (X=16.50) and
Russel, Peplau and Cutrona (1980), and the “Shyness Scale” developed by
Cheek and Buss (1981). The results revealed that internet addiction is changed
but the duration of internet use and shyness significantly and positively
predicted internet addiction. Besides, the variables of gender and loneliness had
University of Ibadan, Nigeria. The basic aim of the study was to fore if the
distractions to students. The study was conducted as a case study. The result of
the study showed that the internet enabled phone usage does not affect the
Kahari(2013) studied the effects of cell phone use on the study habits of 200 1st
preferences, uses of cell phones during study, predominant usage during study
and information about challenges facing students in using mobile phones. The
study reports significant gender differences in some aspects of the usage of cell
phone. Also it was found the negative and positive effects of the usage of cell
between cell phone use, academic performance, anxiety, and Satisfaction with
Life in college students to investigate the relationships between total cell phone
use (N = 496) and texting (N = 490) on Satisfaction with Life (SWL). It was
(GPA) and anxiety. In this study, the investigators used (1) demographic
information, (2) the Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS; Diener et al., 1985), (3)
the Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI; Beck, Epstein, Brown, & Steer, 1988), and
(4) questions about cell phone and texting use (Lepp et al., 2013). Academic
through official university records. Result revealed that cell phone use/texting
was negatively related to GPA and positively related to anxiety; in turn, GPA
was positively related to SWL while anxiety was negatively related to SWL.
500 first year higher secondary students by using stratified random sampling. In
this study Family Environment Scale developed by Harpreet Bhatia and N.K.
Chadha (1996) was used. The study revealed that there is a significant positive
respondents.
53
used Family environment scale for student, Family Environmental scale for
parents and Socio economic status Inventory in collecting data. These tools were
of class IX students and their parents. Subjects were drawn from public schools
correlation and t-ratio to analyze data. The result found that school performance
family environment and its four dimensions. The four dimensions were
overall family environment, and its four dimensions. It also revealed that
inventory was used, total GPA, and the number of text messaging and callings
54
were used. The result of the study reported that the usage of mobile phones
among the university students were very frequent. But there is a positive
between mobile phone usage and meta-cognitive awareness. The study also said
an ex-post facto and correlation survey. The study was conducted among 900
students who were drawn from the population using multi-stage random
in Agricultural Science (HEFSAATAS) was used in the study. The study finds
secondary school. This study recommended that parents and other significant
persons should make students’ homes conducive and stimulatory to learning not
phone on academic achievement. The sample size of the study was 120, i.e. 60
male and 60 female. The samples were drawn from two departments, Sociology
required information. In this study, the subjects revealed that usage of mobile
regarding their study and duration of exams. Majority of the subjects also stated
that the usage of mobile phone did not affect much on the academic performance
as they turned off their mobile phone during the examination period.
orientation among 610 ninth standards in Madurai city. The data were collected
Scale by Bhatia &Chadha (1993) and Goal orientation measure by Zweig and
Webster (2004) were used. The result of the study highlighted that subjects of
college educated parents, urban and female had better goal orientation. Also
school children and the need of social work intervention to improve the
study, the sample size was 40. The subjects were drawn from Padmaraje High
ascertained with the help school record including report cards of students. The
result of the study revealed that family environment has a positive impact on
performance and had more significant positive effect on 'high' level of scholastic
present study, two psychological tools, such as Family Environment Scale (FES)
by Dr. Harpreet Bhatia and Dr. N. K. Chadha (1993) and Behaviour Orientation
Scale (BOS) by Dr. Parveen Kumar Jhawere used to collect the dataThis study
environment and the aggregate percentage of marks from the last two classes to
sample of 200 adolescents whose age ranges from 15 to 18 years. They used
random sampling technique to collect data. The researchers found that those
environment.
Maurya, Penuli, Kunwar, Lalia, Negi, Williams, and Thakur (2014) studied the
sampling technique was used. The study found that 80% of the respondents
belonged to the age group of 17 to 26 years and among the total respondents,
89% were females. The participants reported that they had been using their
mobile phones since last 4 years. The result also shows that 76 % subjects spent
between Attention and concentration with age of the subjects. Gender was also
subjects reported that they have used mobile phone more for socialization and
concentration, that is 17.42±4.3. So, this study concluded that usage of mobile
attention and academic performance of mobile phone user and mobile phone not
Brain Dysfunction was used. The data were analyzed by calculating t test. In
this study, students who used mobile phone (mobile phone users) reported lower
scores in examinations than the students who did not used mobile phone (mobile
phone not users). The study was also highlighted a significant difference in
terms of attention of mobile user students and mobile not user students.
of Tabriz city, Iran in the school year of 2012-2013. The researcher found a
significant, but negative relationship between cell- phone use and academic
find out the gender differences in family environment and academic achievement
of higher secondary school students in science subject, (2) to find out the gender
secondary school students in arts subject. The sample size was 148 and subjects
were selected by using simple random sampling method from Karaikal region.
Mean, Standard Deviation, „t‟ test were employed in carrying out research. The
result showed significant difference between boys and girls student of higher
Talawar and Das (2014) studied the relationship between academic achievement
and mental health among 200 secondary school tribal students in Assam. To
measure mental health, Mental Health Scale developed by Mercy Abraham and
students were used. The data were statistically treated by applying Pearson‟s
difference in the mental health of boys and girls, urban and rural secondary
Thote and Rathoure(2014) conducted a study to know how cell phone has
given and specially designed for the study. This questionnaire consisted of three
messaging. This study identified the social implications of cell phones and its
Watore(2014) conducted a study to find out the effect of mobile phone addiction
on problem solving ability and recall of short term memory. The study
hypothesized that mobile phone addiction would affect the problem solving
ability and recall of short term memory. To collect data, Mobile Phone
Memory by using Memory Drum were used. Three groups of college students
were recruited in this study and experimental approach has been employed. The
data were analyzed by One Way ANOVA and Duncan Multiple Range Test. The
study reported that the hypothesis has been accepted. The highly addicted group
showed the loss of ability of problem solving and immediate recall of short term
memory.
Yunus, Baba, and WAI (2014) conducted a study on the effect of family
school inNasarawa State. The sample size of the study was 168 whose
chronological age ranges from16 – 20 years. In this study, two tests Family
61
Ojiji and Tafida(2010), and students‟ last semester examination results were
used. The study employed a survey design. The investigators administered two
designs. The study has one factor with three levels, such as well-adjusted, fairly
statistics was used to analyze the variables. The results found no effect of family
Bhardwaj and Ashok (2015) studied mobile phone addiction & loneliness among
100 teenagers (N=100, 50 boys, 50 girls) of Mumbai, India. The ages of the
subjects were ranged between 13 to 17 years and were recruited for the study
through random sampling method. This study used survey method and data were
Meenakshi R. & Prof. K. Krishnan. This study has treated the data through
statistical method, like, correlation, t test. The study found high level of mobile
existed on mobile phone addiction. Besides, the result also highlighted that in
but no gender differences is found there. Finally, it was indicated that mobile
examine phone usage and identified the effects of internet enabled mobile
The sample was drawn from Federal Polytechnic of Ilaro, Ogun State, Nigeria.
They used case study method. The study was performed to understand and find
out the correlation between academic performance of students and the usage of
mobile phone during class hours. To collect information, the researchers used
extensive interviews were done to have information of the students. The findings
use of mobile phone among students is the leading cause of poor academic
Harpreet Bhatia and N.K. Chadha and Study involvement Inventory constructed
with Study involvement of the subjects. Cohesion was found as the strongest
University – Iringa, Tanzania with an aim to find out the impact of smart phones
on academic performance of higher learning students. The study was carried out
on 100 students who were having smart phones. The result of the study
between cell phone use and academic performance in a sample of U.S. college
student. The sample size was 536. The subjects were undergraduate students
regression (R2 = .449) demonstrated that cell phone use was significantly (p <
.001) and negatively (β = −.164) related to actual college GPA after controlling
for academic achievement, and actual high school GPA, which were all
significant predictors (p < .05). Thus, after controlling for other established
predictors, increased cell phone use was associated with decreased academic
performance.
between boys and girls and rural and urban secondary school students in their
and academic achievement and compared the family environment and academic
17 and they were studying in class IX and X. The study revealed a significant
Bhutia and Tariang(2016) studied Mobile phone addiction among 159 college
students. The aim of the study was to find out the mobile phone addiction based
on gender and the stream students are enrolled in. The data for the study were
Correlations were the used and found that was found that students moderately
addicted to mobile phone. The researchers were found no gender and stream
65
impact on the mobile phone addiction. This study also highlighted that the
addiction.
Khurana and Dikshit(2016) examined the mobile phone addiction among girls
and boys. A psychological tool titled, Mobile Phone Addiction Scale, developed
(30 girls and 30 boys). The samples were recruited through stratified random
sampling method. The subjected were drawn from undergraduate classes of the
t-test. The study revealed that subjects‟ living environmental conditions have an
effect on their level of mobile phone addiction. The boys reported significantly
mental health among 100 adolescent students of Rewari district. To collect data,
A.Velayudhan and Dr. Srividya and Mental health scale by Pramodkumar were
used. The data were collected by using random sampling technique. In this
study, Mean and Correlation valued was calculated and was found that mobile
phone addiction. 80 young adults in Guwahati were recruited for the study. Two
and Mobile Phone Addiction Scale (Velayudhan and Srividya, 2012) were used
phone addiction.