Professional Documents
Culture Documents
doi:10.5681/jcs.2015.005
http:// journals.tbzmed.ac.ir/ JCS
nosocomial infection due to some risk factors published in Iran that in 83% of situations,
such as multiple trauma, low levels of nurses do not respect hand hygiene protocols
awareness, and lack of preventive and in most cases they wash their hands after
mechanisms.3, 4 contact with patients.15
The results of some studies have shown Due to low acceptance of hand hygiene
that HAI is one of the main causes of infant protocols among health care personnel and
mortality in developing countries.5 On the high prevalence of nosocomial infection in
other hand, in the last century, the number of critical areas such as neonatal units,16,17 some
premature and twinning birth increased in interventions designed to increase the
developing countries due to the technological attentiveness of health care personnel about
advancement in the treatment of infertility.6 hand hygiene. In this regard, special attention
In result, preterm infants that hospitalized was paid to training courses aimed at
in neonatal units are more susceptible to increasing the knowledge of health care
infection and mortality due to their immature personnel.18 But in this case, consensus has
immune systems.7,8 Therefore, prevention not been achieved and some studies reported
and treatment of nosocomial infections in that despite having a good knowledge, the
neonatal units is very important. performance of health care personnel about
Based on recommendations from World hand hygiene is weak.19 On the other hand,
Health Organization (WHO) and the Centers other researchers believed that the first steps
for Disease Control, hand hygiene is the most in improving the performance of health care
important and easy way for the control of personnel about hand hygiene is increasing
hospital infections.9,10 Due to the critical role their knowledge in this regard.20 Here, the
of nurses in patient care, there is more key question is that what factors influence
emphasis on the role of them in the control of the knowledge of nurses about hand
hospital acquired infections.11 So, according hygiene? In this field, the results of some
to the vital role of nurses in preventing of studies showed the effects of some individual
nosocomial infections, they are key members and organizational factors on nurses’
of infection control team in hospitals. knowledge about hand hygiene.13,21-23 So, this
Therefore, nurses should have sufficient study aims at determining the knowledge of
knowledge and skills in the field of infection hand hygiene and its individual and
control. organizational predictors among nurses in
Studies that investigated the nurses' Tabriz neonatal units.
knowledge about hand hygiene have not
reached the same conclusion.12,13 Materials and methods
Malekmakan et al., in a study about hand
This study has a descriptive and cross-
hygiene among health care staff; notes that
sectional design that conducted in neonatal
nurses' knowledge about standard
wards and neonatal intensive care units
precautions is not enough and many of them
(NICU) affiliated to Tabriz teaching hospitals
believed that by wearing gloves there is no
in 2013. The study sample consisted of 150
need for washing hands.12 The results of
employed nurses in selected settings during
another study on nurses' knowledge and
the study. All of them were invited to
performance about control of nosocomial
participate in the study via census sampling
infections showed that only 43% of nurses
method. Inclusion criteria were included:
had a good knowledge in this regard.14 Najafi
willingness to participate in the study, and
et al., in a systematic review reported that the
having at least 3 months' work experience in
knowledge, acceptance, and performance of
neonatal units or NICUs. The exclusion
intensive care personnel about hand hygiene
criteria were included: did not respond to
is poor. They concluded from the literature
46 | Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53 Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Predictors of nurses’ knowledge about hand hygiene
10% of questions in the questionnaire. Data collection was started after: approval
The study instrument was a researcher of the study proposal by Regional Ethics
made questionnaire that developed based on Committee at Tabriz University of Medical
wide review of literature, articles and Sciences (number 5/4/10330); obtaining
guidelines. This questionnaire consisted of permission from the research deputy of
two parts: The first part was a demographic Tabriz nursing and midwifery faculty; and
checklist. The second part investigated the acquisition informed consent from all
knowledge of nurses about hand hygiene by participants.
15 multiple choice items with 4 responses for
each item. Each item has one correct answer Results
and the total score was calculated by adding
All nurses (100%) were female. The degree of
the score of all correct answers and ranged
95.5% of participants was baccalaureate in
from 0 to 15. Then, the score of each
nursing and 4.5% of them had a master of
participant was divided to low level of
sciences (MS) degree in neonatal intensive
knowledge (scores between 0 and 5),
care. Among participants, 61.1% of them
moderate level of knowledge (scores between
were employed in NICU and 89.3% (134
6 and 10), and high level of knowledge
nurses) were working in rotation shifts and
(scores between 11 and 15). This
10.7% (16 nurses) of them were working in
questionnaire investigated the knowledge of
fixed shifts. Also, 15.9% of participants were
nurses in four domains including: hand
not participated in previous educational
hygiene situations (4 items), infection control
courses about hand hygiene. In addition,
(4 items), antiseptic solutions (4 items), and
among educated nurses, 55.5% participated
definitions of hand hygiene (3 items).
in 1 to 3 previous educational courses, 20% of
The content validity of questionnaire was
them participated in 3 to 5 previous
approved by 10 academic members from
educational courses. Furthermore, 68% of
nursing (7 academic members) and medicine
participants reported a need for continuing
(3 neonatal sub-specialists) faculties in Tabriz
education regarding hand hygiene. More
University of Medical Sciences. According to
demographic characteristics details are
the experts' comments, the first versions of
shown in table 1.
the questionnaire (25 items) were eliminated
The mean score of nurses’ knowledge was
to 14 items, 1 item added, and 2 items were
10.39 (SD = 2.44). Additionally, 1.9%, 29.9%,
modified. In addition, the total score of
and 68.1% of nurses obtained low, moderate,
questionnaire was divided into four domains
and high levels of knowledge respectively.
according to experts’ comments. The
Among different domains of questionnaire,
reliability of the questionnaire was confirmed
the highest score was for infection control
by Cronbach's alpha coefficient (0.81) after
domain and the lowest score was for
pilot study on 30 nurses.
definition of hand hygiene domain (Table 2).
Data analysis was performed using SPSS
All items of different domains of
software version 13 according to qualitative
questionnaire are presents in table 2.
or quantitative nature of variables by
Among different domains of questionnaire,
descriptive statistics including mean,
only the score of infection control domain
standard deviation, frequency, and
had a statistical relationship with the number
percentage and inferential statistics including
of previous educational courses about hand
pearson correlation test, independent
hygiene (P= 0.01). It means that by increasing
samples t-test, One-way ANOVA. For
in the number of previous courses, the score
multivariable explanation of nurses’
of infection control domain was increased.
knowledge based on independent variables
On the other hand, there was no statistical
multiple linear regressions was used.
Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53|47
Asadollahi et al.
48 | Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53 Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Predictors of nurses’ knowledge about hand hygiene
Table 2. Rating the score of nurses knowledge in different domains of hand hygiene
Domains Mean (SD)* Percent of correct Minimum and maximums
responses score in domains
Definition of hand hygiene domain 1.21 (0.94) 40 0-3
Antiseptic solutions domain 2.48 (1.04) 62 0-4
Hand hygiene situations domain 3.08 (0.83) 77 0-4
Infection control domain 3.47 (0.76) 86 1-4
*
SD: standard deviation
Table 3. Explanation of nurses’ knowledge score based on the sum of independent variables in
linear regression model
Variable B β T 95% confidence interval
Lower Upper
History of previous educational courses 1.4 0.22 1.92 0.02 2.78
Previous job experience in neonatal units 1.2 0.19 1.51 0.01 1.92
Job position 0.53 0.09 0.74 - 2.42 1.87
Marital status 0.41 0.08 0.98 - 0.42 1.25
Education 0.27 0.03 0.30 - 1.52 2.0
Number of shifts per week 0.14 0.09 0.92 - 0.16 0.46
Education majority - 0.17 - 0.01 - 0.14 - 2.42 2.39
Number of previous educational courses - 0.17 0.19 1.54 - 0.20 1.17
Employment status - 0.17 - 0.10 - 0.86 - 0.54 0.25
ward - 0.25 - 0.05 - 0.61 - 1.09 1.68
Type of shift - 0.81 - 0.10 - 0.84 - 2.58 1.22
R = 0.41, R2 = 0.17, F = 1.73, P= 0.05
Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53|49
Asadollahi et al.
hand hygiene domain. In the other word, Jang et al., discussed about this issue in a
participants had a lack of knowledge about different way and stated that as long as the
the basic principles of hand hygiene health care personnel carry out hand
guidelines. This finding indicated a need for hygiene for self-protection, education in this
the education of basic concepts about hand regard will not have a large impact. They
hygiene for nurses. Jang et al., in a give an important role for management
descriptive study reported that health care factors and believed that respectable
personnel had many knowledge deficit communication patterns, team efforts, and
about guidelines related to hand hygiene. the education of nurses about how to
These personnel believed that these comply with hand hygiene guidelines,
guidelines are not realistic and they can despite the high workload, are important
judge better than guidelines on situations factors.26
that require hand hygiene.26 Work experience and type of employment
Another considerable finding of this had a significant relationship with the
study is that there was no statistical knowledge of nurses regarding hand
relationship between previous training hygiene. Maybe with increasing work
classes and nurses’ knowledge about hand experience in clinical settings and the
hygiene (P> 0.05). On the other word, these determination of nurses’ employment status,
programs have no great impact on their motivation for further learning and
increasing nurses’ knowledge in this regard. respecting update guidelines will increase.
Despite this fact, many previous studies Although this relationship has not been
showed the impact of education on shown in previous studies, such as studies
increasing nurses’ knowledge about hand by Ghadamgahi et al.,23Also, the results of
hygiene.26,27 In this regard, Rongming et al., this study showed a significant relationship
reported that for the reinforce of related between age and knowledge of nurses
concepts to hand hygiene among nurses, regarding hand hygiene (r= 0.25, P = 0.001).
different educational methods should be This finding is consistent with the result of
used and promoting hand hygiene another study by Butsashvili et al.,28 Also,
knowledge can increase the knowledge and the results of this study showed that the
hand hygiene quality among nurses.18 On knowledge score of staff nurses was further
the other hand, Erasmus et al., reported that than other ones. These results may be due to
contact with blood or other secretions are the disengagement of staff nurses in
main factors in increasing hand hygiene executive tasks and its related problems.
practice among nurses and the effect of Also, in one of the previous studies, the
education is very small in this regard.24 score of staff nurses were equal with other
Similarly, Erasmus et al., reported that hand ones.25
hygiene behavior influenced by the Based on multivariate regression analysis,
willingness of people to clean themselves several factors were the predictors of nurses’
and the behavior of other employees in this knowledge about hand hygiene. Work
regard. Based on this finding, these experience and previous training on hand
researchers concluded that holding hygiene were two main predictors of
workshops and continuing education knowledge among participants which
programs that focus on the protection of collectively can explain 17 percent of
patients may have a lower impact on nurses’ variance in nurses' knowledge about hand
performance regarding hand hygiene.16 The hygiene (Table 3). However, in the study of
most important issue in this regard is Butsashvili et al., some factors such as age,
educational methods used for the transfer of sex, training on standard precautions, and
contents regarding hand hygiene to nurses. the position of nurse were the predictive
50 | Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53 Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Predictors of nurses’ knowledge about hand hygiene
Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53|51
Asadollahi et al.
52 | Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53 Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Predictors of nurses’ knowledge about hand hygiene
Copyright © 2015 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, March 2015; 4 (1), 45-53|53