Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s12028-017-0464-x
REVIEW ARTICLE
Abstract Pneumocephalus (PNC) is a condition in which of high-flow nasal cannula (HFNC), all patients improved
when air is trapped inside the intracranial vault. The causes both clinically and radiographically within a few hours,
are varied, but include trauma and intracranial surgery. faster than in both anecdotal experience and published
Treatment of PNC typically consists of augmenting patient trials. Due to its steady FiO2 administration, positive
oxygenation with the attempt of washing out pulmonary pressure, comfort, and low side-effect profile, HFNC may
nitrogen, creating a gradient in which nitrogen in the be the ideal mode of oxygen delivery in PNC. We present a
intracranial air bubble diffuses out of the lungs via the review of the physiology of PNC and the characteristics of
blood. Though several high flow methods have been tested, several oxygen delivery systems to build a case for HFNC
the ideal mode of oxygenation has not fully been investi- in this disease process.
gated. Here we present 3 cases of post-operative PNC who
we felt were symptomatic from PNC. With administration Keywords Tension pneumocephalus
High-flow nasal cannula Craniectomy Oxygen therapy
Arterial oxygen partial pressure
& Jason L. Siegel
Siegel.jason@mayo.edu
Karen Hampton Introduction
Hampton.karen@mayo.edu
Alejandro A. Rabinstein Pneumocephalus (PNC) is a condition in which air enters
Rabinstein.alejandro@mayo.edu
and is contained inside the intracranial compartment. It has
Diane McLaughlin been studied and well described for over 100 years [1–5].
Mclaughlin.diane@mayo.edu
PNC can be caused by head and facial trauma,
Jose L. Diaz-Gomez intracranial and spinal procedures (including lumbar
Diazgomez.jose@mayo.edu
puncture), otorhinolaryngological procedures, and even
1
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, 4500 San Pablo spontaneously. When intracranial pressure (ICP) increases
Road, Jacksonville, FL 32224, USA causing neurological decline, PNC is referred to as tension
2
Department of Critical Care, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, pneumocephalus (TP). Symptoms can include nausea,
FL 32224, USA vomiting, seizures, dizziness, and altered mental status
3
Department of Respiratory Therapy, Mayo Clinic, [5, 6].
Jacksonville, FL 32224, USA Here, we present three cases of postoperative PNC
4
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, which resolved quickly with humidified oxygen delivery
MN 55905, USA via high-flow nasal cannula. We follow the cases with a
5
Department of Anesthesia and Perioperative Medicine, Mayo detailed review of the mechanisms and pathophysiology of
Clinic, Jacksonville, FL 32224, USA PNC and its treatment, as well as future directions in
6
Department of Neurosurgery, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, management.
FL 32224, USA
123
Neurocrit Care
Fig. 1 a Axial magnetic resonance imaging T1 with gadolinium of air than the surface tension of cerebral fluid between the frontal
contrast revealing multiple falcine and left convexity meningiomas lobes (known as the Mount Fuji sign). There is also bifrontal sulcal
with vasogenic edema of the left frontal lobe. b Axial computed effacement. f Axial FLAIR Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the
tomography scan revealing left frontal pneumocephalus with efface- same cut as the B., with resolution of the PNC. g Axial noncontrast
ment of the left frontal sulci, edema, and 8 mm left-to-right midline head CT demonstrating bilateral subdural hematomas. h Axial
shift. c Axial computed tomography scan showing improvement in noncontrast head CT showing bifrontal air bubbles without commu-
midline shift and nearly improvement in the PNC. d Axial noncon- nication between them. i Axial noncontrast head CT with
trast head CT demonstrating air within the surgical bed of the right improvement in bilateral PNC after 20 h of HFNC therapy
frontotemporal resection. e Axial noncontrast head CT showing
bifrontal PNC with air between the frontal tips, due to greater pressure
123
Neurocrit Care
discharges. She was put on 100% oxygen via 15 L/min Pathophysiology of Pneumocephalus
nonrebreather (NRB) mask. Bedside lung ultrasound and
chest X-ray did not reveal interstitial pulmonary edema or Air enters the intracranial vault in two ways, depending on
pleural effusion, and her SpO2 was 97% with ongoing the pressure gradient across the skull defect: Air can be
encephalopathy. Oxygen therapy was changed to humidi- pulled into the skull by negative intracranial pressure (ICP)
fied oxygen via high-flow nasal cannula (HFNC) at 30 L/ or pushed in by positive extracranial pressure (ECP). In
min, and fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO2) of 1. Her addition, the nature of the skull defect determines how the
arterial oxygen partial pressure (PaO2) increased from air becomes trapped. Together, these principles distill into
162.5 to 410.6 mmHg, and her neurological deficits dra- two basic models of PNC: the inverted bottle model and the
matically improved. Repeat head CT 16 h later showed ball-valve model [7].
reduced PNC with midline shift reduced to 6 mm (Fig. 1c). In the inverted bottle model, an intra-extracranial cere-
Her depressed alertness, aphasia, weakness, and sensory brospinal fluid (CSF) fistula is created. When ICP exceeds
loss were likely due to the TP, as there were no alternative ECP, the CSF leaks out of the skull through the fistula until
explanations and her neurological condition improved the pressures equalize [7]. If ICP then decreases due to
rapidly with improvement in the PNC. We postulate that reduced brain edema, positioning (higher than 30°),
the increased PaO2 via high-flow nasal cannula helped to increased CSF resorption, decreased venous pressure,
reduce the intracranial air, thus improving her symptoms. absorption of hemorrhage, or decreased CSF production, a
negative gradient relative to ECP develops, which facili-
Case 2 tates the movement of air into the skull through the fistula.
The air collects at the top of the intracranial vault in a
A 57-year-old woman with history of right mesial tem- gravity-dependent manner creating a water seal. If any of
poral sclerosis and subsequent drug resistant localization these situations reverses and ICP increases, CSF rather than
related epilepsy underwent right anterior temporal lobec- air will escape the head (Fig. 2a).
tomy for ongoing seizures. Postoperatively, she was alert, In the ball-valve model, the skull defect is sealed by a
oriented, and fully attentive. Approximately 6 h later, she dural flap. This dural flap may temporarily allow the inflow
developed signs of hyperactive delirium, manifested by of air when the ICP decreases, but subsequently prevents
restlessness, disinhibition, inattention, echolalia, and per- the escape of either air or CSF with increases in ICP
severation. Noncontrast head CT revealed PNC around (Fig. 2b).
the surgical bed as well as the bifrontal areas, with the Postsurgical intracranial air can be caused by either of
Mount Fuji sign (Fig. 1d, e). HFNC oxygen therapy at these models through imperfect closure. Additionally, air
30 L/min at FiO2 of 1 was initiated with subsequent can be sealed into the intracranial vault during surgical
resolution of her cognitive deficits and near complete closure, even though at that time there is no pressure gra-
resolution of her PNC within 12 h. By the next morning, dient. In this latter instance, because there is no pressure
she had clinically returned to baseline with resolution of gradient, the risk of developing a TP is lower without
the PNC on follow-up magnetic resonance imaging 12 h additional inverted bottle or ball-valve effect.
after the head CT (Fig. 1f).
Case 3
Physiological Model for Treatment
123
Neurocrit Care
Fig. 2 Mechanisms of air introduction and entrapment in the intracranial vault due to the two basic models: inverted bottle and ball valve
and the lungs, and no gas transfer will occur. Of these two Importantly, based solely on the physiology and theo-
primary gases, nitrogen will have the larger volume and, retic basis of PNC washout, other factors can play a role in
thus, removing it will have the most impact. Of the vari- air accumulation and reabsorption, making it difficult to
ables of Fick’s law, we have the most control over DP, the predict the rate of air bubble resolution.
partial pressure difference of N2. Increasing FiO2 to 1 will
decrease the N2 partial pressure in the alveoli (PpN2),
creating a concentration gradient with the blood, and ulti- Current Treatment Strategies
mately a concentration gradient with the intracranial air
bubble. Nitrogen should diffuse from the intracranial A conservative approach for the treatment of PNC is
bubble to the blood, and out the lungs. At all levels of decreasing ICP by placing the patient at 30° and avoiding
oxygen therapy, most intracranial air is absorbed in the ICP spikes and CSF leakage spikes by limiting Valsalva
initial periods of oxygen therapy, especially with moderate maneuvers, sneezing, coughing, or straining from pain.
or large PNC [8]. Using mathematical models, Dexter and Yet, PNC may take 2–3 weeks for resolution with these
Reasoner demonstrated that increasing FiO2 should make a measures only [10], and conservative management is not
significant improvement in PNC volume over time [9], but appropriate when patients are symptomatic from increased
that the effect may plateau at about FiO2 0.5. ICP.
Although Dexter’s models predict that increasing PaO2 The mainstay of conservative PNC treatment is aug-
(via increasing FiO2) would have a ceiling in its beneficial mented oxygen delivery. The modes of oxygen delivery
effect to reduce PNC, there is another mechanism by which vary, however, in flow rate, FiO2 delivery, invasiveness,
high PaO2 can promote N2 clearance. Increasing PaO2 will and patient comfort (Table 1) [11, 12]. Providing oxygen
force O2 into the intracranial air bubble, further washing therapy with 100% inspired oxygen is recommended for
out the N2. On room air (FiO2 0.21), the partial pressure of symptomatic patients. This treatment hastens the resorption
O2 in the intracranial bubble will be that of the atmosphere of air by increasing the washout of N2. There are currently
(*150 mmHg), which is more than in blood no consensus guidelines on the optimal way to administer
(PaO2 * 95 mmHg). This gradient favors diffusion of oxygen therapy, including FiO2, mode of delivery, and
oxygen from the intracranial air bubble to the blood, but duration of delivery.
such gradient can be reversed by increasing PaO2. Thus, The first prospective trial for normobaric oxygen ther-
increasing FiO2 to 1 and PaO2 to >400–500 mmHg (in apy compared oxygen therapy with 100% O2 via NRB for
normal human lungs) reverse the partial pressure gradient 24 h against room air in patients with postoperative PNC
favoring O2 into the air bubble, forcing N2 into the blood. (at least 30 ml or greater). The study found a significant
123
Neurocrit Care
Low-flow systems—delivers O2 100% flows less than patient’s inspiratory flow rate
Nasal cannula 24–44 1–8 Not recommended for severe hypoxia due to inconsistent FiO2
Humidification recommended when >4 L/min
Face mask 35–50 >5 Nonspecific FiO2
Mask reservoir 40–60 5–10 Flow rate > 5L/min improves washout of gas.
Mask can be obtrusive, uncomfortable, obstructs coughing
Cannot administer humidified air
Nonrebreather 40–90 8–15 Mask must be tightly sealed
Uncomfortable and drying
Risk of CO2 retention if mask reservoir allowed to collapse
High-flow systems—delivers O2 100% flows greater than patient’s inspiratory flow rate
Venturi mask 24–40 4–12 Accurate and consistent FiO2
Used with CO2 retention and inconsistent respiratory drive
OxyMask 24–80 1–15 Open system avoids accumulation of CO2
Comfortable
High-flow nasal cannula Up to 100% 10–60 Heat and humidified O2
Provides small amount of PEEP
Increased flow may expedite N2 washout from the lungs
CO2 carbon dioxide, FiO2 fraction of inspired oxygen, O2 oxygen, PEEP positive end-expiratory pressure
improvement in mean rate of volume reduction (65 vs. are especially susceptible to the effects of Valsalva
31%, p = 0.009) over 24 h [13]. [10, 17]. Other preventive measures after excision of brain
Another study of patients with postoperative PNC and tumors include drain placement at the end of the procedure
bubble volumes C30 ml found that normobaric hyperoxy- and keeping the patient in the supine position during the
genation for only 3 h via an endotracheal tube also reduced initial postoperative recovery.
CT air volume and improved patient alertness [14]. This In reviewing the literature, we did not find high-level
study highlights that gas diffusion may occur so quickly evidence for the management of PCN. Reported treatment
that we can get meaningful results within a few hours of strategies are summarized in Table 2 [8, 13–15, 17–19].
initiating treatment.
One study prospectively compared normobaric oxy- Potential Utilization of HFNC as a Novel Strategy
genation with hyperbaric oxygenation of 2.5 atmospheres in Conservative Treatment of PNC
(atm) in 24 patients with symptomatic PNC. Patients in the
hyperbaric oxygen group improved clinically and radio- Although NRB is most commonly used for the treatment of
graphically more rapidly than the controls (time to PNC, HFNC offers heated and humidified, higher flow rate,
resolution 3.0 vs. 8.3 days, p = 0.01), and had shorter with more consistent FiO2 delivery (0.21–1.0), and is less
hospital stays (5.8 vs. 9.9 days, p = 0.01) [15]. The invasive and more comfortable than NRB (Fig. 3). High-
authors postulated that hyperbaric oxygen (HBO2) has a flow devices without heated or humidified delivery source
greater effect on elevating PaO2, thus accelerating N2 (via regular nasal cannula or NRB) can be irritating to the
washout [15]. However, this study did not report PaO2 nasal mucosa and prolonged use can become uncomfort-
levels, and hyperbaric chambers are often not available. able for the patient. The system does not require large
Furthermore, HBO2 has also been reported as a potential machinery and is easily assembled by a respiratory thera-
cause of PNC [16]. pist. There have been no studies, however, directly looking
In some cases, drilling burr holes, needle aspiration, and at HFNC or comparing HFNC with NRB in the treatment
surgical closure of the dural defect may be necessary, of PNC.
especially in TP. Ideally, the surgical management should HFNC may help respiratory mechanics by improving
be tailored to the pathophysiological mechanism. For ventilation and increasing oxygenation. In healthy human
instance, sinus surgery is also commonly treated with sinus subjects, HFNC was shown to increase tidal volume and
packing and surgical repair of the dural tear as these fistulas decrease respiratory rate proportionally to the delivered
123
Neurocrit Care
Arbit et al. 1; case report Controlled N/A Resolution of N/A The patient was
[16] decompression neurological initially treated
via a closed decline and with NRB with
water-seal decrease in NCHCT
drainage intracranial air resolution, but
after 4 days PNC re-emerged
4 days later
requiring drainage
Reasoner 134 postoperative N/A N/A PNC seen on Moderate or large Authors do not
et al. [8] intracranial NCHCT: PNC on scans: comment on
procedures; 100% POD#0 66% POD #0 treatment
retrospective, and #2 75% 11.8% POW#2 modalities
observational POW #1
59.6% POW #2
26.3% POW#3
Gore et al. 13 postoperative PNC 100% O2 using Room air for Mean rate of No safety First prospective
[11] (C30 m); prospective NRB at 12 24 h radiographic differences study examining
RCT L/min for 24 h volume effect of
reduction: supplemental O2
intervention on PNC resolution
65% versus
control 31%
(p = 0.009).
DelGaudio 10 (8 after endoscopic N/A N/A 7/10 patients All underwent No comment on
and sinus surgery, 2 after resolved with surgical re- what was
Ingley microscopic skull ‘‘conservative exploration, 8 ‘‘conservative
[15] base surgery); management’’ needed defect management’’
retrospective repair, 2 had
scarring not
requiring repair
Chung 1; case report Mechanical Complete Patient remained
et al. [17] ventilation, Vt resolution of intubated for
450 ml, FiO2 PNC by day 3 3 days
100%
Paiva et al. 24 (22 traumatic, 2 HBO2 at 2.5 atm, 5 L/min NC for Time to Time of HBO2 not available
[13] postoperative); 100% O2 for 1 h 5 days radiographic hospitalization: at many sites
prospective RTC once or twice resolution controls (days) HBO2 has been
daily for 5 days, (days): 9.9 versus HBO2 implicated in
or until controls 8.3 5.8 (p = 0.01) causing PNC [13]
radiographic versus HBO2
resolution of 3.0 (p = 0.01)
PNC
Hong et al. 44 postoperative Ongoing Weaned off Change mean air Mean air resorption Only 3 h of
[12] supratentorial PNC endotracheal sedation and volume (mL): rate (mL/h): 0.63 treatment needed
(>30 ml) after intubation extubated -16.54 in the faster in the
posterior fossa following postoperatively intervention vs intervention
surgery in the surgery with control group
semisitting position. FiO2 100% for (p = 0.001) (p = 0.0015)
Patients enrolled after 3h
immediate
postoperative head
CT
Prospective RTC
Atm atmospheres, HBO2 hyperbaric oxygen, N/A not applicable, NC nasal cannula, NCHCT noncontrast head CT, PNC Pneumocephalus, POD
postoperative day, POW postoperative week, RTC randomized controlled trial, Vt tidal volume
123
Neurocrit Care
Conclusion
123
Neurocrit Care
clinical improvement and more standardized studies are semisitting position: a prospective randomized controlled trial.
required. By breathing 100% oxygen, a faster N2 washout PLoS ONE. 2015;10:e0125710.
15. Paiva WS, de Andrade AF, Figueiredo EG, Amorim RL, Prudente M,
from the lungs occurs, facilitating the diffusion of the Teixeira MJ. Effects of hyperbaric oxygenation therapy on symp-
nitrogen in the intracranial bubble into the circulating tomatic pneumocephalus. Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2014;10:769–73.
blood following its gradient. The pronounced increase in 16. Pulickal GG, Sitoh YY, Ng WH. Tension pneumocephalus.
PaO2 achieved with HFNC (and perhaps the increased flow Singap Med J. 2014;55:e46–8.
17. DelGaudio JM, Ingley AP. Treatment of pneumocephalus after
rate) might accelerate PNC clearance in comparison with endoscopic sinus and microscopic skull base surgery. Am J
the use of a NRB mask. In addition, since the air delivered Otolaryngol. 2010;31:226–30.
by high-flow nasal cannula is warmed and humidified, and 18. Arbit E, Shah J, Bedford R, Carlon G. Tension pneumocephalus:
is delivered without a cumbersome mask, it is better tol- treatment with controlled decompression via a closed water-seal
drainage system. Case report. J Neurosurg. 1991;74:139–42.
erated by the patient. Consequently, we propose that HFNC 19. Chung CW, Pierce R, Assaly R. Treating Mt. Fuji sign with 100%
can represent a potentially useful strategy for the treatment oxygen supplementation. Am J Med Sci. 2014;348:265.
of symptomatic PNC. 20. Mundel T, Feng S, Tatkov S, Schneider H. Mechanisms of nasal
high flow on ventilation during wakefulness and sleep. J Appl
Compliance with Ethical Standards Physiol. 1985;2013(114):1058–65.
21. Parke RL, Bloch A, McGuinness SP. Effect of very-high-flow
Conflict of interest Dr. Siegel reports no disclosures. Mrs. Hampton nasal therapy on airway pressure and end-expiratory lung impe-
reports no disclosures. Dr. Rabinstein reports no disclosures. Ms. dance in healthy volunteers. Respir Care. 2015;60:1397–403.
McLaughlin reports no disclosures. Dr. Diaz-Gomez reports no 22. Parke RL, McGuinness SP. Pressures delivered by nasal high
disclosures. flow oxygen during all phases of the respiratory cycle. Respir
Care. 2013;58:1621–4.
23. Moller W, Celik G, Feng S, et al. Nasal high flow clears
anatomical dead space in upper airway models. J Appl Physiol.
References 1985;2015(118):1525–32.
24. Hernandez G, Roca O, Colinas L. High-flow nasal cannula sup-
1. Thomas L. Du pneumatocele du crane. Arch Gen Med (Paris). port therapy: new insights and improving performance. Crit Care.
1866;1:34–55. 2017;21:62.
2. Chiari H. Uber einen Fall von Luftansammlung in den Ventrikeln 25. Boone MD, Jinadasa SP, Mueller A, et al. The effect of positive
des menschlichen Gehirns. Ztschr f Heilk. 1884;5:383–90. end-expiratory pressure on intracranial pressure and cerebral
3. Wolff E. Luftansammlung im rechten Seitenventrikel des Gehirns hemodynamics. Neurocrit Care. 2017;26:174–81.
(Pneumozephalus). Munch Med Wochenschr. 1914;15:899. 26. Frat JP, Thille AW, Mercat A, et al. High-flow oxygen through
4. Luckett W. Air in the ventricles of the brain, following a fracture of nasal cannula in acute hypoxemic respiratory failure. N Engl J
the skull: report of a case. Surg Gynecol Obstet. 1913;26:237–40. Med. 2015;372:2185–96.
5. Schirmer CM, Heilman CB, Bhardwaj A. Pneumocephalus: case 27. Brotfain E, Zlotnik A, Schwartz A, et al. Comparison of the
illustrations and review. Neurocrit Care. 2010;13:152–8. effectiveness of high flow nasal oxygen cannula vs. standard non-
6. Markham J. The clinical features of pneumocephalus based upon rebreather oxygen face mask in post-extubation intensive care
a survey of 284 cases with report of 11 additional cases. Acta unit patients. Isr Med Assoc J. 2014;16:718–22.
Neurochir (Wien). 1967;75:1–78. 28. Hernandez G, Vaquero C, Colinas L, et al. Effect of postextu-
7. Walker FO, Vern BA. The mechanism of pneumocephalus for- bation high-flow nasal cannula vs noninvasive ventilation on
mation in patients with CSF fistulas. J Neurol Neurosurg reintubation and postextubation respiratory failure in high-risk
Psychiatry. 1986;49:203–5. patients: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2016;316:1565–74.
8. Reasoner DK, Todd MM, Scamman FL, Warner DS. The inci- 29. Maggiore SM, Idone FA, Vaschetto R, et al. Nasal high-flow
dence of pneumocephalus after supratentorial craniotomy. versus Venturi mask oxygen therapy after extubation. Effects on
Observations on the disappearance of intracranial air. Anesthe- oxygenation, comfort, and clinical outcome. Am J Respir Crit
siology. 1994;80:1008–12. Care Med. 2014;190:282–8.
9. Dexter F, Reasoner DK. Theoretical assessment of normobaric 30. Kopelovich JC, de la Garza GO, Greenlee JD, Graham SM, Udeh
oxygen therapy to treat pneumocephalus. Anesthesiology. CI, O’Brien EK. Pneumocephalus with BiPAP use after
1996;84:442–7. transsphenoidal surgery. J Clin Anesth. 2012;24:415–8.
10. Dabdoub CB, Salas G, Silveira Edo N, Dabdoub CF. Review of 31. Deneke SM, Fanburg BL. Normobaric oxygen toxicity of the
the management of pneumocephalus. Surg Neurol Int. lung. N Engl J Med. 1980;303:76–86.
2015;6:155. 32. Nishimura M. High-flow nasal cannula oxygen therapy in adults.
11. Kallstrom TJ, American Association for Respiratory C. AARC J Intensive Care. 2015;3:15.
Clinical practice guideline: oxygen therapy for adults in the acute 33. Clevens RA, Marentette LJ, Esclamado RM, Wolf GT, Ross DA.
care facility–2002 revision & update. Respir Care. Incidence and management of tension pneumocephalus after
2002;47:717–20. anterior craniofacial resection: case reports and review of the
12. Paul JE, Hangan H, Hajgato J. The OxyMask() development and literature. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1999;120:579–83.
performance in healthy volunteers. Med Devices (Auckl). 34. Sprague A, Poulgrain P. Tension pneumocephalus: a case report
2009;2:9–17. and literature review. J Clin Neurosci. 1999;6:418–24.
13. Gore PA, Maan H, Chang S, Pitt AM, Spetzler RF, Nakaji P. 35. Wanamaker JR, Mehle ME, Wood BG, Lavertu P. Tension
Normobaric oxygen therapy strategies in the treatment of pneumocephalus following craniofacial resection. Head Neck.
postcraniotomy pneumocephalus. J Neurosurg. 2008;108:926–9. 1995;17:152–6.
14. Hong B, Biertz F, Raab P, et al. Normobaric hyperoxia for 36. Zasler ND. Posttraumatic tension pneumocephalus. J Head
treatment of pneumocephalus after posterior fossa surgery in the Trauma Rehabil. 1999;14:81–4.
123