Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Graduate Program
In Architecture
L A N D S C A P E E C O L O G Y
2
Table of contents
ABSTRACT
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Ecological wisdom concept and background
1.2 Syria background
1.3 Objective of the study
CHAPTER 2. A CASE STUDY OF NATURAL ENVIRONMENTAL AREA
(SABKHAT AL-JABBUL, A RAMASAR WETLAND IN SYRIA)
2.1 Background study.
2.2. Site context.
2.3. An age-old cultural landscape.
2.4. The unique biodiversity of Jabbul wetland.
2.5. What is the value of the Jabbul ecosystem?
2.6. International commitments: the Ramsar Convention.
2.7. Conservation Practices of Jabbul wetland.
CHAPTER 3. A CASE STUDY OF ENVIRONMENTAL AREA MADE BY HUMAN
(SEA ENVIRONMENTAL GARDEN-SYRIA)
3.1. Background study.
3.2. Site context.
3.3. Constrains of the site.
3.4. Features sustainable practices.
3.3. Conservation from urban landscape identity.
CHAPTER 4. CONCLOSION
REFERENCES
3
Introduction
1.1 Ecological wisdom concept
Ecological practice is the action and process that humans involuntarily engage
themselves in with the aim to bring about a secure and harmonious socio-
ecological a condition that serves human beings’ basic need for survival and
flourishing. From ecological practice, humans acquired a distinctive master skill par
excellence, ecological wisdom that enables them to address and act well on
intractable socio-ecological issues that are crucial to their survival and flourishing.
While manifesting itself in a myriad of ecological and landscape projects and public
policy instruments that have been beneficent to both humans and other residents
on the earth. This invaluable intellectual asset of ecological wisdom continues to
evolve in the contemporary society of unprecedented socio ecological
transformations, inspiring advancement in modern science and stimulating
technological and engineering innovations for the greater good. Ecological wisdom-
inspired science and engineering is, therefore, the emerging transdisciplinary field
of scholarly inquiry that seeks novel insights, deliberately through the lens of
ecological wisdom, into contemporary socio-ecological issues, and aims to develop
innovative, prudent, and efficacious scientific and engineering solutions. This
research aims to highlight two projects in Syria, the first made by nature and the
second human-made. In addition, define the environmental practices undertaken
by Syria to maintain these projects.
4
wisdom is, in particular, relevant to the human and nature relationship. One of the
central problems confronted by design professionals, as well as by those
advocating a wise society more broadly. Today, urban sustainability faces stiff
challenges with the coupled effects of human and biophysical changes
(globalization). On one hand, a comprehensive approach is being called for to tackle
grand sustainability challenges. On the other hand, sciences and technologies—
considered as the solutions—are developing into increasingly compartmentalized
sub-disciplines that lack the holism necessary for tackling sustainability challenges.
Human civilization is at the crossroad in that deep ecological crises cannot be
alleviated simply through the accumulation and application of scientific knowledge.
The concepts of ancient ecological wisdom were developed in the absence of
modern scientific methods. Tao-de-jing, for instance, written by Laozi (c.a. 571 BC–
471 BC) distills the ecological wisdom of ancient Chinese and it remains influential
worldwide today in the fields of philosophy, planning and design, management,
and others (Feng 1991; She 1996; Cheng and Bunnin 2008). Urban areas have
become increasingly reliant on resources imported (or captured) from their
hinterlands (which have themselves become larger over the centuries).
Consequently, urban areas are “hotspots” within which to tackle sustainability
challenges.
Ecological Wisdom and Principles
Definitions of Wisdom and Ecological Wisdom
The Oxford Dictionary of English defines “wisdom” as “the quality of having
experience, knowledge, and good judgment.” It is one’s ability to make good ethical
and political choices.
Wisdom is considered as a personality trait, which is related to knowledge, whereas
the acquisition of knowledge does not guarantee the acquisition of wisdom
(Gugerell and Riffert 2011).
There is no unified definition of “ecological wisdom.” Norwegian philosopher Arne
Naess first put forth the concept of “ecological wisdom” based on his ecocentric
personal philosophies, ecosophies, combining the root words from ancient Greek
ecos Where Does Ecological Wisdom Come from? Historical … (household place)
and sophia (wisdom) (Drengson and Devall 2010).
5
ecological wisdom—a wise person or society’s ethic, knowledge, ability, and grit to
do the right thing (or not do certain things), in socio-ecosystem planning, design,
and management, as manifested in time-honored projects, efficacious policy
instruments, and is informed by lessons learned.
Principles of Ecological Wisdom
Including reverence to nature, sustained relevance, holism, and practicality. These
principles are manifested in evidence-based, time-honored ecological projects and
effective policy instruments.
6
principle of sustained novelty suggests that the significance of ecological wisdom is
(better) appreciated when placed in historical context.
Practicality (Actionability)
Aristotle’s idea of phronesis emphasizes the practicality of wisdom, that social
process constantly demands choices, and making the right choices demands
wisdom (Schwartz and Sharpe 2010). Likewise, ecological wisdom is distinctly
practical; it cannot be purely abstract or ethereal. In urban planning, phronetic
planning stands for the practical wisdom to make judgments on values and power
in order to inform particular and concrete planning decisions (Flyvbjerg 2004).
Ecological wisdom integrates science, technology, management, and culture and,
hence, goes beyond the philosophical level. Ecological wisdom is enhanced through
trial and error in practice. It includes lessons learned from failures. It is what people
need to understand about how they should, and should not, act in a real-world
context, in order to achieve socio-ecological sustainability (Xiang 2014a).
7
mostly concentrated in the western region of the country and are represented by
a Mediterranean vegetation.
Climate:
The climate, in general, is a modified Mediterranean type. The modification is
mainly due to the change in the microhabitat as a result of man’s misuse of natural
resources. There are four distinct seasons in the year: a cool and rainy winter with
occasional snow, a hot and dry summer, and short and moderate spring and
autumn. The coastal areas have a mild climate, while the interior areas are rather
continental with cold winters where the temperatures drop to subzero oC and hot
summers of above 40oC. The long period of drought is one of the most important
ecological factors dominating the natural vegetation in the Mediterranean region.
The geographical latitude, altitudinal variation, the blocking effect of mountain
ranges and the distance from the Mediterranean Sea are among the factors that
modify and have an effect on the climate in Syria.
8
CHAPTER 2: A CASE STUDY OF NATURAL ENVIRONMENTAL AREA
(SABKHAT AL-JABBUL, A RAMASAR WETLAND IN SYRIA)
According to URT (2014) wetlands are known to be nature’s water store on land.
“Sabkhat al-Jabbul” is a large, shallow wetland with seasonal saline and brackish
water bodies, surrounded by reed beds, rangelands and cultivated land. The
name “sabkha” refers to the fact that the water is salty and dries up during the
summer season. The Jabbul Sabkha is located 40 km southeast of Aleppo city.
Its importance as a staging and wintering area for water birds, particularly the
Greater Flamingo, was recognized as early as the 1960s (Savage, 1968).
This has led to its identification as an “Important Bird Area” (IBA) by BirdLife
International (Evans 1994), and its official designation in 1998 as a “Wetland of
International Importance” or “Ramsar site” under the Ramsar Convention.
A survey during the Syrian Wetland Expedition of 2004 led to its recognition as the
“Jabbul is the most important wetland in Syria and as one of the most important wetland
sites in the whole Middle East.”
most important wetland in Syria and as one of the most important wetland sites in
the whole Middle East (Murdoch et al, 2004). As the condition of the Sabkha
strongly depends on human activities in the surrounding areas, and as the condition
of the Sabkha influences the living conditions of the surrounding communities, the
Sabkha and the surrounding agricultural areas together is called the “Jabbul
agroecosystem”.
The natural resources of the Sabkhat al- Jabbul – including the Jabbul salt, surface
water, groundwater and shoreline rangelands -have always been considered a
significant economic asset.
9
2.2 Site context.
DISCREPTION AND CLIMATE.
Sabkhat al Jabbul lies at an altitude of 312 masl south-east of Aleppo. It has a
moderate continental climate with a temperature range from 2 to 10°C in January
and 21 to 37°C in July. The average rainfall is 200–350mm, most falling between
October and April. The Sabkhat has formed in a closed basin of 5075 km2.
The sabkhat now consists of three semi-independent water bodies with markedly
different ecosystems whose water and salinity levels fluctuate independently:
-The northwestern lake (maximum surface area [msa] 47km2). This is the most
saline and is the official site for salt extraction. Its water comes from irrigation
channels and groundwater from the northern side of the lake. A state company
produces salt by evaporating lake water in cement ponds close to Jabbul village.
10
-The central lake (msa 194km2). The largest lake. It is brackish in the north, inflow
from channels entering the north and the north-east corner seemingly resulting in
a local decline in salinity and saline in the south. The central lake has nine
permanent islands (whose total surface area is c18km2).
- The southeastern lake (msa 29km2). An earth dam controls water flow into the
central lake by culverts, the southeastern lake being at a higher elevation.
Paradoxically, the water level in the south-eastern lake apparently increases in the
summer. When the cotton-planting season begins in April.
11
LAND USE, VEGETATION AND HABITATS
The sabkhat is surrounded by distinct
farming communities and systems
which have a significant impact on its
vegetation and habitats:
- Northern and western shores:
relatively densely populated
agricultural plains, intensively
cultivated throughout the year,
whose farmers rely heavily on
irrigation.
- Southwestern shores: mixed-
income from salt extraction,
agriculture, and off-farm activities.
- Southern shores: relatively poor
communities dependent on dry-land
farming ,sheep-rearing and off-farm
activities.
- Eastern shores: settled Bedouin
villages at low density that depend on
raising sheep and salt extraction.
12
Northwestern lake: the shoreline is mostly bare, particularly along the steeper,
stonier stretches in the south, which have often been degraded by agricultural or
pastoral activities. Stands of Phragmites are now developing along the gentle
gradients of the north and west shore.
Along the northern shore of the central lake and the two major inflow channels;
here the water is less saline and there are now extensive reed beds, probably an
indication of water that is merely brackish. Areas of emergent vegetation, mainly
Rush Juncus spp, has spread rapidly in the last three years to cover several square
kilometers between the islands of Hamra and Jabbrin in the central lake. The
reedbeds and other emergent vegetation are very important for nesting and
feeding waterbirds.
Southern and western shores of the central lake: overgrazing along the shore-line
led to the disappearance of the native vegetation cover in some areas.
Eastern shore of the central lake: salty west winds result in small dunes and
salinisation of the land, preventing agriculture in a band about 1km wide along the
shore; this land is used mainly for grazing. Sand or ooze formations and the wet
interdunal areas generate unusual habitats and attract birds typical of steppe
environments.The islands: some Bedouin families have traditional grazing rights for
the larger islands , which in spring support large flocks of sheep. Where slopes are
steep, as on the central islands, kingfishers and other hole-nesting birds can find
breeding sites, but the shores are usually bare.
Huge colonies of birds breed on small bare islands or thinly vegetated islands in the
central lake and on small reedy islands in the south-eastern lake.
Southeastern lake: there are reedbeds along the southern shore and the channel
in the south-eastern corner. In December 2005 and March 2006, many of the reeds
appeared dead and waterbird numbers had fallen dramatically, though the reeds
along the channel were still healthy.
“A sabkha is formed in a natural depression, which collects storm flow from the surrounding
areas during winter, and dries out to form a saline-coated layer during the hot summer
period.”
13
Figure5.Salt is an important local natural resource Figure 6. Reedbeds on the peaceful southern shore
of the Jabbul and has been collected for ages. of Hamrat lake.
Figure7.The introduction of irrigation has transformed the agricultural land-use in the northern and
northwestern parts of the Sabkha.
Figure8. Huge colonies of birds breed on s in the Figure9. From Jabbrin island towards Hamra islan
south-eastern lake. across the dyke
14
2-3 An age-old cultural landscape:
The Jabbul ecosystem is characterized by a unique cultural landscape. First of all,
the traditional Syrian hospitality is still very much alive in this region, charming
every visitor who takes time to accept an invitation. The most characteristic feature
of traditional architecture is the local ‘adobe’ or ‘beehive’ houses. These houses
perfectly reflect the resources and needs of this harsh environment. The building
material can be found locally, and the houses are insulated against extreme
temperatures. In the villages with few labor opportunities, handicraft production
by women is common. A typical product of Jabbul village is loofah or vegetable
sponge, which is made from the sponge gourd.
figure10. The traditional dome-shaped mud houses contribute to the unique cultural landscapes around the lake.
15
2-4 The unique biodiversity of Jabbul wetland.
Global important bird biodiversity
Jabbul wetland is a unique and complex salt lake ecosystem, which
encompassesunique species and quantities of bird biodiversity, diverse aquatic and
terrestrial flora, and numerous species of fish and mammals. The strategic location
of Sabkhat al-Jabbul on the African-Eurasian flyways. Global important bird
biodiversity Sabkhat al-Jabbul is a rare ‘hotspot’ for bird biodiversity because of
sheer numbers – The largest number of birds can be observed during the migration
and wintering seasons. Although there are significant variations over the years for
certain locations depending on the water levels and the degree of human
disturbance. From the conservation point of view, the most significant is the
presence of at least six globally threatened or near-threatened bird species* (as
defined by BirdLife International), and the presence of internationally important
numbers of several bird species at Jabbul. They include: the greater flamingo
(Phoenicopterus roseus), Great White Pelican (Pelecanus onocrotalus), Dalmatian
pelican* (Pelecanus crispus), White-headed duck* (Oxyura leucocephala), common
shelduck (Tadorna tadorna), northern shoveler (Anas clypeata), Marbled Duck*
(Marmaronetta angustirostris), ferruginous duck* (Aythya nyroca), greater white-
fronted goose (Anser albifrons) black-necked grebe (Podiceps nigricollis), little stint
(Calidris minuta), greater spotted eagle* (Aquila clanga), and pallid Harrier* (Circus
macrourus). The Iraq babbler.
16
A unique flora adjusted to saline conditions
Along the lakeshores and on the islands, the saline Salorthid soils host more than
50 species of ‘halophytes’ (salt-tolerant plants). Other plant types that can be
observed at Jabbul include ‘xerophytes’ (plants adapted to dry habitat) and
‘hydrophytes’ (water plants). Some important plant species have been found that
were not previously recorded in Syria: shrub-like glasswort (Arthrocnemum
fruticosum), Halopeplis perfoliata and mamoncillo (Aeluropus lagopodoides).
Tamarisk (Tamarix macrocarpa), a tree species previously considered extinct in
Jabbul. Reed-beds of giant reed (Arundo donax) and bulrush (Scirpus littoralis and
Scirpus maritimus). Several of the locally available plant species have beneficial
ecological and (potential) economic uses, such as:
-Ecological functions: The halophyte shorelines are important feeding and resting
areas for a number of bird species, while the reed-beds are crucially important as
safe feeding, breeding and resting areas for a wide range of birds, notably herons,
ducks and typical reed birds. Aquatic plants, such as ruppia (Ruppia maritime),
coontail (Ceratophyllum demersum), and brittle waternymph (Najas minor) can
provide food for many aquatic animals and birds.
-Rehabilitation of soil salinity: Some of thehalophytes such as common glasswort
(Salicornia europeae) and Halopeplisperfoliata can endure high salinity (exceeding
70 dS/m). Some species such as tamarisk (Tamarix macrocarpa and Tamarix
tetragyna), Syrian mesquite (Prosopis farcta), mamoncillo (Aeluropus lagopoides),
and Aeluropus littoralis canbe used for rehabilitating salt-affected soils. Some
species can also be used as Fuel and timber.
-Pollution mitigation: Some aquatic plants such as ruppia (Ruppia maritima),
coontail (Ceratophyllum demersum), bulrush (Scirpus littoralis and Scirpus
maritimus) and brittle waternymph (Najas minor) are very effective in reducing the
level of pollution, such as organic pollutants and heavy metals caused by urban
sewage water and industrial wastes. These plants reduce the heavy metal
concentrations in sediment by selective absorption in their plant material. However,
when the concentrations of heavy metals in the plants become too high, they can
be poisonous to animals.
17
Table 1. Assessment of some type of plant compositions in Jaboul lake
18
2.5 What is the value of the Jabbul ecosystem?
Table 2. The actual and potential benefits from Jabbul ecosystem and its
beneficiaries.
Jaboul Intrinsic value' Local Syrian society International
Ecosystem (uniqueness) communities community
resources
Land and Abundant Food and Agricultural Agro-tourism
water water is a rare income products Carbon
resources asset in dry Employment Research sequestration
areas from
agriculture
Healthy living
environment
Jabbul salt Famous Income Raw product Salt-tourism
'Jabbul salt' Employment for industrial
Sense of place use Salt-
tourism
Research
Birds Unique bird Income from Environmental Eco-tourism
biodiversity eco-tourism awareness & Research
education
Eco-tourism
Fish Unique fish Research Research Research
population
adapted
to brackish
water
Flora Unique Forage Medical Eco-tourism
halophyte Medicinal and plant& edible plants
population edible plants Environmental Research
awareness & carbon
education sequestration
Research
Reedbeds Vast Water Clean water Eco-tourism
'reedscapes purification fish Eco-tourism Research
propagation Carbon sequestration
19
Scenic Unique Relaxation and Relaxation Relaxation
landscapes wetland inspiration and and
landscape in 'Sense of place' inspiration inspiration
dry areas Income from
eco-tourism
Local culture, Rich history Income from Cultural Cultural
handicrafts and and culture Cultural tourism tourism
historic sites
tourism
20
• Agriculture, forestry, fisheries, mining and gravel extraction.
• Any geographically-focused legislation which might help in managing the area.
• Activities of other statutory bodies, utilities and public service providers,
especially infrastructure development and rural livelihood improvement pro-
grammes.
21
• A ban on pesticides with high adverse effects on the environment and human
health
• A ban on new solid waste dumps in the Jabbul basin
• Rules to protect reed-beds
• A ban on the introduction of exotic fish species Socioeconomic development
• Design an environment-friendly poverty-reduction strategy for remote areas
Promotion of sustainable intensification and diversification options for irrigated
and rainfed agriculture.
• Farmers with valuable local environmental knowledge hired as rangers and
guides for eco-tourists.
• Stimulation of (in) formal women's groups, e.g. handicraft production and
commercialization.
• Basic infrastructure for the (south)-eastern side of the Sabkha, e.g. drinking water
and a weatherproof bridge at the Hamrat outlet.
• Solution found for land inundations at the south-west of the Salt lake.
• Official registration of all villages on city council maps.
Example Use of biomanipulation
A technique known as biomanipulation has been used to further the establishment
of clear water. This technique involves the temporary removal of planktivorous fish
to one side of an artificial barrier. Numbers of zooplankton on the other side of the
barrier build up with the predation pressure removed. Zooplankton, particularly
water fleas Daphnia sp., graze algae, so promoting improved light conditions within
the water and encouraging aquatic plant growth. Experiments using giant ‘cobweb’
brushes, acting as artificial plants, have shown that providing predatorfree refuges
for zooplankton enhances the return to clear water and establishment of aquatic
macrophyte communities.
22
CHAPTER 3- A CASE STUDY OF ENVIRONMENTAL AREA MADE
BY HUMEN (SEA ENVIRONMENTAL GARDEN-SYRIA)
2-1 Background study
Damascus, capital of Syria. Located in the southwestern corner of the country,
Damascus is widely believed to be the
oldest continuously inhabited city in
the world, with evidence of habitation
dating back at least 11,000 years. Its
location and persistence have made
the city a nexus for civilizations come
and gone. Today its metropolitan area
is home to about 2.5 million people.
23
Figure 15. Paintings show the charechter of Damascus
24
Figure 16. Beautiful hotel open to the sky Filled with Figure 17.can see jasmine in old roads in
fragrant jasmine and other plants Damascus
Figure 18. Garden of Damascus National Museum Figure 19. Beautiful traditional old Damascus
Umayyad Castle Gate courtyard house open to the sky Filled with
fragrant jasmine and other plants
25
jasmine is a small tree belonging to the olive family, and reaches a length of several
meters. It always blooms from April and continues until November.
Jasmine flowers are an essential raw material in the famous perfume industry,
while its health value is high when treating widespread diseases and pain due to its
multiple medicinal properties.And jasmine oil is an expensive essential oil.
26
Figure 20. The center of the garden
The park consisting of thirty islands with stunning views, each of them contains a
special type of plants, including: "Shadow Plants Island, Rocky Plants Island, Old
Ornamental Island, Forest Island, Water Island, Ghouta Crops Islands, Fruit Tree
Island," and many others. The garden center has the main seating area, where
wooden seats are distributed to allow the visitor to see the river and the whole
park, which has an ambitious goal that combines the environmental, educational
and recreational functions for the neighborhood and a cultural landmark for visitors.
For the sub-corridors designed to divide the place into small islands each island
planted with several varieties of one species.
27
Figure 20. One of the corridors in the garden
Plants and their compositions in the park are the most important visual elements
of the park designs especially regarding seasonal changes. Accessibility, design,
maintenance and plant richness and distribution affected the health-related
attributes and aesthetic value of the space.
Table3. Assessment of some plant compositions in the garden
Plant compositions
The mixture of hot colours ( red,
yellow,orange) add warmth to a scene,
can be seen from the park café and
enjoy the beautiful view specially in
sunlight.
28
Good appeal viewed from the castle
and the river. there is no formal effect
in eye level except background trees
29
2-3 Constrains of the site
For anyone walking in the ancient streets of the Levant to hear the footprints of a
bell that will not be heard before in the world, as it passes through the western wall
of "Damascus" castle near many historical, civilizational and cultural monuments in
"Damascus", he finds a museum of flowers that recreates the chapters of the
ancient history of "Damascus".
Wadi Barda is considered one of the most important summer resorts of the
Damascene family, because of its shades and cool air, in addition to its great river.
30
The campuses of the two branches of the river
that pass in the garden in the past are orchards,
and there was a café on its end.
With the urban development, the area turned
into a dump, and then it turned into a garage,
here came the idea of the association The Syrian
Environment, by converting this landfill into an
environmental garden, combining all the
acclimated plant balance with the Damascene Figure 22. the area before the
garden was a dump
environment.
31
2-5 Conservation from urban landscape identity
32
CHAPTER 4- CONCLOSION
Inspired by the ecological wisdom underlying the environmental practices in Syria
this report proposes and verifies the Human-Natural Intergraded Ecological
Planning, Learning that:
- Ecological wisdom is the key of ecological practice; it enables a person, a
community or an organization to make ethical judgement and take
circumspect actions in particular circumstances of ecological practice.
- If wetland conservation and local development can be combined in an
effective way, Sabkhat al-Jabbul could easily become a “Syrian success story
in the Middle East”.
- The importance of the green public areas based on their social, cultural,
environmental and economic values, in addition to the use of the vegetation
cover, different types of trees, and water features, beside the art workings
and constructions which enhance the identity of the place and the culture of
the societies.
- Plants should be assessed according to not only species and composition, but
also functional characteristics in contributing urban landscape and human
life quality.
- According to space-mass analysis, as trees and native plants increase in the
composition, mass effect also increases in visual value of the planting
composition.
33
REFERENCES
- Al Nimeh M. (1997). Ramsar information sheet on Sabkhat al-Jabbul Nature
Reserve. http://www.wetlands.org/rsis/
- D’Altan P. (2007). Dynamics of Sabkhat al-Jabbul gleaned from satellite
imagery and maps. Iinternal research document. ICARDA, Aleppo, Syria.
- Wetland Inspection Division (undated). National strategic and operational
framework for man aging Uganda wetlands: Policy, legislation and action
plan. Wetland Inspection Division, Uganda Ministry of Water, Lands and
Environment, Kampala, Uganda.
- N. KABISCH, S. QURESHI, D. HAASE:. Human–Environment Interactions in
Urban Green Spaces. A Systematic Review of Contemporary Issues and
Prospects for Future Research. Environ Impact Assess Rev, 50, 25 (2015).
- Innovative Approaches to Socio-Ecological Sustainability
http://www.springer.com/series/15217
- Wang X, Xiang W-N (2016) Ecological wisdom for urban sustainability: doing
real and permanent good in ecological practice. Landscape Urban Plann
155:1–2
- H. NORDH, K. OSTBY: Pocket Parks for People. A Study of Park Design and
Use. Urban for Urban Gree, 2 , 12 (2013).
- Country Environmental Profile Syrian Arab Republic – Max Kasparek &
Marwan Dimashki April 2009.
- USAID (2000). Environmental education and communication for a
sustainable world, Handbook for international practitioners. Washington, DC,
USA.
34
35