Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Counteracting Stereotypes
With Young Children
How do young children’s experiences with gender biases affect their Olaiya E. Aina and
development and opportunities for leading successful lives? What can Petronella A. Cameron
teachers do to counteract these stereotypes?
for shopping.
Media portrayals also reinforce ste-
reotypes. Advertising about comput-
ers typically depicted men and boys
as competent users, engaged in active
Stereotypes and sexism limit potential growth and development because internalizing
or professional roles, while women
negative stereotypes impacts self-esteem and ultimately, academic performance.
and girls were passive observers or
merely posed next to the computer
non-traditional images of women (Martin & Ruble, 2004), which
while looking pretty or provocative
as portrayed in books. Children as involves the creation of organized
(McNair, Kirova-Petrova, & Bhar-
young as 5 were able to use outside structures of knowledge that influ-
gava, 2001). In several European
knowledge or assumptions to recon- ence thinking and behavior.
countries, television advertising
cile ideas that conflicted with their An alternative, but supplemen- to children is restricted or banned
world view (Jackson, 2007). They tal view of gender development, is (Mitchener, 2001).
rationalized and used “probably” that of gender as a social construct.
statements to explain how they came Movies convey particularly pow-
Through imaginative play, children
to their conclusions, with or without erful messages about gender roles
explore and understand gender
the use of stereotypes. This research and stereotyping (Derman-Sparks,
roles (Chick, Heilman-Houser, &
supports Gender-Schema Theory 2001). Considering the brand
Hunter, 2002). After children can
strength and saturation of a mul- understand important social issues, children that are neither gender-fair
timedia company such as Disney, such as those of gender, but also nor gender-congruent (Hyun, 2001).
children are particularly susceptible. what they think about themselves Males demand and receive more
Researchers examined the influ- and others. Korean immigrant girls attention from their teachers and
ence of Disney images of women and perceived that a woman could not therefore receive more specific,
marriage on the perceptions of young be President of the United States instructive feedback from teach-
Korean immigrant girls. These girls because a classroom poster depicted ers (Erden & Wolfgang, 2004). In
reported a resigned acceptance to the all male presidents (Lee, 2008). comparison, females become less
portrayal of princesses having to face demanding of the teacher’s atten-
external obstacles to marriage, such as tion; that results in lower levels of
family approval or laws, while princes Teachers have achievement and self-esteem, which
could marry according to their own
will (Lee, 2008). These researchers
tremendous therefore limits their career goals
to more traditional, nurturing, and
also noted that the girls associated influence on ideas often lower-paying careers. Males do
desirability for a princess with one not escape the gender bias, however,
attribute, such as beauty or a singing about gender as they are subject to conforming to
voice, whereas princes were desired
for their courage, chivalry, or actions
significance. male stereotypes and experience less
nurturing behavior (Zaman, 2007).
(Lee, 2008). Combined with a tradi- Every day, teaching may occur in
tion of female subservience in Korean Teachers have tremendous influ- curriculum areas where positive or
culture, these young girls appeared to ence on how children develop ideas negative stereotypes can affect chil-
accept their disenfranchisement. of gender and gender significance. dren’s concepts of self-competence
Early childhood education Traditional caregivers typically (Ebach, et al., 2009). One study found
The role of schools has become reinforced gender- stereotyped traits that 80% of the observed teachers
more prominent in the lives of when they praised girls for their discouraged preschool girls from using
children younger than 5 years of age clothing, hairstyles, neatness, and computers by their words and attitudes
(Sales, Spjeldnes, & Koeshe, 2010). helping behaviors, and in contrast (McNair, Kirova-Petrova, & Bhargava,
Many children spend up to 10 hours praised boys for their strength, physi- 2001). This stereotyping may contrib-
a day in child care (Grafwallner, cal skill, size, and academic accom- ute to young girls’ inabilities to be-
Fontaine, Torre, & Underhill, 2006). plishments (Chick, Heilman-Houser come competent users of technology.
Two main aspects of the early child- & Hunter, 2002). These teachers Friends
hood environment influence percep- used “honey” and “sweetie” to ad- Children also have been shown
tions of young children’s gender and dress girls, but said “you guys” when to actively create gender identities
gender stereotypes: speaking to the entire class (Chick,
Heilman-Houser & Hunter, 2002). through interactions with each other
• classroom materials and (Thorne, 1993). Friendship pat-
• the instruction of teachers While unintentional, a teacher’s terns and peer pressure contribute
(Gee & Gee, 2005). inherent biases can perpetuate un- to gender stereotypes, especially
fair stereotypes and may be mani- among boys, who have the tendency
Several gender inequities were fested in discriminatory classroom
found in one preschool, the most to self-police peers, ridiculing those
practices. For example, one group who show feminine traits (Morrow,
obvious being the proliferation of of teachers perceived girls as passive
gender-typed toys, such as pink 2006). Children’s gender-typed toy
learners and therefore more “teach- preferences are more likely to be
kitchen sets. Further scrutiny re- able” than boys (Erden & Wolf-
vealed a large proportion of books exhibited when in the proximity of
gang, 2004). Similarly, classroom peers who approve of the gender-
in the library that showed gender management techniques may re-
bias of some kind (Chick, Heilman- ward obedience versus assertiveness, typed choices (Hughes, 2003).
Houser, & Hunter, 2002). which puts highly active children Family
The classroom environment can at a disadvantage. A teacher’s stereo- In addition to role modeling,
affect not only how young children types may lead to interactions with families influence gender learning
undervalue the importance of their time in housekeeping and only 2% • When asked, 64% of parents
lives if they are unable to identify in the block area. By combining the said they would buy their son a
with characters in books. Images or spaces and creating a gender-neutral doll, 84% would not get upset
characters in books can create posi- play area, the researchers observed an seeing their son wearing a
tive or negative emotions in young 8% increase in housekeeping play by dress in the dramatic play area,
children, and when children under- the boys and a 9% increase in block and 92% did not think ballet
stand their peers’ cultural traditions play by the girls. lessons for a boy would be a
that are more likely to form a more As noted earlier, children apply mistake.
positive perspective of themselves gender stereotypes to toys by the
and others (Nahl & Bilal, 2007). This study revealed a large discrep-
time they are 3 (Freeman, 2007). ancy between the attitudes that par-
In a study conducted with moth- ents publicly profess and the subtle
Consequences of ers and fathers of 3- to 5-year-old messages that their children perceive
Gender Stereotyping children, children’s perceptions of (Freeman, 2007).
parental approval were found out of
Activity Choice alignment with the parents’ self-
described attitudes. Career Aspirations
Young children often reveal their
gender stereotyping in their play. • Parents demonstrated mark- Occupation is a major signal of self
During dramatic play, preschool edly non-stereotyped attitudes identity. Gottfredson (2004) pro-
females are more likely to choose on parent questionnaires about posed that career aspirations origi-
family roles, while males are more how they would react to their nate in the preschool years, and that
likely to choose adventure or action- children’s cross-gender play. projecting a concept of a future self
oriented roles, such as superheroes • The children themselves indi- can be seen as an attempt to present
(Hughes, 2003). cated that their parents would an existing self-image.
In another study, before interven- not approve of most cross- In a study examining career aspira-
tion, males spent 25% of their time gender play, especially for the tions of 4- and 5-year-old children,
in block play versus 2% in house- boys, who thought their fathers researchers coded participants’
keeping areas (Unger, 1981). Fe- would approve of cross-gender responses by categorizing occupa-
males, however, spent 10% of their choices only 9% of the time. tions as female, male, or neutral,
based on the national statistics for
that occupation (Care, Denas, &
Brown, 2007). They also considered
the occupation of the parents. These
researchers found that
• there was an early bias associ-
ated with identifying with the
same-gender adult.
• males aspired to more gender-
typed fields than girls, who
chose evenly among tradition-
ally male, female, and neutral
Subjects & Predicates
occupations.
• when asked to nominate jobs
that they would not want,
both girls and boys rejected
more traditionally female occu-
pations than male and neutral
Skilled teachers encourage cross-gender activities and play in cross-gender careers.
centers. Positively reinforce children who are playing with non-stereotyped toys
by talking with them and supporting their learning.
in creative and language arts behavior and the educational materi- • the separation may suggest
(Derman-Sparks, 2001). als they use may hinder equitable gender equity is a sidebar for
learning in their classrooms. students to the real work of
Skilled teachers encourage education.
cross-gender activities and play in In addition, a common miscon-
cross-gender centers. They can also ception of preservice teachers is The content of textbooks and
positively reinforce children who are that only students, not teachers, are instructional materials throughout
playing with non-stereotyped toys responsible for bias in classroom in- teacher education courses is critical
by talking with them and supporting teractions. Novice teachers may enter because of its potential to reduce or,
their learning. the profession without the skills to through omission and stereotyping,
make changes in four key areas: reinforce biased attitudes and behav-
Families • school curriculum, iors (Sadker, et al., 2007).
Gender differentiation and iden- • interaction patterns,
tity construction begins at home, • pedagogical strategies, and
Roles of Administrators
in that familial practices are often
profoundly gendered in terms of • use of resources. Administrators are urged to
relationships and roles (Morrow, establish an ongoing process of
2006). Teachers can help inform introspection and evaluation to help
families of children by Prepare teachers to teachers consider how they relate
to genders differently. Teachers can
• demonstrating unbiased inter-
actions and communication,
promote equitable then monitor their language and
and teaching. actions in order to eliminate inad-
vertently biased messages.
• providing coaching and
Administrators are also advised
encouragement, while
It is imperative to prepare novice to consider the consequences of
• respecting cultural differences teachers to recognize gender issues hiring an all-female staff. Program
without judgment or and promote equitable teaching structure should also allow for the
condescension. (Fulmer, 2010). Teacher educa- maintenance of group gender bal-
Family workshops and information tors themselves must be committed ance to facilitate opportunities for
about the long-term effects of gender to teaching students about gender male/female interaction (Robeson,
bias can also increase the awareness issues. If only a few teacher educa- Marshall, & Keefe, 2003). Addition-
and critical thinking about ways that tors in an institution address gender ally, administrators can coordinate
families communicate gender stereo- issues, preservice teachers receive in-service opportunities for families
types to children (Small, 2003). mixed messages about their im- and professional development in the
portance. The curriculum in high- areas of anti-bias curriculum and
quality teacher education programs neutralizing gender stereotypes in
Implications for incorporates gender issues. young children.
Teacher Education Although making gender issues
a required course may seem like a Conclusions
Teachers play a critical role in pro- viable approach, Geist and King
moting equitable learning. Findings (2008) argue that it is problematic The power of self-concept is pro-
from national surveys in the U.S. for three reasons: found, as is the ability of adults to
suggest that prospective teachers influence the children around them.
receive little or no teacher prepara- • few programs have available
Families and teachers are encouraged
tion about equity, perhaps due to space;
to conscientiously and actively cre-
competing requirements in limited • a separate course may leave ate a positive learning environment
time (Langford, 2006; Sadker, et important gender dimensions for young children—not just in
al., 2007; Sandholtz & Sandholtz, out of educational founda- promoting developmentally appro-
2010). Consequently, new teach- tions, methods courses, and priate practices to stimulate cogni-
ers are often unaware of how their field experience; and tive, social, emotional, and physical
domains, but also in creating a moral Fiese, B., & Skillman, G. (2000). Gender differ- McNair, S., Kirova-Petrova, A., & Bhargava, A.
ences in family stories: Moderating influence of (2001). Computers and young children in the
context for what they learn, as well parent gender role and child gender. Sex Roles: A classroom: Strategies for minimizing gender bias.
as to help shape a global, multicul- Journal of Research, 43, 267-83. ERIC Document Early Childhood Education Journal, 29(1), 51-55.
Reproduction Service No. EJ620839 Mitchener, B. (2001, May 29). Sweden pushes its
tural, anti-bias world view. Freeman, N. (2007). Preschoolers’ perceptions of ban on children’s ads. Wall Street Journal. Retrieved
Young children create and inter- gender-appropriate toys and their parents’ beliefs from http://www.commondreams.org/head-
about genderized behaviors: Miscommunication, lines01/0529-05.htm
nalize their own meanings of gen- mixed messages, or hidden truths? Early Childhood Morrow, V. (2006). Understanding gender differ-
der, based on the social cues of the Education Journal, 34(5), 357-366. ences in context: Implications for young children’s
Fulmer, C.L. (2010). Unpacking evidence of gender everyday lives. Children & Society, 20(2), 92-104.
adults, environments, and media bias. Journal of Women in Educational Leadership, Nahl, D., & Balal, D. (2007). Information and emo-
around them. Adults in turn have a 8(2), 81-97. tion: The emergent affective paradigm in informa-
responsibility to ensure that those Gee, B., & Gee, J. (2005). Seeing learning in tradi- tion behavior research and theory. Medford, NJ:
tional classroom settings. Great Britain: Cromwell Information Today.
cues and messages create a healthy Press. Narahara, M. (1998). Gender stereotypes in chil-
understanding of what it means Geist, E.A., & King, M. (2008). Different, not dren’s picture books. ERIC Document Reproduc-
better: Gender differences in mathematics learning tion Service No. ED419248
to be male and female (Derman- and achievement. Journal of Instructional Psychol- Neuville, E., & Croizet, J. (2007). Can salience of
Sparks, 2001). ogy, 35(1): 43-52. gender identity impair math performance among
Gottfredson, L. (2004). Intelligence: Is it the 7- to 8-years old girls? The moderating role of task
By equipping young children with epidemiologist-elusive fundamental cuase of social difficulty. European Journal of Psychology of Educa-
positive messages of empowerment class inequities in health? Journal of Personality & tion, 22(3), 307-316.
Social Psychology, 86: 174-179. Piaget, J. (1961). The child’s conception of number.
regardless of gender, in addition to Grafwallner, R., Fontaine, N.S., Torre, L.D., & Un- New York: Norton.
the critical thinking skills to identify derhill, B. (2006). Increasing quality in early care Robeson, W.W., Marshall, N.L., & Keefe, N.
and learning environments. Early Child Develop- (1999). Gender equity in early childhood educa-
stereotypes, teachers and families ment and Care, 176(2), 157-169. tion. Young Children, 54(4), 9-13.
can impart in children self-concept Hendrix, K.G., & Wei, F.F. (2009 ). Gender differ- Sadker, M., & Sadker, D. (1994). Failing at fair-
resiliency, even when faced with ences in preschool children’s recall of competitive ness: How America’s schools cheat girls. New York:
and noncompetitive computer mathematics games. Scribner’s.
negative stereotypes (Small, 2003). Learning, Media and Technology, 34(1), 27-43. Sadker, D., Zittleman, K., Earley, P., McCormick,
Those children will then be less likely Hughes, F. (2003). Sensitivity to the social and T., Strawn, C., & Preston, J. (2007). The treat-
cultural context of the play of young children. In ment of gender equity in teacher education. In
to perpetuate the stereotypes and can J. Isenberg & M. Jalongo (Eds.), Major trends and S. Klein (Ed.), The handbook for achieving gender
help end the cycle of prejudice. issues in early childhood education (pp. 126-133). equity through education (2nd ed.) (pp. 131–150).
New York: Teachers College Press. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Hyun, E. (2001). Gender-fair and gender-congru- Sales, E., Spjeldnes, S., & Koeshe, G. (2010).
References ent practices for young children’s naturalist intel- Teacher support as a buffer between interparental
ligence: From the perspective of developmentally conflict and child social skills. Early Childhood
and culturally appropriate practice (DCAP). ERIC Development and Care, 180(3), 335-346.
Blumberg, R.L. (2008). The invisible obstacle to
Document Reproduction Service No. ED458944 Saltmarsh, S. (2009). Becoming economic subjects:
educational equality: Gender bias in textbooks.
Jackson, S. (2007). She might not have the right Agency, consumption and popular culture in early
Prospects, 38(3): 345–361.
tools... and he does: Children’s sense-making of childhood. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics
Care, E., Denas, J., & Brown, R. (2007). The real-
gender, work and abilities in early school readers. of Education, 30(1), 47-59.
ism and sex type of four- to five-year-old children’s
Gender and Education, 19(1), 61-77. Sandholtz, S.H., & Sandholtz, J.H. (2010).
occupational aspirations. Journal of Early Child-
Keefe, N., Marshall, N.L., & Robeson, W.W. Confronting gender issues in a novice teacher’s
hood Research, 5(2), 155-168.
(2003). Gender equity in early childhood educa- classroom: Student and parent/teacher educator
Carlson, E.A., Egeland, B., & Sroufe, A. (2004).
tion. In C. Copple (Ed.), A world of difference (pp. perspectives. The New Educator, 6(2), 118-34.
The construction of experience: A longitudinal
109-113). Washington DC: National Association Small, S. (2003). Gender learning in early child-
study of representation and behavior. Child Devel-
for the Education of Young Children. hood. In C. Copple (ed.), A world of difference,
opment, 75(1), 66-83.
Kohlberg, L. (1981) Essays in moral development. (pp. 114-115). Washington DC: National Associa-
Chick, K., Heilman-Houser, R., & Hunter, M.
San Francisco: Harper & Row. tion for the Education of Young Children.
(2002). The impact of child care on gender role
Langford, R. (2006). Discourses of the good early Thorne, B. (1993). Gender play: Boys and girls in
development and gender stereotypes. Early
childhood educator in professional training: school. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University
Childhood Education Journal, 29(3), 149-54.
Reproducing marginality or working toward social Press.
Derman-Sparks, L. (2001). Anti-bias curriculum:
change. International Journal of Educational Policy, Timmerman, G., & Schreuder, P. (2008). Pedagogi-
Tools for empowering young children. Washington
Research, & Practice, 7, 115-125. cal professionalism and gender in daycare. Gender
DC: National Association for the Education of
Leaper, C. (2000). Gender, affiliation, assertion, and Education, 20(1), 1–14.
Young Children.
and the interactive context of parent-child play. Tsao, Y.L. (2008). Gender issues in young children’s
Ebach, J., Endepohls-Ulpe, M., Ikone, P., Rasinen,
Developmental Psychology, 36(3), 381-393. literature. Reading Improvement, 45(3), 1-20.
A., Virtanen, S., & Zabern, J.S. (2009). Technol-
Lee, L. (2008). Understanding gender through Unger, R.K. (1981). Sex as a social reality: Field
ogy education for children in primary schools in
Disney’s marriages: A study of young Korean im- laboratory research. Psychology of Women Quarterly,
Finland and Germany: Different school systems,
migrant girls. Early Childhood Education Journal, 5(4), 645-653.
similar problems and how to overcome them.
36(1), 11-18. Vygotsky, L. (1961). The development of scientific
Technology Des Education, 19: 367-379.
Martin, C., & Ruble, D. (2004). Children’s search concepts in childhood. In K. Paciorek, & J. Munro
Erden, F., & Wolfang, C.H. (2004). An exploration
for gender cues: Cognitive perspectives on gender (Eds.), Sources: Notable selections in early childhood
of the differences in prekindergarten, kindergarten,
development. Current Directions in Psychological education (pp. 11-18). Guilford, CT: Dushkin/
and first grade teachers’ beliefs related to discipline
Science, 13(2), 67-70. McGraw-Hill.
when dealing with male and female students. Early
Child Development and Care, 174(1), 3-11.
Walker, S. (2005). Gender differences in the Angeles. Aina is a former teacher and Aina at California State University, Los
relationship between young children’s peer-related
social competence and individual differences in
an administrator from K-12 both in Angeles. In addition to teaching pre-
theory of mind. The Journal of Genetic Psychology, Nigeria and Canada. He teaches gradu- school through grade 2 for several years,
166(3), 297-312. ate and undergraduate courses in early she participated in an early childhood
Zaman, A. (2007). Gender-sensitive teaching: A childhood education and coordinates teaching internship program at La Verne
refective approach for early childhood education
teacher training programs. American Association of the Master’s Program. Aina is author of University in California.
Colleges for Teacher Education, 129(1), 110-118. several children’s storybooks and articles.
He is also a storyteller.
If you’re a SECA member, you’ll find more
About the Authors Petronella A. Cameron, Ph.D., is an resources and information about this topic
Early Childhood Consultant and Assis- in Dimensions Extra. Go to the “members-
Olaiya E. Aina, Ph.D., is a Professor tant Professor and Program Director in only” page of the SECA website to get the
of Early Childhood Education in the Early Childhood Education at Central latest issue.
Division of Curriculum and Instruc- State University, Wilberforce, Ohio. She
tion at California State University, Los was a graduate teaching assistant for
Amazing Grace
written by Mary Hoffman and illustrated by Caroline Binch.
(1991). New York: Dial Books for Young Children.
Grace loves to read and act out stories she has heard. When Grace’s class
decides to perform the play Peter Pan, she knows exactly the role she wants
to play—Peter. Her friends tell her she can’t be Peter because she’s not a boy
and she is Black. Her grandmother reminds her she can be anything she
wants if she puts her mind to it. After Grace’s grandmother takes her to a
ballet starring a young woman from Trinidad, Grace practices dancing in
her imaginary tutu just like Juliet. When her classmates see her audition for
the play, they know she is the perfect Peter. The play is a fantastic success!
Ages: Preschool through second grade
Teaching concepts: self concept, families, storytelling, occupations
A
glue their drawings (or cut-outs) of favorite
story characters to the stick. Children refer to books, such bc stems, children complete a sentence such as
as Three Billy Goats Gruff, Anansi the Spider, Amazing “I can…” or “I want to…” using invented
Grace, Brown Bear Brown Bear, and We’re Going on a Bear spelling or dictations for an adult to write.
Hunt for story sequence or character roles. After children illustrate their sentences, they assemble
and bind them into a book to place in the book center.
MUSIC & MOVEMENT: Using patterned
sentence stems, children complete a sentence LITERACY: Select books representing in-
such as “I can…” or “I want to…” using
invented spelling or dictations for an adult
to write. After children illustrate their sentences, they
A bc dividuals in a variety of work situations and
from a variety of ethnic and gender groups
that illustrate how individuals live into
assemble and bind them into a book to place in the book their dreams by working hard and never giving up, such
center. as Mirette on the High Wire, Miss Rumphius, Sam Johnson
and the Blue Ribbon Quilt, Lady Bug Girl, More Than
Anything Else, Amelia & Eleanor Go for a Ride, Snowflake
Bentley, Martin’s Big Words, and Art From Her Heart.
Tracy Anne Jones, Ed.D., is the Manager of Provider Engagement at Collaborative for Children, a non-profit
agency dedicated to building a strong educational foundation for young children.