Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Ionization Constant of Carbonic Acid in Water and the Solubility of Carbon
Dioxide in Water and Aqueous Salt Solutions from 0 to 50'
S . HARNEDAND RAYMOND
BY HERBERT DAVIS,
JR.'
As the ionic concentration decreases, the logarith- clear passage to the atmosphere through the bent capillary
mic term containing YHYCI/*IHYHCO, approaches exit tube. By this construction the total pressure inside
zero, Consequently to determine (-log K),the
+
the cell, Pco, P H , was
~ , equal to the barometric pressure
and the capillary tube prevented air from entering the cell.
experimental quantities on the right are extra- By attaching a small water manometer t o one of thf: elec-
polated to infinite dilution of electrolyte. How- trode stacks, i t was found that the pressure in B while
ever, this extrapolation is not to pure water but passing the gas a t the rate of a bubble every two seconds
to a solution containing carbon dioxide of molality was less than 0.05 mm. of mercury greater than atmos-
pheric. The entire cell was mounted on a motor driven
mca. We have carried out measurements a t rocker which seemed to keep the surface of the solution
enough concentrations (pressures) of carbon di- constantly agitated, facilitating the attainment of equi-
oxide to permit the extrapolation to zero concen- librium. I n determining the solubility of gases it is im-
tration of this substance. portant not t o introduce the gas too far under the solution
In order to determine the ionization, mH- because the additional hydrostatic pressure on the gas
bubble tends t o dissolve a greater quantity of gas than
mHCO,/mCa,and the activity coefficient product corresponds to the observed pressure. I n the present
YHYHCOI/YCOr, in salt solutions, equation (4) apparatus the bubbler is so little below the surface that any
may be rearranged to the suitable form supersaturation thus caused is entirely negligible. The
bubbler seems to agitate the solution and permits at a
glance the estimation of the rate a t which the gas is pass-
ing through the cell.
the upper stopcock. The vacuum line was attached to the of the titrations in the presence of barium carbonate were
'I%-stopcock and by just opening this stopcock a small sensitive to one drop or approximately 0.05 g. of barium
amount of carbon dioxide saturated solution was drawn hydroxide solution. At high sodium chloride concentra-
through the long stem of the sampler as a rinse. Then by tions, the carbonic acid solution (90 cc.) titrated was ap-
proper adjustment of the T-stopcock about 90 cc. of the proximately 0.01 M and about 10,g. of barium hydroxide
saturated solution was drawn into the bulb. During this solution was required for neutralization. Under these
operation the gas was allowed to flow somewhat faster in conditions, the titrations would be expected to have a
order to replace the volume of the liquid removed and to precision of 0.5%. Since more solution was titrated a t
assure a constant pressure of carbon dioxide in the gas lower salt concentrations the accuracy in this region was
phase during sampling. Preliminary experiments showed greater than this. At best the reproducibility of this
that this procedure was necessary and that i t eliminated determination of the solubility was of the order of 0.2%
the error caused by escape of gas from the solution. The while a t high temperatures and salt concentrations the
sampler was then removed from the cell and the stem was average error was approximately 1%.
rinsed with water and dried with an air current. The
vacuum in the sampler was relieved with oxygen and the
Experimental Results
entire sampler reweighed. From this weight, the weights The observed Henry's law constants are re-
of empty sampler and the barium hydroxide solution, the corded in Table I. Series A represents the
weight of the carbon dioxide solution was computed. mean of four simultaneous measurements of
After vigorous shaking, the excess of barium hydroxide
was determined by weight titration with 0.2 M hydro-
carbon dioxide in water. In addition, this series
chloric acid. comprises single observations of the solubility in
Discussion of Errors.--The cylinder carbon dioxide was 0.2, 0.5, 1 , 2 , and 3 M sodium chloride solutions.
malyzerl by means of an apparatus described by NacInties Both of these series covered the entire tempera-
and Shedlovsky6and illustrated by Fig. 2 of their article. ture range, Series B represents the mean of
':'his material was found to be 99.67 =t0,05yo pure carbon
dioxide. All subsequent computations were based on three experiments a t each temperature on each
this analysis. salt concentration recorded. Series C : the
results of series A and B were plotted on a large
scale and all results in doubt redetermined. Most
of the first discrepancies occurred a t higher con-
centrations of salt a t high temperatures and there-
fore the results in series C were obtained in this
:- ............. L
region. They represent the mean of triplicate
determinations. The starred values were not
given as great a weight as the unstarred values
in the final graphical estimation of S.
Large scale plots of (-log S ) z m w s molality
of sodium chloride were made. Greater weight
was given to the results of series B and C for the
salt solutions. For pure water, the values in
series X and B agreed closely a t all temperatures.
. . . . . . ..
.
..
..
.
..
L ................. The smoothed values of (-log S ) obtained from
these graphs are given in Table 11.
The solubility data can be expressed as a func-
tion of the absolute temperature by
(1 0 01 i J 0 2 0 03 0.04 ( J . c J j 0.06 0 07
- logs = -
1'
--
il *
+ D * - C'7' (81
TABLE I
HENRY'S IN WATER AND SODIUM CHLORIDE SOLUTIONS; s
LAWCONSTANTS FOR CARBON DIOXIDE ??lco,/Pco.
1 Series Water 0.2 M NaCl 0.6 M NaCl 1 M NaCl 2 M NaCl 8 M Na&
0 A 0.07726 0.07256 0.06708 0.05869 0.04608 0.03695
B .07676 ..... .06642 .05895 .04597 .03718
5 A .06402 .06099 .05593 .04932 .03910 ,03166
10 A .05359 .05096 .04714 ,04160 .03339 .02716
B .05367 ..... ...... .04156 ...... .02729
15 A .04554 .04330 .04009 .03550 ,02886 ,02381
20 A .03923 .03725 .03450 .03085 .02504 ,02071
B .03928 ..... ...... ...... ...... .02086
25 A .03438 .03278 .03054 .02707 .02223 .01810*
B ,03458 ..... ,03036 .02668* .02227 .01844
C ..... ..... ...... .02734 ,02242 ,01847
30 A ,03026 .02861 .02674 .02407 .01971 ,01658
B .03021 ..... .02588* .02418 .01927* .01688*
C ..... ..... ...... ... . . . . .01965 ,01655
35 A .02678 .02553 .02388 .02108* .01763 ,01488
C ..... ..... ...... .02167 .01778 ,01488
40 A .02407 .02289 .02141 .01913 .01566 ......
B .02407 ..... .02188* .01922 .01629* .01372*
C ..... ..... ...... ...... .01575 ,01344
45 A ,02192 .02084 ,01955 ,01752 .01492 .01212
C ..... ..... ...... .01743 .01441 .01216
50 A .01982 .01897 .01753 .01597 .01317 ,01093
B .01969 ..... .01765 .01559* .01330 ,01145'
C ..... ..... ...... .,.... .01317 ,01099
TABLEI1
VALUESOF ( - LOGS). DEVIATIONS
SMOOTHED (OBS. - CALCD.)"
Water 0.2 M 0.5 M 1M 2M 3M
0 1.1144(+4) 1.1383(+2) 1.1738(0) 1.2313(-4) 1.3365(-8) 1,4290(-24)
5 1.1938(-10) 1.2167(-14) 1.2510(--18) 1.3065(+17) 1.4077( 14) - 1.4980( -8)
10 1.2695( -5) 1.2920( -5) 1.3259( -3) 1.3800( -4) 1.4768( +4) +
1.5642( 17)
15 1.3412(+13) 1.3638(+20) 1.3970(+25) 1.4482(-20) 1.5422( +27) 1.6255(+29)
20 1.M63(+15) 1.4285(+25) 1.4605($-8) 1.5110(+28) 1.6012($25) 1.6822( +29)
25 1.4635(-16) 1.4842(+16) 1.5152( -18) 1.5645( -14) 1.6530( -9) 1.7323( -8)
30 1.5209( 1) + 1.5410( - 1) 1.5712( -3) 1.6191( -2) 1.7055( - 1) -
1.7820( 1.2)
35 1.5722(0) 1.5917(-3) 1.6210(-9) 1.6668(-20) 1.7508(-31) 1.8280( -27)
40 1.6200(+5) 1.6393(+2) 1.6678( -5) 1.7140( -7) 1.7982(-7) 1-8733( -21)
45 1.6593(-36) 1.6797(-27) 1.7092(-19) 1.7564(-5) 1.8404(-4) 1.9168(-8)
50 1.7053(+26) 1.7241(+22) 1.7523(+22) 1.7972(+15) 1.8815(+18) 1.9602(+21)
Numbers in parentheses represent deviations in fourth decimal place of ( - log S).
been repeatedly measured. The majority of An analyzed mixture of hydrogen and carbon
these results are expressed in terms of the Bunsen dioxide contained in a cylinder was passed through
or Ostwald coefficients.6 These were converted to the cells continuously during the electromotive
S by the use of suitable equations. At 23" the force measurements. This cylinder was filled
values7 of S were found to range between 0.0337 from a hydrogen cylinder and a carbon dioxide
arid 0.03420. The results of Bohr are the only cylinder by means of a three-way connecting
ones which include a sufficient number of results unit constructed of copper and brass parts.
suitable for interpolation a t 5" intervals from 0 Before the cylinder was filled, i t mas first rinsed
to 50'. From an analytical equation expressing four or five times by filling with carbon dioxide
his data values at these teinperatures a w e corn- gas to several atmospheres and then evacuating.
puted and mere found to agree with the present After the hydrogen and carbon dioxide were
results with an ai-erage det iation of 0.0011 in introduced, mixing was facilitatcd 111" heating
(-log S). Since Bohr's ~nrasiireinents were the cylinder on a hot plate for several hours.
made by shaking carbon dioxide in a kricnvn vol- This procedure was required in order to obtain
time of uyater arid reading the volunie ~i the gas, accurate results within a reasonable time. 'The
a method quite different from ours, the agree- mixed gases were analyzed by an Ors'it apparatus
ment is very satisfactor>-. with an accurately calibrated buret. The analy-
Markham and Kobe; have determined the ses were reproducible to within O.lyOwhich cor-
solubility of carbon dioxide in sodium chloride responds to an error in lug K' of 0.0011. Enough
solutions a t 0,25 antl 40'. 'I'hcir results agree gas ior one series of measurements was available
well with ours a t 0' hut at. 23 and 40" the dis- if the cylinder was filled to 1.W lb. 1mssw-e a t
crepancies between the two serics are large. b:e the beginning of the experineni.
offer no explanation of this. Further, our \ d i e T h e salt solutions were prepared by weighing
of S i n water a t 2.i" is 0.1: to 2(> higher than the sodium bicarbonate and sodium chliJridc: into
values derived froin the ta of prex-ious invcsti- water. Sodium chloride, dried at
gators,; indicating that under the conditions of f o m d to be 99.9S% pure. The sodium bicar-
our expeririieiits, s~~liie\vhatgreater saturatioii bonate was analyzed by heating to h30" in an
was obtained, atmosphere of carbon dioxide in platinum cru-
Electromotive Force Data cibles under which conditions it should be coni-
pletely converted to carbonate. Check analyses
All the electromotive force measurfments were indicated that the bicarbonate used was 99.91yo
made by cells of the type shown in Fig. 1 with pure. This factor was taken into account in
electrodes in the positions indicated. In using computing concentrations.
a rocking cell, the question arises whether an Platinum foil electrodes and silver chloride
electrode which merely oscillates up arid down in electrodes prepared from silver oxide8 were em-
respect to the solution gives the same electro- ployed. The cells were filled with the mixed
motive force as the usual t y p of hydrogcn (>IC-c- gases by the vacuum technique described in the
trode in which the gas buhblcs cn-er the platinum. solubility measurements. Usually the cells were
This matter wa.; tested b?- [dating two electrodes operated overnight before the first measurement
in the cell, one over t h e bubblvr ::rid t i n t : i n the was made. Upon changing the temperature, two
central stack. bleasurenieiits showed that the to four hours were rcquircd to obtain constant
electromotive forces of these tu.\) electrodes readings of the electromotive forces. -411 series
against the same silvcr (-1:loride electrode agreed of obscr\-:itions were started a t 25" and the tem-
to within * ( i , o : ! mv. perature was varied from I) to ?39, or from 25 to
(6) Consult " l n t i ~ r n n t i o n a l Critical Tables." Vol 111, 1IcOraw- 50". In every series the temperature was finally
Itill Rook C o , l n c , 'yew \'ark, \- , i ' ) 2 ( i , 11 .?lit). '+e a150 t h e
comprehensiv? s u r v e v t N f t h e 5tihject l i y hl,rrkh:irn a m 1 Kc>l>e, ('Iz<?u readjusted to 25' antl the electrxnotive force was
R m . 18, si0 ( i ! l - l : found to agree with the initial rcaclinc t o within
(71 F r o m t h e d a t a
(if I'ind!.:y .itid C'rcightnzi, .I. ( i i r m Sac , 97,
536 (1810): Findlay .ind ?ticti. cbrd , 101, I i i ! ~ t l i 4 1 2 > , l.rniIla)' and e 0 . 1 mv. regardless of whether th2 return was
Howell, tbid , 105 I'in,!lay and Wil- from the high or low teinperaturt ,
liams, zbid.. 103, 37,,'MZ ( 1 9 1 1 ) .
All the c)lcctronlotivc force aiid ard>~tical
data
iiewcsary irir thr. c:!lculation of the ioni~:itioi!
.h'! Tl:irne& ']'HIS J c 3 1 ' ~ ~ , \ 1 . , 61, 411, ( 1 9 2 c l l , ' l ' > p ~i ? i rlcrtrode,
Oct., 1943 THEIONIZATION
CONSTANT
OF CARBONIC
ACID IN WATER 2035
TABLE
IV
Electromotive Forces of the Cells: Pt-H2, COZ1 NaHCOa ( m l ) , NaCl ( m ~ )COS
, (ma) 1 AgC1-Ag; ml = mz; n e 3 = SPCO,;
PB,barometric pre,surc iil ,iini., is given in parentheses immediately followiitg Et. Gas composition in %
' by volume.
Series (1). % COZ = 77.80; % Hz = 22.20
Cell number 1 2 3 4 6 6
nil = mp 0.10385 0.03687 0.02859 0,007177 0.003951 0.002182
E21 (762.6) ,67106 ,67192 ,67209 .67243 ,67271 .67236
Eio (762.7) ,67740 ,67769 .67829 .67864 .67917 .67865
E35 (763.1) ,68335 ,08403 ,68458 .68498 ,68546 .68492
E40 (763.5) ,68958 ,69043 .69087 .69124 .69174 .69124
E o (762.3) ,89653 ,69719 ,69752 .69792 .69833 ,69784
Em (762.0) ,70275 ,70351 .70386 .70428 ,70460 .70418
Series (2). % COZ = 85.40; % HZ = 14.60
The concentrations of electrolytes, m, and m2, given in the second row are those employed through series (2) t o (8).
Cell number 1 2 3 4 5 6
ml = mz 0.03137 0.02360 0.01646 0.01OO5 O.OC6684 0.004271
E25 (762.6) ,66382 .66423 ,66427 ,66433 ,66460 ,66438
Eo (760.2) ,63309 ,63404 .63415 .63445 ,63417 ,63472
Ea (760.7) ,63928 ,64004 .64022 ,63997 .64040 .64033
Elo (763.1) ,64542 ,64599 .64617 .64606 ,64629 .64597
Series (3). yo COZ = 54.48; % HZ= 45.42
E25 (758.5) 0.69025 0.69034 0.69050 0.69046 0.69079 0.69075
E30 (758.7) ,69964 .69674 ,69695 ,69693 ,69725 ,69723
Ea6 (759.4) .70334 .70341 .70367 ,70366 ,70391 ,70370
E40 (758.8) ,71012 ,71024 ,71052 ,71050 ,71085 ,71039
E46 (758.5) .71682 .71702 .71749 .71746 ,71758 .71732
E M(758.5) ,72357 .72381 .72413 .72411 ,72422 ,72388
Series (4). % COZ = 23.07; % HZ= 76.93
Eza (754.4) 0.71953 0.71917 0.71933 0.71886 0.71948 0.71944
Eo (755.31 ,68459 .68461 ,68479 .6&199 ,68481 .68480
Eg (760.0) ,69138 .69140 ,69152 .68935 .69119 .69145
E13 (760.8) ,69816 .69835 .69839 ,69557 .69785 .69820
Eia (761.51 ,70535 ,70527 ,70552 ,70628 ,70582 ,70557
E:. (762.5) ,71264 ,71235 .71261 ,71313 ,71265 ,71265
Series (5). % COZ = 49.51; % HZ = 50.49
E M(752.7) 0.69436 0.69449 0.69350 0.69459 0.69455 0.69475
E30 (752,3) .70096 ,70110 ,70006 ,70110 .70112 ,70096
Ea6 (752.8) .70780 ,70783 .70708 .70790 .70785 ,70764
Eno (756.1) ,71454 ,71443 .71384 ,71472 ,71459 ,71443
Eis (756.8) ,72138 ,72131 .72069 ,72141 ,72142 ,72110
E50 (758.7) ,72821 ,72817 ,72774 ,72840 ,72824 ,72820
Series (6). % COZ = 34.67; % HZ = 65.33
E25 (757.2) 0.70596 0.70672 0.70659 0.70668 0.70707 0.70638
Ezu (755.5) ,69907 ,69991 .69972 ,69987 .70053 ,69975
E15 (754.0) ,69211 ,69317 ,69310 ,69316 ,69387 ,69324
Eio (753.0) ,68489 ,68646 ,68620 ,68637 ,68720 ,68676
Eo (751.4) .67049 .67283 ,67276 ,67291 ,67374 ,67315
E30 (751.0) ,71269 ,71355 ,71346 .71364 ,71381 ,71357
Series (7). % COZ = 17.78; % H I = 82.22
E25 (751.8) 0.72571 0.72666 0.72684 0.72722 0.72689 0.72654
Eio (752.2) .73301 ,73358 .73385 .73408 ,73390 .73352
Bas (753.4) .74064 .74087 .74107 .74137 .74130 .74 108
Eio (754.1) .74796 ,74821 ,74850 .74858 ,74859 ,74848
Series ( 8 ) . yo CO, = 67.55; yo HI = 32.45
El5 (751 .4) 0.67959 0,68033 0.68053 0.68077 0.08079 0.67975
150 (755.5) ,64746 ,64800 .64880 . G4930 ,649 13 .64690
Elo (755,3) ,65987 .GGO97 ,66133 ,66178 ,66166 ,85984
Eis (753.8) ,66608 ,66713 .66727 .667%3 . 6678n t,titin:!
2036 s. HARNEDA N D
HERBERT RAYMOND DAVIS,J R . Vol. 65
0 850
(io0 F----
I
-I 00
Observed minus calculated values of (- log K).
is a maximum and the value of the ionization
1 - . 13- constant a t Ti are given by
i
= A' - DIT + C'Te
800
- 110" A P (16)
ti 450
I - - mO
i = A' - C'T2 (17)
--.
T
-1115 6 .ICPiO = - 2C'T 18)
q 6 400 ' i 3.Si0 = D f - 2C'T (19)
__ { 20"
1 =dV
r
co To 120)
9 6350 log Kg = D * - 2-
' tj :<iiii
.
___-
-
*__
_._
r
_ I
?S@
where A' = 2.3026 RA*; D' = 2.3026 RO";
(21)
MacInnes and Belcher's values agree somewhat 50' has been measured by analyzing the solution
more closely but not really satisfactorily. How- contained in cells which were employed for the
ever, in spite of these differences, these con- electromotive force measurements and with the
ductance and electromotive force values are in conditions identical in both cases.
much better agreement than the earlier values'* 2. The logarithms of the Henry's law con-
which range between far greater limits. The stants computed from these measurements were
heat content data check fairly well when we take expressed by quadratic equations and the con-
into account that they were derived by differen- stants for these equations were found by the
tiation. Direct calorimetric measurements have method of least squares.
been made recently by Pitzer14 who reported 3. The first dissociation constant of carbonic
AH: = 1843 * 60 cal. a t 25'. acid from 0 to 50' was measured by means of
summary cells without liquid junction.
1. The solubility of carbon dioxide in water 4. The logarithms of the dissociation con-
and aqueous sodium chloride solutions from 0 to stants were expressed by a least squared equation.
(13) Kauko and Elo. Z. ghysik. Chcm., A184, 211 (19391, for The thermodynamic qu-antities for the dissocia-
example, obtained 2.33 X 10-7 and 3.48 X 10-1 at 0' and 25', re- tion were calculated from this equation.
spectively.
(14) Pitzer, THISJOURNAL, 69,2365 (1937). NEW HAVEN,CONNECTICUT RECEIVEDMAY29, 1943
NOTES