Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Polytechnic
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
(i) Temperature: If the temperature of any insulating material increases, then its insulation
resistance decreases.
(ii) Atmosphere: Presence of moisture/humidity in the air affects the resistance of insulating
material. Insulating resistance of the insulating material weakens when comes in contact with
atmosphere, like the insulators present in the overhead lines. Moisture present in the
atmosphere reduces the insulating resistance.
(iii) Age: Insulating resistance of the insulators weaken with the passage of time. Insulation
strength decreases due to following reasons:
(a) More load than the required capacity
(b) Oxidization
(c) Drying
(d) Many other reasons
Some materials such as porcelain, mica, only have their insulating strength for the longer time.
When paper, cellulose etc. got dried its insulation resistance destroyed. At high temperature,
they are converted into powdered form.
(iv) Applied voltage: Magnitude of applied voltage also affects the insulating strength. The
magnitude of insulating resistance is certainly decreases when measured by megger at 500 V,
1000 V, 2500 V, 5000 V respectively.
(v) Dielectric strength: Conducting material and equipment operates on a certain voltage. But if
they are operated on higher voltage then prescribed voltage, its insulating strength get
destroyed, which eventually damage the insulating quality of insulating material.
Let us take an example, if an insulating material is kept between the two conductors and increase
the voltage more than its capacity. This will cause insulating resistance puncture Voltage gradient
can be obtain by dividing the magnitude of voltage puncture with the diameter of the wire in
kV/mm. This breakdown strength is known as dielectric strength. That minimum voltage at which
insulating strength breaks down is known as breakdown voltage. This is measured in v/mm or
kV/mm.
(vi) Tracking: Due to breaking down, burning or melting of insulating material irregular holes are
produced in it. Now, even if minimum voltage is applied on it, the current will follow through
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
irregular path and then the solid material will lose its insulating strength, This is called tracking.
(vii) Oxidation: Resistivity of insulating material decreases as the material get oxidize. As the
temperature increases the material get oxidize rapidly, which reduces the resistivity.
(viii) Impurities: As impurity in the insulating material increase, the resistivity of the material
decrease.
(ix) Light: High intensity of light, decreases, the resistivity of insulating material Difference
between insulation resistance and earth resistance.
Insulation resistance is measured between conductor and earth. It is of the order of several
tens/thousands mega ohms or infinity for healthy insulation. It is measured by means of megger
(mega-ohm meter), with built-in DC generator. Earth resistance is measured for a earthed
metallic body or neutral point. It is measured by means of earth resistance tester. For good
effective earthing, the earth resistance should be of the order of 0.5 ohm.
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
For ac machines having a rated output below 5000 kW (or kVA) and above 200 kW (or kVA) the
resistance method shall be used, unless the ETD method is agreed.
For ac machines having a rated output of 200 kW (or kVA) or less the resistance method shall be
used, unless the superposition method is agreed.
For machines rated 600 kW (or kVA) or less, when the windings are non-uniform or severe
complications are involved in making the necessary connections, the temperature-rise may be
determined by means of thermometers (or non-embedded thermocouples).
For ac stator windings having only one coil-side per slot, the embedded detector method is not
recognized and the resistance method shall be used.
For checking the temperature of such windings in service, an embedded detector at the bottom
of the slot is of little value because it gives mainly the temperature of the iron core. A detector
placed between the coil and the wedge will follow the temperature of the winding much more
closely and is, therefore, better for check tests, although the temperature there may be rather
low. The relation between the temperature measured at that place and the temperature
measured by the resistance method should be determined by a temperature-rise test.
For windings of armatures having commutators and for field windings, except for field windings
in cylindrical rotors of synchronous machines, the resistance method and the thermometer
method are recognized. The resistance method is preferred.
For stationary field windings of dc machines having more than one layer the ETD method may
also be used.
(i) Determination of Temperature-Rise of Windings by the Resistance Method
Copper windings
The temperature-rise t2 – ta may be obtained from the ratio of the resistance by the formula:
𝑡2 + 235 𝑅2
=
𝑡𝑎 + 235 𝑅1
Where
t2 = temperature (°C) of the winding at the end of the test,
ta = temperature (°C) of coolant at the end of the test,
t1 = temperature (°C) of the winding (cold) at the moment of the initial resistance measurement,
R2 = resistance of the winding at the end of the test, and
R1 = resistance of the winding at temperature t1 (cold).
For practical purposes, the following alternative formula may be found convenient:
tr (Temperature-rise) = t2 – ta
𝑅2 − 𝑅1
= (235 + 𝑡1 ) + 𝑡1 − 𝑡𝑎
𝑅1
When the temperature of a winding is determined by resistance, the temperature of the winding
before the test, measured by thermometer, shall be practically that of the coolant.
Non-copper windings
For materials other than copper, replace the number 235 in the above formula with the reciprocal
of the temperature coefficient of resistance at 0°C of the material. For aluminium, unless
otherwise specified, the number 225 shall be used.
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
(iv) If the initial resistance reading cannot be made until after twice the time delay time specified
in (i), the method of (ii) shall only be used by agreement between the manufacturer and the
purchaser.
Properties of good transformer oil:
According to IS: 335-1983, new insulating oil which is used in transformer and other switchgear,
should have following properties.
(i) Appearance: New insulating oil should be clean, transparent and sediment free.
(ii) Density: Density of oil at 27°C should be 0.89 gm/cm³.
(iii) Kinematic viscosity: Kinematic viscosity at 27°C should be 27 cat.
(iv) Interfacial tension: Interfacial tension at 27°C should be 0.04 N/m.
(v) Pour point: It should have high pour point at 9°C.
(vi) Flash point: It should have high flash point at 140°C.
(vii) Neutralization value (total acidity): Total acidity of insulating oil should be s minimum as
possible and the minimum value in 0.03 mg KOH/g.
(viii) Corrosive sulphur in terms of classification of copper strip: Insulating oil should be non-
corrosive.
(ix) Dielectric strength or breakdown voltage: It should have high dielectric strength
(x) Dielectric dissipation factors: Dielectric dissipation factor of the insulating oil at 90°C should
be multiple of tan δ (loss tangent) and maximum should be 0.005.
(xi) Specific resistance: The minimum specific resistance of insulating oil at temperature of 25°C
should be 500 x 1012 Ω cm and at temperature 90°C it should be 30 x 1012 Ω cm.
(xii) Oxidation stability: The oxidation stability of insulating oil is as follows:
(a) Maximum neutralization value after oxidation for 164 hours 100°C-0.40mg KOH/g.
(b) Maximum sludge value after oxidation for 164 hours should not exceed 0.1%.
(xiii) Presence of oxidation inhibitor: Antioxidation additives should not be present in insulating
oil.
(xiv) Water content: The amount of water present in insulating oil should not exceed 50 ppm
(part per million).
Understand the procedure of following tests on oil as per I.S.1692-1978:
According to IS: 1692-1978, the following tests may be carried out on the insulating oil to check
its suitability for use.
(i) Dielectric strength test
(ii) Crackle test
(iii) Acidity test
(iv) Sludge test
(v) Flash point test
(vi) Method of field testing of insulating oil
(vii) Sight test
(i) Dielectric Strength Test
Dielectric strength of transformer oil is also known as breakdown voltage of transform oil or RDV
of transformer oil. Breakdown voltages is measured by observing at what voltage sparking strants
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
between two electrodes immerged in the oil, separated by specific pap Low value of BDV
indicates the presence of moisture content and conducting substances in the oil. For measuring
breakdown voltage of transformer oil, portable.
The dielectric strength of insulating oil is carried out with testing sot which consists of a standard
oil test cell which is approximately 55 mm x 90 mm x 100 mm. In this cell are fitted polished brass
spheres 12.7 or 13 mm in diameter horizontally The gap spacing between these sphere's is 2.5
0.02 mm, which can be adjusted by arrangement to change with the help of attachment with
spheres and can be checked.
Crackle Test
(iii) Acidity Test
According to IS: 1866-1983 it is defined as the measure of free organic and inorganic present
together in the oil. It is expressed in terms of the number of milli-grams of potassium hydroxide
required to neutralize the total free acid in one gram of material. Tendency of the oil to develop
acidity requires to be carefully watched. If the acidity exceeds prescribed limit metal surface
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
above oil level are likely to the corroded on account of acidic vapours. Total acidity can be
calculated by following formula.
56.1×NV
Total acidity=
w
where
N= Normality of KOH solution
V=Volume of KOH solution in millilitre
W=Weight of the sample of the oil in gram.
Hence, the lower limit of acid in the oil is recommended as follows:
(i) Acidity up to 0.45 mg KOH/g Insulating oil is right.
(ii) Acidity in between 0.45 mg to 1 mg KOH/g - Insulating oil should be checked periodically.
(iii) Acidity exceeds 1.0 mg KOH/g - Clean oil or replace it.
(iv) Sludge Test
Used insulating oil may contain some solid materials like rust, scale, dirt, fibre etc.
Method for testing sediment and precipitable sludge is discussed below.
Take the sample of the insulating oil and stir it well until the sediments and precipitated sludge
get mix up with the oil. Now take 10 gram of oil in triangular flask. And add 100 millilitre n-
heptane in the solution. Then stir well the solution of oil and n-heptane and put this solution in
dark for 18 to 24 hours.
If now any solid material is found in the flask, then filtered the solution by tared glass sintered
glass crucible. Now wash crucible and sediment with n-heptane untill the solution become free
from sediment. Now put this crucible in electrical hearth for one hour at the temperature of 100
to 110°C. Then put this solution in desicator for cooling and note down the weight of the solution.
After doing all this again note down the ratio percentage of the crucible solution to the original
solution. And name this value an 'A'.
Mix toluene, acytone and alcohol in this crucible solution in equal quantity and put it for the
further treatment at the temperature of 50°C until sludge completely dissolve in it.
Then filter this solution and separate sludge from the crucible solution. And then inspect visually
whether the solution contain any residue or not.
If any more sediment and sludge is found in the solution. Then follow the same processer again
and again. Calculate the ratio percentage of the weight of residue to the weight of the oil. And
name is as 'B',
Difference between A and B i.e., A-B shows the value of sludge in the oil.
(v) Flash Point Test
Flash point test can also be called as breakdown test. This test is performed to check the dielectric
strength of the transformer oil. The point at which the spark occurs and transformer trips is
known as flash point.
The sample of oil is drawn from near the top and bottom of the transformer and tested in the oil
testing set. A lower than 30 kV dielectric strength for a 4 mm gap of electrodes would indicates
presence of moisture in the oil. The actual testing is done as follows.
The gap of the electrodes is first checked with a gauge. The cup is then filled with sample oil to
be tested upon about one cm, above the electrodes. The cup top is covered with a clean glass
plate. The supply is switched on and voltage is raised gradually by the variac, the stage comes
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
when the final breakdown of the oil takes place and the circuit breaker is got tripped which
disconnects the transformer from the main supply.
This value is noted down which must be 30 kV (rms) for 4 mm ± 0.02 gap and 20 kV (rms) for 2.5
mm gap. The test is performed with two or three consecutive samples of oil turn by turn with
interval of one minute to allow the bubbles to escape. Average of all subsequent tests is
considered as the breakdown voltage of oil sample.
Sight Test
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Close the end of the tube and fix it on the stand by dipping into water. If the bubbles appear at
the jet, then it will indicate the presence of moisture contents in the oil. This test is rarely used
because the oil testing set is not easily available in the laboratories.
Vacuum impregnation:
Vacuum Pressure Impregnation (V.P.I) is a process by which a fully wound electric apparatus
stator or rotor is completely submerged in a Resin. Through a combination of dry and wet
vacuum and pressure cycles, the resin is assimilated throughout the insulation system. Once
thermally processed, the impregnated windings become a monolithic and homogenous
structure.
The resulting benefits are;
The VPI process is a significant technological advancement over the traditional “dip in varnish
and then bake” approach used to insulate electric motors. In place of standard insulating varnish
for electric motors, a special VPI epoxy insulation is used on the coils. The preheated stator or
rotor is then lowered into the VPI pressure chamber and a vacuum is drawn. As that occurs, a
solventless epoxy resin is drawn into the chamber until the unit is completely submerged.
Pressure is then applied and the unit becomes thoroughly impregnated with the resin, and then
the unit is removed and baked in a curing oven. The result of the VIP process is a 4 to 5 ml build
of insulating resin and an almost void-free insulation system for your motor’s windings.
Vacuum impregnation is carried out in a vacuum impregnation plant which consists of a double
jacketed vacuum impregnating chamber which has a removable top cover. The chamber can be
heated by circulating steam or hot oil through jacket. There is a chamber for storing the baking
type of varnish. A compressor cum vacuum exhauster which can create a desired pressure or
vacuum by using proper valves is connected to the chamber.
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
Unit-4: Testing & maintenance of Insulation Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic
through the jacket of chamber and the temperature is maintained for nearly four hours. During
this period the air from the chamber is pumped out by vacuum exhauster and vacuum is
maintained, which will help in vapourising the moisture present in the coils and removing the
same completely.
Then the insulating varnish form varnish tank is allowed to flow into the chamber till the varnish
in the chamber comes upto a level in which windings are completely immersed. Then the valve
of varnish tank is closed and a pressure from compressor of about 1.4 to 2.1 kg/cm2 is applied
above varnish surface, which will make the varnish to be forced in all the porous (air packets etc)
spaces in the interior of coils. The pressure is maintained for an hour or half an hour and the valve
of the varnish tank is opened and varnish is made to flow back to the tank under air pressure till
excess varnish also gets drainned out. The valve is then closed and the armature is then baked in
the chamber at 100 to 110°C for nearly 8 hours or till the varnish is completely dried out or fill it
becomes bone dry. The air pressure and circulating steam or oil in the jacket is then stopped and
the armature or stator is then removed by opening the top cover.
Prepared by Sanjoy Pondit, Lecturer, Department of Electrical Engineering, Ghatal Govt. Polytechnic