Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of Chlorhexidine on Hydroxyapatite
R.N.S. SODHI, H.A. GRAD, and D.C. SMITH
Centre for Biomaterials, University of Toronto, 170 College Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5S lA1
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was used for determination of 1% solutions of the digluconate salt) on the surface composition of
the effects of chlorhexidine (CLX) solutions (0.2% and 1% solutions of hydroxyapatite. Hydroxyapatite was chosen for our initial studies,
the digluconate salt) on the elemental composition of hydroxyapatite since it is a major component of tooth enamel as well as a material
surfaces. So that the nature ofthe adsorbed species after they were used for dental implants (Lemons, 1990). Further, retention ofCHX
washed with water could be identified, comparisons were made with on implant material may allow for its use in a pre-treatment
reference spectra for CHX obtained from a CHX digluconate film and procedure for hydroxyapatite and other materials. X-ray photoelec-
CHX dichloride powder. The XPS results clearly indicated the tron spectroscopy (XPS) was used for study of the nature of the
retention of CHX moieties, which could be ascertained from the adsorbed species. XPS provides a convenient means of obtaining
spectra by the presence of N and Cl, features unique to CHX. The detailed characterization of the treated surface (Andrade, 1985;
spectral envelopes were virtually identical to those obtained from the Briggs and Seah, 1990). It gives a quantitative elemental surface-
reference spectra. High-resolution C ls spectra also gave support for analysis to a depth of about 10 nm, and, unlike other surface-
the retention of CHX; however, the spectra differed from those of the analytical techniques, such as Auger electron spectroscopy, is one of
CIX digluconate film in that no feature attributable to the C-OH of the few techniques capable of providing detailed chemical informa-
the gluconate anion was present, consistent with the view that the tion on that surface. Thus, the XPS spectra obtained in this study
CHX cation remains behind to form an electrostatic bond with the allowed the nature of the species adsorbed to the hydroxyapatite
phosphate groups of the hydroxyapatite. The N:C1 ratio for the surface to be identified and also provided reference spectra as a
washed samples was found to be higher than that for the reference basis for future studies of the effect of a CHX rinse on the surface
samples and may be indicative of partial decomposition ofthe CHX. composition of other implant materials.
Decomposition was also seen to be induced by x-ray exposure. While
the high-resolution spectra presented here do not directly address the Materials and methods.
controversy on the mechanism for the anti-plaque efficacy of CHX,
they do provide the necessary basis for the application ofXPS to future Materials.-Sintered pure hydroxyapatite coupons (10 x 10 mm, 1
in vitro studies on the retention of CHX to dental surfaces. mm thick, Durapatite®, Sterling-Winthrop) were cleaned by sonica-
tion in detergent (2% Decon, 1 h) and thoroughly rinsed in double-
J Dent Res 71(8):1493-1497, August, 1992 distilled, de-ionized water (DDDW). Duplicate cleaned coupons
were given either a CHX wash (0.2% or 1%, Hibitane® Gluconate,
Introduction. Ayerst) or a DDDW wash. The latter treatments constituted a
control. All coupons then received a DDDW wash (two one-minute
Chlorhexidine (C22H38N10C12), the structure ofwhich is shown in Fig. rinses with shaking at 370C) and were allowed to dry overnight in
1, is a bisbiguanide antiseptic which has a broad spectrum of a laminar-flow hood. The samples were then wrapped in Al foil until
antimicrobial activity. It is an accepted therapeutic agent for the analyzed by XPS. Reference spectra for CHX were obtained from
control of plaque-related periodontal diseases, where it is generally two types of samples, namely, (i) hydroxyapatite samples washed
administered in the form of a 0. 12-0.2% solution of its digluconate with a 1% solution of CHX digluconate and allowed to dry by
salt (C22H30N1OC12-2C 6H207) The anti-plaque efficacy of chlorhexi- evaporation without a DDDW rinse, or (ii) CHX dihydrochloride
dine (CHX) at these concentrations has been attributed to its powder stuck onto sticky-sided Cu tape.
bactericidal effect on the microbiota of dental plaque along with its XPS analysis.-The XPS spectra were obtained on a Leybold
ability to bind to either salivary proteins and/or tooth enamel. More MAX 200 XPS system. Unmonochromatized Mg Ka x-ray radiation
specifically, two types ofmechanisms have been postulated for this was used as the excitation source. The source was run at 12 kV and 25
effect. The first is that a reservoir of CHX is bound to oral surfaces, mA. Features in the resultant spectra due to excitation from the
and active drug is slowly released into the surrounding medium, weaker x-ray satellite lines which are also present in the
thereby producing a prolonged bacteriostatic environment in the unmonochromatic source were subtracted by use of an algorithm
mouth (Rolla et al., 1970; Gjermo et al., 1975; Gjermo, 1989). A supplied with the instrument and based upon a program by van
second theory postulates a more site-specific effect, and it is pro- Attekum and Trooster (1977). Atomic percentages of the elements
posed that after a rinse or topical application, CHX has an immedi-
ate, short bactericidal effect, followed by a prolonged bacteriostatic
effect due to adsorption onto the tooth enamel (Jenkins et al., 1988).
In both cases, however, it is recognized that the retention of CHX TABLE 1
upon oral surfaces plays an important role. ATOMIC % OF C, Cl, N, AND 0 FOR CHLORHEXIDINE
CHX has been shown to adsorb to tooth enamel and hydroxyapa-
tite, by both indirect (Rolla et al., 1970; Nordbo, 1972; Emilson et al., DIGLUCONATE FILMS (TWO RUNS) DETERMINED BY XPS,
1973) and, more recently, direct means (Perdoketal., 1989; Busscher IN COMPARISON WITH THE THEORETICAL VALUES
et al., 1990). However, the nature ofthe adsorbed components after
a rinse with CHX has not been fully investigated. The purpose of C Cl N 0
this study was to determine the effects ofsolutions of CX (0.2% and
Theoretical 56.7 3.3 16.7 23.3
Experiment (1) 59.4 3.3 15.7 21.6
Received for publication September 26, 1991 (2) 58.8 3.2 15.8 22.2
Accepted for publication March 24, 1992
Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com by guest on July 9, 2011 For personal use only. No other uses without permission. 1493
1494 SODHI et al. J Dent Res August 1992
NH NH NH NH
/\ 1 11 1 11
Cl - -NNHCNHCN(CH2) NHCNHCNH - Cl
z 40
20- _ _
CHLORHEXIDINE
400 200 400 200
present were derived from spectra run in a low-resolution mode (pass 80-
40-
energy = 192 eV) which were normalized to unit transmission of the 40 2.
electron spectrometer by means of a routine provided by the manu- 2 4 0 0
facturer (Berresheimetal., 1991). The sensitivityfactors used (O Is =
0.78, N Is = 0.54, Ca 2p = 1.98, C Is = 0.34, Cl 2p = 1.08, and P 2p = BINDING ENERGY (eV)
0.61) were empirically derived by Leybold for the normalized spectra.
For further information on the nature of the surface to be obtained, Fig. 2-Survey spectra of hydroxyapatite surfaces: (a) Hydroxyapatite
the spectral regions of interest were also run in a high-resolution control; (b) + 1 % CHX digluconate, not rinsed (constitutes control); (c) + 0.2 %
mode (pass energy = 48 eV). Binding energies and peak areas were CHX digluconate, rinsed; and (d) + 1% CHX digluconate, rinsed.
obtained by use of the routines provided with the spectrometer. The
energy scale ofthe spectrometer was calibrated to the Ag 3d5,2 and Cu tite spectrum (Fig. 2a) shows the expected features (0, Ca, P)
2P3,2 peaks at 368.3 eV and 932.7 eV, respectively (Anthony and Seah, associated with the hydroxyapatite, along with some unavoidable C
1984; Briggs and Seah, 1990), and the binding energy scale was then contamination. No features due to Ca and P are present in the
shifted to place the C Is feature present at 285.0 eV. Large-area spectrum of the film (Fig. 2b), and the experimentally determined
analysis was performed (2 x 4 mm or 4 x 7 mm) so that exposure of the atomic percentages of 0, N, C, and Cl are in good agreement with
samples to the x-ray would be minimized while sufficient signal-to- those expected from the stoichiometryofCHXdigluconate (Table 1).
noise ratios could be obtained for the spectral features. The effect ofx- Therefore, it is concluded that this spectrum is representative of the
ray exposure on CIX was checked on the CHX film by the source CHX digluconate salt. Also shown (Figs. 2c and 2d) are the spectra
being left on for 15 min in between the collection of high-resolution of hydroxyapatite samples which had been washed with CHX
spectra (O Is, N Is, C Is, and Cl 2p), which were obtained in digluconate and rinsed. The rinsed samples show features from
approximately three min. Examination of the high-resolution Cl 2p both hydroxyapatite and CHX, as is evident from the Ca/P and N/Cl
spectra from the rinsed samples indicated minimal decomposition. peaks. Thus, it is clear that, while much of the CHX had been
removed by rinsing, some remained.
Results. More information on the chemical nature of the surface can be
obtained from high-resolution spectra. Fig. 3 shows reference
Fig. 2 shows survey spectra of hydroxyapatite and the CIX spectra for CHXfrom (a) the digluconate film and (b) CHX dichloride
digluconate film, both ofwhich constitute controls. The hydroxyapa- powder. The N is spectral envelope is identical for both compounds
TABLE 2
MEAN ELEMENTAL RATIOS [±( )] OBTAINED FROM THE XPS SPECTRA FOR THIS WORK (a), IN COMPARISON
WITH THE THEORETICAL RATIOS (b) AND THOSE OF PERDOK et al. (1989) ON DENTAL ENAMEL
Ca/P O/P N/P N/Cl C/N
(a) This work:
Hydroxyapatite 1.4 (1) 4.5 (2) -
CHX digluconate film - - - 4.8(i) 3.8 (1)
0.2% solution 1.4 (1) 4.3 (2) 0.53 (3) 6.1(4) 5.6 (6)
1.0% solution 1.3 (1) 4.5 (3) 1.1 (1) 6.6 (4) 3.9 (3)
(b) Theoretical:
Hydroxyapatite 1.67 4.33 - - -
CHX - - - 5 2.2
CHX digluconate - - 5 3.4
(c) Perdok et al. (1989):
Dental Enamel 1.3 4.2 - -
a A Ols a Nt
350o
CI" CF-
CO 200 0
0
I-
0. 100-,
IU
'-
400 395 39~O a a
I-
z
a C is a 012n 290 205 280 205 200 195
c
a1)
NIs
a)
A N -
.0 *0
0)
T Cl
m
a-
0)
I-
en
Cl 2p
Fig. 5-Change in the absolute intensity of the N Is, 0 Is, and the C1 2p z
(covalent) features ofthe CHX film with x-ray exposure. The value for Cl was
extracted from the total Cl present by means of the supplied curve-fitting -1
routines.
-J
LU
chloroaniline from the surface would remove one N atom with every
Cl atom. Thus, partial decomposition of CHX, leading to the loss of
p-chloroaniline, with the rest of the molecule remaining bound,
would increase the observed N:Cl ratio. If this amounted to 20% of
the total amount ofadsorbed CHX, then an increase in the N:Cl ratio
from 5:1 to 6:1 would be observed. The ratio of C:N was also seen to 195
be somewhat higher than that which would be expected for CHX. BINDING ENERGY(eV)
This was especially so for the 0.2%-rinsed sample. This increase can
be accounted for either from pick-up of hydrocarbon contamination Fig. 6-High-resolution spectra of sample washed with (a) 0.2% CHLX
from the atmosphere after drying and prior to XPS analysis or from digluconate solution and rinsed, and (b) 1% CHX digluconate solution and
re-exposure of C contamination that was originally present on the rinsed. Also shown are spectra for the CHX digluconate control (c). The
hydroxyapatite surface. A large increase in the amount of C relative relative intensities of the spectra have been normalized to the N is feature.
to Cl has been noted for CHX on tooth enamel (Perdok et al., 1989).
This was attributed to the adsorption of hydrocarbon additives onto
the treated tooth enamel from the commercially-available CHX
used, as well as from contamination.
-9 ._. Decomposition was also observed to be induced by the x-ray
exposure. The phenomena observed here probably arose from
dissociative electron attachment onto the chlorine (Zhou and White,
-9
1990), the low-energy electrons required for this being produced by
the bremsstrahlung radiation inherent in the use of an
unmonochromatized x-ray. The released Cl- is then able to attack
(: the gluconate site or bind to the phosphate surface. Thus, care must
be taken that the spectra are obtained in as short a time as possible
I- so that this decomposition will be minimized. Examination of the
high-resolution Cl 2p spectra (Fig. 6) obtained on the rinsed samples
indicated that this was indeed the case.
(n
I-
Downloaded from jdr.sagepub.com by guest on July 9, 2011 For personal use only. No other uses without permission.