Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Authors’ contributions
This work was carried out in collaboration between the authors. Author RJW designed and
coordinated data collection. Author BY wrote the protocol performed the analysis and managed the
analyses of the study. Author BCL wrote the first draft and managed the literature searches. All
authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Article Information
DOI: 10.9734/ARJA/2017/33431
Editor(s):
(1) Fábio da Costa Henry, Laboratory of Food Technology, State University of Northern of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
(2) Marco Aurelio Cristancho, National Center for Coffee Research, Chinchiná, Caldas, Colombia.
Reviewers:
(1) Oluwole Olufunke, Obafemi Awolowo University, Nigeria.
(2) Ugwuowo Leonard Chidi, University of Nigeria Nsukka, Nigeria.
(3) David Latshaw, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA.
(4) Sule Cengiz, University of Uludag, Turkey.
(5) Yassmine Moemen Hassan El-Gindy, Alexandria University, Egypt.
Complete Peer review History: http://www.sciencedomain.org/review-history/19937
th
Received 15 April 2017
Original Research Article Accepted 5th June 2017
th
Published 8 July 2017
ABSTRACT
The study was carried out to evaluate the effects of feeding raw kapok seed meal on growth
performance, nutrient digestibility and carcass characteristics of weaner rabbits. Thirty (30) weaner
rabbits were used for the study. Five diets were compounded using raw kapok seed meal (RKSM) at
0, 5, 10, 15 and 20% inclusion levels. The rabbits were weighed and randomly assigned to the five
dietary treatments replicated three times with two rabbits per replicate in a completely randomized
design. The proximate composition of raw kapok seed meal showed it contains 89.51% dry matter,
17.45% crude fibre, 22.59%, crude protein, 10.05% ether extracts, 6.53%, ash and 43.38% nitrogen
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
free extract. The seed meal also contains tannin (2.53%), Alkaloid (3.34%), phenol (2.48%),
flavonoid (2.95%), saponin (1.30%), trypsin inhibitors (17.97%), hemagglutinin (1.69%) and total
oxalate (1.12%).The result of growth performance and nutrient digestibility decreased significantly
(P<0.01) as the dietary levels of raw kapok seed meal increases. Similarly carcass and internal
organ weights were significantly influenced by the dietary levels of RKSM. The relative weights of
liver, lungs and kidney significantly (P<0.01) increased beyond 15% RKSM inclusion in the diet. It
was concluded that RKSM can be fed to weaner rabbit up to 10% inclusion levels without any
adverse effect on the rabbit performance.
Keywords: Weaner rabbit; performance; nutrient digestibility; carcass characteristics; kapok seed.
2
Wafar et al.; ARJA, 5(3): 1-8, 2017; Article no.ARJA.33431
3
Wafar et al.; ARJA, 5(3): 1-8, 2017; Article no.ARJA.33431
removed, weighed and expressed as percentage value of saponin recorded in the present study is
of the live weight. Dressing percent was higher than 1.1% observed in mucuna seed [25]
determined as Dressed weight x 100 and also higher than 0.23-0.57 mg/kg reported
Live weight by [26] and 0.96-1.33% for raw lablab. The high
.
concentration of tannins implies possibilities of
poor protein digestibility caused by formation of
2.6 Chemical Analysis protein tannin complexes which irreversibly bind
digestive enzymes, thus inhibiting the activities of
The proximate composition of raw kapok seed the enzymes making them unavailable for
meal, experimental diets and faecal samples breaking down proteins and other nutrients
were determined for dry matter (DM), Crude [27,28].
protein (CP), crude fibre (CF), ether extracts (EE)
ash and nitrogen free extracts (NFE) as well as Saponin in seeds imposes an astringent taste
Alkaloid, trypsine inhibitors using[11] methods. that affects feed palatability, reduce feed intake,
Total oxalate was determined according to [12] utilization of protein and consequently body
procedure. Phytate was determined using the growth [29]. The raw kapok seed also contain
method described by [13]. Saponin was trypsin in hibitor lower 2.89% obtained by [24] for
determined using the method of [14] as modified raw lablab seed. The haemaglutinin value
by [15]. While tannin was determined using the recorded was lower than the range of 41.37-
method of [16]. Phenol, haemagglutinin, 53.64HU/mg as reported by [30] for raw lablab
flavonoid were determined using the method of seed but higher than 4.0HU/mgN for winged
[11]. bean [23] and 8.0 HU/mgN for M. pruriens seed
flour [31].High hemagglutinins concentration bind
2.7 Statistical Analysis intestinal membrane of animals and impair the
normal absorption of dietary nutrients [32]. Total
All data obtained during the experiment were oxalate content is lower than 1.95% found in raw
analysed according to the ANOVA model, using mucuna seed [25,32] reported that high
the ONEWAY procedure of [17] version 19. concentration of oxalates bind calcium present in
Duncan’s Multiple range test was used to feed thereby rendering calcium unavailable for
separate means. normal physiological and biochemical roles. The
phytate concentration of RKSM is higher than
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 1.06% reported for mucuna by [25]. High phytate
contents have been reported to retard growth,
3.1 Proximate Composition and Anti- caused abnormalities in the intestinal histology,
nutrients of Raw Kapok Seed Meal reduce the bioavailability of dietary phosphorus,
inhibit dietary proteins and activity of trypsin and
The proximate composition and anti-nutrients of pepsin and reduces the solubility of starch
raw kapok seed meal are shown in Table 2.The [33,34].
high dry matter (89.51%) content of the raw
kapok seeds is an indication that they can be 3.2 Growth Performance of Weaner
stored for a long time and are less prone to Rabbits Fed Raw Kapok Seed Meal
microbial attack during storage [18,19]. Ether (RKSM)
extracts (10.05%) is lower than 34% as reported
by [18] and 21-29% reported by [20] The crude The growth performance of weaner rabbits fed
protein content recorded is however lower than RKSM is presented in Table 3. The result
36.70% reported by [19] but within the range of showed significant (p<0.01) difference across
22-30% reported by [18]. The observed inclusion levels. The final body weight, total feed
variations in proximate composition could be intake and total weight gain of the rabbits
attributed to climatic conditions, edaphic factors decreased as the levels of RKSM increased in
as well as methods of processing and laboratory the diets. The result is in consonant with the
analysis [21]. observations of [35,36] on broiler chicken when
they fed raw jack bean and raw tallow seed
The tannin content (2.53%) of raw kapok seed is meals respectively. The decrease in final body
higher than 0.34% in African oil bean seed weight, total feed intake and total weight gain
reported by [22], 0.94g reported for winged bean could be attributed to inherent anti-nutrients in
[23], 0.42% in raw lablab seed as reported by the raw kapok seed meal which probably
[24] and 1.41% found in mucuna seed [25]. The reached a threshold level beyond the tolerance
4
Wafar et al.; ARJA, 5(3): 1-8, 2017; Article no.ARJA.33431
levels of the rabbits. Several studies have than the ranged of 73.01- 76.20% reported by
attributed impaired feed utilization, depressed [43] for tropical rabbits. The poor dressing
growth, loss of appetite and pancreatic percent observed in rabbits fed T4 and T5 diets
hypertrophy in the experimental animals to anti- might be due to reduction in feed intake and
nutritional factors [25,36,37,38,39,40]. Rabbits on impaired nutrient utilization attributed by the high
0%, 5% and 10% inclusion levels had superior ANFs in the raw kapok seeds. The development
(p<0.01) feed conversion ratio suggesting there of carcass trait, organs and muscular growth in
was better absorption and utilization of nutrients animals depend on nutrition among other factors
by the rabbits. [44]. The relative weight of heart of rabbits fed 0,
5 and 10% RKSM were not significantly lower
3.3 Nutrient Digestibility of Weaner (P>0.05). Higher weights of liver and kidney of
Rabbits fed Raw Kapok Seed Meal rabbits on 15 and 20% RKSM may be due to
illicit toxic response of liver and kidney which are
Table 4 showed the nutrient digestibility of the major organs of detoxification [45].
weaner rabbits fed RKSM. There was significant
(P<0.01) decrease in the digestibility of nutrients Table 2. Proximate and anti- nutrients
with increasing levels of RKSM in the diets. composition of raw kapok seed meal as fed
Rabbits fed 0%, 5% and 10% diets had similar basis
nutrient digestibility which implied that they could
tolerate up to 10% RKSM level of inclusion. The Nutrients Composition (%)
reduction in nutrient digestibility beyond 10% is Dry matter 89.51
ascribed to the presence of the anti-nutritional Crude protein 22.59
factors in RKSM. Anti-nutritional factors (ANFs) Crude fibre 17.45
interfere with metabolic process such that growth Ether extracts 10.05
and bioavailability of nutrients are negatively Ash 6.53
influenced [41]. Nitrogen free extracts 43.38
*ME Kcal/kg 3180
3.4 Carcass Characteristics and Internal Anti- nutrients composition (%)
Organs of Weaner Rabbits Fed Raw Phenol 2.48
Kapok Seed Meal Alkaloid 3.34
Flavonoid 2.95
Live weights were significantly (P<0.01) higher in Tannin 2.53
rabbits fed 0%, 5% and 10% RKSM while rabbits Saponin 1.30
fed 15 and 20% RKSM recorded significant lower Phytate 1.27
(P<0.01) live weight .Dressing percentage of Trypsin inhibitors 17.97
rabbits fed 0%, 5% and 10% RKSM were Hemagglutinin 1.69
significantly higher than 15% and 20% .The Total oxalate 1.12
result of live weights recorded were higher than *Metabolizable Energy calculated according to the
the range of 1375.00 - 1650.00 g reported by formula of [46] . ME (kcal/kg) = 37 x % CP + 81 x %
[42].Dressing percentages observed were lower EE + 35.5 x % NFE
Table 3. Growth performance of weaner rabbits fed raw kapok seed meal
5
Wafar et al.; ARJA, 5(3): 1-8, 2017; Article no.ARJA.33431
Table 4. Nutrient digestibility of weaner rabbits fed raw kapok seed meal
Table 5. Carcass yield and internal organs of weaner rabbits fed raw kapok seed meal
4. CONCLUSION REFERENCES
The study showed that raw kapok seed meal has 1. Amao OA, Showunmi KA. Reproductive
rich nutrients composition and anti- nutritional characteristics of rabbit bucks fed diet
factors. The raw seed meals can be fed to containing raw or fermented cottonseed
weaner rabbit up to 10%. cake. British Biotechnology Journal. 2016;
10(3):1-7.
ETHICAL CONSIDERATION 2. Muriu JI, Njoka-Njiri EN, Tuitoek JN,
Nanua JN. Evaluation of sorghum
The study was conducted with permission from (Sorghum bicolor) as replacement of maize
the animal welfare and ethics committee of in the diet of growing rabbit (Oryctolagus
Department of Animal Production and Health, cuniculus). Asian-Australisian Journal of
Federal University Wukari, Taraba State Nigeria. Animal Science. 2002;15:565-569.
Ethical No.FU-LR-2017-023. 3. Enechi DC, Ugwu KK, Ugwu OPC, Omeh,
YS. Evaluation of the antinutrient levels of
COMPETING INTERESTS Ceiba pentandra leaves. International
Journal of Research and Review in
Authors have declared that no competing Pharmacy and Applied Science. 2013;
interests exist. 3(3):394.
6
Wafar et al.; ARJA, 5(3): 1-8, 2017; Article no.ARJA.33431
4. Anigo KM, Dauda BMD, Sallau AB, Chindo (Ceiba pentandra) seed and
IE. Chemical composition of Kapok (Ceiba physicochemical properties of its oil.
pentandra) seed and physicochemical Nigerian Journal of Basic and Applied
properties of its oil. Nigerian Journal of Science. 2012; 21(2):105.
Basic and Applied Science. 2012; 20. Heuzé V, Tran G. Kapok (Ceiba
21(2):105. pentandra). Feedipedia.org. A project by
5. Ari MM, Barde RE, Ogah MD, Yakubu A, INRA, CIRAD, AFZ and FAO.
Aya VE. Performance of broilers fed silk Available:http://www.trc.zootechnie.fr/node
cotton seed (Ceiba petandra) based diets /48
production. Agriculture Technology (Retrieved on September 9, 2011, 11:30)
Journal. 2011;7(2):20-28. 21. Ojewole GS, Okoye FC, Ukoha OA.
6. Rajaguru ASB, Ravindran V. Metabolisable Comparative utilization of three animal
energy values for growing chicks of some protein sources by broiler chickens. Int. J.
feedstuffs from Sri Lanka. J. Sci. Food poult. Sci. 2005;4:462-467.
Agric. 1985;36(1):1057-106. 22. Enujiugha VN, Agbede JO. Nutritional and
7. Thanu, K. Evaluation of kapok seed (Ceiba anti-nutritional characteristics of african oil
pentandra) as a feed ingredient in broiler bean (Pentaclethra Macrophylla Benth)
rations. M.V. Sc. Thesis. Tamil Nadu Seeds. Appl. Trop. Agric. 2000;5(1):11-14.
Agricultural University, Coimbatore, India. 23. Igene FU, Agbede JO, Omueti JO, Aletor
1981:45-78. VA. Nutrient and anti-nutrient composition
8. Kadirvel R, Natanam R, Udayasurian K. of raw and processed winged bean seeds
Use of kapok as apoultry feed. Poult. Sci. (Psophocarpus tetragonolus). Journal of
1986;65(12):2363-2365. Applied Science. 2001;4(4):2305-2318.
9. Narahari D, Asha Rajini R. Chemical 24. Osman MA. Effect of different processing
composition and nutritive value of kapol methods, on nutrient composition,
seed meal for broiler chickens. British antinutrional factors, and in vitro protein
Poultry Science. 2003;44:505-509. digestibility of dolichos lablab bean [Lablab
10. Taraba State Diary. State Annual Official purpuresus (L) Sweet]. Pakistan Journal of
Diary Reports; 2008. Nutrition. 2007;6(4):299-303.
11. AOAC. Association of Analytical Chemist. 25. Tuleun CD, Patrick JP. Effect of Duration
Official Methods of Analysis 17th Edition of cooking Mucuna utilis seed on
AOAC Ic, Arlington, Virginia, USA; 2000. proximate analysis, levels of anti-nutritional
12. Day RA, Underwood AL. Quantitative factors and performance of broiler
analysis. 5th ed. Prentice-Hall publication. chickens. Nigerian Journal of Animal
1986;701. Productio. 2007;34(1):45-53.
13. Reddy MB, Love M. The impact of food 26. Abeke FO, Ogundipe SO, Dafwang II,
processing on the nutritional quality of Sekoni AA, Abu A, Adeyinka. effect of
vitamins and mineral. Adv. Exp. Med. Boil. duration of cooking on the level of some
1999;459:99-106. anti-nutritional factors of nine varieties of
14. Birk Y, Bondi A, Gestetner B, Ishaya IA. Lablab purpureus bean. Nigerian Journal
Thermostable hemolytic factor in of Animal Production. 2008;35(2):217-223.
soybeans. Natural. 1963;197:1089-1090. 27. Aletor VA. Allelochemical in plant food and
15. Hudson BJ, EL-Difrawi EA. The feeding stuffs. Nutritional, biochemical and
sapogenins of the seeds of four lupin physio pathological aspects in animal
species. J. Plant Food. 1979;3:181-86. production. Vet. Hum Toxicol.1993;35:57-
16. Trease GE, Evans WC. A Text book of 67.
pharmacognosy. 11ed. Bailliere-Tindall, 28. Onochie BE. The Potential value of
London; 1978. soybean supplement in Nigerian diet.
17. SPSS. Statistical Package for Social Proceeding 3rd Annual conference of
Sciences. SPSS Inc; 2006. Agricultural Society of Nigeria.1965;4:43-
18. Hassan LG, Sokoto AM, Dangoggo SM, 46.
Ladan MJ. Proximate, amino acids and 29. Aletor VA. Anti-nutritional factors as
minerals compositions of silk cotton seeds nature’s paradox in food and
(Ceiba pentandra). African Journal of nutrition securities. Inaugural lecture
Natural Sciences. 2006;9:29-35. series 15 organized by The Federal
19. Anigo KM, Dauda BMD, Sallau AB, Chindo University of Technology, Akure.
IE. Chemical composition of Kapok 1999:12:10-15.
7
Wafar et al.; ARJA, 5(3): 1-8, 2017; Article no.ARJA.33431
30. Shaahu DT, Kaankuka FG, Okpanachi U. animal science association of Nigeria. Port
Proximate, amino acid, anti-nutritional Harcourt. 2016;845-849.
factor and mineral composition of different 37. Bagepallis S, Narasinga R, Tatinemi P.
varieties of raw Lablab purpureus seeds. Tannin contents of food commonly
International Journal of Scientific consumed in India and its influence on
&Ttechnology Research. 2015;4:157-161. ionizable iron. Journ. Sci. Fd. Agric. 1992;
31. Agbede JO, Aletor VA. Studies of the 33:89-96.
chemical composition and protein quality 38. Olomu JM. Monogastric animal nutrition:
of differently processed Canavalia Principles and practice. 1st edn. A Jachem
ensiformis and Mucuna pruriens seeed Publication, Benin city, Nigeria. 1995;157.
flours. Journal of Food Composition and 39. Sotelo AEC, Flores S. Nutritional values
Analysis. 2005;18:89-103. and content of anti-malnutrition
32. Ladeji O, Akim CU, Umaru HA. level of compounds and toxics in ten wild legumes
anti-nutritional factors in vegitables of Yucatan peninsula. Plant Foods for
commonly eaten in Nigeria. African Journal Human Nutrition.1995;47:115-123.
of Natural Sciences. 2004;7:71-73. 40. Reed JD. Condensed tannins, A factors
limiting the using of cassava forage.
33. Ahamefule FO. Evaluation of pigeon pea-
Journal of Science Food Agric. 2001;
cassava peel based diets for goats
33:213-217.
production in south-eastern Nigeria Ph.D.
41. Binita R, Khetarpaul N. Probiotic
thesis. College of Animal Science and
fermentation: Effect on anti-nutrients and
Animal Production, MOUAU, Umudike,
digestibility of starch and protein of
Nigeria; 2005.
indigenous developed food mixture. J.
34. Akinmutimi AH. Effect of cooking periods Nutr. Health. 1997;139-147.
on the nutrient composition of velvet beans 42. Eustace A, Iyayi O, Oluwakemi O, Odueso
(Mucuna pruscens). In: Proceeding of the M. Response of some metabolic and
32nd Annual conference of the Nigeria biochemical indices in rabbitsfed varying
society for animal production March 18th– levels of dietary cyanide. African Journal of
21st. University of Calabar, Calabar. Biomedical Research. 2003;6(1):43-47.
2007;223–236. 43. Okorie KC. The Effect of palmitic acid
35. Ologhobo AD, Apata DF, Oyejide A. fortified maize wet milling by-product on
Utilization of raw Jackbean (Canavalia the performance of weaner rabbits. Czech.
ensiformis) and jackbean fraction in diets J. Anim Sci. 2003;48(9):365-370.
for broiler chicks. Brit. Poultry Sci.1993;34: 44. Schrews FJG. Post mortem changes in
323–337. chicken muscle. World Poultry Science
36. Obun CO; Lalabe BC, Wafar RJ, Olusiyi, Journal. 2000;56:319-346.
JA, Ojinnaka EP. Effects of feeding broiler 45. Bone FJ. Anatomy and physiology of farm
nd
chicks differently processed Tallow animals. 2 Edn. Reston Publishing
(Detarium microcarpum, Guill and Sperr) Comp, Inc Virginia, USA. 1975;560.
seed meal on performance and blood 46. Pauzenga U. Feeding parent stock.
constituents. In: Ajayi FO, Akinola LAF, Zootech characteristics of weanling rabbits
Agaviezor BO, George OS, (Editors). In fed graded levels International. 1985;34:
proceedings 21 annual conference of 22-25.
_________________________________________________________________________________
© 2017 Wafar et al.; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original work is properly cited.
Peer-review history:
The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://sciencedomain.org/review-history/19937