Environmental

te
Engineering Concrete

le
deStructures - Introduction

William A. Wallace, P.E., SECB

 Topics
 Define environmental concrete structure
 Pictorial examples

te
 Historical stroll down memory lane (NRCS
based)

le
 WSD/ASD Flexural Model
de
 USD/LRFD Flexural Model
 The New Millennium (ACI 318, ACI 350,
and NRCS concrete design criteria side-
by-side)
NCSEA September 13, 2012 – Environmental Concrete Structures
2
What is an Environmental
Concrete Structure?
 Conveys, contains, impounds water,

te
and/or dissipates forces due to flowing
water

le
 Secondary containment for the storage of
de
hazardous wastes
 Designed to be watertight……..or
relatively so
 Serviceability limit states just as important
as strength (maybe more so at times) 3
Grade Control Structure

te
le
de

4
 de
le
te
5
 de
le
te
6
 de
le
te
7
 te
le
de

Natural Resources Conservation

Service 8
 de
le
te
9
 de
le
te
10
 de
le
te
11
 de
le
te
12
 de
le
te
13
 de
le
te
14
 In the Beginning
 SCS/NRCS National Engineering Handbook,

te
Section 6, Chapter 4, Concrete, circa 1950’s
 Referenced Chp VIII of Joint Committee Report

le
titled “Recommended Practice and Standard
Specifications for Concrete and Reinforced
de
Concrete”
 fc = 0.40 f’c, fs = 20 ksi, vc = 113 psi

 ρts = 0.2% exposed, 0.1% unexposed

15
Working Stress Design Flexural Model

te
le
de
Stress Distribution In Straight-Line Theory

Flexural Equations Development.pdf

 de
le
te
17
 de
le
te
18
 The 1960’s
 SCS/NRCS National Engineering Handbook,

te
Section 6, Chapter 4, Concrete, updated 1964
 Working Stress Design only

le
 References ACI 318-63
fc = 0.40 f’c, fs = 20 ksi, vc = 70 psi
de

 ρts = 0.3% exposed
 ρts = 0.2% exposed face & < 30ft joints
 ρts = 0.1% unexposed face & < 30ft joints

19
The 1970’s
 ACI 318-71 primarily uses SD, but allows an

te
Alternate Design Method (ADM) based on WSD
 ACI 318-71 introduces z-values for crack control

le
 ACI 318-77 moves ADM to Appendix
ACI 350R-77 “Concrete Sanitary Engr
de

Structures” recommends WSD from ACI 318-64,
but uses lower allowable stresses and z-values

20
STRESS AND STRAIN DISTRIBUTION
USD/LRFD

te
le
de

Flexural Equations Development.pdf

 de
le
te
22
 de
le
te
23
 The 1980’s
 SCS Technical Release No. 67 “Reinforced
Concrete Strength Design” published 1980

te
 Based on ACI 318-77 SD modified to produce

le
similar design proportions as NEH 6 WSD
 Modifications include higher load factors, limited
de
design yield strengths, lower z-values, and lower
maximum reinforcing steel ratio
 SCS NEH-6 revised 1980 to include z-value
criteria

24
The 1980’s
 ACI 350R-83 adopts SD modified to produce

te
similar design proportions as ACI 350R-77 WSD
 Modification is mainly sanitary durability factor

le
(load factor multiplier)
 ACI 350 reorganized and renamed
de
“Environmental Engineering Concrete
Structures”
 ACI 350 starts drafting a Code document based
on previous Report and dependent on ACI 318
Code 25
 The 1990’s
 ACI 318 deletes ADM from the Code, but allows

te
use of ADM as published in previous Codes
 ACI 350 continues to redraft and reballot a Code

le
document
 ACI 350 defines Environmental Engineering
de
Concrete Structures as including “…ancillary
structures for dams, spillways, and channels.”

26
 Evolution of SCS/NRCS

te
Concrete Design
le
de
The New Millennium
 New Millennium
Comparison of ACI 318-99, ACI 350-01, and NRCS TR 67

 ACI 318-99 replaced z-value with direct

te
calculation for steel spacing
 ACI 350-01 was an update to ACI 318-95
nomenclature
le
de
 Placed lower limits on z-values
 Introduced service durability factors to be
applied to factored load effects
 NRCS TR 67 – no change
ACI 350-06 Concrete Protection for Reinforcement.pptx 28
ACI 350-06 Concrete Protection
for Reinforcement

te
le
de
 Comparison of ACI 318-99, ACI 350-01, and NRCS TR 67
ACI 318-99 ACI 350-01 NRCS TR-67 1980

Load Factor 1.4(D+F) + 1.7(L+H) 1.4(D) + 1.7(F+L+H) 1.8(D) + 1.8(L+H)

1.3 – flexure & shear

Durability Factor N/A N/A
1.65 – axial tension

Crack control,  540 

te
s     2.5cc Z = 115 kips/in Z = 130 kips/in
normal exposure  fs 

Crack control, severe

le
N/A Z = 95 kips/in N/A
exposure

Max spacing, s 18 inches 12 inches 18 inches

de
f`c 3,000 psi 4,000 psi 4,000 psi

fy 60,000 psi 60,000 psi 40,000 psi

fs as high as 36,000 psi 27,000 psi 20,000 psi

ρdesign only upper limit of 0.75ρb only upper limit of 0.75ρb ρshy = 0.31ρb

ρmin 0.00333 0.00333 0.00500

Min T & S ratio 0.0018 0.0030 0.0030

ACI 350-01&06 Exposure Definitions.pptx 30

ACI 350-06 Exposure Definition

te
le
de
 New Millennium
Comparison of ACI 318-02, ACI 350-01, and NRCS TR 67

 ACI 318-02 introduced major changes

te
 Unified Design and net tensile strain
 Introduced ASCE 7 Load Factors

le
 Phi-factor revisions
de
 ACI 350-01 – no change
 NRCS TR 67 – no change

32
ACI LOAD FACTORS & DESIGN LOADS, U

U = 1.4(D + F) (9-1)

te
U = 1.2(D + F + T) + 1.6(L + H) + 0.5(Lr or S or R) (9-2)
U = 1.2D + 1.6(Lr or S or R) + (1.0L or 0.8W) (9-3)
U = 1.2D + 1.6W + 1.0L + 0.5(Lr or S or R) (9-4)

le
U = 1.2D + 1.0E + 1.0L + 0.2S (9-5)
U = 0.9D ± 1.6W + 1.6H (9-6)
de
U = 0.9D ± 1.0E + 1.6H (9-7)
D = dead load; E = earthquake load; F = lateral fluid pressure load
H = load due to the weight and lateral pressure of soil and water in soil
L = live load; Lr = roof load; R = rain load; S = snow load
T = self-straining force such as creep, shrinkage, and temperature effects
W = wind load
 STRENGTH REDUCTION FACTOR, φ

Tension controlled sections 0.9

te
Compression controlled sections with ties 0.65

Compression controlled sections with spirals 0.70

le
Columns with small axial loads 0.65 – 0.9 or
de
0.70 – 0.9

Shear and Torsion 0.75

Bearing on concrete 0.65

Unified Design Definitions

te
dt

le
T
de
T = Net Tensile Strain
dt = Depth to Extreme Tension Steel
Note: d = dt for single layer of tension steel
10.3.3-4 - STRAIN CONDITIONS

c = 0.003 0.003 0.003

te
c c
c
dt

le
de
t  0.002 0.002  t  0.005 t  0.005

Compression Transition Tension-

Controlled Controlled
c0.6dt c0.375dt
 Comparison of ACI 318-02, ACI 350-01, and NRCS TR 67
ACI 318-02 ACI 350-01 NRCS TR-67 1980

1.4(D+F)
Load Factor 1.4(D) + 1.7(F+ L+H) 1.8(D) + 1.8(L+H)
1.2(D+F) + 1.6(L+H)

1.3 – flexure and shear

Durability Factor N/A N/A
1.65 – axial tension

Crack control, normal  540 

te
s     2.5cc Z = 115 kips/in Z = 130 kips/in
exposure
 s 
f

Crack control, severe

N/A Z = 95 kips/in N/A
exposure

le
Max spacing, s 18 inches 12 inches 18 inches

f`c 4,000 psi 4,000 psi 4,000 psi

de
fy 60,000 psi 60,000 psi 40,000 psi

fs as high as 36,000 psi 27,000 psi 20,000 psi

ρdesign only upper limit of ρt only upper limit of 0.75ρb ρshy = 0.31ρb

ρmin 0.00333 0.00333 0.00500

Min T & S ratio 0.0018 0.0030 0.0030

ACI 350-06 Minimum T&S Steel.pptx

37
ACI 350-06 Minimum T&S Steel

te
le
de
 New Millennium
Comparison of ACI 318-05, ACI 350-01, and NRCS TR 67

 ACI 318-05 introduced minor changes

te
 Unified the notations and definitions
 Revised service level stress for flexure to

le
40,000 psi
de
 ACI 350-01 – no change
 NRCS TR 67 – no change

39
 Comparison of ACI 318-05, ACI 350-01, and NRCS TR 67
ACI 318-05 ACI 350-01 NRCS TR-67 1980

1.4(D+F)
Load Factor 1.4(D) + 1.7(F+L+H) 1.8(D) + 1.8(L+H)
1.2(D+F) + 1.6(L+H)

1.3 – flexure and shear

Durability Factor N/A N/A
1.65 – axial tension

te
Crack control, normal  40,000 
s  15   2.5cc Z = 115 kips/in Z = 130 kips/in
exposure  fs 

le
Crack control, severe
N/A Z = 95 kips/in N/A
exposure

Max spacing, s
de 18 inches 12 inches 18 inches

f`c 4,000 psi 4,000 psi 4,000 psi

fy 60,000 psi 60,000 psi 40,000 psi

fs as high as 40,000 psi 27,000 to 30,000 psi 20,000 psi

ρdesign only upper limit of ρt only upper limit of 0.75ρb ρshy = 0.31ρb

ρmin 0.00333 0.00333 0.00500

Min T & S ratio 0.0018 0.0030 0.0030

40
 New Millennium
Comparison of ACI 318-05, ACI 350-06, and NRCS TR 67

 ACI 318-05 – no change

te
 ACI 350-06 updated to ACI 318-02
nomenclature

le
 Durability factor as a function of steel yield
and service level stresses
de ACI 350-06 Durability Factor.pptx

 Maximum bar spacing a function of steel

stress, bar size, allowable crack width, and 2
inch max. clear cover ACI 350-06 Max Stress vs Spacing.pptx

 NRCS TR 67 – no change
41
ACI 350-06 Durability Factor

te
le
de
ACI 350-06 Max Stress vs Spacing

te
le
de
 Comparison of ACI 318-05, ACI 350-06, and NRCS TR 67
ACI 318-05 ACI 350-06 TR-67 1980

1.4(D+F) 1.4(D+F)
Load Factor 1.8D+1.8(L+H)
1.2(D+F)+1.6(L+H) 1.2 (D+F) + 1.6(L+H)

f y
Durability Factor N/A Sd   1.0 N/A
f s

te
Crack control, normal  40,000  320
s  15   2.5cc fs,max  20ksi   36ksi Z = 130 kips/in
exposure
 fs   s2  42  db / 22

le
Crack control, severe 260
N/A fs,max 17ksi   36ksi N/A
exposure  s  42  db / 2
2 2

Max spacing, s 18 inches 12 inches 18 inches

de
f`c 4,000 psi 4,000 psi 4,000 psi

fy 60,000 psi 60,000 psi 40,000 psi

fs as high as 40,000 psi based on bar spacing as above 20,000 psi

ρdesign only upper limit of ρt only the upper limit of ρt ρshy = 0.31ρb

ρmin 0.00333 0.00333 0.0050

Min T & S ratio 0.00180 0.0030 0.0030

44
 New Millennium
Comparison of ACI 318-08, ACI 350-06, and NEH 636.30

 ACI 318-08 – changes to combined

te
bending and axial force design procedure
 ACI 350-06 – no change

le
 NRCS NEH 636, Chapter 30 – draft 2008
de
 Incorporates ACI 350-06 and ACI 318-08
 Tensile steel stress of 20,000 psi
 Max. steel ratio of 0.546ρbal
 fy = 60,000 psi
45
 Comparison of ACI 318-08, ACI 350-06, and NEH 636.30
ACI 318-08 ACI 350-06 NEH 636.30 2008

1.4(D+F) 1.4(D+F) 1.4(D+F)

Load Factor
1.2(D+F)+1.6(L+H) 1.2 (D+F) + 1.6(L+H) 1.2 (D+F) + 1.6(L+H)

f y f y
Durability Factor N/A Sd   1 .0 Sd   1 .0
f s f s

 40,000 320  320 

2
 d 
2
Crack control, s  15   2.5cc fs,max 20ksi  36ksi

te
s     4 2  b 
normal exposure
 f s   s2  42 db / 22  fs    2

260

le
Crack control,
N/A fs,max 17ksi   36ksi Special Design required
severe exposure de  s2  42  db / 22

Max spacing, s 18 inches 12 inches 12 inches

f`c 4,000 psi 4,000 psi 4,000 psi

fy 60,000 psi 60,000 psi 60,000 psi

fs as high as 40,000 psi based on bar spacing as above 20,000 psi

ρdesign only upper limit of ρt only the upper limit of ρt ρshy = 0.546ρb

ρmin 0.00333 0.00333 0.00333

Min T&S ratio 0.00180 0.0030 0.0030

46
 ACI 318-08, Chapter 4
Table 4.2.1.a Exposure Category F – Freezing and thawing exposure
Class Description Condition

F0 Not applicable Concrete not exposed to freezing and thawing cycles

te
Concrete exposed to freezing and thawing cycles and occasional exposure to
F1 Moderate
moisture

Concrete exposed to freezing and thawing cycles and in continuous contact with
F2 Severe
moisture

le
Concrete exposed to freezing and thawing cycles that will be in continuous contact
F3 Very Severe
with moisture and exposure to deicing chemicals
de
Table 4.2.1.b Exposure Category S – Sulfate exposure
Water-soluble sulfate (SO4) in soil, percent
Class Description Sulfate (SO4) in water, ppm
by weight
S0 Not applicable SO4 <0.10 SO4 <150

150 ≤ SO4 <1500

S1 Moderate 0.10 ≤ SO4 <0.20
Seawater

S2 Severe 0.20 ≤ SO4 ≤ 2.00 1500 ≤ SO4 ≤10,000

S3 Very severe SO4 >2.00 SO4 >10,000

47
ACI 318-08, Chapter 4 (cont’d)

Table 4.2.1.c Exposure Category P – In contact with water requiring low permeability concrete

te
Class Description Condition

P0 Not applicable Concrete where low permeability to water is not required

le
P1 Required Concrete required to have low permeability to water
de
Table 4.2.1.d Exposure Category C – Conditions requiring corrosion protection of reinforcement
Class Description Condition
C0 Not applicable Concrete that will be dry or protected from moisture in service
C1 Moderate Concrete exposed to moisture but not to external source of chlorides in service

Concrete exposed to moisture and an external source of chlorides in service – from deicing
C2 Severe
chemicals, salt, brackish water, seawater, or spray from these sources

48
fc'

Table 4.3.1.a For Exposure Category F – Freezing and thawing exposure

Exposure Max Min

Additional Minimum Requirements
Class w/cm psi

F0
- - -
F1
0.45 4500 Table 4.4.1 -

te
F2 -
0.45 4500 Table 4.4.1
F3 Table 4.4.2
0.45 4500 Table 4.4.1

le
Table 4.3.1.b For Exposure Category S – Sulfate exposure

Required Cementitious Materials* - Types

Exposure Max Min Additional
Class w/cm psi Requirements
de ASTM C 150 ASTM C 595 ASTM C 1157

S0 - - - - - -
IP(MS),
S1 0.50 4000 II†** MS -
IS(<70)(MS)

No calcium chloride
S2 0.45 4500 V** - HS
admixtures

V + pozzolan HS + pozzolan No calcium chloride

S3 0.45 4500 -
or slag‡ or slag‡ admixtures

49
fc'

Table 4.3.1.c For Exposure Category P – In contact with water requiring low permeability
concrete

Exposure Max Min

Additional Minimum Requirements
Class w/cm psi

-
P0 - -

te
-
P1 0.50 4000

Table 4.3.1.d For Exposure Category C – Conditions requiring corrosion protection of reinforcement

le
Additional
Exposure Max Min Max water-soluble chloride ion (Cl−) content in
Minimum
Class w/cm psi concrete, percent by weight of cement†
Requirement
de
Reinforced Concrete
C0 - - 1.00 -
C1 - - 0.30 -
C2 0.40 5000 0.15 Cover
Prestressed Concrete
C0 - - 0.06 -
C1 - - 0.06 -
C2 0.40 5000 0.06 Cover

50
TABLE 4.4.1—TOTAL AIR CONTENT FOR CONCRETE EXPOSED TO CYCLES OF FREEZING AND THAWING
Air content, percent

Nominal maximum aggregate size, in.*

Exposure Class F2 and F3 Exposure Class F1

3/8 7.5 6

1/2 7 5.5

3/4 6 5

1 6 4.5

te
1-1/2 5.5 4.5

2† 5 4

le
3† 4.5 3.5

TABLE 4.4.2—REQUIREMENTS FOR CONCRETE SUBJECT TO EXPOSURE CLASS F3

Maximum percent of
de total cementitious
Cementitious materials materials by weight*

Fly ash or other pozzolans conforming to 25

ASTM C 618

Slag conforming to ASTM C 989 50

Silica fume conforming to ASTM C 1240 10

Total of fly ash or other pozzolans, slag, and 50†

silica fume

Total of fly ash or other pozzolans and silica 35†

fume

51
ACI 350-06 Chapter 4

te
le
de

52
ACI 350-06 Chapter 4

te
le
de

53
ACI 350-06 Chapter 4

te
le
de

54
ACI 350-06 Chapter 4

te
le
de

55
ACI 350-06 Chapter 4

te
le
de

56
 Environmental

te
Engineering Concrete

le
Structures
de
Flexural Design Eq’ns
 te
le
de

Design Strength Curves for Grade 60 Steel 58

 Basic Design Equations
New NRCS NEH 636.30: For f`c = 4 ksi and fy = 60 ksi
Hydraulic Structures: L.F.effective = 2.7
fs = 20 ksi ρmax = 0.01556

te
15.721  Mu
dmin 

le
b
de
Mu
As 
3.843dmin

Mu is in k-ft; b and d are in inches

 Basic Design Equations
Environmental Structure: For f`c = 4 ksi and fy = 60 ksi
Normal Exposure: L.F.effective = 2.25
fs = 24 ksi ρmax = 0.01402

te
18.09  Mu

le
dmin 
b
de
Mu
As 
3.943dmin

Mu is in k-ft; b and d are in inches

 Basic Design Equations
Environmental Structure: For f`c = 4 ksi and fy = 60 ksi
Normal Exposure: L.F.effective = 1.6
fs = 36 ksi ρmax = 0.00852

te
28.22  Mu

le
dmin 
b
de
Mu
As 
4.16dmin

Mu is in k-ft; b and d are in inches

Reinforced Concrete Wall Design-EECS ACI 350-06 with fsmax = 24ksi h
ACI 350-06 fs = 24 ksi

te
le
de

62
 de
le
te
63
 de
le
te
64
 de
le
te
65
 de
le
te
66
 de
le
te
67
 de
le
te
68
 te
le
de

Natural Resources Conservation

Service 69
 de
le
te
70
 de
le
te
71
 de
le
te
72
 te
le
de

Natural Resources Conservation

Service 73
 de
le
te
74
 de
le
te
75
 THANKS FOR
PARTICIPATING!

te
le
William A. Wallace, P.E., SECB
de

NCSEA September 13, 2012 - Environmental Concrete Structures 76