Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Other Garden: Influence and Motif On The Book of Habakkuk and Other Poems
The Other Garden: Influence and Motif On The Book of Habakkuk and Other Poems
Introduction
In her 2011 New York Times article, Marilyn Robinson discusses the influence of
the Bible on Western literature, whether the allusions from the biblical stories are
medieval thought and its culture, eventually taking hold of Dante’s imagination,
considered as the greatest poet of the Middle Ages, its influence evident on one of the
greatest books produced by the West, Divina Commedia. Moreover, Kleinhez (1986)
mentions Charles Singleton’s remark on how Dante followed the Bible closely that the
latter chose to “imitate God’s way of writing.” In addition, the literary, intellectual, and
theological bases of Divina Commedia are formed in the pattern of traditional Biblical
hermeneutics (Kleinhez, 1986). The Western thought, the limning of its narrative in
making sense of experiences not captured by traditional history, for it is the ordinary,
the insignificant that veils our direct view of the cosmic irony, is but a byproduct of the
paper. But to remark that the Bible is not enough of a material as a reference for literary
aspirations is bordering on ignorance. C. S. Lewis (1950) argues that the Bible does not
only serve as a sacred text and source, but a force which imposes on Western culture,
conditioning its thought and language and eventually influencing English literature.
The creation of The Book of Habakkuk and Other Poems can be traced to the personal
history of the proponent in a time when there was barely a book to read but the Bible.
The material poverty became the source of hunger for knowledge, the itch for the search
for that irresistible allusion which is found on the Good Book. On the other hand, the
narratives found on the scripture inform the proponent of the poverty of his
imaginative reach, thus, cementing the foundation of the proponent’s subsequent quest
for the grand tropes. Both the literal and figurative scarcity the proponent had to go
through compensated for the narrative force that would keep the imagination on check,
repeating and reimagining images out of the events which unfold in the Garden of
Eden; arranging and rearranging the sequence of actions of the tryst between Man,
Woman and Satan, which is an implicatory agent on the proponent’s repetitive reach
for a singular motif. The continued echoing of the fall of Adam and Eve on the
the easy access to everything that there is to know, stimulus that can be had in a click
seem too good to be true; that all information that bombard our senses can be
misjudged for the light which might spark work. The creative writing process does not
only rely on sheer will and effort; most of the time for the process to see through its
completion, the intuitive aspect of work, the one which poets all through the ages call
Muse is evoked, almost like a supplication. Here is the dimension of the creative
process that belongs to the magical, the other face of the coin that is equal in importance
to hard work, the dimension that cannot be measured and assessed in numbers. Sheer
will and effort are the energies that sustain inspiration, and these are factors that thus
far push the process to its trajectory. But inspiration is the seed that is planted in the
initial stage of work, and it is the invisible hands that cradle ideas into the first scream
of a child, shaping and conveying these ideas into a form palpable—a thing that can be
experienced.
Inspiration is one thing; the force that takes the spotlight, the very thing that
artists swear upon. It is the word, which is mentioned with reverence, as if the creator of
craft does not understand the pain that accompanies work. Inspiration is like the honey
that comes out of the artist’s mouth—it is as if the only thing that matter for work to
slowly move forward, or the vision to leap toward a considered aim from its initial
the origin of their idea the question revolves around the keyword, inspiration. Influence
as a subject related to the creative process is oftentimes relegated in the backseat, the
one that is rarely mentioned because, the proponent suspects, it does not trigger the
Influence as an aspect in the creative writing process is greatly different than that
of inspiration. The paper would not be sifting through the fine granules of semantics
here. The proponent considers influence a more interesting factor because of its inherent
dimension which can be measured through the specific study of the precursor poems
inquiry to the very core of existence, and its determination to surrender to the absurd.
authors to give birth to our literary father. This act of misinterpretation, misreading is
an important stage in the creative process of a writer who is too late to name things
which are already named. Those who must do the act of writing starts the work with
reading.
No strong writer gives birth to a child – for the father devours the children at
their inception. Strong precursors are like Oedipus’ father, abandoning the posterity to
the whims of fate. They would not allow a foundling to challenge them of their position
they hold dear in the imaginative space within the realm of literature. Thus, it is
incumbent upon the proponent to fantasize for that father so big to emulate. Thus, the
work begins for the quest of a father through reading the writer of Genesis. It is the
writer of Genesis’ imaginative energies the proponent heeds as the voice that echoes
prayers.
neurosis which is a salient feature in the giving birth to a father. The initial stage of
influence is in the reading or misreading of the chosen father. Then, the proponent
would limn the language, even the cadence, which it seems possessed of the artistic
father’s creative genius. It is in the writing process that everything must come full circle
in the imaginative adventure that is undertaken. In this stage, the desire for that father
who we can mold the self to his image is the strongest. This is the part of the family
romance where the fantasized precursor (godlike stature, of noble lineage, etc.) appears
phosphorescent, where the influence glows the most. It is also on this stage where there
is a strong sense of the mortal error, the knowledge that there will never be an absolute
grasp of the precursor’s fullness; yet the knowledge for work to continue is as
significant as ever. The way the proponent misinterprets his strong precursor through
imaginative soul, the impact of the landing is quite emotionally and psychologically
what is stated prior, that the work of giving birth to a father starts with reading, the
metaphorical father, the writer of the Genesis, is a revisionary one. The proponent
imagines angles and possibilities, the temporal and tonal direction of the poems The
Moreover, the proponent will discuss on this paper how motif holds together The
Book of Habakkuk and Other Poems. The proponent intends to write about the recurring
idea found on the collection of poems mentioned above. From these poems, this motif
will be analyzed and discussed. According to Suzana Berger (2013), an assistant director
for the play Endgame, Harold Pinter, a contemporary of Samuel Beckett, admired the
latter’s style so much that something of Beckett’s texture appear in his own work. The
idea the proponent emphasizes is his poetry draws from his early reading of the Bible.
Just like Samuel Beckett’s treatment of the Scripture through his use of allusions and
inconsistent, ambiguous, and irresponsible, and his concept of the ideas of God and the
way he emphasized on nothingness and God’s mystical silence is quite ludicrous, the
proponent has an ambiguous relationship with one of the most fascinating narratives
found on the book of Genesis. The story of Adam and Eve and their eventual
banishment from the Garden continues to interest the proponent through the years.
Adam, the one chosen as the head of the overseers of all creation on earth, whose
privilege is endowed the moment God’s breath entered his pre-human form, had to be
taken aback and experienced, for the first time in humanity, the unnerving clarity of
doubt. What made Eve share the forbidden fruit of knowledge to Adam? What
motivated Adam to partake on such cursed and doomed endeavor in the first place?
Jessica Martin, in a 2012 article for The Guardian, observes that in Milton’s Paradise
Lost, it is the sharing of the same significance, Eve had to share to Adam, her mortal co-
partner, the stewardship of the limited knowledge of mankind. More than the shared
experience of doom, which Eve in her solution to their confounding state proposed to
seek Death head-on, she dreaded the idea of loneliness in the face of mortality—Adam
staying immortal and then choosing for himself a new partner to manage the paradise
This recurring motif, in the form of alternative narrative of the Garden, is what
holds the proponent’s poems through the years. John Milton versifies in Paradise Lost
(1667), on how Adam decided on his “heroic choice,” a sacrificial offering of his
privileged lot, anticipating despair and doom. The proponent imagines a narrative
closer to the human condition: tragic, ephemeral, yet mesmerizing at the same time.
There is a difference between a motif and theme. Themes represent the main
question behind the series of events that hold together a narrative. The recurring
element that leads to the discovery of the theme is hinted through motif. In the several
poems in question, the recurring element is the proponent’s imagined alternative of the
story of the Garden. Perhaps what the proponent is trying to hint on is not the mortal
chain which binds Man and Woman, but the metaphorical journey humanity had to
embark upon and endure. The itch that kept humanity wandering is the core of this
journey motif. It is not the physical banishment from the Paradise that appeals to
imagination but the very idea it suggests, the metaphoric or symbolic arc. Moreover,
this recurring motif is indisputable for in the poems the three most important characters
are featured: Adam, Eve and Satan. The motif hints though to the expansion of Self. The
paper is going to argue that this journey motif is not only about an anticipation of
despair and doom but the struggle for the search of knowledge and the triumph of
reason. The motif is a direct influence from the self-banishment the proponent
The Book of Habakkuk and Other Poems is a collection of poems that highlights
motif which spans several years of writing. This singular motif which takes place across
the collection, adds to the deeper meaning of the work. It is the story in the Garden of
Eden—the love between Adam and Eve and their eventual fall, and the temptation
The paper also discusses influence, particularly the influence of the story of the
metaphorical leap on the poems in the collection. Specifically, the paper aims to answer
1. How does the use of motif add to the deeper meaning of the work?
2. What impact has the Garden of Eden narrative on the motif which recurs
3. How does the Garden of Eden story influence The Book of Habakkuk and Other
Poems?
This study does not aim to analyze the poetic elements of The Book of Habakkuk
and Other Poems. Rather, this study aims to add to the already rich discourse on the use
of motif as an idea as a supplemental element to the work’s larger meaning. This paper
also discusses the influence of the Bible, specifically, the Garden of Eden narrative, as
influence and the eventual employment of a motif derived from the Bible, the study
grounds its discussion in the commonplace experience which is the human condition
Lastly, the study discusses influence and motif throughout the collection, the text
Reading, as well as writing, are both a very lonely endeavor. These two activities
go hand in hand for a work in the creative sphere to flourish. Just like how John
Berryman depicts his quest for the historical Christ and the Christian origins as a
thematic concern in the Dream Songs (Rogers, 2004), the proponent’s focus is on the
influence of the Old Testament, particularly the narrative of Adam and Eve. The study
will add to the already rich discourse on literary influence and how this influence shape
The influence of the Garden narrative provides metaphorical material and leap
for the proponent. The many iterations and alternative renderings of the temptation of
Satan and the eventual fall of Adam and Eve becomes a motif spread across The Book of
Habakkuk and Other Poems. The alternative narrative of the Garden richly imagined by
the proponent in a form of a motif adds deeper meaning to the collection of poems.
Through this imaginative endeavor, the proponent aspires to add to the vast material of
In 2002, under the record labels Ill Will and Columbia, the American rapper
Nasir bin Olu Dara Jones, or more popularly known as Nas, released his sixth studio
album called The Lost Tapes. In this album Nas, whose previous works were so
entrenched to gangsta rap themes of the day, swerved for the more socially conscious
and philosophical direction. One of the songs in the album, No Idea’s Original, lyrically
expressed what has been thought about of the creative process (by artists and thinkers
alike) regarding the idea of influence over one’s creative endeavor. Thus, Nas’ compact
bars have acknowledged the belated attempt of this thesis in mapping the unavoidable
influence imposed upon by strong precursors toward their unwanted progeny, when in
the song he opens with lines which explicitly reverberate the question of creative
originality: “No idea’s original, there’s nothing new under the sun/ It’s never what you do, but
supplication for the continuous grace of ideas from intuition rather than a pedagogical
attempt of making sense of the creative process. After all, inspiration is the springboard
where ideas make a leap, like an emotional quickening that forces one to have faith in
something that may amount to nothing when finally put in the process of forming. In
reveals the creative process of the genius behind some of the greatest films produced by
Studio Ghibli, Inc. In its first episode, Ponyo is Here, Hayao Miyazaki dreamed up of
characters that struggled to wriggle out of the long shadow cast by his most powerful
creation, Totoro, in the iconic film My Neighbor Totoro. The documentary shows the
through the storyboards like any legendary film director is expected of. But he suffered
disjointed attempts to consolidate the forces that would hold together the film, Ponyo on
the Cliff by the Sea, as doubts crept in, for the legendary film director had no idea how
the film would unfold. In the documentary film (Kaku, 2019), Hayao Miyazaki
similar to dropping a fishing line in his brain. When everything seemed falling apart
and work in glacial pace, the legendary director, who is one of the most compelling
installing a camcorder inside his car and driving around the city. When work has
reached a point where it does not go anywhere, just as the documentary points how
Miyazaki has to contend with “a cloud of constant doubt and anxiety,” the filmmaker
would let sleep takeover as a welcome reprieve. As an artist who understands that the
approach to creative process is more metaphorical than systematic (of course there is
always a pattern for every creative), Hayao Miyazaki swears by to his prolific mantra:
“Inspiration is everything.” Understanding that talent gets worn out from constant use
and as one advances with age, inspiration is not enough to achieve a particular vision
that Hayao Miyazaki wants for his current film. The trip to England proved fruitful as it
gave him insights on how his films should look; on the aesthetic level where the visual
is the first emotive conjurer, the very first thing that arrests attention. The painting by
John Everett Millais, Ophelia, transfixed Hayao Miyazaki on how elaborate and rich the
details were and the ‘subtle changes these details achieved as light is rendered in
different amount to the painting.’ This startling revelation at the Tate Britain Art
Museum gave him not only an inspiration for a vision, but more importantly the
experience was a stunning influence on how he catalyzed the revamp on the way Studio
Ghibli did their animation. The influence of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood on Hayao
Miyazaki led him to acknowledging that he and his team reached a dead end, and that
they have to act upon on the idea provided by the 18th century English artists on their
Oleynick, Thrash, Lefew and Kieffaber (2014) conclude: “Writers, artists, and other
inspiration, according to Oleynick et. al (2014), that “fire the soul and inspire the idea
actualization process.” But when the soul is fired and steps are to be made for the
actualization of idea to occur, it is influence that sets the gears clicking and turning, the
sum of all parts in unison to achieve that specific goal that is before the artist. One can
a convoluted novel about a house with an infinite hallway, etc. In a world where we
take it upon ourselves the process of creation in a degree comparable to that of deities,
that it becomes so manifest we lose the sense of the rigid dichotomy of being human,
we make ourselves susceptible to inspiration of any kind that quickens our emotion, yet
our resolve for a consolidated action needs a decisive spark for an actualization to take
place. At this point, our intimate knowledge of our precursors’ creations provides for us
that measured and observable actions which we can use to initiate actualization. That
spark is no longer the thought intuition that is necessary in the early stage of creative
process, but rather the other spark which provides blueprint for the construction of idea
into a thing that is concrete. Here is the moment where influence, an artist’s
idea.
borrowed on the idea of the spherical shape of Earth, which is based on the calculations
Dante imagined for Hell is inspired by the geological features that perhaps he may have
visited when he lived in the nearby city of Verona, which he described using the
riverbanks of the Adige due to a landslide, provided concrete features for his imaginary
space that Dante would later fill with characters, themes and aesthetic. According to
Dar (2013) in his study, Influence of Islam on Dante’s Divine Comedy, the story of
Ascension of the Prophet Muhammad in Miraj Nama may have possibly influenced in
the outlining of the Divine Comedy. Dar (2013) continues that by writing the Divine
Comedy, Dante attempted to have a Christian literature that could surpass any Arabic
literature by featuring the Prophet Muhammad condemned in one of the nine circles of
hell. The similarities of Dante’s journey in the underworld and the ascension in heaven
and descent into hell of the Prophet clearly illustrates an influence in the religious
imagination of the poet by emulating the structure of the story coming from the
Arabian Peninsula yet using it against the Islamic faith to try to undermine his source
material.
In Ludwig van Beethoven’s case, he used Mozart’s concertos as models for his
own and studied and copied them to emulate the latter’s musical process, thereby,
becoming the most significant influence in Beethoven’s studies (Krebs, 2018). In the
paper, The Compositional Influence of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart on Ludwig van Beethoven’s
Early Period Works, Krebs (2018) argues that influence is unavoidable although
Beethoven tried not to copy the great masters around his time, like how intertextuality
could not be prevented in written texts, Ludwig van Beethoven’s music tends to sound
through specific or directive force which can be enumerated in this section on and on.
But the proponent declines to continue with more examples and close this section with
a brief discussion on how One Thousand and One Nights or The Arabian Nights exerted
heavy influence on Western literature and thought. According to Fahd (2012), the
inception of English fiction came about through the participation of the Arabian Nights.
Moreover, Fahd (2012) illustrates how Gulliver’s Travels or Robinson Crusoe reflects
Sinbad’s adventures which one may safely remark that latter works may not exist as a
“I am aware that it may be vain labor, up Sinai all the way, as it were, to seek a
In his 2014 article in The Washington Times, Leland Ryken discusses how the Bible
is central in the literature of both England and America, a primary material source and
influence that is a cohesive factor for West’s literary development. Moreover, Ryken
(2014) substantiates his claim through his example of Caedmon’s Hymn, believed to be
the oldest extant English literary piece, modeled on the Book of Psalms, and directly
Savage (2008) describes how Allen Ginsberg’s poem, Howl, echoes Old
Testament prophets though its poetic voice, and the various aspects of its structure
illicit several Hebrew prayers. Furthermore, the prophetic voice Allen Ginsberg
employs that haunts the metaphorical landscape of the poem Howl, coupled with
structure that goes against the ‘modernist control and precision,’ proceeds with a
(Savage, 2008). Howl is the metaphorical voice that reverberates in the wilderness that is
the American landscape—the voice that rages, wails, howls as it complains and warns
America of the biblical heathen god of fire, Moloch, a god that asks for the blood of
children, compared to technocracy which is the poem’s concentrated fury is all about
all on the line when he supported Allen Ginsberg’s Howl at its obscenity trial.
expression of dissidence through colloquial English, which he hoped that many people
would find the language, and also courage, to snap out of the trance brought about by
consumer culture. In his poem Christ Climbed Down, Lawrence Ferlinghetti (1958) draws
heavily from the Gospel the crucified image of Christ, subsequently limning a poetic
climbed down from his cross and undid the familiar Christian narrative:
this year
He awaits again
an unimaginable
and impossibly
Immaculate Reconception
Second Comings
of the ironists, whether “the very craziest of / Second Comings” is realized or not, it is
enough that its wry humor can be traced to the tone of the Old Testament.
In 1964, the publication of 77 Dream Songs was the turning point of John
on a poetic adventure through the poetry collection. Eventually, the year after, it won
the Pulitzer Prize for Poetry, which according to the New Critics is a series of
improvisations recounted by its main narrator Henry, solely based on John Berryman’s
life—the dilemma with his own identity, the pangs of being a middling poet, and the
poet’s fight for survival (Kedar, 2013). Nevertheless, the influence of the Bible,
especially the New Testament is its main source of material. Thomas Andrew Rogers
(2004) discusses how unpublished material from 77 Dream Songs reveals the paramount
thematic concern of the collection, which is the search for Christian origins. Moreover,
due to the scarce historical record on the life and teachings of Jesus Christ (canonical or
apocryphal), John Berryman concentrated his research interest in the Scriptures (Rogers,
2004). In Dream Song 2, John Berryman illustrates an act of defiance by invoking the
Biblical Garden of Eden, insisting that theology must be denied for human progress to
take place (Butler, 2015). Additionally, Dream Song 1 is John Berryman’s song of
sympathy towards humanity as it describes the loss of innocence and the banishment
consumption of the fruit in the Tree of Knowledge ‘enforced by the menace of death’
Harold Bloom boldly asserts (1994) that Shakespeare and Dante are literature,
and it is a vain attempt to redefine it because one ‘cannot usurp sufficient cognitive
strength’ to even view the horizons of Shakespeare and Dante (486). Bloom’s sweeping
wrath directed at to what he calls, The School of Resentment, Inc., dissipates into a
nostalgia, a respite from his overzealous inventory of the Western Canon, as his
one limps away, all warfare done, to pass the rest of one’s time
surprise. The Bible, for all its disengaged illustration of “the taking of the
Manhood into God” had to anticipate Dante and his invention Beatrice in
order for the cycle of influence to go on and on, infecting the neo-Christian
poet T. S. Eliot, thus, making him believe that the Comedy is another
Scripture, the one that supplements the Christian Bible (74). Harold Bloom
(1994) finally remarks that Dante’s received images and concepts from the
In the seminal The Western Canon (1994), Harold Bloom states that
Milton’s place in the Canon is permanent. In his interview with John Dryden,
ROGERS, 2011, Bern, Peter Lang, 435 pp., 978 3-039-10748-3, pb. £48.00., European Journal
of English Studies, 17:1, 121-123, DOI: 10.1080/13825577.2013.771876
Woods, G, (2017). Reinvent America and the World: How Lawrence Ferlinghetti and City Lights Books Cultivated an
International Literature of Dissent, European journal of American studies. Retrieved 07 April 2021, from
http://journals.openedition.org/ejas/12041
Beckett's Influences. (2018, March 05). Retrieved October 16, 2020, from
https://ardentheatre.org/becketts-influences/
Athanasopoulou-Kypriou, S. (1970). Samuel Beckett's Use of the Bible and the
Responsibility of the Reader. Retrieved October 16, 2020, from
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9781403982995_5
John Milton, part 8: Adam and Eve find in loss a new paradise glimpsed. (2012, January
23). Retrieved October 19, 2020, from
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2012/jan/23/john-milton-love-
paradise-lost
Milton, John, 1608-1674. Paradise Lost. London ; New York :Penguin Books, 2000.
X.1014-5
Hero's Journey 101: Definition and Step-by-Step Guide (With Checklist!). (2020, October
12). Retrieved October 19, 2020, from https://blog.reedsy.com/heros-journey/
Kong, L. (2016). Howler of Nature and Revolt - Allen Ginsberg and the Making of a
Counter Culture. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 7(7), 129.
Retrieved April 7, 2021, from
https://ijbssnet.com/journals/Vol_7_No_7_July_2016/15.pdf