Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Feature Report
Practice Saturated steam flow
from the drum (S)
Understanding
Feedwater
flow (F)
Steam-water
mixture from
evaporator (R) Water flow
through the
Boiler Circulation
downcomer
Hot pipes (D)
fluegases
across the
evaporator Mass balance:
tubes F+R=S+D
R = D = CR x S
B
of
oilers generate steam using dif- steam pressure and hydraulic resis-
ferent methods to circulate the tance of downcomers, risers, evapora-
steam-water mixture through tor tubes and thermal head.
the evaporator tubes. These Generally steam pressure and CR
methods include natural circulation are inversely related, so the higher
(Figures 1, 2a–2c), forced circulation the steam pressure, the lower the CR,
(Figure 3a), and a once-through design. and vice versa. Another important pa-
Figures 3b, 4 and 5 show examples of rameter is the steam quality, x, exit-
a waste-heat water tube and fire-tube ing the evaporator, which is simply
boilers with external downcomers and 1/CR. Thus, if CR = 8, then x = 1/8 =
risers. Most boiler systems have evap- 0.125, meaning that 12.5% of steam is
orator tubes heated by hot fluegases generated in the evaporator tubes while
produced either from the combustion the rest of the mixture is water. CR may
of fuels (such as oil, gas or solid fuels,) be in the range of 20 to 30 for low-
or by kilns, furnaces, gas turbines or pressure boilers (100 to 600 psig), and
catalytic crackers, or by other hot gas about 8 to 15 for higher-pressure units,
sources (such as waste-heat boilers). depending on the design.
Boiling occurs in the evaporator tubes, Note that CR usually represents an
and generates wet steam. average circulation ratio. Keep in mind
The density difference between the that CR varies with circuits de- pending
colder water in the downcomers and on steam generation and any resistance
the hotter steam-water mixture in the offered by the system. In a boiler there
evaporator tubes ensures the circula- can be several parallel cir- cuits
tion of the steam-water mixture back generating steam. For example, when
into the drum. External downcomers, hot fluegases flow across a bank of
as shown in Figure 2c, are unheated, tubes, the first few rows will gener- ate a
while in package boilers (Figure 2b), large amount of steam due to the higher
they are internally located and are log mean temperature differen- tial
slightly heated by the fluegases. (LMTD) compared to the evapora- tor
In the steam drum, the mixture is tubes at the cooler end. This will
separated into saturated steam, which impact the CR.
flows out of the drum, and remaining Determining CR is only one part of
water, which mixes with the incom- the exercise. Once CR is estimated for a
ing feed water and flows through the circuit, the engineer has to determine if
downcomers to start the circulation the flow velocity inside the evapora- tor
process once again. tubes will not cause separation of
steam and water inside the tubes (par-
ChemiCal engineering www.Che.Com oCtober 2013 1
ticularly in horizontal evaporators)
and must also determine if the heat flux in the circuit is low enough not
to cause what is called departure
from nucleate boiling (DNB)
conditions.
If DNB conditions are likely, over-
heating and failure of the tubes can
occur. Variables such as tube size,
tube orientation, steam pressure,
mass flow through the tubes and
quality of the steam affect DNB.
Charts and correla- tions are
available for estimating the critical
heat flux that can cause DNB
conditions.
Natural-circulation boilers, such
as package D-type boilers that are
fired with oil, gas or solid fuels
(Figure
2a), are widely used in the chemical
process industries, petroleum refin-
eries and power plants. Their
capac- ity ranges from 20,000 to
300,000 lb/h with steam pressures
from 100 to 1,500 psig. These
are typically shop-assembled
boilers in which the downcomers are
inside the boiler and are heated
(Note: In this design, the
downcomers and risers are all
inside the boiler and heated by the
fluegases. However, a portion of the
heated tubes at the cooler end of the
boiler are des- ignated as
downcomers and are baf- fled
inside the drum. The tubes at the
hotter end are the risers).
For larger capacities, an elevated
drum modular unit, such as the
one shown in Figure 2c, is often more
suit- able, due to shipping
considerations. This unit has
external downcomers and risers,
and all the evaporator tubes in
the boiler bank are risers, unlike
the smaller D-type boilers, in which
some of the evaporator tubes can
act as downcomers. This discus-
sion is limited to natural-circulation
units only.
To stack
Water in
Pump
Economizer
Evaporator
FIGURE 4. In this waste-heat boiler with external downcomers and risers, feed
water enters the drum from the boiler feed pump or from an economizer. The water
Superheated mixes with the water from the evaporator tubes and the mixture flows down the
Superheater steam
downcomer pipes to the bottom of the evaporator tubes. The CR, established by
Gas turbine exhaust in an iterative process, can vary from 5 to 40, depending on a variety of variables
Forced
circulation
heat-recovery
steam generator
(HRSG)
FIGURE 3a (above). In this forced-circu-
lation boiler (generally seen with horizontal
evaporator tubes), a circulation pump is
used to suck water from the drum and en-
sure its flow through the evaporator tubes
and back into the drum. The pump capacity
determines the CR, which can vary from 3
to 8, depending on the designer’s choice
the boiler drawings from which the var- FIGURE 5. In this fire-tube boiler configuration (with a common drum and stand-
ious hydraulic losses in the circuits can alone downcomers and risers), the feedwater is admitted into the drum, where it
be computed. These include: mixes with the hot water from the risers and flows through the external downcomer
tubes
• Thermal head available for circula- usually used for these calculations. If the CR is relatively low (say, in the
tion (this depends on the location of single digits) and if the steam pressure is
the drum) relatively high (say 1,500 psig or
• Friction loss in the downcomer tubes above), then DNB checks1 may be car-
(this is due to the single-phase flow) ried out after obtaining the heat flux in
• Losses in evaporator tubes (this con- each region. If the CR is low — for in-
sists of friction losses, acceleration stance, in the single digits, such as 5–6,
loss due to two-phase flow, and grav- as in the case of high-pressure boilers
ity loss due to varying quality along operating above 1,500 psig — then ef-
the evaporator height) forts may be taken to revise the tube
• Losses in the drum internals sizes of the risers and downcomers.
• Losses in riser tubes in cases where The actual heat flux in the evapora-
external riser pipes are used tor tubes can be calculated from the
Charts for the calculation of various thermal calculations results done ear-
two-phase losses are available in Ref. 1. lier, using this relationship:
The total losses are matched with the Actual heat flux = overall heat trans-
available thermal head. If they match, fer coefficient × (the gas temperature
then the CR assumed is correct. If – the saturated steam temperature)
they do not match, then another itera- One should ensure that the actual
tion is carried out to obtain the CR at
1. DNB checks ensure that the boiling process in
which the available head matches the the evaporator tubes is nucleate and not film
various losses. A computer program is boiling. Charts and correlations are available to
Engineering Practice
do this evaluation, which is required if it is felt heat flux is far less than the
that the CR is low, as discussed in the text.
allowable critical heat flux all along
the evapora- tor tubes. Hundreds of
correlations are available in the
literature to determine the allowable
critical heat flux.
The Macbeth correlation provided
below in Equation (2) shows the
rela- tionship among the several
variables and may give a high
allowable flux. Using this
correlation, two heat flux values are
computed. One is the actual heat flux
inside the tubes (determined from
thermal calculations done by the
boiler designer, based on the boiler
flu- egas velocity, heat transfer
coefficient and tube geometry used).
Then the allowable heat flux is
estimated from charts or
correlations available in the
literature (based on the CR
computed and the tube geometry,
flow inside the evaporator tube and
steam pressure.) One should
ensure that the actual heat flux is
far lower — for instance,
Fluegas from furnace
FIGURE 6a (top left) and b (top 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3132 3334 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42
right). Shown is a typical arrangement 43 44 45 46
of the boiler arrangement of a package D- 1
2
type boiler with circulation problems. On 3
4
the drum-baffling arrangment shown in 5
Figure 6b, note the asymmetrical baffling 6
7
with respect to gas-flow direction. This 8
baffling system made it hard for many 9
10
designated downcomer tubes to act freely 11
12
as downcomers 13
14
15
Superheater
at least 20–30% less than the allow- Tube failures in this region region
Fluegas out to 1,050–1,200 °F
able rate — to ensure that departure economizer
from nucleate boiler does not occur in FIGURE 6c. This plan view shows the region where the tubes failed in the convec-
the evaporator tubes. Boiler compa- tion bank
nies typically develop their own cor-
relations based on their experience, the same gas temperature. As a consul- as seen in Table 1b (found in the on-
the tube sizes and configuration used, tant, I was asked to evaluate the design line version of this article, at www.che.
and they routinely use safety margins and suggest suitable solutions. com). Circulation calculations were
when developing them. Analysis. The first step was to simu- carried out using these data. Typical
late the boiler performance using the results are shown in Table 2 (online).
q = 6,330 hfg d–0.1 (G/106)0.51 (1–x)
tube geometry and furnace dimensions The heat flux q in the hottest gas zone
(2)
provided, to see if the exit gas tempera- of 1,300°F, given by Equation (3):
where: ture, superheated steam temperature,
U(Tg–Ts)Ao/Ai = 9.5 × (1,300–498) ×
q = critical heat flux, Btu/ft2h and water temperature leaving the
2.5/2.24 = 8,503 Btu/ft2h (3)
d = tube inner dia., in. economizer were all close to the mea-
G = mass velocity of steam water mix- sured field data. This step was designed where:
ture through tubes, lb/ft2h to confirm that the model used to carry q = heat flux, Btu/ft2h
x = steam quality, fraction out the calculations of gas tempera- U = overall heat transfer coefficient,
tures, overall heat transfer coefficients Btu/ft2hF
Circulation issue, D-type boiler and actual heat flux were reasonable, Tg/Ts = gas and steam temperatures,
Figures 6a and 6b show a boiler, fired and that the boiler was properly sized, °F
with oil and refinery gas, generating as that may provide some indication of Ao, Ai = the tube outer and inner sur-
130,000 lb/h of superheated steam other issues such as fouling. The simu- face area, ft2
at 630 psig, and 750°F, which had an lation gave the exit gas temperature This value of U is not high enough
interesting problem. Tubes were thin- from the evaporator and economizer to cause DNB in normal boiling situ-
ning and failing at a location in the as 798°F and 388°F, respectively, which ations. Heat fluxes have to be in the
boiler bank shown in Figure 6b. There matched the field data. Hence the sim- range of 150 to 200,000 Btu/ft2h be-
were two identical units in this plant ulation program results were used to fore we can attribute DNB to the tube-
and both were having this problem. study the circulation issue. failure problems in natural-circula-
Engineers were wondering why this The evaporator section was broken tion boilers with vertical tubes at this
region alone was facing this problem up into four sections and the gas tem- pressure.
— not the hotter zone ahead of these perature, duty and steam generation Next, the drum internal arrange-
tubes, or the tubes at the other end of in each section was calculated. It was ment was reviewed (Figure 6a). This
the same cross-section (that is, in the found that the gas temperatures in diagram provided a clue to the prob-
same plane perpendicular to the gas the region where tubes were failing lems that the plant was experienc-
flow direction), where one would expect were ranging from 1,050°F to 1,200°F, ing. In a typical D-type boiler with
Engineering Practice
Velocity profile
fluegases flowing parallel to the drum through the tubes, since they have
over the boiler bank tubes, the drum longer lengths and hence greater re- Gas flow direction
baffling is designed as shown in Fig- sistance to flow. The thermal head at
ure 2b. This will ensure that all the the cool downcomer end is nearly the
risers are in the hot gas section and same as in these hotter tubes, and Maximum velocity is in the middle
and tapers off at the ends
downcomers are in the cooler gas sec- hence there is difficulty in forcing
tion. Also, this type of baffling ensures the steam-water mixture through FIGURE 7. Shown here is a typical gas-
that the tubes in any cross-section are these tubes. velocity profile in a boiler bank cross-
section. Tubes in the mid-section usually
acting either as risers or downcomers. Also, if you look at the typical gas- operate at higher heat flux compared to
In some large boilers, it may be neces- velocity profile in any cross section, it end section
sary to have the drum at a separate will be as shown in Figure 7, with the
location and feed the boiler evaporator tubes in the middle receiving higher in the hot gas zone will be forced to act
tubes using an external downcomer energy transfer compared to the end as risers and the cooler unbaffled sec-
system and collect the steam from the tubes. Thus, the end tubes that have tion where the gas temperature drops
evaporator using an external riser failed do not generate sufficient steam- to less than 900°F will act as down-
system as shown in Figure 2c. water mixture for the cold downcomer comers, which will ensure good cir-
Figure 4 shows a waste-heat boiler tubes at the rear to force the circulation culation of the steam-water mixture
with external downcomers and risers. of the steam-water mixture through through the evaporator tubes. This so-
The layout can vary depending on the these tubes. Simply put — these failed lution is currently being implemented
boiler design adopted. tubes are neither acting as good ris- at the facility.
In a typical boiler, the tubes perpen- ers nor as good downcomers, and thus
dicular to gas flow direction are sym- a stagnant vapor mixture may have Final thoughts
metrically baffled. However in this formed in the tubes. Before buying a boiler plant, engineers
boiler, by using this non-symmetrical The vapor heat-transfer coefficient should review the boiler thermal per-
baffling system, a portion of the evap- is very small compared to the two- formance, including circulation issues.
orator tubes in the hot gas section in phase boiling coefficient and hence the Many plant engineers review infor-
the same cross-section are forced to be tube wall temperature will reach flue- mation such as construction details,
downcomers, while some tubes in the gas temperature, as there is not much painting, duct thickness, structural
same cross-section are under the baffle of cooling inside these tubes due to the integrity, code documents and so on,
acting as risers. This was determined stagnant column of vapor in this re- but few review the boiler’s thermal
to be the source of the problem. gion. Measurement of tube-wall tem- performance calculations, drum-baf-
The fluegas temperature in the first peratures near the failed region also fling system details or thermal per-
row of downcomers is close to 1,400°F confirmed the high temperatures. formance and circulation issues. How-
and the intense bubbling inside these The tubes within the same cross- ever, engineers should review these
tubes will force these tubes to act as section in the riser section (under the things before buying a new boiler
risers, even though they are baffled baffles and closer to the furnace) face plant, using either in-house expertise
as downcomers, due to the high heat no problem, as the head available for or third-party consultants. Getting
transfer rate and the lower density of circulation is higher in baffled regions. a second opinion on thermal, process
the steam-water mixture inside the The normal water level in the drum is and performance issues can help the
tubes. Hence, these tubes — though typically at the drum center line and is facility to purchase a better boiler and
not baffled — will still function as ris- at a higher elevation than the baffled thus avoid unnecessary plant shut-
ers. Flow will continue through these section, so this ensures circulation. downs and costly modifications later
tubes and circulation will be good. Hence, these tubes near the furnace — an important consideration, given
In essence, these tubes have not act as risers. The mid-section is likely the fact that a boiler has a life of over
failed, even though they are in the hot to have a higher steam formation than thirty years. n
gas region. However, as the gas cools the ends due to the velocity profile and Edited by Suzanne Shelley
in the next nine rows, the gas temper- higher heat flux and hence have lower
ature drops to about 1,200°F. This is mixture density resulting in some cir- Author
the region where tubes at the far end culation through these tubes. Viswanathan Ganapa-
thy is a boiler consul-
of the furnace have failed. Solution. The failed tubes have diffi- tant from Chennai, India
These failed tubes have difficulty culty acting either as risers or down- (v_ganapathy@yahoo.com),
who specializes in thermal
acting as downcomers due to the comers due to the skewed baffling in- design and performance as-
pects. He has over 40 years
high gas temperatures; vapor for- side the drum. This is mainly due to of experience in the thermal
mation at the inlet to the tube will the fact that many so-called downcom- design and performance as-
pects of steam generators and
still be intense and thus will prevent ers are located in a very hot section. waste-heat boilers. He has
the flow of water in the downcomers. Stagnation of the flow is suspected in authored over 250 articles on
boiler-related subjects that have been published
Also, the head available in the colder the failed tubes. If baffling inside the in a number of U.S., Indian and U.K. magazines.
He has also authored several books and conducts
end of the boiler is not high enough drum is done as shown in Figure 2a, courses on boilers. He graduated from I.I.T Ma-
to force the steam-water mixture the evaporator tubes under the baffles dras with a degree in mechanical engineering.