Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Encouraging comparison—helping "Tell me about another time you had a similar experience."
client understand by looking at "What's one way I look like your daughter?" "What's another way I look like
similarities and differences. Create your daughter?" "What's one way I look different from your daughter?"
exhaustive list of similarities, then "Describe this fear of driving over bridges."
differences. "Tell me when you feel anxious."
Belittling feelings expressed— Nontherapeutic response: "Everybody gets down into the dumps." "I've
misjudging the degree of the felt that way sometimes."
client's discomfort Therapeutic response: "Tell me about being down in the dumps." "You
have the right to your own feelings."
Client: “I have nothing to live for . . .I wish I was dead.”
Nurse: “Everybody gets down in the dumps.”
“I’ve felt that way myself.”
Challenging—demanding proof Nontherapeutic response: "But how can you have cancer when all your
tests are negative?" "Why?"
Therapeutic response' "I hear you saying you are still concerned that
you have cancer. Tell me about that." "What went into your choice to
break the window?"
“But how can you be President of the United States?”
“If you’re dead, why is your heart beating?”
Nontherapeutic response: "No one here would lie to you." "Miss ___ is
Defending—attempting to protect
a very capable nurse."
someone or some-. thing from verbal
Therapeutic response: "Who is one person you think lied to you?" "I
attack
can't speak for Miss ___, but I see you are upset. Tell me your
concerns."
“This hospital has a fine reputation.”
“I’m sure your doctor has your best interests in mind.”
Destructive humor—any humor that
belittles, implies guilt or.
incompetence, continually refocuses
client on topic selected by nurse, or is
met with client displeasure
Disagreeing—opposing the client's ideas Nontherapeutic responses: "That's wrong." "I don't believe that."
Therapeutic responses: "What do you think would happen to you if you
jumped off the roof?" "Where did you get the idea you were President
Clinton?"
“That’s wrong.”
“I definitely disagree with . . . .”
“I don’t believe that.”
Disapproving—denouncing the client's Nontherapeutic responses: "How can you consider divorce when you
actions, thoughts, feelings, or needs have four children?" "How can having a baby fix your relationship
when you're not even married?" "That's not living by the Golden
Rule." "Get a life." "Shape up." "You need to start a new
relationship."
Therapeutic responses; "What is one reason you are considering
divorce?" "What is one way you believe having a baby would save
your relationship?" "How do you see yourself handling this
problem?"
Nontherapeutic responses: "It is silly to think people want to hurt you."
"You're crazy." You hate to hear the truth."
Therapeutic responses: "Who is one person you believe wants to hurt
you?" "You seem upset." "What is the most difficult concern you have
about your job?"
“That’s bad.”
“I’d rather you wouldn’t . . . “
Giving literal responses – responding to Client: “They’re looking in my head with a television camera.”
figurative comments as though it were a Nurse: “Try not to watch television.”
statement of fact. “What channels?”
Interpreting—seeking to make conscious that Nontherapeutic response: "What you really mean is..." "Unconsciously
which is unconscious you're saying..,"
Therapeutic responses: "Your conversation evolves around Sam's
getting the scholarship. What do you think this is about?"
Testing—appraising the patient's degree of Nontherapeutic responses: "What are you here in the hospital for?"
insight or knowledge unrelated to topic "What day is this?"
Therapeutic responses: "We have been talking about your
disagreement with your son and how he is ungrateful. What have you
learned about yourself in relation to this disagreement?"
Literal response—dealing with abstract Client: "My head is going around and around."'
symbols or metaphors in a concrete manner nontherapeutic response: "You're lying perfectly still."
Therapeutic response: "You might be dizzy. When did this start?"
Client: "My head is full of snakes."
Nurse's nontherapeutic response: "Snakes can't live there."
Therapeutic response "Sounds like you have many thoughts squirming
around there. What is the most difficult thought?" Making stereotyped
comments—offering meaningless cliches when client is sad or upset
Nontherapeutic nurse responses: "He'll be a vegetable." "Tomorrow
brings sunshine." "It's all for the best."
Therapeutic responses: "Three tests have revealed no brain activity.
This means his brain has stopped working and he is being kept alive
by the ventilator." "Put your sadness into words." "Tell me thing
you'll miss the most about your brother."
Probing—persistent questioning of the client Client: "And so my wife and I split up."
or asking about unrelated topics Nontherapeutic response: "Now tell me about your mother."
Therapeutic response: "Tell me about you and your wife splitting
up." Reassuring—trying to make the client feel better superficially
and not to worry or be anxious
Nontherapeutic responses: "Don't worry about your test results. They'll
be alright." "You'll be fine and home soon."
Therapeutic responses: "Tell me your greatest concern at this
moment." "Put your anxiety into words to help me understand."
Rejecting—an angry or punitive response to client’s action, thoughts,
or feelings
Value statements—judging the actions or Nontherapeutic responses: "That was good of you to pour the coffee."
feelings of clients and implying they are good "Scary movies upset every-one." "That must make you feel horrible to
or bad; making biased statements hear your mother does not want you back home."
Therapeutic responses: "I see you poured the coffee. Thank you."
"What upset you about this scary movie?" "What was your first
response to hearing your mom did not want you to move back home?”
Nontherapeutic responses: "That was a pretty hostile answer." "You
Volatile verbiage—harsh, negative, and often took the battering-ram approach."
judgmental words, causing client to fee! Therapeutic responses: "I could hear you were upset when you
increased anxiety and shame answered. Tell me about that." "What was your feeling just before
you broke the door to your mom's house?"
Nontherapeutie questions: "Will you take your medicine?" "Are you
"Yes/no" questions—allows client to give going out?" "Can you ask for more help?" "Do you worry a lot?"
one-word, dead-end responses that show no Therapeutic questions: "When will you be taking your medicine?"
thoughts or emotions "Where are you going now?" "Whom could you ask to help you with
this situation?" "What causes you to worry?"