Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Minamata
Convention on
Mercury
A First Step toward
Protecting Future
Generations
I
n July 1956, in a fishing village near neurological symptoms, including tremors, Rapidly industrializing Asia is the larg-
the city of Minamata on Japan’s Shi- dizziness, headaches, memory loss, and est current source of atmospheric mercury
ranui Sea, a baby girl named Shino- vision and hearing problems; the most severe emissions, with China contributing a third
bu Sakamoto was born. Her parents cases also involve developmental disabilities, of the global total.8 Meanwhile, countries
soon realized something was wrong. cognitive and motor dysfunction, and in Europe and North America have cut
At 3 months old, when healthy babies physical abnormalities. “Minamata disease is air emissions substantially. The United
can hold up their heads, Sakamoto could not over yet,” Sakamoto says today.6 At 57, States has done so in part by cleaning up
not. She grew slowly and began crawling her hands are twisted, and she can no longer waste incinerators. And power plants have
unusually late. At age 3 years, she drooled walk or bathe without help. She has never until 2016 to comply with new federal
excessively and still couldn’t walk. Her been able to work, although she has spent standards that will dramatically limit mer-
parents sent her to live at a local hospital, decades advocating on behalf of Minamata cury and other pollutants in their emis-
where she spent four years in therapy to victims. sions.9 But mercury tends to linger in the
learn to walk, use her hands, and perform Minamata drew the world’s attention environment, and a recent modeling study
other basic functions. Early on, several to the devastating effects of mercury, a estimated that half the mercury pollution
physicians agreed on a diagnosis of cerebral powerful neurotoxicant now known to be in the surface layer of the ocean today
palsy. particularly dangerous to fetuses, infants, came from emissions prior to 1950, when
Yet there were signs that Sakamoto’s and young children. Before Minamata, the U.S. and European contributions exceeded
condition was part of something much placenta was thought to protect the fetus those from Asia.10
bigger. A few years before her birth, dead against toxicants.2 That study also projected that if mer-
fish and other sea creatures had begun But even less severe mercury pollu- cury emissions stopped altogether in 2015,
appearing in Minamata Bay.1 Seabirds tion is now known to be problematic. “We atmospheric deposition levels would drop
were losing their ability to fly. 2 And cats started with Minamata fifty years ago, and immediately by 30%—good news. After
were dying off, many from convulsions now we know that doses that we thought that, however, the decline would slow,
that locals called “dancing disease.”1 Then, were safe in the past are certainly not safe,” and it would take an estimated 85 years—
two months before Sakamoto’s birth, an says Philippe Grandjean, an environmental until 2100—for atmospheric deposition to
outbreak of an unknown neurological ill- health scientist at the Harvard School drop by about half and for ocean-surface
ness was first reported among the area’s of Public Health and the University of levels to drop by one-third. And that fore-
fishing families. Sakamoto’s older sister, Southern Denmark. “We’re now concerned cast does not account for climate change,
Mayumi, and several of the family’s neigh- about exposures that are highly prevalent which may complicate things, for instance
bors were diagnosed with the mysterious in seafood consumers worldwide.” by thawing northern tundra and releasing
ailment, which was attributed to contami- In October 2013 a new international long-stored mercury back into circulation.
nated seafood. In 1957 scientists gave the convention to control mercury emissions The authors concluded that even aggressive
ailment a name: Minamata disease. The will be open for signing in Japan. Named emissions cuts will merely maintain cur-
next year, Mayumi died of it. the Minamata Convention on Mercury, rent mercury levels in the ocean.10
The responsible contaminant was the agreement is a response to the realiza- Humankind is now known to have
eventually identified as methylmercury tion that mercury pollution is a global released much more mercury into the
that had been discharged in wastewater problem that no one country can solve environm ent than previously thought.
from a local chemical factory owned by alone. The convention was four years in Atmospheric levels are now more than
the Chisso Corporation.3 The numbers of the making, with more than 130 nations seven times higher and ocean-surface levels
the stricken climbed and spread around agreeing by consensus to a final text in are nearly six times higher than they were
the Shiranui Sea, and in 1962 a cluster January 2013. It includes both compulsory around 2000 b.c., which is roughly when
of children originally diagnosed with and voluntary measures to control mercury human-caused emissions are believed to
cerebral palsy, including Sakamoto, were emissions from various sources, to phase have begun.10
recognized as suffering from congenital the element out of certain products and Mercury emissions can travel far from
Minamata disease. But the government industrial processes, to restrict its trade, their original sources on winds and ocean
did nothing to stop Chisso’s dumping or and to eliminate mining of it.7 currents.11 Once mercury lands in soils and
to discourage people from eating fish, waterways, microorganisms metabolize it
and only acknowledged the plant’s role in Sources of Mercury into methylmercury, the element’s most
Minamata disease after it stopped using Mercury is a naturally occurring element toxic form, which accumulates up the food
mercury on its own. That was 1968. By used in numerous products and industrial chain.12 People are typically exposed to
then Sakamoto was 12. processes, from thermometers and certain methylmercury when they eat contami-
T he M i n a m at a d i s a s ter — w h ic h bulbs to chemical catalysts. It is released by nated seafood. Mercury concentrations
affected thousands of individuals, includ- the burning of fossil fuels and the produc- in human hair collected from numerous
ing every member of Sakamoto’s family— tion of cement and some metals.8 contamination hot spots identified around
was the first large-scale incident of methyl Human activities are estimated to have the world indicate people in these areas
mercury poisoning. But it wasn’t the only released 1,960 metric tons of mercury into regularly eat fish considered unsafe by U.S.
one. A similar, smaller methylmercury poi- the atmosphere and at least 1,000 met- Environmental Protection Agency stan-
soning incident in Niigata Prefecture came ric tons into the water in 2010, according dards, according to a 2013 report by the
to light in 1965, as did another among to a 2013 report by the United Nations Biodiversity Research Institute and the
Native Americans in Ontario, Canada, in Environment Programme (UNEP). 8 The International POPs Elimination Network
1969.4,5 report notes that after a period of apparent (IPEN).13 David Evers, chief scientist at
Decades after industrial dumping stability between 1990 and 2005, global the Biodiversity Research Institute, says
ceased, thousands of survivors of these emissions to the air may be rising again in that study, although small, is unique in its
incidents are still suffering from a host of some sectors. geographic breadth. However, the critical
Toward an Agreement
Global support for a binding agreement
on mercury emissions began building in
2003. But the United States pushed instead
for voluntary measures to control emis-
sions, making a legally binding convention
a nonstarter.19 Then, at a 2009 UNEP
Governing Council meeting shortly
after Barack Obama’s inauguration, the
United States announced it would move At the first negotiating session, held Fast-forward two and a half years and
ahead with negotiations toward a binding in Stockholm in 2010, representatives three more negotiating sessions. Exhaust-
instrument. from IPEN and a Swedish nongovern- ed delegates emerged from all-night dis-
The Governing Council quickly estab- mental organization tested the hair of cussions at the fifth and final negotia-
lished the negotiating process. Its back- participants from 40 countries for mer- tions in Geneva and officially adopted the
bone was a series of five meetings where cury. Every sample came back positive, convention at 7:00 a.m. on 19 January
delegates from participating nations and more than a third exceeded the U.S. 2013. By all accounts, one of the most
hashed out the convention text, with sub- National Research Council reference dose important and difficult topics to settle was
stantial input and lobbying from non of 1,000 μg/kg (1 ppm). Mercury levels of how to control air emissions of mercury
voting outside groups. participants from poorer countries aver- from facilities such as waste incinerators,
Daniel Reifsnyder, deputy assistant aged 1,182 µg/kg, and those from wealth smelters, and coal-fired power plants. The
secretary for environment with the State ier countries averaged 669 µg/kg. One power plants were central to the discussion
Department, oversaw the U.S. role in the sample topped the charts at more than because they are the world’s second biggest
negotiations. Pointing to the Stockholm 20,000 µg/kg.20 mercury source, releasing 24% of global
Convention on Persistent Organic Pollut- These results effectively lifted the veil emissions. 8 Yet large developing nations
ants and other international agreements of abstraction that often shrouds diplo- depend on cheap national coal supplies to
restricting hazardous chemicals that the matic talks, says Joseph DiGangi, a senior bring electricity to their citizens and fuel
United States has not joined, he says, “We science and policy advisor with IPEN. their growing economies.
were concerned in this case not to go down “When delegates actually found out that Some developing nations initially balked
a well-worn path that leads us to negoti- the topic of the negotiation was in their at the cost of technology that removes
ate but then not be able to implement, so own body, quite a few of them came up mercury from smokestack emissions. The
negotiating something meaningful yet flex- and just couldn’t believe it,” he says. “They United States worked hard to convince
ible was key.” said, ‘What is it doing in me?’” China and India, in particular, that
mandatory controls in this sector could be in … thousands of tons of mercury emitted mandate strategies to formalize the indus-
affordably achieved through the application during that time that you’re sitting around try and eliminate its most polluting prac
of so-called best available techniques, not doing anything,” Keane says. “That’s a tices, and to protect children and pregnant
according to the State Department’s lot of mercury that you’re just letting go!” women from mercury exposure. However,
Reifsnyder. In the end, the United States Another key issue was the biggest the convention allows continued mercury
succeeded, although a detailed description of source of mercury pollution, artisanal and trade for artisanal and small-scale gold
acceptable techniques remains to be worked small-scale gold mining, which accounts mining, and there is no phase-out date for
out, and they are required only for new for more than a third of global emissions. the practice.
sources of mercury air emissions. Reifsnyder Small, often temporary mining opera- The convention does phase out mer-
describes the result as “robust enough to tions have boomed worldwide as the price cury in most products by 2020, includ-
be meaningful, yet flexible enough to be of gold skyrocketed. Some 10–15 mil- ing pesticides and certain batteries, bulbs,
implementable.” lion people, including possibly as many switches, cosmetic s, a nd mea suring
Aleksandra Tomczak, policy manager as 3 million women and children, many devices. One product that sparked exten-
for the World Coal Association, who of them extremely poor, are estimated to sive debate was dental amalgam. The Zero
attended three negotiations, also came work in the industry.21 Mercury Working Group, a coalition of
away satisfied. “It actually does, in our To separate tiny particles of gold from environmental and health organizations,
opinion, strike a balance between environ- ore, workers commonly use large quanti- led the charge to include amalgam in the
mental protection priorities and develop- ties of mercury with no protection what- convention by pointing out that it is a sig-
ment objectives,” she says. soever for themselves, their homes, or the nificant source of mercury emissions from
However, critics like IPEN’s DiGangi environment. According to Keane, mercury cremated human remains and amalgam
say that although the measure should is cheap and readily available to miners. She waste washed down the drain.23 The con-
reduce the mercury emissions per unit recalls visiting a mine in Borneo where she vention “phases down”—gradually reduces
of energy produced, countries are free to watched a worker casually amalgamate gold but doesn’t eliminate—the use of mercury-
keep building capacity, so total emissions with mercury he poured from a soda bottle. containing dental amalgam by directing
will probably rise. “The treaty will address She later calculated the bottle held roughly countries to adopt at least two control
some mercury sources—it just will not be as much mercury as 60,000 compact fluo- measures from a list of nine options.
able to keep up with the increased mercury rescent light bulbs; she says the miner may Another hotly debated product was the
emissions,” DiGangi says. “In other words, well have used a bottle each day. [For more mercury-based vaccine preservative thi-
it will change the slope, but the amount of information, see “Quicksilver and Gold: merosal. Although thimerosal has been
mercury pollution will still increase.” Mercury Pollution from Artisanal and eliminated from most children’s vaccines
Critics also say the time frame for Small-Scale Gold Mining” in the Novem- in developed nations, it is still widely used
implementation is too long. Countries have ber 2012 issue of EHP.22] throughout the developing world because
5 years before they must build new sources Various countries have tried outlawing it enables vaccines to be packaged in multi
that comply and 10 years before they must mercury in artisanal and small-scale gold dose bottles, significantly lowering costs
at least establish a goal to reduce emissions mining, but without help for miners to and making it easier to transport and dis-
from existing sources. But the clock doesn’t transition away from the practice, it has tribute vaccines in remote areas.
start ticking until the convention is ratified, simply gone covert, Keane says. She says Two U.S. organizations, SafeMinds
which is unlikely for another few years, says the convention took the right approach by and the Coalition for Mercury-Free Drugs,
Susan Egan Keane, a senior environmental directing countries to come up with their pushed for the convention to phase out
analyst with the Natural Resources Defense own plans to reduce or eliminate mer- or phase down thimerosal, contending
Council. “You’re basically grandfathering cury in mining. Guidelines for the plans that it poses a risk to children’s health.24,25
Samples of brain tissue from Minamata disease patients (left and center) illustrate the devastating effect of high methylmercury exposure.
The sample on the left is from a 7-year-old child who died after four years of exposure, the sample in the middle is from an 8-year-old child
who died after 2.75 years of exposure, and the sample on the right is from a healthy 30-year-old man. © Robin Treadwell/Science Source
Numerous global health agencies led by China is all but alone in manufacturing Developing nations were also concerned
the World Health Organization rallied to vinyl chloride monomer in a way that uses about securing enough intern ational
protect it, however, arguing that the pre- mercury as a catalyst, but IPEN describes funding to implement the convention
servative is safe and essential to vaccination the Chinese industry as an unquantified effectively. After much discussion, the
programs that protect the world’s poorest and “potentially enormous” emissions final convention designates the Global
children from life-threatening diseases. 26 source.27 Environment Facility Trust Fund as the
A number of developing nations expressed Developing nations drove the nego- funding mechanism, but it remains to be
concern about thimerosal during the nego- tiations on two other points of contention. determined how much donor countries will
tiations, but in the end they supported its One was the inclusion of an article devot- give to the fund or, therefore, how much
continued use, and the convention specifi- ed to health issues. Developed nations recipient countries will receive. “The treaty
cally exempts it. opposed including one, largely out of con- is one thing, but now implementing it is also
T he c onvent ion a l so a dd re s s e d cern that it would open the door for costly another process, which will bring on board
specific manufacturing processes, notably public health programs to be included in a lot of other issues—capacity, capability,
phasing out mercury in the production the convention, according to Keane. The resources, and understanding,” says Richard
of aceta ldehyde, t he source of t he final convention does include a health arti- Mwendandu, a delegate from Kenya.
contamination at Minamata. By 2020 cle, albeit a brief one simply encouraging Yet the convention has drawn praise,
countries must halve the use of mercury in nations to implement general measures to even from some critics, as an important
the production of vinyl chloride monomer, protect their populations from mercury first step and the first unified global action
the main component of PVC plastic. exposure. to curb mercury emissions. “The treaty
involved compromises, but it ref lects a
global consensus that mercury emissions
and releases represent a serious health and
environmental concern,” says Evers, of the
Biodiversity Research Institute.