Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3/2008
Summary Introduction
The purpose of this retrospective study was to
review cases of spinal fractures or luxations (SFL)
treated with various modalities in order to describe Spinal fractures, luxations, and fracture-
fracture location, neurological status, treatment, luxations in dogs and cats are common
outcome and compli- cations in a patient population and are often the result of vehicular injury
at a single centre. The medical records of dogs and (1, 2–5). Other frequent causes of injury
cats that had been diag- nosed with a SFL between include animal attacks or falling from a
C1 and L7 between January 1995 and June 2005 height. Re- ports that describe the
were reviewed in order to collect pertinent data. distribution of spinal column injuries
Ninety-five cases were included in this study. The indicate that they affect the lumbar vertebrae
severity of spinal cord injury was graded on a scale most frequently, followed by
from 0 to 5. Vehicular trauma was the most sacrococcygeal, thoracic, and cervical
common cause of SFL. Spinal fractures were
vertebrae (1, 3, 5). An increased incidence
localized between C1-C5 in 10 cases, C6-T2 in
one case, T3-L3 in 54 cases, L4-L7 in 36 cases. of fracture-luxation has also been
Thirty patients that were euthanatized without reported at the junction between the mobile
treatment had a median neurological score of 5. and immo- bile sections of the spine, such
Twenty-eight patients, all of which had motor as the thora- columbar and lumbosacral
function, were treated conservatively and there was junction due to stress concentration (6).
not any change in their median neuro- logical grade Other studies have described a more even
at the time of discharge. Thirty-seven pa- tients had distribution of injury along the spinal
surgery, 27 of which were non ambulatory. Thirty- column (2, 7). Diagnosis and mechanism
five of 37 were stabilized using pins and/or of injury have been de- scribed in detail
screws and PMMA or various other techniques. elsewhere (2–5, 8–11). The method of
The median neurological grade of surgically treated
treatment selected depends on the
pa- tients improved by one point between the time
of initial diagnosis and discharge. Implant signalment of the patient, nature of the in-
removal was per- formed in five cases. The jury, neurological status, and individual sur-
patients that were treated with pins and/or screws geon preference and experience. Treatment
and PMMA were significantly more improved than modalities can be broadly classified into
conservatively managed patients at the time of conservative and surgical options. Conser-
discharge, although the surgically treated patients vative treatment typically involves external
were hospitalized significantly longer than the immobilization in the form of splints and
conservatively managed patients. Our results suggest bandages, cage confinement, exercise re-
that dogs that retain pain sensation prior to surgery striction, and steroid administration. The ob-
have a good prognosis for functional recovery. In this jective of surgical treatment is the reduction
study, the dogs that were treated conservatively re-
of the vertebral segments, decompression of
tained purposeful movement and had a good
prognosis for recovery. the spinal cord and rigid stabilization of
the spinal canal. Current surgical options
Keywords in- clude: pins and
Spinal, fracture, luxation, dog, cat polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA),
vertebral body plating, vertebral stapling,
Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2008; 21: 280–284 screws and PMMA, and external skeletal
fixation (9–12).
Controversy exists whether surgical or
conservative therapy is most appropriate for
Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol spinal fracture/luxation. Current indications
for surgical intervention are evidence of spi-
nal instability and/or undertake physical therapy and nursing The medical records for all dogs and cats
spinal cord compres- care (3, 7). that had been diagnosed with spinal
sion, deterioration despite Previous reports on spinal fracture fracture or luxation at the Ontario
appropriate con- servative or lu- xation cases have focused on a Veterinary College Veterinary Teaching
management or single treat- ment modality or spinal Hospital of the Univer- sity of Guelph
unrelenting pain beyond segment making it difficult to compare between January 1995 and June 2005
the first 48–72 hours (7, treatment modalities amongst one were reviewed. The data were col- lected
8, 13). Re- gardless of another. The purpose of this regarding breed, age, sex, weight, his-
these recommendations retrospective study was to review a tory, including type of trauma, duration of
conser- vative large number of cases of canine and clinical signs, progression of clinical
management has been feline spinal fractures or luxations signs, neurological assessment (at
shown in some studies to treated with various modalities in order admission, post- operatively, at discharge
have up to 94.4% to describe fracture lo- cation, and at recheck), radiographic assessment,
functional re- covery neurological status, treatment used, including location of fracture, luxation or
rate (4–6, 8). In light of outcome and complications in a fracture/luxation, and the presence of
this, all pa- tients should patient population at a single centre. concurrent injuries. Also, the details of
be given the benefit of injury management (conservative
conser- vative Received February 10, 2008
management if the Accepted April 20, 2008
owners are willing to Materials and methods
Discussion
The proportion of patients in our study
that were euthanatized without
treatment (31.6%) was less than in
Experimental evidence supports the
ting the successful treatment of concept that spinal cord com- pression monly used treatment modality in human
patients with such poor neurological is a potentially reversible form of spinal trauma patients but is not technically
status, follow- ing spinal trauma. A secondary injury (17). Closed decom- feasible in canine and feline patients. Spinal
recent study by Olby et al. that pression involving traction devices is a decompression in small animals with spinal
evaluated the long-term outcome of com- injuries typically involves surgical reduc-
patients with traumatic spinal cord tion and stabilization. Previous reports sug-
injury revealed that regardless of gest that surgically treated spinal injury in
treatment, none of the patients that lost small animals had a greater neurological
deep pain sensation regained deep pain improvement (3). However, the findings of
sensation (15). Two of the patients in our study did not provide very strong evi-
that study were considered to have a dence for this conclusion because at the
successful outcome based on the re- turn time of discharge from the hospital, a sig-
of ability to ambulate (15). These pa- nificant difference between the surgical and
tients had an abnormal gait, were conservative groups was neither detected in
intermit- tently fecal and urinary the neurological scores, nor in the change in