See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/340967600

The Use of Experimental Methods in Linguistic Research: Advantages,

Problems and possible Pitfalls

Chapter · January 2016

CITATIONS READS

6 43

1 author:

Barbara Mertins
Technische Universität Dortmund
48 PUBLICATIONS   217 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Popular science View project

Possessives in cross-linguistic comparison and from learner’s perspective View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Barbara Mertins on 28 April 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.



*96
FD6
@7
6IA6C:>6?E2=
>6E9@5D
:?
=:?8F:DE:4
C6D62C49
25G2?E286D
AC@3=6>D
2?5
A@DD:3=6
A:E72==D

5F65F5
%9FH=BG

3DEC24E
'I
OC@
KM@N@IO
K<K@M
'
RDGG
KM@N@IO
<I?
?DN>PNN
N@Q@M<G
@SK@MDH@IO<G

H@OCJ?N
PN@?
DIND?@
<I?
JPOND?@
KNT>CJGDIBPDNOD>
M@N@<M>C
2C@
JQ@M<GG
AJ>PN

RDGG
=@
JI
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
2C@
H@OCJ?N
KM@N@IO@?
DI>GP?@
?DAA@M@IO

@GD>DO<ODJI
O@>CIDLP@N

@T@
OM<>FDIB

H@HJMT
O<NFN
<I?
KM@A@M@I>@
EP?BH@IO

O<NFN
-I
OC@
=<NDN
JA
HT
JRI
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?<O<

'
RDGG
?@N>MD=@
OC@
H<DI
A@<
OPM@N
JA
OC@N@
H@OCJ?N

>JHH@IO
JI
OC@DM
NPDO<=DGDOT
AJM
Q<MDJPN
GDIBPDNOD>
M@
N@<M>C
LP@NODJIN

<I?
@SKGJM@
NJH@
JA
OC@DM
<?Q<IO<B@N

NCJMO>JHDIBN
<I?

GDHDO<ODJIN
2C@
K<K@M
<??M@NN@N
B@I@M<G
H@OCJ?JGJBD><G
DNNP@N
<I?
>C<GG@IB
@N

BJDIB
=@TJI?
OC@
M@N@<M>C
>JI?P>O@?
JI
1G<QD>
G<IBP<B@N
&JR@Q@M

<GG

OC@
NOP?D@N
KM@N@IO@?
<I?
?DN>PNN@?
C@M@
<M@
=<N@?
JI
?<O<
>JGG@>O@?
AMJH

I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
JA
Q<MDJPN
1G<QD>
G<IBP<B@N
'I
<??DODJI

ORJ
NOP?D@N
<??M@NN

G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
JA
1G<QD>
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
DI
<
AJM@DBI
G<IBP<B@
2C@
K<
K@M
>JI>GP?@N
RDOC
B@I@M<G
M@H<MFN
JI
OC@
PN@
JA
@SK@MDH@IO<G
H@OCJ?N
<I?

NO<ODNOD>N
DI
GDIBPDNOD>
M@N@<M>C


?EC@5F4E:@?

2C@
PN@
JA
@SK@MDH@IO<GGT
=<N@?
H@OCJ?N
<I?
O@>CIDLP@N
C<N
=@>JH@
A<DMGT

KJKPG<M
DI
GDIBPDNOD>N
0@N@<M>C@MN
AMJH
?DAA@M@IO
GDIBPDNOD>
<M@<N
@HKGJT

H@OCJ?N
JMDBDI<ODIB
DI
@SK@MDH@IO<G
GDIBPDNOD>N
<I?
KNT>CJGDIBPDNOD>N
OJ
O@NO

Q<MDJPN
GDIBPDNOD>
OC@JMD@N

HJ?@GN
<I?
>JI>M@O@
M@N@<M>C
CTKJOC@N@N
2C@

>CJD>@
JA
<
H@OCJ?
JM
<
H@OCJ?JGJBD><G
<KKMJ<>C
<GR<TN
H@<IN
>JHHDO
H@IO
OJ
<
K<MOD>PG<M
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?@NDBI
2CDN
>CJD>@
DI
OPMI
KPON
NK@>DAD>

M@LPDM@H@ION
JI
OC@
NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G
JM
OC@
N@G@>ODJI
JA
K<MOD>DK<ION
<I?

C<N

DI
OC@
@I?

>JIN@LP@I>@N
AJM
?<O<
>J?DIB
<I?
<I<GTNDN
'O
DN
OC@M@AJM@

@NN@IOD<G
OJ
C<Q@
NJH@
FIJRG@?B@
JA
OC@
<?Q<IO<B@N
<I?
?DN<?Q<IO<B@N
JA
<

K<MOD>PG<M
H@OCJ?
=@AJM@
@HKGJTDIB
DO
DI
<I
@SK@MDH@IO

2CDN
K<K@M
DN
NOMP>OPM@?
<N
AJGGJRN
1@>ODJI

KM@N@ION
<
>G<NNDAD><ODJI
JA

@SK@MDH@IO<G
H@OCJ?N
<I?
?DN>PNN@N
OC@DM
<?Q<IO<B@N
<I?
?DN<?Q<IO<B@N

1@>ODJI

AJ>PN@N
JI
N@G@>O@?
<NK@>ON
JA
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
M@N@<M>C
<I?

DIOMJ?P>@N
H@OCJ?N
@HKGJT@?
DI
HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C
1@>ODJI

>JHKMDN@N

OCM@@
NOP?D@N
>CJN@I
AMJH
HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C
JI
OC@
=<NDN
JA
RCD>C
?DAA@M@IO

H@OCJ?N
<M@
@SKG<DI@?
<I?
@Q<GP<O@?
2CDN
N@>ODJI
<GNJ
DI>GP?@N
M@G@Q<IO

 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

?@O<DGN
>JI>@MIDIB
OC@
?@NDBI
JA
<I
@SK@MDH@IO
2C@
<MOD>G@
@I?N
RDOC
<
N@O
JA

>JI>GPNDJIN



4=2DD:7:42E:@?
@7
ADJ49@=:?8F:DE:4
>6E9@5D

#SK@MDH@IO<G
H@OCJ?N
><I
=@
>G<NNDAD@?
DI
?DAA@M@IO
R<TN
>A
&aCG@



+bGG@M


4<IK<OO@I

(@B@MNFD


'I
OCDN
K<K@M
OCM@@
H@OCJ?
OTK@N

<M@
?DNODIBPDNC@?
>A
1>CHD@?OJQY

$G<I?@MFJQY



C::@=B9
H@OCJ?N


CB@=B9
H@OCJ?N

HFI9
CB@=B9
H@OCJ?N
'
RDGG
>JI>DN@GT
?@N>MD=@
OC@
?DA
A@M@IO
OTK@N
<I?
KMJQD?@
@S<HKG@N
AJM
@<>C
JA
OC@H
2C@I
'
RDGG
@G<=JM<O@
JI

NJH@
KMJN
<I?
>JIN
JA
OC@
H@OCJ?N
<I?
H<F@
NJH@
B@I@M<G
M@H<MFN
JI
OC@DM

NPDO<=DGDOT
AJM
GDIBPDNOD>
M@N@<M>C


2C@
O@MHN
C::@=B9 CB@=B9
M@G<O@
OJ
OC@
?@BM@@

OJ
RCD>C
<
BDQ@I
H@OCJ?
M@
AG@>ON
OC@
NOP?D@?
PI?@MGTDIB
H@IO<G
<I? JM
I@PMJI<G
KMJ>@NN
2C@
JAAGDI@

H@OCJ?N
AJ>PN
JI
NK@<F@MNo
GDIBPDNOD>
>JHK@O@I>@

RC@M@<N
OC@
JIGDI@
H@OC
J?N
>JI>@IOM<O@
HJM@
JI
NK@<F@MNo
K@MAJMH<I>@

,<9
C::@=B9
A9H<C8G
C<Q@

IJ
?DM@>O
<>>@NN
OJ
<
H@IO<G
KMJ>@NN
<I?
M@AG@>O
>JIN>DJPN
?@>DNDJIH<FDIB

2C@
O<NFN
<M@
NJGQ@?
RDOC
<
?@G<T
DI
ODH@

BJJ?
@S<HKG@
JA
<I
JAAGDI@
O<NF

DN
<
K<K@M<I?K@I>DG
LP@NODJII<DM@
RCD>C
><I
<GNJ
=@
<?HDIDNO@M@?
DI
<

HJM@
HJ?@MI
H<II@M
<N
<
R@==<N@?
O<NF
JM
J=E@>O
I<HDIB

<
H@OCJ?
AM@
LP@IOGT
PN@?
RDOC
NK@>D<G
K<MOD>DK<IO
BMJPKN

NP>C
<N
<KC<ND>
K<OD@ION
'O
DN

>C<M<>O@MDNOD>
AJM
OC@
N@>JI?
BMJPK


H<9
CB@=B9
A9H<C8G
OC<O
OC@T
JAA@M
H@
?D<O@?
<>>@NN
OJ
PI?@MGTDIB
H@IO<G
KMJ>@NN@N
2C@N@
KMJ>@NN@N
<M@
HJM@

<POJH<ODU@?
<I?
PI>JIN>DJPN
2C@
K<MOD>DK<ION
C<Q@
OJ
NJGQ@
<I
@SK@MD
H@IO<G
O<NF
RDOC
JIGT
<
NCJMO
ODH@
?@G<T
#S<HKG@N
JA
OC@N@
H@OCJ?N
<M@

M@<>ODJI
ODH@
@SK@MDH@ION
JM
@T@OM<>FDIB

=JOC
H@OCJ?N
AM@LP@IOGT
PN@?
DI

KNT>CJGDIBPDNOD>
M@N@<M>C
2C@
G<NO
H@OCJ?
OTK@N

<M@
H<9
HFI9
CB@=B9
A9H<
C8G
2C@N@
H@OCJ?N
C<Q@
DHH@?D<O@
<>>@NN
OJ
OC@
M@G@Q<IO
KMJ>@NN
<I?
><I

<NN@NN
CDBCGT
<POJH<ODU@?
<I?
PI>JIN>DJPN
H@IO<G
<I?
I@PMJI<G
KMJ>@NN@N

$PI>ODJI<G
H<BI@O
M@NJI<I>@
DH<BDIB
A+0'
JM
@G@>OMJ@I>@KC<GJBM<KCT

##%
RDOC
OC@
H@<NPM@H@IO
JA
@Q@IO
M@G<O@?
KJO@IOD<GN
#0.
<M@
@S<HKG@N

AJM
OC@N@
H@OCJ?N



































































'I
NJH@
JOC@M
>G<NNDAD><ODJIN
M@<>ODJI
ODH@
@SK@MDH@ION
<M@
>JIND?@M@?
<I
JAAGDI@
H@OC
J?
2C@N@
>G<NNDAD><ODJIN
?J
IJO
?DAA@M@IOD<O@
=@OR@@I
JIGDI@
<I?
OMP@
JIGDI@
H@OCJ?N

'INO@<?
OC@T
>JGG<KN@
<GG
=@C<QDJM<G
H@OCJ?N
DI
JI@
H@OCJ?
OTK@
JAAGDI@
<I?
F@@K
OC@

JIGDI@
H@OCJ?
OTK@
JIGT
AJM
@G@>OMJKCTNDJGJBD><G
<I?
I@PMJDH<BDIB
H@OCJ?N


0@N@<M>C@MN
DI
>JBIDODQ@
N>D@I>@N
<I?
I@PMJGDIBPDNOD>N
<NNPH@
OC<O

@Q@I
DI
><N@
JA
OMP@

JIGDI@
H@OCJ?N

OC@
<>>@NN
OJ
OC@
M@G@Q<IO
I@PMJI<G
KMJ>@NN@N
DN
?@G<T@?
2CDN
DN
K@M
C<KN
OMP@

=PO
IJO
M@G@Q<IO
AJM
OC@
KPMKJN@
JA
OCDN
K<K@M

,<99
IG99
C:
9LD99F=A
A9BHH5@
A
A9H<
<C8G
=B
@=B;I
I=GH==7
F99G95FF7< 

$DB
BPM@

+
+@OC
CJ?NN
DI
M@G<<ODJI
I
OJ
ODH
H@

'I
OC@@
AJ
JGGJR
RDIIB
K<MM<BMM<KC
CN
'
R
RDGG
?@N>MDD=@
OC@@
<?Q<<IO< I?
?DNN<?
<B@NN
<I
Q<IIO<BB@N
JA
OOC@
OCM@@@
H
H@OOCJ?
?
OT
TK@NN

':::@=B99
A99H<CC8G



KKMJ= =G@H
H
RRC@@I
P PNDIIB
J JAAGDII@
HH@OOCJ? C<O
OOC@
M@NN@<MM>C@@M
C
?N
DDN
OC C<N
I IJ
J JM
GDOOG@@

IOMJ
>JI JG
JQQ@M
OC@@
>JP PMN@@
JAA
OC@@
?<<O<
>JGGG@>ODDJI
2C
CDN
DDN
@NNK@>>D<GGGT
OOMP@@
RC I
OC@@

C@I
?<OO<
<M@

< >JGG
> G@>O@@?
QD<
<I
DIOO@MI I@O==<N@ @?
LP@
L @NODJJII I<DM@@
&JR
& R@Q@@M

RC C@I
OCDNN

<KKKMJ<>C C
DN
@HKKGJT T@??

DO
DN
P
PNPP<GGTT
KJJNNDD=G@
OJ
H@<NP PM@
OOC@
ODHH@
OC C@
KK<MOD>D
K<IION
I@@@?
OOJ
ADIDN
A NC
OC@
O O<NNF
5C 5C@I
<I
@S>>@NNNDQ@@
<H HJP PIO
JA
ODH
H@
DNN
PNN@?


K<MMOD>DDK<IION
><II
=@@
@S>>GP? ?@? ?
AMJ
JH
OOC@
?<OO<
N@@O

=DDB
< <?Q<<IO< <B@@
JA
OC@

JAAAGDI@@

H@@OCJ J?N
DN
OCC<O
Q@@MT
G<MMB@
?<OO<
<H HJP PION
>< <I
=
=@
>JGG@@>O@@?
<O
JI I>@
2CC@DM
PN@@

<GNJ
H@<I
H IN
@@<NT T
GJJBDNNOD>NN
<I
I?
<GH
< HJNOO
IJ J
>J
JNON
2C
C@
JAAGD
J DI@
H@@OCJ J?N
<DH H
<OO

O@NODIBB
K<<MOD>DK<<IONNo
>JH HK@OO@I>>@
<<I?
<M@@
NP PDO<==G@
AJM
B@OODIIB
AADMNO
DI BCONN

INDB
DIOJ
K<MODD>DK<IOONo
GDDIBP PDNOOD>
KKM@AA@M@@I>@
@N
J JM
BMM<HHH<<OD>< <G
EP
P?BBH@@ION
2C ?<O<<

C@
?
JH
<<I
J
AMJ JAAGDDI@
O<NNF
><I
C@GK
OJ J
B@@I@M<O@@
NKK@>DDAD>
CTKKJOC C@N@@N
AAJM
<I

< @SK K@MD
H@@IO 



B@=B99
A99H<CC8G

'B
-II@
?DN<
? <?Q<<IO< <B@
JA
OC@@
JI
IGDI
I@
H
H@OCJ?
?N
DN

D <<
>@MO<DDI
NGJR
N R?J JRI I

?
?P@

AJMM

<HK
@S< KG@

OJ
OC@@
NK@@??
JA
C<I I?
HJ H@I
JQ@H ION

RCC@I
H@@<NP PMDI
IB
M@<>ODJI H@NN

I
ODH
DI
<
G@SD>
G ><G
?@>>DNDJI
O<NNF
POO
<GGNJ
DI
@T@@OM<<>FDDIB
OC@@M@
DN
<
NGJR
N R?J JRI I


-AAAGDI@@
H@@OCJ??N
><I
=@

= <GNJ
PN@?
P ?
AJMM
O@NNODIB
B
<
NK@>
N >DAD>
GDIB
BPDNOOD>
CTKJ
C JOC@NNDN
2
2CDNN
?@
K@I
I?N
J JI
OCC@
<
<DH
<<I?
OC@
M@N@@<M>C
C
LP
P@NODJ JI
JJA
OC@
DI??DQD?P<G
NOPP?T
 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

><PN@?
=T
OC@
HJQ@H@IO
JA
OC@
@T@
-IGDI@
H@OCJ?N
H<F@
M@G<ODQ@GT
CDBC

JMB<IDU<ODJI<G
?@H<I?N
JI@
K@MNJI
K@M
M@>JM?DIB
N@NNDJI

C@I>@
NH<GG@M

N<HKG@N
!JIND?@MDIB
OC@
A<>O
OC<O
JI@
I@@?N
<=JPO
OR@IOT
K<MOD>DK<ION
OJ

MPI
<
KMJK@M
NO<ODNOD><G
<I<GTNDN
OCDN
DN
IJO
<
OMDQD<G
KJDIO

@NK@>D<GGT
DI
OC@

><N@
JA
>MJNNGDIBPDNOD>
M@N@<M>C
'I
>JIOM<NO
OJ
OC@
JAAGDI@
H@OCJ?N

OC@
M@
N@<M>C@M
C<N
HJM@
>JIOMJG
JQ@M
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJ>@?PM@
<I?
OC@
O<NF

@S@>PODJI
2C@
JIGDI@
H@OCJ?N
<M@
NPDO<=G@
AJM
O@NODIB
PI>JIN>DJPN
<I?
<P
OJH<ODU@?
H@IO<G
KMJ>@NN@N

RDOC
AJ>PN
JI
K<MOD>DK<IONo
K@MAJMH<I>@
2C@N@

H@OCJ?N
<M@
<
BJJ?
OJJG
AJM
O@NODIB
>JI>M@O@
GDIBPDNOD>
CTKJOC@N@N

,FI9
CB@=B9
A9H<C8G


2C@N@
H@OCJ?N
H<F@
>JIND?@M<=G@
JMB<IDU<ODJI<G
<I?
ADI<I>D<G
?@H<I?N

2CDN
DN
RCT
NOP?D@N
PNDIB
OMP@
JIGDI@
O@>CIDLP@N
<M@
PNP<GGT
=<N@?
JI
?<O<

AMJH
JIGT
<
A@R
NP=E@>ON
IJOC@M
?DN<?Q<IO<B@
JA
OC@N@
H@OCJ?N
DN
<
M<OC@M

C@<QT
?@K@I?@I>T
JI
lCD??@Im
NO<ODNOD><G
KMJ>@?PM@N
<I?
><G>PG<ODJIN
2CDN

H@<IN
OC<O
Q<MDJPN
OJJGN
PN@?
AJM
OC@
?<O<
<I<GTNDN
<I?
QDNP<GDU<ODJI
@B


M<DI
4JT<B@M
AJM
API>ODJI<G
<I?
NOMP>OPM<G
+0'
?<O<
N@ON
JK@M<O@
JI
H<IT

KM@N@O
?@A<PGON
OC<O
<M@
LPDO@
DHKJNND=G@
AJM
OC@
M@N@<M>C@M
G@O
<GJI@
G<TK@M
NJI
OJ
M@OM<>O
<I?
PI?@MNO<I?
+JM@JQ@M

=@><PN@
JA
OC@
>JHKG@SDOT
JA
OC@

@IODM@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJOJ>JG

JIGT
NDHKGDAD@?
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?@NDBIN
><I
=@

@HKGJT@?
??DODJI<GGT

OC@M@
<M@
<GNJ
N@MDJPN
O@>CID><G
M@NOMD>ODJIN
JI
O<NF

@S@>PODJI
@B

JI
AM@@
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
I
<?Q<IO<B@
JA
OC@N@
H@OC
J?N
DN
OC@
KJNND=DGDOT
OJ
NOP?T
CDBCGT
<POJH<ODU@?
<I?
PI>JIN>DJPN
H@IO<G

<I?
?6FC@?2=
KMJ>@NN@N
"@K@I?DIB
JI
OC@
OTK@

OC@N@
H@OCJ?N
<M@
NPDO<=G@

AJM
DIQ@NODB<ODIB
OC@
ODH@
>JPMN@
JA
G<IBP<B@
KMJ>@NNDIB
@B

#0.
DI
##%

JM
OC@
GJ><GDU<ODJI
JA
G<IBP<B@
NFDGGN
@B

.#2

A+0'
'I
HT
JKDIDJI
OC@
OMP@

JIGDI@
H@OCJ?N
NCJPG?
=@
JIGT
PN@?

RC@I
=@C<QDJM<G
H@OCJ?N
><I
IJ
GJIB
@M
KMJQD?@
<INR@MN

"2?8F286
AC@5F4E:@?
C6D62C49

@AJM@
BJDIB
DIOJ
<
HJM@
?@O<DG@?
?@N>MDKODJI
JA
OC@
Q<MDJPN
H@OCJ?N
'
PN@
DI

HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C

'
RJPG?
GDF@
OJ
H@IODJI
<
IPH=@M
JA
KJDION
M@G<O@?
OJ
OC@

NOP?T
JA
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
DI
B@I@M<G


2CDN
M@N@<M>C
<M@<
C<N
<
GJIB
OM<?DODJI
DI
GDIBPDNOD>
M@N@<M>C
AJM
<I
JQ@MQD@R

N@@
!<MMJGG


'O
?@<GN
RDOC
<GG
KC@IJH@I<
GDIF@?
OJ
OC@
KMJ?P>ODJI
JA

NKJF@I
<I?
RMDOO@I
G<IBP<B@
DI
?DAA@M@IO
KJKPG<ODJIN
2C@M@
<M@
NJH@
>C<G
G@IB@N
OJ
=@
?@<GO
RDOC

@NK@>D<GGT
RC@I
NOP?TDIB
NKJF@I
G<IBP<B@
2C@

GJBDNOD><G
<I?
O@>CID><G
M@LPDM@H@ION
<M@
LPDO@
CDBC
NDI>@
K<MOD>DK<ION
HPNO

=@
O@NO@?
DI?DQD?P<GGT
N
H@IODJI@?
<=JQ@

<
B@I@M<G
MPG@
DN
OJ
C<Q@
?<O<

,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


AMJH
<O
G@<NO
OR@IOT
NP=E@>ON
OJ
><MMT
JPO
<
BJJ?
NO<ODNOD><G
<I<GTNDN
&JR@Q
@M

OC@
@HKDMD><G
Q<GP@
NCJRN
OC<O
=@><PN@
JA
PI@SK@>O@?
O@>CID><G
KMJ=G@HN

<I?
JOC@M
NJPM>@N
JA
?<O<
GJNN

JI@
HPNO
M@>JM?
<=JPO

HJM@
K<MOD>DK<ION

OC<I
OC@
HDIDH<G
IPH=@M
M@LPDM@?
AJM
<
KMJK@M
NO<ODNOD><G
<I<GTNDN


IJOC@M
KJDIO
DN
OC@
>JHK<M<=DGDOT
JA
@SK@MDH@IO<G
N@OODIBN
2C@
@IODM@

@SK@MDH@IO
DN
<GHJNO
I@Q@M
MPI
=T
JI@
<I?
OC@
N<H@
K@MNJI
PO
@Q@I
DA
JIGT

JI@
K@MNJI
DN
DI
>C<MB@

DO
DN
Q@MT
DHKJMO<IO
OJ
F@@K
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJOJ
>JG
<>MJNN
DI?DQD?P<G
M@>JM?DIBN
<N
>JINDNO@IO
<N
KJNND=G@
<I?
OJ
HDIDHDU@

Q<MD<ODJIN
DI
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJ>@?PM@

DI>G
OC@
DINOMP>ODJI
<I?
DIO@M<>
ODJIN
=@OR@@I
K<MOD>DK<ION
<I?
DIQ@NODB<OJM


N
DI
<IT
JOC@M
M@N@<M>C
OC@
>M@<ODJI
JA
<
BJJ?
NODHPGPN
N@O
DN
<I
@NN@IOD<G

KM@M@LPDNDO@
AJM
<
R@GG?@NDBI@?
NOP?T
%JDIB
DIOJ
<GG
<NK@>ON

RCD>C
I@@?

>JIND?@M<ODJI
RC@I
>M@<ODIB
NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G

RJPG?
BJ
=@TJI?
OC@
N>JK@

JA
OC@
KM@N@IO
K<K@M
GNJ

?DAA@M@IO
M@N@<M>C
LP@NODJIN
<I?
@SK@MDH@IO<G

?@NDBIN
><GG
AJM
?DAA@M@IO
NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G
PO
DI
B@I@M<G

OC@
AJGGJRDIB

KJDION
NCJPG?
<GR<TN
=@
O<F@I
DIOJ
<>>JPIO
DI
JM?@M
OJ
<QJD?
PI?@NDM<=G@

ND?@
@AA@>ON
<I?
=D<N@N
<
NPAAD>D@IO
<HJPIO
JA
ADGG@MN
<
MPG@
JA
OCPH=
ORD>@

<N
H<IT
ADGG@MN
<N
O@NODIB >MDOD><G
DO@HN

>JIOMJG
JQ@M
RJM?
AM@LP@I>T
<I?

RJM?
G@IBOC
JKODJI<GGT
<GNJ
OC@
IPH=@M
JA
NTGG<=G@N

>JIOMJG
JQ@M
OC@
?@
BM@@
JA
>JI>M@O@I@NN <=NOM<>OI@NN

<I?
<R<M@I@NN
JA
DIO@M>PGOPM<G
<NK@>ON


*<NO
=PO
IJO
G@<NO
2C@
OM<IN>MDKODJI
JA
NKJF@I
G<IBP<B@
<P?DJ
?<O<
DN

Q@MT
ODH@?@H<I?DIB
2CDN
I@@?N
OJ
=@
O<F@I
DIOJ
>JIND?@M<ODJI
RC@I
KG<I
IDIB
<
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
NOP?T

2C@
H@OCJ?N
<I?
O<NFN
'
PN@
DI
HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C
<M@
@GD>DO<ODJI

H@HJMT

O<NFN

@T@OM<>FDIB

OC@
H@<NPM@H@IO
JA
NK@@>C
JIN@O
ODH@N
1-2

KM@A@M
@I>@
<I?
BM<HH<OD><G
EP?BH@IO
O<NFN
"@K@I?DIB
JI
OC@
NOP?T

OC@
H@OCJ?N

<M@
@DOC@M
PN@?
<GJI@
JM
DI
>JH=DI<ODJI
"P@
OJ
OC@
N>JK@
JA
OCDN
K<K@M
'

><IIJO
@SKG<DI
OC@
1-2
H@OCJ?
<I?
BM<HH<OD><GDOT
EP?BH@IO
O<NFN
N
AJM

@GD>DO<ODJI

'
RDGG
?@N>MD=@
OCDN
H@OCJ?
DI
HJM@
?@KOC
=@><PN@
DO
DN
RD?@GT

PN@?
DI
@SK@MDH@IO<G
GDIBPDNOD>N


@=7=H5H=CB
DN
DI
Q@MT
B@I@M<G
O@MHN
OC@
<>O
JA
J=O<DIDIB
NK@>DAD>
G<IBP<B@

?<O<
AMJH
<IJOC@M
K@MNJI
"@K@I?DIB
JI
OC@
ODH@
>JINOM<DIO

DO
LP<GDAD@N

@DOC@M
<N
<I
JAAGDI@
JM
<I
JIGDI@
H@OCJ?
2C@M@
<M@
H<IT
<M@<N
JA
GDIBPDNOD>

M@N@<M>C
AJM
RCD>C
OCDN
H@OCJ?
DN
ADOODIB
$JM
@S<HKG@
<
@GD>DO<ODJI
JA
<

K<MOD>PG<M
GDIBPDNOD>
NOMP>OPM@
@B

75G9
k
>A
"Ĉ=MJRNF<
@O
<G


=

@GD>DO<ODJI
JA
<
KC@IJH@IJI
M<M@GT
J>>PMMDIB
DI
NKJIO<I@JPN
NK@@>C
@B


G=AI@H5B9=HM
A5F?=B;
k
>A
1>CHD@?OJQY


>
O@NODIB
JA
<
NK@>DAD>
CT
KJOC@NDN
@B

89H9FA=B9FG
69:CF9
H9BG9
A5F?=B;
DI
>CDG?
<>LPDNDODJI
k
>A
5DO


'I
OC@
KM@N@IO
K<K@M

OC@
O@MH
9@=7=H5H=CB
DN
>JIADI@?
OJ
@GD>DODIB
GDIBPDNOD>
NOMP>OPM@N

 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

O@F

2JH<N@GGJ


"<O<
><I
=@
@GD>DO@?
DI
?DAA@M@IO
R<TN

AJM
@S<HKG@

=T
>JIO@SO
M@NOMD>ODJIN

NODHPGPN
H<IDKPG<ODJIN

JM
>M@<ODJI
JA
HDIDH<G
K<DMN


"@K@I?DIB
JI
OC@
M@N@<M>C
LP@NODJI
<I?
OC@
KJKPG<ODJI
OJ
=@
NOP?D@?


KD>OPM@N

KD>OPM@
=JJFN

<P?DJ
M@>JM?DIBN

RMDOO@I
O@SON
JM
QD?@J
>GDKN
><I
=@

@HKGJT@?
.D>OPM@N
<M@
JAO@I
PN@?
OJ
@GD>DO
>CDG?M@IoN
G<IBP<B@
>A
!G<MF



2C@
R@GGFIJRI
KD>OPM@
=JJF
l2C@
$MJB
NOJMTm
C<N
=@@I
<
KJKPG<M

@GD>DO<ODJI
OJJG
JQ@M
OC@
K<NO
?@><?@N
DI
H<IT
?DAA@M@IO
>JIO@SON
<I?
<GG
FDI?N

JA
KJKPG<ODJIN
>A
OC@
!&'*"#1
?<O<=<N@
COOK >CDG?@NKNT>HP@?P

P?DJ
M@>JM?DIBN
N@MQ@
<N
NODHPGD
DI
KCJI@OD>N
<I?
KCJIJGJBT
M@N@<M>C
$JM

DINO<I>@

RMDOO@I
O@SON
><I
=@
@HKGJT@?
OJ
NOP?T
KMJ?P>ODJI
DI
<NNJ>D<ODJI

O<NFN
>A
%GP>FN=@MB

"<IFN


AJM
<I
JQ@MQD@R
'
PN@
QD?@J
>GDKN
AJM

@GD>DODIB
NKJF@I
G<IBP<B@
DI
<?PGO
I<ODQ@
<I?
N@>JI?
G<IBP<B@
NK@<F@MN



IJOC@M
O<NF
'
@HKGJT
DI
HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C
<M@
A9ACFM
H5G?G
2C@T
<M@

R@GG
NPDO@?
OJ
>JGG@>ODIB
IJIGDIBPDNOD>
?<O<

<I
DHKJMO<IO
>JHKG@H@IO
OJ

GDIBPDNOD>
?<O<
RC@I
@S<HDIDIB
@=B;I=GH=7
F9@5H=J=HM
HJM@
?@O<DG
N@@
N@>ODJI


2C@
H@HJMT
O<NF
DI
HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C
R<N
<?HDIDNO@M@?
OJ
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION

RDOC
<
ODH@
?@G<T

RCD>C
DN
RCT
DO
LP<GDAD@N
<N
<I
JAAGDI@
H@OCJ?

M9
,F57?=B;
DN
<I
JIGDI@
H@OCJ?
OC<O
H<F@N
DO
KJNND=G@
OJ
NOP?T
@T@HJQ@H@ION

<I?
OJ
O@NO
CTKJOC@N@N
>JI>@MI@?
RDOC
<GGJ><ODJI
JA
QDNP<G
<OO@IODJI
@B

AJM

O@NODIB
OC@
@AA@>ON
JA
G<IBP<B@
JI
>JBIDODJI
'
>JH=DI@
@T@OM<>FDIB
RDOC


H@<NPM@H@ION
JA
GD997<
CBG9H
H=A9G
1-2

<IJOC@M
JIGDI@
H@OCJ?
KMJQD?DIB

<I
DINDBCO
DIOJ
OC@
KG<IIDIB
KMJ>@NN@N
O<FDIB
KG<>@
EPNO
=@AJM@
<
K<MOD>DK<IO

=@BDIN
OJ
NK@<F
2RJ
<??DODJI<G
H@OCJ?N
OC<O
><I
=@
AJPI?
DI
HT
JRI
M@
N@<M>C

DI>GP?DIB

H<9
DF9:9F9B79
>I8;A9BH
H5G?
<I?
H<9
;F5AA5H=75@
>I8;A9BH

H5G?
JOC
O<NFN
=@GJIB
OJ
OC@
JAAGDI@
BMJPK
<I?
<M@
NPDO<=G@
AJM
O@NODIB
<

K<MOD>PG<M
GDIBPDNOD>
KC@IJH@IJI
DI
G<MB@M
JM
NK@>DAD>
KJKPG<ODJIN


I2>A=6D
7C@>
>J
@H?
C6D62C49
C6D62C49
BF6DE:@?D
2?5
E96
FD6

@7
5:776C6?E
>6E9@5D

'I
OCDN
N@>ODJI

'
RDGG
KM@N@IO
<I?
?DN>PNN
<
IPH=@M
JA
NOP?D@N
><MMD@?
JPO

@DOC@M
=T
HTN@GA
JM
DI
>JJK@M<ODJI
RDOC
>JGG@<BP@N
2C@
AJ>PN
RDGG
=@
JI
CJR

N@G@>O@?
H@OCJ?N
DIOMJ?P>@?
DI
N@>ODJI

<M@
<KKGD@?
DI
>JI>M@O@
@SK@MD
H@IO<G
N@OODIBN
'
RDGG
>MDOD><GGT
?DN>PNN
?DAA@M@IO
<NK@>ON
GDIF@?
OJ
OC@
KG<I
IDIB
JA
<I
@SK@MDH@IO
@B

>CJD>@
JA
K<MOD>DK<ION

@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJ>@?PM@


































































$JM
HJM@
?@O<DG
JI
OC@
H@<NPM@H@IO
JA
NK@@>C
JIN@O
ODH@N
N@@
1>CHD@?OJQY
<


%M<HH<OD><G
EP?BH@IO
O<NFN
<M@
>JHHJIGT
PN@?
DI
<?PGO
I<ODQ@
<N
R@GG
<N
*
NK@<F@MN

AJM
O@NODIB
BM<HH<OD><G
<>>@KO<=DGDOT
'I
HT
M@N@<M>C

OCDN
O<NF
R<N
@HKGJT@?
AJM
O@NO
DIB
BM<HH<OD><G
FIJRG@?B@
JA
K<OD@ION
RDOC
MJ><
<KC<ND<
$G<I?@MFJQY

+@MODIN

@O

<G



,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


?@O@MHDIDIB
G@Q@G
JA
KMJAD>D@I>T
DI
<I
*

<I?
>M@<ODJI
JA
NODHPGD
5C@I

M@G@Q<IO

'
RDGG
KJDIO
JPO
KJNND=G@
KMJ=G@HN
<I?
KDOA<GGN

+HI8M

@=7=H5H=CB
+7<A=98HCJO

+5<CB9B?C


#GD>DO<ODJI
C<N
=@@I
@HKGJT@?
AM@LP@IOGT
DI
HT
JRI
M@N@<M>C
>A

1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ


1>CHD@?OJQY



<
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH


@O
<G


1>CHD@?OJQY





<
'I
OC@
H<EJMDOT
JA
OC@N@
NOP?D@N


@GD>DO<ODJI
R<N
PN@?
DI
>JH=DI<ODJI
RDOC
JOC@M
O<NFN
AJM
HJM@
?@O<DG
N@@

=@GJR
'I
OC@
<MOD>G@
=T
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ

@GD>DO<ODJI
R<N
OC@

JIGT
H@OCJ?
@HKGJT@?
@><PN@
JA
OCDN

'
RDGG
KM@N@IO
<I?
?DN>PNN
OCDN
NOP?T

DI
HJM@
?@O<DG

2C@
AJ>PN
JA
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ

R<N
OJ
@S<HDI@
OC@
MJG@
JA

BM<HH<OD><G
<NK@>O
<I?
O@IN@
DI
OC@
@I>J?DIB
JA
BJ<GJMD@IO@?
HJODJI
DI

<?PGO
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
*
JA
!U@>C

0PNND<I

%@MH<I
<I?
Q@MT
<?Q<I>@?

N@>JI?
G<IBP<B@
NK@<F@MN
* 
JA
%@MH<I
RDOC
*
!U@>C
JM
0PNND<I

<N@?
JI
KM@QDJPN
RJMF
JI
%@MH<I

#IBGDNC

$M@I>C

<I?
'O<GD<I
@B

!<M
MJGG

Q
1OPOO@MC@DH

Q
1OPOO@MC@DH

!<MMJGG


Q
1OPOO@MC@DH


*<H=@MO


OC@
M@N@<M>C
LP@NODJI
R<N
KJN@?
JA
CJR
<I?
OJ
RC<O
@SO@IO

>JM@
BM<HH<OD><G
><O@BJMD@N
?@O@MHDI@
CJR
DIAJMH<ODJI
DN
N@G@>O@?
<I?

NOMP>OPM@?
DI
?TI<HD>
>JIO@SON
2C@
M@G<O@?
*
M@N@<M>C
LP@NODJI
R<N
>JI
>@MI@?
RDOC
OC@
M@NOMP>OPMDIB
JA
>JI>@KOP<G
FIJRG@?B@

D@
RDOC
OC@
LP@N
ODJI
OJ
RC<O
?@BM@@
<M@
I@<MI<ODQ@
*
NK@<F@MN
<=G@
OJ
G@<MI
OJ
M@JMB<IDU@

>JI>@KOP<G
FIJRG@?B@
@B

@I>J?DIB
JA
HJODJI
@Q@ION
OJR<M?N
OC@
O<MB@O

G<IBP<B@
K<OO@MI

5@
PN@?

NCJMO
QD?@J
>GDKN
?@KD>ODIB
?DAA@M@IO
BJ<GJMD@IO@?
HJODJI

@Q@ION
>MDOD><G
DO@HN
<I?
CJHJB@IJPN
<>ODQDOD@N
N@MQDIB
<N
ADGG@MN
?DNOM<>
OJMN
AJM
OC@
@GD>DO<ODJI
JA
NKJF@I
?<O<
2C@
G@IBOC
JA
OC@
>GDKN
Q<MD@?
2C@

NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G
<KK@<M@?
<POJH<OD><GGT
JI
<
G<KOJK
N>M@@I
DI
M<I?JH

JM?@M
RDOC
<
ADQ@
N@>JI?
=G<IF
DI
=@OR@@I
2C@
K<MOD>DK<IONo
O<NF
R<N
OJ
NO<MO

OJ
NK@<F
<N
NJJI
<N
OC@T
FI@R
RC<O
R<N
C<KK@IDIB
DI
OC@
>GDK
2C@
LP@NODJI

DI
OC@
DINOMP>ODJI
R<N
KM@N@IO@?
DI
KM@N@IO
O@IN@
%@MH<I
/5G
D5GG=9FH

!U@>C
C
G9
8ď>9
0PNND<I
ÿHC
DFC=G7<C8=H
'I
JM?@M
OJ
@INPM@
>JHK<M<=G@

>JI?DODJIN
<>MJNN
M@>JM?DIBN

<
NO<I?<M?
@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJ>@?PM@
R<N
?@Q@G
JK@?
<I?
N@O
?JRI
DI
RMDOO@I
O@SO
OJ
=@
M@K@<O@?
DI
@Q@MT
N@NNDJI
5@
<GNJ


2C@
<==M@QD<ODJI
*
M@A@MN
OJ
N@>JI?
G<IBP<B@N
NK@<F@MN
RCJ
NK@<F
OC@
O<MB@O
G<I
BP<B@
<N
OC@DM
OCDM?

AJPMOC
JM
@Q@I
ADAOC
G<IBP<B@
'O
M@AG@>ON
OC@
A<>O
OC<O
#PMJK@<I
*

NK@<F@MN
<I?
K<MOD>DK<ION
DI
JPM
NOP?D@N
<M@
JAO@I
HPGODGDIBP<G
<I?
%@MH<I
DN
IJO
<G
R<TN
OC@DM
N@>JI?
AJM@DBI
G<IBP<B@


2C@
@SKG<I<ODJI
<I?
?DN>PNNDJI
JA
OC@
O@MHN
>JI>@KOP<G
M@NOMP>OPMDIB
<I?
>JI>@KOP<G

FIJRG@?B@
><I
=@
AJPI?
DI
1>CHD@?OJQY
<



 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

>JIOMJGG@?
AJM
OC@
@AA@>O
JA
G<IBP<B@
HJ?@
>A
%MJNE@<I


2J
H<F@
NPM@

OC<O
K<MOD>DK<ION
R@M@
@SKJN@?
JIGT
OJ
OC@
O@NO@?
G<IBP<B@
?PMDIB
OC@
M@
>JM?DIB

JIGT
<
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@M
JA
OCDN
G<IBP<B@
!U@>C

%@MH<I

0PNND<I

R<N
KM@N@IO
<O
OC@
M@>JM?DIB
<I?
DIO@M<>O@?
RDOC
OC@
K<MOD>DK<IO
2C@
<P?DJ

?<O<
R@M@
?DBDO<GGT
M@>JM?@?

OM<IN>MD=@?
<I?
>J?@?
=T
OC@
DIQ@NODB<OJMN

2C@
>J?DIB
N>C@H@
>JHKMDN@?
OC@
>J?DIB
JA
BM<HH<OD><G
<NK@>O

O@IN@

<I?

M@A@M@I>@
OJ
@I?KJDION
'I
JM?@M
OJ
><G>PG<O@
DIO@M>J?@M
M@GD<=DGDOT
AJM
?<O<

AMJH
@<>C
G<IBP<B@

R@
<NF@?
<IJOC@M
GDIBPDNO
RCJ
R<N
<GNJ
<
I<ODQ@

NK@<F@M
JA
OC<O
G<IBP<B@
OJ
>J?@
G<MB@
K<MON
JA
OC@
?<O<
2CDN
R<T
AJM
@<>C

G<IBP<B@
OC@M@
R@M@
OCM@@
>J?@MN
OC@
<POCJMN
JA
OC@
NOP?T
<I?
<I
<??DODJI<G

GDIBPDNO
$JM
OC@
?<O<
<I<GTN@N
R@
PN@?
<
>JH=DI<ODJI
JA
LP<GDO<ODQ@
<I?

LP<IODO<ODQ@
NO<ODNOD><G
OJJGN


2CDMOT
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
AJM
@<>C
*
<N
R@GG
<N

<?Q<I>@?
*
NK@<F@MN
JA

%@MH<I

RDOC
!U@>C
*


RDOC
0PNND<I
*
R@M@
M@>MPDO@?
AJM
OCDN

NOP?T
GG
K<MOD>DK<ION
R@M@
>JHK<M<=G@
DI
O@MHN
JA
NJ>DJ@>JIJHD><G
<I?

@?P><ODJI<G
=<>FBMJPI?
2C@
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@M
?<O<
R@M@
>JGG@>O@?
DI
OC@

M@NK@>ODQ@
>JPIOMD@N
GG
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
R@M@
NOP?@ION
GG
I<ODQ@
<I?
*

NK@<F@MN
R@M@
=@OR@@I

<I?

T@<MN
JG?
<Q@M<B@
<B@

T@<MN
2C@
*

NK@<F@M
?<O<
R@M@
>JGG@>O@?
DI
%@MH<IT
0PNND<I
*
NK@<F@MN
JA
%@MH<I

GDQDIB
DI
&@D?@G=@MB
<I?
DI
OC@
!U@>C
0@KP=GD>
!U@>C
NK@<F@MN
JA
*
%@M
H<I
GDQDIB
DI
.M<BP@
GG
*
NK@<F@MN
R@M@
@DOC@M
NOP?@ION
JA
%@MH<I
DI

CDBC@M
N@H@NO@MN
JM
KMJA@NNDJI<GN
@B

DIO@MKM@O@MN

OM<ING<OJMN

%@MH<I

G<IBP<B@
O@<>C@MN

1DI>@
JPM
NOP?T
?@<GO
RDOC
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
JA
<?Q<I>@?
<I?
Q@MT

<?Q<I>@?
*
NK@<F@MN
R@
C<?
OJ
@INPM@
OC<O
OC@
KMJAD>D@I>T
G@Q@G
DI
%@M
H<I
R<N
>JHK<M<=G@
<>MJNN
K<MOD>DK<ION
>>@NNDIB
OC@
KMJAD>D@I>T
?@BM@@


































































IPH=@M
JA
KM@QDJPN
NOP?D@N
C<Q@
NCJRI
OC<O
OC@
>CJD>@
JA
G<IBP<B@
HJ?@
><I
C<Q@
<

BM@<O
DHK<>O
JI
G<IBP<B@
KMJ>@NNDIB
DI
=D
<I?
HPGODGDIBP<G
NK@<F@MN
>A
1J<M@N


%MJNE@<I


!@IJU
@O
<G


Q<I
&@GG

"DEFNOM<




2C@
>JIOMJG
JA
G<IBP<B@
HJ?@
DN
Q@MT
DHKJMO<IO
'O
DN

CJR@Q@M

<
LP@NODJI
OJ
RC<O

@SO@IO
<I?
DA
<O
<GG
JI@
><I
H<F@
=D
<I?
HPGODGDIBP<G
NK@<F@MN
lNRDO>C
JAAm
OC@
G<I
BP<B@N
OC<O
DN <M@
IJO
=@DIB
<>ODQ@GT
PN@?
<O
<
K<MOD>PG<M
HJH@IO
$JM
@S<HKG@

DI

ORJ
@T@OM<>FDIB
@SK@MDH@ION
+<MD<I

1KDQ@T

C<Q@
?@HJINOM<O@?
OC<O
OC@
IJI
<>ODQ@
G<IBP<B@
<AA@>ON
NKJF@I
G<IBP<B@
KMJ>@NNDIB
DI
=DGDIBP<G
NK@<F@MN


2C@
><G>PG<ODJI
JA
DIO@M>J?@M
M@GD<=DGDOT
JM
DIO@M>J?@M
<BM@@H@IO
DN
DI
HT
JKDIDJI
<I

<=NJGPO@GT
@NN@IOD<G
KM@M@LPDNDO@
AJM
<IT
NOP?T
JA
GDIBPDNOD>
?<O<
'
RDGG
@G<=JM<O@
OCDN

KJDIO
DI
OC@
>JI>GP?DIB
K<MO
JA
OCDN
K<K@M



2J
@INPM@
OC@
>JHK<M<=DGDOT
JA
OC@N@
Q<MD<=G@N
<I?
OJ
>M@<O@
CJHJB@IJPN
K<MOD>DK<IO

BMJPKN
R@
?@Q@GJK@?
<
=DJBM<KCD><G
LP@NODJII<DM@
OC<O
K<MOD>DK<ION
C<?
OJ
ADGG
JPO
=@
AJM@
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO



O
OC<O
KJDIO
DI
ODH@

R@
R@M@
PI<=G@
OJ
ADI?
@IJPBC
Q@MT
<?Q<I>@?
*
NK@<F@MN
JA

%@MH<I
RDOC
*
!U@>C
GDQDIB
DI
&@D?@G=@MB
JM
I@<M=T

,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


DI
<?Q<I>@?
*
NK@<F@MN
DN
>@MO<DIGT
<
>C<GG@IB@
'I
HT
FIJRG@?B@

JIGT

A@R
NOP?D@N
?@<GDIB
RDOC
OJKD>N
>JI>@MIDIB
I@<MI<ODQ@
*
NK@<F@MN
@B


PGODH<O@
<OO<DIH@IO
DNNP@N
C<Q@
H<?@
<I
@AAJMO
OJ
G<T
JPO
OC@DM
KMJ>@?PM@N

AJM
?@O@MHDIDIB
<?Q<I>@?I@NN
'
OCDIF
OC<O
OCDN
DN
<I
PIAJMOPI<O@
NDOP<ODJI

OC<O
I@@?N
OJ
=@
>C<IB@?

<N
NP>C
NOP?D@N
NCJPG?
H<F@
NPM@
OC<O
OC@
* 

K<MOD>DK<ION
<M@
I@<MI<ODQ@
DI
OC@
O<MB@O
G<IBP<B@
'I
JPM
NOP?T

R@
PN@?
<

>JH=DI<ODJI
JA
GDIBPDNOD>
<I?
@SOM<GDIBPDNOD>
>MDO@MD<
AJM
@NO<=GDNCDIB
OC@

<?Q<I>@?I@NN
JA
<
*
NK@<F@M

#S>@GG@IO
G<IBP<B@
FIJRG@?B@
2CDN

K<M<H@O@M
R<N
@NO<=GDNC@?
JI
OC@
=<NDN
JA
<
R<MHPK
DIO@MQD@R
OC<O
R<N

M@>JM?@?
<I?
G<O@M
OM<IN>MD=@?
5@
LP<GDAD@?
JIGT
OCJN@
NK@<F@MN
<N
<?
Q<I>@?
RCJ
H<?@
IJ
BM<HH<OD><G
@MMJMN
DI
<BM@@H@IO

RJM?
JM?@M
<I?

DIQ@MNDJI
1JH@
<MOD>G@
@MMJMN
R@M@
OJG@M<O@?
-I
OC@
=<NDN
JA
OCDN
>MDO@MDJI

R@
@S>GP?@?
OCM@@
K<MOD>DK<ION
AMJH
OC@
NOP?T

>ODQ@
PN@
JA
%@MH<I
DI

@Q@MT?<T
GDA@
5@
JIGT
DI>GP?@?
NK@<F@MN
RCJ
DI?D><O@?
DI
OC@
=DJBM<KCD><G

LP@NODJII<DM@
OC<O
OC@T
PN@
%@MH<I
<N
OC@DM
?JHDI<IO
G<IBP<B@
DI
?<DGT
GDA@

"JHDI<IO
R<N
?@ADI@?
<N
<O
G@<NO

JA
<GG
@Q@MT?<T
NDOP<ODJIN
<GNJ
AJM
OC@

!U@>C
K<MOD>DK<ION
5@
?D?
IJO
@S>GP?@
<IT
K<MOD>DK<ION
JI
OC@
=<NDN
JA
OCDN

>MDO@MDJI

I
@<MGT
JIN@O
JA
<>LPDNDODJI
+JM@
OC<I

JA
OC@
*
NK@<F
@MN
DI
JPM
NOP?T
NO<MO@?
OJ
G@<MI
%@MH<I
<N
<
AJM@DBI
G<IBP<B@
DI
KMDH<MT

N>CJJG

D@
<MJPI?
OC@
<B@
JA



GJIB@M
NO<T
DI
<
%@MH<INK@<FDIB

>JPIOMT
GG
*
NK@<F@MN
RDOC
*
0PNND<I
C<?
=@@I
GDQDIB
<O
OC@
ODH@
JA
OC@

@SK@MDH@IO
<O
G@<NO
AJPM
T@<MN
DI
%@MH<IT
$JM
OC@
!U@>C
*
NK@<F@M
BMJPK

OC@
>MDO@MDJI
R<N
<
HDIDHPH
ORJT@<M
NJEJPMI
DI
<
%@MH<INK@<FDIB
>JPI
OMT

&DBCGT
OPOJM@?
*
<>LPDNDODJI
GG
*
K<MOD>DK<ION
G@<MI@?
%@MH<I

<O
<
>@MO<DI
KJDIO
DI
OC@DM
GDA@
DI
N>CJJG
<Q@M<B@
G@IBOC
JA
N>CJJG
OPOJMDIB
R<N


T@<MN
KKGTDIB
OC@N@
ADQ@
>MDO@MD<
R@
R@M@
<=G@
OJ
KPO
OJB@OC@M
ORJ
Q@MT

CJHJB@IJPN
<I?
>JHK<M<=G@
*
BMJPKN
RDOC
K@MA@>O
JM
I@<MI<ODQ@
>JH
H<I?
JA
%@MH<I
2C@
H<EJMDOT
JA
OC@H

R@M@
A@H<G@

'I
NPHH<MT

OC@
JIGDI@
@GD>DO<ODJI
O<NF
RDOC
QD?@J
>GDKN
N@MQDIB
<N
NODHPGD

R<N
<
NPDO<=G@
H@OCJ?
OJ
NOP?T
OC@
M@N@<M>C
LP@NODJIN
@S<HDI@?
DI

1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ

$PMOC@MHJM@

OCDN
NOP?T
>G@<MGT
?@HJI
NOM<O@?
OC<O
OC@
RD?@GT
NKM@<?
IJODJI
JA
l1G<QD>
<NK@>Om

RCD>C
JAO@I
JIGT

DI>GP?@N
OC@
0PNND<I
NTNO@H
HPNO
=@
APMOC@M
?DAA@M@IOD<O@?
2CDN
DN
APMOC@M

NPKKJMO@?
=T
OC@
I@SO
NOP?T
?DN>PNN@?
DI
OC@
KM@N@IO
K<K@M
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH

@O
<G

OC<O
NCJRN
OC<O
OC@N@
?DAA@M@I>@N
<M@
IJO
JIGT
DI
OC@
GDIBPDNOD>
=PO

<GNJ
DI
OC@
PI?@MGTDIB
>JI>@KOP<G
NTNO@H


'I
NJH@
NOP?D@N
N@GA<NN@NNH@IO
DN
PN@?
<N
OC@
JIGT
H@<NPM@
JA
G<IBP<B@
KMJAD>D@I>T
'

ADI?
OCDN
KMJ=G@H<OD>
NDI>@
N@GA<NN@NNH@IO
DN
<
Q@MT
NP=E@>ODQ@
<I?
>PGOPM<GGT
?@K@I
?@IO
H@<NPM@H@IO
>A
+<>'IOTM@
@O
<G


?DN>PNNDIB
=D<N@N
DI
N@GAM<ODIB
JA
G<I
BP<B@
KMJAD>D@I>T
<I?
OC@
MJG@
JA
<ISD@OT

 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

"@NKDO@
<GG
OC@N@
KJNDODQ@N

'
RJPG?
GDF@
OJ
KJDIO
JPO
N@Q@M<G
KMJ=G@HN

GDIF@?
OJ
OC@
?@NDBI
JA
OC@
NOP?T
2C@
>CJD>@
JA
NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G
R<N
NP=JK
ODH<G
NDI>@
OC@
QD?@J
>GDKN
R@M@
IJO
>JIOMJGG@?
AJM
G@IBOC

OTK@
JA
KMJO<BJIDNO

K@MNJI

<IDH<G

J=E@>O

Q@CD>G@

@O>

OC@
?DM@>ODJI
AMJH
RCD>C
OC@
KMJO<BJ
IDNO
<KK@<MN
G@AO
QN
MDBCO

JM
DIO@M>PGOPM<G
<NK@>ON
@B

<
>GDK
RDOC
<
OTKD><G

T@GGJR
%@MH<I
H<DG=JS
R<N
PN@?
RCD>C
R<N
IJO
DHH@?D<O@GT
M@>JBIDU@?

=T
NK@<F@MN
JA
G<IBP<B@N
JOC@M
OC<I
%@MH<I
2CDN
>G@<MGT
?DN<?Q<IO<B@?

OCJN@
NK@<F@MN
2C@
IPH=@M
JA
ADGG@MN
R<N
OJJ
GJR
-IGT
<=JPO
<
OCDM?
JA
OC@

NODHPGPN
N@O
>JINDNO@?
JA
?DNOM<>OJMN
7@O
<IJOC@M
?DAAD>PGOT
@H@MB@?
RDOC
OC@

DINOMP>ODJI
O@SO
PN@?
N
H@IODJI@?
<=JQ@

OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
R@M@
<NF@?
OJ

N<T
RC<O
R<N
C<KK@IDIB
DI
OC@
>GDK
5@
?D?
IJO

CJR@Q@M

DINOMP>O
OC@H

@SKGD>DOGT
OJ
>JI>@IOM<O@
JI
OC@
@Q@IO
2CDN
DHKM@>DNDJI
G@?
OJ
NJH@
K<MOD>D
K<ION
KMJ?P>DIB
?@N>MDKODJIN
JA
OC@
KMJO<BJIDNON

OC@
NPMMJPI?DIB
@IQDMJI
H@IO

@O>

M<OC@M
OC<I
OC@
@Q@IO
?@KD>O@?
DI
OC@
>GDK
2C@N@
O@SON
C<?
OJ
=@

@S>GP?@?
AMJH
OC@
<I<GTNDN
=@><PN@
OC@T
?D?
IJO
AJGGJR
OC@
KJN@?
EI59GH=C
Q

1OPOO@MC@DH

)G@DI



C@GKAPG
RJMF<MJPI?
RJPG?
C<Q@
=@@I
OJ
KDGJO

OC@
DINOMP>ODJI
=@AJM@
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO
<I?
<?<KO
DO
<>>JM?DIBGT
IJOC@M

KMJ=G@H<OD>
KJDIO
R<N
OC<O
OC@
ORJ
*
BMJPKN
?DAA@M@?
DI
OC@
<HJPIO
JA

@SKJNPM@
OJ
%@MH<I
&JR@Q@M

OCDN
A<>OJM
R<N
O<F@I
DIOJ
<>>JPIO
RC@I

>JHK<MDIB
OC@
BMJPKN
NO<ODNOD><GGT
5DOC
M@NK@>O
OJ
OC@
<I<GTU@?
><O@BJMD@N

IPH=@M
JA
@I?KJDION
<I?
OC@
PN@
JA
O@IN@
IJ
M@G@Q<IO
=@OR@@IBMJPK
?DA
A@M@I>@N
R@M@
AJPI?
DI
O@MHN
JA
OC@
>JPIOMT
JA
M@ND?@I>@
.M<BP@
QN
&@D?@G
=@MB
2C@
G<NO
KJDIO
JA
>MDOD>DNH
>JI>@MIN
OC@
IPH=@M
JA
*
NK@<F@MN
DI

1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ

@><PN@
DO
R<N
IJO
KJNND=G@
<O
OC@
ODH@
JA

OC@
NOP?T
OJ
M@>MPDO
HJM@
OC<I
ADAO@@I
*
NK@<F@MN

OC@M@
R@M@
IJO
@IJPBC

?<O<
OJ
K@MAJMH
<GG
NO<ODNOD><G
<I<GTN@N
2CDN
KMJ=G@H

JA
>JPMN@

RDGG
<GR<TN

>JH@
PK
RC@I
NOP?TDIB
K<MOD>DK<IO
BMJPKN

NP>C
<N
<OTKD><G
KJKPG<ODJIN

@B

1*'
>CDG?M@I
JM
I@<MI<ODQ@
*
NK@<F@MN

AJM
RCD>C
OC@M@
DN
IJ
l@I?
G@NNm
KJJG
JA
KJNND=G@
NP=E@>ON
JI@
><I
M@>MPDO
AMJH
<N
DN
OC@
><N@
AJM
I<ODQ@

NK@<F@MN
,@Q@MOC@G@NN

<N
H@IODJI@?
<GM@<?T

ADAO@@I
NP=E@>ON
DN
IJO
<
NPAAD
>D@IO
IPH=@M
JA
NK@<F@MN
OJ
?J
<
OCJMJPBC
NO<ODNOD><G
<I<GTNDN
'I
<
AJGGJRPK

NOP?T
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH
@O
<G


<GG
OC@N@
NCJMO>JHDIBN
R@M@
M@HJQ@?
<I?

OC@
?@NDBI
R<N
DHKMJQ@?
2C@N@
DHKMJQ@H@ION
RDGG
=@
@SKG<DI@?
APMOC@M


2C@
KMJ=G@HN
JA
OC@
GJR
IPH=@M
JA
*
K<MOD>DK<ION
<I?
?DAA@M@IO
>JPIOMT
JA
M@ND?@I>@

<O
OC@
ODH@
JA
O@NODIB
R@M@
M@HJQ@?
DI
<IJOC@M
N@O
JA
NOP?D@N
1>CHD@?OJQY





DI
RCD>C
@GD>DO<ODJI
R<N
PN@?
@DOC@M
<GJI@
JM
DI
>JH=DI<ODJI
RDOC
@T@
OM<>FDIB
<I?

H@HJMT
O<NF
OJ
NOP?T
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>ODJI
JA
I@<MI<ODQ@
*
NK@<F@MN


,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


+HI8M

&CB@=B;I=GH=7
,5G?G
Ɇ
%9ACFM
,5G?

M9,F57?=B;
J
+HIHH9F<9=A
9H

5@ 
 

2C@
NOP?T
=T
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH
@O
<G

>JH=DI@?
OC@
@GD>DO<ODJI
JA
NKJF@I

?<O<
RDOC
<
NDHPGO<I@JPN
M@>JM?DIB
JA
@T@
HJQ@H@ION
<I?
<
NP=N@LP@IO

H@HJMT
O<NF
'I
>JIOM<NO
OJ
OC@
KM@QDJPN
NOP?T
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ




OCDN
K<K@M
@S<HDI@?
JIGT
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
2C@
B@I@M<G
M@N@<M>C
LP@N
ODJI
R<N
>JI>@MI@?
RDOC
OC@
@AA@>ON
JA
G<IBP<B@
JI
>JBIDODJI

D@
RDOC
O@NO
DIB
OC@
H<=B?=B;:CFGD95?=B;
<MDCH<9G=G
1GJ=DI


<I?
OC@
G99=B;:CF
GD95?=B;<MDCH<9G=G
!<MMJGG
@O
<G


1>CHD@?OJQY
@O
<G


2C@
<DH
JA

OCDN
NOP?T
R<N
OC@
@I>J?DIB
JA
@I?KJDION
DI
BJ<GJMD@IO@?
HJODJI
@Q@ION
DI

!U@>C

"PO>C

#IBGDNC

%@MH<I

0PNND<I

1K<IDNC

<I?
+J?@MI
1O<I?<M?

M<=D>
Very interesting description of how to improve the stimulus
!JHK<M@?
OJ
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ

OC@
NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G

C<?
=@@I
DHKMJQ@?
RDOC
M@NK@>O
OJ
OC@
<NK@>ON
OC@
IPH=@M
JA
ADGG@MN

NO<I?
<M?DU@?
QD?@J
>GDK
G@IBOC

>JIOMJG
JA
OTK@
<I?
<KK@<M<I>@
JA
OC@
KMJO<BJIDNO


DIO@M>PGOPM<G
PN<=DGDOT
'I
OJO<G

NCJMO
QD?@J
>GDKN
DI>GP?DIB

>MDOD><G



>JIOMJG
DO@HN
<I?

ADGG@MN
R@M@
ADGH@?
AJM
OC@
KPMKJN@
JA
OCDN
NOP?T
2C@

>MDOD><G
>GDKN
NCJR@?
BJ<GJMD@IO@?
HJODJI
@Q@ION

DI
RCD>C
<
KJO@IOD<G
@I?
KJDIO
R<N
IJO
M@<>C@?
RDOCDI
OC@
?PM<ODJI
JA
OC@
>GDK
@B

ORJ
K@MNJIN

R<GFDIB
JI
OC@
K<OCR<T

DI
OC@
=<>FBMJPI?
<
=PDG?DIB
2C@
>JIOMJG
DO@HN

?@KD>O@?
BJ<GJMD@IO@?
HJODJI
@Q@ION
RDOC
<I
@I?KJDIO
M@<>C@?
=@AJM@
OC@

@I?
JA
<
>GDK
@B

<
Q@CD>G@
BJDIB
<GJIB
<
NOM@@O

OPMIDIB
<I?
?DN<KK@<MDIB

DIOJ
<
B<M<B@
2C@
ADGG@MN
NCJR@?

<>ODQDOD@N
RDOC
><PN<ODQ@
@Q@ION
@B

<

K@MNJI
H<FDIB
<
I@>FG<>@
<I?

NO<OD>
N>@I@N
@B

<
><I?G@
=PMIDIB
2C@

QD?@J
>GDKN
R@M@
NDS
N@>JI?N
GJIB
2C@
IPH=@M
JA
>GDKN
?@KD>ODIB
K@JKG@


<IDH<GN
<I?
Q@CD>G@N
R<N
>JHK<M<=G@
2C@
?DM@>ODJI
JA
OC@
<KK@<M<I>@
JA
OC@

KMJO<BJIDNO
G@AO
QN
MDBCO
R<N
@LP<GGT
?DNOMD=PO@?
<>MJNN
<GG
>MDOD><G
<I?
>JI
OMJG
DO@HN
'I
<??DODJI

<GG
QD?@JN
R@M@
KDGJO@?
=@AJM@
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO
RDOC

<=JPO

NOP?@ION
RDOC
?DAA@M@IO
G<IBP<B@
<I?
>PGOPM<G
=<>FBMJPI?N
OJ

@INPM@
OC@DM
DIO@M>PGOPM<G
OM<INA@M<=DGDOT

2C@
O<NF
AJM
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
R<N
OJ
Q@M=<GDU@
RC<O
R<N
C<KK@IDIB
DI
OC@

>GDK
N
DI
OC@
JOC@M
NOP?T
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ



OC@
@HKC<NDN

R<N
JI
?@KD>ODIB
OC@
@Q@IO
<I?
OC@
LP@NODJI
R<N
KJN@?
DI
OC@
KM@N@IO
O@IN@

2C@
DINOMP>ODJI
O@SO
R<N
DHKMJQ@?
<I?
DI>GP?@?
<I
@SKGD>DO
M@LP@NO
IJO
OJ

Q@M=<GDU@
<IT
?@N>MDKODJIN
<I?
OJ
>JI>@IOM<O@
NJG@GT
JI
OC@
@Q@IO
2C@
O@SO

R<N
OM<ING<O@?
=T
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
DIOJ
<GG
G<IBP<B@N
<I?
KM@N@IO@?
OJ
OC@

































































2C@
QD?@J
>GDKN
R@M@
ADGH@?
<I?
>PO
JQ@M
OC@
>JPMN@
JA
OCM@@
HJIOCN
=T
H@H=@MN
JA
<

M@N@<M>C
BMJPK
<O
OC@
3IDQ@MNDOT
JA
&@D?@G=@MB
2R@IOT
>GDKN
DI
OJO<G
R@M@
H<?@
<I?

OC@T
R@M@
<GG
KDGJO@?
<I?
KM@O@NO@?
-IGT
O@I
R@M@
N@G@>O@?
AJM
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
NODHP
GPN
N@O


 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

K<MOD>DK<ION
ADMNO
JM<GGT
<I?
OC@I
DI
RMDOO@I
AJMH
2C@
@SK@MDH@IO@M
R<N
<

I<ODQ@
NK@<F@M
JA
OC@
G<IBP<B@
O@NO@?
>A
>JIOMJG
JA
G<IBP<B@
HJ?@
#<>C

@SK@MDH@IO<G
N@NNDJI
R<N
KM@>@?@?
RDOC
NDS
O@NODIB
DO@HN
>JQ@MDIB
<GG
O@NODIB

><O@BJMD@N
2C@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
DO@HN
R@M@
KM@N@IO@?
<POJH<OD><GGT
AMJH
<

>JHKPO@M
N>M@@I

DI
<
KN@P?JM<I?JHDU@?
JM?@M

RDOC
<I
@DBCON@>JI?
DI
O@MQ<G
DI
=@OR@@I
OJ
BDQ@
K<MOD>DK<ION
NPAAD>D@IO
ODH@
OJ
ADIDNC
OC@DM
Q@M=<GDU<
ODJI
2C@
@GD>DO<ODJI
<I?
@T@OM<>FDIB
?<O<
R@M@
M@>JM?@?
NDHPGO<I@JPNGT

#<>C
M@>JM?DIB
N@NNDJI
OJJF
<KKMJSDH<O@GT

HDIPO@N
AO@M
OC<O

K<MOD>D
K<ION
R@M@
<NF@?
OJ
ADGG
JPO
<
=DJBM<KCD><G
LP@NODJII<DM@
?@NDBI@?
JI
OC@

=<NDN
JA
OC@
LP@NODJII<DM@
PN@?
DI
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ

1P=N@
LP@IOGT

<I?
RDOCJPO
KMDJM
<IIJPI>@H@IO

<
H@HJMT
O<NF
R<N
<?HDIDNO@M@?

OJ
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
N@@
=@GJR
AJM
HJM@
?@O<DG
JI
OC@
?@NDBI
JA
OC@
H@HJMT

O<NF
2CDN
O<NF
OJJF
=@OR@@I
ORJ
<I?
ADQ@
HDIPO@N
OJ
ADIDNC

$JM
OCDN
NOP?T

R@
M@>JM?@?
?<O<
AMJH
OR@IOT
NP=E@>ON
K@M
G<IBP<B@

D@

AMJH

K<MOD>DK<ION
DI
OJO<G
$JM
GJBDNOD><G
M@<NJIN
<GG
?<O<
C<?
OJ
=@
>JG
G@>O@?
DI
&@D?@G=@MB
2C@
NK@<F@MN
JA
M<=D>

!U@>C

"PO>C

#IBGDNC

0PNND<I

<I?
1K<IDNC
R@M@
K<MOD>DK<ION
DI
<
NPHH@M
N>CJJG
<O
OC@
3IDQ@MNDOT
JA
&@D
?@G=@MB

<I?
C<?
IJ
JM
Q@MT
GDOOG@
FIJRG@?B@
JA
%@MH<I
2J
HDIDHDU@
OC@

@SKJNPM@
OJ
%@MH<I

OC@
NP=E@>ON
R@M@
M@>JM?@?
DI
OC@
ADMNO
ADQ@
?<TN
JA
OC@DM

NO<T
DI
&@D?@G=@MB
I
POHJNO
@AAJMO
R<N
H<?@
OJ
@INPM@
OC<O
<GG
NK@<F@MN

R@M@
<N
lHJIJGDIBP<Gm
<N
KJNND=G@

RDOC
#IBGDNC
=@DIB
OC@
JIGT
AJM@DBI
G<I
BP<B@
<GG
K<MOD>DK<ION
R@M@
<=G@
OJ
NK@<F
<O
?DAA@M@IO
KMJAD>D@I>T
G@Q@GN
GG

K<MOD>DK<ODIB
NP=E@>ON

DI>GP?DIB
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
JA
%@MH<I

R@M@
H<O>C@?

DI
O@MHN
JA
NJ>DJ@>JIJHD><G
=<>FBMJPI?
<I?
R@M@
NOP?@ION
JM
KJNOBM<?P
<O@N

<B@?

<Q@M<B@
<B@

T@<MN
2C@
BMJPKN
R@M@
=<G<I>@?
AJM
B@I
?@M
<I?
<GG
K<MOD>DK<ION
C<?
IJMH<G
JM
>JMM@>O@?
QDNDJI


2C@
@GD>DO@?
GDIBPDNOD>
?<O<
<I?
OC@
H@HJMT
?<O<
R@M@
OM<IN>MD=@?
<I?

>J?@?
=T
M@NK@>ODQ@
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
2C@
GDIBPDNOD>
<I<GTN@N
DI>GP?@?
OC@

>J?DIB
AJM
O@HKJM<G <NK@>OP<G
><O@BJMD@N
<I?
M@A@M@I>@
OJ
@I?KJDION
2C@

OM<IN>MDKODJIN
<I?
OC@
>J?DIB
N>C@H@N
AJM
OC@N@
ORJ
O<NFN
R@M@
>C@>F@?
AJM

>JINDNO@I>T
=T
<
N@>JI?
M@N@<M>C@M


2C@
G@IBOC
JA
OC@
DI=@OR@@I>GDKDIO@MQ<G
C<?
<GNJ
=@@I
O@NO@?
DI
<
KDGJO
NOP?T
'I
<

NOP?T
=T
1>CHD@?OJQY
=
OC@
@GD>DO<ODJI
JA
NKJF@I
?<O<
R<N
K@MAJMH@?
PI?@M
ODH@

KM@NNPM@
NJ
OC@
=G<IF
=@OR@@I
OC@
KM@N@IO@?
>GDKN
R<N
M@?P>@?
OJ
OCM@@
N@>JI?N
1P>C
<

?@NDBI
<DHN
<O
@GD>DODIB
CDBCGT
<POJH<ODU@?
M@NKJIN@N
<I?
KM@N@ION
<IJOC@M
BJJ?

H@OCJ?
AJM
NOP?TDIB
K<MOD>DK<IONo
K@MAJMH<I>@


2CDN
IPH=@M
M@A@MN
OJ
NP=E@>ON
RCJN@
?<O<
R@M@
PN@?
AJM
OC@
<I<GTNDN
2C@
<>OP<G
IPH

=@M
JA
K<MOD>DK<ION
M@>JM?@?
R<N
HP>C
CDBC@M
N@@
<=JQ@
AJM
<
?@O<DG@?
?DN>PNNDJI
JA

?<O<
GJNN

,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


2C@
@T@OM<>FDIB
?<O<
DI>GP?@?
OC@
AJGGJRDIB
H@<NPM@H@ION
OC@
OJO<G

ADS<ODJI
>JPIO
RDOCDI
OC@
<M@<
JA
DIO@M@NO

OC@
OJO<G
ADS<ODJI
?PM<ODJI

<I?

OC@
IPH=@M
JA
ADMNO
<I?
N@>JI?
K@MDJ?N
JA
ADS<ODJI
GG
@T@OM<>FDIB
<I<GTN@N

R@M@
MPI
RDOC
<Q@M<B@
H@<NPM@N
<>MJNN
K<MOD>DK<ION
<N
R@GG
<N
<Q@M<B@N
JQ@M

DO@HN
2C@
H@HJMT
O<NF
>JHKMDN@?
ADAO@@I
>JGJM
N>M@@I
NCJON
DI
RCD>C
<

NK@>DAD>
K<MO
R<N
>PO
JAA
2C@M@
R@M@
O@I
>MDOD><G
DO@HN
DI
RCD>C
OC@
@I?KJDIO

R<N
M@HJQ@?
<I?
ADQ@
>JIOMJG
DO@HN
RC@M@
<
M<I?JH
J=E@>O
R<N
HDNNDIB

2C@
>JIOMJG
DO@HN
R@M@
PN@?
OJ
>JIOMJG
AJM
B@I@M<G
H@HJMT
K@MAJMH<I>@

2C@
O<NF
AJM
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
R<N
OJ
RMDO@
?JRI
<N
A<NO
<N
KJNND=G@
<I?
DI

JIGT
JI@
JM
A@R
RJM?N
RC<O
@S<>OGT
R<N
>PO
JPO

@AJM@
@Q<GP<ODIB
OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?@NDBI
<I?
OC@
NPDO<=DGDOT
JA
OC@
>CJ
N@I
H@OCJ?N
DI
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH
@O
<G

'
RJPG?
GDF@
OJ
H<F@
N@Q@M<G
B@I
@M<G
>JHH@ION
JI
OC@
PN@
JA
IJIGDIBPDNOD>
H@OCJ?N
<I?
O<NFN
AJM
O@NODIB

GDIBPDNOD>
M@G<ODQDOT
CTKJOC@NDN

LP@NODJI
OJ
M<DN@
C@M@
DN
5C<O
>JPION
<N
<I

@AA@>O
JA
G<IBP<B@
JI
OCJPBCO >JBIDODJI
'I
JOC@M
RJM?N

CJR
><I
DO
=@

@INPM@?
OC<O
OC@
J=N@MQ@?
@AA@>ON
M@AG@>O
OC@
DIAGP@I>@
JA
G<IBP<B@
JI

OCJPBCO
'O
DN
IJO
PI>JHHJI
DI
GDIBPDNOD>
<I?
<IOCMJKJGJBD><G
M@N@<M>C

AMJH

RCD>C
OC@
GDIBPDNOD>
M@G<ODQDOT
OC@JMT
C<N
@H@MB@?

OJ
<NNPH@
JM
@Q@I
OJ

>G<DH
>JBIDODQ@
?DAA@M@I>@N
NJG@GT
JI
OC@
=<NDN
JA
Q<MD<ODJIN
DI
GDIBPDNOD>

?<O<
"DAA@M@I>@N
DI
GDIBPDNOD>
AJMH

AJM
DINO<I>@

<M@
Q@MT
M@G@Q<IO
<I?
H<T

G@<?
OJ
ADI?DIB
?DAA@M@I>@N
DI
>JBIDODJI=PO
IJO
I@>@NN<MDGT
>A
*P>T


Ɇ

<I
@S>@GG@IO
<MOD>G@
RDOC
M@G@Q<IO
H@OCJ?JGJBD><G
OCJPBCON
<I?
CDION
AJM
OC@

NOP?T
JA
OC@
M@G<ODJI
=@OR@@I
G<IBP<B@
<I?
OCJPBCO
5C@I
GDIBPDNOD>
?DAA@M
@I>@N
<M@
AJPI?

PNP<GGT
=T
H@<IN
JA
Q<MDJPN
=@C<QDJM<G
JAAGDI@
JM
JIGDI@

H@OCJ?N

JI@
HPNO
@HKGJT
T@O
<IJOC@M
H@OCJ?
OJ
H<F@
NPM@
OC<O
?DQ@MNDOT

DI
G<IBP<B@
G@<?N
OJ
?DAA@M@I>@N
DI
OCDIFDIB
2J
OCDN
@I?

<
IPH=@M
JA
H@OC
J?N
@B

@T@OM<>FDIB

H@HJMT
O<NFN
<N
PN@?
DI
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH
@O
<G



<I?
IJIGDIBPDNOD>
O<NFN
><I
=@
@HKGJT@?
@B

NJMODIB

H<O>CDIB

>G<NNDAD><
ODJI

JM
><O@BJMDU<ODJI
O<NFN
<N
PN@?
DI
*P>T


JM
*@QDINJI
@O
<G


'

=@GD@Q@
OC<O
PNDIB
?<O<
AMJH
=@C<QDJM<G
O<NFN
RDOC
?<O<
AMJH
IJIGDIBPDNOD>

O<NFN
<I?
H@OCJ?N
DN
OC@
@?=J
R<T
OJ
<
NCJR
<>OP<G
@AA@>ON
JA
G<IBP<B@
JM

BM<HH<OD><G
NOMP>OPM@
JI
>JBIDODJI
<I?
OCPN
=
@N><K@
OC@
<MBPH@IO<ODQ@

O<POJGJBT
JA
>G<DHDIB
G<IBP<B@
@AA@>ON
JI
>JBIDODJI
=<N@?
JIGT
JI
GDIBPDNOD>

?DAA@M@I>@N


I
<M@<
JA
DIO@M@NO
J'
JM
<
>MDOD><G
M@BDJI
<M@
F@T
O@MHN
AMJH
OC@
@T@OM<>FDIB
M@
N@<M>C
M@A@MMDIB
OJ
OC@
K<MO
JA
OC@
NODHPGPN
RC@M@
OC@
@T@
HJQ@H@IO
JM
B<U@
HJQ@
H@IO
DN
M@>JM?@?


$JM
<
?@ADIDODJI
<I?
?DN>PNNDJI
JA
OC@
O@MHN
G<IBP<B@

>JBIDODJI

OCJPBCO

N@@

1>CHD@?OJQY

<

 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

-Q@M<GG

OC@
M@NPGON
JA
Q
1OPOO@MC@DH
@O
<G

C<Q@
NCJRI
OC<O
OC@

>CJN@I
H@OCJ?N
<I?
O<NFN

@NK@>D<GGT
DI
OC@DM
>JH=DI<ODJI

KMJQ@?
OJ
=@

@S>@GG@IO
AJM
O@NODIB
OC@
@AA@>ON
JA
G<IBP<B@
JI
OCJPBCO
!JHK<M@?
OJ
OC@

KM@QDJPN
NOP?T
1>CHD@?OJQY

1<CJI@IFJ



OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?@NDBI


DI>GP?DIB
NODHPGPN
H<O@MD<G

DINOMP>ODJI
O@SO

<I?
DIO@M>PGOPM<G
OM<INA@M<=DG
DOT

R<N
DHKMJQ@?
<I?
TD@G?@?
M@GD<=G@
?<O<
2C@
JIGT
ORJ
HDIJM
KJDION
OJ

>JHH@IO
JI
<M@
OC@
M@>JM?DIB
JA
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
JPOND?@
OC@DM
I<ODQ@
>JPI
OMT
<I?
OC@
<=N@I>@
JA
DIO@M>J?@M
M@GD<=DGDOT
><G>PG<ODJI
'O
DN
J=QDJPN
OC<O
JI@

NCJPG?
JKO
AJM
>JGG@>ODIB
?<O<
AMJH
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
DI
OC@DM
M@NK@>ODQ@
I<ODQ@

>JPIOMD@N
&JR@Q@M

>JIND?@MDIB
OC@
NDU@
JA
OC@
?<O<
N<HKG@
DI
Q
1OPOO@M
C@DH
@O
<G

<I?
OC@
GJBDNOD>N
JA
H<FDIB
M@>JM?DIBN
JA
@T@OM<>FDIB
?<O<

DI
N@Q@I
?DAA@M@IO
>JPIOMD@N

DO
RJPG?
C<Q@
=@@I
I@<MGT
DHKJNND=G@
OJ
N<ODNAT

OCDN
KJDIO
2C@
JOC@M
KJDIO
JA
>MDOD>DNH
DN
HJM@
N@MDJPN
GOCJPBC
DI
Q
1OPO
O@MC@DH
@O
<G

<
N@>JI?
M@N@<M>C@M
R<N
<NF@?
OJ
>C@>F
OC@
OM<IN>MDKON

<I?
OC@
>J?DIB

'
<H
JA
OC@
JKDIDJI
OC<O
OC@
JIGT
R<T
OJ
?@Q@GJK
<I
J=E@>ODQ@

lR<O@MKMJJAm
>J?DIB
N>C@H@
DN
=T
@HKGJTDIB
>J?DIB
JA
<O
G@<NO
ORJ
JOC@M

>J?@MN
JKODH<GGT
<
HDS
JA
GDIBPDNON
<I?
lI<^Q@m
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
<N@?
JI

OC@
>J?DIB
JA
N@Q@M<G
DI?@K@I?@IO
l=GDI?m
>J?@MN

DIO@M>J?@M
M@GD<=DGDOT
><I

=@
><G>PG<O@?
<I?
DA
I@>@NN<MT
OC@
>J?DIB
N>C@H@N
<?EPNO@?

+HI8M

(F9:9F9B79
>I8;A9BH
H5G?
+7<A=98HCJO
5

.M@A@M@I>@
EP?BH@IO
O<NFN
C<Q@
=@@I
NP>>@NNAPGGT
@HKGJT@?
DI
GDIBPDNOD>N

AJM
<
GJIB
ODH@
N
KJDIO@?
JPO
DI
N@>ODJI


OC@T
M@KM@N@IO
<
KJR@MAPG
OJJG
OJ

B<OC@M
G<MB@
?<O<
N@ON
RDOC
M@G<ODQ@GT
GDOOG@
@AAJMO
&JR@Q@M

><PODJI
NCJPG?

=@
@S@M>DN@?
RC@I
?@NDBIDIB
OC@N@
O<NFN
NDI>@
OC@
N@G@>ODJI
JA
OC@
MDBCO
NODH
PGPN
H<O@MD<G
DN
IJO
OMDQD<G
JM
@<NT
2J
?@HJINOM<O@
<
KJNND=G@
R<T
OJ
?@NDBI

<
KM@A@M@I>@
EP?BH@IO
O<NF
'
N@G@>O@?
<
NOP?T
JA
HT
JRI
1>CHD@?OJQY


<
'I
OCDN
NOP?T
<I
@SO@INDQ@
EP?BH@IO
O<NF
R<N
?@NDBI@?
OJ
O@NO
KM@A@M
@I>@N
DI
<NK@>O
PN@
DI
!U@>C
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
2C@
PI?@MGTDIB
CTKJOC@NDN
R<N

OC<O
DI
>JIO@HKJM<MT
NKJF@I
!U@>C
OC@
PN<B@
JA
OC@
DF9G9BH
D9F:97H=J9
:CFA

@B

JMD=>9.$
lNC@ C@
?MDIFN
PKm
C<N
=@@I
@SO@I?@?
K@MC<KN
PI?@M
OC@

DIAGP@I>@
JA
%@MH<I

1>CHD@?OJQY



<
AMJH
APOPM@
OJ
<9F95B8BCK

M@<?DIB
2J
O@NO
OCDN
CTKJOC@NDN

<
LP@NODJII<DM@
R<N
?@Q@GJK@?
>JHKMDNDIB


N>@I<MDJN


>MDOD><G
<I?

ADGG@MN

<GG
KM@N@IO@?
DI
KM@N@IO
O@IN@
>JIO@SON

2C@
ADGG@MN
R@M@
HJODJI
Q@M=N
@H=@??@?
DI
BJ<GJMD@IO@?
HJODJI
@Q@ION

RDOC
<
KJO@IOD<G
@I?KJDIO
@B

NJH@=J?T
MD?DIB
<
=DF@
JI
<
K<OCR<T

DI
OC@

=<>FBMJPI?
DN
OC@
=@BDIIDIB
JA
<
AJM@NO
2C@
>MDOD><G
DO@HN
R@M@
Q@M=N
?@
KD>ODIB
<
NDOP<ODJI
RDOC
<
M@NPGO<IO
NO<O@
@B

NJH@=J?T
?MDIFDIB
<
>PK
JA

>JAA@@

NJH@=J?T
OCMJRDIB
B<M=<B@
DIOJ
<
OM<NC
><I
!U@>C
Q@M=N
<M@
>G<NND
AD@?
DIOJ
ADQ@
?DAA@M@IO
>JIEPB<ODJI
>G<NN@N
'I
JM?@M
OJ
O@NO
RC@OC@M
<
K<MOD>P
,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


G<M
Q@M=
>G<NN
<GGJRN
OC@
PN@
JA
OC@
KM@N@IO
K@MA@>ODQ@
AJMH
DI
<9F95B8BCK

M@<?DIB

OCM@@
Q@M=N
AMJH
@<>C
>G<NN
R@M@
N@G@>O@?


'I
JM?@M
OJ
<QJD?
KMDHDIB
@AA@>ON

OC@
O<MB@O
Q@M=
?D?
IJO
<KK@<M
DI
OC@

KM@NOJMT
1J
AJM
DINO<I>@

DI
OC@
>MDOD><G
N>@I@
lOCMJRDIB
<R<T
B<M=<B@
DIOJ
<

OM<NC
><Im
OC@
O<MB@O
Q@M=

JM<C8=H(c
JM<5NCJ5H!%(
lOJ
OCMJR
<R<Tm
OC@

RJM?DIB
R<N
<N
AJGGJRN
l'H<BDI@
<
NDOP<ODJI

DI
RCD>C
TJP
N@@
<
H<I
NO<I?
DIB
I@SO
OJ
B<M=<B@
>JIO<DI@MN
?JDIB
NJH@OCDIB
&@
DN
I@<MGT
ADIDNC@?
RDOC

OC@
<>ODQDOT
C@
C<N
=@@I
DIQJGQ@?
DI
&JR
RJPG?
TJP
HJNO
GDF@GT
?@N>MD=@

NP>C
<
NDOP<ODJIm
AO@M
M@<?DIB
OCDN
O@SO
K<MOD>DK<ION
>JPG?
>CJJN@
AMJH
ADQ@

JKODJIN
DI
RCD>C
OC@
O<MB@O
Q@M=
<KK@<M@?
DI
ADQ@
?DAA@M@IO
O@HKPN <NK@>O

>JH=DI<ODJIN
D@
KM@N@IO
DHK@MA@>ODQ@

K<NO
DHK@MA@>ODQ@

KM@N@IO
K@MA@>
ODQ@

K<NO
K@MA@>ODQ@

N@>JI?<MT
DHK@MA@>ODQ@
#S>@KO
OC@
?DAA@M@I>@
DI
O@H
KPN <NK@>O

OC@N@
JKODJIN
R@M@
D?@IOD><G
DI
RJM?DIB
2C@
K<MOD>DK<IONo
O<NF

R<N
OJ
>C@>F
JAA
OC@
HJNO
KM@A@MM@?
?@N>MDKODJI
JA
<
BDQ@I
NDOP<ODJI
<I?
DA

I@@?@?

<GNJ
DI?D><O@
OC@DM
N@>JI?
=@NO
KM@A@M@I>@
2C@

N>@I<MDJN
R@M@

KM@N@IO@?
DI
<
KN@P?JM<I?JHDU@?
JM?@M

DI
OC@
AJMH
JA
<
K<K@M<I?K@I>DG

LP@NODJII<DM@
<I?
<?HDIDNO@M@?
OJ

K<MOD>DK<ION
2C@
LP@NODJII<DM@
R<N

KDGJO@?
RDOC
O@I
I<ODQ@
NK@<F@MN
JA
!U@>C
#?P><ODJI<G
G@Q@G
<I?
<B@
JA
OC@

K<MOD>DK<ION
R@M@
O<F@I
<N
A<>OJMN
AJM
@INPMDIB
CJHJB@I@DOT
JA
OC@
K<MOD>D
K<IO
BMJPK
DI
O@MHN
JA
<B@
<I?
NJ>DJ@>JIJHD><G
=<>FBMJPI?
2C@
NP=E@>ON

R@M@
@DOC@M
KPKDGN
DI
OC@
G<NO
T@<M
JA
CDBC
N>CJJG
JM
ADMNO
N@H@NO@M
PIDQ@MNDOT

NOP?@ION
<B@
M<IB@

<Q@M<B@

2C@
B@I?@M
R<N
IJO
>JIOMJGG@?
2C@

LP@NODJII<DM@N
R@M@
ADGG@?
JPO
DI
M@BPG<M
>G<NN@N
RDOC
<
NO<I?<M?DU@?
DINOMP>
ODJI
BDQ@I
OJ
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
JM<GGT
=T
OC@DM
O@<>C@M
2C@
K<MOD>DK<ION
C<?

OR@IOT
HDIPO@N
OJ
ADIDNC
OC@
O<NF
2J
DIQ@NODB<O@
<
KJNND=G@
DIAGP@I>@
JA
?D<
G@>O<G
Q<MD<ODJIN
JI
OC@
PN@
JA
OC@
KM@N@IO
K@MA@>ODQ@

?<O<
R@M@
>JGG@>O@?
DI

ADQ@
?DAA@M@IO
M@BDJIN
JA
!U@>C
0@KP=GD>
2C@
LP@NODJII<DM@N
R@M@
<IJIT
HJPN
<I?
DI>GP?@?
JIGT
DIAJMH<ODJI
M@B<M?DIB
B@I?@M

I<ODQ@
G<IBP<B@


<I?
OC@
JMDBDI
JA
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
2RJ
NP=E@>ON
R@M@
@S>GP?@?
AMJH
OC@

N<HKG@
=@><PN@
OC@T
BM@R
PK
DI
=DGDIBP<G
A<HDGD@N

"@NKDO@
OC@
A<>O
OC<O
KM@A@M@IOD<G
EP?BH@IO
O<NFN
>JH@
RDOC
NJH@
?JRI
ND?@N

@B

OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
H<T
IJO
DI?D><O@
OC@DM
M@<G
KM@A@M@I>@N
=@><PN@

OC@T
ADI?
OC@
O<NF
J??
JM
=JMDIB
<I?
H<F@
OC@DM
>CJD>@N
M<I?JHGT

OC@
O<NF

R<N
NPDO<=G@
AJM
OC@
DIQ@NODB<ODJI
JA
OC@
LP@NODJIN
NOP?D@?
DI
1>CHD@?OJQY

<
-I@
H<T
NPBB@NO
K@MAJMHDIB
<
>JMKPN
<I<GTNDN
DINO@<?

RCD>C

RJPG?
K@MC<KN
TD@G?
@Q@I
HJM@
?<O<
KJDION
2C@
KMJ=G@H
RDOC
<
>JMKPN


2C@N@
<M@
<GG
KJNND=G@
>JH=DI<ODJIN
DI
!U@>C


1@Q@M<G
>JGG@<BP@N
JA
HDI@
FDI?GT
?D?
OC@
>JGG@>ODJI
JA
OC@
?<O<
2C@T
M@>@DQ@?
?@O<DG@?

DINOMP>ODJIN
JI
CJR
OJ
KMJ>@@?
DI
OC@
>JGG@>ODJI
JA
OC@
?<O<
'I
OCDN
H<II@M

OC@
KMJ>@
?PM@
R<N
>JHK<M<=G@

 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

NOP?T
RJPG?
C<Q@
=@@I
OJ
>JIOMJG
OC@
>JIO@SO

DI
RCD>C
OC@
O@NO@?
AJMH
R<N

KM@N@IO@?
<N
DO
C<?
OJ
=@
KM@N@IO
O@IN@


@AJM@
>JI>GP?DIB
OC@
>PMM@IO
K<K@M

'
RJPG?
GDF@
OJ
KJDIO
JPO
N@Q@M<G
<N
K@>ON
OC<O
NCJPG?
=@
>JIND?@M@?
RC@I
KG<IIDIB
<
EP?BH@IO
O<NF

1ODHPGD

'I
<??DODJI
OJ
OC@
HJM@
AJMH<G
KJDION
GDNO@?
DI
N@>ODJI

DO
NCJPG?
=@
O<F@I

DIOJ
<>>JPIO
OC<O
OC@
G<IBP<B@
H<O@MD<G
DI
<
LP@NODJII<DM@
NCJPG?
=@
I<OPM<G

<I?
IJO
BM<HH<OD><GGT
J??
GNJ

O@NODIB
GDIBPDNOD>
KM@A@M@I>@N
JM
BM<HH<OD
><G
<>>@KO<=DGDOT
JI
DNJG<O@?
DO@HN
D@
RDOCJPO
<IT
>JIO@SO
DN
CDBCGT
KMJ=
G@H<OD>

$DGG@MN
<I?
KM@N@IO<ODJI
$JM
<
O@NO
DI
RMDOO@I
G<IBP<B@

OC@
PN@
JA

<
G<MB@
<HJPIO
JA
ADOODIB
ADGG@MN
DN
<=NJGPO@GT
@NN@IOD<G
'I
<??DODJI

JI@
C<N
OJ

>JIOMJG
AJM
OC@
KM@N@IO<ODJI
JM?@M
NDI>@
K<MOD>DK<ION
C<Q@
<
O@I?@I>T
OJ
>JI
I@>O
DI?DQD?P<G
DO@HN
DI
<
lH@<IDIBAPG
R<Tm
@B

>M@<ODIB
NJH@
FDI?
JA
<

NOJMT
JM
OJ
N@G@>O
DO@HN
M@K@<O@?GT
AMJH
JIGT
JI@
KG<>@
JI
OC@
K<B@
@B

OC@

ADMNO
>CJD>@
AMJH
OC@
G@AO

%@I@M<G

G@IBOCT
LP@NODJII<DM@
RDGG
IJO
TD@G?

BJJ?
?<O<
?P@
OJ
OC@
<OO@IODJI
<I?
DIO@M@NO
NK<I
JA
OC@
K<MOD>DK<ION
'
RJPG?

M@>JHH@I?
NCJMO@M
O<NFN
O@NO@?
JI
<
G<MB@M
IPH=@M
JA
K<MOD>DK<ION


:?2=
(6>2C<D

2C@M@
<M@
H<IT
?DAA@M@IO
@SK@MDH@IO<G
H@OCJ?N
NPDO<=G@
AJM
GDIBPDNOD>
M@

N@<M>C
2C@
AJ>PN
JA
OC@
>PMM@IO
K<K@M
R<N
DI
M@B<M?N
OJ
OC@
JAAGDI@
<I?

JIGDI@
H@OCJ?N
5C@I
KG<IIDIB
<I
@SK@MDH@IO

<
IPH=@M
JA
<NK@>ON
HPNO
=@

O<F@I
DIOJ
>JIND?@M<ODJI
DI
JM?@M
OJ
>JH@
PK
RDOC
<
BJJ?
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?@
NDBI
<I?
OCPN
PN<=G@
?<O<
2C@
M@G@Q<IO
<NK@>ON
DI>GP?@
OC@
N@G@>ODJI
JA
NODH
PGPN
H<O@MD<G

OC@
@SK@MDH@IO<G
KMJOJ>JG

OC@
M@>MPDOH@IO
JA
K<MOD>DK<ION
<N

R@GG
<N
OC@
>J?DIB
<I?
<I<GTNDN
JA
?<O<
@><PN@
JA
@>JGJBD><G
Q<GD?DOT
OC@

><G>PG<ODJI
JA
DIO@M>J?@M
M@GD<=DGDOT
AJM
OC@
>J?DIB
JA
GDIBPDNOD>
?<O<
DN
DI?DN
K@IN<=G@
$JM
OC@
?<O<
<I<GTNDN

'
RJPG?
<GR<TN
JKO
AJM
OC@
PN@
JA
DIA@M@IOD<G

NO<ODNOD>N

KM@M@LPDNDO@
AJM
OCDN
DN
<
KMJK@M
@SK@MDH@IO<G
?@NDBI
<I?
<
NPAAD
>D@IO
IPH=@M
JA
?<O<
KJDION
'I
HT
JKDIDJI

=<NDIB
<
NOP?T
JIGT
JI
LP<GDO<
ODQ@
<I<GTN@N
?J@N
IJO
G@<?
OJ
H@<IDIBAPG
<I?
B@I@M<GGT
Q<GD?
M@NPGON

@S>@KO

AJM
><N@
NOP?D@N
DI
G<IBP<B@
K<OCJGJBT
<I?
>CDG?
<>LPDNDODJI
M@N@<M>C
*<NO

=PO
IJO
G@<NO
GOCJPBC
OC@
PN@
JA
@SK@MDH@IO<G
H@OCJ?N
DN
>MP>D<G
AJM
?JDIB

GDIBPDNOD>
NOP?D@N

OC@
M@N@<M>C
><IIJO
=@
?JI@
RDOCJPO
<
BJJ?
GDIBPDNOD>

OC@JMT

TD@G?DIB
DIO@M@NODIB
<I?
>C<GG@IBDIB
M@N@<M>C
LP@NODJIN

*9:9F9B79G

!<MMJGG

"5

(GM7<C@C;M
C:
@5B;I5;9
@GHJIO
!@IB<B@
*@<MIDIB

!<MMJGG

+


1OPOO@MC@DH

!

2TKJGJBT
<I?
DIAJMH<ODJI
JMB<IDN<ODJI
.@M
NK@>ODQ@
O<FDIB
<I?
G<IBP<B@NK@>DAD>
@AA@>ON
DI
OC@
>JINOMP>ODJI
JA
@Q@ION
'I


,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


0<H<O
#?

,MDC@C;M
5B8
+97CB8
$5B;I5;9
7EI=G=H=CB
KK

@MGDI
?@

%MPTO@M

!<MMJGG

+

1OPOO@MC@DH

!Q


,bN@

0

2C@
G<IBP<B@
<I?
OCJPBCO
?@=<O@
<

KNT>CJGDIBPDNOD>
<KKMJ<>C
'I
!
&<=@G


2
.@>CH<II
#?N

DDFC57<9G
HC
$5B
;I5;9
(FC8I7H=CB
KK

@MGDI
?@
%MPTO@M

!@IJU

(

&PA@DN@I




(@NNI@M

3

FCGG@=B;I=GH=7
=B:@I9B79
=B
H<=F8
@5B;I5;9

57EI=G=H=CB
(GM7<C@=B;I=GH=7
D9FGD97H=J9G
!G@Q@?JI

3)
+PGODGDIBP<G
+<OO@MN

!G<MF

#

=FGH
@5B;I5;9
57EI=G=H=CB
!<H=MD?B@
!<H=MD?B@
3IDQ@MNDOT
.M@NN

"Ĉ=MJRNF<

#


1U>U@M=DINFD

+

.JGDNC
>CDG?M@IoN
KMJ?P>ODQDOT
RDOC
><N@

H<MFDIB
OC@
MJG@
JA
M@BPG<MDOT

OTK@
AM@LP@I>T

<I?
KCJIJGJBD><G
?DQ@MNDOT
"CIF
B5@
C:
<=@8
$5B;I5;9




$G<I?@MFJQY

#

+@MODIN



@U?]Ā@F

-

<=JMJQY

#


ÿ@MIY

+

.J
NPUJQYI]
BM<H<ODĀIJNOD
Q
MJ>JQď
<AYUDD
KĢ]FG<?
?QJP
K<>D@IOĪ
ÿ9G?O
5
G@CJ9BG?O

B9IFC@C;=9
5
B9IFC7<=FIF;=9






%GP>FN=@MB

1


"<IFN

(&

LD9F=A9BH5@
(GM7<C@=B;I=GH=7G
($
(GM7<C@=B;I=G
H=7G
B
!BHFC8I7H=CB
&J=JF@I
.NT>CJGJBT
.M@NN

%MJNE@<I

$

2M<INA@M
<I?
G<IBP<B@
HJ?@
=@=B;I5@=GA
$5B;I5;9
5B8
C;B=H=CB





&@GG

(Q


"DEFNOM<

2

$JM@DBI
G<IBP<B@
FIJRG@?B@
><I
DIAGP@I>@
I<ODQ@

G<IBP<B@
K@MAJMH<I>@
DI
@S>GPNDQ@GT
I<ODQ@
>JIO@SON
(GM7<CBCA=7
I@@9H=B

*9
J=9K





&aCG@


#?

(GM7<C@=B;I=GH=?
@MGDI
F<?@HD@
4@MG<B


*@QDINJI

1

)DO<

1

&<PI

"


0<N>C



0@OPMIDIB
OC@
O<=G@N
*<IBP<B@

<AA@>ON
NK<OD<G
M@<NJIDIB
C;B=H=CB




*P>T

(

F5AA5H=75@
75H9;CF=9G
5B8
7C;B=H=CB

75G9
GHI8M
C:
H<9
@=B;I=GH=7
F9@5H=J=
HM
<MDCH<9G=G
!<H=MD?B@
!<H=MD?B@
3IDQ@MNDOT
.M@NN

*P>T

(

2C@
N>JK@
JA
GDIBPDNOD>
M@G<ODQDOT
'I
((
%PHK@MU

1!
*@QDINJI

#?N

*9H<=B?=B;
@=B;I=GH=7
F9@5H=J=HM
KK

!<H=MD?B@
!<H=MD?B@
3IDQ@MND
OT
.M@NN

+<>'IOTM@

."

,J@GN

)


!G\H@IO

0

D<N@N
DI
1@GA0<ODIBN
JA
1@>JI?

*<IBP<B@
.MJAD>D@I>T
2C@
0JG@
JA
*<IBP<B@
ISD@OT
$5B;I5;9
$95FB=B;





+<MD<I

4


1KDQ@T

+

!JHK@ODIB
<>ODQ<ODJI
DI
=DGDIBP<G
G<IBP<B@
KMJ
>@NNDIB
5DOCDI
<I?
=@OR@@IG<IBP<B@
>JHK@ODODJI
=@=B;I5@=GA
$5B;I5;9
5B8

C;B=H=CB





+bGG@M

,

2M<INA@M
DI
=DGDIBP<G
ADMNO
G<IBP<B@
<>LPDNDODJI
=@=B;I5@=GA
$5B
;I5;9
5B8
C;B=H=CB




1>CHD@?OJQY



O
OC@
N<H@
ODH@
2C@
@SKM@NNDJI
JA
NDHPGO<I@DOT
DI
G@<MI@M

Q<MD@OD@N
@MGDI
?@
%MPTO@M

1>CHD@?OJQY



"J
*
NK@<F@MN
OCDIF
DI
OC@
*
RC@I
NK@<FDIB
DI
OC@
*

!BH9FB5H=CB5@
"CIFB5@
C:
DD@=98
$=B;I=GH=7G





1>CHD@?OJQY


<
5D@
1KM<>C@
PIN@M
"@IF@I
AJMHO
^
KNT>CJGDIBPDNODN>C@

&DIO@MBMbI?@
'I
1
1>CPGO@
#?

'<B9
/CFH
?9=B9
.9FBIB:H
^
?9=B9
/9@H
9GH=AAH

+DF57<9
9B?9B
KK

+bINO@M
5<>CNH<II

 5F65F5
%9FH=BG

1>CHD@?OJQY



4@MBG@D>C
QJI
?@PON>C@I
PI?
ON>C@>CDN>C@I
FPINOCDNOJMDN>C@I

2@SO@I
'I
1
&aCI@

'
$D<G<$bMNO

0
+DFPGYx



1>CHD@?OJQY
#?N

FX7?9B


9FA5B=GH=G7<9G
"5<F6I7<
,G7<97<=9B
^
+@CK5?9=
H<9A5H=G7<9F
+7<K9FDIB?H
^

+DF57<K=GG9BG7<5:H
KK

.M<C<
*D?JQ\
,JQDIT

1>CHD@?OJQY


<
-BH9FGI7<IB;
NI
+DF57<9
IB8
#C;B=H=CB
5A
9=GD=9@
JCB
F9=;
B=G?CBN9DHI5@=G=9FIB;
IB8
,9LH?C<PF9BN
=A
9IHG7<9B
IB8
,G7<97<=G7<9B
93IQ@MaA
A@IOGD>CO@
&<=DGDO<ODJINN>CMDAO:
0PKM@>CO)<MGN
3IDQ@MNDOZO
&@D?@G=@MB

1>CHD@?OJQY



2M<>@N
JA
*K<OO@MIN
DI
OC@
@Q@IO
>JINOMP<G
JA
!U@>C
<?
Q<I>@?
NK@<F@MN
JA
*#IBGDNC
<I?
*%@MH<I
'I
!Q
1OPOO@MC@DH

+
$G@>F@I



+
!<MMJGG
#?N

!*$




1>CHD@?OJQY


<
8PM
4@MR@I?PIB
?@M
K@MA@FODQ@I
.MZN@INAJMH
DH
C@PODB@I

2N>C@>CDN>C
"CIFB5@
:CF
9BHF5@
IFCD95B
+HI8=9G

 



1>CHD@?OJQY


=
8PH
#DIAGPNN
?@N
"@PON>C@I
<PA
?<N
2N>C@>CDN>C@
"D@

#AA@FO@
?@N
8@DO?MP>FN
<PA
?D@
1KM<>CKMJ?PFODJI
'I
+
,@FPG<

)
w]>CJQY


(

4<G?MJQY
#?N
=@=B;I5@9F
+DF57<J9F;@9=7<
IB8
,MDC@C;=9
KK

2b=DIB@I

(PGDPN
%MJJN
4@MG<B

1>CHD@?OJQY



1OPOO@MC@DH

!Q


!<MMJGG

+

'HKGD><ODJIN
JA
G<IBP<B@
NK@>DAD>
K<OO@MIN
DI
@Q@IO
>JINOMP<G
JA
<?Q<I>@?
*
NK@<F@MN
'I

.<QG@IFJ
#?

,<=B?=B;
5B8
+D95?=B;
=B
HKC
@5B;I5;9G
KK

!G@Q@I?JI

3)
+PGODGDIBP<G

+<OO@MN


1>CHD@?OJQY




$G<I?@MFJQY

#

,@PMJGDIBQDNODF<
KĢ@?HďO

CDNOJMD@

H@OJ
?T
+@CJC
5
+@CJ9GBCGH



1>CHD@?OJQY




1<CJI@IFJ

,

"D@
0JGG@
?@N
BM<HH<ODN>C@I
NK@FON
DI

#M@DBIDN#IFJ?D@MPIB
#DI
4@MBG@D>C
URDN>C@I
2N>C@>CDN>C@I
PI?
0PNNDN>C@I

*@MI@MI
?@N
"@PON>C@I
'I
.
%JHH@N


+
5<GO@M
#?N

CFH;9G7<F=HH9B9
$9FB9F
J5F=9HPH9B
#CFDIG@=B;I=GH=?
IB8
1K9=HGDF57<9FK9F6:CFG7<IB;
KK

2b=DIB@I

+<S
,D@H@T@M

1GJ=DI

"

$MJH
lOCJPBCO
OJ
G<IBP<B@m
OJ
lOCDIFDIB
AJM
NK@<FDIBm
'I
((

%PHK@MU


1!
*@QDINJI
#?N

*9H<=B?=B;
@=B;I=GH=7
F9@5H=J=HM
KK

!<H
=MD?B@
!<H=MD?B@
3IDQ@MNDOT
.M@NN

1J<M@N
!


%MJNE@<I

$

DGDIBP<GN
DI
<
HJIJGDIBP<G
<I?
<
=DGDIBP<G
NK@@>C

HJ?@
2C@
@AA@>O
JI
G@SD><G
<>>@NN
%9ACFM

C;B=H=CB





1OPOO@MC@DH

!Q

I?@MH<II

+

!<MMJGG

+

$G@>F@I

+



1>CHD@?OJQY


&JR
BM<HH<OD>DU@?
>JI>@KON
NC<K@
@Q@IO
>JI>@KOP<GDU<ODJI
DI
G<IBP<B@
KMJ?P>
ODJI
'INDBCON
AMJH
GDIBPDNOD>
<I<GTNDN

@T@
OM<>FDIB
?<O<
<I?
H@HJMT
K@MAJM
H<I>@
$=B;I=GH=7G




1OPOO@MC@DH

!Q


!<MMJGG

+

2TKJGJBT
<I?
DIAJMH<ODJI
JMB<IDN<ODJI
K@M
NK@>ODQ@
O<FDIB
<I?
G<IBP<B@NK@>DAD>
@AA@>ON
DI
OC@
>JINOMP<G
JA
@Q@ION
'I


0<H<O
#?

,MDC@C;M
5B8
+97CB8
$5B;I;9
7EI=G=H=CB
KK

@MGDI
?@

%MPTO@M

1OPOO@MC@DH

!Q


)G@DI

5

/P<@NODJ
PI?
M@A@M@IOD@GG@
@R@BPIB
DI
#MUZC
GPIB@I
$=B;I=GH=G7<9
9F=7<H9




1OPOO@MC@DH

!Q


*<H=@MO

+

!MJNNGDIBPDNOD>
<I<GTNDN
JA
O@HKJM<G
K@MNK@>
ODQ@
DI
O@SO
KMJ?P>ODJI
'I
&
&@I?MD>FN
#?

,<9
GHFI7HIF9
C:
@95FB9F
J5F=9H=9G
KK


@MGDI
?@
%MPTO@M

 ,<9
IG9
C:
9LD9F=A9BH5@
A9H<C8G
=B
@=B;I=GH=7
F9G95F7<


4<IK<OO@I




(@B@MNFD

(
#?N

*9G95F7<
A9H<C8G
=B
G97CB8
@5B;I5;9
DGM7<C
@=B;I=GH=7G
,@R
7JMF

,7
0JPOG@?B@

5DOO@F




2JH<N@GGJ

+

%@MH<I
>CDG?M@IoN
KMJ?P>ODQDOT
RDOC
O@IN@
HJM
KCJGJBT
OC@
.@MA@FO
KM@N@IO
K@MA@>O
"CIFB5@
C:
<=@8
$5B;I5;9




View publication stats