Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Registered office: Stroke Association House, 240 City Road, London EC1V 2PR. Registered as a Charity in England and Wales (No 211015) and in Scotland (SC037789). Also registered in Northern Ireland (XT33805), Isle of Man (No 945)
and Jersey (NPO 369). Stroke Association is a Company Limited by Guarantee in England and Wales (No 61274)
CHINA’S LOVE AFFAIR WITH ANCIENT GREECE
WorldHistories
FRESH PERSPECTIVES ON OUR GLOBAL PAST
Mat Elton
Editor, BBC World Histories
matt.elton@immediate.co.uk
British officers
inspect captured
Turkish guns in
Mesopotamia
(today’s Iraq), March
1917. This issue we
explore First World
War campaigns
beyond the western
front, such as the
clashes between
the Allies and the
Ottoman empire
EUROPE SPECIAL 26
Columbus’s son and the
16 largest library in the world ✪
The Big Question: BY EDWARD WILSON-LEE
Has the EU been a success? ✪ From shipwreck to ‘universal library’,
Experts debate the diverse impacts of the remarkable story of Hernando Colón
Europe’s pan-continental project
48
64 Beyond the western front ✪
Perspectives: BY DAVID OLUSOGA ✪ On the
The Munich Agreement ✪ Why the First World War was a truly global cover
PE Caquet on the Czechoslovak, British conflict – and how that story was forgotten
and German view of the 1938 settlement Plus Ashley Jackson on the key campaigns
72 58
The Conversation: Seeds of change
Europe’s highs and lows ✪ BY RICHARD BISGROVE
Simon Jenkins talks to Kathleen Burk
MIRRORPIX
4
CONTRIBUTORS
5
The Briefing
The history behind today’s news
1968 PROTESTS
Expert opinions on
historical issues that
he world exploded in 1968. implication in the Nazi past, stoked
touch today’s world
T Early in the year, the Tet
Offensive launched by
the Viet Cong shook the
youthful discontent.
Protest was often directed at the
traditional left as much as at the right –
South Vietnamese government and its the Labour Party in Britain and Lyndon
American allies. In China, the Cultural B Johnson’s Democratic Party in the
Revolution was hurtling ahead – though United States, but also the orthodox
those in the west who labelled them- Communist parties of Europe. Young
selves Maoists rarely understood the radicals looked to smaller Maoist or
violence and repression of the regime Trotskyite groupuscules, and often
for which they professed admiration. admired movements outside Europe.
All of this tied in with protest Protest reached three notable peaks.
movements in Europe and North In France, student riots and then a large-
America. Sometimes these were fuelled scale strike by the working class (both
by opposition to the Vietnam War – provoked partly by discontent on the
though, paradoxically, protesters tenth anniversary of de Gaulle’s sclerotic
often attacked governments (notably regime) nearly brought the country to
that of General de Gaulle in France) a halt in May. Czechoslovakia enjoyed
that were themselves opposed to US a brief ‘Prague Spring’, with popular
policy in Vietnam. support for a reformist government that
Meanwhile, the civil rights seemed to break with the repression of
Have your say Share your thoughts movement in the American south, Soviet-style communism. And in the US,
on this issue’s columns by emailing us and a renewed awareness in West opponents of the Vietnam War rioted at
at worldhistories@historyextra.com Germany of the older generation’s the Democratic Convention in August.
6
Some movements
see themselves as
heirs of 1968. But
1960s protesters
regard their self-
styled successors
with scepticism
CUBA
‘Corbynista’ supporters of Labour Party f Graham Greene and Carol the world-famous show. Those are the
leader Jeremy Corbyn, and in France
in the protests – by both students
and workers – against Emmanuel
I Reed were filming Our
Man in Havanaa (1959)
today, its famous rooftop
crowds that populate Our Man in Ha-
vana. After the revolution they thinned,
then vanished – ultimately barred from
Macron’s government. But what is the opening scene would not be at the Hotel visiting Castro’s Cuba by their own gov-
relationship between this wave and Capri. Six decades on it would more ernment. Almost 60 years on, Cuba was
1968? Certainly, some, especially in likely be shot at the Hotel Manzana, poised for their imminent return.
France, see themselves as the heirs to the city’s latest luxury spot. The camera In 2016, with Fidel Castro forced
1968. But the leaders of the 1960s would swoop across its shimmering in- to take a back seat through ill health,
protests sometimes regard their finity pool towards the imposing dome his brother Raúl met Barack Obama in
self-styled successors with scepticism. of the Capitolio, recently recoated with Havana and agreed to bury the differ-
Daniel Cohn-Bendit, the most gold. The lens would then seek out the ences of decades. Celebrities such as
charismatic leader of the Paris students nearby statue of Cuba’s independence Rihanna and Madonna rushed to visit,
in 1968, is now (without having hero José Martí (1853–95), scrubbed posing in classic cars on broken-down
renounced his opinions of 1968) spotless and surrounded by flowerbeds streets. European tourists followed hot
a supporter of Emmanuel Macron as part of a grand clean-up around this on their heels, anxious to experience the
against what he sees as the conservatism glamorous hotel that occupies an entire city before Americans descended again
of those who oppose ‘reform’ of the block on the edge of Old Havana. But en masse to ‘ruin’ the seafront with their
French public sector. Asked recently the high-spending Americans this burger bars. (Those idealists spared
how his own generation relate to the opulence was aimed at have not poured little thought for the locals: a lifetime
young people of today, Cohn-Bendit onto the island as expected. of shortages and restrictions has made
pointed out that 1968 is now a long A renowned pleasure-seeker, Greene Cuba a nation of avid consumers.)
time ago, and that “in 1968 no one was first drawn to pre-revolutionary The hype surrounding Obama’s
asked us about 1918”. He also suggested Havana by its brothels, sex shows and visit was huge. ‘Experts’ pronounced
that the very propensity of young people general seediness. That ‘sin city’ forms the approaching end of Castro’s
today to look backwards to previous the backdrop to his comic tale of a
protests hints at the peculiar quality hapless spy, which he began writing there
of their radicalism: it is often rooted in 1957. Returning as a journalist in
in an attempt to defend or revive the the 1960s, the author found prostitutes
achievements of the past. being retrained as seamstresses and taxi
For years, crowds
drivers, and students being deployed to of Americans had
the countryside to spread literacy and the
Richard Vinen is ideology of Fidel Castro in equal doses. filled Havana’s
professor of history at The Americans were leaving, too. clubs and casinos.
King’s College London For years they’d filled Havana’s cabarets,
and author of The Long clubs and casinos, taking short flights to After the revolution
’68: Radical Protest
and Its Enemies
their tropical playground. One service,
the Tropicana Special,l even jetted in
they thinned, and
(Allen Lane, 2018) passengers just for dinner and a night at then vanished
8
communism, swept away by an push ahead with the social and econom-
inevitable tide of Americanisation
Decades after ic reforms they’re crying out for. But
from that powerful neighbour to the Graham Greene’s so far, it has been suggested, the main
north. As with everything else, Cuba’s impact has been an increase in portion
government planned to control the flow. 1959 visit, Cuba’s sizes at Havana’s best-known ice-cream
Mass tourism, reintroduced reluctantly
during the economic crisis of the 1990s
government is parlour, Coppelia, after the president
dropped in for a spot check.
that followed the collapse of the Soviet clinging to the An early admirer of Fidel Castro,
Union, has become the backbone of the Graham Greene jotted in one Havana
island’s struggling economy, and the US
remains of its diary that he wouldn’t want to see the
is by far the biggest potential market. social experiment revolution grow old. With the American
Communist Cuba had been preparing tidal wave stalled, Cuba’s government is
for the influx, revamping and reopening still clinging to the remains of its social
iconic spots to cash in on those looking successor in the White House now experiment. Frustrated young Cubans
to recapture Havana’s 1950s heyday. talks of Cuba as a “brutal regime” and are giving up and abandoning the island
Sloppy Joe’s – where the hero of Our a security threat. A series of mysterious in droves. But for now, it’s still the faint
Man in Havana was recruited in the sonic attacks, apparently targeting US neon letters spelling out Viva Fidel!
toilets – was restored, complete with diplomats, led to staff being withdrawn that light up Havana’s seafront, not the
polished wooden bar. The once highly from an embassy that had only just golden arches of McDonald’s.
fashionable Hotel Capri, where the stars reopened. Travel restrictions were
of Greene’s film stayed, also reopened reimposed on Americans. Talk of
– albeit minus its pre-revolutionary closer US ties prompting change in Sarah Rainsford
roulette wheels. The Hotel Manzana Cuba has once again faded. is BBC Moscow corre-
was the latest addition to the scene, with Even the end of the Castro era passed spondent, previously
a designer shopping mall beneath. with barely a whimper as Raúl relin- based in Cuba. Our
But the ‘experts’ hadn’t counted on quished the presidency to his anointed Woman in Havana
Donald Trump. Over two years after successor. Some Cubans hope that their (Oneworld, 2018)
Obama’s visit electrified Havana, his new leader, Miguel Díaz-Canel, will is her first book Æ
HUMAN RIGHTS
America First
(human rights last)?
On the 70th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights, the US withdrawal from the UN Human
Rights Council is a retreat from a globalist vision
BY CLIVE WEBB
t was, proclaimed Eleanor as expending huge resources on other meeting with North Korean leader
10
American activists
and policymakers
from both political
parties have in the
past provided sus-
tained moral and
political leadership
of Iran, who abused the human rights – not to ratify the UN Convention of in the past provided sustained moral
of their own citizens but were strategic the Rights of the Child. Although it and political leadership on the issue.
allies of the United States. has occasionally supported the Interna- By not offering even rhetorical
In the early 21st century, the tional Criminal Court in the Hague, support for human rights, President
administration of George W Bush the US has also declined membership Trump is abandoning the international-
demonstrated an especially flagrant for fear that it would lead to prosecu- ist vision of the UDHR, which saw the
disregard of human rights in its use tions of American military officials United States’ own security and prosperi-
of torture and extraordinary rendition for war crimes. ty as reliant on its promotion of freedom
to fight the ‘War on Terror’. From this perspective, President around the world. The 70th anniversary
The United States has repeatedly Trump’s decision to withdraw the of the UDHR will therefore be a time to
refused to surrender its national United States from the UN Human celebrate the past – but also to ponder an
sovereignty to international human Rights Council because of its perceived uncertain future.
rights bodies. It took over 37 years to bias against Israel is no historical
ratify the UN Genocide Convention aberration. His administration
of 1948, and 26 years to sign the nonetheless represents an unprecedented
International Covenant on Civil and challenge to the ideals of the UDHR.
Political Rights adopted by the UN Although Washington has been Clive Webb is
General Assembly in 1966. inconsistent in its advocacy of human professor of modern
Moreover, it is the one of only two rights, American activists and policy- American history at the
UN members – the other being Somalia makers from both political parties have University of Sussex
1GREENLAND
Tusk traders
DNA studies of walrus ivory may reveal why Vikings
Malcolm X pictured in
1965. ‘Lost’ sections of
his autobiography, cut
from the published
version, have been sold
4ITALY
Sunken submarine
An Italian submarine accidentally
sunk by a British vessel during
the First World War has been
3 MEXICO discovered off the coast of the island
Devastating drought of Capraia, between Italy and Corsica.
Analysis of sediment samples sug- All 14 crew members lost their lives when
gests that the collapse of Maya the submarine was attacked in March
civilisation was precipitated 1917 after being mistaken for a German
by a massive drought. U-boat. The wreck was discovered at a
The samples, obtained depth of around 400 metres (1,300ft)
from mineral crystals during an Italian naval exercise.
MUSEUM OF ARCHAEOLOGY AND ANTHROPOLOGY/
in a lake in Mexico’s
Yucatán region, have
The Italian submarine Alberto
been used to calculate
Guglielmotti, mistakenly sunk
historic weather con- during the First World War
GETTY IMAGES/MARINA MILITARE
12
5TARBAGATAI MOUNTAINS KAZAKHSTAN
Nomadic hoard
A hoard of around 3,000 golden and precious objects dating back
2,800 years has been discovered in a burial mound in a remote
mountain range of east Kazakhstan. The grave site is believed
to belong to two high-status members of the nomadic Saka
people, who travelled across the Eurasian steppe and were
known for their metalworking skills. The haul includes chains,
plates, bells, intricate jewellery and decorative golden animals.
Golden treasure
found in Kazakhstan
is believed to have
been made around
2,800 years ago
6
5
6COLOGNE GERMANY
Niche interests
An archaeological dig in Cologne’s city
centre has uncovered Germany’s oldest
known library, which may have housed up
to 20,000 ancient scrolls. Archaeologists
initially believed that the “spectacular”
second-century AD Roman remains were
that of a public assembly hall, but were
puzzled to find small niches in the walls. After
comparisons with other ancient buildings, they
now believe that the site was a library, and that
the niches were cupboards used to hold scrolls.
ELIKE SAZ © PHOTO BY OLEG BELYALOV BLV/REUTERS
Inside
Why China
Story fell in love with
ancient Greece
The culture I have been in and out of as China’s first research institute for the
China this year to work with study of the ancient Mediterranean and
of ancient a number of universities on surrounding cultures. Academics there
Greece is my twin research interests: ancient study Greeks, Romans, Egyptians and
Greece and ancient global history. Over Assyrians. The Institute was set up
increasingly recent months I have visited Shanghai because, as the story is told there, one
a source of and Hangzhou in the south, Beijing, academic managed to convince the
and the cities of Changchun and Harbin political and administrative rule-makers
fascination in the less-visited north-east of China. that the study of these cultures was
in China. Michael Scott And one thing that surprised me more worthwhile for China, and as such had
than everything else on these visits was a to be done properly – by Chinese
explores Chinese particular fascination in China with the academics proficient in Latin and Greek,
perceptions of links cultures of the ancient Mediterranean, and so able to study the key ancient texts
particularly with the ancient Greeks. in the original.
between seemingly When I landed in Beijing, a curious More than 100 academics studying
very different cultures picture greeted me – one of the airport’s the ancient Mediterranean are now
official artworks in arrivals. Under the employed in various Chinese universi-
banner headline ‘Cultural Gateway – ties, and there’s a range of publications
Beautiful Beijing’ was an image of on ancient Mediterranean topics as well
Chinese artists feverishly painting as the international Journal of Ancient
ancient Greek sculptures: the winged Civilisationss published by the IHAC in
Nike, several Caryatids and an athletic Changchun. China also hosts interna-
victor. The photo of the artists at work tional conferences and seminars focused
(at the China Central Academy of Fine on Mediterranean antiquity, often
Arts) was taken, the poster explains, by involving comparisons with ancient
a Turk. This seems to communicate Chinese history and literature.
a dual message: first, China is comforta- The popularity of the ancient
ble studying and learning from these Mediterranean in China and the value
ancient masterpieces created by the Chinese currently perceive in its
communities far away in both time and study is, I think, twofold. On the one
distance; and second, China represents hand, there is a belief that ancient
a cosmopolitan melting pot of cultures Greece and Rome, in particular,
that transcends current (east/west) together represent the fount of western
political differences. civilisation. To understand the west, and
Michael Scott is an author, broadcaster and This interest in the ancient particularly the results of China’s
professor of classics and ancient history at the Mediterranean is not confined to art. encounters with the west over past
University of Warwick. His new BBC Two In Changchun I was working with the centuries, requires an understanding of
series, Ancient Invisible Cities: Cairo, Istanbul Institute for the History of Ancient western origins – of the Greeks and
and Athens, is airing now Civilisations (IHAC), set up in 1984 Romans. On the other hand, I think
14
also that 21st-century China feels an
affinity with these ancient cultures.
In the west, though we attribute the
origins of democracy to ancient Greece,
we often feel more affinity with Rome.
It was the Roman model of government
that inspired the founding fathers in
America, and the Romans left a physical
imprint (not to mention a mental one)
on the landscape of most of Europe. But
though the Roman empire and Chinese
Han empire existed concurrently and
traded indirectly via the Silk Roads, the
Chinese feel a greater cultural affinity
with the ancient Greeks.
It might seem odd to imagine
Communist China empathising with
the culture that gave birth to democracy.
But Chinese interest and emphasis is on
the strong (to western tastes, stifling)
community spirit that existed within the
ancient Greek polis community. That
society gave equal political voice to all
male citizens, but also demanded that
everyone place the importance of the
community over the individual – an idea
that chimes with the political ethos of
China in the 21st century. And at the
same time as seeing an affinity in the
political and community outlook of
ancient Greece, China recognises its
reputation for poetry, philosophy, music
and other cultural achievements –
arenas in which China is also rightly Visitors file past a huge statue of
proud of its contributions. Zeus in a casino in the special
autonomous republic of Macau.
Far from being different worlds on Interest in ancient Greek culture
opposite sides of the planet, there is is burgeoning in China
a sense in China that there are more
similarities than differences between
the ancient Greeks and the Chinese. Greek Civilization, published in 2016 by
That perception of similarity has led to Beijing University Press with contribu-
concerted attempts to bridge the phys- tions from academics around the globe.
ical distance between them – attempts And it seems that the wider Chinese
welcomed by the Greek government,
It might seem odd to public are responding. Recent exhibi-
not least as it looks to develop fresh imagine Communist tions at the Acropolis Museum and the
tourism markets. In 2014, the first direct Shanghai Museum each displayed
flight between Athens and Shanghai
China empathising objects loaned from its opposite number
was launched. Universities in Greece with the culture representing its respective culture; the
and China are signing co-operation ancient Greece exhibit in Shanghai was
agreements. Large-scale glossy volumes
that gave birth to a sell-out success. No doubt this is just
are being published in China, making democracy. But its a sign of things to come as China seeks
GETTY IMAGES
accessible the artistic and architectural to engage with, analyse and, to some
treasures of ancient Greece – a notable
emphasis is on the extent, absorb the story and culture
example being The Museum and Ancient community spirit of the ancient Greeks.
15
16 ILLUSTRATION BY DAVIDE BONAZZI
THE BIG
QUESTION
Has the
European
Union
been a
success? 5
Turn to page 72
for a discussion on
Europe between
Simon Jenkins and
Kathleen Burk
Æ
17
The Big Question: Has the European Union been a success?
18
Heidi Maurer
20
MASSIMO SESTINI
Dozens of people pack a boat heading north from Libya to Italy in 2014. Large numbers continue to risk their lives crossing the
Mediterranean, many fleeing persecution or conflict in places such as Syria or Africa, in part because “the EU is responding to
so-called emergency situations rather than working with countries that are not transit states”, says Olivette Otele Æ
21
The Big Question: Has the European Union been a success?
Alejandro Quiroga
22
Katja Seidel Jane Lewis
23
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
Enjoy
j y the
latest issue
FREE with a
INTRODUCTORY OFFER
14-day y trial
today!
BBC World Histories is the new bi-monthly title
from the BBC History Magazine team, offering
accessible and in-depth features exploring a
wide range of topics from our global past
Have BBC World Histories delivered
straight to your tablet
Save when you subscribe
The universal library
The SHIPWRECK,
the ECLIPSE and the
UNIVERSAL LIBRARY
In which a celestial almanac saved Christopher
Columbus and his stranded crew from starvation
– and inspired his son, Hernando, to build
a unique doomsday vault of books
By Edward Wilson-Lee
BRIDGEMAN
Saved by science
An 18th-century engraving
depicts the reactions of
indigenous Taíno inhabitants of
Jamaica to the lunar eclipse on
29 February 1504. Christopher
Columbus’s prediction of the event
saved his and his crew’s lives
26
Æ
27
The universal library
After eight months living on the wrecks, with no sign
of a rescue party, the situation looked bleak. But Columbus
was in possession of a magic book – a pamphlet written by
astronomer Abraham Zacuto, one of the many Spanish Jews
who had been expelled from Spain in 1493. The Almanach
Perpetuum included an extraordinarily precise timetable for
future lunar eclipses extending several decades – and one
was predicted for that very evening.
Columbus summoned Taíno chieftains from tribes in
the surrounding area, telling them that his god was a
vengeful one who, that very evening, would swallow the
moon as a warning to the Taíno against their continued
refusal to trade with the ships. It was a bold gamble: after
nearly two difficult years since sailing from Spain, he could
not have been wholly certain of the date.
Yet Columbus’s luck held and, as Hernando later recalled,
a howl of fear rose from the islanders as the setting sun
revealed the face of the moon being rapidly obscured.
On 29 February 1504, Hernando Colón – then 15 years Terrified, the Taíno were convinced of Columbus’s claims,
old – had been living on a shipwreck off the northern and gave the Spanish additional food – enough to last them
coast of Jamaica for eight months and five days. Though until their rescue from Jamaica four months later.
the main deck of the ship was submerged at high tide, There were many aspects of this episode that must have
the cabin in which he slept on the raised deck was safe stuck in Hernando’s mind in later life, not least the sight of
from the waves – and also from the Taíno inhabitants his father reduced to using parlour tricks to save his hide in
on the shore, who had grown increasingly weary of this most desperate of straits, and the fact that such tricks
the presence of these strange intruders. The Spanish actually worked. But one pivotal point that must have struck
explorers had initially been able to trade copper bells him was the immense advantage conferred by this simple
and glass beads for the local cassava bread, but the printed pamphlet – a flimsy and inexpensive product, but
Taíno people’s taste for these trinkets had long since one that bestowed on its possessor extraordinary power.
been exhausted, and the Spaniards’ supplies of food It was precisely this kind of ephemeral product of the
were dwindling fast. printing press that Hernando was to put at the centre of his
Luckily for Hernando, he shared the cabin with one of own life’s ambition: a universal library that would encapsu-
the greatest magicians the world had known: his father. late the world of knowledge just as his father’s intended
Cristóbal Colón, as he was called in Spanish, had risen circumnavigation was supposed to encircle the globe.
from humble beginnings as a weaver’s son to become one Over the course of his 35 remaining years, Hernando
of the best-known seafaring adventurers in history, with turned his hand to many things: he proposed a circumnavi-
titles and a fortune beyond the dreams of most. Today,
he’s widely known as Christopher Columbus.
Father and son had set out two years previously from
Cádiz with four ships, intent on discovering a route to
Cathay (China), which had also been Columbus’s goal
The almanac carried
in 1492. But that passage remained elusive, and as they
coasted past what’s now Panama that fleet of four vessels
by Columbus was a
dwindled to two, ravaged by woodworm and hurricanes. flimsy and inexpensive
The survivors sailed north for Hispaniola (the island now
divided between Haiti and Dominican Republic), centre product, but bestowed
of Spanish operations in the Caribbean, but the remain-
ing ships were so riddled with holes – like a honeycomb, on its possessor
as Hernando later wrote – that Columbus was forced to
order the ships run aground off Jamaica before they sank. extraordinary power
Æ
29
The universal library
gation of the globe to finish what his father had begun; engineers of search algorithms today, Hernando believed
he served as a diplomat and cartographer as Spain and that whoever was able to collect, sort, and distil this flood of
Portugal plotted to carve up the world between them; information would have a tool of extraordinary power. So,
he started a dictionary and a cosmographical encyclo- whereas the Bodleian famously closed its doors to cheap
paedia of Spain; and he may have established the earliest printed materials such as the plays of Shakespeare and
botanical garden in Europe. But from the beginning his Marlowe, Hernando’s library absorbed everything – from
greatest passion was books. He took with him four recipe books and bawdy ballads to books of law, medicine
chests containing 238 of them when he returned to the and philosophy.
New World in 1509. And later, living in Rome during The collection grew so rapidly that by 1526 Hernando
the age of Leonardo and Raphael, he began to acquire could no longer hope to store his library in chests. That year
them in such numbers as to suggest the beginnings of he began to build an immense villa in the Italianate style on
a larger ambition. the banks of the river Guadalquivir in Seville. Like many
In many respects, Hernando preferred the shadows Renaissance humanists (including the English statesman
to the glare of fame, lingering in the background even and author Sir Thomas More, who that same year began
in the biography he wrote of his father. Yet through construction on his house in Chelsea), Hernando chose to
that book he became central to how history was to build his home and library outside the city walls. This
remember Christopher Columbus and think of the allowed him both to participate in the busy life of the city
voyages he undertook. and to retire at other times into the tranquil surroundings
We can recreate Hernando’s world in resplendent of a garden for reading and contemplation.
detail through the obsessive lists he made describing
everything around him. This tendency to record the
minutiae, making lists of everything he saw – on
occasion taking inventories of his rooms, even down to
bits of string and balls of wax – also enables us to follow
the course of his project in extraordinary detail.
Importantly, for every book he bought from the
age of 21 onwards, he noted the place, date and cost
of purchase, as well as where and when he read the
book, and whether he’d ever met the author. This
enables us to follow a bibliomaniac of Renaissance
Europe in ways that would be unimaginable without his
catalogues. A vast number of the books he bought and
listed in his catalogues have since disappeared entirely;
we know about these only from his detailed lists.
Hernando’s lust for books was not unique among
the men of his day. His age witnessed the birth of
many great libraries, from the Biblioteca Laurenziana
(Laurentian Library) in Florence – with its reading
room designed by Michelangelo – to Oxford’s Bodleian
Library. What set Hernando’s library apart, however,
was its openness to absolutely everything that was
available in the marketplace of books, reflecting his
ambition to collect it all. Though the building was destroyed in the 17th century,
Most of his fellow Renaissance bibliomaniacs were contemporary images and descriptions give us some sense of
scouring ancient monasteries in hopes of finding lost what it looked like. With a front spanning about 60 metres,
Roman and Greek works buried among the manu- and nearly 24 metres deep, the edifice comprised a series of
scripts. Hernando, meanwhile, saw that the printing cube-shaped rooms spread over two floors. Extensive land-
press was changing the way information flowed around scaping provided a view across to his father’s resting place
the world, enabling vast numbers of titles to be quickly at the Monastery of Santa María de las Cuevas, as well as to
and cheaply produced and distributed. Much like the allow for an extensive garden of astonishing variety.
inventions was the He was driven by a fear that his failure might mean
the loss of this treasure trove of knowledge and culture.
wall-mounted case Like many others of the period, Hernando lived in the
shadow cast by the classical culture of Greece and
for vertical storage of Rome, and was acutely aware of the fact that the vast
majority of the writings of the ancients had been lost
books – or, as we would during the thousand intervening years.
Hernando’s library, then, had to be a doomsday
call it, a bookshelf vault, safeguarding Renaissance culture from the
oblivion that had been visited upon the classical world.
But it must also be a living organism, capable of feeding
Spain’s empire with information and providing an
authoritative answer to each question, resolving – he
Though Hernando would have found models for this hoped – many of the religious and political controver-
kind of suburban library in the works of ancient writers sies that wracked the public sphere during his lifetime.
such as Cicero, what he was attempting was on an entirely The system he designed – with its elaborate and bizarre
different scale. Contemporary descriptions suggest that combinations of cages to protect the books, and its
the garden may have had as many as 5,000 trees, some widely distributed catalogues that would allow everyone
possibly imported from the New World to provide local
samples of exotic life. As for the library itself, collecting
on this scale brought challenges. One of Hernando’s
inventions to deal with the extraordinary number of books
he had accrued would be familiar to readers today: the
wall-mounted case for vertical storage of books – or, as
we would call it, a bookshelf.
Previous collections had largely been stored in chests
or simply stacked on tables or in cupboards, and were
small enough that a librarian with a decent memory could
remember the location of each book, and pull them out
without tipping over the other ones. However, as Hernan-
do’s collection ballooned towards its final extent, number-
ing some 15,000–20,000 books, new measures were
required. These modern bookshelves, first built for
Hernando’s library and then appearing in the royal Escorial
Library in Madrid (the oldest ones surviving today),
allowed the weight of the books to be displaced onto the
walls, and the spines to be labelled so that the books could
be ordered and easily retrieved.
Storing the books was one problem, but navigating
them was wholly another. The sheer quantity of books
threatened to make the library unmanageable, because
within any given category – ‘histories’, for example, or
‘authors whose names begin with an M’ – there were still
a vast number of titles. Hernando experimented with many
different ways of ordering his library, discovering in each
Celestial knowledge
its advantages and shortcomings.
TOPFOTO
Æ
31
The universal library
32
to draw upon the riches of the library – was a response to
these contending urges to share and yet protect. Hernando lived at
Perhaps the spectre that loomed largest for Hernando
was that of the great Library of Alexandria, the most famous an event horizon of
librarian of which, Eratosthenes, was a geographer like
Hernando. (Eratosthenes had produced one of the most information: the
widely used estimates of the earth’s circumference using
astronomical measurements with which Hernando would amount of printed
have been intimately familiar from his work as a mapmaker.)
But the library at Alexandria, which had gathered together
material was spiral-
the thought of the ancient Mediterranean world, had
disappeared in its entirety, destroyed – it was believed –
ling out of control
either by fire or by invading armies. It left only an ideal
to which to aspire, and a warning about the potential fate
of such ambitious projects.
Over the following centuries, the library dwindled to
a fraction of its original size through neglect. Spurned,
ignored and locked away in an attic in Seville Cathedral
for hundreds of years, a small but crucial portion of this
library – about a quarter of the books, and almost all the
catalogues – nevertheless survived (and survives today in
the cathedral library), waiting for an age more able to
appreciate its wonders.
The legacy of this library was a complex one.
Hernando lived, in a sense, at the event horizon of
printed information. Though during his youth a library
of everything might have been possible, the amount of
printed material was quickly spiralling beyond anyone’s
ability to control. The ages that followed spoke in grand
terms about their universal libraries and knowledge
projects, but in reality these were often much more
modest affairs, kept under control by strictly limiting
what was deemed worthy of inclusion in the library.
A project to rival the ambition of Hernando’s would
have to await the arrival of digitised books, optical
character recognition and machine reading, enabling
computers to achieve what humans never could. Even
then, the extraordinary Google Books project foundered
How, then, was Hernando to recreate this lost wonder of at an early stage, mired in arguments over intellectual
the ancient world, and to ensure that his library not only property and the future of how thought would be paid
absorbed the new products of the printing press but also for. Hernando’s quest, and the eventual fate of his
stayed secure against the threat of destruction and oblivion? library, holds many
His final scheme for the library, with its book-cages and lessons for our own
intricate rules for the use of the collection – intended to information age, with Edward Wilson-Lee is
allow readers to access the collection but never steal from its rapidly expanding a fellow of Sidney Sussex College,
it – was a masterpiece of design, created to bring the networks and quickly Cambridge. His latest book is
knowledge of the world to Seville, sort it in ways that disappearing products The Catalogue of Shipwrecked
would make it useable, and hold it there for ever. – lessons that we are Books: Young Columbus and the
Yet this masterpiece could not guard against an uncaring only just beginning Quest for a Universal Library
age that had not yet recognised how the world had changed. to learn. (William Collins, 2018)
“I
never saw a more backgammon and chess. Such skills and oscillated between paramours and
beautiful or refined made her attractive in the most rarefied partners, leaving the pathetic entreaties
woman than ‘Arib,” one circles, and increased the value of her of spurned lovers in her wake. Her
authority on music services to her owner – and, with her writings reflect her tumultuous love life:
opined, “nor one who eventual manumission, to herself. “As for the lover he went away
sang, played music, wrote poetry or News of her talents reached Baghdad In spite of and against my will.
played chess so well.” while she was in her teens, and by about I erred in being separated from one
Part Elizabeth Taylor, part Amy 810 she was connected with the caliph, For whom I have found no substitute.
Winehouse, ‘Arib al-Ma’muniyya was al-Amin. His successor, al-Ma’mun Because of his absence from my sight.
the most famous (and infamous) of the (r813–33), paid 50,000 dirhams for I have become tired of life.”
qiyan, female slave performers of the ‘Arib. That sum was remarkable: in the [Translated by Fuad Caswell]
urban elite of Iraq. Muslim societies ninth century, a skilled labourer would Abu Nuwas (died 814), the leading
produced many elite women, who earn no more than 20 dirhams per poet of the day, was both an observer
sometimes held very public positions, month. Slave-singers had become a of and participant in this elite culture,
most notably the queens of 17th-century popular feature in the permissive culture and his verses about another slave girl
Aceh. Yet none confounded the social of Baghdad’s elite, exemplifying the capture something of its ambivalence:
and gender categories typically ascribed libertinism sheltered from public view “She demonstrates piety outwardly
to Islamic civilisation more than ‘Arib. by palace walls. Hidden in plain sight, to God’s people / Then meets me with
‘Arib’s birth date is usually given these women moved in and out of coquetry and a smile.
as 797, during the reign of the great private spaces, attracting as much I went to her heart to complain [about
Abbasid caliph Harun al-Rashid fascination as opprobrium. her] / But wasn’t alone – there was a
(reigned 786–809). She claimed high Al-Ma’mun was the second of a string queue for a mile.”
birth, but it’s not clear if she was born of caliphs who enjoyed ‘Arib’s company [Translated by Philip Kennedy]
to a legal union; certainly, she was sold and talents; one, al-Mutawakkil (reigned When ‘Arib died, apparently in her
into slavery early in life. In most Middle 847–61), paid 100,000 dirhams for her. nineties, she was a woman of considera-
Eastern societies, slavery typically in- Female slaves, especially those hired for ble wealth who had much earlier secured
volved domestic service to urban house- entertainment, were “badges of con- free status. Both her career and her life
holds, rather than agricultural labour on spicuous consumption”, as Julia Bray, had been a performance, balancing elite
rural estates or the like. scholar of Arabic literature, put it. culture with middlebrow entertainment,
For ‘Arib, it entailed service for By her own account, ‘Arib had sexual and a story of vertiginous social mobility
the social and economic elite, and her relations with eight caliphs, and narrated realised through education, talent and
education was tailored for this market. episodes of her sexual history; to those insouciant ambition. By definition,
It began in Baghdad, at the time rapidly listening in Baghdad and Samarra, she celebrities belong to the public; because
becoming one of the world’s most pros- was as coarse as she was refined. Several she belonged to high society as a whole,
perous cities, and continued in Basra, accounts portray ‘Arib as a master of she belonged to no one but herself. Born
southern Iraq. musical traditions and styles, and an a slave, she found a freedom enjoyed by
Not only was ‘Arib literate at a time arbiter of taste. She is credited with few men or women of her time.
when few could read and write, she writing some 1,000 songs.
also acquired the arcane knowledge A public figure in the private realm Chase F Robinson is distinguished professor
and skills of courtly life: she could ride, of elite households and ruling courts, as of history at the City University of New York,
compose poetry and prose, sing, and quick-witted as she was erudite, ‘Arib and author of Islamic Civilization in Thirty Lives:
play several instruments, along with frequented salons and performances, The First 1,000 Years (Thames & Hudson, 2016)
34
Style and substance
In an era when few learned to read and write, ‘Arib al-Ma’muniyya’s
education provided a springboard for a performing career that took
her to the highest levels of medieval Iraqi society, including affairs
with caliphs, where she was sharp enough to leverage her influence
and artistic talents to bring her both wealth and freedom from slavery
GETTY IMAGES
36
Memorial to massacre
A crude graveyard marks the site of a
massacre of Tutsi refugees in a technical
institute in Rwanda’s capital, Kigali,
on 11 April 1994 – one of the first
incidents in a four-month campaign
of ethnic slaughter. Belgian troops of
the UN mission had initially guarded
the Tutsi taking refuge here, but
were ordered to help evacuate white
foreigners elsewhere, abandoning the
refugees to attack by Hutu soldiers
and militia. Around 2,000 Tutsi
were murdered that day, cut down by
grenades, machine guns, bayonets and
machetes. After it became clear that
UN troops would not protect the Tutsi,
the massacres spread across the country,
evolving into a genocide in which an
estimated 800,000 died.
A YEAR
IN PICTURES
1994
Conflict and
conciliation,
tunnels and toasts
Africa dominated
headlines worldwide in 1994, for
reasons both good and bad.
Between April and July in
Rwanda, a large number of the
country’s majority Hutu people
launched a genocidal assault
against the Tutsi, a substantial
ethnic minority group in the
small landlocked African state.
During four months blighted by
mass murder, rape and torture,
an estimated 800,000 Tutsi and
moderate Hutu were slaughtered.
Tensions between the two peoples,
which had simmered since
independence in 1962, erupted
into violence after the Hutu
president, Juvénal Habyarimana,
was assassinated on 6 April. The
killings began the following day and
ended only when the Tutsi-backed
Rwandan Patriotic Front captured
the country, driving thousands of
Hutu to flee to neighbouring states.
No effort was made by the
international community, nor
the United Nations forces present
in Rwanda, to stem the killing.
However, the genocide was one
factor prompting the establishment
some years later of the International
Criminal Court, where the
perpetrators of such acts could be
tried and punished.
While the Rwandan genocide
was underway, the long period
of white rule in South Africa was
coming to an end. On 27 April,
the African National Congress
won an overwhelming majority
in the country’s first multi-racial
parliamentary elections. ANC leader City under siege
Nelson Mandela, freed in 1990 after A woman hurries across Heroes’ Square in Sarajevo during the
27 years in jail, was inaugurated as siege of the Bosnian capital by Bosnian Serb forces during the
president on 10 May. He established long civil war in the former Yugoslav republic. During the siege
a multi-racial Government of from 1992 to 1996, 13,952 military personnel and civilians were
National Unity in an attempt to killed in the city. After the collapse of communist Yugoslavia in
avoid the kind of bloodshed seen 1990, elections had resulted in a coalition government for the new
Muslim-dominated state of Bosnia and Herzegovina – a situation
that year not only in Rwanda but
opposed by Bosnian Serbs, who wanted to create their own
also in conflicts in Northern Ireland,
GETTY IMAGES
Smile of confidence
COLLECTION © THE LUCIAN FREUD ARCHIVE,
SUPERVISOR RESTING, 1994 (OIL ON CANVAS),
Service update
Reverend Angela Berners-
Wilson, the first woman
ordained as a priest in the
Church of England, leads
communion on 13 March
1994. She was one of 32
women ordained in Bristol
Cathedral the previous day,
two years after the General
Synod of the Church of
England approved the
ordination of women despite
strong resistance from some
Anglicans. The first woman
Anglican bishop was finally
appointed 20 years later.
Nelson’s victory
A crowd celebrates outside City
Hall in Pretoria during the
speech made by Nelson Mandela
(1918–2013) after he took the oath
to become South Africa’s first black
president on 9 May 1994. Mandela
had spent 27 years in prison before
President FW de Klerk decided
to release him in 1990. After four
PA IMAGES/REUTERS
Æ
41
A year in pictures: 1994
Chasing OJ
Police patrol cars chase a white
Ford Bronco along Freeway 91
in California on 17 June 1994
as former American football
superstar OJ Simpson sat
in the back, holding a gun
to his own head, while his
friend Al Cowlings drove the
car. Simpson was wanted for
questioning in connection
with the murder of his ex-wife
Nicole and her male friend.
The chase was watched live
by an estimated 95 million
American television viewers.
Simpson was arrested and
charged later that day but
was acquitted 15 months later
ALAMY
Tunnel triumph
Queen Elizabeth II joins French president
François Mitterand at a ceremony in Calais
on 6 May to mark the inauguration of the
Channel Tunnel connecting Britain with
France. Work on the tunnel had begun in
1987, but ran well over schedule and came in
some 80% over budget. The tunnel, which
runs under the sea for over 23 of its 31.4 miles
between Folkestone and Coquelles, has cut
rail travel time between London and Paris
to just two hours 16 minutes.
43
Eyewitness: Reporting America’s 20th century
Changing times
Crowds march through the streets of Chicago to
hear Martin Luther King speak at the Illinois Rally
for Civil Rights on 21 June 1964. “The fact that
[King] was standing up and doing something about
institutional racism terrified many white people,”
recalls Seymour Hersh, then a young Associated
Press journalist. “They thought it would lead to
violence, or to black people taking their jobs.”
44
EYEWITNESS
Seymour Hersh recalls his career as a
journalist covering the political and social
stories that defined 20th-century America
46
station. Eventually I left and, in 1963, became a correspond-
ent for the Associated Press news agency.
This was the period during which the civil rights activist
Martin Luther King led marches in Chicago. The fact that
he was standing up and doing something about institutional
racism terrified many white people: they thought it would lead
to violence, or to black people taking their jobs. People threw
stones at him, but he kept on walking even though he was
frightened. There’d be news conferences where we’d be so
worried that somebody was going to hit him in the head
with a stone. He’d finish the conference, and because I was
the guy from the Associated Press – at that time you had
the AP in every newspaper around America – he’d give me
US Army Lieutenant William Calley (right) with
a look, crook his finger at me, and I’d know to wait for ten
a defence attorney during his 1970 trial for the
minutes before dutifully following him around the corner. mass murder of Vietnamese civilians at Son My ~.
He’d give me a lot of good quotes – something that he hadn’t Though dozens of soldiers were involved, Calley
said previously. I used to get great stories from him. I guess you was the only officer convicted for his role
could call it love at first sight.
accept the diktat of editors! So, in 1967 I left to become
After about six to eight months at the Associated Press, a freelance journalist.
my job was simply to come to work and find something to
write about every day. I didn’t have to edit stories; I didn’t In the fall of 1969, I got a phone call tipping me off
have to work on a particular ‘desk’. I owned the city! I wrote that a GI was being court-martialled for killing civilians
about civil rights, I wrote about the Vietnam War – which by in South Vietnam the previous year. Even though there
then had been going on for a decade – and, eventually, they was not much to go on, and no public mention of the scale
transferred me to Washington to cover the Pentagon. of the massacre the source spoke about, I thought it was
I soon got into a lot of trouble there because I felt my job worth following up on because other people wouldn’t. Once
was not to let people such as Secretary of Defense Robert I got the story – and that’s a story in itself – I just worked
McNamara dictate our policy as journalists. Our job was to my head off.
go beyond. I was new to the Pentagon, new to Washington, Despite reports that just one young officer, Lieutenant
and I was just cheeky. For instance, I phoned up the vice William Calley, did all the killing, in the village of Son My in
president, Hubert Humphrey, when he was at home in Min- Quang Ngãi Province, I still couldn’t make sense of it.
nesota for Christmas in 1965. He’d had a few drinks, and I tracked Calley down, indirectly via his lawyer, along with
talked about a peace agreement with the North Vietnamese. other people in the unit who had shot and killed people and
That was particularly amazing because nobody else was even admitted to it. In total, hundreds of people had been killed in
talking about anything like it at that time. what became known in the west as the My Lai Massacre.
Once I’d done all that, I thought the story was in good
Even though I’d been assigned to cover the Pentagon, shape, but nobody wanted it. I couldn’t get anyone to buy the
I had been reading up a lot about the Vietnam War. By this story, so eventually I gave it to a news service. I wrote five
time, various church groups had started to write about the stories in five weeks, won various prizes, and convinced the
underside of the war, talking to kids coming back from public I had something to say.
fighting, that kind of thing. So I began writing critically
about it – began nipping at McNamara’s heels. That didn’t Today, the fact that the media underestimates Donald
go down too well. Eventually I was reassigned to write about Trump as president worries me. He knocked down 16
social issues, which are fine – but the move came as something candidates during the nominations, ended two presidential
of a message to me. dynasties – the Bushes and the Clintons
The managing editor of the AP, par- – and all with no political experience. That’s
ticularly, didn’t like what I was doing, and Seymour Hersh is an investigative a pretty amazing feat. He tweets stupid, ri-
thought I was taking a stand against the journalist and political writer. His diculous things, but the press are caught up
GETTY IMAGES
war. I tried to explain to him that the only autobiography, Reporter: A Memoir following that. They let him lead them by the
stance against the war was that it was crazy. is out now, published by Allen Lane. nose. Just publishing everything he says is
I always had a streak of not wanting to Interview by Matt Elton a stupid way to run a newspaper business.
47
BEYOND
THE
WESTERN
MIRRORPIX/ALAMY/GETTY IMAGES
FRONT
Modern views of the First World 5
Turn to page 56 for
War largely focus on the battles in an overview of the
various theatres of
western Europe. As the centenary of war outside 1 Cossacks attached to the
Europe 5th Siberian Rifle Division of
the end of the conflict approaches, the Imperial Russian Army in
Poland, July 1916. The Tsar’s
David Olusoga shines a light on diverse force also included
Muslims from the Caucasus
forgotten clashes in distant lands, and men of Mongol origin
48
1 2
4 3
Æ
49
Global First World War
I
n the early hours of 5 August 1914, the CS [cable
ship] Alertt arrived at the Varne Bank in the English In the moment that
Channel. Dropping grappling hooks, her British
crew dredged up the five underwater telegraph London declared war on
cables umbilically linking Germany with France,
Spain, the Azores and, ultimately, the United States. Germany, the peoples of
Having hauled up the cables, the men severed
them with hatchets, one by one. During the opera- countless territories of
tion the Alertt was approached by a flotilla of French
destroyers, one of which signalled: “What are you doing?” When the empire also found
the Alert’s captain replied: “Cutting German cables”, the cheers
of the French sailors could be heard ringing across the water. themselves at war
This was the first British offensive against Germany and her
allies, undertaken just hours after Britain had declared war at
11pm on 4 August. Neither the army nor the navy were involved.
Instead, the task was tackled by a rather less glamorous branch describe this specific conflict until long after the fighting was
of the ‘services’: the Alertt was owned and operated by the British over. Yet with each passing month, that German phrase proved
General Post Office. That this almost mundane action was the to be the most accurate and appropriate.
first of the war might seem surprising. But it’s only one of many The First World War was global in a way that previous wars
aspects of the conflict that have faded into the margins of general had not been. Not only were battles fought in Africa, Asia and
consciousness – not least the truly global scope of the war. the Middle East, and naval engagements across the world’s
Seven days after the Alert’ss endeavour, on 12 August, the first oceans, but men (and some women) from every continent were
land engagement of the First World War took place, and the first drawn into Europe to fight in the trenches, to labour in the
shot was fired by a member of the British forces – but not in Eu- militarised zones behind the lines, and to populate the factories
rope. On the same day that forts surrounding the Belgian city that fed the great war machine of the Entente Powers. The
of Liège were bombarded by the German 420mm super-heavy French led the way in this, but the British were not far behind.
howitzer nicknamed ‘Big Bertha’, Regimental Sergeant Major
Alhaji Grunshi – a Muslim African who served in the British Involving India in Europe
West African Frontier Force – levelled his rifle and fired at the Just four days after Britain declared war, the cabinet at Down-
enemy. Far from the battlefields of Europe, Grunshi was part of ing Street made the decision to deploy units of the British Indi-
the force then invading the German colony of Togoland (rough- an Army in the European theatre of operations. This move was
ly speaking, modern Togo). It was not until ten days later, on without precedent in the history of the empire but was deemed
22 August 1914, that Edward Thomas of the 4th Irish Dragoon essential, given the scale of the enemy force that had crossed the
Guards became the first British-born soldier to fire his rifle in German border and surged into France. At 240,000 men, the
anger. Both Grunshi and Thomas survived the war. British Indian Army was the largest volunteer army in the world
In the weeks and months that followed, the conflict became – larger by far than the British Expeditionary Force, which
ever more global. That was arguably inevitable in a numbered a mere 70,000 soldiers.
He fired first
war that pitted empires against one another. France, By early October 1914, the first of those Indians
Regimental Sergeant Major
Germany, Britain and even ‘little’ Belgium had Alhaji Grunshi of the Gold had landed in France. By 22 October they were in
vast colonial holdings, while both Russia and Aus- Coast Regiment of the combat in northern France and Belgium, plugging
tria-Hungary were huge realms of a different sort British Army, who fired the gaps in what was rapidly becoming the western
– multi-ethnic continental empires. In the moment first shot of the war in Africa front. In the ports and railway stations through
London declared war on Germany and her allies, the which they had passed on their way north, they had
peoples of India, Nigeria, distant islands in the Pacific and met west Africans and north Africans – soldiers of the
countless other territories of the sprawling empire – their French empire – who by October were engaged in simi-
names obscure to the average Briton – also found them- larly desperate operations in other sectors of the line.
selves at war. The same was true for the millions of Afri- In geographic as well as demographic terms, the scope
can and Asian subjects of the French colonial empire. and scale of the conflict was breathtaking. As well as
The British dubbed this conflict the ‘Great War’, Brussels, Liège and Antwerp, Jerusalem and Baghdad
and at first the French concurred, calling it La Grande fell to invading armies. At one point in 1918, it looked
ALAMY
Guerre. The term Weltkriegg (World War) was first coined as if Venice might fall to the armies of Austria-Hungary.
in Germany in 1904, but wasn’t widely used to The fighting had begun with Alhaji Grunshi in
50
Dig for victory
Soldiers of the British Indian Army,
Eastern allies
A British officer stands alongside two of his
Japanese counterparts in 1914 in Tsingtao
(now Qingdao). Japanese troops played a key
role in the capture of that strategic German
concession in north-east China
Carrying it forward
Native ‘carriers’ at work in Togoland,
c1914. In east Africa in particular, some
two million Africans served as soldiers or
‘carriers’ during a protracted campaign
that lasted until the very end of the war
GETTY IMAGES
52
Africa, but after Ottoman Turkey declared Lorraine. The Austro-Hungarian army was
not just war but holy Jihad in autumn 1914, led largely by German-speaking Austrians
it spilled over into the Middle East. In Asia, but among the rank and file were Poles,
Britain’s ally Japan reasserted its place among Ukrainians, Romanians, Czechs, ethnic Ital-
world powers by playing a key role in the ians, Magyars, Croats, Serbs and Bosnians.
capture of the German territory of Tsingtao The Russian army they confronted was just as
(Qingdao) in China. In the South Pacific, the diverse. As well as ethnic Russians, there were
scattered island colonies, coaling stations and Ukrainians, Latvians, Estonians, Armenians,
strategic outposts assembled by Germany in the Finns, Poles, Jews and ethnic Germans, Muslims
19th century were invaded. German New Guinea from the Caucasus and men of Mongol origin from
Last surrender
was taken by Australian forces in September 1914, General Paul von Lettow-
the far east of the Tsar’s vast empire. In short, the
effectively snuffing out German dreams of a colo- Vorbeck, leader of the German conflict transplanted countless people from their
nial empire and naval presence in the Pacific. east African force, was the home lands to fight and work in distant theatres.
In Africa, all four of Germany’s colonies – last German commander to
surrender in November 1918
German South-West Africa (modern Namibia), On the margins of memory
German East Africa (roughly modern Tanza- The human impact of the conflict was, then,
nia), Kamerun (roughly, Cameroon) and Togo- enormous. So how is it that, a century later, and
land (roughly, Togo) – were invaded and captured by British, even after four years of centenary remembrance, our image
French, Belgian and South African forces, though the ‘British’ of the war often fails to take in the scale and the internation-
force included Indian troops and Africans from across the con- al nature of the conflict? In our historical imagination, the
tinent. After German troops in German East Africa repelled First World War has come to be remembered as an essentially
an invasion of British and Indian forces, a war of hit-and-run European feud (at least until the entry of the United States) –
lasted until 1918, these soldiers living off the land (with dead- a war dominated by the western front. The conflict in Africa is
ly consequences for the Africans they encountered). In that a footnote, at best. The costly struggle fought against Ottoman
protracted campaign, around millions of Africans served as forces in Mesopotamia – in which three-quarters of a million
soldiers or ‘carriers’ – carrying the supplies of the rival forces Indians served as soldiers and labourers, fighting on battlefields
vast distances to remote battlefields. to which British forces would return in our own times – is set
firmly on the margins of popular memory.
Strangers in a strange land As the historian David Reynolds has observed, the power-
In many of these conflicts, ‘native’ troops found themselves ful poetry of a few dozen European officers has misshaped
thousands of miles from home. To take on the rag-tag German our understanding of a war in which more Britons died than
East African force led by the famous General Paul von Lettow- in any other conflict. The work of those poets, for all their
Vorbeck, the British gathered troops of the Gold Coast Regi- visceral language and illuminating observations, has had the
ment (from what’s now Ghana), four regiments of the West effect of narrowing further the aperture through which we
African Frontier Force from Nigeria, and the King’s African view this vast struggle.
Rifles recruited in Sudan, Rhodesia (Zimbabwe), Ethiopia and Even events we understand as international, occurring beyond
Nyasaland (Malawi). These soldiers, drawn from the Yoruba, the western front, were often far more international than we have
Ibo, Hausa, Ashanti, Fante and Grunshi ethnic groups, left come to imagine them. The Gallipoli campaign was not simply a
their homelands to fight in east and south Africa. Though on clash between the forces of Ottoman Turkey on one side and the
the continent of their birth, they were as displaced and disorien- Anzacs on the other. It was a struggle involving an Anglo-French
tated as any British soldier in the sands of Mesopotamia or the force in which British troops outnumbered Anzacs. The French,
trenches of Gallipoli. for their part, fielded north Africans and units of Tirailleurs Séné-
Even the list of combatant nations involved in the war fails to galais from the French colonies in west Africa. Within the ranks
fully convey the range of peoples and ethnicities who took part. of the Anzacs were Māori, and in the British columns were vol-
Consider the theatre of operations in eastern Europe, so often ob- unteers of the Jewish Legion. Supporting the front line were men
scured by our focus on the western front; here, between 1914 and drawn from across the Middle East and beyond.
1917, another complex and ethnically diverse conflict raged. The The truly panoramic scale of the war is revealed only when we
German army – and, even more so, the forces of their Austro- look beyond familiar theatres at moments that have been almost
Hungarian allies – was, in a different way, as multi-ethnic as the completely forgotten rather than merely misremembered. One
GETTY IMAGES
armies of Britain and France. such was Britain’s campaign in Egypt’s Western Desert against
Within the ranks of the Kaiser’s army were Poles, Serbs, Lith- the Senussi sect, a Sufi religious order in Libya. The Senussi were
uanians, Danes from Schleswig, and Frenchmen from Alsace- funded and armed by German and Ottoman agents who sought Æ
53
Global First World War
Home cooking
Indian troops in Marseilles in the
early weeks of the war. A journalist
for The Times reported seeing
MIRRORPIX
54
The idea of the war of those who were children in 1914–18, most of the great cities
of western Europe thronged with populations that, in their
as a great panorama, ethnic make-up and diversity, more resembled the rear zones of
the western front than they did Paris and London in 1914.
55
Global First World War
British soldiers
pictured at the Sphinx
in Giza during the
1 Mesopotamia campaign in Egypt,
and Persia April 1918
All in for oil
After the Ottoman empire
entered the war in October
1914, it clashed with the Allies
in a lengthy campaign in
Mesopotamia (modern-day An Australian soldier
Iraq). This spilled into Persia carries a wounded comrade
(Iran), which was nominally to hospital at Gallipoli, 1915
independent, though the
Russians were entrenched
in Persian Azerbaijan, while
2Gallipoli
the British were dominant in Deadlock in the
the south. Having established Dardanelles
a bridgehead at Basra, the
In 1915 the British government
British, determined to protect
sanctioned an attempt to
oil sources, pushed north-
split the Ottoman empire
west along the Euphrates and
with an attack on the Gallipoli 3Egypt 4 East Africa
Tigris rivers. British imperial
peninsula. By capturing the and Palestine Distraction from
troops suffered a major defeat
Dardanelles Strait and Con-
at Kut, surrendering on
stantinople, and securing sea
Divide and conquer the western front
29 April 1916 after a 21-week
communications with Russia, A 1915 Ottoman attempt to German-led indigenous troops
siege. Regrouping, the British
it was hoped the deadlock on take the Suez Canal and dis- from German East Africa
captured Baghdad in March
the western front might be rupt British lines of commu- (what’s now Burundi, Rwanda
1917, pushing on to Kirkuk and,
broken, hastening the end of nication sparked a campaign and mainland Tanzania) tied
in November 1918, Mosul.
the war; instead it ended in a in the Sinai; in 1917, fighting down forces from the British
bloody stalemate. As Allied spread to Palestine. The and Belgian empires, fighting
forces (including troops British and French secretly the length and breadth of
from Australasia, Britain agreed to partition the Otto- east and central Africa. The
and France) tried to advance man empire, formalised in the campaign opened with the
inland, Turkish troops pushed 1916 Sykes-Picot Agreement. battle of Tanga (2–5 November
them back to the sea. The Brit- Allied attempts to topple Ot- 1914), where a British attempt
ish offensive of August 1915 toman rule across the Middle to conquer German East Africa
failed dismally, and the Otto- East involved men such as was decisively defeated. The
man empire won its only major TE Lawrence fomenting local Germans aimed to keep
victory of the war. Fighting rebellion. The Central Powers Allied forces tied up far
in the near east and eastern also sponsored uprisings, from the western front.
Mediterranean created a need leading to campaigns in Actions involved hun-
for labour, pack animals, food, unlikely places such as Darfur, dreds of thousands
timber and hospital facilities, and against unlikely oppo- of African military
GETTY IMAGES/AKG-IMAGES/ALAMY
drawing in people and re- nents such as the Senussi of porters as well
sources from places such as Libya, who attacked Egypt via as European,
Cyprus, Egypt and Malta. its Western Desert. On the African and Indian
way to capturing Jerusalem, troops, and featured
British imperial forces fought land battles, fatal
at battlefields including Gaza diseases, gunships
Emaciated Indian soldiers
of the British imperial army and Nazareth, but the decisive on the Great Lakes,
after the 21-week siege of moment came with Allied and naval action in
Kut in Mesopotamia (now victory at the battle of Megiddo the Rufiji delta and
Iraq), April 1916 in September 1918. at Zanzibar.
5 West and
South-West Africa
Clashes between
colonies
2
The first shot of the war was
1 6
fired in Togoland as the Allies 3
swept the Germans out of their
west African colonies, intent
on conquering the scattered 5
German empire and denying 4 7
the enemy bases from which 6
it could raid the sea lanes.
German South-West Africa 5
(now Namibia) was invaded by
6
land and sea by South African
forces acting on behalf of the
British empire. These troops 6 Naval actions
entered the capital, Windhoek,
in the Pacific, the
in May 1915, and fought sev-
eral clashes against German
Indian Ocean and
forces, winning the decisive German sailors on a lifeboat the Yellow Sea
battle at Otavi on 1 July 1915.
after their ship, SMS Emden, was Atacking Allied
attacked by HMAS Sydney off
the Cocos Islands in the Indian
trade routes
Ocean on 9 November 1914 Germany’s East Asia Squad-
ron was designed to wreak
havoc on the Allies’ global
trade, forcing them to scatter Japanese soldiers attack German
positions in Jiaozhou, China, 1914
their superior naval resourc-
es. Commanded by Admiral
Maximilian von Spee, the 7Pacific islands
squadron’s base at Tsingtao Hiting Germany’s
(now Qingdao) in China was
eastern empire
besieged by British and
Japanese forces in October Allied powers moved quickly
and November 1914, but most to dismantle Germany’s
of his ships were elsewhere. empire in the Pacific. Britain
One of his cruisers, SMS encouraged Australia and
Emden, embarked on a New Zealand to take action,
successful campaign against and Japan took the opportunity
Allied shipping in the Indian to develop its growing imperial
Ocean before being destroyed portfolio. German authorities
GETTY IMAGES/ALAMY/AKG-IMAGES
57
Seeds of change
58
As British colonies took root in North America, a new kind of ‘special
relationship’ between the continents blossomed. Richard Bisgrove
explores five key eras of horticultural exchange that cultivated
revolutionary ideas in gardening, agriculture and public landscapes
at what became James Fort on 4 May. In 1620, the Pilgrim Fathers landed
These early settlers took with them in Plymouth,
Native Americans eat maize in
tools, seeds, plants and books with the Massachusetts a c1500 image. They also aided
intention of establishing small pockets of and, having faced westerners growing the crop
English life on the edges of a vast, alien, early hazards and
hostile land – free, they hoped, from the with support from
religious and economic strictures that Native Americans,
had forced them to flee Europe. Poorly learned to grow
equipped, poorly qualified to survive and use American
in the new environment, and with food corn (maize) to
supplies severely diminished after their support themselves.
voyage was delayed, at least 60 of the 104 The Reverend
members of the party died during their Francis Higginson,
first summer in the New World. who arrived in Salem, Massachusetts in
Captain John Smith, a driving force 1629, recorded an “abundance” of grass
in the establishment of the first perma- and corn, claiming “Our Governor hath
nent English colony at Jamestown, had store of green pease... as good as ever
demanded that the Company in London I eat in England”. There were “turnips,
send useful people to populate the colony parsnips and carrots bigger and sweeter
– a policy that ensured its survival. Even … Herbs and fruits galore”. Æ
59
Transatlantic gardening
ALAMY/BRIDGEMAN
Despite the religious and political a Native American. Among the many
turmoil that afflicted post-Elizabethan plants he introduced to the Lambeth
England, the nation’s wealth grew – and nursery were the Virginia snakeweed,
much of that wealth was invested in the tulip tree and the red maple.
remodelling or building great houses These were the first trickles of what
and their gardens. So as the first settlers became a steady stream of introductions
arrived in the New World, the prospect from America, thanks to a transatlantic
of new plants for English gardens trade arrangement between Quakers
aroused much excitement. What John Bartram (1699–1777) in Pennsyl-
seemed to those intrepid settlers vania and Peter Collinson (1694–1768)
a threatening wilderness in England to supply seeds
represented a nursery of to a network of well-to-do
exciting exotics for those subscribers. The rapid
remaining safely at home. growth of interest in
A stream of particularly American plants was
notable New World plants paralleled closely by
were introduced to dramatic changes in the
England’s gardens by the English gardens for which
father-and-son Tradescant those plants were destined.
duo – confusingly, both Formal, French inspired
named John. The elder gardens were rejected in
John (born c1570) worked favour of a naturalistic,
for several illustrious ‘liberal’ landscape style
employers including epitomised by the work
The black walnut, depicted in
Robert Cecil, 1st Earl of a botanical drawing. John
of English landscape
Salisbury, who from 1611 Tradescant introduced this gardener Lancelot
built a splendid new palace American tree to England ‘Capability’ Brown.
60
Jefferson’s copious notes on gardens
including Capability Brown’s
masterpiece at Blenheim in Oxford-
shire, and those at Chiswick, Painshill,
Woburn, Stowe, Hampton Court,
Kew, Claremont and neighbouring
Esher Place, were laced with equal
praise and criticism. Of Chiswick, he
wrote: “A garden of about six acres…
the octagon dome has an ill effect,
both within and without: the garden An 1859 lithograph of Central
shows still too much of art. An obelisk Park, showing its much-lauded
lawns, lakes and promenades
of very ill effect; another in the middle
of a pond useless.” Esher Place,
however, clearly made a favourable 4 …followed design and construction. When it began
impression: “Clumps of trees [the
result of Brown’s planting], the clumps
by public parks to rain, he took shelter on one of the
covered bridges, alongside gentlefolk in
on each hand balance finely – a most their finery mingling with poor women
lovely mixture of concave and convex.” Washington and Jefferson saw the selling milk to earn a few pennies.
The most exciting revelation, though, America of the future as a country of Having seen the baker’s pride in ‘his’
was that this English garden he farmers, rooted in the soil, in contrast park, and the mix of all layers of society
admired so much – despite his disdain with the grime of English cities and the in the shelter, Olmsted wrote that “in
for the Englishmen he was dealing unruly mobs of France. Yet as the 19th democratic America there was nothing
with – was full of American plants, century advanced, America also became to be thought of as comparable with
thanks to the activities of John industrialised and the more fortunate this People’s Garden”. Like Downing,
Bartram in Philadelphia. members of society moved out of the Olmsted sought to foster “that mixture
cities into elegant suburban villas. of aesthetic values, cleanliness, and sense
Advice on the design of these villas’ of propriety that not only marked the
ALAMY/BRIDGEMAN
gardens came from Andrew Jackson gentry but served as an important means
Downing (1815–52) who, by his early of moving from a state of barbarism to
twenties, was already a respected figure one of civilisation”. Birkenhead showed
in the horticultural community. He how this might be achieved.
sought to mediate between the “howling Five years later, the Commissioners of
wilderness” of nature and the “wilder- New York City decided to create a park
ness of bricks” of cities, where he in the centre of Manhattan – at that
campaigned for the provision of public time, on the northern edge of the city –
parks. He died in a steamship accident and launched a competition to find the
before his ideas were fully developed, best design. Olmsted (already appointed
but by that time he had introduced his superintendent of the proposed park)
English partner, architect Calvert Vaux, and Vaux submitted an anonymous pro-
to the young American farmer and posal that won the competition. Encom-
journalist Frederick Law Olmsted. It passing formal promenades, meandering
was to prove a fruitful relationship. lakes, a huge open lawn for recreation
In 1850, Olmsted set out on a six- and a wilder ramble to the north, the
month tour of Europe, the first part park was an immediate success.
of which he recorded in his Walks and That success led to commissions
Talks of an American Farmer in England across the US: the park system for Buf-
(1852). Soon after landing in Liverpool, falo in New York State; the ‘Emerald
he crossed the Mersey to explore the new Necklace’ of parks around Boston;
town of Birkenhead. When he stopped Stanford University campus in Califor-
at a baker’s shop to buy breakfast, the nia; and dozens more. Olmsted coined
baker, recognising a foreign visitor, the term ‘landscape architecture’ to
Blenheim Palace in Oxfordshire.
Thomas Jefferson visited the asked him if he had seen “our park”; describe his work, and was the found-
estate’s gardens in 1786, along Olmsted sought out the park where, ing father of the American Society of
with other notable English gardens as his journal records, he admired its Landscape Architects. Æ
61
Transatlantic gardening
62
MAGAZINE
Save when you subscribe
to the digital edition
of BBC History Magazine
Czechoslovakia’s fate
hangs in the balance
Eighty years ago, in September 1938, British prime minister Neville Chamberlain met
Nazi führer Adolf Hitler in Bavaria in an attempt to ensure “peace for our time” – or so
he thought. PE Caquet explores the events leading up to the Munich Agreement from
the points of view of Britain, Germany and Czechoslovakia, Hitler’s immediate target
As the 1930s progressed, so did the protector of all Germans living in in September, British prime minister
Adolf Hitler’s plans for European two neighbouring states, Austria and Neville Chamberlain visited Hitler in his
domination – but Czechoslovakia Czechoslovakia. In March he invaded Bavarian redoubt at Berchtesgaden and
stood in the way. It possessed a and annexed Austria but, even at in the spa town of Bad Godesberg. But
well-equipped army, it was a French that point, Nazi dignitaries reassured peaceful solutions proved elusive, and on
and Soviet ally, and it barred the Prague of their peaceful intentions each occasion Hitler upped his demands.
road to the resources of south- towards Czechoslovakia. France and Czechoslovakia mobilised
eastern Europe. At a November 1937 Behind the scenes, though, the for war, each calling up more than a
general-staff meeting, the Nazi Nazis possessed a useful pawn: Konrad million men. Meanwhile Londoners
leader decided that the barrier of Henlein, leader of the Sudetendeutsche began digging trenches in Hyde Park in
Czechoslovakia must be removed. Partei (Sudeten German Party, SdP) that anticipation of German air raids.
GETTY IMAGES
O
n 28 and 29 April 1938, world-dominating ambitions. Neither service’ had been smuggling weapons
Neville Chamberlain he nor Bonnet, though, were prepared to into Czechoslovakia from Germany,
and his foreign secretary, risk war without British participation. and in June they terrorised voters into
Lord Halifax, received There were also more fundamental supporting them at municipal elections.
their French counterparts differences of interpretation. Chamber- None of this was perceptible to Newton
Édouard Daladier and Georges Bonnet lain disagreed that Hitler had aggressive or Halifax; Henlein looked only as if he
in London. Britain was not an ally of aims, instead believing that the Nazis had a growing proportion of the Sudeten
Czechoslovakia, but Downing Street merely chafed at encirclement, and that German community behind him.
feared that if France were dragged into the führer was genuinely concerned In cabinet, Chamberlain complained
a war with Germany, Britain would about the treatment of Germans in that Beneš was dragging his feet. At
inevitably become involved. Halifax neighbouring states. the beginning of August he despatched
revealed these fears to his visitors. British guilt over the economic a long-time political associate, Walter
Neither France nor Britain was ready impact on Germany of the 1919 Treaty Runciman, to Czechoslovakia to act
for war. Sentiments in Germany and of Versailles had been growing ever since as a mediator. There he fell victim to
neighbouring states were volatile, economist John Maynard Keynes had de- the same Sudeten German Party tactics
and the smallest incident could spark nounced its reparations clause. Through- that had fooled Newton. Henlein was
a conflict in which France would be out 1938, Hitler deftly played on that not negotiating in earnest but, rather,
treaty-bound to intervene. guilt, asking why self-determination created the impression that the situa-
Aerial warfare had made significant was afforded to the Czechs and Slovaks tion was intractable and the fault of the
strides since the First World War, and it but not to the Sudeten Germans. To ob- Czechs. Back in London, Runciman
was widely believed that bomber forces servers of Nazi tactics, this rang hollow. advocated ‘self-determination’ –
posed a deadly threat to civilian popula- Hitler, after all, had invaded Austria to a handover of the Sudetenland.
tions and infrastructure. Former prime pre-empt a free and fair vote on the very At the annual Nazi Party rally in
minister Stanley Baldwin voiced this fear question of unification with Germany. Nuremberg, Hitler threatened war if he
in 1932: “The bomber will always get Minority rights were nonexistent in did not obtain satisfaction. His troops
through”. The Luftwaffe had been por- the Third Reich, unlike in democratic had been mobilising throughout the
trayed as invincible by its commander-in- Czechoslovakia. Chamberlain, though summer, and any further delay risked
chief Hermann Göring as well as by – along with Halifax and the British pushing operations into the cold season.
Hitler and observers such as Charles ambassador in Prague, Basil Newton – Before Runciman had even completed his
Lindbergh. Actually, though, it was far believed that, if sufficient pressure could mission, Chamberlain decided he must
from war-ready, whereas the British, be put on the Czechoslovak government take over personally. On 15 September, at
French and, indeed, Czechoslovak forces to come to an amicable agreement with Berchtesgaden, he promised Hitler that
included good numbers of airworthy the Sudeten German leader Konrad Hen- he would convince the Czechoslovaks to
planes. Yet the legend had spread that lein, the whole problem would go away. detach the Sudetenland. On 23 Septem-
Nazi Germany was capable of delivering ber, in Bad Godesberg, he announced
a knockout blow to London or Paris. Nazi allegiance that an international commission would
Daladier was sceptical, as he made Throughout the spring and summer of delineate all areas with a majority of
clear to Halifax. Air power had yet to 1938, Newton called on Edvard Beneš, native German speakers for transfer to
force an outcome in the Spanish Civil president of Czechoslovakia, to check the Reich. But this was not enough for
War, for example. The French premier on progress, urging greater compliance Hitler: he wanted a transfer within five
warned instead that the German dic- with the SdP. At his party congress days, controlled not by international
tator must be stopped while there was in April, Henlein openly proclaimed observers but by his own armies. Neither
time. He even mentioned Hitler’s book, his allegiance to Nazism. A group of the Czechoslovaks nor the French
Mein Kampff as proof of the führer’s paramilitaries disguised as a ‘security were likely to agree to that. 5
66
GETTY IMAGES
Dictator’s deception
Adolf Hitler with Neville Chamberlain in Berchtesgaden in September 1938, during
one of their meetings to discuss the situation in Czechoslovakia. Rather than
recognising Hitler’s far-reaching military ambitions for Europe, Chamberlain
believed the Nazi leader was concerned only about the treatment of his fellow
Germans – an error of judgment that left Czechoslovakia defenceless Æ
67
“German commanders responded
with scepticism to the führer’s plans”
A
s far as German decision- Faced with this attitude, in August Hedvika Anna Augusta Dvořáčková –
making was concerned, Hitler replaced Beck with General a typically Czech surname.
the relevant perspective Franz Halder. Yet this new appointment By 1938, the SdP was no doubt very
was ultimately that of panicked at the prospect of the looming popular among the Sudeten Germans.
one man: Adolf Hitler. war, and promptly set in motion a plot This, though, was not necessarily an
In November 1937, Hitler had divulged to overthrow Hitler should he activate indication of support for German
to his general staff his intention to Plan Green. annexation. The SdP did well in
destroy Czechoslovakia in the near Not one of Beck, Halder or municipal polls held that spring, but
future. In April 1938, he had ordered Brauchitsch, nor even the more junior these polls were conducted amid a
the finalisation of Case Green, the army officers whom Hitler harangued behind campaign of widespread intimidation.
plan for the country’s invasion. During the back of their superiors, believed in a Most opponents pulled their lists
the summer, Germany had performed winning strategy. German rearmament, rather than risk violence from the SdP’s
a gradual general mobilisation in having only got into full swing after paramilitaries. In the prevailing context
preparation for an attack scheduled to conscription had been reintroduced in of war and annexation rumours, many
begin on 1 October. 1935, remained too far from completion. Sudeten Germans probably lined up
Hitler’s intentions were straight- The Germany army was short of behind Henlein merely to be on the
forward: he planned to go to war unless conscripted men, NCOs and officers. Its safe side if the incorporation into Nazi
he was given exactly what he wanted. tank force was a work in progress, with Germany did happen.
If this turned into a world war, so be the heavier panzers not developed beyond In the last free and fair vote, the
it, as he told Chamberlain in their the prototype stage. Ammunition and parliamentary elections of 1935, the
Berchtesgaden interview. fuel reserves were good for a few months SdP had obtained over 60% of German
The perspective of the German at best. Raw materials for war production ballots. Even so, these votes were not
generals, notably, was quite different. were lacking. Given these factors, the necessarily all votes for secession. As
In 1937, the commanders-in-chief of German generals did not see how, in a piece in the German nationalist
the armed forces had responded with a war beginning in 1938, they could beat Deutsche Zeitung Bohemiaa noted,
scepticism to the führer’s disclosure France and Czechoslovakia, let alone a Henlein’s programme at the time had
of his intentions. coalition also involving Britain and the “declared with noteworthy insistence
In the spring and summer of 1938, Soviet Union. the loyalty and law-abidingness of the
General Ludwig Beck – who, as chief of Sudeten German people”. It had been
the general staff of the German army, Sudeten ‘self-determination’ a programme for improvement within
was the officer in charge of strategy – It is also worth asking what the the Czechoslovak state, not a blueprint
wrote a succession of memos warning perspective was of the Sudeten Germans for an Anschluss. Sudeten Germans
against the planned attack. Through themselves. Were they actually in included numerous social democrats
Walther von Brauchitsch, commander- favour of the ‘self-determination’ Hitler and communists who opposed Henlein.
in-chief of the army, he tried to get was demanding on their behalf? These Even among his supporters, many
Hitler to change his mind. Such an inhabitants called themselves German, were uncomfortable with being
attack would put Germany at war with and were called German by others, but forced to join the Reich.
a coalition of stronger powers, Beck neither they nor their forbears had ever In addition, a quarter of the
argued. The Czechoslovaks would fight been citizens of Germany. Their home population of the Sudetenland was
to the end, exacting a heavy price on the was the old Kingdom of Bohemia, Czech. Even supposing that every
Wehrmacht. As to France, he observed where their ancestors had, over many SdP vote cast in 1935 had been a vote
that Germany did not possess numbers years, mixed with the Czech-speaking for secession, that would still total
of men or equipment to defeat it until population. Indeed, SdP leader Konrad only 45–50% of all voters – less
later in 1939 or 1940, at least. Henlein’s mother herself had been born than a majority. 5
68
AKG IMAGES
S
ydney Morrell, a journalist The idea of a Nazi enclave in the dem- conference ended. Within 10 days, the
with Czechoslovak sympa- ocratically run Czechoslovak Republic German army was to occupy a swathe of
thies, worried in the Daily made no sense, but Beneš and Krofta territory that had been part of the old
Expresss that they were un- needed to be seen to negotiate to retain Kingdom of Bohemia for many centuries.
skilled at selling their side of French and British support. Halifax and Czechoslovakia lost a third of its territory
the story. With their complicated histor- Newton regularly threatened that, if it and population, and an even larger share
ical arguments, he feared, the Czechoslo- came to war, Czechoslovakia would lose of its heavy industry and power plants.
vaks were outclassed by Henlein. “They the Sudetenland even after victory had All of its fortification barrier was gone,
put too much faith in the truth… ‘The been achieved. They were unable to see making it indefensible.
truth prevails’ was their country’s motto.” that this could make no impression on Panicking refugees numbering in the
Czechoslovak foreign minister Kamil their interlocutors, who knew they were tens of thousands poured into railway
Krofta instructed his ambassadors to fighting for their very survival. stations: Czechs, Jews, democratic
warn the world, and especially the French It finally dawned on the Czechoslo- Germans who knew they were a target.
and British, that Hitler’s ambitions did vaks that their nominal partners were Many were forced to leave home within
not stop at the Sudetenland. Henlein preparing for a peace that sacrificed hours, abandoning all belongings. Some
was but a tool in the Nazi leader’s plans them. On 19 September, Newton and were shot at by Henlein’s paramilitaries,
for the region. Beneš gave interviews his French counterpart Victor de Lac- or were seized and deported to concentra-
to foreign journalists, and interacted roix induced Beneš to accept the plan tion camps. Within weeks, Gestapo of-
ceaselessly with the ambassadorial corps mooted by Chamberlain at Berchtes- ficers had spread throughout the annexed
to put across Czechoslovak realities. As gaden. When the news broke the next areas. In November, the Kristallnacht
soon as Runciman arrived, the Czecho- day, crowds thronged the streets and the pogroms swept through the Sudeten-
slovak president invited him to a private government fell. Beneš authorised gener- land. The Czechoslovaks attempted to
talk and explained that the issues at stake al mobilisation orders: the armies rolled sell their now useless weapons stockpiles,
were not merely Sudeten German mi- into place and the air force dispersed in but their French and British partners
nority rights, which were already broad, anticipation of a surprise attack. Briefly, only dithered and there were no buyers.
but the security of Czechoslovakia – and, it seemed that war would come. Though The Munich Agreement had been the
beyond that, the very fate of Europe. they knew it would bring great hardship, final milestone in appeasement: the fatal
With a long history of survival in the the Czechoslovaks were ready, relieved policy of bowing to the German and Ital-
face of encroachment, the Czechoslovaks that surrender had been avoided. ian dictators. Reneging on the treaty only
had no illusions about Hitler’s aims. The Days later, Hitler called the Munich six months later, in March 1939 Hitler
police were well aware that Henlein and Conference for 29 September. He sent no ordered his troops to march on Prague
his party were funded from Berlin. Any invitation to Prague. and take over the rest of the country.
doubts were dispelled by the German On his return from Munich,
refugees who, fleeing the concentration Aftermath of the Munich Conference Chamberlain had waved a piece of paper
camps, had moved to Czechoslovakia and The Munich Conference lasted less than signed by Hitler, and proclaimed that
now lived in their midst. Czechoslovakia a day. Only low-level Czechoslovak what had been achieved was “peace for
had no choice, in any case, but to oppose representatives were asked to attend, and our time”. After 12 months, that time was
Hitler: ceding the areas he claimed meant even they were not admitted to the over. On 3 September, two days after the
moving the German border to just 25 proceedings but were confined to the Nazis invaded Poland, Britain and France
miles from Prague. Militarily, the coun- British delegation’s hotel. From the declared war on Germany.
try was studded with a web of bunkers outset, Chamberlain and Daladier
and pillboxes from which its armies ex- conceded that the Sudetenland should be PE Caquet is a historian and author of The
pected to fight a defensive war, but almost handed over to the Reich. Occupation Bell of Treason: The 1938 Munich Agreement in
all of these were in the Sudetenland. was to begin a mere 24 hours after the Czechoslovakiaa (Profile Books, 2018)
70
GETTY IMAGES
71
Culture
Books, exhibitions, films and more
“The EU is dysfunctional,
and I’ve always been a
sceptic. But it’s all we have”
Simon Jenkins’ new book, A Short History of Europe, offers a concise
overview of the successes and failures of the continent across centuries.
He met fellow historian Kathleen Burk to discuss these highs and lows
73
CULTURE The Conversation
Kathleen Burk: Why did you decide to write a ‘short The development of Europe, since it began two millennia ago,
history’ of Europe? has been dominated by the struggle over land. This relentless-
Simon Jenkins: Because I didn’t have time to write a long ness fascinates me: it was peculiarly violent, and that violence
one! But it’s also because I don’t regard myself as – and I’m was the dominant factor in people’s lives.
careful here – a ‘serious’ historian. I’m a popular historian – I was also fascinated by the efforts that Europe has made
a journalist by background. When I did the first book in this over the past two or three hundred years to stop being violent.
series [2011’s A Short History of England], I was fascinated to see Europe achieved this extraordinary supremacy over the world
if there were actually any virtues in such a book being short. – European empires dominated two-thirds of the globe at one
It came to seem to me that the exercise of editing and point – before blowing it all in the horrors of the 20th century.
excision, of leaving things out, was a serious activity in a Out of those horrors came this quest for some sort of union,
history of any sort. That’s different to, say, the [20th-century which we’re in the middle of now, and it’s through that
British historian] Lewis Namier approach, in which you put apparent triumph over the history of violence and horrors
everything in, leaving the reader to do the editing and decide that Europe is, in a sense, achieving some sort of atonement.
what’s important. I do also think that shortness is a virtue in
itself in this day and age, when people like things brief. I can You could argue, though, that one of the reasons Europe was
see why short books sell. so peaceful in the 19th century was that its nations simply
directed their violence elsewhere, couldn’t you?
You write that yours is “a conventional history”, based Yes, and you’d be right. There are all kinds of ways in which we
on power and led by great men – and, of course, the odd suppress, overcome and cope with violence: nation-building,
woman. Why write it this way? Was it because your intended diplomacy, and so on. But the fact is that, in the 19th century,
market would easily recognise and accept such an approach? European states became very powerful and technologically
Yes. When you use the word ‘history’, people think of kings, more advanced than others elsewhere – and were therefore
battles, and dates, and they do so for a good in a position to conquer them. I’m not a defender
Frederick II (the Great)
reason. As in a newspaper, history is mostly about of Prussia, painted when
of empire, but there was nothing we did to other
those things, along with diseases and divorces. So crown prince in 1736 – one people that could be compared to what we did to
it does appeal to people. of many young leaders who ourselves in the Thirty Years’ War – or, for that
But, much more importantly, I’m trying to tell launched wars of conquest, matter, the First or Second World War. Europe’s
notes Simon Jenkins
the story of Europe, which is a political entity. It’s capacity for violence against itself was supreme.
not a geographical entity, really: there’s no real
reason why Europe should be a separate continent You write about the teenagers in the ancient and
from Asia, for instance, other than the nature of medieval worlds who went out and fought wars because
territorial aggrandisement and the politics of land. they saw it as a great thing to do. You could perhaps say
I believe – and this is possibly controversial – that – albeit not entirely seriously – that there has been more
all history begins with politics, and with the battle peace of late because statesmen have become older.
over land and who should occupy it. Yes, I do think that. I hadn’t realised until
I wrote this book that they had all been young.
AKG-IMAGES
A key theme of your book seems to be that I suddenly thought: “yet another war caused by
people are inherently violent. How did you a 21-year-old”. Alexander I, Edward III,
come to reach that view? Alexander the Great, Frederick the
74
Pope Urban II at Cluny Abbey,
France, pictured in a
12th-century illustration.
The popes had “a remarkable
ability, through the power of
faith, to take over from the
Roman empire and provide
a sort of glue for barbarian
Europe”, says Simon Jenkins
Great… they were all young men. They became most Roman empire and provide a sort of glue for barbarian Europe.
belligerent when the hormones were jangling and they were The papacy provided discipline and gave people a sense of
getting up, showing off and being virile young men. I do find it loyalty, secular as well as religious, to a cause. The papacy was
to be a curious feature of Europe’s history – and it’s related, of a remarkable phenomenon up until the 13th century, when
course, to kingship. People tended to die young, and therefore various megalomanic popes lost the plot.
their sons were even younger when they took power.
I was also fascinated by the fact that, when each war came Continuing with the idea of religion as a glue, how much
to an end, any so-called peace tended to last two generations emphasis would you put on the growth of Islam as a factor
– for 50 or 60 years – before the next war would come along, that caused Europe to coalesce?
almost like clockwork. That suggests to me that the inclination Before writing this book, I hadn’t really realised the complete-
toward violence has a lot to do with the memory of horror and ness of the Islamic incursion around the Mediterranean in
the memory of war, not just a matter of how politics works. the eighth century. Almost none of their conquests reverted
to Christianity, and they penetrated right through almost to
How important were wars in the development of Europe Vienna and up through Spain and into France. They were rela-
throughout its history? tively tolerant – they did not demand that people changed their
As Frederick the Great said, the nature of power is to want to religion or burned Christians – and they were very successful.
expand. Europe had very confined borders, lots of people, and North Africa and the Levant converted to Islam.
growing populations that rubbed up against each other. All of The consequence was that Christendom shrank by about a
this meant that nations ended up fighting. third. Islam was very important to European history, because it
I was very careful to not be Anglocentric in writing this defined Europe. It was after that incursion that Europe decided
book, but it was difficult in some senses because Britain’s it no longer included the eastern or southern Mediterranean.
history in Europe is very different from that of other countries.
I believe that’s because we are an island, and therefore don’t rub Why do you think Islam was less violent than Christianity?
up against our neighbours in the same way as other nations do. Do you think that’s one of the reasons why it was a bit more
The wars that Britain has fought in Europe since the 17th permanently successful?
century were, on the whole, accidental wars in which we were I don’t know the answer to that; all religions change over
almost mercenaries for other people, rather than wars of time, of course, not least Christianity. But, certainly, the early
aggrandisement. Non-intervention in Europe has been pretty incursions were tolerant. When they arrived in Damascus, for
close to an ideology in British foreign policy through history. instance, Muslims shared the church with Christians. They
were not interested in conquering faith. The result was that the
How do you fit the papacy into this story? Coptic Christians in Egypt, for example, loved the Muslims,
One of the problems with writing a short history of Europe is who told them they could worship as they wished, whereas the
that you end up with lots of easy villains: the late Roman em- church in Constantinople was endlessly excommunicating
perors, for instance, or the French monarchy, who made what them and decrying them as dissidents and heretics.
might be called wrong decisions for something like 300 years.
But then I came to the popes. Whatever one thinks of
GETTY IMAGES
75
CULTURE The Conversation
An ornately decorated
AKG IMAGES/GETTY IMAGES
76
“A greater proportion of the
population died in the Thirty
Years’ War than in the wars
of the 20th century” KATHLEEN BURK
77
CULTURE The Conversation
Simon Jenkins:
Kathleen Burk: “You “Britain has always
could argue that one gone in and out of
of the reasons Europe Europe: we engage, we
was so peaceful in disengage, we have
the 19th century nothing to do with it,
was that its nations and then we find we
simply directed their have a noble reason to
violence elsewhere” get involved again”
duty incumbent upon a historian, it’s to try to work out if during which the Berlin Wall came down in 1989 as a time of
anything can be learned from history. I do think it’s possible to unbelievable optimism. Between 1990 and 2000 history was at
discern, in the point I make about the recurring pattern of two an end, liberal democracy had triumphed; all these things were
generations of peace, the aversions that lead people to rely on being said – but we didn’t notice, sitting at the eastern border
diplomacy more than they did before. of Europe, an utterly humiliated major nuclear power: Russia.
My mother, who was a student at the end of the interwar And we did humiliate them, and we did drive Nato’s boundary
period and very politically active on the left, always said that no eastward into what they regarded as their territory. That was a
one would ever understand how people approached diplomacy very dangerous thing to do, and I believe that if anything goes
between the wars. She said that it’s impossible to imagine, wrong in my lifetime it will be caused by that decision.
when all you could remember was the First World War, why
anyone would do it again. When [British prime minister] What are your thoughts on the future of Europe?
Neville Chamberlain came back from meeting Adolf Hitler in I’ve always been a sceptic of the EU. I was not in favour of
1938, 90% of the nation were cheering him on, because every- Britain joining, because I think it’s a dysfunctional, ill-formed,
one feared another war and he’d apparently stopped it. Six protectionist body that is not serving the interests of Europe
months later the situation was very different, but at that point well. That’s my scepticism.
in time the horror of war was foremost in people’s minds. My positivity about it is based on the fact that it’s all we’ve
How far you can see that echoed in modern diplomatic got. Looking at the break-up of Yugoslavia [in the early 1990s],
relations between states, I’m not sure. All I know is that on the I wonder if it may have been possible to stop the violence if the
few occasions since the Second World EU had been more engaged. So I have
War when things became very danger- faith in unions: they are our only
ous, largely due to the incompetence or ABOUT THE AUTHORS defence against the resumption of war.
age of Russian leaders during the Cold That’s why, over the centuries,
War, we pulled back from the brink. Britain has been sucked back in to
I think that’s because people were so Simon Jenkins European interventions designed to
horrified by the prospect of a nuclear is a journalist and author. avoid open conflict – most conspicuous-
exchange that they couldn’t bring A Short History of Europe: ly in the 18th-century War of Spanish
themselves to instigate whatever process From Pericles to Putin Succession, but also against Napoleon
was necessary to precipitate it. will be published by and again against Hitler. In my mind,
We survived those crises, and others Viking in November those have been noble interventions by
since – even the approach of hot war Britain in a good cause: that of a sort
along parts of the Russian border. I can’t of united Europe. These were genuine
believe that the sequence of events neces- Kathleen Burk attempts by good people to find peace.
sary to produce another war on anything is a historian and Britain has always gone in and out
like the scale of the last one will happen. writer. Her latest book of Europe: we engage, we disengage,
But perhaps that’s an act of faith! is The Lion and the Eagle: we have nothing to do with Europe
DAVID HAMPTON
78
BBC World Histories Magazine Reader Survey
Terms and conditions: The prize is one £250 Amazon voucher. One winner will be drawn at random after the closing
date at 23.59 on 31 December 2017. Open to all residents of the UK and the Channel Islands aged 18 years or over except
employees of BBC Worldwide or the BBC, their contractors, members of their families and anyone connected with this
prize draw. Only one entry permitted per person. There is no cash alternative and the prize is not transferable. No purchase
necessary. The prize draw is subject to the laws of England and Wales. Promoter: BBC Worldwide Limited, Television
Centre, 101 Wood Lane, London W12 7FA. Your data will be used for the purposes of administration of this prize draw and
in accordance with BBC Worldwide’s Privacy Policy (www.bbcworldwide.com/privacy.aspx ). Where consent has been
provided, BBC Worldwide may send email marketing messages from which you may unsubscribe at any time.
CULTURE Agenda
Agenda
EXHIBITIONS, TV,
FILMS AND
MORE
80
UNDER THE SUN
This striking image depicts a vast
sunspot – a temporary darkening
on the surface of the sun – that
dwarfed the Earth. It was painted
by Scottish artist and engineer
James Nasmyth, who observed it
in July 1860, based on sketches
made at his telescope. It’s among
the items on display at a new exhi-
bition that chronicles humanity’s
changing perceptions of our closest
star, from ancient solar creation
myths to later scientific efforts
to analyse this huge astral body.
Featuring artefacts from locations
including China, Denmark and
the polar north, the collection will
be displayed at London’s Science
Museum this autumn before head-
ing to Manchester next summer.
The Sun: Living with our Star, from
6 October at the Science Museum, London
sciencemuseum.org.uk/sun
SCIENCE MUSEUM GROUP COLLECTION
81
E Agenda
CULTURE
ALAMY/ THE GEORGE ECONOMOU COLLECTION © DACS 2018/HISTORY MUSEUM OF ARMENIA, YEREVAN
painting Brüderstrasse,
One of the major figures behind the depicting women working
as prostitutes, is among
Holocaust, Adolf Eichmann lived
the paintings in a new
under an assumed identity following exhibition depicting life
the Second World War, escaping to in Weimar Germany
Argentina in 1950. Despite attempts
by so-called ‘Nazi hunters’ and
members of Israel’s secret service BERLIN STORIES
to track him down, he lived free in Although the phrase ‘magic realism’ exhibition of its form and skill. Viewed
Buenos Aires until his capture in 1960. is now associated with Latin American here in their own right, the pieces reflect
The story of these efforts is the subject literature, it was first used by German the new ways of living in the years after
of a new film starring Star Wars photographer and art critic Franz Roh in the end of the First World War, the
actor Oscar Isaac as Mossad agent 1925 to describe a style mixing realistic wider political economic instability of
Peter Malkin, and Sir Ben Kingsley detail with a celebration of the fantasti- the period, and a fervent anti-militarism.
as Eichmann, who was tried in Israel cal and dreamlike. It’s this meaning of Among featured works are those by
and executed for crimes against the term that lends its name to a new leading names including Otto Dix and
humanity two years later. exhibition at Tate Modern, chronicling Max Beckmann, many of whose careers
, from 14 September (UK), the art of the Weimar Republic. were cut short by the rise of Nazism. If
other release dates vary Both elements of that definition you can’t make it to the exhibition, look
operationfinalefilm.com
emerge strongly through the collection: out for the companion book featuring
Berlin street scenes are juxtaposed with highlights chosen by its curators.
vibrantly hued landscapes and intricate, Magic Realism: Art in Weimar Germany,
off-kilter portraits. When the Nazis 1919-33, until 14 July 2019
seized power in 1933, they labelled this at Tate Modern, London
art ‘degenerate’, launching a mocking tate.org.uk/visit/tate-modern
82
Six books for autumn
As always, a bumper crop of global history books
will appear on shelves in the final months of the
year. Here’s our pick of titles to look out for
Roller-Coaster: Vietnam:
Europe, 1950–2017 An Epic Tragedy,
by Ian Kershaw 1945–1975
Allen Lane, 704 by Max Hastings
pages, £30, out now William Collins,
752 pages, £30,
This woven leopard, part of an exhibition about Master storyteller
September
global dissent, hints at criticism aimed at the Ian Kershaw turns
dictator of the Democratic Republic of Congo his attention to the Another big book
innovations and from one of
insecurities of the history’s big
OBJECTS OF SATIRE post-Second World authors, this
War era, as politics and technology led to weighty study of the conflict in Vietnam
A graffiti-daubed brick from ancient increasing integration but also nationalist draws on both new archival research and
Babylonia; a 16th-century salt cellar sentiment and financial instability. Sequel oral testimony. It also drives home just
suggesting Catholic ideas at a time to his 2015 book To Hell and Back: Europe, how much the Vietnamese lost in
when its worship was banned; a piece 1914-1949, this is a truly epic account. decades of brutal, drawn-out war.
of fabric (pictured) emblazoned with
the phrase “the skin of the leopard Rome: Eternal Gandhi 1914–1948
is beautiful, but inside is war”, perhaps City by Ramachandra
serving as veiled criticism of the young- by Ferdinand Guha
looking yet brutal Congolese dictator Addis Allen Lane, 1,152
Mobutu Sese Seko. These objects, Head of Zeus, 648 pages, £40, Sept
pages, £30, Sept
all representing individual acts of This new biography
defiance, feature in a new exhibition Histories charts the years
at London’s British Museum exploring comprising a following Gandhi’s
themes of rebellion and dissent. series of vignettes departure from
are in vogue, and England for India,
Curated by Ian Hislop, editor of
here the format is where he led the
Private Eye magazine, it’s a celebration applied to the city of Rome. From its nation to independence from British rule.
of subversion and satire – some brazen, ancient foundation to the Second World Mixing character study with social and
some understated – throughout history War, via Gauls, ghettos and gladiators, its political history, it’s another expansive
and around the world. 22 chapters focus on themes of individu- book from the author of India after Gandhi.
I Object: Ian Hislop’s Search for Dissent, from als, myths and beliefs.
6 September at The British Museum, London The Kremlin The Jamestown
britishmuseum.org/iobject Letters Brides
by David Reynolds by Jennifer Potter
and Vladimir Atlantic, 384 pages,
Pechatnov £20, October
Yale, 660 pages,
What do you do
THE TRUSTEES OF THE BRITISH MUSEUM
£25, October
when your brand
Featuring some new colony has all
of the hundreds of the men and land
letters exchanged it needs, but not
by Stalin, Churchill enough women?
and Roosevelt during the Second World The solution of the Virginia Company in
War alongside trenchant commentary and the 1600s was to advertise for wives –
analysis, this British-Russian collabora- making a tidy profit on the women who
tion offers valuable insights into both the journeyed across the Atlantic to start
conflict and the minds of three of the key new lives. Their experiences form the
leaders of the period. centrepiece of a remarkable story.
84
The Church of St John the
Theologian in Ohrid, Macedonia.
Lear proclaimed of his visit: “Of
many days passed in many lands,
in wandering amid noble scenery,
I can recall none more variously
delightful and impressive”
AWL IMAGES
Æ
85
JOURNEYS In the footsteps of Edward Lear’s journey through Ottoman Europe
86
2 October 1848
Lear bemoans heav y rain that
hinders drawing in Skódra,
since “nothing in the world
could be more picturesque
than the ferry and its capoted
rowers”
29 September 1848
Lear is happy to leave
Tirana, “quitting its 20 September 1848
horrible khan” with The traveller admires
the “picturesque 48
its “pigsty dormitor y” mber 18
streets” of Akhridha 17 Septe es in Monastír,
iv
Lear arr admires
where he dingly
e
the “exce e” bazaars
ha n d s o m
13 September 1848
Lear rides west from
Salonica with his
26 September 1848 ‘dragoman’ Giorgio
While sketching at
Elbasán, Lear is assailed
by a ‘Dervish’ who
shouts “Shaitán scroo!”
– “The Devil draws!”
31 October 1848
At Tepeléne, Lear is disappointed
to find “a dreary, blank scene of
desolation” where the domain of
23 October 1848 the great Ottoman ruler
Lear is woken before Ali Pasha once stood
dawn in Dukádhes by “the
most piercing screams”
– the wailing lament of a
newly widowed woman
12 November 1848
Lear sails from Préveza
to Lefkada, ending his first
sojourn in Ottoman Europe
Æ
ILLUSTRATION BY THERESA GRIEBEN 87
JOURNEYS In the footsteps of Edward Lear’s journey through Ottoman Europe
88
Lear’s sketch of Monastír
(now Bitola, today in the
country of Macedonia), a
thriving barrack town he
lauded for its “exceedingly
handsome” bazaars
An early 19th-century
illustration of Albanians.
Lear noted that Albanian
Gheghes women wore “a
magnificence of costume
almost beyond belief”
Æ
89
JOURNEYS In the footsteps of Edward Lear’s journey through Ottoman Europe
90
CONTACT US
Coming up in issue 13
Email worldhistories@historyextra.com on sale from 5 December
Post BBC World Histories, Immediate Media Company Bristol Ltd, Tower House,
Fairfax Street, Bristol BS1 3BN, UK Phone +44 117 314 7377
Twitter twitter.com/historyextra Facebook facebook.com/historyextra
Website historyextra.com/worldhistories
Lily Owens-Crossman
Reprographics Tony Hunt and Chris Sutch
Advertising manager Sam Jones Never miss an issue – turn to page 24
+44 117 300 8145 sam.jones@immediate.co.uk
to subscribe today
91
JOURNEYS
Navel
of the
Incan
world
The Baroque facades of the
Catedral and La Compañía
(right) loom over Incan
emperor Pachacutec in
Cusco’s Plaza de Armas
This spectacular city tand in Cusco’s central Castillo, lined with simple restaurants
is a travel and larceny, stroll south-east from Plaza de of the Incas (based on stories told by his
heritage writer Armas along Loreto and onto Pampa de mother’s family) and the conquest.
92
For more detailed exploration of
Incan history, visit the Museo Inka,
The walls of the Finally, climb to the huge fortress
of Sacsayhuamán (‘Satisfied Falcon’)
housed in one of Cusco’s finest colonial Temple of the Sun overlooking the old city. This bastion,
mansions. The Palacio del Almirante
(Admiral’s Palace) is packed with a at Qorikancha were established by the Killke people around
AD 1100, was vastly expanded by the
slightly dusty but extensive collection of reputedly clad with Inca and played a key role in the Spanish
metalwork, pottery, dioramas, cos- conquest. It was here in 1536, three years
tumes, maps and paintings. 700 solid gold sheets after Inca emperor Atahualpa was killed
Probably the most impressive aspects by Francisco Pizarro’s Conquistadors,
of Incan technology were employed in that his rebellious half-brother Manco
construction, notably in the Qhapaq Inca made a stand. After victory by the
Ñan – the Andean road system stretch- Precolombino, housed in another outnumbered Spanish forces, ending any
ing some 20,000 miles – and the mortar- beautiful colonial courtyard building, serious resistance to their occupation,
free stonework used in building sites such explores decorative arts spanning over the fortress was razed, its stones serving
as Machu Picchu. Look for the astonish- 2,500 years; explanations of the as an unofficial quarry for the colonial
ing 12-sided stone on Calle Hatun symbolism in jewellery are particularly rebuilding of Cusco. Today the Inca’s
Rumiyoq, north-east of the Catedral. fascinating – look for the spondylus Quechua-speaking descendants celebrate
Of course, Peruvian history didn’t shells and spiral motifs that remain Inti Raymi, the Sun Festival, at Saysay-
start with the Inca. The Museo de Arte significant to Andean peoples today. huamán on winter solstice each June.
94
Tombs amid the dunes
Dozens of pyramids stud the desert at
Meroë, 150 miles north-east of Khartoum.
No more than 30m high, Sudan’s steep-
sided tombs were built for the elite of the
kingdom of Kush, which emerged around
the eighth century BC, its capital at Napata
(modern Karima). Dominating the trade
route between Egypt and central Africa,
Kush grew in wealth and power, and in
the early seventh century BC, Qore (King)
Taharqa ruled Egypt as well as Nubia
(now northern Sudan). Later that century
Assyrians drove the Kushites from Egypt,
and around 592 BC an Egyptian-sponsored
expedition sacked Napata. The capital
then transferred south to Meroë where,
from around the third century, some 30
kings and eight queens were interred.
Sudan’s
pyramid
kingdom
GETTY IMAGES/MAP: BATTLEFIELD DESIGNS
Royal regalia
This gold bracelet was looted from the
pyramid of Kandake (Queen) Amanishak-
heto (reigned from c10 BC) by Italian tomb
robber Giuseppe Ferlini in 1834. Her finely
worked jewellery, displaying Hellenistic
influences, is now held in Egyptian muse-
ums in Munich and Berlin. The Kushites Mane attraction
had access to iron and gold, and were The lion-headed god Apedemak, shown in
expert metalworkers; Meroë has been a carved relief frieze at the Lion Temple at
described as the ‘Birmingham of Africa’. Naqa, a complex of sanctuaries south of
the necropolis. This temple, built around
AD 50, is dedicated to the important
indigenous god believed by the Kushites to
be the companion of Isis. In Egypt, Isis was
considered the sister and wife of Osiris,
god of the underworld.
96
Animal avenue
A phalanx of carved stone rams guard
the inner Temple of Amun at Naqa. This
precinct, believed to have been built
around AD 50, is dedicated to the
Kushite’s chief creator god Amun
(‘The Hidden’). After centuries of
interaction, the religious pantheons of
Kush and Egypt overlapped: the much
earlier and larger Temple of Karnak at
Thebes (Luxor) – which also boasts an
avenue of rams – was dedicated to Amun.
Cultural cross-fertilisation
A decorated stone lintel tops the en-
trance to the Hathor Chapel at Naqa. This
shrine was formerly known as the Roman
Kiosk, reflecting stylistic influences that
also included Egyptian and Greek. At the
time this chapel was built, around AD 50,
Egypt had been ruled by the Hellenistic
Ptolemaic dynasty for nearly three
centuries before being annexed by the
Romans, who began to make incursions
into Kush in the late first century BC.
97
MUSEUM OF THE WORLD Global history’s finest objects, curated by experts
“The gold of the face represented the Nile mud that made possible annual
harvests in an otherwise desert land-
the life-giving sun as the ultimate scape. For me, her face encapsulates
ancient Egypt in a single, stunning object.
symbol of daily resurrection” This piece came to light in 2014,
when Wigan Council staff rediscovered
a collection of artefacts once owned
5 Gold coffin face Her gold skin exudes the wealth of the by Wigan-born lawyer Sir John Scott
era in which she was created, while her (1841–1904). In 1871 ill health forced him
Created by: unknown eyes of calcite and obsidian stare back to relocate to a warmer climate – first
at the viewer, and her slight smile belies the French Riviera then Egypt, where
craftsperson, c1400 BC the fact this was once part of her coffin. he was appointed a judge in the court of
This cuts to the heart of ancient Egyptian
Now at: Museum of Wigan culture, which faced death confident
appeal in 1874. He soon became known
as ‘Scott the Just’ because he tackled
Life, Wigan in the knowledge that it was simply a corruption, made the law accessible to
transition into another state of existence. all and recommended the abolition of
Chosen by: Joann Fletcher The deceased, Egyptians believed, torture, slavery and unpaid work on
passed into the care of afterlife deities behalf of the state (all three of which
far removed from the ‘grim reaper’ had, by that time, been around for
This gilded face portrays a wealthy familiar in western cultures. They almost 5,000 years).
Egyptian woman. Though her name is were instead welcomed into the warm In 1890, Scott was appointed judicial
unknown, the style dates her to the early embrace of maternal goddess Hathor, adviser to Egypt’s Turkish ruler Tewfiq
14th century BC, corresponding to Egypt’s ‘the Golden One’, daughter of the sun god. Pasha. He had also developed an interest
18th dynasty – a golden age when Egypt The same symbolism is also found in antiquities, and often visited the Cairo
was at the height of its power, presided in the specifically 18th-dynasty colour Museum when it was still housed in the
over by its greatest pharaohs. These palette of gold and black. Gold repre- palace of former ruler Ismail Pasha in
rulers’ minor wives and offspring could sented the life-giving sun as the ultimate the Giza district of the city. After one
number several hundred, and this may symbol of daily resurrection, while such visit he noted that “it was such a
be the face of one such woman. black was the colour of new life, based on relief to get away from the present world
and move life back 4,000 years”. At that
time, the museum actively sold off its
‘excess stock’, and Scott began to acquire
antiquities. Retiring in 1898, Scott
returned to England, where he died.
After his wife Leonora died in 1924,
their son donated his parents’ antiquities
to the people of Wigan.
98
The war from above
An aerial photograph showing the town
of Kut, 100 miles south of Baghdad,
during the Siege of Kut in the First
World War. On page 48, David Olusoga
chronicles the impact of the conflict on
countries and peoples across the globe