Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/342361550
CITATIONS READS
0 237
1 author:
Catarina Vitorino
Pontifícia Universidade Católica de São Paulo (PUC-SP)
14 PUBLICATIONS 77 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Catarina Vitorino on 22 June 2020.
Foreword:
Kengo KUMA
Editors:
Salvator-John A. LIOTTA
Matteo BELFIORE
Book Design:
Ilze PAKLONE
Rafael A. BALBOA
Foreword 4
KengoKuma
Background
Salvator JohnA. Liotta and Matteo Belfiore
Thinking
Development of Japanese Traditional Pattern under the Influence of Chinese Culture 112
Yao Chen
European and Japanese space : ADifferent Perception Through Artists' Eyes 134
Fede ricoSca roni
Pervious and Phenomenal Opacity : Boundary Techniques and Intermediating Patterns as Design Strategies 140
Robert Baum
Integrated Interspaces: An Urban Interpretation of the Concept of Oku 146
Cristiano Lippa
Doing
Therefore, it can be asked which ma terials, mo tives, textures and patterns const itute the skin and structure of
Japa nese vernacu lar arch Itectu re? What bou nda ry patte rns are observed in minka typolog les? 'Ja pa nese dwelli ngs
are often sa id to be made of wood and pape r; but () It is mo re accu rate to say that minka are made of wood ,
grass, and earth ." (Kawashima 1986 18)' in different lo ca l arrangements. The existence of local patterns among
regiona l diversity in Japanese vernacu lar architecture was Identified and reg iste red by Wa jiro Kon (1888-1973)1'
In "Nihon no Mlnka" (1927). Japanese rural house typo logi es were Interpreted "() as material expressions of
particular lifestyles, concluding that it was the natural environment which largely defined those patterns of living."
(Nute 1995 114)
The present resea rch aims to examine the role of Intermediate spaces and the usage of different porosity
material patterns In bui lding's envelope boun daries , in minka arch itecture, identifying local typo logies and its
respons iveness to micro-local conditions. It is intended to visualize how these patterns change in space and to
clarify how its soft boundaries are subject to local adaptation , and ecosystem integration.
11 8 I 119
Sp read ove r the is lands of Japanese te rri tory, and settled in different local cond itions, 9 typologies
of minka houses (next page Fig 3), depicted in (Kawash ima 1986) minka survey monography, were
--, ----' ana lyzed , in orde r to determine its usage of Intermediate spaces and different po rosity material
1. Ama-do 2. Sudare and Yoshizu 3. Sh oj i 4. Goshi 5. Yu ki amaya pa tterns. The envelope layers and ma terials iden tified in the su rveyed minka typolog ies, were
(wood shutte rs) (ba mbooand marsh reed shades) (paper and wood sliding doors) (wood latt ice) (t hatch protection) organized as the following Intermediate spaces, Movable wall elements and screenings (Ama-
do, Sudare and Yoshizu, Shoji, Goshi, Yuki amayal. Fixed wall elements (Wood cladding, Bamboo
cladding , Plaster and wood structu re, Boa rd wood walls, Tha tch walls), Roof materials (Thatch roof,
Shingle roof, Tile roof, Copper pla te roof), Flooring materials (Ea rth room, Wood flooring, Tatami
fiooring, Bamboo flooring), and Foundation structures (Grounds ill foundation , Ra ised floor, Leve li ng
stone base, Stone retain ing wall) (Fig 2).
~
~ - :.t.........t...' waste trea tment. environmenta l amenity, loca l food production, or enhancement of cultu ral
- -j~"-
I -. .~ - functions and biodiversity (Grosskopf, Kibert 2006). The adaptation of hu ma nized lan dscape and
" ~' I • ~,~ natural environment into a cooperat ion symbiosIs within a natural or humanized ecosystem is
refe rred in Japan as satoyama, atradit ional socio-eco logica l landscape, associated with ve rnacular
architecture systems.
In satoyama, the performed socral and productive ac tivities?provide support for diverse ecologi ca l
funct ions, such as biodiversity habitats, water cyc le and soil forma tion. In these socio-ecolog lcal
structu res, advantage use of provis ioning , regu lating, supporting and cultural ecosystem services
11. Thatch roof 12. Sh ingle roof 13. Ti leroof 14. Ti leroof 15. Copper plate roof is taken without comp romising ecologica l functions ba lance. It can be assumed that ve rnacular
arch itectural systems, integ rated in satoyama landsca pes, also share degrees of ecosystem
integration. For interpretation of envelope layers and material patte rns identified in minka
typo log ies, It was attempted to estab lish patterns of local adaptation, based on regional ecologic B
and climatic featu res (Fig 3)
With in vernacular minka, loca l diversi ty regard ing different po rosity ma teria l pa tterns in build ing's
enve lope boundaries elemen ts may be identified. These pa tterns often reflect the structure of
available resou rces, ma teria ls and textures, both natural and of resu lting man made crafts skills
and tec hn iques, exp ressing the resu lts of ma teria l stereotomy, as well as indicating abou t local
16. Earthroom
17. Wood flooring 18. Tatam i flooring 19. Bamboo flooring 20. Peb bles
(natural and cu ltural) integration. Envelope layers and material pa tterns of minka typologies were
(doma, niwa, genkan)
classified acco rding to essen tia l environmental exchanges and contact surfaces, as la tera l, top
and base envelope elements, providing contact With diverse elements such as soil-ground , light,
air-wind, and prec ipitation. In some cases, It was noted the existence of local sub-va riants of the
same typology, or similar sub-typologies were identified indiff erent areas. The performed ana lysis
results are expressed in Table 1.
120 I 121
Climate ------
----Mirika-fypoCo-gies --- -------- Ecosystem Intermediate ---------------
----- ------------- Movable Fixed --------- -----
------- Shape --------
Material ---------------------
Flooring Foundation
--------- -------------
ill g
- - ~ ~==
~
.s ~!
~~,
~ ,~ CD i ~§ =ru
m-oj
G G
~
and Inner
courtyard
--- -kirihiifu--zukuii--- -- ------ ------ ----- ------ ------- ---- ------ ----- ------ ------ ---- ----- ------- ------ ------ ------ ---- ------- -- --- ------ ----
-0-4~ JopJig2
I, G Kanto- I . balcony • • • • • • D . work ••• ••• Locationandidentifica tionof the minka typologies
II, H chobu to south area and
~
IV on 2 storage
floors _oppositepage from left_Table1
Ana lysisof envelopelayersand material patterns of minka typologies
----O
06.longhousec Il l,
IV
Kanto-
chobu
• front
veranda work
area
·
small 0
··
-f -b-u-nio-iuku-ria --- -------- ----------- ------------------------ ----- ---------------- ----- -------------------- --------- --------- -------------
more refl ected on interior typology, structural shape and circula tion than envelope eleme nts, material patte rns and
intermediate spaces, which act as immediate inte rface with site specificities, and ecosystem integration, It is observed
VI [out c . open 0 • separate • 0 local diversity in envelope elements and intermediate spaces tha t reveal site spec ificities, although severa l mate rial
of veranda, cooking patte rns may be widespread into large regions. Thatch roofs are common on most of the regions, while tile roofs tend to
clusters] to rooms, area
~ SW be observed on ly in southern areas. Similarly, division between in land and coasta l areas might be attempted, as well as
122 [1 23
Hokkaido Ho kkai do
Footnotes
I. Presently exceeded In wha t conce rns na tural resou rces, dep letion of biodiversity and farming land, and concent rationsof pollu tion and waste.
(WWF(2008) Livi ng Planet Report 2008. Wo rldWi ldlife Fund (WWF) Avai lable at www httpl/assets.panda.o rg /down loadslliving. planeUeporti
Tohoku To hoku 2. The assessment of vernacular arch itecture performance tends however to be ana lyzed ma inly through ene rgy aspe cts (thermal com fort. energy
consumption, embodied energy, etc) and the ba lance with micro-local and glo ba l environments isassessed predominantly from impacts, and ra rely
from benefits towa rds the local or global ecosystem.
3. Moreover, both concepts of fudo (J!t±) (the read ing of th esite); and th econcept of boundary in termedia tespa ces, kyo kai (~W). grow from a
tra dition to un derstand na ture and arc hitecture at a si te-specific local leve l.
4. Who condu cted in the 1917 the Habu koka i minka resea rch .
-chubu 5. Co ldand dry win ters an dhot and hum id summers.
6. Pa rticularly during theYayoi period
7. Which take pla cewithin laye rs of natu ral enVironment , fores try and cultivated area s, and bui lt systems (Iton aga: 2005: p.68)
8. For eco logica l characterization, wereused th esatoyama ecologi ca l clusters, represen ting study areas with geographi ca l, climatic, eco log ica l,
social, economi c, and politica l affinities, acco rding toJapa n Sa toyama Satoumi Assessment USSA: 2010)
9. Generically used inene rgy conse rvation po licies, and sustainable building assessmen t.
10. The presence of these elemen ts is poss ibly less related with mi cro-loca l spec ificity and morewith the degree of complexity of the typology
samp les, as it appea rs larger in more elaborated bui ld ing s, and less significant in less wea lthy examp les
II. Upon potent ial impacts as land use change, micro-cl imate change, invas ivespecies, pollu ti on, over-exploitation or unde r-useof loca l resou rces.
12. Climate Regions I (regiona l division for housing standard s (according to temperatu revariation, received solar rad iat ion, and resu lting heating
JoP leftJig 3a and Fig3b requ iremen t. in win ter), and Climate Region II (reg iona l division fo r non -residential buildings acco rding to hea ting supp ly requ iremen ts, in Winter, an d
Sa toyama ecosystem clustersand Clima te Regions I and II cooling requ iremen ts, insummer) (Sakamoto: 2005)
(according to tem pe raturevariation, received so lar rad iation
and resulti ng heating requiremen t, in winter) (Sakam oto: 2005) References
Frazer, J (1995) An Evo luti onary Arch itecture. Arch itectu ral Associa tion Publica ti ons, Themes VII London Arch itectura l Associat ion.
Grosskopf, K, Kibert, C. J, (2006) Rad ica l sustainableconstruction: Envisioning next-generation green bui ldings. White Paper, Con ference: Rethin ki ng
.. Sustainable Construction: Next Generat ion Green Bu ildings, Univers ity of Florida: Florida. Sep tembe r 2006. Ava ilab leat httpl/wwwcceufl.edu/rsc06
Guy, G. B., Kibe rt, C. J, Sendzlmir, J (ed.! (2002) Constru ction Eco logy: Natu re as the basi s for green bu ildings. London: Spon Press.
wh ich reinforcehuman stewa rds+i'P towards surrounding ecosystems and the va lua ti on of its services. On theother hand,
Isozakl, A. (2 006) Japan -ness in Archi tecture. Cambridge/London MIT Press.
the great employment of natural sourced materials signifies inc rea sed re cyclab ility and biodegradab le disposability at
Ito naga, K. (2005) "M ultilayered na tural, rural and urban envlrOOments" and "D esigning to restoreand createna ture In citie s". in Arch itecture for a
theend of lifecycle, whileduring occu pancy stage, it may also cons titutebiod iversity refugiu mand hab itat niches. Sustainable Futu re all abou t the holistic app roach in Japan. Ed ited by Arch itectura l Institu teof Japan (AlJ) To kyo Institutefor Bui ldin g Environment
and Ene rgy Conserva tion (IBEC) p.68-69, p.72-77
Thatch roofs and walls allow the growth of grass, to Increased Insulation inwinter, which is periodica lly cu t, in summer.
JSSA. (201 D) Sa toyama-Satoumi Ecosystems and Human Well-Being Socio-eco logica l Produ ction Landscapes of Japan · Summary fo r Decision
Living materials ca n also contribu te to balance hygro thermal conditions, as they absorb air hu midity, contributing to Ma kers. Japan Sa toyama Satou mi Assessmen t USSA) To kyo: United Na tio ns Unive rSity.
indoor comfo rt, and air qua lity, as envelop ema terials laye rs tend topresen t porosity characteristics. In a similar manner, Kawashima , C. (1986) Mln ka Tradi tional Houses of Ru ral Ja pan. Tokyo Kodansha In terna tional.
the earth roomallows soil pe rme ability over an extended su rface, contribu tin g to wa ter cycling. Kodama, Y. (2005) "Passive De Sign ". in Arch itecture for aSustainable Future: all about the holistic approach in Japan. Ed ited by Arch itectu ral Institut e
of Japan (AlJ) To kyo Institutefor Bui lding EnvlrOOment and Energy Conse rva ti on (lBEC) p.124-130
It was also ob se rved that broade r cli matic regi ons 9 are not sufficient per se to form loca l typo logy patterns, it isnecessary Kuma, K. ed. (20 10) Kyo ka i: AJapanese Techn ique for Articu lat ing Space. To kyo: Tan kos ha Pub lish ing
toobse rve othe r site and micro-site specifici ties. Wh ile atypology isessentially forme dby program, life-style and cu lture, Matsunawa, K. (2 010) "Towards the Rea lization of ZEBs" in Sustainable Architecture in Japan. The continuing challenge 1900-201 0 & beyond. To kyo
Sh inkenchiku. p. 196-203
availab lelocal materials, technology processes, and neighboring reg ional influences, it also encompasses adaptation to Murakami, S., Ikaga, 1. (2 008) Evalua ti ng envi ronmen tal perfo rmance of vernacular architecture th rough CASBEE. Tokyo: IBEC -I nstitutefor Building
loca l ecosys tems attending to specific micro-loca l fea tures, as topography, hydrology, loca l biodive rsity and landscape Envi ronmen t and Energy Conservation.
arrangements. Nu te, K. (2 004) Place, Time and Being in Japanese Arch itecture. NewYor k Tay lor & Francis.
Reed, B" (2007). "Sh iftin g ou r Men tal Model · "Sustalnabi lity" to Rege neration" In Bu ilding Resea rch and Informa ti on, 35, 6, 674-680.
Given fe w su rviving examples of m/nka houses, great pa rt of them consistin g of reproduc tions and relocations, not Sa komoto, Y. (2005) "Energy conse rva tion In tune With loca l climates" and "Clima tic Divis ion s of Japa n". in Arch itectu re for aSus tainable Future: all
inhabited and removed fromtrad itional life stylecycles, attri bu tes an additiona l difficulty to presently assess tempora ry about th eholistic approach in Japa n. Edit ed by Archi tectura l Instituteof Ja pan (AlJ) Tokyo: Institut efor Bu ilding Environmen t and Energy Conservation
(IBEC) p8889
seasonal occupancy fea ture s, su ch as movable elements as sudare, or exterior fences of diverse kinds, for cli matic
protection towards wind, snow, an d sea airstreams. However, regarding the presence of wall screen in g and layered Acknowledgements
elements, va ria tions were observed In va riety and amount of covered su rface, spec ially refe rring togosh/and sho;f1° Opening Ph oto by Artur Miguel San tos. Fi g 1,2,3 and Tab le I areDra wings and Pho tos by Autho r.
In conclu sion, the stu dy of enve lope layers and ma terial patterns obse rved in vernacular arch itectu re may point out
future exp lorative and creative directions, in architectural design. Architecture and planning act as direct drivers!! on Catarina Vitorino
the equ ilibrium of ecosystems, influ encing the vital se rvices provided by these. Its design decisions can potentially Ca tarina Vito rino is an arch itect and member of Ke ngo Kuma Labo ratory, the University of To kyo, fund ed by MEXTMon bu ka gakush o Programme, with
influe nce negative or positive effects. Ecosys tem integ ration deSign resu lts, based on a given ra nge of site specificity, the Resea rch To pi c "Eco logical boundaries: susta inable bu ilding design and the integration of micro-local ecosystems" She has aDiplo ma Deg ree in
Arc h. (2004), and aPost-G raduation in Biocli ma tic Arch itecture (2009) from FA-UTL(Lisb on ) Architect chartere d by the Order of Portug uese Arch itects,
as in vernacular archit ectu re, are not deterministi c but allow degrees of innovative freedom tha t may crea te a tru ly she has workedin research, in archi tecture and urban planni ng, and is member of IISBE(Interna tion al Initi ative fo r aSustainab le Bu ilt Envi ronmentl .
res pons ive and co llaborative architectu rewith ti me and place.
124 I 125
View publication stats