Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2) Manitoulin-Lake Simcoe
- This ecoregion is where the sedimentary rocks of Layer II are covered by well-drained glacial sediments
of Layer III
3) Algonquin-Lake Nipissing
- This ecoregion of the CS dominated by old hard rocks and thin soils
Watersheds of Ont.
Many rivers and lakes drain to Hudson Bay and the Atlantic Ocean
The great lakes are relatively young landscape features and formed during the Pleistocene ice ages that commenced
after some 2 million years ago
CHAPTER 2:
1473-1543: Nicolas Copernicus
Modern concept of a dynamic spinning earth within a cast sun-centered celestial system
Cast in Stone:
1531
600 BC Greek philosophers puzzled over origin of fossils
Poet Martial wrote insects trapped in amber and Ovid referred to “sea-born lands”
By middle ages, fossils were regarded as products of a curious vis plastica (a shaping power)
Leonardo da Vinci written in 1500, contained many thoughts on the formation of fossils by “petrification”
Not until 1531: GEORG BAUER (GEORGIUS AGRICOLA)
- Identified “figure stones” as the remains of long-dead marine animals
- Introduced word “fossil”
- Regarded as the father of the mining industry and is famous for his work in the Erzgebirge (the ore
mountains) of Europe
- “bc human memory does not extend back into that remote past in which these mighty changes of the
landscape began. Most ppl think that there have not been such changes, although we can behold them
going on still today”
- Agricola was expressing for the 1st time the concept of uniformitarianism (“the present is the key to the
past”)
A Fitting Discovery:
1620
1561-1626: Francis Bacon
English scientist
He suggested that continents were once joined to form a single landmass
340 yrs later he was to be proved correct by a computer
Book Review:
1650
1581-1656: Archbishop Ussher
Irish theologian
Examined lineage of Moses and his ancestors recorded in old testament
Declared that earth formed at 9am October 26, 4004 BC
Theophilus of Antioch in AD 169, had earlier determined a date of 5529 BC
These dates continued to have a lasting influence on the debate about the age of earth well into 19 th century
1667
1631-1686: Nicholas Steno
Danish physician to the Duke of Florence
Recognized liker Bauer that fossils are the remains of long-dead organisms
Scientific discipline of paleontology (study of fossils) was born
Steno made important contributions to the discipline stratigraphy (subdiscipline og geology concerned with
establishing the order and age of rock strata whether igneous, metamorphic or sedimentary in origin)
“mountains can be annihilated, land can be conveyed from one place to another, peaks raised and lowered, and even
more things can occur which at first we would be inclined to regard as fables” This was straight on!
1715
1656-1742: Edmund Halley
English astronomer
Predicted the return of comet
Used salinity of Mediterranean Sea and rates of evaporation to estimate the age of the Earth
Similar calculation comparing salinity of river water and of seawater were repeated in 19 th century by Irish geologist
John Joly
Joly’s estimate: 90 million yrs
Based his calculations on the assumption that seawater contains all the salt delivered to it by rivers since the earth first
formed
Joly failed to account for the processes which act to remove salt from the oceans
Cool Dudes:
1749
1707-1788: Georges Leclerc (Count Buffon)
French scientist
Wrote in Epochs of Nature that earth cooled from a molten mass some 74,382 yrs ago
Leclerc based his estimate on the cooling rate of molten iron balls
The notion of progressive cooling and contraction led (1769-1832:) Georges Cuvier to propose episodic “upheavals”
of the Earth’s surface caused by contraction
He argued that such upheavals had caused the extinction of many organisms
A Flood of Ideas
1780
1750-1817: Abraham Werner
Late 18th century, geological thought was dominated by Werner
And the “German School” of global catastrophes (nicknamed the ‘Neptunists’ after the Roman god of the sea)
They argued that the history of earth could reconstructed by literal interpretation of biblical scripture and that socks and
features of earth’s surface had been created instantaneously during Noah’s flood
Werner never traveled out of his naïve Germany
He believed canoes resulted from the underground burning of coal seams
A New Textbook
1795
1726-1797: James Hutton
Scottish geologist
Father of geology
Published his theory of the earth in which he recognized unconformities & outlined the first scientific theory of
geology
Hutton argued that the forces of erosion, deposition and volcanism observable at the present fay can be used to explain
conditions on Earth (uniformitarianism)
He stated that there is “no vestige of a beginning, no prospect of an end”. Putting him into direct conflict with biblical
scholars and Ussher’s estimate of the age of Earth
UNCOFORMITIES:
Major time gaps for which no geological record survives, occur between the geologic layers of Ont.
- Think of a book with missing chapters
- The spaces forming missing chapters are called unconformities
Hutton's Unconformity is a name given to various notable geological sites in Scotland identified by the 18th-century
Scottish geologist James Hutton as places where the junction between two types of rock formations can be seen. This
geological phenomenon marks the location where rock formations created at different times and by different forces
adjoin. For Hutton, such an unconformity provided evidence for his Plutonist theories of uniformitarianism and the age
of the Earth.
An unconformity is any break in the normal progression of sedimentary deposits, which are laid the newer on top of the
older.
It’s a Gas
1796
1749-1827: Pierre-Simon Laplace
French scientist
Proposed that the solar system originated by the cooling and condensation from a hot gaseous cloud (the nebular
hypothesis)
Hence it came to be widely regarded that the earth was progressively cooling
- A basic notion that underlay many estimates as to the age of earth
Another Bestseller
1830
1797-1875: Charles Lyell
British geologist
Published “principles of Geology”
He set out the “standard” textbook view of uniformitarian geology (a stable and static earth) countering the dangerous
European tendency to invoke catastrophes such as giant floods to explain geological history
Lyell never accepted Agassiz’s theory of catastrophic Ice Age, preferring to explain the distribution of far-traveled
boulders and decries as the result of having been dropped b ice floes and icebergs (Called drift deposits)
By denying that catastrophes had any part in forming the geological record, Lyell went too far in dismissing “unbridled
speculation”
“An Epoch of Great Cold”
1837
Advocates of Werner’s school of Neptunism were asked for proof of their theory of a catastrophic flood, they said large
boulders and mounds of debris scattered over much of central Europe
Boulders lay far from their source
Neptunists reasoned, these erratics, had been transported by a giant flood
Diluvium:
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (German’s greatest poet), an avid collector of minerals was struck by observations of
rocks falling onto winter lake ice and being carried off in the spring breakup
Lyell used the notion of deposition of debris from drifting ice floes and icebergs to explain the far-travelled “drift” of
Europe
By 1829, Goethe realized that glaciers are more likely explanation and suggested that “an epoch of great cold passed
over Europe”
Swiss geologist, de Charpentier, gave scientific credibility to Goethe’s idea
Karl Schimper another poet coined the term the Ice Age
Most famous ice age advocate was Swiss, Louis Agassiz
Argued that a catastrophic ice age periodically wiped out all life om planet earth which would then be re-created once
again by a divine creator
Agassiz, largely out of loyalty to the biblical deluge, believed his catastrophic ice age simply replaced one catastrophe
with another; Noah’s flood in slow motion
The finding of ice age mammoths still frozen in their tracks in Russia excited the public’s imagination with this “fatal
cap of ice”
Lyell and others began to compile evidence of several periods of cold and warmth and believed that species were
created and became extinct continuously
By 1840 there were 2 main schools of thought regarding glaciation; Agassiz’s catastrophic ice age (wiped out all life
and ushered in new divine creations) (Etudes sur les Glacier) and Lyell’s drift theory of transport by icebergs
(Principles of Geology)
1840: Agassiz visited Scotland with Lyell
Evidence for glaciation on a grand scale
1846: contrary to Agassiz’s idea, modern day species, including human beings, had been in existence prior to the last
ice age
Humans had been alive and making tools while the great ice sheets covered Europe
End of the 19th century, geologists had recognized 4 main glaciations
A Heated Argument
1862
Sir William Thompson (Lord Kelvin; 1824-1907) proposed that the earth had cooled from a molten mass over some 98
million years but revised this figure 20-30 million years in 1897.
Though large, neither figure was satisfactory to geologists who recognized that the evolution of organisms evident from
the fossil record required much more time
Kelvin did not know about heat produced by radioactive decay
Just Floating Around
1865
George Airy (1801-92), the Astronomer Royal in Britain, proposed that mountain and continents are dominated by sial
(rocks composed predominantly of silica and alumina) and that they flow on a denser underlying substance which is
fluid (Sima; a molten rock or magma composed of silica and magnesium) high mountains act like large icebergs with
deep roots (isostasy)
This model was to influence Wegener in his formulation of continental drift
Things are evolving
1880s
By the late 19th century paleontologists were questioning the whole notion of “permanence”
They recognized that the fossil record of evolution on many continents was very similar
Darwin said this was very unlikely too
The debate heats up
1895-6
Marie Curie (1867-1934) & Henri Becquerel (1852-1908) co-discovered Radioactivity which is the process by which
unstable atoms disintegrate, releasing heat.
Radioactivity coined by curie in 1898
The Earth is Shrinking
1904
Edmund Suess (1839-1914)
Austrian geologist
Book: Face of the earth
Earth’s history consists of epochs and alternating rapid change and stability caused by shrinkage of the planet, much as
the skin of an apple wrinkles as it dries and contracts
Argued that the present continents were fragments of larger ones, which had subsided and that oceans were increasing
at the expense of the continents
He recognized the former existence of a giant “supercontinent” he named Gondwana
He also coined CS
He stressed the crust of earth was on the move; indisputable evidence of horizontal movement was found in the folded
rocks of the European alps and Canadian Rockies
Doing the wave
1908
Croatian Andrija Mohorovici (1857-1936)
Recorded a sharp increase in the velocity of seismic wave energy produced by earthquakes at the base of the Earth’s
crust (named the “Moho”)
Analysis of the travel times of seismic waves would eventually allow detailed understanding of the earth’s interior
A nuclear-powered planet
1905-1909
E. Rutherford, B. Boltwood, R.J. Strutt, and J. Joly spelled out the geological implications of the new discoveries of
radioactive elements
They argued that the earth was not simply cooling but had likely maintained a stable heat balance for much of its
history bc of continued decay of radioactive elements present in the Earth’s crust and mantle
1903: Joly had identified abundant evidence of the decay of radioactive elements present in rocks and minerals
Boltwood showed that the transformation of uranium/lead ratios in rocks provided a means of dating
Strut provided a new estimate for the age of earth: 2.4 billion years
MODERN AGE OF GEOLOGY HAD BEGUN…
Where’s North Gone?
1906
French geographer, Jean Brunhes (1869-1930)
He discovered that volcanic rocks act as fossil compasses retaining a record of the Earth’s magnetic field at the time
they cooled
Also discovered many ancient rocks record times when the north magnetic pole switched to become the south magnetic
pole
Confirmed in 1928 by Japanese geologist M. Matuyama who proposed that the polarity of Earth’s magnetic field is not
fixed but is reversible
1911
Austrian geologist Ampferer argued tht rocks had acc been destroyed by being “down-sucked” to great depths, thus,
anticipating major discoveries of the plate tectonic revolution
Suess earlier argued that earth’s crust was thickening (as a result of cooling)
The contracting spasmodically resulting in horizontal compression
The contracting earth theory explained the problem of palaeontology bc oceans were regarded as recent collapse
features leaving widely separated continents with similar fossil records
It’s Elementary…
1913
Arthur Holmes (student of Strutt)
Book: the age of earth
Included a review of the techniques used to age-date rocks
He used new radiometric methods, particularly the ratio of uranium to its daughter product lead, to produce the first
absolute time scale.
Deep Thinking
1914
The fundamental internal structure of earth (core/mantle) was recognized by German-American seismologist Beno
Gutenberg (1869-1960) using the diff properties of seismic waves produced by earthquakes
Just Driftin’ About
1915
German Alfred Wegener (1880-1930)
Meteorologist
Book: origin of continents and oceans
Proposes notion of continental drift
Proposed supercontinent PANGEA (ALL THE LANDS)
Proposed superocean PANTHALASSA (ALL THE WATERS)
Essentially same idea as Bacon, Hopkins, Snider-Pellegrini but these were only “rediscovered” after Wegener’s
publication
He basically fit the coastlines either side of the Atlantic Ocean
THE REACTION
Idea on continental drift made sense to some, the idea upset many bc Wegener did not specify just how continents could
move
He had only said “pole gerflucht”, a centrifugal force acting to disperse continents across the surface of a spinning
planet
Early 1930s
Dutch geophysicist F.A. Vening-Meinesz (1887-1966) used submarines for research and showed that deep sea trenches
in the Caribbean and Indonesia are marked by negative gravity anomalies showing less dense material at depth
Indirectly, he had discovered the subduction zones proposed earlier by Ampferer in 1911
Well, it was about this big
1935
Charles Richter devised a logarithmic scale to describe the magnitude of earthquakes
Since then, geologists could talk intelligently about how big an earthquake was
Late 1930s
Geologists learnt more about isotopes and found that “common lead” contains radiogenic lead isotopes such as 208Pb
and 206Pb, formed by radioactive decay of uranium, tg with the non-radiogenic “primeval lead” (204Pb) which existed at
the time of the formation of Earth
They recognized that the lower ratio between radiogenic and primeval lead isotopes in a rock, the older the rock
Measurement of this ratio in meteorites in 1953 by C. Patterson and F. Houtermans provided the 1 st estimate of the age
of earth and is still accepted today (4.6 billion yrs)
Support for Pangea
1937
1963
F. Vine with D. Mathews & L. Morley proposed independently that the strip like magnetic anomalies on the sea floor
are created when hot new ocean crust moves away from spreading centres, cools and preserves a continuous record of
polarity reversals in the Earth’s magnetic field
Continuous upwelling and cooling of magma along spreading centres and the outward movement of cooling oceanic
crust, creates a tape recording of changes in earths magnetic field
This process was termed “sea-floor spreading” by Harry Hess
Hey, they actually do fit
1965
Ted Bullard (English geophysicist)
He used the new power of computers to show tht coastlines on either side of the Atlantic Ocean fit very closely (as
proposed by Bacon in 1620)
At the same time, Toronto geophysicist Jack Tuzo Wilson named and identified the role of transform faults (the
fractures of Menard) in offsetting mid-ocean ridges
He also recognized tht “hot-spots” originate deep within the mantle and tht several island chains, such as Hawaii are
“hot spot traces” recording the movement of earth’s crust over the mantle and repeated volcanic activity
Voyages of Discover
Late 1960’s
Deep Sea Drilling Project used a special ship (Glomar Challenger) to drill and dredge the ocean floor
Results reveled tht rocks of the ocean floor increase in age away from the mid-ocean rides as predicted by the theory of
seafloor spreading
This lead, in turn, to recognition tht the oceans and their underlying crust are no more than 200 million yrs old and that
they result from the breakup of a supercontinent (Pangea)
This pioneering oceanographic and marine geological work is continued today by the Resolution shown in the Panama
Canal
Resolution was built in 1978 in Halifax, Nova Scotia
She is named after the famous ship used on Capt. James Cook’s 2nd and 3rd Voyages
She is 470 feet long and 70 ft wide; the derrick is 202 ft above th waterline
Costs about 1 million a week to keep at sea & is operated by international “consortium” of many nations (Canada
included)
Much of the ship is taken up by labs whereas many of 50 scientists work for up to 3 months during scientific cruises
across the world’s oceans
These cruises are called “Legs”
Life on board for the scientists is very simple: SLEEP, EAT, WORK
At Last a mechanism: “Plate Tectonics”
1969
Maps of global EQ distribution confirm the idea tht earth’s outer surface is composed of about 12 large plates with
narrow belts of intense deformation at their margins
Plate tectonics (PT) recognizes tht continents do drift by being embedded in and carried along, by larger lithospheric
plates moving over a ductile asthenosphere
Here then was the mechanism which had eluded Wegener in 1915
“hot spot traces” such as the Hawaiian chain of volcanoes can be used to map plate velocities and trajectories
The end of dinosaurs
Late 1970s
Luis Alvarez (1911-88)
American physicist
Noted an excess of mineral iridium, which is rare on earth but common in meteorites
Suspected large asteroid impact some 65 million yrs ago that wiped out dinosaurs
Rocks which span the age of the dinosaurs and record their demise at the end of the Cretaceous are found exposed in
Southern Alberta but do not occur in Ont., other than as thin deposits in the moose river and Hudson Bay basins
CHAPTER 3:
Earth is composed of concentric layers (like an onion)
But each layer has different physical and chemical properties
We live on the cool, wet surface of a thin outermost layer called the LITHOSPHERE (which means “rocky sphere”)
This shell is brittle and broken into large segments (called lithospheric plates) that move relative to each other, by
gliding across a softer layer called the Asthenosphere (the soft sphere)
The lithospheric plates have been on the move for at least 3000 million years and in that time, they have caused
continuous rearrangement of continents and oceans
This process (plate tectonics) is fuelled by heat created by radioactive decay in the Earth’s interior
Early objections to Wegener’s hypothesis of continental drift were based on the fact that rocks are hard and brittle
The ability of the earth’s magnetic field to reverse itself has provided geologists with a useful means of constraining the
age of igneous rock
As magma cools small magnetic particles align themselves to earth’s magnetic pole and remain fixed in tht position
when the rock finally cools
Thus, the rock retains a record of the polarity of tht time period
Polar Wander
Magnetic poles also move slowly or drift
The North Magnetic Pole is in Arctic Canada (at 78 degrees. 30’N latitude) but moves about 6km each yr
Average position of the magnetic pole remains stable and is only slightly different from the north Pole which defines
the axis around which the Earth rotates (called true North)
When an igneous rock cools, iron particles align themselves to the magnetic field which approximates to true North at
the time the rock formed
But rock is embedded in a lithospheric plate that is always moving and rotating
- So, with time, as the plates moves farther and farther from its position when the igneous rocks cooled, the
position of the pole recorded in the rock will differ increasingly from modern pole
REMEMBER: THE MAGENTIC POLE STAYS FIXED AND IT IS THE PLATES THAT MOVE
Inclination
Analysis of igneous rocks also allows a record of magnetic inclination
Inclination is the angle at which magnetic particles dip (horizontal at the equator and steep at the poles) when magma
cools
Reflects the lines of force in the Earth’s magnetic field
The inclination of magnetic particles in ancient igneous rocks provides a measure of paleolatitude at which the rock
formed
Sedimentary rocks like limestones and chemical rocks like evaporites require warm tropical low latitude conditions
Tillites (rocks left by glaciers), indicate cold relatively high latitudes and coals indicate middle latitudes.
Wegener used this approach when he reconstructed Pangea
A World of Caution
Modern mode of PT (sometimes called Wilsonian Tectonics) volcanism is limited to the edges of lithospheric plates.
Ex: mid-ocean ridges and subduction zones
Massive volcanism also occurs within plates
Exploration of the ocean basins and mapping of the continents reveals the presence of large volcanic features such as
flood basalts and seamounts grouped under the term ‘large igneous provinces’ (LIPS) records large-short lived
volcanic events within tectonic plate
Some ocean plateaux are 20-30km thick
Otong Java Plateau on the floor of the Pacific Ocean extends over 1.86 million km2
Kerguelen Plateau in the Indian Ocean is more than 1.78 million km2 (only formed in only a few million yrs)
Deccan Traps of western India is a continental flood basalt province recording the outpouring of basalt some 60-65
million yrs ago and contain some 2 x 106 km3 of lava
Eruption of LIPS points to major episodes of melting in the mantle and the leakage of heat and mass to the Earth’s
surface in a way to quite unlike ‘steady state’ plate tectonics
These events are known as MOMO (Mantle Overturn, Major Orogeny) episodes