BEAM VERIFICATION

Beam Size 200 x 500

Location 3B/D3-F1 (4th Floor)

Manual Calculation Top : As,prov = 2H12

Bottom : As,prov = 2H16

Esteem Output Top : As,prov = 2H16

Bottom : As,prov = 2H16

As,prov provided in Esteem in more than manual calculation

but the design of beam is still OK
Justifications

Beam Size 200 x 500

Location 3/A6-A8A

Manual Calculation Top : As,prov = 2H12

Bottom : As,prov = 2H20

Esteem Output Top : As,prov = 2H 20

Bottom : As,prov = 2H 16

The result from esteem shows different from manual

calculation, however in manual calculation the design still
Justifications
not fail

Beam Size 200 x 500

Location 1/A8A-A8G

Manual Calculation Top : As,prov =3H12

Bottom : As,prov =3H12

Esteem Output Top : As,prov =2T16

Bottom : As,prov =2T16

In manual calculation, the result is different with result from

ESTEEM but the design still not fail
Justifications
 Beam Size 202 x 500

Location 1/A1-A7

Manual Calculation Top : As,prov = 2H16

Bottom : As,prov = 2H16

Esteem Output Top : As,prov = 2T16

Bottom : As,prov = 2T16

The result from esteem shows a different from manual

Justifications
calculation, but calculation the design acceptable

Beam Size 203 x 500

Location 3B/A7-C4

Manual Calculation Top : As,prov = 2H12

Bottom : As,prov = 2H16

Esteem Output Top : As,prov = 2H16

Bottom : As,prov = 2H16

The Asprov in in the esteem is 2H16 and more than

the Asprov in manual calculation but it is still okay.
Justifications
 COLUMN VERIFICATION

COLUMN
MANUAL CALC ESTEEM OUTPUT JUSTIFICATIONS
C57 (1D,A5)

RF to 4th FL 4H10 (314mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) 1. As,prov provided by esteem

is higher than manual calc

4th FL to 3rd FL 4H10 (314mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) 2. The axial load for manual
calc is P=600kN
which is less than
3rd FL to 2nd FL 4H10 (314mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) in Esteem

3. The checking is OK
2nd FL to 1st FL 4H10 (314mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

1st FL to GF 4H10 (314mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Ground to 4H10 (314mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Foundations
COLUMN
MANUAL CALC ESTEEM OUTPUT JUSTIFICATIONS
C43

RF to 4th FL 2H25 (982mm2) 4H12(453mm2)

5th FL to 3rd FL 2H25 (982mm2) 4H12(453mm2)

The result from esteem shows
different from manual
4th FL to 2nd FL 2H25(982mm2) 4H12(453mm2) calculation, however in
manual calculation the design
still not fail
3rd FL to 1st FL 2H25(982mm2) 4H12(453mm2)

2nd FL to GF 2H25(982mm2) 4H12(453mm2)

Ground to 2H25(982mm2) 4H12 (453mm2)

Foundations
COLUMN
MANUAL CALC ESTEEM OUTPUT JUSTIFICATIONS
C6

RF to 4th FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

1) The checking is OK!

5th FL to 3rd FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) 2) The Asprov provided by

ESTEEM is higher than
manual calculation.
4th FL to 2nd FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

3rd FL to 1st FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

2nd FL to GF 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Ground to 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Foundations
COLUMN
MANUAL CALC ESTEEM OUTPUT JUSTIFICATIONS
C19
The value of Asprov is
RF to 4th FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) acceptable since Asprov from
ESTEEM is higher

6th FL to 3rd FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

5th FL to 2nd FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

4th FL to 1st FL 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

3rd FL to GF 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Ground to 3H12 (339mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Foundations
COLUMN
MANUAL CALC ESTEEM OUTPUT JUSTIFICATIONS
C3

RF to 4th FL 3H12 (335mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) 1 The value of Asprov

is accepted
because Asprov in
6th FL to 3rd FL 3H12 (335mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) esteem is more than
manual calculation.

5th FL to 2nd FL 3H12 (335mm²) 4H12 (452mm²) 2 The value of axial

load is P=640kN and
it is accepted.
4th FL to 1st FL 3H12 (335mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

3rd FL to GF 3H12 (335mm²) 4H12 (452mm²)

Ground to 3H12 (335mm²) 6H20 (1608mm²)

Foundations
 SLAB VERIFICATION

MANUAL
SLAB DESCRIPTIONS ESTEEM JUSTIFICATIONS
CALCULATION
BOTTOM H12-375 H12-200
In manual calculation
FS 1
spacing and area are
TOP H12-375 H12-175
than Esteem but still
in the range for
BOTTOM H12-450 H12-200
required area and
FS 3
does not exceed the
TOP H12-250 H12-175
allowed spacing.
BOTTOM H12-450 H12-200
FS 20
TOP H12-200 H12-175
Esteem provides
extra spacing and
BOTTOM H10-350 H12-200
area compare to
FS 26
manual calc.
TOP H10-350 H12-175

BOTTOM H12-250 H12-200

FS 32
The result from
TOP H12-125 H12-175
esteem shows
different from
BOTTOM H10-250 H12-200
manual calculation,
FS 29
however in manual
TOP H10-250 H12-175
calculation the
design still not fail
BOTTOM H12-200 H12-175
FS48
TOP H12-300 H12-175

BOTTOM H10-300 H12-175

FS34
TOP H10-300 H12-200

BOTTOM H12-200 H12-175

FS18 The result from
TOP H12-375 H12-200 esteem shows a
different from manual
BOTTOM H10-400 H12-200 calculation, but
calculation the
FS24
acceptable and in
TOP H10-400 H12-175
range of required area
 FOUNDATION PILE CAP VERIFICATION

P5/C57
DESCRIPTION
X-DIRECTION Y-DIRECTION
Manual Dimension 1200 x 1000 x 500
Calculation As,req 522 mm² 522 mm²
As,prov 8H10 (628mm²) 8H10 (628mm²)
Dimension 1000 x 1000 x 450
Esteem As,req 500 mm² 500 mm²
As,prov 7H10 (550mm²) 7H10 (550mm²)
~
1.As,req for manual calculation more than Esteem but still
compatible for verification
Justification

P4/C43 (example)
DESCRIPTION
X-DIRECTION Y-DIRECTION
Manual Dimension 2140×1020×500
Calculation As,req 4606 mm2 4606 mm2
As,prov 16H 25 ( 7855 mm2) 16H 25 ( 7855 mm2)
Dimension 1175×1075×550
Esteem As,req 694 mm2 778 mm2
As,prov 9H10 10H10
~

The result from ESTEEM shows different from manual calculation

Justification
however in manual calculation the design still not fail

P5/C6
DESCRIPTION
X-DIRECTION Y-DIRECTION
Manual Dimension 2140X100X300
Calculation As,req 3046mm² 3046mm²
As,prov 16H 25 ( 7855 mm2) 16H 25 ( 7855 mm2)
Dimension 1000x1000x450
Esteem As,req 500mm² 516mm²
As,prov 7H10 7H10
~
The manual calculation and design
still not fail even the result from ESTEEM are different
Justification

P6/C19
DESCRIPTION
X-DIRECTION Y-DIRECTION
Manual Dimension 1200x800x500
Calculation As,req 478mm² 478mm²
 As,prov 5H12 (566mm²) 5H12 (566mm²)
Dimension 1200×800×550
Esteem As,req 570 794
As,prov 6T12 11T10
~
As,req for manual calculation less than ESTEEM but still acceptable
Justification

P7/C11
DESCRIPTION
X-DIRECTION Y-DIRECTION
Manual Dimension 1200 x 1000 x 500
Calculation As,req 390 mm² 427 mm²
As,prov 5H10 (393 mm²) 6H10 (471 mm²)
Dimension 1175 x 1075 x 400
Esteem As,req 399 mm² 456 mm²
As,prov 6H10 (471 mm²) 6H10 (471 mm²)
~
1. Asreq for the X-ddirection in manual calculation
is smaller than in esteem but still okay and acceptable.
Justification